Armenian News Network - Groong: Week In Review Podcast
Armenian News Network - Groong: Week In Review Podcast
Matt Hoh - What Happened to America First, TRIPP and other US Adventures | Ep 491 - Nov 30, 2025
Conversations on Groong - November 30, 2025
Topics:
- Venezuela
- Ukraine War
- Gaza
- TRIPP in Armenia
Guest: Matthew Hoh
Hosts:
- Hovik Manucharyan
- Asbed Bedrossian
Episode 491 | Recorded: November 29, 2025
Show Notes: https://podcasts.groong.org/491
Video: https://youtu.be/ZZ_n9Mwum30
#Venezuela #AmericaFirst #USForeignPolicy #TRIPP #UkraineWar
Subscribe and follow us everywhere you are: linktr.ee/groong
Hello, everyone, and welcome to this Conversations on Groong episode.
Asbed (00:00:09):Today, we're talking about Trump's foreign policy and action around the world and the
Asbed (00:00:13):splinter it is causing inside MAGA and America First.
Asbed (00:00:18):We will be joined by Captain Matthew Ho,
Asbed (00:00:20):a veteran Marine Corps officer,
Asbed (00:00:22):former diplomat and prominent anti-war advocate.
Asbed (00:00:25):So stay tuned for this exciting discussion.
Hovik (00:00:29):Folks,
Hovik (00:00:30):if this is the first time you're seeing us,
Hovik (00:00:32):namely through Matt Ho,
Hovik (00:00:34):then I want to introduce myself.
Hovik (00:00:36):My name is Hovik Manucharyan.
Hovik (00:00:38):I'm in Yerevan. Asbed Bedrossian is in Los Angeles.
Hovik (00:00:41):We're glad that you have found the show and glad that you're listening.
Hovik (00:00:45):and it shows us that you trust us and you find this interesting uh do us a favor
Hovik (00:00:50):right now and make sure that you're subscribed we see a lot of new uh people but
Hovik (00:00:55):they don't end up subscribing so wherever the button is on your screen make sure
Hovik (00:01:00):you're subscribed that's number one thing you can do to support us right now thanks
Hovik (00:01:04):to all the folks who have chosen to support us financially in the past
Hovik (00:01:08):That means a lot to us,
Hovik (00:01:10):and we aim to reach a level where we can find the help we need to free our time
Hovik (00:01:14):from tedious chores like editing and post-production,
Hovik (00:01:18):and allow us to prep and bring you more shows and more interesting content,
Hovik (00:01:23):more captivating content.
Hovik (00:01:24):So to help us do that, go to podcasts.groong.org and become a sustaining member.
Hovik (00:01:30):Thanks in advance, folks.
Hovik (00:01:31):We have Matt coming on in just a second, so on to the show.
Asbed (00:01:35):Captain Matthew Ho, welcome back to the Groong Podcast.
Matthew (00:01:39):Thanks for having me back on, guys.
Hovik (00:01:40):Great to have you.
Asbed (00:01:42):So we talked a month before Trump's inauguration.
Asbed (00:01:46):There was much hope for the federal government to turn its attention to America
Asbed (00:01:50):first, take care of Americans and drop the forever wars and dreams of a global empire.
Asbed (00:01:56):He would get Ukraine fixed in one day,
Asbed (00:01:59):Gaza a couple of months later,
Asbed (00:02:00):deal with inflation,
Asbed (00:02:01):economy,
Asbed (00:02:02):affordability.
Asbed (00:02:04):But fast forward 10 months later,
Asbed (00:02:05):we have Ukraine,
Asbed (00:02:07):Gaza,
Asbed (00:02:08):Venezuela,
Asbed (00:02:09):Argentina,
Asbed (00:02:10):TRIPP in Armenia and on and on.
Asbed (00:02:13):And I'm sure everyone remembers Greenland and Canada as the 51st state.
Asbed (00:02:18):And Panama, don't forget Panama was the first stop for Marco Rubio.
Asbed (00:02:21):I even forgot that one.
Asbed (00:02:22):Right, yeah.
Asbed (00:02:24):But earlier this morning, Donald Trump announced that the Venezuelan airspace is closed.
Asbed (00:02:29):In a true social post, he wrote to all airlines, pilots, drug dealers and human traffickers.
Asbed (00:02:34):This is one group, I guess, pilots, airline pilots and human drug traffickers.
Asbed (00:02:41):Please consider the airspace above and surrounding Venezuela to be closed in its entirety.
Asbed (00:02:46):This has led analysts to warn that an attack may be imminent.
Asbed (00:02:50):And The Intercept also reports that it has reviewed War Department documents outlining U.S.
Asbed (00:02:55):logistics planning for a Caribbean buildup through 2028.
Asbed (00:03:00):So explain us.
Asbed (00:03:01):What's your take on these developments?
Asbed (00:03:02):What's the geopolitical strategy or reasoning driving Washington towards something
Asbed (00:03:07):like this in Venezuela?
Matthew (00:03:09):I think, and again, thank you for having me back on with you guys.
Matthew (00:03:13):I think there are multiple reasons.
Matthew (00:03:14):A lot of times there's an intersection of desires that make it such a goal is going
Matthew (00:03:24):to be enjoyed by multiple groups,
Matthew (00:03:27):even if those groups are disparate.
Matthew (00:03:29):So if you look in Venezuela,
Matthew (00:03:31):you see this confluence,
Matthew (00:03:33):you see this intertwining or this dovetailing.
Matthew (00:03:35):Of course, the first major interest is that Venezuela has the world's largest oil reserves.
Matthew (00:03:42):You know, I mean, I don't think we really have to elaborate on what that means,
Matthew (00:03:45):but certainly we've seen that commentary in the last weeks,
Matthew (00:03:49):including from,
Matthew (00:03:50):you know,
Matthew (00:03:51):Representative Salazar,
Matthew (00:03:52):who is the third or fourth ranking Republican in the US House,
Matthew (00:03:56):you know, saying that this will be a field day for the American oil companies in Venezuela,
Matthew (00:04:00):you know,
Matthew (00:04:01):I mean, so.
Matthew (00:04:02):You know, they're not even trying to hide that.
Matthew (00:04:06):You know, there are other interests as well.
Matthew (00:04:08):There are just the old neoconservative interests at play here,
Matthew (00:04:12):this idea that the United States has to exert dominance.
Matthew (00:04:16):This is a latent aspect of the United States as the sole superpower,
Matthew (00:04:21):the idea that emerges after the Cold War.
Matthew (00:04:23):that any threat to American supremacy must be destroyed.
Matthew (00:04:29):And that's something that each president since the end of the Cold War has firmly embraced.
Matthew (00:04:33):Trump has his own take on it,
Matthew (00:04:35):which is why the establishment,
Matthew (00:04:37):the foreign policy establishment is often very critical of him and doesn't trust
Matthew (00:04:41):him.
Matthew (00:04:42):And many of them want him out for that reason.
Matthew (00:04:44):John Bolton, I think, being the best example of that.
Matthew (00:04:47):But, you know, there are other reasons as well.
Matthew (00:04:49):You have personal reasons.
Matthew (00:04:51):So Marco Rubio is obsessed with Venezuela.
Matthew (00:04:54):He is obsessed with Latin America in general.
Matthew (00:04:58):He has a personal story that comes from his parents fleeing Cuba,
Matthew (00:05:03):not incidentally from Castro's Cuba,
Matthew (00:05:07):but from the dictator Batista's Cuba.
Matthew (00:05:09):But still, he has this obsession with
Matthew (00:05:12):with Venezuela and Latin America in general.
Matthew (00:05:16):There are grand strategy reasons for this.
Matthew (00:05:19):In the last couple of decades,
Matthew (00:05:21):you've seen China make enormous inroads in Latin America,
Matthew (00:05:25):both Central and South America,
Matthew (00:05:27):to the point now that many South American and Central American companies
Matthew (00:05:32):Their largest trading partner or possibly soon to be their largest trading partner
Matthew (00:05:36):is China,
Matthew (00:05:37):not the United States.
Matthew (00:05:38):This is a real difficult thing for the Americans to accept this idea of a larger scale.
Matthew (00:05:44):Right. Globally, China cutting in on America's good thing.
Matthew (00:05:48):When you're the sole superpower, you've got it well.
Matthew (00:05:51):Right. And one of the best things about being the sole superpower is that you sit on top
Matthew (00:05:55):of a world that's yours to extract from.
Matthew (00:05:57):And so this idea of this rising power,
Matthew (00:06:00):this competitor, China,
Matthew (00:06:01):possibly taking part of a,
Matthew (00:06:03):taking some or taking from the Americans,
Matthew (00:06:05):you know,
Matthew (00:06:06):that's something that can't be abided.
Matthew (00:06:07):I mean, so there's all these different reasons, you know, just the affront.
Matthew (00:06:11):If you're the world's sole superpower, you can't have particularly someone in your society
Matthew (00:06:15):traditional sphere of influence,
Matthew (00:06:18):Central and South America,
Matthew (00:06:19):thumbing their nose at the American empire,
Matthew (00:06:21):at the American government.
Matthew (00:06:22):For that reason alone,
Matthew (00:06:24):many feel they have to remove Maduro from power because you can't have this type of
Matthew (00:06:29):insolence. You can't have this type of...
Matthew (00:06:33):Independence.
