The Jewish Education Experience Podcast
The Jewish Education Experience Podcast by Yasminah with the goal to uncover gems of wisdom with Jewish educators from around the world. The podcast features interviews with Jewish educators outlining their stories, tips of the trade, advice, support, and insights. We hope this podcast will assist educators at every stage of their journey - those who are just beginning and those who have dedicated their lives to this vital profession that is Jewish Education.
The Jewish Education Experience Podcast
120: Keeping Jewish Teens Connected with Rabbi Glenn Black
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Rabbi Glenn M. Black is a passionate Jewish educator and mentor dedicated to inspiring teens through meaningful Torah learning and community building. He has played a significant role in strengthening Jewish identity and engagement through his leadership as CEO of NCSY. For more than 30 years, Rabbi Black has devoted his career to creating transformative opportunities for Jewish youth and helping thousands of teens build a lasting connection to their heritage. His leadership, vision, and unwavering commitment have helped shape stronger Jewish communities and inspired countless young people to carry their Jewish identity forward with pride, ensuring a vibrant Jewish future for today and for generations to come.
Gems:
- Care about Yiddishkeit.
- Help young people learn who they are.
- There must be consistency in the home.
- Investing in NCSY helps with all three major difficulties facing our nation today are the safety of Israel, assimilation and intermarriage, and antisemitism.
- Jewish identity is crucial to teach.
- Multigenerational learning is monumental today.
- Be role models for children.
- Children need rules and guidance.
- Parents need to be parents.
- Look at each child and ask yourself what does this child need from me today?
- Give children a sense of belonging.
- Make Torah relevant to our children’s lives today.
Featuring 100 of the most notable tips from educators who were featured on the podcast.
Parenting On Purpose
This course will help you better understand your child and build a deeper connection.
Tikvah
Tikvah focuses on Classical Jewish Education.
Wellnesse Natural Personal Care Products
Wellnesse was founded by a mom who wanted healthier options for families. Check out my unique link!
Disclaimer: This post contains affiliate links. If you make a purchase, I may receive a commission at no extra cost to you.
Welcome And Big-Picture Vision
SPEAKER_01Welcome to the Jewish Education Experience podcast with your host, Yasmina, featuring inspiring conversations and gems of wisdom from Jewish educators around the world. This episode is brought to you by TikTok.
SPEAKER_02There's a growing movement reimagining Jewish education, one grounded in a simple but powerful idea that real thinking starts with real reading. A movement that believes teachers should be teachers, not therapists. And that every Jewish student deserves to understand how Judaism has shaped the human story. TICFA, a leading organization in this space, has partnered with the University of Dallas to offer a master's degree that reflects that vision. An MA in humanities with a concentration in Jewish classical education. This isn't just a program for classroom teachers. It's designed for educators, yes, but also for parents, school leaders, and anyone who wants to engage deeply with Western civilization and culture through a
A Master’s Path In Jewish Humanities
SPEAKER_02Jewish lens. If you're looking to strengthen both your teaching and your own learning, this is a program worth exploring. Applications for the upcoming year are now open. To learn more, visit Jewish Classicaleducation.org.
SPEAKER_01Again, Jewish Classicaleducation.org. And thanks to TICFO for supporting our show. I'm really excited to share that my new book, A Hundred Gems of Wisdom from Jewish Educators, is now available on Amazon. So you can search for that on Amazon, you'll find it. And you can also find it in the link to the podcast. When you search for the podcast, you'll also be able to see it there. And it's a short book, it's an easy read. It has some quotes that various educators that I've interviewed over the course of podcasts have mentioned. It also has a story that goes along with the quote that the educator mentioned. And then it has some practical tips for each educator or even a parent or administrator to implement into their lives, into their classroom. So I hope that you will check that out and that you'll enjoy reading it also. To our audience, thank you so much.
SPEAKER_02We really appreciate your support. And because of you, our podcast has reached 10,000 downloads and growing.
SPEAKER_01It's continuing to reach Jewish educators, parents, principals, administrators, and also students.
