Why Your Tenants Matter with Joe Rinderknecht

Weiss Advice

Weiss Advice
Why Your Tenants Matter with Joe Rinderknecht
Nov 25, 2025 Season 1 Episode 445
Yonah Weiss

Send us a text

What if the key to successful multifamily investing isn't just about the numbers—but about the people living in your properties? Joe Rinderknecht, the cowboy-hat-wearing founder of Cowboy Capital, shares his unconventional path from shoveling manure on a Utah ranch to operating over 1,000 multifamily units. 

[01:40 - 06:15] From Ranch to Real Estate: Building on Grit

  • Grew up ranching and breaking horses in northern Utah—learned that your word is your bond
  • Father left the ranch for construction and cabinet making, taught Joe everything from concrete to framing

[06:40 - 10:10] Trial by Fire: The 80-Unit Section 42 Property

  • Asked for a property management job with zero experience—got thrown into an 80-unit low-income housing property
  • Property had no manager for two weeks, with sky-high delinquency, vacancy, crime, drugs, and cockroaches


[10:11 - 15:20] The Path to Becoming a Sponsor

  • Never planned to stay in property management long-term—goal was always to learn and move on
  • Admits being "unemployable" with a resume showing 6-8 month stints at various companies


[16:35 - 23:35] Impact Investing: Making Every Dollar Matter

  • Lost his brother (age 20) and grandmother in a 2013 car accident—nearly died himself
  • Provides four types of support: capital, food, construction/home modifications, and mindset coaching

[23:36 - 26:40] Why Treating Tenants Well Is Good Business

  • Questions how slumlords succeed when they don't care about people's lives
  • When tenants feel like a unit is their home, turnover drops, repairs decrease, delinquency falls

[26:41 - 32:00] Rapid Growth and What's Next

  • Bought 4 deals (419 units) since September 2024, currently under contract on 117 more units
  • Believes there's a great buying opportunity in the next 10-24 months

[26:45 - 32:55] Final Four & How to Connect


Connect with Joe: 

Website: https://cowboycapital.us
Email: Joe@CowboyCapital.us
LinkedIn: Joe Rinderknecht
Instagram: @joe_rinder

LEAVE A 5-STAR REVIEW by clicking this
link.

WHERE CAN I LEARN MORE?

Be sure to follow me on the below platforms:

Subscribe to the podcast on Apple, Spotify, Google, or Stitcher.

LinkedIn

Youtube

Exclusive Facebook Group

www.yonahweiss.com

None of this could be possible without the awesome team at Buzzsprout. They make it easy to get your show listed on every major podcast platform.


Key Quote:
"If you can get a tenant to feel like their unit is their home, your turno

Support the show

Episode Artwork Why Your Tenants Matter with Joe Rinderknecht 33:42 Episode Artwork Is Your Business Stealing Your Joy with Amy Calandrino 32:52 Episode Artwork How To Work Less & Impact More with Divya Smith 30:12 Episode Artwork Why I Left Hollywood for Real Estate with Michael Jacobs 29:25 Episode Artwork Why Investors Follow People, Not Brands with Julia Anderson 34:47 Episode Artwork The Best Investment You Haven’t Heard Of (Yet) with Chris Hanson 37:49 Episode Artwork Why Lead Generation Is the Real Estate Skill That Changes Everything with Carl SanFilippo 35:38 Episode Artwork From Software Revenue to Strategic Acquisitions with Morgan Ehrenzeller 34:58 Episode Artwork How ADUs Are Reshaping Affordable Housing in California with Jonathan Mitchell 31:54 Episode Artwork From Family Business to Full-Service Firm with Frank Sproviero 30:58 Episode Artwork Why Passive Income Often Leads to Passive Losses with Shlomo Chopp 34:33 Episode Artwork Retail Isn’t Dead — It’s Misunderstood with Andy Weiner 31:29 Episode Artwork How Infinite Banking Changes Everything with Jim Oliver 30:34 Episode Artwork Serving Through Real Estate After the Military with Marcus Long 36:23 Episode Artwork The Development Advantage with Justin Goodin 25:58 Episode Artwork Smart Investing for Busy Professionals with Param Baladandapani 37:37 Episode Artwork From Skeptic to Investor: How Real Estate Changed Everything with Jeanette Friedrich 34:23 Episode Artwork Why Client Relationships Matter More Than Transactions with George Pino 40:49 Episode Artwork Revolutionizing Real Estate with Total Cost of Ownership with Andy McQuade 46:06 Episode Artwork Turning Authenticity into a Capital-Raising Superpower with Jeremy Dyer 36:58 Episode Artwork Why Content Creation Drives Business Growth with Joe Killinger 35:20 Episode Artwork Scaling Success: From Rentals to Hard Money Lending with Owen Dashner 37:20 Episode Artwork Social Media Mastery in Commercial Real Estate with Carson Baird 40:14 Episode Artwork Why Omaha is a Real Estate Goldmine with Seth Campbell 30:49 Episode Artwork The STARS Method: Transform Your Mindset, Transform Your Life with Chris Schwagerl 36:24