The Business of Ergonomics Podcast
The Business of Ergonomics Podcast
Chair Nerd Deep Dive: A Comparison of 6 Task Chairs
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Task chairs are the piece of equipment ergonomists get asked about more than anything else. They're also where clients reliably spend the most money and get the least return because nobody explained the features that actually matter.
This episode is for ergonomics practitioners. We go through seven task chairs using the same clinical feature framework we use in our Ergo Equipment Database inside Accelerate: lumbar height, lumbar pressure and depth, independent back angle, seat depth adjustment, 4D arms, backrest airflow, headrest availability, sizing range, seat pan modification options, warranty, and return policy. Not the marketing copy. The clinical picture.
The 6 chairs:
- Branch Pro (~USD $500-649)
- Steelcase Leap V2 (~USD $1,200-1,500 new / USD $400-750 refurbished)
- HON Ignition (~USD $400-600)
- Herman Miller Aeron (~USD $1,400-1,800)
- ErgoCentric AirCentric (~USD $800-1,200)
- Humanscale Freedom (~USD $1,200-1,500)
All 6 chairs and dozens more are in the Accelerate Ergo Equipment Database, where members can run side-by-side comparisons matched to a client's specific clinical picture and download a branded comparison guide to hand directly to clients. Access through Accelerate: The Business of Ergonomics at ergonomicshelp.com/accelerate.
We're also running a free training next Wednesday September 23rd at ergonomicshelp.com/infographic.
Discover How to Add Office Ergonomics Assessments to Your Practice and Charge $300-$1,000+ per Client. Click here to save your seat for this FREE training: https://ergonomicshelp.com/ergo-webinar/
Welcome to the Business of Ergonomics Podcast. Today on the show, we are talking about chairs, and if you've ever done more than a handful of office ergonomics assessments, you know that chairs are the one thing every client has an opinion about already. Someone spent $1,400 on an Aeron, and they're still having back pain, and you're the one standing in their office trying to figure out what's actually going on with the setup. Today, I'm gonna go through task chairs I use in our Ergo Equipment Database inside Accelerate, and I'm gonna talk about them the way ergonomists talk about them, not the way the marketing copy does. Lumbar adjustability, seat depth, tilt mechanism, return policy, the things that determine whether a chair actually works for a specific client. if you're an ergonomist or health professional building an ergonomics practice, this is the conversation I wish someone had with me earlier. Let's get into it. Welcome to the Business of Ergonomics podcast. I'm your host, Darcy Jeremy. I'm a board certified professional ergonomist with over 15 years of experience delivering ergonomics programs to employers of all different types. In this podcast, I share what other healthcare professionals are already doing with ergonomics assessments, and how to land those clients that you dream of. Did you know that consistent marketing doesn't have to consume your entire week? Most ergonomists don't market consistently because of the time, not motivation. When you have the right tools, showing up regularly becomes something you can sustain alongside your actual work. You can join me next week on Wednesday, September 23rd. I'm hosting a free webinar all about how to use one simple tool, infographics, to build sustainability in your entire business, especially marketing to bring in new clients. All you have to do to save your spot today is go to ergonomistshelp.com/infographic, and I'll see you next Wednesday in our live training. Even if you can't make it, be sure to register, and I'll send you the recording as soon as it's live. One thing that I've noticed with Ergonimus is that It's very much a time management system. Just like I referred to in that infographic webinar that's coming up next week, I've noticed if I can give ergonomists time-saving tools, then they can get through what they want so much faster, make more money, spend time with the family, do marketing. And that's why I have developed the Ergo Equipment Database. The Ergo Equipment Database has everything that we're gonna be talking about in today's episode, and this is only available through Accelerate the Business of Ergonomics. The really neat thing with the Ergonomic Equipment Database is that it allows you to do a real-time search for any sort of ergonomic equipment, whether it's chairs, keyboards, alternative keyboards, alternative mice, regular mice, footrests, you name it. If it is a piece of equipment that you might recommend to a client in your office ergonomic assessment, then all the specifications are there, and purchasing websites, so that it saves you major time when you're writing the recommendation. Not only that, one of my favorite features of this is that you can live compare between multiple chair types. For instance, if I have a client and there's about five chairs that would meet the specifications, I can develop a document just by clicking one button in the Ergo Equipment Database, and it will make a live comparison chart that I can print off, put on the back of the ergonomic report, or something aside, I can offer this as a side type of service that I could probably charge hundreds of dollars for, because that's the amount of time it would typically take to develop a chair comparison PDF for a client. How many times have you heard from a client that they're narrowing down chairs, they're gonna be purchasing 30 or $40,000 worth of new chairs for their department, and they wanna make sure that they're making the right decision? Not only can you assist with that whole process, you can give them this one document that steers the right