The American Retirement Advisor
Retirement should feel like freedom, not a puzzle. The American Retirement Advisor is your daily dose of straight talk on the three decisions that shape every retirement: your healthcare, your income, and your inheritance plan.
Each episode is a short, focused read of our latest article, drawn from real conversations with real families at American Retirement Advisors in Scottsdale, Arizona. No jargon. No sales pitch. Just the kind of advice you'd want from a trusted friend who happens to do this for a living.
Hosted by Ian Schaeffer, author of Medicare Made 123Easy, COO of ARA, and founder of 123Easy Studios. Articles read by Betty.
American Retirement Advisors has served over 14,900 families since 2001. Featured in Forbes, a 4-time America's Select Financial Advisors honoree, a 3-time Inc. 500, and a Nextdoor Neighborhood Favorite.
New episodes daily. Subscribe so you never miss one.
Read the full articles at https://news.americanretirementadvisors.com/
The American Retirement Advisor
The Steak Dinner
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
You know the invitation. Heavy cardstock, a nice restaurant, a free dinner, and a presentation about an exciting financial opportunity. Go. Enjoy the steak. I mean that sincerely. Just bring the one question that turns the whole evening in your favor.
Read the full article: https://news.americanretirementadvisors.com/the-steak-dinner/
American Retirement Advisors helps families in Arizona and Nevada navigate healthcare, retirement income, and inheritance planning. Want to reach out? Text us at (602) 281-3898, email support@americanretire.com, or visit https://americanretirementadvisors.com.
Welcome to the American Retirement Advisor, coming to you from One to Three Z Studios. Real stories, real strategies, and straight talk about healthcare, retirement income, and inheritance planning. I'm Ian Schaefer, joined with Eddie and Betty. Let's get into it.
SPEAKER_08Welcome back to the American Retirement Advisor. I'm Betty, and Eddie is here with me in the studio today, which I'm glad about because this one is going to be fun. We are talking about the steak dinner. You know the one. The heavy cardstock invitation, the nice steakhouse, the complimentary ribeye, the brief educational presentation. If you've been retired for more than about 20 minutes, one of these has shown up in your mailbox.
SPEAKER_01And anybody a bit further down that road has probably gotten enough of them to do something decorative with them. Ian Schaefer used that very image in his piece today, and it stuck with me. Some clients he says could wallpaper a hallway with these invitations.
SPEAKER_08Which tells you how common this is. And I think most of us have been told, either by a family member or just by general financial advice culture, throw it away, don't go. It's a sales trap. And Ian Schaefer's piece today takes a pretty direct swing at that advice.
SPEAKER_01He says go, and he is completely serious about it. Wear the good jacket, order the ribeye medium rare, have the creme brulee, let them refill the decaf. Do not feel one ounce of guilt. Those are basically his words.
SPEAKER_08Which, if you're hearing that from a financial professional, probably sounds a little surprising.
SPEAKER_01It caught me off guard too, but his reasoning is really solid once he lays it out, and I think it reframes the whole experience in a way that's genuinely useful.
SPEAKER_08So let's start there. Why does he say go? What's the argument for showing up to one of these things?
SPEAKER_01A couple of reasons, and they build on each other. The first is that he wants to be fair to the dinner itself. He says the products being pitched at these events are usually real products. Often they're products that his own team uses with the right clients in the right situations. The presenter is usually licensed, usually personable, and usually telling the truth about whatever the product does.
SPEAKER_07So it's not that the products are fake or that anyone's lying to you over the fillet.
SPEAKER_01Right, nobody's being deceptive. That's an important distinction. The issue is something different and honestly subtler. The dinner works, he says, because in that room, the product is the only thing on the table. The charts are compelling, the stories are moving, the numbers are real numbers, but not one thing in that ballroom knows anything about you specifically.
SPEAKER_08And he makes that point with an analogy that I thought was really clear. He compares it to a new medication.
SPEAKER_01Yes, and it's a good one. He says a new prescription is never judged on its own. It's always judged against everything you're already taking. Interactions matter. What looks like a great drug in isolation could be a real problem for a specific patient on a specific combination of other things. The steak dinner, as he puts it, is a beautifully catered evening built on skipping that step.
SPEAKER_08It's a specialist with a microphone, and the intake form is a reservation for two. That line stopped me when I read it.
SPEAKER_01It's a perfect image. That kind of presenter can go very deep on one thing. That depth is real and it can be impressive, but a specialist, by definition, has not seen your whole chart. They haven't seen your other accounts, your social security timing, your pension, your beneficiary forms, any of it. They can tell you a lot about the product. They cannot tell you whether the product fits you.
