Armenian News Network - Groong: Week In Review Podcast
Armenian News Network - Groong: Week In Review Podcast
Hrant Mikaelian - Venezuela, Attacks on the Armenian Church Continue, MPG Poll Results | Ep 501, Jan 4, 2026
Groong Week in Review - January 4, 2026
Topics:
- Developments in Venezuela
- Attacks on Armenian Church Continue
- New MPG Poll Results
- Armenian Economy in 2025 (Jan-Oct)
Guest: Hrant Mikaelian
Hosts:
Episode 501 | Recorded: January 6, 2026
SHOW NOTES: https://podcasts.groong.org/501
VIDEO: https://youtu.be/ACfF9ryiswE
Subscribe and follow us everywhere you are: linktr.ee/groong
Hello, everyone.
Asbed (00:00:07):Happy New Year.
Asbed (00:00:08):We hope that 2026 is a successful year for all of our listeners.
Asbed (00:00:13):Welcome to the year's first Groong Weekend Review for January 4, 2026.
Asbed (00:00:17):Today, we have Hrant Mikaelian with us.
Asbed (00:00:20):He is an interdisciplinary researcher in Yerevan.
Asbed (00:00:23):And to all of our Armenian listeners,
Asbed (00:00:26):today on January 6,
Asbed (00:00:27):Armenian Christmas,
Asbed (00:00:28):Christos dznav yev Haidnetzav,
Asbed (00:00:30):Orhnyal eh dzununtuh Christosi.
Hrant (00:00:32):Mezi Dzezi mets avetis.
Asbed (00:00:36):Actually, I'm not sure if it's more proper to say Orhnyal eh dzununtuh, or Orhnyal eh Haidnutunuh.
Hovik (00:00:42):Orhnyal eh Haidnutunuh.
Asbed (00:00:44):Yeah, probably Haidnutunuh because Armenian Christmas is more about baptism and theophany.
Asbed (00:00:49):It's about the appearance of the divine nature of Christ rather than the physical
Asbed (00:00:53):birth of Christ.
Asbed (00:00:54):Anyway, Hrant, Happy New Year.
Asbed (00:00:58):And thank you for joining us on the Groong Podcast.
Hrant (00:01:00):Thank you.
Hrant (00:01:01):Thank you for having me.
Hrant (00:01:02):Happy New Year to you and all listeners.
Asbed (00:01:06):Thank you. Let's hit our topics then.
Asbed (00:01:09):Whether you call it a blatant breach of international law,
Asbed (00:01:12):an act of war,
Asbed (00:01:13):state terrorism,
Asbed (00:01:14):an abduction,
Asbed (00:01:15):or all of the above,
Asbed (00:01:16):what happened in Venezuela over the weekend of January 3rd is going to have
Asbed (00:01:20):far-reaching repercussions around the world because within a matter of a few hours,
Asbed (00:01:25):U.S.
Asbed (00:01:26):special ops swooped into Caracas,
Asbed (00:01:28):stormed the presidential compound,
Asbed (00:01:30):and abducted President Nicolas Maduro and his wife from Venezuela.
Asbed (00:01:35):Just to make sure that you really understand this,
Asbed (00:01:39):the president of Venezuela's Republic,
Asbed (00:01:42):the head of a UN recognized state was kidnapped from his own residence and in his
Asbed (00:01:48):own country by the United States.
Hovik (00:01:50):Yeah, I have to say this as well, that Trump made a claim that the U.S.
Hovik (00:01:57):is going to run the country.
Hovik (00:01:59):I mean,
Hovik (00:02:00):I think Marco Rubio tried to walk it back a little bit,
Hovik (00:02:04):but it was an audacious claim that is still being reverberated across the news
Hovik (00:02:11):shows.
Asbed (00:02:12):Yeah.
Asbed (00:02:13):Trump further threatened that in Maduro's absence,
Asbed (00:02:16):vice president and now acting president,
Asbed (00:02:18):Delcy Rodriguez better follow U.S.
Asbed (00:02:20):demands or else the U.S.
Asbed (00:02:22):will attack again.
Asbed (00:02:24):Rodriguez has demanded that Maduro and his wife be released immediately,
Asbed (00:02:27):but she has also indicated that she's going to collaborate with the United States.
Asbed (00:02:32):Actually,
Asbed (00:02:33):there are many indications,
Asbed (00:02:34):there are many reports that Delcy Rodriguez and her brother,
Asbed (00:02:38):Jorge Rodriguez,
Asbed (00:02:39):carried out essentially what amounts to a palace coup.
Asbed (00:02:43):They had been working with the U.S.
Asbed (00:02:44):through an intermediary for months,
Asbed (00:02:46):the United Arab Emirates,
Asbed (00:02:48):I think, to hand over Maduro to the U.S.
Asbed (00:02:50):and take control of Venezuela.
Hovik (00:02:53):Can I just also ask that these are reports from Western media?
Hovik (00:02:57):Yeah.
Hovik (00:02:58):And I think that,
Hovik (00:03:00):you know, we shouldn't take everything for granted,
Hovik (00:03:02):especially something that was printed in the telegraph.
Hovik (00:03:06):But,
Hovik (00:03:07):you know, I understand that there are a lot of questions that Venezuelans and everyone is
Hovik (00:03:10):asking on how exactly this happened.
Asbed (00:03:12):Yeah.
Asbed (00:03:13):Yeah. It's a little unexplainable.
Asbed (00:03:15):So I'm sure that there are backstories to the whole thing.
Asbed (00:03:19):Meanwhile,
Asbed (00:03:20):you should not be surprised to know that many so-called world leaders have followed
Asbed (00:03:26):suit. They've come out in support of the illegal U.S.
Asbed (00:03:29):kidnapping.
Asbed (00:03:30):The poodles of war,
Asbed (00:03:31):Mertz, Macron,
Asbed (00:03:32):other EU heads of state have said things like,
Asbed (00:03:35):oh, the Venezuelan people are now rid of Nicolas Maduro's dictatorship and can only
Asbed (00:03:40):rejoice.
Asbed (00:03:41):And meanwhile,
Asbed (00:03:43):the UN has declared that the special ops was illegal from the perspective of
Asbed (00:03:47):international law.
Asbed (00:03:48):China and Russia have slammed the US,
Asbed (00:03:51):but it doesn't look like anybody's going to intervene in any immediate apparent
Asbed (00:03:55):ways.
Asbed (00:03:57):The one voice that I also heard,
Asbed (00:03:59):Serbian leader Aleksandar Vucic,
Asbed (00:04:03):he said, public international law no longer exists.
Asbed (00:04:06):So, Hrant, that is the question.
Asbed (00:04:08):Is international law dead?
Hrant (00:04:10):Well, actually,
Hrant (00:04:11):the discussion of whether international law is dead or not is ongoing for the last,
Hrant (00:04:19):let's say, 20 years,
Hrant (00:04:20):I would say.
Hrant (00:04:21):And basically, the international law was on its high during the Cold War.
Hrant (00:04:29):Because for the law, you need a law enforcement entity.
Hrant (00:04:34):Now, who can be the enforcement entity?
Hrant (00:04:38):Formally, it was a UN Security Council.
Hrant (00:04:43):And aside from that, you need a power.
Hrant (00:04:45):And those were two powers who could control the world,
Hrant (00:04:48):basically,
Hrant (00:04:49):United States and Soviet Union.
Hrant (00:04:51):And based on post-World War II agreements and then Helsinki Act,
Hrant (00:04:58):there has been rather,
Hrant (00:05:00):we can say,
Hrant (00:05:01):consensus on what is the international law.
Hrant (00:05:04):And then we had...
Hrant (00:05:07):you know, political processes that could violate it.
Hrant (00:05:10):I will bring a couple of examples.
Hrant (00:05:12):For example, the U.S.
Hrant (00:05:14):attack on Granada in 1983,
Hrant (00:05:17):and then attack on Panama,
Hrant (00:05:20):if I'm not mistaken,
Hrant (00:05:22):where Noriega,
Hrant (00:05:23):the president of Panama,
Hrant (00:05:26):was kidnapped in a very similar way.
Hrant (00:05:28):It was,
Hrant (00:05:29):if I'm not mistaken,
Hrant (00:05:30):1989 or 1990,
Hrant (00:05:32):a very similar way to what happened,
Hrant (00:05:35):you know, on January 3th.
Hrant (00:05:37):So basically, we're talking about precedents that are very similar to what happened these days.
Hrant (00:05:44):So it's not something that is really new.
Hrant (00:05:47):And of course, we can discuss betrayal of elites in this case and in previous cases as well.
Hrant (00:05:54):I'm not sure what happened exactly,
Hrant (00:05:56):but it seems like it has happened to some extent,
Hrant (00:05:59):at least because,
Hrant (00:06:00):you know,
Hrant (00:06:01):there was no fire from Caracas on Americans.
Hrant (00:06:05):And, you know, to have this type of operation,
Hrant (00:06:07):you need to be sure that no one will be hitting back.
Hrant (00:06:11):So anyway,
Hrant (00:06:12):I think that on one hand,
Hrant (00:06:15):international law is in a very problematic state of affairs because the Security
Hrant (00:06:21):Council is in a dysfunctioning state.
