When Internal Succession Fails: Why Multi-Partner CPA Firms Are Turning to External Sales

Accountant's Flight Plan

Accountant's Flight Plan
When Internal Succession Fails: Why Multi-Partner CPA Firms Are Turning to External Sales
Dec 21, 2025
Brannon Poe; Darryl Boyd


You've spent years developing your next generation of partners, but what happens when they don't want to lead, can't secure financing, or simply aren't the right fit to take over? 

In this episode, our Ontario Market Leader Darryl Boyd, reveals why so many multi-partner firms are discovering that their "default" internal succession plan isn't working, and why external sales often deliver better outcomes for everyone involved.

Over his decade with Poe Group Advisors, Darryl has helped the Canadian M&A landscape transform from earnout-heavy transactions to all-cash deals that prioritize fit over spreadsheets. 

We explore the uncomfortable truth about internal succession: technical excellence doesn't equal business leadership, and the partner who's great at client work may have zero interest or aptitude for running the firm.

The conversation highlights that:

  • Why exhausted accounting firm owners often just need better systems, not an exit strategy
  • How private equity is slowly earning trust in Canada, and why most CPA firm sellers still choose CPA buyers
  • The hidden assumptions killing Accounting M&A deals (like the "25% client loss" myth with zero data behind it)
  • Why the best transactions happen when both parties forget about price and focus on whether the handoff will actually work

We also tackle the massive variability across firms that makes a cookie-cutter valuation worthless: profitability, owner workload, geographic markets, and cultural dynamics all impact valuation more than sellers realize. Whether you're a multi-partner firm wrestling with succession, a solo tax practitioner planning your exit, or a buyer trying to understand what sellers really care about, this episode will challenge your assumptions about how accounting practice transitions actually work.

Link to full listing: https://poegroupadvisors.com/practice/sc2038/ 

Firm Highlights:
- Young, energetic owner committed to staying 10+ years to run and grow the firm.
- Selling 70–100% equity, with plans to offer key employees an ownership stake.
- 3+ CPAs on staff and over 20 employees.
- High-net-worth clients with strong loyalty and consistent referrals.
- 78% of services tied to business clients.

Episode Artwork When Internal Succession Fails: Why Multi-Partner CPA Firms Are Turning to External Sales 43:19 Episode Artwork From Survival Mode to Sustainable Success in Your CPA Firm with Lisa Smith 38:20 Episode Artwork Building an Offshore Staffing Strategy for your CPA Firm with Nick Sinclair 36:20 Episode Artwork Building Trust and Value In Your Accounting Firm Through Marketing with Kristen Corey 31:32 Episode Artwork The AI-First CPA Firm: Redefining Accounting with Jody Padar, The Radical CPA 31:13 Episode Artwork Modern Accounting In the Age of AI: Scaling Your Firm, Adopting AI, and Maximizing Your Capacity with Mike Schwarz 45:47 Episode Artwork Grow Your Business Meaningfully with Rob Dube 39:37 Episode Artwork Private Equity Market Update in the Accounting Space: With Guest Morry Brown 1:01:19 Episode Artwork Former Seller Raffi Yousefian Talks About How Niching Down Transformed His CPA Firm 33:46 Episode Artwork From the Archives - The Making of Accounting Practice Academy 17:45 Episode Artwork Private Equity, Fit, and the Future of CPA Firm Deals with PGA Intermediary Morry Brown 27:56 Episode Artwork Building a Scalable Firm with Offshoring, AI, and Talent Strategy — with Wayne Findlay 28:58 Episode Artwork Telling a Better Story: Using Personal Branding to Shape Better Accounting Firms with Rob Brown 47:39 Episode Artwork Navigating the Future of Accounting Through AI and Adaptation with Dan Hood of Accounting Today 39:43 Episode Artwork Reduce Staff Turnover Through Cutting-Edge Technology with Dominic Piscopo 29:44 Episode Artwork The Future of Accounting Firms: Embracing AI, Advisory and Finding a Balanced Life with Seth Fineberg 52:14 Episode Artwork The Benefits and Challenges of Working with Family: A Special Birthday Episode w/ Brannon Poe & Bailey Ball 40:23 Episode Artwork Hiring Smarter, Not Harder: How Testing Transforms CPA Firm Recruitment with Giles Pearson 31:27 Episode Artwork Using Your Passion to Find Your Niche within the Accounting Industry 21:58 Episode Artwork Celebrating 100 Episodes: An Inside Look at Building a Business and Growing a Podcast with Brannon Poe 50:54 Episode Artwork Scaling your CPA Practice and Providing Small Business Clients with Value 26:23 Episode Artwork What the Influx of Private Equity in the Accounting Industry Means for Your CPA Firm 37:39 Episode Artwork What To Consider Before Buying or Selling An Accounting Firm with Intermediary Stephanie Smith 32:48 Episode Artwork Break Free from Hourly Billing and Increase Your CPA Firm’s Value with Geraldine Carter 39:05 Episode Artwork Finding The Right Fit for Buyer and Seller with Buyer Specialist Carol Poe 26:02