SPEAKER_08So you're sitting in a ballroom eating a very good piece of steak, being presented with something that might genuinely be a solid product, but there's no way to know if it belongs in your life because no one in the room has seen your life.
SPEAKER_01Exactly. And that's not necessarily a sin on the presenter's part, it's just the structural reality of what that event is. It is not and cannot be a personalized financial review. It's a product presentation to a room full of strangers.
SPEAKER_08Okay, so that's the setup. Now here's the part I really want to dig into, because Ian Schaefer doesn't just say go and enjoy yourself, he gives you something specific to bring with you. One question.
SPEAKER_01Just one. And he calls it polite, friendly, and devastating, which is a great combination of words. It is. So what's the question? When the presenter or the person who comes by your table during dessert asks what you thought, you smile and you say something like, It sounds interesting. How would it interact with what I already have? That's it. That's the whole play. Seven words, more or less, and he says it reveals everything. Why is that one question so powerful? Because of what it forces. A specialist, by definition, cannot answer it. They have never seen your annuities, your life insurance, your pension election, your social security timing, your beneficiary forms. So if they respond confidently and immediately without asking a single question about your situation, you've learned something very important about the evening. And as Ian Schaefer puts it, it costs them a stake to teach you.
SPEAKER_03What a way to put it. The ribeye was their tuition, not yours. They paid for the education and you get to keep it.
SPEAKER_01And flipping it the other way, if they hear that question and they actually stop and start genuinely asking about your full picture, that's a different signal. That might mean you found a careful professional. And he makes a point that I think is worth underlining. Careful professionals are not threatened by that question. They're relieved by it. It's the question they wish every prospect asked.
SPEAKER_08Because a good advisor wants to know the whole situation before they recommend anything.
SPEAKER_01Right. The question itself acts as a filter. It separates the people who are product focused from the people who are client-focused. Either response you get is useful information. Either way, as he says, you win the dinner.
SPEAKER_08Now, I want to push on something here, because I think there's a version of this where someone shows up, asks the question, gets a reasonable sounding answer, and still goes home and signs something they shouldn't. The question protects you, but only if you know what you already have.
SPEAKER_01And that's the catch he names directly. It only has real power if somebody truly knows the answer. If there's no current picture of your finances, no list of what you own, no one who has looked at everything together, then the steak dinner isn't your problem. The drawer is.
SPEAKER_08Which for anyone just joining us this week is the place where all the old statements and policies and random financial paperwork have lived for the last 15 years.
SPEAKER_01The place where things go when you're not sure what to do with them and you're not ready to deal with them. And he references earlier pieces in this series where he talks about that specific problem: products bought one at a time from salespeople who never met each other, death benefits nobody remembers owning, situations where a funeral ended up being paid for twice because no one had the full picture.
SPEAKER_08So the question at the dinner is downstream of something bigger, which is having someone who has really looked at your whole financial life together, not just in pieces.
SPEAKER_01That's the armor he's describing. He says clients who go to those presentations with a current annual review, who know that every piece of their money already has a job, who have someone they trust who has seen the whole picture, they sit through those presentations differently, not with cynicism, with clarity.
SPEAKER_08That's a meaningful distinction. One of them is just defensive, the other is protective, and only one of them ever did anybody any good.
SPEAKER_01Cynicism might make you throw away the invitation and miss a genuinely good idea. Clarity lets you go, ask the right question, and then make a real decision with real information.
SPEAKER_09So what does he say should happen with the brochure you bring home? Because you're going to come home with something.
SPEAKER_01Accept it with a smile, he says. Be pleasant, and then carry it to your next review and drop it on the desk with everything else. Let it compete fairly. The audition happens in the office with everything on the table, not in a ballroom where the only thing on the desk is a contract and a pen.
SPEAKER_06I want to sit with that image for a second, because it's kind of a nice way to think about it. Any new idea has to audition against the plan you already have.
SPEAKER_01And he's clear that's not a hostile thing. Auditions are healthy. Some new ideas pass them. A product from a steak dinner could genuinely be the right fit for a particular client in a particular situation, but you can't know that until it's been put side by side with everything else, in a context where someone who knows your full picture is doing the evaluating.
SPEAKER_05Which is a much better outcome than signing something in a ballroom because the presentation was compelling and the creme brulee was good.
SPEAKER_01So is the dessert. That's by design. Nothing about that evening is an accident. You've been to one of these, haven't you? I've been to more than one. And the food is genuinely good. That's also by design. You are the marketing budget, as he says. They have budgeted for a nice dinner, and that budget is working on you while the presentation works on you.
SPEAKER_09So knowing that going in changes the experience.
