To inspire, educate and motivate you to be the best you can be. Learn about tackling mental health problems like Anxiety and Depression as well as simple tips to understand the world better, in a down to earth and genuine way with the Best Selling Author and Psychotherapist Richard Nicholls.
Somebody dies, or something awful happens, and sooner or later somebody will ask if you've got closure yet. Like it's a certificate. So this week I look at where that word actually came from, which is not psychology, and why it contradicts itself, and why the fact that you're still carrying something years later isn't a fault. It's just what humans do.
Hey there, it's Friday. So I've got a short one for you. And this week it's about a word that I reckon does more damage than you'd think. 'cause it gets said with the very best intentions every single time. And that's closure because somebody dies or a relationship falls apart or something awful happens. And sooner or later somebody will tell you that you need to get closure on it. Or worse, they'll ask you if you've got closure yet, like it's a certificate, like there's a box somewhere you'll eventually be allowed to tick. And I've had people sat in front of me in the therapy room, almost apologising for not having managed it. They'll say things like, it's been 18 months now and I still cry sometimes. What's wrong with me? And the answer is, nothing. Nothing is wrong with you. Because here's the thing I found out that properly annoyed me. Closure, in the grief sense of it, didn't come from psychology at all. There's a sociologist called Nancy Berns who went and traced where it actually came from. Turns out it got assembled through the late eighties and into the nineties. Out of the way the US News covered court cases and executions. Out of daytime telly. Out of victim's rights campaigning. And out of advertising, the funeral trade. Closure got bolted onto products, onto things like coffins, onto services, onto memorial jewellery, buy the thing and get the feeling. So the next time somebody tells you that you really ought to have closure by now what they're repeating without having the faintest idea that they're doing it is basically a marketing slogan. And so Berns went and looked at what people actually mean when they use the word. Turns out there is no agreed definition. She found six different versions of it in circulation. There's closing a chapter, remembering, forgetting, getting even, knowing, and confessing or forgiving. And if you have a proper look into that list, you'll see some of those are the exact opposites of each other. Remembering and forgetting, getting even and forgiving. Both of them sold to us as closure. Well, if a word can point in two opposite directions at once, it isn't telling as much is it? Now, I'm not saying that the feeling underneath it is made up because it isn't. The wanting to know that's real. That's about as human as it gets, and it's very well documented. When a family with somebody missing say, We just need to know what happened to them. That is genuine. It matters. And actually getting an answer does help. It's the same with funerals. It's the same with going in to see somebody one last time. There's decent research that suggests that those who do that never seem to regret it because it makes the death real. So I'm not disputing any of that, but wanting to know something and grief coming to an end are two completely different claims and they keep getting bundled up and sold as one. Because what the research actually shows, and this is decades of it, is that even when the answer does arrive, even when the body comes home, for example, and the funeral happens and everybody says their goodbyes. The grief doesn't shut down. It changes shape, but it doesn't end. And there is a whole body of work now called continuing bonds, which found that the people coping best after a loss aren't the ones who've detached and moved on at all. They're the ones that are still talking to them, still keeping certain rituals, still asking themselves what they'd have said about something. The relationship carries on. It's just changed into something that they can carry about with them. So once you know that you can stop measuring yourself against a finish line that was never there in the first place, because that's the real cost of the idea of closure. Not that it's wrong, exactly, but that once everybody expects grief to have an ending grief that carries on, starts to look like a fault. And it isn't a fault. It's just what love does when there's nowhere left to put it. So if you are still carrying something and it still knocks you sideways occasionally, seemingly outta nowhere on a Tuesday afternoon, you're not doing anything wrong. You're living your life in the way that humans have always done it. And if you want to hear a bit more about this, I made a full episode over on Patreon and there's a new one every single Monday morning. It's about the price of a cup of coffee once a month, and there's a massive back catalogue on there now sorted into collections if you wanna have a dig around. Anyway, that's your lot for today. Have a super duper weekend and I'll speak to you soon. See ya.