decision. I gotta be straight up. Was I sponsored? Was I sent any free chairs? Did any of these chair manufacturers pass me along anything? Nope. Was I paid any money? Nope. These are just based off my personal comparisons, my research, my experience with chairs. There's been no product placements here. There's no sponsorships. No money has been paid for me from any of this Before I touch on any individual chair, I want to establish this framework I'm using, because if you evaluate a chair on specs alone, back height, weight capacity, number of adjustments, you'll miss most of what actually determines clinical fit. Here are the features I look at. First up, lumbar adjustability, and I want to separate this into two things, height and pressure or depth. Lumbar height Can you move the support up or down to find the right vertebral level for this client? That varies by anatomy. Lumbar pressure or depth, can you control how far the support protrudes into the lumbar curve? Some chairs give you one, some give you both. A few give you neither in any meaningful way. These are not the same feature. Next up, seat depth adjustment. I think this is the single most underappreciated feature in a task chair, I'll explain why when it comes to a few chairs today. If a client cannot sit fully back in the chair with proper knee clearance, two to three fingers between the front edge of the seat and the back of the knee, the backrest becomes irrelevant. Why? They're gonna perch forward and lose all the lumbar support they just paid for. The ability to shorten the seat pan or lengthen it is absolutely foundational in any chair. Third up, independent back angle, also called multi-tilt. There's a meaningful difference between basic tilt, when the seat and back move as one unit, synchro-tilt, when they move at a ratio, and true independent back angle, where you can use the backrest position independent of what the seat's pan is doing. For clients who need to recline for pain relief but can't have the seat pitching forward, that distinction matters 4D arms. Four-dimensional arms adjust height, width, depth, and pivot. That last one, pivot or inward rotation, is what determines whether the arm can actually support the forearm at desk height without forcing the shoulder to elevate. A lot of chairs claim adjustable arms and mean two-dimensional. That's worth verifying before you go forward with any recommendation. Backrest airflow. Mesh versus foam. For long sitters and clients with thermoregulation issues, this can be a comfort preference. However, if this is something that's high on your client's priority list, it's something worth considering when developing a chair selection process. Sizing options. Some chairs are petite, some are big and tall. There's weight capacity involved with this too. These determine whether the chair is even in play for a portion of your client population. Seat pan modification. This is something that's truly unique, only available in a fraction of chairs. However, it's important to know if clients with coccyx injuries or some sort of, bursitis, sometimes they need load distribution. And what these seat pan modifications can do, specifically cutouts or contouring of the back of the seat pan, it's a niche feature that comes up in accommodation context Knowing which chairs support that modification saves you a ton of time. And finally, warranty and return policy. I know, again, these aren't specifically ergonomic specifications, but if your client has any concerns with what the return policy is or how long the chair is gonna last, it all comes in to play here, especially when they know how far their dollar is gonna take them. It matters for the confidence of your recommendation. A chair you recommend with a 12-year warranty and a 30-day free return is a different recommendation than one with a five-year warranty and a 25% restocking fee. All right, seven chairs. Let's start with the Branch Pro. The price is approximately $500. This chair surprises people when they look at the feature list for the price point, and genuinely, it surprised me, too. There are 14 adjustments, and most of them are really, quite frankly, useful. First up, lumbar. It has a height and depth, both adjustable independently. That's not a given at this price point. You can set the height to find the right vertebrae level, and then tune the depth so that it's really comfortable for your client. For a client with a pronounced lumbar curve versus a client who's relatively flat back, this is incredibly important. The seat depth is adjustable. The back angle is an independent multi-tilt. The seat and back can be set independently. This isn't just synchro, it's more flexible. The arms are four-dimensional: height, width, depth, and pivot. The backrest is a mesh. Airflow is available there. It has a high back option. It has a headrest option, too. It does have limitations, and I want to flag this for you right now. The weight capacity is 300 pounds. If you have a client who is larger or taller, this may be outside the designated range. The sizing is one standard size. There's no petite configuration. There are no seat pan modifications, and by that I mean the cutout or the shave. It's not available from the manufacturer. And the warranty is seven years, which is the shortest on the list with the chair with the set of features that I just described. The return policy is 30 days, and clinically, I would have to say that this chair Overall, this is a strong recommendation. Before I dived into the various types of chairs, I took a really deep dive earlier this year, I had overlooked the Branch chair. But when I looked at the specs this chair had, the recommendations from other ergonomists, I would have to say that this is a really strong recommendation for especially home