SPEAKER_01Completely. Once you understand what the mechanism is, once you see that the room is built to make one product look like the answer to everything, you can appreciate the stake for what it is and evaluate the product for what it is. Two separate things.
SPEAKER_08Let me ask something I think listeners might be wondering.
SPEAKER_09These presentations, they cover a lot of different kinds of products.
SPEAKER_08Annuities come up a lot. But some of these dinners also pitch life insurance strategies. What's the thinking there? Because I know life insurance in retirement is a topic that comes up in a very different way than it did when people were younger.
SPEAKER_01It's a whole other conversation at that stage of life, and it's one where the product type matters enormously. Earlier in life, the job that life insurance is doing is usually straightforward income replacement. If something happens to you while your family depends on your paycheck, the insurance makes them whole. Term coverage does that job very well and at a low cost. It's temporary by design because the need for that particular protection is temporary.
SPEAKER_08But by the time you're getting steak dinner invitations, that chapter is probably over.
SPEAKER_01Often, yes. The kids are grown, the mortgage may be paid off, and the income replacement need has changed or gone away entirely. But in retirement, life insurance can take on completely different jobs. Estate liquidity, making sure there's cash available to settle in a state without forcing the sale of a business or a piece of property. Inheritance equalization, making sure that if one child is getting the family farm and another child isn't, the numbers still feel fair to everyone. Or leaving a legacy to a charity or a family through a trust structure. And those later-in-life jobs, those aren't jobs for term coverage. They're not, because term is temporary, it ends. If the job is something that needs to be there no matter when you die, it generally requires permanent coverage, coverage that lasts the whole of life. Those are fundamentally different products, and if a steak dinner presentation is blurring that line or treating them as interchangeable, that's something to notice.
SPEAKER_02And that's where the question earns its keep again, isn't it? How does this interact with what I already have? Forces the presenter to at least try to account for what coverage you might already own and what it's doing.
SPEAKER_01It does. And for anyone who isn't sure what they own or has a policy stuffed in that drawer without knowing whether it's still in force or what the death benefit is, that's the kind of thing where I genuinely say bring it to an advisor before you sign anything new. Our team at American Retirement Advisors does that kind of full picture review. And that's precisely the setting where questions like that get real answers instead of ballroom answers.
SPEAKER_08I think there's also something worth saying about the emotional side of sitting in one of those rooms, because the presentations are designed to be moving. The stories are real. There are real people who got into trouble and a product helped them. And when you're sitting in a nice restaurant, you're relaxed, you've had a good meal, and someone is telling you a story that resonates, it can be hard to stay analytical.
SPEAKER_01It's designed to be hard. That's not cynical, that's just marketing. Stories move people. That's why every presentation leads with a story and not a spreadsheet. And the stories are usually true, but true and applicable to your situation are two different things. The couple in the story had a specific problem that this specific product solved. That doesn't mean you have that problem.
SPEAKER_08Which goes back to the medication analogy. A drug that saves one patient's life can be the wrong drug for a different patient.
SPEAKER_01And nobody in that ballroom can tell you which one you are. Only someone who has your chart can do that.
SPEAKER_08So the armor Ian Schaefer is describing isn't about being cold or suspicious. It's about having already done the work so that you're not making the decision in an emotionally optimized environment.
SPEAKER_01Right. Nothing has to be decided at the dinner. The dinner is just reconnaissance. You go, you gather information, you ask the question, you take the brochure, and then you bring it somewhere where the decision can be made properly.
SPEAKER_08I want to talk about what that annual review needs to look like, because he references it as the source of that protective clarity. What does it mean to have someone who has seen the whole chart?
SPEAKER_01It means that at least once a year, everything is on the table at the same time. Every account, every policy, every income source, social security, pension if there is one, beneficiary designations, the works. And someone who understands how those pieces interact is looking at them together and making sure they're still working as a system.
SPEAKER_08Not just each piece doing its own thing.
SPEAKER_01That solo act is how you end up with duplicate coverage or a gap you didn't know was there, or a new product from a steak dinner that conflicts with something you bought 15 years ago from someone else. The interaction check, as Ian Schaefer calls it, is the whole point.
SPEAKER_08And the thing that gets me about this is how reasonable and non-dramatic it is as a framework. It's not, don't go. It's not, these people are out to get you. It's just go with your eyes open, ask one good question, and make the real decision somewhere else.
SPEAKER_01It respects the dinner and the person sitting through it. He's not being dismissive of the event or the product or even the presenter. He's just being clear about what the event is and is not. It is not a comprehensive financial review. It is a product presentation in a social environment designed to lower your guard. Both of those things can be true at the same time.