Hrant (00:06:26):But at the same time,
Hrant (00:06:28):it's nothing new because the things which are happening right now have happened
Hrant (00:06:34):before as well.
Hrant (00:06:35):So the U.S.
Hrant (00:06:36):has attacked different countries beforehand.
Hrant (00:06:40):And by the way, Russians did too.
Hrant (00:06:42):Chinese did not.
Hrant (00:06:43):And most likely they will not attack in near future as well.
Hrant (00:06:47):So basically what we're observing now has happened before as well.
Asbed (00:06:51):Well, 70% of the Venezuelan oil was exported to China and Maduro was also close to Russia.
Asbed (00:06:57):Do you expect that Russia and China will be reacting to these events in any more
Asbed (00:07:03):than words or are they simply impotent in the face of US military operations,
Asbed (00:07:09):especially in the Americas,
Asbed (00:07:11):in the Western hemisphere?
Hrant (00:07:13):Well, first Russian statement was somewhat strong and today's statement was very soft.
Hrant (00:07:20):So we can expect that either Russians were part of a deal, which is to my opinion,
Hrant (00:07:29):to my assessment,
Hrant (00:07:30):less likely,
Hrant (00:07:32):or they are incapable of acting,
Hrant (00:07:35):you know,
Hrant (00:07:36):firmer,
Hrant (00:07:37):or they are just not willing to engage in a new battlefield,
Hrant (00:07:42):having one which they are very poorly managing,
Hrant (00:07:45):frankly speaking. So as of now, I think Russians will not intervene more than they do.
Hrant (00:07:51):And by the way, your question is legitimate to the extent that the, you know, approach of
Hrant (00:07:59):the current government,
Hrant (00:08:01):government without president,
Hrant (00:08:03):government without Maduro towards United States will be dependent on the position
Hrant (00:08:09):of Brazil,
Hrant (00:08:11):of Russia and China.
Hrant (00:08:12):So basically that's BRICS.
Hrant (00:08:15):And as of now, we see that BRICS is passive.
Hrant (00:08:18):China is passive too, making very soft statements and does not provide with any feasible aid.
Hrant (00:08:28):So I think Venezuela is left alone.
Hrant (00:08:31):And it looks like Venezuelan authorities,
Hrant (00:08:35):which have made several harsh statements immediately after American attack,
Hrant (00:08:43):are now backing down.
Hrant (00:08:45):So most likely they will
Hrant (00:08:48):subordinate, at least partially, towards US demands.
Hrant (00:08:52):And Russia and China will score another loss.
Hrant (00:08:57):We can remember Syria, which took place a year ago.
Hrant (00:09:00):where Russians and Iranians,
Hrant (00:09:04):and indirectly Chinese as well,
Hrant (00:09:06):also scored their defeat politically,
Hrant (00:09:09):very important defeat,
Hrant (00:09:11):not to say about Artsakh and many other events.
Hrant (00:09:13):So as of now,
Hrant (00:09:14):US is effectively trying to keep or even restore its power,
Hrant (00:09:19):because what we observed these days was very harsh reaction on the side of Latin
Hrant (00:09:27):Americans,
Hrant (00:09:28):But if they see that no one is coming to help,
Hrant (00:09:32):they will have to renegotiate with the United States and take into consideration
Hrant (00:09:37):Americans' view more and more.
Asbed (00:09:39):So what is the larger strategic reason behind this move by the United States?
Asbed (00:09:45):What do you think was the reason suddenly this year in January for the U.S.
Asbed (00:09:50):to attack Venezuela?
Hrant (00:09:55):Frankly speaking,
Hrant (00:09:56):I see here more tactical reasons because Trump desperately needed some kind of win,
Hrant (00:10:06):especially media win,
Hrant (00:10:08):because as of now,
Hrant (00:10:09):he just won in media.
Hrant (00:10:13):Venezuela is not run by friendly government as of now, so not many things have changed.
Hrant (00:10:19):But he has shown Maduro to the public the very same way as Roman emperors were showing
Hrant (00:10:26):barbaric kings in Rome.
Hrant (00:10:28):So I think he is trying to show himself as an emperor and he is trying to utilize
Hrant (00:10:35):this event in media as much as he can.
Hrant (00:10:40):But if we enlarge the scope
Hrant (00:10:43):from the tactical move,
Hrant (00:10:45):which favors Trump internally and externally as well,
Hrant (00:10:48):we can see that Trump is following his national security agenda,
Hrant (00:10:53):which was adopted in November.
Hrant (00:10:56):And so he's trying to show that he's very firm with what he's trying to achieve.
Hrant (00:11:04):So he is trying to reinforce American imperialism, which is vital right now because
Hrant (00:11:13):given that America has right now lots of deaths and lots of internal crisis.
Hrant (00:11:20):U.S.
Hrant (00:11:21):desperately needs new finances, new resources.
Hrant (00:11:24):So he's hungry for resources, trying to find them elsewhere.
Hrant (00:11:30):And that's why we can see the tariff policy.
Hrant (00:11:32):We can see attack on Venezuela,
Hrant (00:11:35):discussion on attacking Greenland and other places which are resource rich.
Hrant (00:11:42):So Trump will try to create a foundation for new prosperity for America in the 21st
Hrant (00:11:49):century,
Hrant (00:11:50):because right now America has exhausted its resources for development.
Hrant (00:11:56):A lot of internal crises are there right now.
Hrant (00:12:01):So either America has to deal very accurately with its own domestic situation,
Hrant (00:12:08):Or it might try to find all the resources outside and export all its instability
Hrant (00:12:13):towards other countries,
Hrant (00:12:15):other regions,
Hrant (00:12:16):and try to improve situation internally with harsh foreign policy.
Hrant (00:12:24):I think that's his overall agenda.
Hrant (00:12:27):And of course, it's about resources.
Hrant (00:12:29):It's about influence.
Hrant (00:12:30):And it's about a grand strategy of acquiring resources from all over the world.
Hovik (00:12:34):Hrant,
Hovik (00:12:35):for the past five years,
Hovik (00:12:38):it seems like Armenians have been forced to watch lessons on geopolitics.
Hovik (00:12:46):And I think that this may be another learning experience for many Armenians,
Hovik (00:12:52):even though I'm not sure if Armenians are good students of geopolitics nowadays.
Hovik (00:12:58):What lessons can we extract for Armenia from this incident that happened with Venezuela?
Hrant (00:13:06):Well, today we have heard comments by Azerbaijani president and he expressed a very
Hrant (00:13:14):similar approach as Vucic.
Hrant (00:13:19):He said that international law doesn't work and what works is the policy and who is
Hrant (00:13:27):capable and who is strong on the ground.
Hrant (00:13:31):I think that it's not about theory,
Hrant (00:13:33):but it's about the approach of Azerbaijan,
Hrant (00:13:36):which declares that it does not see international law working,
Hrant (00:13:40):which is very important.
Hrant (00:13:41):So even if international law to some extent is working globally,
Hrant (00:13:46):but in this region,
Hrant (00:13:47):it will not be working because Aliyev rejects it.
Hrant (00:13:51):That's first.
Hrant (00:13:52):Second, if you do not protect yourself, no one will do.
Hrant (00:13:56):For example, Russians or Chinese or Brazil or other countries or United States.
Hrant (00:14:02):You should do your job.
Hrant (00:14:04):And then another job which you should do is acquire alliances.
Hrant (00:14:09):International law does not work by itself.
Hrant (00:14:11):International law works by reinforcement.
Hrant (00:14:14):And reinforcement might come with alliances.
Hrant (00:14:18):And alliances might also use international law as a glue.
Hrant (00:14:22):But international law does not come first yet.
Hrant (00:14:25):It's third part of the equation.
Hrant (00:14:27):First,
Hrant (00:14:28):your own policy,
Hrant (00:14:29):second, alliances,
Hrant (00:14:30):and then international law,
Hrant (00:14:31):not vice versa,
Hrant (00:14:32):which is very important.
Hrant (00:14:34):Another thing is that as of now, every country's sovereignty is under question.
Hrant (00:14:44):First,
Hrant (00:14:45):strong countries and the West do not recognize leadership of the majority of the
Hrant (00:14:50):countries in the world.
Hrant (00:14:51):Every country is kind of in a half legitimacy state of affairs.
Hrant (00:14:58):And the Western leaders,
Hrant (00:14:59):for example,
Hrant (00:15:00):they always question legitimacy of any other leaders in the world.
Hrant (00:15:04):And they can say, you are democratic, you are non-democratic.
Hrant (00:15:08):So either you play these games or you find another sources of legitimacy,
Hrant (00:15:14):which is also important.
Hrant (00:15:16):And the last lesson, which I would say, is that you should be very strategic about your future.
Hrant (00:15:21):Because if you try playing short-term games,
Hrant (00:15:26):like Venezuela did last 20 years.
Hrant (00:15:29):They were trying to adopt Bolivarian approach and so on,
Hrant (00:15:35):but it was very tactical in every point.