Matthew (00:06:34):Independence.
Matthew (00:06:35):Exactly right.
Matthew (00:06:36):You know, that's exactly right.
Matthew (00:06:37):I mean,
Matthew (00:06:38):so you see all these reasons why,
Matthew (00:06:41):you know,
Matthew (00:06:42):it makes sense that Venezuela has become the major target for the United States in
Matthew (00:06:49):terms of its war making in this,
Matthew (00:06:51):you know,
Matthew (00:06:52):first year of the Trump administration.
Hovik (00:06:54):But nevertheless, was it the only choice that the U.S.
Hovik (00:06:57):had in terms of dealing with Venezuela?
Matthew (00:07:00):No, certainly not.
Matthew (00:07:02):We're still to see what's going to come of it.
Matthew (00:07:08):We're still uncertain exactly what the Americans will do.
Matthew (00:07:12):The idea of a full-scale invasion is certainly not on a table because simply the
Matthew (00:07:16):number of troops aren't there.
Matthew (00:07:17):You know,
Matthew (00:07:18):you're looking at 16 to 20,000 troops in and around Venezuela right now,
Matthew (00:07:23):including in the Caribbean,
Matthew (00:07:24):like in Puerto Rico.
Matthew (00:07:27):You know, that's not nearly enough to launch a ground invasion.
Matthew (00:07:32):You know, there's speculation that we will seize airfields and ports,
Matthew (00:07:36):you know, and same,
Matthew (00:07:38):you know, that idea is for what purpose?
Matthew (00:07:40):You know, so I think the idea of large scale military operations
Matthew (00:07:45):involving American ground troops is something that we can rule out.
Matthew (00:07:50):But the reality is the United States has ruled that out for the last dozen years or
Matthew (00:07:56):so, going back to the second half of the Obama administration,
Matthew (00:08:00):the idea of putting American troops on the ground and taking casualties.
Matthew (00:08:05):is politically unacceptable to the White Houses, whether they're Democratic or Republican.
Matthew (00:08:10):The George W. Bush administration learned that the hard way with the elections of 06 and 08.
Matthew (00:08:16):And the Democrats with 16 as well.
Matthew (00:08:19):Trump's election of 16 was a predation of Hillary Clinton and the wars.
Matthew (00:08:24):So I think the White House is savvy enough to understand that.
Matthew (00:08:29):And so what will we see?
Matthew (00:08:31):Will we see CIA-led operations, coup attempts?
Matthew (00:08:36):Will we see airstrikes with drones and missiles and fighter aircraft?
Matthew (00:08:42):We're just not certain as to what will come about.
Matthew (00:08:46):You know, they have the assets there.
Matthew (00:08:49):They've got the aircraft.
Matthew (00:08:51):They've got the support aircraft.
Matthew (00:08:53):When you start seeing things like the U.S.
Matthew (00:08:56):military, the U.S.
Matthew (00:08:57):Air Force sending its...
Matthew (00:09:00):like RC-135 Rivet Joint signals intelligence aircraft places,
Matthew (00:09:04):the Air Force only has 10 or 12 of those operationally.
Matthew (00:09:08):So when they start moving those around, you know, it's a pretty big deal.
Matthew (00:09:11):You know, I mean,
Matthew (00:09:12):you start seeing other things as well,
Matthew (00:09:13):too,
Matthew (00:09:14):that, okay, they're taking this pretty seriously in the sense of sending the right pieces of
Matthew (00:09:20):equipment,
Matthew (00:09:21):aircraft,
Matthew (00:09:22):personnel,
Matthew (00:09:23):that if they were to carry out
Matthew (00:09:25):such operations, they'd be able to do it in the way that they fully want to.
Matthew (00:09:30):But I think we're just kind of stuck and we'll have to wait and see.
Matthew (00:09:33):There's this hope that somehow a deal will be made.
Matthew (00:09:36):Maduro and Trump supposedly spoke on the phone a week or so ago.
Matthew (00:09:40):And, you know, there's this idea that Maduro might visit Washington, D.C.
Matthew (00:09:44):to speak directly with Trump.
Matthew (00:09:46):I think a lot of people looking at that say we can probably never come back.
Matthew (00:09:50):You know, I mean, so, you know, I don't think that's probably an option.
Matthew (00:09:53):But,
Matthew (00:09:54):you know, I think with all that we know,
Matthew (00:09:56):all that we understand,
Matthew (00:09:57):all the experiences that we've lived through watching the United States carry out
Matthew (00:10:03):its wars overseas,
Matthew (00:10:04):I think we all really need to hope and pray that somehow there's some type of
Matthew (00:10:10):diplomatic resolution found to this crisis and not not a military resolution that's
Matthew (00:10:16):sought because,
Matthew (00:10:17):you know,
Matthew (00:10:18):it's just not Venezuela that would be affected.
Matthew (00:10:19):It would be all of Latin America.
Matthew (00:10:22):Yeah.
Hovik (00:10:22):Yeah.
Hovik (00:10:23):All right.
Hovik (00:10:24):Shall we go to Eurasia, I guess?
Hovik (00:10:27):It just seems there's too many hotspots around the world.
Hovik (00:10:33):Matt, so earlier this week,
Hovik (00:10:35):we read that the United States Army Secretary,
Hovik (00:10:39):Dan Driscoll,
Hovik (00:10:40):was in Kyiv.
Hovik (00:10:43):And he gave the Ukrainians a stark warning.
Hovik (00:10:46):He told them about,
Hovik (00:10:48):quote,
Hovik (00:10:49):imminent defeat,
Hovik (00:10:50):and that the situation would only get worse as time went on.
Hovik (00:10:54):Yet, when I was researching for this podcast, I did a quick search on YouTube.
Hovik (00:10:59):for Ukraine war.
Hovik (00:11:01):And I'd like to read some of the top results that popped up,
Hovik (00:11:04):all having near unanimous tone to them.
Hovik (00:11:07):The military show channel said, Ukraine destroys Russian warship.
Hovik (00:11:11):Putin's Navy retreats in total panic.
Hovik (00:11:14):Canal 13, I'm assuming it has a Ukrainian channel.
Hovik (00:11:17):Ukraine launches U.S.
Hovik (00:11:18):GBU-62 bombs at Russian infantry's gathering point.
Hovik (00:11:22):Invaders are eliminated.
Hovik (00:11:24):So forth and so on.
Hovik (00:11:26):No news about Driscoll's warning.
Hovik (00:11:28):So we want to ask, is Russia collapsing militarily and economically?
Hovik (00:11:34):And it's just a matter of time before Putin swallows the cyanide pill as Zelensky
Hovik (00:11:39):leads the infantry to Moscow.
Hovik (00:11:42):Marches into Moscow.
Matthew (00:11:45):Right, right.
Matthew (00:11:46):I mean, that certainly has been the popular narrative in the Western media for the last
Matthew (00:11:54):almost four years now.
Matthew (00:11:58):This constant refrain that...
Matthew (00:12:01):It's just a matter of more money and more time and Russia will lose,
Matthew (00:12:06):that they'll collapse,
Matthew (00:12:07):that the Russian people will be so upset by the war,
Matthew (00:12:09):they'll overthrow Putin,
Matthew (00:12:11):you know, there'll be a coup because people,
Matthew (00:12:13):you know, the government has failed,
Matthew (00:12:14):you know,
Matthew (00:12:15):on and on and on with the various...
Matthew (00:12:17):explanations and predictions of what's just bound to occur if people just have more
Matthew (00:12:22):faith, if people don't give up hope,
Matthew (00:12:24):if people just aren't weak,
Matthew (00:12:25):or they just stop accepting their funding from the Kremlin,
Matthew (00:12:30):you know, which...
Matthew (00:12:31):So...
Matthew (00:12:35):you know, certainly Russia's not in that position.
Matthew (00:12:37):The Russians have, they prepared for this war very well.
Matthew (00:12:42):They were in a position where they knew they were going to be isolated or there
Matthew (00:12:49):would be an attempt to isolate them.
Matthew (00:12:51):And so they understood how the West was going to react to this war and the Russians
Matthew (00:12:55):prepared themselves for it.
Matthew (00:12:56):I think that
Matthew (00:12:57):over everything else is their greatest success in this war.
Matthew (00:13:02):Both the flexibility of their mindset,
Matthew (00:13:04):the Russians,
Matthew (00:13:05):to look for other partners in the world,
Matthew (00:13:08):to look for other trading relationships in the world,
Matthew (00:13:10):to reimagine and have confidence in their economy that they could survive the
Matthew (00:13:15):harshest sanctions program the world has ever seen,
Matthew (00:13:18):and
Matthew (00:13:19):And not just survive it, but to have success from it.
Matthew (00:13:26):Right.
Matthew (00:13:28):To what we see in the Russian economy that has grown.
Matthew (00:13:32):over these years of war.
Matthew (00:13:34):Their domestic industries have stepped up to fill the gaps from these Western
Matthew (00:13:40):sanctions, from the Western blockade.
Matthew (00:13:42):You've seen them find other partners around the world for all of their commodities,
Matthew (00:13:48):all of their exports,
Matthew (00:13:50):most notably oil and gas.
Matthew (00:13:52):And the gas that used to go to Europe is now going to go to China.
Matthew (00:13:56):And that gas is never going to return to Europe.