office clients who need a genuinely adjustable chair without getting into the 1,000-plus price range. It covers most of the feature checklist. The one thing I need to flag is the weight capacity and the single sizing option. if your client is within the standard sizing range, then it's gonna be fine. This chair delivers the feature set of chairs that cost twice as much The next thing we are talking about is the Steelcase Leap version two. The price is about $1,200. It has a 12-year warranty and 30-day free returns. There are two mechanisms on the Leap that are worth understanding because they're not marketing copy. It's about the engineering. The first thing I want to talk about is their LiveBack. The Leap's backrest doesn't just tilt as a rigid surface. It has two what they call flexible zones or flex zones that change shape as the user reclines, and this is supposed to follow the shape of the spine rather than moving away from it. In practice, what this means is that the lumbar support maintains contact with the lumbar region through the range of recline instead of losing contact as most standard backrests do. So for a client who needs to recline, maybe they're not super up to date with the types of adjustability that you might eventually get to that type of adjustment in a regular chair, this chair does it for you, and that's why this chair is so popular. The second thing is the natural glide system. So this is how it works. When you lean forward in the Leap, which most office workers do most of the time, the seat pan slides slightly forward and down rather than the user just perching off the backrest. The purpose is this: it's to keep the sight line stable and maintain the lumbar contact even in a forward tilt This is cool because it's designed around how people actually sit, not how a typical ergonomic textbook wants people to sit. That's again, another reason why this chair is so popular, because it's comfortable in situations like this that is very common Next up, the Lumbar. With the lumbar, it's height adjustable and upper and lower firmness independently adjustable too. This is a dual zone lumbar, which lets you change the support at the thoracic area from support at the mid-lumbar area. It's not the same mechanism as a traditional depth adjustment, but it gives you similar functional control, which is very unique to this chair. The arms are four-dimensional, the seat pan depth is adjustable, and the natural glide system that I was talking about also augments this further. Here's what to know about sizing. The Leap comes in standard sizing with options for larger users. This is not a petite chair. The seat pan dimensions run medium to large, and if you have a very small client, I would encourage you to check the dimensions before you recommend this chair. There's no headrest, but after-market options exist, and having a headrest is not an ergonomic necessity by any means. So that is not a deal breaker with this chair There is a reason why this chair has been a workhorse for so many years and why it's the go-to chair for many individuals. It's adjustable. There's a lot of unique engineering with this chair, and for a lot of people, that makes it so comfortable to sit in, especially if there's any sort of dynamic lower back needs where the support needs to follow their movement Let's move on to the Han Ignition The Hot Ignition is approximately $400. There's a five-year warranty and a 30-day free return. This chair comes out most often in fleet purchase conversations. Large employers, open plan offices, replacement cycles at scale. And there's legitimate reasons for that Let's talk about the lumbar. It's height adjustable The depth or pressure adjustment is limited depending on the model configuration. The Ignition 2.0 offers a two-position lumbar dial that gives you some pressure adjustment, but it's less precise than the dual system on the Leap or the Branch It's seat depth adjustable. The tilt mechanism is synchro-tilt. So this is where the Ignition differs from the Leap and the Branch. Synchro-tilt means that the seat and back move at a coordinated ratio, typically two to one, so the back tilts further than the seat. It's better than the basic tilt, but it's not independent back angle. For a client with specific position requirements or lower back issues, or they really want to achieve that slight recline, it's probably worth noting here The arms on the 2.0 model are four-dimensional. The earlier version had limited arm adjustability. So verify which model you are looking at for your client. There is a high back option. There is a headrest. And remember, a headrest isn't an ergonomic necessity. It's more of like a reminder perhaps to encourage that person to lean back on the backrest and not, scoot their neck forward during the day, but it is not an ergonomic requirement by any means. for an individual client, a five-year warranty on a 500 buck chair is something you wanna consider as an ergonomist. For a large employer doing a huge replacement every three to five years anyway, it doesn't matter as much. Now, that seat pan modification doesn't exist with the HON. So chair, is an ergonomically adequate chair at a reasonable price. It hits the main features. The limitation is the warranty and the tilt mechanism Something to keep in mind. If price point, this is a good chair for your client Next up, we're moving into the Herman Miller Aeron. Price range could be about 1,500 bucks. There's a 12-year warranty, there's a 30-day return with a 50 buck return shipping fee So the Aeron chair has a bit of a reputation. Some people love the Aeron, some people aren't big fans. in terms of comfort padding, that's one aspect I think the Herman Miller lacks. In terms of aesthetics and a beautiful looking chair, this is where the