Hrant (00:15:39):But if you don't have strategy,
Hrant (00:15:40):ground strategy,
Hrant (00:15:41):I would say,
Hrant (00:15:42):of implementing your ideology,
Hrant (00:15:43):of reinforcing your state,
Hrant (00:15:45):of assuring peace and prosperity of your country,
Hrant (00:15:49):you will fail.
Hrant (00:15:50):And it's not only U.S.
Hrant (00:15:51):fault.
Hrant (00:15:52):I mean, Venezuela failed long before 2026, frankly speaking.
Hrant (00:15:57):So you should reinforce your state by yourself first and primarily.
Hrant (00:16:01):So hoping that someone from another country,
Hrant (00:16:06):from U.S., from Russia,
Hrant (00:16:07):from Brussels and elsewhere,
Hrant (00:16:09):will come and fix your country is a delusion which has cost Armenia too much.
Hrant (00:16:16):So those are the lessons which I would like Armenians to learn.
Hovik (00:16:21):Yeah, indeed, Hrant, points well taken.
Hovik (00:16:26):So today is Christmas Day in Armenia,
Hovik (00:16:29):and Christmas celebrations,
Hovik (00:16:32):I would say,
Hovik (00:16:33):did not take place in a peaceful and calm atmosphere,
Hovik (00:16:37):as Pashinyan has escalated his attack against the Armenian Apostolic Church.
Hovik (00:16:43):On Christmas Day, state media didn't cover the official Christmas Mass from Etchmiadzin.
Hovik (00:16:48):At least I wasn't able to catch it.
Hovik (00:16:51):Meanwhile, Pashinyan attended the fake Christmas Mass or liturgy by one of the renegade
Hovik (00:16:58):bishops where the name of the Catholicos was omitted.
Hovik (00:17:02):Days ago,
Hovik (00:17:03):Pashinyan had doubled down on his strategy,
Hovik (00:17:06):and along with the ten renegade bishops,
Hovik (00:17:09):two of whom were signed remotely,
Hovik (00:17:13):but the list is headed after Pashinyan is headed by Archbishop Hovnan Derderian of
Hovik (00:17:21):the Western Diocese.
Hovik (00:17:24):So they basically rehashed a statement that Pashinyan had made previously,
Hovik (00:17:30):a month ago,
Hovik (00:17:31):his so-called vision of reforming the Armenian Church.
Hovik (00:17:35):And some points from this statement include the necessity to remove the Catholicos,
Hovik (00:17:42):the election of a caretaker Catholicos, or a Catholicos vicar.
Hovik (00:17:47):I don't know what that means.
Hovik (00:17:50):The statement also kept referring to the Armenian Apostolic Church as the Apostolic
Hovik (00:17:58):Church of Armenia,
Hovik (00:18:00):which to me is a very important distinction.
Hovik (00:18:05):And then, of course,
Hovik (00:18:06):adoption of church charter,
Hovik (00:18:09):establishing mechanisms for ethics and principles of clergy,
Hovik (00:18:14):which is all BS in my opinion.
Hovik (00:18:19):Pashinyan, in my opinion,
Hovik (00:18:20):wants to do the same with the Armenian church,
Hovik (00:18:24):the same that he has done with the courts and justice system,
Hovik (00:18:28):to co-opt them and to make them his tools.
Hovik (00:18:31):But there also might be some wider-ranging repercussions from Pashinyan's move.
Hovik (00:18:39):What sort of stage is Pashinyan setting up for 2026, Hrant, between him and the church?
Hovik (00:18:47):And what can we expect as the year moves forward?
Hrant (00:18:52):Okay,
Hrant (00:18:53):these days I have had several discussions with my friends in church who are
Hrant (00:19:01):currently serving in the church or are supporting it and who are involved
Hrant (00:19:07):significantly.
Hrant (00:19:09):So, I'll try to share this insight with the public as well.
Hrant (00:19:15):First,
Hrant (00:19:16):regarding the media,
Hrant (00:19:17):it's also important to note that the broadcasting of the church TV channel,
Hrant (00:19:25):Shoghakat TV,
Hrant (00:19:27):has been stopped lately.
Hrant (00:19:28):So, it is also important.
Hrant (00:19:30):Not only Pashinyan is trying to silent Catholicos on the state media, but also he's...
Hrant (00:19:38):silencing the church's TV channel.
Hrant (00:19:41):And it is not about Catholicos, it's about church.
Hrant (00:19:44):So that's the first important thing.
Hrant (00:19:47):Another thing is that when Pashinyan is trying to distinguish Catholicos and the
Hrant (00:19:52):church,
Hrant (00:19:53):he is clearly bullshitting because he has made several steps which are targeting
Hrant (00:19:59):the church as an institution,
Hrant (00:20:01):not the Catholicos himself.
Hrant (00:20:02):For example, lately there was a new law adopted that limits church's ability to
Hrant (00:20:08):acquire and govern land.
Hovik (00:20:12):Does it limit it or does it completely remove it?
Hovik (00:20:14):Basically, it's transforming the,
Hovik (00:20:17):you know,
Hovik (00:20:18):it wouldn't allow the Armenian Apostolic Church to own property as far as I know.
Hrant (00:20:24):As far as I know, it's regarding the new property, not the existing.
Asbed (00:20:28):Yeah, additional property.
Hrant (00:20:30):That is why I'm saying limiting.
Hrant (00:20:31):Yeah, that is why I'm saying limiting.
Hrant (00:20:35):Otherwise, it would be just renting, let's say.
Hrant (00:20:40):So it's an institutional thing,
Hrant (00:20:42):and there are lots of other institutional things,
Hrant (00:20:44):including those so-called reforms,
Hrant (00:20:46):which are targeting the church as an institution.
Hrant (00:20:52):Another funny thing is how Pashinyan has gathered all those bishops who were not
Hrant (00:21:01):wearing crosses,
Hrant (00:21:03):and in his statement,
Hrant (00:21:06):in that statement that they have signed,
Hrant (00:21:10):first surname was Nikol Pashinyan,
Hrant (00:21:13):prime minister of Armenia,
Hrant (00:21:15):and then names of those bishops,
Hrant (00:21:17):10 out of 51,
Hrant (00:21:20):which Armenian church has left right now.
Hrant (00:21:22):So this is clearly a try to directly govern the church, which is forbidden by the constitution.
Hrant (00:21:32):So it's also another thing which is...
Hrant (00:21:36):noteworthy beforehand Pashinyan was you know kind of trying to use his his own
Hrant (00:21:45):legitimacy or own media power and of course informally he was using state
Hrant (00:21:53):mechanisms but right now he is directly using state mechanism which is a change
Hrant (00:21:59):also noteworthy that in this in this
Hrant (00:22:05):In this rally, which he has today organized,
Hrant (00:22:08):there were many people which were brought by the administrative resources.
Hrant (00:22:13):Beforehand, he was trying to gather people on their own will.
Hrant (00:22:19):And that is why the crowds were very, very small.
Hrant (00:22:22):And today,
Hrant (00:22:23):there was a leak of demand by the head of a hospital who has asked the employees to
Hrant (00:22:33):participate.
Hrant (00:22:34):in the rally.
Hrant (00:22:35):So we know one such case,
Hrant (00:22:37):but I assume all the state-run hospitals and educational institutions have had this
Hrant (00:22:46):agenda as well.
Hrant (00:22:48):So at least some of the employees did participate.
Hrant (00:22:54):And finally,
Hrant (00:22:55):in the beginning, there were some 5,000,
Hrant (00:22:57):but when they reached the church in the center of Yerevan,
Hrant (00:23:01):two-thirds of those or even more
Hrant (00:23:04):have you know disappeared so they they came in the beginning so that their
Hrant (00:23:11):employers could see that they came and they were not fired afterwards but then they
Hrant (00:23:17):have left so this shows that the crowd that Pashinyan has gathered has nothing to
Hrant (00:23:23):do with his agenda or at least two-thirds of his crowd or 70-75 percent and other
Hrant (00:23:30):things which are also important to note
Hrant (00:23:32):That's basically what Pashnyan says.
Hrant (00:23:35):He is rejecting apostolic nature of Armenian church.
Hrant (00:23:39):Because Armenian apostolic church means that apostles have created it.
Hrant (00:23:44):Apostles Tade and Bartholomeus.
Hrant (00:23:47):And Pashinyan said that Terdat III and Grigor Lusavorich have created.
Hrant (00:23:56):Which is basically the same approach as Russian Empire has shown.
Hrant (00:24:02):200 years ago when it tried to limit Armenian Church's influence and called it
Hrant (00:24:08):Gregorian Church after Gregory the Illuminator or Grigor Lusavorich.
Hrant (00:24:13):So basically it declares the church as state-run but not as a separate institution.
Hrant (00:24:20):So basically it's a heresy that state has created the church.
Hrant (00:24:24):The church, as Catholicos says,
Hrant (00:24:27):And it is opinion of the church.
Hrant (00:24:29):So, Catholicos said that the church belongs to Jesus, not to the current time.
Hrant (00:24:36):And Pashinyan says the church belongs to the state.
Hrant (00:24:40):So, basically, he's rejecting the apostolic nature of Armenian church.
Hrant (00:24:46):So, he was trying very hard to organize tensions inside the church.
