MedicareFAQ
At MedicareFAQ, our mission is simple; make sure each individual we help is educated on all their Medicare options so they can make an informed decision.
Our online resource center is built to give you unbiased information regarding your Medicare coverage choices.
We work with the top carriers in the nation to find the best Medicare supplemental options that fit each individual’s budget. Our team of licensed agents work around the clock to make sure our resource center is always up to date and accurate so that you’re always informed on your Medicare benefits. Our agents & Client Care Team love what they do. They provide unlimited support for the lifetime of your policy.
Let our licensed Medicare agents help you so you can get back to enjoying life! Our services are 100% free.
MedicareFAQ
95% of Medicare Advantage nursing facility denials get overturned
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
A 2024 federal watchdog report found that when Medicare Advantage enrollees appealed prior authorization denials for Skilled Nursing Facility (SNF) admission, they won 95% of the time.
When an independent reviewer looks at the same cases a plan rejected and reverses the decision nearly every single time, that is not a system working correctly. It is a system producing denials that consistently fail review.
Hello, and thanks for joining us on the podcast with Elite Insurance Partners. Today, our mission in this deep dive is exploring a 2024 federal watchdog report. And uh it exposes a pretty shocking reality about Medicare Advantage skilled nursing denials.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, it really is a staggering report. Um, the Office of Inspector General found that when Medicare Advantage enrollees actually appeal their prior authorization denials for a skilled nursing facility, they win 95% of the time.
SPEAKER_00Wow, 95%. I mean, it's like a referee who blows the whistle on every single play, but uh if you demand an instant replay, you win 19 out of 20 times.
SPEAKER_01That is the exact perfect analogy. And the plans deny about 12% of skilled nursing requests overall. But you know, for nursing home residents, that number actually jumps to 40 percent.
SPEAKER_00Oh my gosh, 40 percent.
SPEAKER_01Yes, huge. And the really crazy part is that only 18% of patients actually bother to appeal.
SPEAKER_00But I mean, the human cost of that is just devastating because if you do appeal, patients wait an average of six days for this instant replay, right? Exactly. Yeah.
SPEAKER_01Six days of just waiting.
SPEAKER_00Six days while you're trying to recover from a major health event, like a stroke or something. So why would insurers rely on a system with a 95% failure rate? I feel like we have to follow the money here.
SPEAKER_01You always have to follow the money. So it comes down to the Medicare Advantage capitated model. The government basically pays the plans a fixed monthly rate per enrollee.
SPEAKER_00Right. So if they spend less on care, they just keep more of that money.
SPEAKER_01Exactly. That incentive structure is why 99% of enrollees face these prior authorization hurdles, and they outsource these decisions to contractors like Navi Health, who use algorithms. Navi Health actually saw a 97% overturn rate on their denials.
SPEAKER_00Wait, 97%? That is wild.
SPEAKER_01It is. And major players like Aetna, Humana, and United Healthcare all show massive post-acute care denial rates, ranging from 71 to 80%.
SPEAKER_00That is so incredibly stressful. You know, if navigating these network restrictions and authorizations feels overwhelming, we at Elite Insurance Partners can help you select a Medicare plan or just answer any questions. You can fill up the form on this page or call us at 877-324-1512. We just want to help you figure it out. But uh back to those algorithms, why do they fail so much?
SPEAKER_01Well, it's because they match a patient to a really rigid generic recovery curve. So they look at a stroke, for example, and assign an average timeline, completely ignoring the patient's individual history.
SPEAKER_00Uh, I see. So if that patient also has severe diabetes, which like slows down healing, the algorithm just doesn't care.
SPEAKER_01Nope, it doesn't care at all. It just issues the denial. And while we're waiting for slow-moving legislation or the new 2026 CMS rules, you have to know how to protect yourself right now.
SPEAKER_00Well, it just seems fundamentally unfair to put the burden of fighting this bureaucracy onto sick recovering patients. Like, how can you effectively fight back against a machine?
SPEAKER_01Aaron Powell You have to appeal immediately. That is the most important thing. You need to build a strong case with your medical records and use free help, like SHIPS or the Medicare Rights Center at 800-3334114.
SPEAKER_00Okay, that is great advice. And you know, you can also consider Medigap plans since they generally avoid prior authorization hurdles entirely. And we are here to help you navigate these exact choices. Just call 877-324-1512 or use the form. We really want to help.
SPEAKER_01Having that guidance is huge because prior authorization has totally morphed from a clinical safeguard into just a financial gatekeeper.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, it really has. Well, a final reminder to let us at Elite Insurance Partners assist you with any questions, fill out the form or call 877 3241512.
SPEAKER_01And I'll leave you with this provocative thought. If algorithmic tools are currently generating denials that fail 95% of human reviews, what happens to patient care if the appeals process itself eventually becomes automated?