Matthew (00:13:59):You know,
Matthew (00:14:00):I mean, in and on the battlefield,
Matthew (00:14:01):you've seen certainly the Russians be able to withstand the weight of Western
Matthew (00:14:09):support for Ukraine.
Matthew (00:14:12):The Russian battle plans,
Matthew (00:14:14):I think, are confusing to many,
Matthew (00:14:16):but they seem not as interested as territorial advancement.
Matthew (00:14:21):as just trying to destroy every piece of kit,
Matthew (00:14:24):every weapon,
Matthew (00:14:26):every piece of equipment,
Matthew (00:14:27):vehicle,
Matthew (00:14:28):et cetera,
Matthew (00:14:29):that the Ukrainians bring to the front.
Matthew (00:14:31):So just fighting a war of attrition where the Russians correctly surmised that
Matthew (00:14:36):their industrial capacity would be stronger than the collective West's industrial
Matthew (00:14:41):capacity.
Matthew (00:14:42):And they were right.
Matthew (00:14:43):And then I think the most important, I just said,
Matthew (00:14:47):Industrial development and their economic plan was the most important,
Matthew (00:14:50):but equally important as well,
Matthew (00:14:52):I think,
Matthew (00:14:53):has been the fact that the Russian generals have defeated the American generals,
Matthew (00:14:59):that the big arrow movements of the Ukrainian army,
Matthew (00:15:03):as we know from reporting by The New York Times,
Matthew (00:15:06):nonetheless,
Matthew (00:15:07):have come from the Americans.
Matthew (00:15:10):that the Americans based in Wiesbaden,
Matthew (00:15:13):Germany,
Matthew (00:15:14):where the Americans set the headquarters to run this war,
Matthew (00:15:17):the Americans have been in charge of the major operational moves of the Ukrainian
Matthew (00:15:22):army.
Matthew (00:15:23):And so in terms of who was fighting who at the general level,
Matthew (00:15:27):essentially,
Matthew (00:15:28):this was the Americans fighting the Russians,
Matthew (00:15:31):the Russians utilizing their own forces as well,
Matthew (00:15:33):and the Americans using
Matthew (00:15:34):proxy Ukrainian forces.
Matthew (00:15:36):And I think anyone who looks at this now says,
Matthew (00:15:38):particularly with the spectacular disasters of several Ukrainian campaigns,
Matthew (00:15:44):most notably the summer or spring,
Matthew (00:15:47):summer 2023 offensive campaign,
Matthew (00:15:50):that the Russian generals defeated the American generals.
Matthew (00:15:52):So, I mean,
Matthew (00:15:53):so that's my estimation of the war in terms of the power balance,
Matthew (00:16:00):in terms of who's,
Matthew (00:16:03):quote,
Matthew (00:16:04):winning, unquote.
Matthew (00:16:05):There's other winners in this war,
Matthew (00:16:06):other losers,
Matthew (00:16:07):you know, certainly when you look at the pullback,
Matthew (00:16:10):look at the larger geopolitical commercial aspects of this.
Matthew (00:16:15):Certainly the American and Qatari
Matthew (00:16:18):Gas companies are winners because they're the ones who got the market for gas in
Matthew (00:16:25):Europe when the Russians were forced out,
Matthew (00:16:28):both by sanctions as well as by the destruction of the Nord Stream pipeline.
Matthew (00:16:32):So there have been winners in the West,
Matthew (00:16:34):the weapons companies,
Matthew (00:16:35):of course,
Matthew (00:16:36):who have years upon years of backlogs and running in tens of billions of dollars
Matthew (00:16:42):for orders for Ukraine as well as for European countries.
Matthew (00:16:46):countries that want to expand their militaries.
Matthew (00:16:50):So there have been some winners in the West as well.
Matthew (00:16:53):But certainly as we look at this,
Matthew (00:16:54):we've seen that Russia is the one who is in the dominant position right now.
Hovik (00:17:00):So the most rational,
Hovik (00:17:01):I mean,
Hovik (00:17:02):from what you're describing,
Hovik (00:17:03):the most rational decision would be to sit down and come up with a negotiated
Hovik (00:17:08):solution to this.
Hovik (00:17:09):But we've been seeing a lot of challenges to it,
Hovik (00:17:12):especially some of the hawks in the US administration and US Congress,
Hovik (00:17:17):but also Europeans.
Hovik (00:17:19):Nevertheless,
Hovik (00:17:22):There was a 28-point proposal, then became a 19-point.
Hovik (00:17:25):I lost count how many points there are now, currently.
Hovik (00:17:29):But good news,
Hovik (00:17:31):I guess maybe it's good news that Witkoff is visiting Moscow,
Hovik (00:17:35):Kremlin, next week for negotiations.
Hovik (00:17:38):But ahead of that visit, Putin doubled down on his territorial conditions.
Hovik (00:17:43):He essentially said that he would only stop fighting if Ukraine withdrew.
Hovik (00:17:47):At the same time,
Hovik (00:17:48):Ukraine's chief negotiator,
Hovik (00:17:49):Andrei Yermak,
Hovik (00:17:51):also ruled out any territorial concessions.
Hovik (00:17:53):So,
Hovik (00:17:54):you know, with all this jockeying,
Hovik (00:17:57):I guess, or positioning,
Hovik (00:17:59):what is the prospect of Russia and at least the U.S.
Hovik (00:18:02):achieving or coming close to some kind of a concord next week?
Matthew (00:18:08):Yeah, you know, honestly, it's tough to, you know, be predictive here, right?
Matthew (00:18:18):how steadfast,
Matthew (00:18:20):how firm both sides have been in their goals or objectives or demands of this war.
Matthew (00:18:26):And certainly, I think objectively, you can understand both.
Matthew (00:18:31):Whether or not politically it's possible for them to...
Matthew (00:18:36):negotiate, whether it's to compromise on those demands is something we'll see.
Matthew (00:18:42):I mean,
Matthew (00:18:43):the Ukrainian government is so weak right now,
Matthew (00:18:45):particularly with this corruption scandal,
Matthew (00:18:47):where it was bad enough that two ministers were dismissed.
Matthew (00:18:53):But now the chief of staff,
Matthew (00:18:54):who is popularly known as the other president of Ukraine,
Matthew (00:18:58):Andrei Yermak,
Matthew (00:18:59):is
Matthew (00:19:00):you know, implicated as well.
Matthew (00:19:01):And so the ability of the Zelensky government to carry out negotiations and to
Matthew (00:19:09):give, to compromise,
Matthew (00:19:11):right, to forget about the sacrifices of all the hundreds of thousands who have given
Matthew (00:19:16):their lives and limbs and minds and souls to this war,
Matthew (00:19:19):is that possible for him?
Matthew (00:19:21):You know, the reality of, say, a coup occurring where the far right is
Matthew (00:19:26):in Ukraine to pose of Zelensky with the backing from the Europeans and many
Matthew (00:19:32):Americans because they don't want to see capitulation,
Matthew (00:19:35):that's not very far-fetched,
Matthew (00:19:37):right? I mean, so,
Matthew (00:19:38):and then on the Russian side as well,
Matthew (00:19:40):when you have most of the political pressure,
Matthew (00:19:43):or I should say most,
Matthew (00:19:44):nearly all the political pressure that's been on Vladimir Putin during this war has
Matthew (00:19:48):come from his right.
Matthew (00:19:49):You know,
Matthew (00:19:50):I think a lot of people in the West would be astonished to understand that Putin is
Matthew (00:19:54):essentially a moderate when we're talking about these types of things.
Matthew (00:19:57):And almost all the pressure comes from his right in the sense,
Matthew (00:20:01):you know,
Matthew (00:20:02):from nationalists,
Matthew (00:20:03):essentially, who say you're not prosecuting this war hard enough.
Matthew (00:20:06):You're being too easy on the Ukrainians.
Matthew (00:20:08):Why haven't we won this already?
Matthew (00:20:10):Right.
Matthew (00:20:11):So and you go back and look at the great sacrifices of the Russians as well.
Matthew (00:20:15):Hundreds of thousands of their men have lost their lives, their limbs.
Matthew (00:20:20):their minds, their souls,
Matthew (00:20:21):as well as the pronouncements of the Russian government,
Matthew (00:20:25):including from the president himself,
Matthew (00:20:26):about the need to denazify and fully demilitarize Ukraine to make sure this threat
Matthew (00:20:33):cannot come at them again.
Matthew (00:20:35):plus the writing into Russian law, the acquisition of all four provinces or oblasts.
Matthew (00:20:42):And this doesn't even get into the whole issue of,
Matthew (00:20:45):you know, the main thing about this was our national security.
Matthew (00:20:48):This doesn't remove American missiles from Poland and Romania.
Matthew (00:20:53):I mean,
Matthew (00:20:54):so is this a compromise that Putin can make where the political pressure on for him
Matthew (00:20:59):is full victory and nothing else?
Matthew (00:21:02):And how come you haven't accomplished that already?
Matthew (00:21:04):Right. I mean, so the political forces at play here in both countries are not in any way lined up
Matthew (00:21:11):to see a successful resolution through negotiation.
Matthew (00:21:18):And you have any of other complicating factors.
Matthew (00:21:20):The Europeans are simply.
Matthew (00:21:23):pretty much dead set against this for matters of their own political identity,
Matthew (00:21:27):for their own aspirations,
Matthew (00:21:29):for their own beliefs in the necessity of this proxy war.