Aeron crushes it I worked with a client once, a lawyer, five foot two, spending nine-plus hours a day at a desk. She bought an Aeron because someone told her it was the gold standard, and she had size B, and she was still having lower back pain. The Aeron comes in three sizes, A, B, and C, where C is the largest and A is the most petite. So I came in, looked at her setup, and within two minutes, I could see what was happening. She wasn't sitting in the back of her chair. She was perched on the front edge, her back nowhere near the backrest because the seat pan was too long for her. This is a really big issue that we need to be aware of before we recommend a chair for anyone. The front edge was pressing into the back of her knees, so she'd move forward to relieve the pressure, and by moving forward, she'd lost contact with the PostureFit's lumbar support she'd paid 1,500 bucks for. The Aeron does have a seat pan adjustment, but what you need to do as an ergonomist is ensure that you're getting the right size of chair with your client first because The seat pan adjustment may not be enough to rectify a chair that's too big So the posture fit that I mentioned, SL, it's a two-zone lumbar that independently adjusts the sacral region and the lumbar region. This is different from a traditional lumbar pad. The sacral support component is something most chairs don't offer, and for clients with sacroiliac pain or clients whose lumbar support has historically felt uncomfortable because it's loading too high, this can be something that's useful. What I've found over the years of adjusting Aeron chairs is that when you get the additional lumbar support, people just don't know that you can pull it out, turn it around, and put it back in. There's two different types of depths of the lumbar support. I once did an ergonomic assessment for an individual that was having a really hard time sitting in the Aeron. He said that there just wasn't enough padding, and it was causing a lot of discomfort. So what we ended up doing is just changing the chair entirely. There was a real red flag moment when I walked into the ergonomic assessment, and he was sitting on a pillow from his home. It was that uncomfortable. The Aeron mesh, especially as it gets older in age, and that may mean that over a time of using the mesh, it just gets more uncomfortable. So depending on the individual user on the setups, it can cause some discomfort. It's something to be aware of. Of course, with a mesh, that backrest airflow is excellent. It comes in three sizes, petite, standard, and large, or A, B, and C If you're ever doing an ergonomic assessment and you're not sure what size that individual is in, A, B, or C, the way to figure out what size it is on the back of the backrest near the top. There's this overhang on the top of the Aeron, and it has indentations. One means A, two means B, three means C. The arms are four-dimensional There's no headrest on this chair. There's no ergonomic requirement for it to have a headrest, although there are some aftermarket headrests exist There's no seat pan modifications I think that Aeron belongs in your toolkit as an ergonomist Especially for those folks that need to have those chairs that are aesthetically pleasing and there's no specific back issues that they have Next up, let's talk about the ErgoCentric/AirCentric. This price range is about 800 bucks depending on the configuration. Has a lifetime warranty. The return policy includes a fee, and the exact amount depends on the configuration. It's built to order, and there is roughly a two-week lead time. It's a Canadian manufacturer too Now, I really enjoy sitting in the Ergo Air Centric. the only grievance I have with this chair is that I wish the backrest would recline more. Otherwise, this is one of my favorite chairs that I've ever used. for whatever reason, the chair is less visible in the US market than others on this list, and I think it's totally underused for the number of things I'm gonna be going into in this description. First of all, the lumbar mechanism is pneumatic. There's a small air pump, similar in concept to a blood pressure cuff, and that's integrated into the lumbar support. So the client can just pump air in or release air, to adjust the pressure of the lumbar support. The backrest moves up and down to adjust where that backrest is hitting, that lumbar curve is hitting on that person's lumbar For clients with significant lumbar curve variability This is something that could work really well for them It has an independent back angle with a multi-tilt mechanism. The seat depth is adjustable. The arms are four-dimensional. There is a high back option. There is a headrest option too, although not ergonomically necessities by any means. There's multiple size configurations, including petite, larger frame options too. One of my favorite things about this chair is the seat pan modification. Many times when I've done ergonomic assessments, I've worked with clients that have had some issue that the regular type of seat pan was causing them much, too much discomfort. The fact that this has a cutout option or a shave as a configuration choice is huge. This is one of the few chairs on the list where the manufacturer will build the seat pan accommodation in. For clients returning from a coccyx fracture or a bursitis, post-surgical issues, this is huge, and it could be a lifesaver for your client. The warranty is lifetime as well. It's the strongest warranty on the list by a significant margin When you're advising an employer that an ergonomic chair is a capital purchase rather than a furniture rotation, a lifetime warranty is the documentation that supports that framing The two factors to flag here, first, the return policy includes a fee So if you have access to a showroom