Hrant (00:24:55):And they are pushing every priest separately.
Hrant (00:24:59):For example, I've heard that there were governors of provinces of Armenia are directly calling
Hrant (00:25:05):different clergy,
Hrant (00:25:08):even low-grade clergy representatives,
Hrant (00:25:11):to push them,
Hrant (00:25:13):to force them to write or not write something on Facebook,
Hrant (00:25:16):and so on and so forth.
Hrant (00:25:17):So the whole government mechanism is used.
Hrant (00:25:22):to attack the Armenian Apostolic Church and what we are observing the ultimate goal
Hrant (00:25:27):is to leave Armenian Apostolic Church without its sovereignty and without its
Hrant (00:25:33):historical legitimacy and recreate it as a state-run church which will be just used
Hrant (00:25:42):by the state as a tool or you know will be kind of
Hrant (00:25:50):very close to what they have in Scotland or England or Presbyterian church or
Hrant (00:25:56):something like that.
Hrant (00:25:57):So those cases were viewed as a model cases.
Hrant (00:26:03):So as of now, Pashinyan is in the middle of that process.
Hrant (00:26:08):And obviously he is failing on one hand because he was not able to acquire new
Hrant (00:26:15):support from new members of church what he was able to gather through because of
Hrant (00:26:22):some internal tensions within the church which have existed before or because of
Hrant (00:26:27):his pressure on some clergy representatives or because of money and some other
Hrant (00:26:35):tools anyway what he has got that's very limited that is why he started repeating
Hrant (00:26:42):the places of worship
Hrant (00:26:44):He was trying to cover as many churches as possible,
Hrant (00:26:47):but he has passed through four churches and he is now repeating and passing from
Hrant (00:26:53):one to another.
Hrant (00:26:54):But at the same time,
Hrant (00:26:56):we should recognize that if Pashinyan will win in 2026 and will continue having the
Hrant (00:27:03):external support which he has right now,
Hrant (00:27:05):He will have five more years to attack the church,
Hrant (00:27:08):and it will be very hard to keep the church viable under these repressions.
Hrant (00:27:15):I want to remember that four bishops, including two archbishops, are jailed right now.
Hovik (00:27:21):Yeah.
Hovik (00:27:22):I mean, some explain Pashinyan's motivations by saying that he's basically looking for
Hovik (00:27:29):revenge because in 2020,
Hovik (00:27:34):the church called for his resignation.
Hovik (00:27:37):Others,
Hovik (00:27:38):for instance, are recalling that shortly before this incident began,
Hovik (00:27:42):the Catholicos went to Bern and talked loudly about the rights of Artsakh,
Hovik (00:27:49):the cultural legacy and cultural rights and also human rights of Artsakh's
Hovik (00:27:56):refugees.
Hovik (00:27:58):And so others are explaining it by geopolitics.
Hovik (00:28:03):What do you think,
Hovik (00:28:04):in your opinion,
Hovik (00:28:05):is the chief factor or motivation that contributes to Pashinyan being so intent on
Hovik (00:28:16):doing what he's doing right now?
Hrant (00:28:18):It is obviously geopolitical.
Hrant (00:28:19):It's not revenge.
Hrant (00:28:20):Of course, he hates church, but that's a very insignificant thing.
Hrant (00:28:24):Right now, it is geopolitical because Catholicos not only talked about human rights,
Hrant (00:28:28):but he also was talking about political rights of Artsakh,
Hrant (00:28:33):and he was also talking about statehood of Artsakh.
Hrant (00:28:36):So he is clearly opposing so-called peace agenda of Pashinyan and pro-Turkish
Hrant (00:28:42):policies of Pashinyan require him attacking Armenian church at the next step.
Hrant (00:28:46):So obviously this is the next agenda.
Hrant (00:28:49):And since he is crushing all sovereign institutions of Armenia, white church should be omitted.
Hrant (00:28:55):So it's just on the list.
Hovik (00:28:58):Okay.
Hovik (00:29:00):All right,
Hovik (00:29:01):for the next section of our discussion,
Hovik (00:29:03):I think we want to talk about a recent MPG poll that was published.
Hovik (00:29:10):And Hrant, you are our favorite analyst to discuss polls with.
Hovik (00:29:15):So I hope you don't mind if we bring in you with too many questions from this poll.
Hovik (00:29:22):So this poll was released by MPG, which is Gallup International Armenia.
Hovik (00:29:28):It has an error margin of plus or minus 3%,
Hovik (00:29:34):and it was conducted toward the last week of December,
Hovik (00:29:37):essentially.
Hovik (00:29:39):It addresses a number of things,
Hovik (00:29:41):like public mood,
Hovik (00:29:43):agreement with the government,
Hovik (00:29:46):and a lot of questions on actually just drilling down into public mood solidarity.
Hovik (00:29:51):So I want to begin with slides three to five of this poll.
Hovik (00:29:57):which talk about the direction of the country and what people consider the most
Hovik (00:30:02):important issues.
Hovik (00:30:06):If you're watching this on YouTube, you will see the slides as well.
Hovik (00:30:11):Slide number three says,
Hovik (00:30:15):which are the most important issues in front of Armenia today,
Hovik (00:30:20):the most important problems?
Hovik (00:30:22):And 37.1% said security issues.
Hovik (00:30:29):The number two on that list was low social benefits and low salary.
Hovik (00:30:40):Number three is the financial situation with 13.8%.
Hovik (00:30:47):Number four is unemployment, similarly in that same range.
Hovik (00:30:51):inflation.
Hovik (00:30:52):So it's all about either security or economics, something that we have seen previously before.
Hovik (00:30:58):So, okay, that's one of the questions.
Hovik (00:31:00):The other is, is everything going right or wrong in Armenia today?
Hovik (00:31:06):I would say just by looking at this graph,
Hovik (00:31:09):you would see that a majority think that the country is going in the wrong
Hovik (00:31:15):direction.
Hovik (00:31:16):Although I would say that a lot of the respondents also,
Hovik (00:31:20):there's a significant number of respondents that the country is going in the right
Hovik (00:31:23):direction.
Hovik (00:31:24):And then how do you assess the public mood in Armenia, which is slide number five.
Hovik (00:31:29):Some just, you know, apathy.
Hovik (00:31:31):32% said they're apathetic.
Hovik (00:31:36):31% assessed the public mood as tense,
Hovik (00:31:41):and only 17.8%, or actually sort of,
Hovik (00:31:43):yeah, altogether about 25% or 26% said that the situation is good.
Hovik (00:31:53):Okay,
Hovik (00:31:54):so over 60% of the respondents view Armenia's political situation as very tense or
Hovik (00:32:00):rather tense.
Hovik (00:32:01):Findings align with the visible polarization,
Hovik (00:32:05):the church-state conflict that we talked about,
Hovik (00:32:07):and the elite infighting.
Hovik (00:32:09):And this data,
Hovik (00:32:10):I think,
Hovik (00:32:11):provides a good quantitative confirmation of the unease that we are experiencing.
Hovik (00:32:17):So to begin with, Hrant, what are the repercussions of such a tense state in our society today?
Hrant (00:32:23):Well,
Hrant (00:32:24):in reality,
Hrant (00:32:25):what I see from these results is that despite all inputs and all tries by Pashinyan
Hrant (00:32:35):to increase the tension,
Hrant (00:32:37):it does not work as much as he wants.
Hrant (00:32:39):So subjectively,
Hrant (00:32:42):we see that only some 27% see the social situation in Slovenia as good,
Hrant (00:32:50):while majority see negative trends.
Hrant (00:32:53):Objectively, 36% assess situation as positive, while 56% assess it as negative.
Hrant (00:33:02):So, objectively, people consider it to be better than subjectively, which is important.
Hrant (00:33:08):So,
Hrant (00:33:10):I mean, the emotional state of affairs is on one side,
Hrant (00:33:14):and as people assess their own life and own situation,
Hrant (00:33:19):it's not as bad.
Hrant (00:33:22):It is also because Armenians are not very prone to have a conflict on the,
Hrant (00:33:27):you know,
Hrant (00:33:28):besides government,
Hrant (00:33:32):internal conflicts about politics.
Hrant (00:33:34):So people would rather stop communicating with each other than have fighting with
Hrant (00:33:38):each other over the politics.
Hrant (00:33:40):In Armenia, it's culturally not a not acceptable thing, frankly speaking.
Hrant (00:33:46):That is why, despite all this, you know, all these new and new
Hrant (00:33:50):agendas of you know new clashes regarding the church regarding other issues you
Hrant (00:33:59):know we don't see this fighting in the streets we don't see that and majority of
Hrant (00:34:03):people look at it as a you know as a cinema some support more opposed but basically
Hrant (00:34:12):most of people are trying to be away of this and just just you know not be involved
Hrant (00:34:19):which is important
Hrant (00:34:21):to understand all these trends.
Hrant (00:34:23):Another thing is that in last five years,
Hrant (00:34:26):this is lowest percentage of security as a top issue compared to what we have seen
Hrant (00:34:32):in previous polls.
Hrant (00:34:34):So right now it's 37%.