Matthew (00:21:32):And just like you have many Americans,
Matthew (00:21:33):you know,
Matthew (00:21:34):Mitch McConnell, Lindsey Graham,
Matthew (00:21:35):Richard Blumenthal,
Matthew (00:21:37):certainly if this does go through,
Matthew (00:21:39):you will see a re-ignition in the U.S.
Matthew (00:21:41):of Russia-gate.
Matthew (00:21:43):hysteria, Russia-gate accusations against Donald Trump, his appeasement of Russia.
Matthew (00:21:49):You've already seen it, but if it was to go through.
Matthew (00:21:51):So politically,
Matthew (00:21:52):this is going to be a very difficult thing to pull off for anyone involved in this.
Matthew (00:22:01):But the alternative then is for the war to continue and for Ukraine to lose more land.
Matthew (00:22:08):uh you know for the Ukrainian government to eventually be lost in a collapse a
Matthew (00:22:11):military an economic or a political collapse the uh Ukraine is a failed state etc
Matthew (00:22:17):etc and i'll also say for the russians as well yes the russians do have the
Matthew (00:22:21):dominant hammer right now the russians are quote winning unquote right now but this
Matthew (00:22:26):idea of having certainty in warfare is belied by the reality of warfare if anyone
Matthew (00:22:31):thinks
Matthew (00:22:32):that war is going to go the way you expect it to,
Matthew (00:22:36):or war will be your agent and not its agent,
Matthew (00:22:40):just simply hasn't studied war.
Matthew (00:22:42):And so I would caution the Russians that,
Matthew (00:22:44):yes,
Matthew (00:22:45):it's going well now,
Matthew (00:22:46):you are dominating now,
Matthew (00:22:47):you have the advantage now,
Matthew (00:22:49):but in two,
Matthew (00:22:50):three, four years' time,
Matthew (00:22:52):There's no certainty to that.
Matthew (00:22:53):So I would encourage the Russians as well to take this deal.
Matthew (00:22:56):But like you said, Hovic, I don't even know what this deal looks like right now.
Matthew (00:23:01):You know, what they're actually, how many points are there, you know, all of that.
Matthew (00:23:05):So we'll have to see.
Asbed (00:23:06):Actually, when I was looking at the 20,
Asbed (00:23:08):24,
(00:23:18):28 point plan,
Asbed (00:23:10):one thing stuck out to me is that they were saying the West will acknowledge the de
Asbed (00:23:15):facto control of Russia over these places.
Asbed (00:23:18):And I thought that's dead on arrival because,
Asbed (00:23:21):I mean,
Asbed (00:23:23):they wanted to be legally part of Russia,
Asbed (00:23:26):not de facto.
Asbed (00:23:27):Aspet, are you part of the Russia, right?
Asbed (00:23:30):Sorry. Yeah.
Asbed (00:23:31):Well, I just don't see.
Asbed (00:23:34):Okay, well, I don't see how Putin is going to accept that.
Asbed (00:23:36):Right, no, exactly.
Matthew (00:23:38):I mean, I think that's a thing we get to, too.
Matthew (00:23:41):It's so hard.
Matthew (00:23:42):It's because you were bringing up,
Matthew (00:23:43):Hovec,
Matthew (00:23:44):Earl, when you first asked this question about going through the YouTube channels.
Matthew (00:23:47):And it's a lack of objectivity here.
Matthew (00:23:49):Right. I mean,
Matthew (00:23:50):the lack of the ability to have any kind of strategic empathy or cognitive empathy,
Matthew (00:23:55):right, for all sides in this to put yourselves in the Russian shoes and try and approach
Matthew (00:24:01):this from that worldview and try to determine how,
Matthew (00:24:05):you know,
Matthew (00:24:06):I mean, this is this is not anything that should be scandalous,
Matthew (00:24:09):but that's the state of Western media is that if you if you try and advance an
Matthew (00:24:15):objective view based on your analysis and understanding
Matthew (00:24:18):of one party's needs or desires or actions, you're accused of being a booster.
Matthew (00:24:26):You're accused of being on their payroll.
Matthew (00:24:29):You're abused of carrying for their agenda.
Matthew (00:24:32):And that's just nonsense.
Hovik (00:24:33):We frequently, even when we try to be objective and just reason about it, we get accused.
Hovik (00:24:39):So let me ask you one more quick question about Ukraine.
Hovik (00:24:43):um so i mean there are multiple scenarios obviously you went through some of them
Hovik (00:24:47):uh i don't want to go through all of them but it seems to me i mean uh like in all
Hovik (00:24:52):cases it seems like the military gears continue will continue to uh turn but what
Hovik (00:24:58):happens if there's some kind of a agreement between moscow and washington dc but
Hovik (00:25:06):Ukraine and Europeans don't agree.
Hovik (00:25:09):And what does that look like?
Hovik (00:25:11):You know, because we've heard these scenarios where Trump wants to pull out.
Hovik (00:25:15):So he's going to stop intelligence support or there are some other like,
Hovik (00:25:18):you know,
Hovik (00:25:19):predictions being made.
Hovik (00:25:20):Do you see that as one of the more likely scenarios?
Hovik (00:25:23):What do you think about that?
Matthew (00:25:24):I think it's a very possible scenario where Donald Trump says,
Matthew (00:25:28):OK, you know,
Matthew (00:25:29):a pox on everyone involved here.
Matthew (00:25:32):I'm washing my hands of this, the United States is out.
Matthew (00:25:36):At that point,
Matthew (00:25:37):Moscow feels that it has the ability to further persecute this war and actually see
Matthew (00:25:44):some form of capitulation by Ukraine because of the battlefield or because of
Matthew (00:25:50):economic or political collapse.
Matthew (00:25:52):I don't know why the Russians would want that, because then you're talking about
Matthew (00:25:58):That's one aspect.
Matthew (00:25:59):The farther west the Russians go, the more they're moving into Ukrainian-speaking lands.
Matthew (00:26:04):Just to put this in really simple terms, right?
Matthew (00:26:06):Because I know it's more complicated than that.
Matthew (00:26:08):And so then they risk, exactly, being occupiers and having insurgency.
Matthew (00:26:12):The Russians have never stated that they've wanted anything more
Matthew (00:26:16):than the four provinces in which they've been fighting.
Matthew (00:26:19):They've been talking about buffer zones and things like that,
Matthew (00:26:22):but nothing ever that you can really point to and say,
Matthew (00:26:25):this actually is a Russian goal.
Matthew (00:26:28):So their goals have been those four provinces or oblasts in the east.
Matthew (00:26:34):And so the idea of going past that,
Matthew (00:26:35):well,
Matthew (00:26:36):now they're moving into a whole aspect of this war that they didn't want,
Matthew (00:26:41):that was never their goal.
Matthew (00:26:43):And then the idea of having to take it all the way to the Polish and Romanian borders.
Matthew (00:26:49):And would Ukraine even last that long or would it collapse?
Matthew (00:26:52):And then if it collapses,
Matthew (00:26:53):you have millions of refugees going throughout Europe,
Matthew (00:26:57):including into Russia.
Matthew (00:26:59):And then you have, what are the Poles and the Romanians going to do?
Matthew (00:27:02):Are they going to sit and watch as the Russian armies come across Ukraine?
Matthew (00:27:06):Or are they going to advance into Ukraine themselves?
Matthew (00:27:09):for a whole bunch of reasons.
Matthew (00:27:11):I mean, you can see that,
Matthew (00:27:12):how this becomes a nightmare scenario in a bunch of different ways,
Matthew (00:27:15):how this bloke goes into World War III,
Matthew (00:27:19):true World War III stages here.
Asbed (00:27:22):Preamble, sort of, yeah.
Matthew (00:27:23):Exactly, yeah, thank you, right?
Matthew (00:27:24):You know,
Matthew (00:27:25):I mean, so that's,
Matthew (00:27:28):I think, one example of the danger if the United States pulls out of this.
Matthew (00:27:33):But the reality is, I think that,
Matthew (00:27:36):The way the Europeans and the Ukrainians will look at it is that our best bet,
Matthew (00:27:40):though,
Matthew (00:27:41):is for us to wait this out.
Matthew (00:27:45):Hopefully in 26, the Democrats will take both the House and the Senate.
Matthew (00:27:50):There's enough Republican support for this that maybe we can get aid from the United States.
Matthew (00:27:55):through to us overriding a Trump veto on this,
Matthew (00:27:59):or Trump is willing to change his mind enough that maybe he will allow aid to come
Matthew (00:28:06):back,
Matthew (00:28:07):and that we can then win,
Matthew (00:28:09):the Democrats win the election in 28,
Matthew (00:28:11):or we get a Republican neoconservative,
Matthew (00:28:14):which there are plenty,
Matthew (00:28:16):not J.D. Vance,
Matthew (00:28:17):but we get somebody else,
Matthew (00:28:18):like a Marco Rubio,
Matthew (00:28:19):who wins the election in 28,
Matthew (00:28:21):and then we're back in business with this war.
Matthew (00:28:23):And I think that's the estimation that the Ukrainians and the Europeans will make,
Matthew (00:28:29):that that is a better thing to shoot for,
Matthew (00:28:32):that that hope is better than the reality of accepting a defeat.
Matthew (00:28:39):And so the danger here is so,
Matthew (00:28:42):so great that this could get much worse than even what we've been seeing.