SPEAKER_04And walking in with both ideas in your pocket puts you in a pretty good position, relaxed enough to have a lovely time, awake enough to keep your signature to yourself.
SPEAKER_01And you enjoy the steak with zero guilt, you ask the question, you learn something about the presenter from how they answer it, and you go home with a brochure instead of a contract. That's a good evening.
SPEAKER_08There's a version of this too where the person you meet at the dinner turns out to be genuinely good. He leaves that door open.
SPEAKER_01He does, and I appreciate that he does. If someone responds to that question by engaging with your situation, by asking about your full picture, instead of deflecting or steamrolling, that's a real signal. Careful professionals are relieved by that question. It is, as he says, the question they wish every prospect asked. So the question doesn't just protect you from the wrong people, it can help you find the right ones.
SPEAKER_09Though even then, the next step is the same: bring whatever they offer to a place where the whole picture can be evaluated.
SPEAKER_01Always. A good idea stands up to scrutiny. If what they pitched is as strong as it sounded in the ballroom, it'll still be strong when your advisor looks at it alongside everything else. The audition is fair. Good ideas pass auditions.
SPEAKER_09Okay, I want to give people something very concrete to walk away with today, because today's show is really practical. What's the actual sequence?
SPEAKER_04Someone gets the invitation, then what?
SPEAKER_01First, before you even go, make sure you have a current sense of what you own. If you haven't done a full review recently, that's the thing to prioritize. The specific details of how to pull that together, what accounts to include, how to track down old policies, that's a great conversation to have with one of the advisors on our team before you walk into one of these dinners. But start there. Then go to the dinner. Go. Wear the good jacket, order the ribeye, enjoy the creme brulee, listen to the presentation with genuine curiosity because you might learn something real about a product category you didn't know much about. Just remember the context you're sitting in. Ask the question. When they come around, smile and say, It sounds interesting. How would it interact with what I already have? Watch the response. Listen for whether they slow down and ask about you, or whether they speed up and try to close you. Take the brochure.
SPEAKER_08I mean it. Take two.
SPEAKER_01Take all of it. Be pleasant. Say thank you, and then go home with the reading material, not the contract.
SPEAKER_08And then the next step, the one that matters most.
SPEAKER_01Bring it to your next review. Drop it on the desk with everything else. Let your advisor look at it in the context of your actual situation. If it's as good as it sounded, it'll hold up. If it doesn't fit, you'll know exactly why, and you'll understand your own picture better for having gone through the exercise.
SPEAKER_08And dinner was on them. That part still delights me.
SPEAKER_01The steak is complimentary. The question is yours to keep. That's how he closes it, and I think it's spot on.
SPEAKER_08I do too. And I'll just say if it dawns on you tonight that you don't have that full picture right now, you're not sure what you own or whether it all fits together, that's the most important thing to fix first. Not because a steak dinner is coming, but because you deserve to know that every piece of your retirement is doing what you think it's doing.
SPEAKER_01And that's not a complicated or scary process when you do it with someone who knows what they're looking at. It's actually a relief. Most people who go through a comprehensive review for the first time say the same thing, which is that they feel better, not worse, even if some things need adjusting. Clarity is better than the drawer.
SPEAKER_08Every single time. Alright, we should mention that Ian Schaefer teased what's coming tomorrow, and it involves a cardboard box named Bob, which I am completely here for, and I have no idea what that means yet.
SPEAKER_01He promised it will make sense, and based on everything else in this series, I believe him.
SPEAKER_08That's tomorrow's episode, so come back for that. And in the meantime, if today got you thinking about your own picture, about whether someone has looked at all of it together, that's worth acting on. You can reach out to the team at American Retirement Advisors, sit down with one of our advisors, and just start that conversation. There's no commitment in asking the questions. That's true with the steak dinner, and it's true with us. We'll see you tomorrow.
SPEAKER_01A quick note before we wrap up. Today's episode covers financial topics for educational purposes only. American Retirement Advisors does not provide tax or legal advice. Please consult a CPA or tax professional before making any decisions based on what you heard today.
SPEAKER_08This is Betty with the American Retirement Advisor. Thanks for listening. If this episode helped you think differently about your retirement, share it with someone who needs to hear it. You can read the full article and browse hundreds more at AmericanRetire.com. Want to reach out? You can text us at 602-281-3898. Or email support at AmericanRetire.com. Be sure to subscribe so you never miss an episode. We publish daily. See you next time.
SPEAKER_00Thanks, Eddie. Thanks, Betty. Until next time, this is Ian Schaefer coming to you from 123 Easy Studios. I hope you've enjoyed this recording of the American Retirement Advisor, where we make healthcare, income, and inheritance planning 123 Easy.