Hrant (00:34:35):Previously it was up to 90,
Hrant (00:34:40):95% because there were several security related issues combined and all those were
Hrant (00:34:45):very, very high.
Hrant (00:34:46):And economic issues were very highly suppressed.
Hrant (00:34:50):So now we see economic issues increasing the importance and unemployment,
Hrant (00:34:56):inflation,
Hrant (00:34:58):low wages and pensions are increasing in their rate.
Hrant (00:35:04):This we have not observed since 2019, frankly speaking.
Hrant (00:35:08):Yes, security still is top priority, but not as high as it used to be.
Hrant (00:35:13):So it opens the space for non-political discussion as well in the country,
Hrant (00:35:18):which some of the powers are trying to have in this electoral campaign.
Hrant (00:35:22):Although I think still the most important issue will be security.
Hrant (00:35:27):But again, economic factors combined, they are very high already.
Hrant (00:35:31):So it's also important to understand.
Hrant (00:35:34):So as of now,
Hrant (00:35:35):I see that objectively,
Hrant (00:35:37):the tensions in the country are decreasing,
Hrant (00:35:39):despite Pashinyan's campaign.
Hrant (00:35:43):And his campaign,
Hrant (00:35:44):which was in 2021,
Hrant (00:35:46):very aggressive,
Hrant (00:35:47):very divisive,
Hrant (00:35:48):was successful because the tensions were much higher at the time.
Hrant (00:35:53):Now tensions are lower.
Hrant (00:35:55):And that is why it's a divisive campaign.
Hrant (00:35:57):I think it will not be as successful as it used to be five years ago.
Hovik (00:36:02):Yeah.
Hovik (00:36:03):So high expenses and low wages is consistent with the fact that the government has
Hovik (00:36:08):not dealt with poverty.
Hovik (00:36:09):Even Pashinyan has admitted that a high level of poverty exists in the country after
Hovik (00:36:15):eight years in office.
Hovik (00:36:18):So why hasn't the poverty come down at all?
Hrant (00:36:22):Well, officially, we have 2%.
Hrant (00:36:25):percentage points, decrease of poverty last year.
Hrant (00:36:29):But frankly speaking, of course, there are very significant problems.
Hrant (00:36:34):For example, pensions.
Hovik (00:36:36):I mean, can we say what the overall, what is the overall poverty rate as well?
Hovik (00:36:41):Because 2% sounds like a lot.
Hovik (00:36:44):But when you look at the whole number, I think it's like something in the 20 percentage or?
Hrant (00:36:48):Yeah, it was kind of 21.5 or something.
Hrant (00:36:52):So the latest figure was 21.5.
Hrant (00:36:55):five or something.
Hrant (00:36:56):And a year ago, it was 2% higher.
Hrant (00:37:00):So it's not really a low number.
Hrant (00:37:03):We had similar numbers in 2018 as well, frankly speaking.
Hrant (00:37:07):So the result of Pashinyan is not significant.
Hrant (00:37:10):Of course, there was some but not significant methodological change.
Hrant (00:37:14):But still,
Hrant (00:37:15):what I want to say is,
Hrant (00:37:16):you know,
Hrant (00:37:17):we have big troubles with pensions,
Hrant (00:37:20):incomparable prices.
Hrant (00:37:21):Pensions are right now lower than in 2015.
Hrant (00:37:25):That's first thing.
Hrant (00:37:26):Then we have collapsing agriculture.
Hrant (00:37:29):And it is also important because in villages, one million people or a third of population lives.
Hrant (00:37:36):So one third of the population is struggling because of collapse of agriculture.
Hrant (00:37:41):One, six or 15 to 20 percent of population are receiving pensions.
Hrant (00:37:46):They are also in trouble because of low
Hrant (00:37:49):pensions so at least this half of population is in trouble that is obvious and then
Hrant (00:37:55):we have some some issues and also some achievements economically because uh frankly
Hrant (00:38:02):speaking unemployment has gone down significantly and i would say this is uh
Hrant (00:38:09):also an achievement, partly by this government, by the way.
Hrant (00:38:12):But in many other cases,
Hrant (00:38:15):we see that the inequality is still high and it's more and more structurized.
Hrant (00:38:20):So we see very insustainable trends right now in the social sphere and lots of
Hrant (00:38:28):things need to be done.
Hrant (00:38:29):Especially the issue of pensions is a big trouble because the number of pensioners
Hrant (00:38:34):will start growing again since next year because,
Hrant (00:38:39):you know, There was some slowing of growing of pensioners and of aging of population because
Hrant (00:38:45):there was an echo of the Second World War.
Hrant (00:38:49):Now we have restarted process of aging in Armenia,
Hrant (00:38:53):so pensions will become more and more an issue.
Hovik (00:38:57):Given all these insights that we just talked about,
Hovik (00:39:01):what kind of a campaign do you think that the opposition should be running?
Hovik (00:39:05):in the upcoming elections?
Hovik (00:39:07):And is the opposition ready?
Hovik (00:39:09):Do you see any signs that they are reading these polls and they are able to
Hovik (00:39:15):structure their campaigns to have maximum impact?
Hrant (00:39:20):Well, right now, opposition is somewhat following these polls.
Hrant (00:39:24):And not only that, opposition has some polling organizations by themselves as well.
Hrant (00:39:31):So at least I know
Hrant (00:39:34):Almost all of major opposition subjects have their own polling organizations.
Hrant (00:39:40):So it is somewhat different from 2021 when opposition was kind of blind towards these results.
Hrant (00:39:48):And now it is ready to be more efficient, at least.
Hrant (00:39:52):That's the first thing.
Hrant (00:39:54):Another thing is that opposition is, of course, very divided right now.
Hrant (00:40:00):last year, 2025,
Hrant (00:40:01):was marked with very high tensions between the Pativunin bloc and the Armenian
Hrant (00:40:08):bloc.
Hrant (00:40:09):So they were attacking each other and trying to discuss the issue of who is to
Hrant (00:40:13):blame for bringing Pashinyan in power in 2018.
Hrant (00:40:17):And in fact,
Hrant (00:40:18):this is a historical question,
Hrant (00:40:19):not a matter of political discussion,
Hrant (00:40:22):but still they somehow managed to eat each other with this question and they lost a
Hrant (00:40:28):share of credibility
Hrant (00:40:30):Both of them.
Hrant (00:40:32):And then the Mer Dzevov block appeared,
Hrant (00:40:36):which has to be presented as a party in the beginning of 2026,
Hrant (00:40:41):I think.
Hrant (00:40:42):But here is the thing that the leader of this block was captured by Pashinyan and
Hrant (00:40:49):brought to jail.
Hrant (00:40:50):He spent six months there.
Hrant (00:40:51):And now he's serving since end of December.
Hrant (00:40:57):He's serving his term at home.
Hrant (00:41:00):So he's still... He's under house arrest.
Hrant (00:41:07):Yeah, he's still a prisoner.
Hrant (00:41:08):And politically,
Hrant (00:41:09):his situation has worsened because while he was in jail,
Hrant (00:41:14):he could spread political statements.
Hrant (00:41:17):But right now, he cannot do that.
Hrant (00:41:19):He cannot do even that.
Hrant (00:41:21):So that's an interesting thing.
Hrant (00:41:23):So personally, for him, situation has improved, but politically, it has worsened.
Hrant (00:41:28):So...
Hrant (00:41:30):I've seen that when he himself has stated that he's participating in politics,
Hrant (00:41:37):the approval rate of his party was very high.
Hrant (00:41:40):But since then, it has dropped significantly, basically twice.
Hrant (00:41:45):So right now, it's...
Hrant (00:41:48):Very unclear situation on the opposition ground.
Hrant (00:41:51):And I'm not sure opposition will find strong ground to fight.
Hrant (00:41:55):But what I see is that they are creating some grounds and they're in search of their agenda.
Hrant (00:42:03):And let's see what they will offer.
Hrant (00:42:05):Because the offer of Pashinyan is clear and visible.
Hrant (00:42:09):But the offer of opposition is yet information.
Hovik (00:42:13):So not from this poll,
Hovik (00:42:14):but from previous polls,
Hovik (00:42:15):we've seen that the traditional opposition parties have scored,
Hovik (00:42:20):you know, I mean...
Hovik (00:42:22):They're number two and number three after Pashinyan and then maybe now with Mer Dzevov.
Hovik (00:42:28):But it's clear that Pashinyan is still leading the polls.
Hovik (00:42:35):And that has led to some opposition parties,
Hovik (00:42:37):even Mer Dzevov,
Hovik (00:42:38):to distance themselves from the other opposition parties.
Hovik (00:42:43):So the Mer Dzevov
Hovik (00:42:45):leader who is currently running the movement,
Hovik (00:42:49):Narek Karapetyan,
Hovik (00:42:50):Samvel's nephew,
Hovik (00:42:52):has said that we're not going to cooperate or go into an alliance with any of the
Hovik (00:42:57):main opposition parties,
Hovik (00:42:58):either Robert Kocharyan or Sargsyan.