Asbed (00:28:46):Well,
Asbed (00:28:47):OK, let me turn our attention to another conflict where Trump is campaigning for his
Asbed (00:28:52):Nobel Peace Prize, because his 20-point peace plan sets the frame for a Gaza
Asbed (00:28:59):ceasefire, and phase one produced a hostage and detainee swap and a partial Israeli
Asbed (00:29:03):pullback from Gaza.
Asbed (00:29:05):Phase two calls for Hamas to disarm and for a UN-backed international stabilization
Asbed (00:29:12):force, the ISF,
Asbed (00:29:13):to take over security.
Asbed (00:29:15):And for a new technocratic authority, they're calling it the Board of Peace.
Asbed (00:29:20):Orwell would be very proud of this, to run Gaza.
Asbed (00:29:24):Right.
Asbed (00:29:26):The truce remains shaky.
Asbed (00:29:28):Settler violence and rapid settlement growth in the West Bank now threatened to
Asbed (00:29:32):break this peace process.
Asbed (00:29:34):But also the ICC,
Asbed (00:29:37):the International Criminal Court,
Asbed (00:29:38):has issued arrest warrants for leaders on both sides,
Asbed (00:29:41):including Netanyahu and senior Hamas figures.
Asbed (00:29:44):The plan has ramped up a split inside Trump's MAGA and America First base.
Asbed (00:29:50):Many believe Trump's pledge to end foreign wars is being pulled off course by the
Asbed (00:29:55):same globalist and neocon networks that they view as responsible for past
Asbed (00:30:00):interventions.
Asbed (00:30:01):And they see the ISF,
Asbed (00:30:02):the governance plan,
Asbed (00:30:04):the population transfer plans as a return to nation building and forced engineering
Asbed (00:30:08):of societies that they were hoping to leave behind.
Asbed (00:30:12):What is Trump's endgame in Gaza?
Matthew (00:30:16):I think there's a few different things at play here that the U.S.
Matthew (00:30:20):government, the Trump administration is reaching for.
Matthew (00:30:23):One, it's to honor its commitments to its Israeli allies, right?
Matthew (00:30:26):Whether that be its political donors, like Miriam Adelson, who has given
Matthew (00:30:31):her and her late husband,
Matthew (00:30:33):$600 million to Donald Trump and Republican Party in the last three presidential
Matthew (00:30:37):election cycles.
Matthew (00:30:38):You know, it's the relationship that many in the administration maintain with Israel directly.
Matthew (00:30:48):The fact that many in Trump's government are committed Zionists.
Matthew (00:30:53):They really do believe in the idea of a
Matthew (00:31:00):Israeli state for the purposes of jewish supremacy but also as well this idea of
Matthew (00:31:10):Israel first is equivalent to America First that the united states needs israel as
Matthew (00:31:15):Richard Nixon called it to be their sheriff in the middle east i mean so you see
Matthew (00:31:20):again just like in Venezuela a combination of reasons coming together a combination
Matthew (00:31:25):of rationales or desires
Matthew (00:31:27):that drives this type of commitment.
Matthew (00:31:29):I think for Donald Trump as well,
Matthew (00:31:31):there are other things that are at stake here,
Matthew (00:31:35):the Nobel Peace Prize.
Matthew (00:31:37):I mean, this is ridiculous that we have to bring this up,
Matthew (00:31:40):that we have to talk about this seriously.
Matthew (00:31:42):But this man's need obsession, right?
Matthew (00:31:48):The idea that Barack Obama had a Nobel Peace Prize,
Matthew (00:31:51):I have to have one,
Matthew (00:31:52):whatever it is that's really driving him,
Matthew (00:31:55):is something that's real.
Matthew (00:31:56):It's something that we have to take into account.
Matthew (00:31:58):I mean, that is fantastical.
Matthew (00:32:00):That is infuriating.
Matthew (00:32:01):That is,
Matthew (00:32:02):I think,
Matthew (00:32:03):you talk about,
Matthew (00:32:04):you know,
Matthew (00:32:05):you need a guy,
Matthew (00:32:06):you need a writer,
Matthew (00:32:08):you need to combine an Orwell with Gore Vidal,
Matthew (00:32:11):right? with Oscar Wilde to put together something like this, right?
Matthew (00:32:15):And this is what we have here.
Matthew (00:32:17):But then there's also two other less noble reasons, if you will, more transactional.
Matthew (00:32:24):I think the Trump administration sees this as a commercial opportunity.
Matthew (00:32:32):The fact that these efforts are led by his billionaire real estate friend,
Matthew (00:32:37):Steve Witkoff,
Matthew (00:32:38):as well as his son-in-law,
Matthew (00:32:39):Jared Kushner,
Matthew (00:32:40):And particularly on Kushner's tongue,
Matthew (00:32:44):coming out of his mouth all the time,
Matthew (00:32:46):is the idea of this reconstruction of Gaza,
Matthew (00:32:49):this development of Gaza, whether it be...
Asbed (00:32:50):As a Middle Eastern Riviera.
Matthew (00:32:54):Exactly, a Trump Riviera.
Matthew (00:32:56):But it's more than just like the
Matthew (00:32:58):Trump resorts and the towers and the condos and the casinos or whatever.
Matthew (00:33:02):It's also,
Matthew (00:33:03):too, now we're going to pull in the Elon Musk and,
Matthew (00:33:06):you know, with his he's going to build electric vehicles there.
Matthew (00:33:09):And Larry Allison is going to fund AI data centers.
Matthew (00:33:13):Right.
Matthew (00:33:14):So you see this new Gaza, as they call it, as really this 21st century hellscape.
Matthew (00:33:25):of technology, AI, profit, et cetera.
Matthew (00:33:29):Because you even hear things along the lines that there will be no currency in
Matthew (00:33:33):Gaza, it will be a digital currency,
Matthew (00:33:35):right? So all the fantasies of those who were sitting in the,
Matthew (00:33:41):you know, had the prime seats behind Donald Trump at the inauguration,
Matthew (00:33:45):all those tech giants,
Matthew (00:33:46):you're seeing their fantasies,
Matthew (00:33:48):their fever dreams possibly coming to fruition.
Matthew (00:33:52):And, you know,
Matthew (00:33:55):What can you say?
Matthew (00:33:56):This has been the history of the Palestinian people.
Asbed (00:33:58):You were saying that less noble reasons.
Asbed (00:34:01):That's very important to me.
Asbed (00:34:03):Are America's national interests served here?
Asbed (00:34:07):Is Trump achieving American national interests or are they his personal interests?
Matthew (00:34:13):Both in the sense of his own profit lining his own pocket.
Matthew (00:34:17):Again, this idea of the Trump Riviera, right?
Matthew (00:34:19):And that's no secret.
Matthew (00:34:21):But as well as the...
Matthew (00:34:25):national interests of the American establishment of the American empire,
Matthew (00:34:29):this idea of having this Western colony that is Israel in the Middle East.
Matthew (00:34:36):I mean, you go back to the 1930s when the British governor general of Jerusalem
Matthew (00:34:40):says what we are doing here with the British mandate,
Matthew (00:34:44):what we are doing here in Palestine is establishing a loyal Jewish ulster in the
Matthew (00:34:49):midst of potentially hostile sea of Arabs,
Matthew (00:34:52):right? I mean, so the idea of Israel as a colonial project is not anything new and it shouldn't be
Matthew (00:34:57):anything controversial.
Matthew (00:35:00):And so you have this idea of American interests then continuing to work through Israel.
Matthew (00:35:05):In the past, it was called, you know, a
Matthew (00:35:11):aircraft carrier in the Middle East, you know, as we just had the Nixon quote.
Matthew (00:35:15):I mean, all this idea of this Western colony through Israel allows the West all types of
Matthew (00:35:23):access,
Matthew (00:35:24):military,
Matthew (00:35:25):intelligent,
Matthew (00:35:26):diplomatic,
Matthew (00:35:27):commercial,
Matthew (00:35:28):etc. And it's reliable because they are us.
Matthew (00:35:31):And so I think it's a continuation of that that we're seeing there,
Matthew (00:35:34):even though I think most of us who
Matthew (00:35:36):look at this would say, look, Israel is a liability.
Matthew (00:35:40):We do not get from Israel nearly what we give.
Matthew (00:35:44):And all our military bases are not in Israel.
Matthew (00:35:47):All our military bases are in the Arab states and the Turkish state.
Matthew (00:35:52):They're not in Israel.
Matthew (00:35:53):What do we need Israel for?
Matthew (00:35:55):This is a major problem for us.
Matthew (00:35:56):It's a liability for us.
Matthew (00:35:58):But there are those who,
Matthew (00:36:00):like I said, who really do believe either in Zionism or this idea that an Israel first policy is
Matthew (00:36:06):in the best interests of the American government or the American empire.
Matthew (00:36:10):And so we see that continuation.
Matthew (00:36:12):All the inertia is with that, the type of conversation we're having.
Matthew (00:36:17):we don't have any political capital.
Matthew (00:36:18):We don't have the ability to intersect or intercede and potentially break that
Matthew (00:36:23):inertia that has come from decades of this type of policy.
Matthew (00:36:26):So I think that's what we're seeing.
Matthew (00:36:28):And Trump sees it also as well as a way to, again, line his pockets.
