404 Joe Tomandl – CAFOs have caught up, can regenerative dairy still win?

Investing in Regenerative Agriculture and Food

Investing in Regenerative Agriculture and Food
404 Joe Tomandl – CAFOs have caught up, can regenerative dairy still win?
Feb 10, 2026 Episode 404
Koen van Seijen

We are at an interesting moment in the dairy sector. For years, smaller farmers with around 200 cows, who were also great graziers, could undercut the costs of large concentrated dairy operations, keeping costs low, taking healthy margins in good years, and surviving the bad ones.

But something has changed: CAFO dairies have grown bigger and bigger (10,000 cows is now normal, and 100,000 is no longer an exception) and their economies of scale mean they are undercutting the grazers. Of course, this leads to massive manure lagoons, animal welfare disasters, and all kinds of other externalities, but nobody is paying for that yet. Not to mention that you can only push biology so far before it literally breaks.

So what’s next for regenerative grazing? Joe Tomandl, 4th generation dairy farmer, founder and director of the Dairy Grazing Alliance, argues instead for focusing on the transition of mid-size farms with 300– 700 cows that have surrounding land which could be grazed but currently isn’t. You need grazing experience and a long-term offtake agreement, but it can be done.

More about this episode.

==========================

In Investing in Regenerative Agriculture and Food podcast show we talk to the pioneers in the regenerative food and agriculture space to learn more on how to put our money to work to regenerate soil, people, local communities and ecosystems while making an appropriate and fair return. Hosted by Koen van Seijen.

==========================

👩🏻‍💻 YOUR OUR WEBSITE 

📚 JOIN OUR VIDEO COURSE 

💪🏻 SUPPORT OUR WORK

==========================

🎙 LISTEN TO OUR PODCAST AND SUBSCRIBE TO OUR CHANNEL OR WATCH IT ON  📽️ our YouTube channel

==========================

FOLLOW US!

🔗 Linkedin

📸 Instagram

==========================

The above references an opinion and is for information and educational purposes only. It is not intended to be investment advice. Seek a duly licensed professional for investment advice.

Thoughts? Ideas? Questions? Send us a message!

Use KOEN10 for 10% off

RFSI Europe 2026

Find out more about our Generation-Re investment syndicate:
https://gen-re.land/

Thank you to our Field Builders Circle for supporting us. Learn more here

Support the show

Feedback, ideas, suggestions?
- Twitter @KoenvanSeijen
- Get in touch www.investinginregenerativeagriculture.com

Join our newsletter on www.eepurl.com/cxU33P!

Support the show

Thanks for listening and sharing!

Episode Artwork 404 Joe Tomandl – CAFOs have caught up, can regenerative dairy still win? 1:07:25 Episode Artwork 403 Million Belay - Why the USAID shutdown was a gift to agroecology in Africa 53:18 Episode Artwork Martin Reiter - Meat Mythbusters (Bonus Episode) 5:47 Episode Artwork 402 Martin Reiter – Building a $100B home for regenerative brands 1:03:32 Episode Artwork 401 Bart van der Zande - A venture studio is the solution to all our regenerative challenges 1:13:04 Episode Artwork 400 Omoke Brian - Inside Africa’s regenerative agriculture opportunity 1:00:39 Episode Artwork 399 AI in Ag: What’s Possible, What’s Not, What Farmers Need to Know @ Groundswell 2025 59:34 Episode Artwork 398 Thekla Teunis and Gijs Boers - Regenerative practices deliver higher quality and way higher prices in year one 1:33:55 Episode Artwork What 2025 taught us about making regen bankable, animals, water, chefs, scale, Al in ag, agroforestry, education, food as medicine, ROl, storytelling 14:29 Episode Artwork 397 Andres Jara - How a chef-butcher-farmer turned legumes into a scalable, clean-label food that rewards farmers 1:34:17 Episode Artwork 396 Erin Martin - Making America Healthy Again with food as medicine, not Ozempic 1:08:49 Episode Artwork 395 Alfonso Chico de Guzmán - The ag-tech that brings cows back 1:36:53 Episode Artwork 394 Stef van Dongen - Trees don’t send invoices so a Catalan valley is rewiring water, forests and finance 57:38 Episode Artwork 393 Simon Kraemer - The 'We’ll starve without fertilizer' crowd forgot to check the fields 1:05:43 Episode Artwork 392 Toby Parkes - Mapping the underground fungi world by building a unicorn 1:23:42 Episode Artwork 391 Julia Kasper - Rewetting peatlands is the biggest climate opportunity to cut CO2 50:55 Episode Artwork 390 Nicola Giuggioli - Building a regenerative brand: from soil health to living wages 1:43:32 Episode Artwork 389 Jonathan Lundgren - You need more cows, not fewer, to save the planet 1:07:37 Episode Artwork 388 Justin Bruch - Organic out-earn conventional, how do we transition more farms and farmers? 1:16:10 Episode Artwork 387 Douglas Sheil - Why fixing water fixes carbon 1:00:41 Episode Artwork 386 Lauren Tucker - Inner regen work, gut molds, almonds groves in the Central Valley and taste buds 1:05:01 Episode Artwork 385 Maria Jensen - Giving cows a voice through epigenetics while improving animal welfare and profitability 1:27:44 Episode Artwork 384 Thomas Kliemt - A farming incubator with a 75% success rate (that nobody knows about) lands in Germany 52:51 Episode Artwork 383 Rasmus Nørgaard - From bricks to soil: rethinking real estate from the ground up 1:22:27 Episode Artwork 382 Dianne, Ian and Matthew Haggerty - Food, not commodities: how regenerative agriculture works at scale on 63,000 acres 1:31:51