or trial area before recommending it to a client, that could be something to do second, that two-week lead time is worth communicating upfront for accommodations where timeline is really important Let's next talk about the HumanScale Freedom. This has a price range of about 1,200 bucks, has a 15-year warranty The Freedom's design philosophy is different from the other chairs on the list, and I want to be precise about what that means clinically, because it cuts both ways. The recline mechanism is self-adjusting. This means that there are no tension knobs. The chair calibrates its resistance to the user's body weight, so the counterbalance is always proportional. You lean back, the chair reclines smoothly. You lean forward, it returns. For clients who find tension adjustments confusing or who tend not to adjust it correctly, this is a genuine usability advantage for some of the population. However, as an ergonomist, there's some s- flags I have here with this design that's The armrests are integrated with the recline mechanism, so they move with the backrest as the user reclines, keeping the forearm-to-surface relationship consistent through the range of motion. For clients who actually recline, this is a feature. For clients who sit mostly straight upright, it's not important. The seat pan depth is adjustable. The arms are four-dimensional Now let's talk about the lumbar. Human Scale's form-sensing mesh backrest is designed to respond passively to the user's spine shape as they move. there is no manual lumbar adjustment in the traditional sense. They're just saying, there's no dial, there's no pump, there's no slider. They're just saying that the fabric will conform to the person's inward curve of their lumbar support. So for users that don't have any lower back concerns, that may be fine. But for those people that need more support, need more adjustability, then this chair may not cut it. What I suggest you doing is trying this chair out. If there's a showroom somewhere near your client, see if they can try it out for at least 18 minutes. Even better if they can have it loaned out to that individual for a couple weeks. Then they'll have a better idea about the lumbar, this form-sensing mesh for a client with a relatively normal lumbar curve who moves through a range of positions and who doesn't really need a specific lumbar protrusion depth, the passive system could work well. For a client with a pronounced curve, a flat back, or a special clinical requirement for precise lumbar pressure, for example, a post-surgical client or a client with a known disc pathology at a specific level, the inability to precisely dial in lumbar support is a limitation. this isn't a criticism of the design. It's a genuine design trade-off. The Freedom trades precision lumbar adjustability for a system that requires less correct adjustment to function. You just need to know your client before you recommend it. There's a high back option. There's petite and larger sizing available, and there is no seat pan modification. 15-year warranty is absolutely notable If you're recommending the Freedom to an employer as a capital investment, that warranty supports this conversation A few things stand out to me when I look across these chairs. Seat depth is the feature most clients don't know to ask about. I've been in offices when someone has spent over $1,000 on a chair and couldn't use the lumbar support because the seat pan was too long for them As a practitioner, measure the client, measure the seat. They need Two to three finger widths between the front edge and the back of the knee Lumbar height and lumbar depth are not the same adjustment. Chairs that offer both, the Branch, the Leap, the Air eccentric, give you a different tool. A client whose pain is from a lumbar support that protrudes too aggressively into their curve needs depth or pressure adjustment. These are two separate problems independent back angle matters most for clients with specific positioning requirements. Someone who needs to recline for pain relief but can't have the seat pan tilting forward, or someone who needs a forward-tilted backrest for task-specific work. For clients who sit mostly neutral upright, the difference between synchro tilt and independent back angle is less clinically significant The CPEN cutout question, this comes up in accommodations The ErgoCentric AirCentric is the only one that offers a manufacturer-configured cutout. That's really important for accommodations when you need to reduce the loading, knowing that it saves you from recommending a workaround Before I close, a quick note on where these chairs live inside Accelerate. We built the ergo equipment database because I was tired of doing the comparison work from scratch every time a client asked about chairs. Every chair in this episode, and dozens more, are in the database. Not only that, but as I mentioned in the beginning of this episode, you have mice, keyboards, so many different types of products. You can pull up any chair, run a side-by-side comparison, match to the features that matter for a specific client's picture, and download a branded comparison guide with your name and company name on it, and hand it directly to that client The last piece is so important here. The ability to hand a client a branded comparison is huge You can get access to this through Accelerate the Business of Ergonomics. And if you're not yet in Accelerate, we have a free training coming up Wednesday, September 23rd at ergonomicshelp.com/infographic. It's a great starting point. That's it for this episode. If you have questions about any of the chairs that we covered or a chair that came up in your own practice that I should add to the next comparison, reach out. This is the type of conversation I love having. Talk soon