Hovik (00:43:01):Meanwhile, some smaller opposition parties have called,
Hovik (00:43:05):so I'm talking about the Wings of,
Hovik (00:43:07):sorry, Wings of Unity,
Hovik (00:43:09):by Arman Tatoyan,
Hovik (00:43:11):who has said that
Hovik (00:43:14):basically presidents number two and presidents number three should discontinue
Hovik (00:43:18):their campaign and declare that they're not participating in order for them to win.
Hovik (00:43:23):We also know that the Pashinyan regime has lowered the threshold for individual
Hovik (00:43:28):parties to clear the elections and it has increased the threshold
Hovik (00:43:33):for alliances,
Hovik (00:43:34):so it's now more difficult as an electoral alliance to clear the threshold and go
Hovik (00:43:42):into the parliament.
Hovik (00:43:43):What do you think should be the strategy for opposition parties,
Hovik (00:43:48):and should they join one big alliance,
Hovik (00:43:50):for instance,
Hovik (00:43:51):and every one of them without any exception?
Hovik (00:43:56):Is that even realistic?
Hovik (00:43:58):And what do you think about these statements from Armand Tatoyan and Narek
Hovik (00:44:03):Karapetyan,
Hovik (00:44:04):who are trying to distance themselves from the main opposition,
Hovik (00:44:08):parliamentary opposition parties?
Hrant (00:44:10):Well,
Hrant (00:44:11):frankly speaking, this divisive approach that we are the only and so on is not very efficient in the
Hrant (00:44:20):situation where authorities are clearly
Hrant (00:44:25):heading in authoritarian direction and harshing the environment.
Hrant (00:44:31):And in reality, very many people are afraid to speak out.
Hrant (00:44:36):And in this situation,
Hrant (00:44:37):you know,
Hrant (00:44:38):playing in their game,
Hrant (00:44:43):I don't think it will be beneficial for opposition,
Hrant (00:44:45):frankly speaking.
Hrant (00:44:47):And obviously,
Hrant (00:44:48):this trend has been set by the government because Pashinyan has declared,
Hrant (00:44:52):you know,
Hrant (00:44:53):this black and white division where white those are black and since then many people are
Hrant (00:45:00):trying to distance themselves from the main opposition parties and that is why and
Hrant (00:45:06):from especially those who are regarding the previous governments so that is why
Hrant (00:45:13):people somehow they are divided and the divided impera rule the roman rule
Hrant (00:45:21):divided impera or divided rule, is in play in Armenia.
Hrant (00:45:27):So Pashinyan has effectively divided all opposition.
Hrant (00:45:32):And if opposition plays this game, I don't think opposition will succeed.
Hrant (00:45:38):So eventually,
Hrant (00:45:39):I think,
Hrant (00:45:41):towards the elections,
Hrant (00:45:42):opposition will have to approach at least some form of coalition.
Hrant (00:45:46):At least some form of coalition should be found by opposition.
Hrant (00:45:52):maybe a kind of Georgian opposition has achieved in 2024.
Hrant (00:45:58):For example,
Hrant (00:45:59):they have signed a charity where they have presented the main principles of
Hrant (00:46:04):opposition.
Hrant (00:46:05):So this will also mean that if altogether they might form a coalition,
Hrant (00:46:10):although it will be very fluid coalition,
Hrant (00:46:13):but at least it will mean the governmental change in Armenia.
Hrant (00:46:17):So at least that will create a new space and
Hrant (00:46:21):they will declare by that that they are ready to cooperate,
Hrant (00:46:24):at least after the election,
Hrant (00:46:25):maybe not before,
Hrant (00:46:26):but after.
Hrant (00:46:27):But if they will refuse to cooperate,
Hrant (00:46:29):that will mean that they will not be able to form a coalition.
Hrant (00:46:31):So I think towards the elections, their stance will change.
Hrant (00:46:36):And by the way,
Hrant (00:46:38):both parties which you have cited right now,
Hrant (00:46:41):both of them represent very new parties.
Hrant (00:46:45):So they don't have enough experience.
Hrant (00:46:47):I think the more experience they will gain, the more their approaches will change as well.
Asbed (00:46:53):Regardless of who the opposition turns out to be in the elections,
Asbed (00:46:58):to me,
Asbed (00:46:59):it seems like they have a very real opportunity to capitalize on what is indicated
Asbed (00:47:05):in these polls, because from an economic perspective,
Asbed (00:47:08):there's a real opportunity to show that the government is not really doing a lot of
Asbed (00:47:13):good for the common people.
Asbed (00:47:16):Hrant, I want to talk about slide six and seven.
Asbed (00:47:19):Security as well.
Asbed (00:47:20):Oh, absolutely.
Asbed (00:47:21):I was going to mention a little bit earlier, but you talked a little bit about that.
Asbed (00:47:26):Even though the number of respondents about national security being the top concern
Asbed (00:47:30):has decreased,
Asbed (00:47:31):it still seems like it's the top concern for people.
Asbed (00:47:34):And I don't know how you mesh that with this agenda of peace talk from Pashinyan,
Asbed (00:47:40):because people are not feeling very secure in their own country.
Asbed (00:47:44):So in response to slide six, 54% of the people said yes, and 42% of the people said no.
Asbed (00:47:53):And in slide seven,
Asbed (00:47:55):the poll shows that the vast majority of people are not afraid of expressing their
Asbed (00:47:59):thoughts.
Asbed (00:48:00):At least that's how they've responded.
Asbed (00:48:02):So this is an interesting case for me in that there is a little bit of an embedded
Asbed (00:48:07):optimism in these answers,
Asbed (00:48:08):perhaps even
Asbed (00:48:10):a little bit of defiance in slide seven, that they are not afraid of expressing themselves.
Asbed (00:48:15):Do you think that this optimism,
Asbed (00:48:17):if I'm correct in calling it optimism,
Asbed (00:48:20):will translate to a higher turnout in the June 2026 elections?
Asbed (00:48:24):And could the turnout result in a change of government in direction of the country?
Hrant (00:48:30):Frankly speaking, I think that both represent delusion.
Hrant (00:48:35):And I will try to explain why.
Hrant (00:48:37):first regarding the so-called people like you can affect the government policy and
Hrant (00:48:42):so on or situation in the country.
Hrant (00:48:45):Since Pashinyan has came,
Hrant (00:48:47):well, previous government was trying to show the situation as you cannot do anything.
Hrant (00:48:53):You just have to obey the law and we will carry for the other stuff.
Hrant (00:48:57):So that was a message by the previous government and it is very common for any
Hrant (00:49:03):post-Soviet government.
Hrant (00:49:05):And people really agreed to that.
Hrant (00:49:07):They considered that they cannot do anything.
Hrant (00:49:11):Although,
Hrant (00:49:12):when there was any discontent in the country towards any issue,
Hrant (00:49:18):the government was very cautious and tried to react or maybe change the policy.
Hrant (00:49:24):And in many cases, they did.
Hrant (00:49:27):So, in fact, the previous government was based on the very broad but not formalized consensus on
Hrant (00:49:34):one hand. And on another hand, when they faced resistance, they changed the policies.
Hrant (00:49:40):There have been many cases of that.
Hrant (00:49:43):And since the government changed in 2018,
Hrant (00:49:47):the new government declared that they listen to the people and that people get the
Hrant (00:49:51):voice heard through them.
Hrant (00:49:55):And since then, they do not rely on any consensus.
Hrant (00:50:03):but they rely on narrative governing and also they do not listen to any discontent.
Hrant (00:50:09):For example, regarding the church, majority opposes these policies.
Hrant (00:50:13):Regarding the constitutional referendum, majority opposes.
Hrant (00:50:16):Regarding Artsakh and regarding any issue government has made its top priority,
Hrant (00:50:21):we will see that majority opposes.
Hrant (00:50:26):What does majority support?
Hrant (00:50:27):Well, first of all, majority does not support this government at all.
Hrant (00:50:31):But at least majority of their supporters have some kind of personal sympathy and
Hrant (00:50:36):there are some populist tools and so on.
Hrant (00:50:39):So basically, the people are told that they have power in their hands.
Hrant (00:50:45):And based on very harsh clash in the country and, of course, some people speaking out,
Hrant (00:50:54):They say that, OK, right now we see that many people speak out.
Hrant (00:50:58):So on the second question,
Hrant (00:50:59):it was not you think that you have the freedom of speech,
Hrant (00:51:04):but the people in Armenia have freedom of speech.
Hrant (00:51:07):So people think that if there is criticism, it means that there is a free space for criticism.
Hrant (00:51:16):It's not that they consider that they have this freedom of criticism,
Hrant (00:51:19):because in reality,
Hrant (00:51:21):many people are very restrained.
Hrant (00:51:23):criticizing government or criticizing anything in Armenia.
Hrant (00:51:26):And it is not only a political phenomenon,
Hrant (00:51:29):but also a cultural phenomenon,
Hrant (00:51:30):because Armenia is a post-totalitarian state as any other post-Soviet country.
Hrant (00:51:35):And in every of these countries,
Hrant (00:51:38):there are many social patterns that forbid discontent and forbid being opposing the
Hrant (00:51:45):ruling narrative.
Hrant (00:51:46):And any government is trying to utilize this, and this government is doing it very effectively.
Hrant (00:51:53):So if you talk separately to people, you will see that they are afraid.