Asbed (00:36:32):So this is a very interesting inner dialogue that you have exposed.
Asbed (00:36:35):And it looks like all these distractions in foreign lands have
Asbed (00:36:39):already taken a toll in the 2025 elections.
Asbed (00:36:43):I think Trump lost some ground here.
Asbed (00:36:46):What are your thoughts about how this could project into the 2026 midterm elections?
Asbed (00:36:51):And what does it predict for Republicans and the MAGA and the America Firsters?
Matthew (00:36:57):Well,
Matthew (00:36:58):certainly we see the public opinion polls on this are against Donald Trump and
Matthew (00:37:03):against his foreign policy decisions,
Matthew (00:37:05):whether it be Venezuela,
Matthew (00:37:07):where less than one in three Americans say they're in favor of U.S.
Matthew (00:37:11):military action against Venezuela, whether it be, say, Israel, where...
Matthew (00:37:17):A majority of Americans oppose the Israeli government's genocide.
Matthew (00:37:21):A majority of Americans are against providing assistance and aid to Israel.
Matthew (00:37:25):Even with Ukraine,
Matthew (00:37:27):Trump had public opinion support on Ukraine immediately when he came into office.
Matthew (00:37:32):He had a clear majority of Americans wanting to see a negotiated end of the war.
Matthew (00:37:37):And 10 months later, here we are now with finally getting points on a paper.
Matthew (00:37:42):I mean, so he does have that, but he's also been acting in ways that have been
Matthew (00:37:46):counter to the American public sentiment to get American involvement out of
Matthew (00:37:51):Ukraine, as well as to end that war through negotiations.
Matthew (00:37:54):The things with public opinion is whether or not people will actually vote
Matthew (00:37:59):on these issues right so what you can have you could have people who feel very
Matthew (00:38:04):strongly about an issue you could have issues out there that have 70 80 90 support
Matthew (00:38:10):but are people going to actually vote on that particularly when inflation is still
Matthew (00:38:15):around when cost of living is still high when we have health care uh continuing
Matthew (00:38:21):health care crisis in the united states when
Matthew (00:38:23):pick any number of things that you can point to that are going to make people vote
Matthew (00:38:31):in one way or another,
Matthew (00:38:32):that Venezuela,
Matthew (00:38:34):Ukraine,
Matthew (00:38:35):Palestine,
Matthew (00:38:36):Israel just won't have that pull.
Matthew (00:38:39):You know, we've seen that.
Matthew (00:38:41):We saw, I mentioned this earlier,
Matthew (00:38:43):you saw in the first George W.
Matthew (00:38:45):Bush administration,
Matthew (00:38:46):the results of the Iraq war,
Matthew (00:38:48):where the Republicans lose the 06 midterms,
Matthew (00:38:52):clearly because of Iraq.
Matthew (00:38:53):And then the 08 election is essentially a referendum.
Matthew (00:38:57):on Iraq. The Republicans didn't do themselves any favors by being incredibly corrupt at that
Matthew (00:39:01):time as well and having all those scandals.
Matthew (00:39:03):But at the same time,
Matthew (00:39:05):that 08 elections,
Matthew (00:39:07):both the Democratic primary and the general election,
Matthew (00:39:09):were clear referendums on the Iraq war.
Matthew (00:39:13):And what the Obama administration does
Matthew (00:39:16):is when they come into office and they escalate the Afghan war,
Matthew (00:39:19):that war becomes just as unpopular,
Matthew (00:39:22):actually more unpopular than the Iraq war.
Matthew (00:39:25):By December of 2013,
Matthew (00:39:26):the Afghan war is the most unpopular war in American history,
Matthew (00:39:31):more unpopular than Iraq.
Matthew (00:39:34):or the Vietnam War, you had 80% of Americans were opposed to the Afghan war at that point.
Matthew (00:39:39):But what the Obama administration was able to do was Obama surges troops into
Matthew (00:39:44):Afghanistan,
Matthew (00:39:45):massively escalates the war as soon as he comes into office,
Matthew (00:39:49):does a whole show about it essentially for the first year where we're escalating
Matthew (00:39:53):war, we're going to win.
Matthew (00:39:54):And then he also says, we're going to be out though.
Matthew (00:39:56):We're going to start getting out in the summer of 2011.
Matthew (00:39:58):So as the war continues,
Matthew (00:40:00):continues,
Matthew (00:40:01):as it's clear we're not winning militarily,
Matthew (00:40:03):as public support continues to go against the war,
Matthew (00:40:08):there's no consequence politically because we're getting out.
Matthew (00:40:13):So when the 2012 election comes and the Afghan war is wildly unpopular,
Matthew (00:40:17):at that point,
Matthew (00:40:18):probably about 65% or 70% of Americans are against the war.
Matthew (00:40:21):And you would think then that based on the experiences of the Iraq war,
Matthew (00:40:25):that this would mean that the Republicans are going to take the White House back.
Matthew (00:40:29):No, they don't, because the response from the administration is, we're getting out.
Matthew (00:40:33):We're getting out of Afghanistan, so it's not a big issue.
Matthew (00:40:35):So people don't feel- But it did cost them the midterms, though, in 2010.
Matthew (00:40:38):Well, what cost them the midterms was 10 million people losing their homes.
Matthew (00:40:42):Yeah, absolutely.
Matthew (00:40:44):Right? I mean, that was the other thing you had, right?
Matthew (00:40:46):I mean, so you saw actually, too, you saw the Republicans, the Bush White House in 08, trying-
Matthew (00:40:54):stop this from happening to McCain.
Matthew (00:40:56):So the reason why the US gets out of Iraq or agrees to that status of forces
Matthew (00:41:01):agreement with Iraq that says we'll be out by December of 2011,
Matthew (00:41:05):why George W.
Matthew (00:41:06):Bush signs that in the summer of 2008,
Matthew (00:41:07):why he commits to getting out is to try and take Iraq off of the table,
Matthew (00:41:13):try and get Iraq out of the election so that McCain could do that while we're
Matthew (00:41:16):getting out of Iraq.
Matthew (00:41:17):That wasn't good enough at that point.
Matthew (00:41:19):So, I mean,
Matthew (00:41:20):there are all these lessons,
Matthew (00:41:21):I think, in a sense of,
Matthew (00:41:22):you know,
Matthew (00:41:23):public opinion matters unless it doesn't matter to the people who are giving you
Matthew (00:41:28):their opinion,
Matthew (00:41:29):right? So, you know, I can tell you a story.
Matthew (00:41:33):I learned this from Grover Norquist,
Matthew (00:41:37):the far right anti-tax advocate,
Matthew (00:41:40):Americans for tax reform,
Matthew (00:41:41):incredibly important in American politics for decades.
Matthew (00:41:45):And Norquist told me a story one time that when he first got into politics,
Matthew (00:41:49):in the early 80s, as part of the Reagan revolution, the Reagan wave.
Matthew (00:41:54):And this would have been, I guess, maybe the 82 midterms.
Matthew (00:41:57):At that point, prayer in school was the winning issue.
Matthew (00:42:04):85, 90% of Americans agreed that kids should be allowed to pray in school.
Matthew (00:42:09):And the Republicans, that's where they put their effort.
Matthew (00:42:12):And what they realized too late was that
Matthew (00:42:15):Yeah, people are OK with voting, you know, with kids praying in school.
Matthew (00:42:19):But in terms of things that matter to you, that's number 11 or 12 on the list, right?
Matthew (00:42:24):So no one's voting on it.
Matthew (00:42:25):Everyone might agree on it, but no one's voting on it.
Matthew (00:42:28):So I think that's, you know, long, long discussion here.
Matthew (00:42:33):But getting back to this idea of will this have an effect on Trump will be whether or not
Matthew (00:42:42):one, how close the races are going to be,
Matthew (00:42:44):but also,
Matthew (00:42:45):two, whether or not people have more pressing things on them.
Matthew (00:42:49):I mean, certainly we can look at the 24 elections and point out that Harris loses because
Matthew (00:42:55):she will not stop her firm embrace of Israel.
Matthew (00:42:58):I mean,
Matthew (00:42:59):we have public opinion data that shows that,
Matthew (00:43:01):polling data that shows that if Harris had agreed to a weapons ban on Israel,
Matthew (00:43:06):she would have won millions of more votes than
Matthew (00:43:10):That would have made a difference in the election.
Matthew (00:43:12):So it can have that impact.
Matthew (00:43:14):But on the Republican side,
Matthew (00:43:15):you're not going to see that sentiment as you did on a Democratic side where they
Matthew (00:43:19):were getting heavy.
Matthew (00:43:20):You're talking about heavy votes from progressives or from the Arab community.
Hovik (00:43:26):Let's move to our next topic,
Hovik (00:43:27):but it's an interesting parallel because Armenia is also being promised AI data
Hovik (00:43:34):centers. It seems to be the newest drug on the market, fashion, fat drug.
Hovik (00:43:40):And it's crazy because...
Hovik (00:43:42):I mean,
Hovik (00:43:43):sure, there might be some economic investments,
Hovik (00:43:45):but with just one wave of a pen,
Hovik (00:43:50):Armenia is now able to import the technology required for these AI data centers.
Hovik (00:43:57):All these years, if such technology could be given to Armenia,
Hovik (00:44:02):Maybe there would be less issues in this part of the world, but that's an aside.
