More of a Comment Than a Question

Tage-gate!

September 19, 2020 Smriti Mehta and Paul Connor Season 1 Episode 11
More of a Comment Than a Question
Tage-gate!
Chapters
More of a Comment Than a Question
Tage-gate!
Sep 19, 2020 Season 1 Episode 11
Smriti Mehta and Paul Connor

This week, we talk about the controversy over a blog by an anonymous person on Twitter, AlvaroDeMenard, about participating in "Replication Markets, a part of DARPA's SCORE program, whose goal is to evaluate the reliability of social science research."
The thread about this on Twitter elicited a response from an editor at Science, Tage Rai, and consequently, multiple responses to that from the Open Science community.


Original thread by @AlvaroDeMenard
https://twitter.com/AlvaroDeMenard/status/1304399437641461760
Associated Blog: https://fantasticanachronism.com/2020/09/11/whats-wrong-with-social-science-and-how-to-fix-it/

Tage Rai's Response
https://twitter.com/tage_rai/status/1304985745157914624

Some notable responses to Tage
Brian Nosek: https://twitter.com/BrianNosek/status/1305319912613838850
Fiona Fidler: https://twitter.com/fidlerfm/status/1305372732889026560
Simine Vazire: https://twitter.com/siminevazire/status/1305703047096532993

Paul Meehl's lecture
(starts at 46:13): https://youtu.be/7vx-A8P1BIw?t=2773

Show Notes

This week, we talk about the controversy over a blog by an anonymous person on Twitter, AlvaroDeMenard, about participating in "Replication Markets, a part of DARPA's SCORE program, whose goal is to evaluate the reliability of social science research."
The thread about this on Twitter elicited a response from an editor at Science, Tage Rai, and consequently, multiple responses to that from the Open Science community.


Original thread by @AlvaroDeMenard
https://twitter.com/AlvaroDeMenard/status/1304399437641461760
Associated Blog: https://fantasticanachronism.com/2020/09/11/whats-wrong-with-social-science-and-how-to-fix-it/

Tage Rai's Response
https://twitter.com/tage_rai/status/1304985745157914624

Some notable responses to Tage
Brian Nosek: https://twitter.com/BrianNosek/status/1305319912613838850
Fiona Fidler: https://twitter.com/fidlerfm/status/1305372732889026560
Simine Vazire: https://twitter.com/siminevazire/status/1305703047096532993

Paul Meehl's lecture
(starts at 46:13): https://youtu.be/7vx-A8P1BIw?t=2773