Hrant (00:51:58):And many people are really afraid.
Hrant (00:52:00):And I would say majority are afraid of speaking out.
Hrant (00:52:03):But they think that if there are some people who speak out,
Hrant (00:52:07):that means that there is freedom in Armenia.
Hrant (00:52:09):That's very different from what has been happening in Armenia previously.
Hrant (00:52:13):when they were speaking out but since they were hearing in the media that oh you
Hrant (00:52:19):know there is you know Armenia is authoritarian which this current government which
Hrant (00:52:25):was opposition back then was claiming Armenia to be then and I will tell you that I
Hrant (00:52:31):mean I never had even remotely this much of political repression says now since
Hrant (00:52:37):1991 so if
Hrant (00:52:40):And remotely, they did not close as many political channels and so on and so forth.
Hrant (00:52:47):And political prisoners, anything you might imagine.
Hrant (00:52:50):So back then, people would consider that they don't have voice when they did.
Hrant (00:52:55):And now it's opposite because the media narrative is telling them so.
Hrant (00:53:02):So I think this is complete delusion that is based on reproduction of the common
Hrant (00:53:07):narrative which they hear from media,
Hrant (00:53:09):not observing in real life.
Hovik (00:53:11):Hrant,
Hovik (00:53:12):slide number eight through 13,
Hovik (00:53:15):I think this poll really tried to dig into the issue of solidarity and trust in
Hovik (00:53:21):institutions.
Hovik (00:53:22):So five slides, all talking about different aspects of solidarity.
Hovik (00:53:27):I wanna quickly go through them.
Hovik (00:53:29):Slide number eight, how do you assess the overall political situation in Armenia?
Hovik (00:53:34):Around 63% said that either
Hovik (00:53:38):Very tense or somewhat tense.
Hovik (00:53:41):Site number nine says, do you think there is a need to build solidarity within Armenian society?
Hovik (00:53:47):And almost 90% said yes.
Hovik (00:53:53):Slide number 10 says, what factors, in your opinion, hinder social solidarity in Armenia?
Hovik (00:53:59):Number one with 32% is fake news and fake media.
Hovik (00:54:03):Number two is social inequality with 27%.
Hovik (00:54:05):Number three is distrust in public institutions at 26%.
Hovik (00:54:15):Number four is political polarization at 21%.
Hovik (00:54:22):So those are the top four issues that hinder social solidarity.
Hovik (00:54:30):Slide number 11, to what extent do you trust the following institutions?
Hovik (00:54:35):And without mentioning all the other ones,
Hovik (00:54:38):the church with around 71% or 72% is the number,
Hovik (00:54:46):the highest trusted institution.
Hovik (00:54:48):And then slide number 12,
Hovik (00:54:49):in your opinion,
Hovik (00:54:51):which institutions should play a leading role in restoring social solidarity?
Hovik (00:54:57):Number one is the church with 28%.
Hovik (00:54:59):Number two is the state or the government with 21%.
Hovik (00:55:04):All right.
Hovik (00:55:07):And lastly,
Hovik (00:55:09):slide number 13 says,
Hovik (00:55:11):evaluate the extent to which each of the following figures can lead to the
Hovik (00:55:16):spiritual and social healing and unity of society.
Hovik (00:55:20):Number one is Mikhail Ajabahyan, Archbishop Mikhail Ajabahyan.
Hovik (00:55:28):Number two is the Catholicos of all Armenians, Garegin II.
Hovik (00:55:33):Let's skip all the other answers and go directly to the questions.
Hovik (00:55:38):So we spent this past couple of months covering Pashinyan's,
Hovik (00:55:43):I would say,
Hovik (00:55:44):storm against the church,
Hovik (00:55:47):the state versus church storm.
Hovik (00:55:49):Yet the polls show people do not see religious or cultural differences as an issue.
Hovik (00:55:55):In fact, they trust the church institution and church leaders.
Hovik (00:56:01):In fact, this is very interesting because one of the previous episodes we were talking with
Hovik (00:56:05):Benjamin Pogosian,
Hovik (00:56:06):and this time I'm mentioning his name correctly.
Hovik (00:56:08):But Benjamin said,
Hovik (00:56:10):you know,
Hovik (00:56:11):polls should distinguish between institutions and leaders of the institution.
Hovik (00:56:16):It seems like in this poll,
Hovik (00:56:17):both the leadership as well as the institution of the church has received high
Hovik (00:56:22):marks.
Hovik (00:56:25):What does this say about the current patterns of unrest in our country?
Hovik (00:56:31):The government is trying to make a big deal out of this issue with the church,
Hovik (00:56:34):but it seems like the polls say otherwise.
Hrant (00:56:40):First of all, regarding the theoretical issue,
Hrant (00:56:42):trust in institution versus trust in the head of the institution.
Hrant (00:56:48):In reality, sociologically, it's not that highly distinguishable.
Hrant (00:56:51):Of course, politically, it is a very different thing, but sociologically, it's not.
Hrant (00:56:57):And usually the discrepancy is one, two or maybe three percent, not more.
Hrant (00:57:02):So, for example,
Hrant (00:57:03):if you see trust in government and trust in Pashinyan,
Hrant (00:57:08):it's more or less the same.
Hrant (00:57:10):It might be plus minus two percent, but not more.
Hrant (00:57:14):And the same regarding the church.
Hrant (00:57:16):So the Armenian Apostolic Church is under attack of this government basically since August 2018.
Hrant (00:57:23):And since then, the approval rate of the church has been declining.
Hrant (00:57:28):Before this government, it was about 72% trusting the church.
Hrant (00:57:33):And then it went down to, you know, 60, 65, and then 50, and at some point even lower than 50.
Hrant (00:57:40):But then, since Pashinyan restarted the attacks,
Hrant (00:57:44):and especially he started attacking the institution since June 2025,
Hrant (00:57:50):and especially after Azerbaijan's attack on Armenian
Hrant (00:57:53):church, you know, I mean, verbal attack on Armenian church on Azerbaijani side.
Hrant (00:57:58):And then Pashinyan has continued.
Hrant (00:58:01):Since then, we see the reversal of the trend and we see the approval rate of Armenian church
Hrant (00:58:06):growing back to some 71 to 72 percent,
Hrant (00:58:10):which has been observed before the Pashinyan's government.
Hrant (00:58:13):So before 2018.
Hrant (00:58:15):So it is one important trend.
Hrant (00:58:18):Of course,
Hrant (00:58:19):I should mention that five institutions are represented here,
Hrant (00:58:24):but if we look at other polls,
Hrant (00:58:26):we see that there are some other institutions which also have significant support
Hrant (00:58:31):on the population side.
Hrant (00:58:33):That includes, for example, the army, which has similar support to the church, around 70%.
Hrant (00:58:38):And then we have
Hrant (00:58:41):rather high support of local governments, which is about 50 to 55 percent.
Hrant (00:58:48):And then we have some support towards the police, which is 50 to 60 percent.
Hrant (00:58:54):So the church is not only the only institution which has significant public
Hrant (00:58:59):support,
Hrant (00:59:00):but as of now,
Hrant (00:59:01):church might be the first already.
Hrant (00:59:04):But all this happened.
Hrant (00:59:06):especially during last five to seven months.
Hrant (00:59:10):Last half year basically has,
Hrant (00:59:12):you know, brought trust towards church back for the significant portion of population.
Hrant (00:59:19):And it is also due to the moral stance of the church.
Hrant (00:59:23):And, you know,
Hrant (00:59:24):church was,
Hrant (00:59:25):you know,
Hrant (00:59:26):using all these early Bolshevik narratives against the church,
Hrant (00:59:31):which was made by the
Hrant (00:59:35):by this government.
Hrant (00:59:37):On one hand, it, of course, brought all those social realities and so on back.
Hrant (00:59:43):But on the other hand, people see how bankrupt these messages are.
Hrant (00:59:48):They were blaming the church in being consumerist or very materialized.
Hrant (00:59:55):But what people have observed that the church is under attack,
Hrant (00:59:59):their identity is under attack,
Hrant (01:00:01):and churches are
Hrant (01:00:03):has set very high moral ground,
Hrant (01:00:06):and the Pashinyan's attack on church is based on very low moral ground.
Hrant (01:00:11):Moreover,
Hrant (01:00:12):the people in the church among bishops whose support he has gathered are known for
Hrant (01:00:18):having the lowest respect in the church.
Hrant (01:00:21):And vice versa,
Hrant (01:00:22):those who have highest respect in the church are now jailed,
Hrant (01:00:25):especially Mikayel Ajapahyan,
Hrant (01:00:28):whom you have mentioned.
Hrant (01:00:29):So basically what happens, those whom people love, they are jailed.
Hrant (01:00:34):Those whom people hate, they are with Pashinyan.
Hrant (01:00:37):So this is obvious that the attack on church is trying to kill all the good in
Hrant (01:00:43):church and promote all the bad in church.
Hrant (01:00:46):So that is why we see that the church as an institution and all the good which is
Hrant (01:00:51):there is trying to improve itself as well and is showing its best compared to the
Hrant (01:00:58):government.
Hrant (01:01:00):And the language of communication, on one hand, it's a very low street language of attack.