Hovik (00:44:08):One of the key Trump turnabouts,
Hovik (00:44:10):I think the most surprising one for us,
Hovik (00:44:13):Armenia watchers,
Hovik (00:44:16):from America first,
Hovik (00:44:17):was this TRIPP deal that was signed in the Oval Office when Trump invited Pashinyan
Hovik (00:44:23):and Aliyev.
Hovik (00:44:25):to sign agreements that enable Azerbaijan to essentially cross Armenia into
Hovik (00:44:31):sovereignty-busting unimpeded-ness access.
Hovik (00:44:35):The word unimpeded is so problematic, but that was deliberately included in that agreement.
Hovik (00:44:41):So besides connecting Turkey and Azerbaijan,
Hovik (00:44:44):the Trump route also enables NATO to reach out all the way to Central Asia.
Hovik (00:44:49):uh to the western border of china uh surround Russia uh from the south and iran
Hovik (00:44:54):from the north and it is actually us and possibly Israel possibly other players
Hovik (00:45:00):directly on the border of Iran and inside Armenia one key aspect of the discussion
Hovik (00:45:07):now is whether the trump route will be 50 or 100 years as a lease and um
Hovik (00:45:15):I think Trump wanted 200 years initially.
Hovik (00:45:19):So is America ready for a 50 or 100 year engagement in a region very,
Hovik (00:45:23):very hostile to its presence?
Hovik (00:45:25):How does such a plan sit with America First?
Matthew (00:45:29):It doesn't.
Matthew (00:45:30):It doesn't sit with America First.
Matthew (00:45:33):You could take it maybe on the value of it that this is a commercial transaction
Matthew (00:45:40):and that this lease,
Matthew (00:45:41):whether it's 50 or 100 years or whatever it's going to be,
Matthew (00:45:44):is going to be subcontracted to a corporation and that this is all about
Matthew (00:45:48):establishing new pipeline routes.
Matthew (00:45:50):It's all about somebody getting to build railroads and highways and that.
Matthew (00:45:54):you know that there are mineral rights and etc etc and that this is simply a
Matthew (00:45:58):commercial transaction um and i think that's the way that uh it's it's sold i think
Matthew (00:46:05):to skeptical uh American members of congress certainly the members of American
Matthew (00:46:11):congress who i've seen speak about this have spoken about that exactly
Matthew (00:46:14):And then they layer in some geopolitical things,
Matthew (00:46:17):saying how this weakens Russia and this weakens China.
Matthew (00:46:19):I know there have been members of Congress who've spoken about this,
Matthew (00:46:22):talking so much about China.
Matthew (00:46:23):And I look at the map, and I see how far removed China is from the region.
Matthew (00:46:27):This is not China's sphere of influence.
Matthew (00:46:29):It does have a huge effect on Russia, Armenia, of course, and then Iran, as you just described.
Matthew (00:46:35):But it doesn't fit into America First.
Matthew (00:46:37):And it also doesn't fit into what many of us understand as the Trump
Matthew (00:46:42):administration's grand strategy.
Matthew (00:46:44):or its rehabilitation of the American empire.
Matthew (00:46:49):Something that was begun in the first administration really didn't get very far.
Matthew (00:46:53):But in this administration, you could see this.
Matthew (00:46:56):There's a method in the madness.
Matthew (00:46:58):This idea that the Trump administration understands that we are already in a
Matthew (00:47:03):multipolar world,
Matthew (00:47:05):that the days of the age of America as a sole superpower is gone.
Matthew (00:47:10):that the United States is overextended,
Matthew (00:47:12):that if we continue to have this belief in ourselves as a sole superpower,
Matthew (00:47:17):we're going to wake up one day and we're going to be in free fall and the rest of
Matthew (00:47:21):the world is going to be beyond us.
Matthew (00:47:25):And the idea being not that...
Matthew (00:47:27):The Trump administration sees itself,
Matthew (00:47:29):sees the United States as being one of many in a multipolar world or one among
Matthew (00:47:34):equals in the multipolar world,
Matthew (00:47:36):but as reshaping the American empire so it can dominate in a multipolar world.
Matthew (00:47:40):And that involves re-consolidation.
Matthew (00:47:43):That involves shoring up what's in our spears of influences, right?
Matthew (00:47:47):So this is why you see the shift to Venezuela, the shift to Latin America, the idea of
Matthew (00:47:53):of uh getting china out of the hemisphere you know those types of things but then
Matthew (00:47:59):you have this type of stuff you know we were talking before about Nigeria but this
Matthew (00:48:03):issue where as well with say the TRIPP where you're gonna have this 100 year
Matthew (00:48:08):investment in Armenia where a part of of Armenia that most of us didn't know
Matthew (00:48:15):existed until august
Matthew (00:48:17):And now some are going to have this 100 year contract to be there in some form or
Matthew (00:48:22):another that,
Matthew (00:48:24):you know, this is not simply we got the best deal possible on a piece of real estate that
Matthew (00:48:29):became available.
Matthew (00:48:30):This is deliberately sticking our nose into the Russian sphere of influence.
Matthew (00:48:34):This is deliberately blocking and trying to encircle and contain Iran.
Matthew (00:48:41):This is,
Matthew (00:48:42):as you said, creating a passageway,
Matthew (00:48:44):a connection,
Matthew (00:48:46):lines of communication between NATO and the Caspian Sea.
Matthew (00:48:52):So there's all these different geopolitical grand strategy,
Matthew (00:48:57):Zygmunt Brzezinski grand chessboard type things going on here that America First
Matthew (00:49:02):was supposedly dead set against because it's ultimately not in America's interest.
Matthew (00:49:07):You want to talk about not overextending America, now you're going to do this?
Matthew (00:49:11):Right.
Matthew (00:49:12):You know, now you're going to.
Matthew (00:49:13):Right. I mean,
Matthew (00:49:14):and again, this is,
Matthew (00:49:15):you know, we say it so often that Americans can't find places on a map.
Matthew (00:49:19):But this really is a part of the world that for many Americans is someplace unheard of.
Matthew (00:49:25):Maybe they've heard of Azerbaijan and Armenia.
Matthew (00:49:27):But the idea that there was this autonomous Azerbaijani republic that was to the
Matthew (00:49:35):west of Azerbaijan proper and it was cut off by Armenia and then
Matthew (00:49:39):No one knows that in the U.S.
Matthew (00:49:41):So, yeah.
Asbed (00:49:42):Well,
Asbed (00:49:43):as an American and an Armenian,
Asbed (00:49:46):my concern here is that this is this basically is a Turkish plan to connect Turkey
Asbed (00:49:51):with Azerbaijan.
Asbed (00:49:53):And it didn't feel like a real American plan to me.
Asbed (00:49:56):So for Trump to be committing America for the next 50 years,
Asbed (00:49:59):100 years,
Asbed (00:50:00):all these next presidents that are to come in the next century to a plan that is
Asbed (00:50:05):not completely thought out,
Asbed (00:50:07):let's say,
Asbed (00:50:08):or part of the American strategy seems bizarre,
Asbed (00:50:11):to be honest.
Asbed (00:50:12):Yeah.
Matthew (00:50:13):Yeah, and I think,
Matthew (00:50:14):you know,
Matthew (00:50:15):the reality is for most American policymakers,
Matthew (00:50:19):decision makers,
Matthew (00:50:20):elected members of Congress,
Matthew (00:50:22):they don't even get that far into details.
Matthew (00:50:24):They just see the map and they say, OK, this is going to cut off Iran from Russia.
Matthew (00:50:29):That's what you're telling me.
Matthew (00:50:30):That's good news for us.
Matthew (00:50:31):Let's do it. And that's it.
Matthew (00:50:33):The other aspects of how other regional countries are affected by this,
Matthew (00:50:39):how they may be shaping it,
Matthew (00:50:40):how this may be,
Matthew (00:50:41):as you said, which sounds right to me.
Matthew (00:50:43):Certainly, why wouldn't the Turks want to have this direct connection through to Azerbaijan?
Matthew (00:50:50):But for the American frame of view, that's all secondary, if it even comes up in a discussion.
Matthew (00:50:56):This is about Russia, and it's about Iran.
Matthew (00:50:59):The dreams of having this unified alliance against Iran,
Matthew (00:51:04):that if we ever go to war with Iran,
Matthew (00:51:06):the Azerbaijanis will be there for us to take Iran from the north.
Matthew (00:51:11):You know, this belief that somehow we can get the Turks involved in it, right?
Matthew (00:51:15):I mean, the...
Matthew (00:51:17):The mania with all this,
Matthew (00:51:19):the obsession with Iran in particular,
Matthew (00:51:22):as well as the Russians,
Matthew (00:51:23):but really with Iran and the United States,
Matthew (00:51:24):can't be overstated.
Matthew (00:51:26):I can't find it,
Matthew (00:51:27):but I swear,
Matthew (00:51:29):after the fall of Kabul,
Matthew (00:51:30):after the Taliban took Afghanistan back,
Matthew (00:51:36):there is a commentator,
Matthew (00:51:37):an American think tank commentator,
Matthew (00:51:40):who said this is actually maybe a good thing because we can align with the Taliban
Matthew (00:51:45):because the Taliban have a long history of conflict with Iran.
Matthew (00:51:49):And so we can use the Taliban as, you know, a proxy against the Iranians in the future.