Hrant (01:01:08):You know, they made up videos and so on.
Hrant (01:01:12):And on the other hand, you see continuation of institutional tradition.
Hrant (01:01:17):And, you know, you can take the second statements and compare those to the
Hrant (01:01:24):communication that his predecessors had with Ottoman and Persian emperors.
Hrant (01:01:29):And you see that it's an institution and it's a completely different thing to what
Hrant (01:01:34):Pashinyan represents.
Hrant (01:01:36):Now, the government's approval rate, according to this poll, was around 38.6%.
Hrant (01:01:40):The church's approval rate is 71.4%.
Hrant (01:01:41):So it's
Hrant (01:01:47):almost twice less than the church so when a small when a small subject from physics
Hrant (01:01:52):you know when a small subject attacks the bigger subject you know the energy of
Hrant (01:01:57):biggest prevails
Hrant (01:01:59):But at the same time,
Hrant (01:02:01):if the small is very energetic and the big is very passive,
Hrant (01:02:04):the big will move,
Hrant (01:02:05):the small will lose its energy,
Hrant (01:02:07):but still will succeed somehow.
Hrant (01:02:09):So it's also dependent on how church will react.
Hrant (01:02:11):And we see on one hand,
Hrant (01:02:13):it's passive and on another hand,
Hrant (01:02:16):the church has to respond and it's responding more and more efficiently.
Hrant (01:02:20):I think this is a situation in transition.
Hrant (01:02:23):And I think this attack on the church might be decisive in the result of elections in 2026.
Hrant (01:02:30):I think this is causing Pashinyan very big trouble right now.
Asbed (01:02:35):In this case,
Asbed (01:02:36):of course, the small has administrative resources and the police and the national security
Asbed (01:02:41):apparatus,
Asbed (01:02:42):all of which are being used like rabid dogs.
Asbed (01:02:46):Hrant, in light of the major economic and financial concerns that were expressed in this
Asbed (01:02:50):poll, I just want to take a quick moment to talk,
Asbed (01:02:53):ask a couple of questions about the economy.
Asbed (01:02:55):A month ago,
Asbed (01:02:56):the Luys Foundation put out a quarterly report,
Asbed (01:02:59):which emphasized a couple of major areas of concern with the economy,
Asbed (01:03:02):capital expenditure,
Asbed (01:03:04):underperformance,
Asbed (01:03:06):and those were in the areas of infrastructure,
Asbed (01:03:09):construction,
Asbed (01:03:10):IT, defense and military,
Asbed (01:03:12):industrial complex.
Asbed (01:03:13):And then there was also the other concern was the national debt,
Asbed (01:03:16):which in nine months from January to September has added something like 10%,
Asbed (01:03:20):$1.4 billion of additional national debt.
Asbed (01:03:26):We could go deeper, but we don't have enough time for this.
Asbed (01:03:30):How is the reported underperformance in the economy affecting the people, or is it?
Hrant (01:03:36):Frankly speaking, it is not affecting people that much.
Hrant (01:03:41):Why I'm saying that?
Hrant (01:03:42):Because, of course, it has a very different effect on different groups of population.
Hrant (01:03:51):We have talked about agricultural production.
Hrant (01:03:54):We have talked about pensions, social benefits.
Hrant (01:03:57):But at the same time, business has been growing lately.
Hrant (01:04:02):And yes,
Hrant (01:04:03):we have seen some troubles for the exporters,
Hrant (01:04:06):including the exporters of services,
Hrant (01:04:09):including IT,
Hrant (01:04:10):tourism and some other fields.
Hrant (01:04:12):But at the same time, generally businesses has grown last several years, primarily to
Hrant (01:04:19):because of anti-Russian sanctions and Armenia being involved in all those trade,
Hrant (01:04:24):but also because of,
Hrant (01:04:26):you know, some global trends and because of some low base effect.
Hrant (01:04:30):But anyway, but also there were some other policies adopted as well.
Hrant (01:04:39):So basically, we have seen very significant economic growth lately.
Hrant (01:04:44):To which extent it is healthy?
Hrant (01:04:46):That is a good question.
Hrant (01:04:48):And to some extent,
Hrant (01:04:49):it is exaggerated and not healthy because high growth of debt is not an adequate
Hrant (01:04:56):situation when you have high economic growth.
Hrant (01:04:59):Pashinyan desperately tries to hit the economy
Hrant (01:05:06):And the overheated economy somehow shows the results,
Hrant (01:05:10):and you see what you are achieving during Pashinyan,
Hrant (01:05:13):and that is why he is increasing the debt.
Hrant (01:05:16):But generally,
Hrant (01:05:18):it's adopted that debt should be increased during the crisis,
Hrant (01:05:22):and during the period of economic growth,
Hrant (01:05:24):you pay back.
Hrant (01:05:26):While if you acquire new debts during the period of economic growth,
Hrant (01:05:30):we understand that to some extent and to a big extent,
Hrant (01:05:33):this economic growth is fake.
Hrant (01:05:35):And you will have to pay off in the future.
Hrant (01:05:38):So he's leaving the debt to the future generations, that's obvious.
Hrant (01:05:43):But who will ask him after all he has done?
Hrant (01:05:46):So that's a good question.
Hrant (01:05:47):On another hand,
Hrant (01:05:49):he has somehow benefited from the geopolitics and the situation around Russia and
Hrant (01:05:56):around all these conflicts globally has benefited Armenia.
Hrant (01:06:03):So economic growth has increased.
Hrant (01:06:06):Again, I want to note that it's not spread equally among the population.
Hrant (01:06:11):So the high economic growth does not mean that everyone is benefiting.
Hrant (01:06:15):Regarding the rest issues,
Hrant (01:06:16):which you have noted,
Hrant (01:06:17):the military expenses,
Hrant (01:06:22):the social benefits and the capital expenses,
Hrant (01:06:27):all those issues we have since 2018,
Hrant (01:06:28):those are,
Hrant (01:06:30):you know, watermark of this government.
Hrant (01:06:32):So nothing has changed since 2018.
Hrant (01:06:35):Every year is the same.
Hrant (01:06:37):Military expenses and capital expenses are underperformed and debt is increasing.
Hrant (01:06:42):But that's the economic reality.
Asbed (01:06:44):I think you're right about the consumer debt,
Asbed (01:06:46):because as indicated in the polls,
Asbed (01:06:48):people are complaining about the
Asbed (01:06:50):their wages not making ends meet and also poverty levels have not particularly
Asbed (01:06:57):improved and they're complaining about inflation as well.
Asbed (01:06:59):So are you concerned about the national debt, though, because it has added another $1.4 billion?
Asbed (01:07:05):It stands at about $14 billion at this point.
Asbed (01:07:09):At what point is this going to become a problem for Armenia, the servicing of this debt?
Hrant (01:07:15):In reality, it already is a problem.
Hrant (01:07:18):But
Hrant (01:07:20):But when it will cross the line of maybe two thirds of GDP,
Hrant (01:07:26):it will start becoming a real problem.
Hrant (01:07:29):As of now, it is below this line.
Hrant (01:07:31):I mean, the government debt and especially the external debt.
Hrant (01:07:37):And now we're in the process of transformation of external debt towards internal debt.
Hrant (01:07:44):But the percentages are rather high.
Hrant (01:07:46):So, for example,
Hrant (01:07:47):if on one hand the share of GDP,
Hrant (01:07:51):I mean, the share of debt towards GDP is not that high,
Hrant (01:07:54):but the percentage is very high,
Hrant (01:07:57):which means that Armenia has to pay back too much.
Hrant (01:08:02):So I think it is already a problem, but it's not catastrophic here.
Hrant (01:08:06):But anyway, any responsible statecraft would imply decreasing the spending
Hrant (01:08:15):and decreasing the state debt,
Hrant (01:08:19):or at least trying to maintain it at current level because the economy is
Hrant (01:08:24):overheated with the debt money,
Hrant (01:08:26):with the foreign currency,
Hrant (01:08:30):which is coming because of the trade with Russia and so on.
Asbed (01:08:35):Okay.
Asbed (01:08:36):Thank you, Hrant, for joining us.
Asbed (01:08:37):That's all the time we have today.
Asbed (01:08:38):We look forward to talking with you throughout 2026.
Asbed (01:08:41):Thank you, friends.
Hrant (01:08:45):Thank you, Henan Can.
Asbed (01:08:47):Okay, that was our Week in Review show recorded on January 6th, 2026.
Asbed (01:08:54):Once again, Merry Christmas to all of our Armenian listeners.
Asbed (01:08:57):We've been talking with Hrant Mikaelian,
Asbed (01:08:59):a political scientist and multidisciplinary researcher in social sciences based in
Asbed (01:09:04):Yerevan.
Asbed (01:09:05):I'm Asbed Bedrossian and I'm in Los Angeles.
Hovik (01:09:08):I'm Hovik Manucharyan and I'm in Yerevan.
Asbed (01:09:11):We'll talk to you soon.
Hovik (01:09:12):And again, Merry Armenian Christmas.
Hovik (01:09:16):Christos dznav yev haidnetsav, mez yev dzes mets avetis.
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.