Matthew (00:51:56):I mean, this was like months after the fall of Kabul and you have people in Washington, D.C.
Matthew (00:52:00):already speaking again in the Brzezinski grand chessboard style of thought that, you know,
Matthew (00:52:07):Yeah,
Matthew (00:52:08):I mean, is this going to lead to,
Matthew (00:52:10):as you know,
Matthew (00:52:12):not just overextension,
Matthew (00:52:13):but entrapment where the United States is now caught in something that it didn't
Matthew (00:52:17):fully understand to begin with?
Matthew (00:52:19):Its reasons for it aren't,
Matthew (00:52:21):as you were saying,
Matthew (00:52:22):related to the actual reasons it's occurring on the ground.
Matthew (00:52:25):This is all because of high-minded,
Matthew (00:52:30):wistful,
Matthew (00:52:31):whimsical American thinking looking at a map on a wall and how we're going to cut
Matthew (00:52:35):the Russians off from the Iranians.
Matthew (00:52:37):And that's, let's go for it.
Matthew (00:52:39):You know, and so,
Matthew (00:52:40):yeah, you wonder,
Matthew (00:52:41):as you said,
Matthew (00:52:42):three, four presidents from now,
Matthew (00:52:44):what are these guys going to be,
Matthew (00:52:45):you know,
Matthew (00:52:46):thinking about this?
Matthew (00:52:47):Exactly.
Hovik (00:52:49):Well, I have so much to say about this, but I'll say two things.
Hovik (00:52:52):One is that,
Hovik (00:52:54):and this is my opinion,
Hovik (00:52:55):I apologize to the audience if you disagree,
Hovik (00:52:58):but it seems like Armenians are very simple people.
Hovik (00:53:03):We like to be liked.
Hovik (00:53:06):So we're saying, if you just pick us, we will be your best buddies.
Hovik (00:53:11):We will be the best US ally in the region, not realizing the bigger games being played here.
Hovik (00:53:18):But the other lament I will say is that, you know, this is all being done.
Hovik (00:53:25):I realized we talked for about an hour without mentioning the fact that all of this
Hovik (00:53:29):was made possible by the graves,
Hovik (00:53:32):by, you know,
Hovik (00:53:33):ethnic cleansing of Armenians from Nagorno-Karabakh,
Hovik (00:53:36):which is also absent from discussions between U.S.
Hovik (00:53:39):and it seems like
Hovik (00:53:41):even basic things such as human rights,
Hovik (00:53:43):the right to return,
Hovik (00:53:44):the right to visit the grave of your loved one in Nagorno-Karabakh.
Hovik (00:53:48):Let's just say,
Hovik (00:53:49):okay, give me a supervised escorted trip so I can go and lay flowers on my son's grave.
Hovik (00:53:57):Even that is being treated as almost like Armenian leadership right now is saying
Hovik (00:54:04):that's a security threat to Armenia,
Hovik (00:54:06):so we're not going to talk about it.
Hovik (00:54:08):Well, I mean,
Matthew (00:54:09):that's what's so amazing is when that happened,
Matthew (00:54:13):the cleansing of Nagorno-Karabakh,
Matthew (00:54:15):that was 2022 or 2023?
Matthew (00:54:17):23.
Matthew (00:54:19):23. I remember watching that and just being amazed that no one was saying anything.
Matthew (00:54:26):You know,
Matthew (00:54:27):I was watching on Al Jazeera and just seeing how clear this was a cleansing,
Matthew (00:54:31):how there was Armenians there one day and then they had a correspondent there and
Matthew (00:54:35):then there was nobody there the next day and
Matthew (00:54:37):And like there are some Azerbaijani troops.
Matthew (00:54:39):But meanwhile, everything was gone.
Matthew (00:54:41):It looked like a scene from a movie.
Matthew (00:54:43):All the people had fled.
Matthew (00:54:44):And they were just,
Matthew (00:54:45):you know,
Matthew (00:54:46):you could tell people have fled because they were,
Matthew (00:54:47):you know,
Matthew (00:54:48):a baby shoe laying in the street,
Matthew (00:54:50):you know, and the dogs left behind.
Matthew (00:54:52):And, you know, clear indications that of what had really occurred here.
Matthew (00:54:57):And just silence in the West, it seemed like.
Matthew (00:55:00):Absolute silence was amazing.
Matthew (00:55:03):Yeah.
Matthew (00:55:04):And so I know I think Armenia,
Matthew (00:55:06):unfortunately,
Matthew (00:55:08):you know,
Matthew (00:55:09):I think people have these aspirations or hopes for the multipole of the world that
Matthew (00:55:14):I think are not going to be realized.
Matthew (00:55:16):I think it's going to be essentially the strong taking the weak as they want.
Matthew (00:55:21):You know, go back to Thities,
Matthew (00:55:24):excuse me,
Matthew (00:55:25):the strong do as they wish,
Matthew (00:55:28):the weak suffer as they must.
Matthew (00:55:30):You know, our best thing that we have was following World War Two,
Matthew (00:55:33):the attempt to create an international order through international law and
Matthew (00:55:37):institutions and.
Matthew (00:55:40):That has broken down,
Matthew (00:55:43):and now as we move into the multipolar world,
Matthew (00:55:45):I think we're going to see dominant nations,
Matthew (00:55:48):dominant alliances,
Matthew (00:55:49):dominant blocs as well,
Matthew (00:55:51):and nations like Armenia or nations like Palestine are going to suffer.
Matthew (00:55:59):If they don't have something that can be provided,
Matthew (00:56:01):if they don't have something that's worth it,
Matthew (00:56:04):they are going to be just trod upon by the dominant nations.
Asbed (00:56:09):A dog-eat-dog world and the law of the jungle.
Asbed (00:56:13):Well, we love to leave our shows on happy notes like that. Matthew,
Asbed (00:56:18):Thank you so much for coming on our show.
Asbed (00:56:19):We really appreciate your insight and the time you take to talk with us.
Matthew (00:56:23):Oh, my pleasure.
Matthew (00:56:24):Thank you for having me join you.
Matthew (00:56:26):Thank you very much, Matthew.
Asbed (00:56:28):Well, that's our show today.
Asbed (00:56:30):We recorded it on November 29, 2025.
Asbed (00:56:33):And we've been talking with Captain Matthew Ho,
Asbed (00:56:36):who is an Eisenhower Media Network Associate Director.
Asbed (00:56:39):He's a former U.S.
Asbed (00:56:41):Marine Corps Captain and State Department Officer,
Asbed (00:56:44):Iraq War Combat Vet and Afghanistan War State Department Officer.
Asbed (00:56:48):For more information,
Asbed (00:56:49):you can click on the show notes,
Asbed (00:56:52):podcasts.groong.org/episode-number and click on the people.
Hovik (00:56:57):All right, folks, if you like what you heard and saw today, please like, share, and comment.
Hovik (00:57:02):We're trying to do a good job for you,
Hovik (00:57:05):and we are working hard,
Hovik (00:57:07):and we appreciate any and all types of support,
Hovik (00:57:10):including financial support.
Hovik (00:57:12):The URL for that, if you're not tired of listening to that, is podcasts.groong.org/donate
Hovik (00:57:19):become a search sponsor for five bucks a month or you can go all the way up to a
Hovik (00:57:24):harissa humanitarian it's a yummy food if you haven't heard if you haven't eaten it
Hovik (00:57:28):try it at an armenian restaurant uh at least once uh and uh that keeps us going
Hovik (00:57:34):that keeps us uh circulating in front of more eyes
Hovik (00:57:39):And last but not least,
Hovik (00:57:41):because a lot of you folks may have just reached us through clicking on Matt Ho's
Hovik (00:57:46):name,
Hovik (00:57:47):you might be new to us.
Hovik (00:57:48):So please make sure you're subscribed.
Hovik (00:57:49):We promise we will bring you other great shows like this.
Hovik (00:57:54):We also focus on Armenian content,
Hovik (00:57:55):but feel free to ignore those if you want to focus more on global content.
Hovik (00:57:59):We want to do at least two international shows a month.
Hovik (00:58:04):Hope you like the quality.
Hovik (00:58:05):If you like the quality, then subscribe.
Asbed (00:58:08):We're very interested in geopolitics and especially the way that it affects Armenia.
Asbed (00:58:12):But it's not all just Armenian politics.
Asbed (00:58:14):It's actually world politics.
Asbed (00:58:15):And since Armenia has a very strong diaspora, especially here in the United States, like me,
Asbed (00:58:22):There's a lot to be said about the US politics, for example, America First, MAGA.
Asbed (00:58:28):We are very interested in these things because when a superpower sneezes,
Asbed (00:58:32):Armenia catches a cold or worse pneumonia.
Asbed (00:58:35):Take care, folks.
Asbed (00:58:36):I'm Asbed Bedrossian in Los Angeles.
Hovik (00:58:40):And I'm Hovik Manucharyan back in my place in Yerevan.
Hovik (00:58:44):But my son kicked me out of my favorite spot in front of my bookshelf.
Hovik (00:58:49):So I am here recording in a different room with my standard background.
Hovik (00:58:54):But I hope to be in front of my bookshelf for the next recording,
Hovik (00:58:59):which is going to happen in less than an hour.
Hovik (00:59:03):Talk to you, folks.
Hovik (00:59:04):Bye-bye.
Hovik (00:59:05):Bye-bye.
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.