SPEAKER_02Also, please consider supporting our podcast by joining our Patreon community. www.patreon.com forward slash Jewish Education Experience podcast. And to all of you Jewish educators and students of Jewish education around the world, please go the insu. May you be strengthened and encouraged in your holy endeavors. In this episode, I
Book Launch And Patreon Support
SPEAKER_02interview Rabbi Glenn Black. He is a passionate Jewish educator and mentor dedicated to inspiring teens through meaningful Torah learning and community building. He has played a significant role in strengthening Jewish identity and engagement through his leadership as CEO of NCSY. For more than 30 years, Rabbi Black has devoted his career to creating transformative opportunities for Jewish youth and helping thousands of teens build a lasting connection to their heritage. His leadership, vision, and unwavering commitment have helped shape stronger Jewish communities and inspired countless young people to carry their Jewish identity forward with pride, ensuring a vibrant Jewish future for today and for generations to come. And the topic was how do we keep our children engaged and inspired within Judaism? Because as we're seeing, a lot of young people, unfortunately, are deciding that, you know what, this is not for me. And they walk away. And we have seen a little bit of a resurgence since October 7th. But overall, it is something that we are dealing with as a Jewish community. And who better to be able to discuss this with than Rabbi Black, who is the CEO of NCSY, and that's an organization who specifically works with teens. And we mentioned this in the interview also, that teens they're really at a crucial point in their lives and also a challenging point in their lives where they're changing and their bodies are changing, their brains are changing, and there's so much that they're having to deal with at this stage. They're learning to come into their own a bit more and experience a little bit more of an independence from their parents, and they're connecting more with friends at this stage of their lives. And now for these teens to also experience many of them who are going to public school, this shift. And you know what? You're a murderer. You're a Jew, you're associated with Israel, you're evil, you're bad, and all these things that they're hearing. The work that Rabbi Black is able to do through NCSY is to tell these teens, no, you're not. You have a special Nishama. You are created, but Selim Elohim, you're created in Hashem's image. There is something about you. And come here, come connect with other people who are like you. So throughout this episode, he mentions the programs that NCSY does. He mentions Sparks, another way that teens connect. And one thing that sticks out is many teens are asking that their high schools have an NCSY branch or that they can build a branch there within their schools so that they can connect with
Why Teens Drift From Judaism
SPEAKER_02other Jewish teens also. First and foremost, what we can do as educators, as parents, as leaders, is help our children, our students care about their Yiddishkai. It's so important that we help young people learn and understand who they are and how the Torah, how the values and our tradition, how it is relevant in their lives today, and how it will help them in the future also. We talk a little bit about how NCSY raises funds. And he says he goes and asks for donations. He mentions that NCSY actually accomplishes three of the big things that are plaguing the Jewish community right now. And that's the safety of Israel, assimilation, and intermarriage, and also anti-Semitism, which he really calls an attack on the Jewish identity. And he said NCSY really solves all three of those because it gives it creates an environment where Jews, teens, they learn to love Israel and have a connection with Israel. They go to on trips to Israel. And it fixes the assimilation and intermarriage because it gets Jewish teens around each other so they can meet and interact with each other. And hopefully in the future, uh God will and get married. And then also it tackles the anti-Semitism or the Jewish identity piece because it gives the teens a stronger root and really educates them on how to have a stronger identity. More recently, he mentioned that NCSY has branched out into more multi-generational learning and includes parents and allows them to go on trips to Israel and allows parents to see what the kids are connecting with. And I love this. He mentions a story about a daughter who goes to NCSY and she's really inspired and she goes home and she says, I want to be more observant and wants to do all these things, but her mother flat out rejects it and just is not into it at all. And so unfortunately for that young woman, she turns off, she marries someone who's not Jewish. And then in the future, the mother goes on a trip with NCSY and is inspired and says, oh my gosh, this is beautiful. And then encourages her younger daughter to get involved. And then the other daughter sees that and reconnects with her Jewish heritage. Such a beautiful story and really highlights the work that NCSY does. A very, very important, crucial thing that I'm hearing so much today is parents need to be parents. We are not friends with our children. We are their parents. Hashem has entrusted us with these nishamas that we're supposed to be building and teaching and guiding. And it is our job to play that role and to do what we need to do. And sometimes they are not gonna like the decisions we make, but it's our job to do it. And lastly, for us, look at each child and ask ourselves what does that child need from me today? And figure out how you can connect with them and help them in that process. Again, I really enjoyed this episode, and I hope that you will enjoy listening.
Rabbi Black’s Personal Jewish Journey
SPEAKER_02Our guest today is Rabbi Glenn Black. Hello, Rabbi Black. Welcome to the podcast, and thank you so much for being here today.
SPEAKER_03Great pleasure. Thank you for having me.
SPEAKER_02It's such a pleasure. So, just for our audience, so they uh have a little bit of a background. Over Shovuot, I was in Toronto with my family, and you were featured as one of the panelists. I guess it was the first day of Shovuot, right? The afternoon, there was a discussion about Primoch and how it pertains to our times. And I forget the exact uh title, um, but you were one of the panelists on there. And Rabbi Kropkin actually helped make the kesher, the connection between us. Um, so it's so great that you're now we're the kesher here via the internet.
SPEAKER_03So we're very happy to continue this relationship for sure. Thank you.
SPEAKER_02Definitely. Well, would you please tell our audience a little bit more about yourself and how you got involved in Kinoch in Jewish education?
SPEAKER_03Um I mean, I my story is not that exciting, honestly. I grew up in Montreal, Canada, Quebec, Canada. And um, and two two parents, I have two, I'm one of three, I'm the eldest son. I have two younger sisters. My parents, I would describe them as Balichuva. My father, Oliver Shalom, passed away a couple of years ago. He is uh he his family's from Poland. My my Ashkenazic side is Polish. My mother is actually Tunisian. Um, and um the family uh ran from Tunisia around the time of the State of Israel's establishment. So she's one of those Jews from Arab lands. She ended up going to Paris, France, and from France, they were looking for another place to live, and they ended up in in Outremont, French-speaking Quebec, where my parent, my father, and many Jews from Montreal who came from Poland moved to. So my parents, my father spoke not a word of French, my mother spoke not a word of English, and they had a magical uh uh what's it called a um marriage for 50 55 years or so.
SPEAKER_02Amazing.
SPEAKER_03Pretty amazing. And so we were raised in a in a in a home that cared about Yiddish gite, that cared about uh growing the they wanted to teach us, they wanted us to teach them more importantly, because they didn't have they were traditional, but they didn't have really, it was not really Halacha in the home, but they sent us to Jewish schools. Um my sister and I would go to Talmatara in Shamini Laval, which is a little suburb outside of Montreal, so like speaking about like Hamilton, wow just outside, and uh we'd come home and say, hey, there's something called Shalom Alechem on Friday nights, and there's something called Kiddish, and uh you can't use that fork again if it fell into the meat pot. Uh so um we our parents were so sincere that as they grew, the family became more observant and more connected. And I and I went to Jewish Day school, put us in Jewish day school, more observant Jewish day school. I was a tomato, but then they sent me to a school called Hebrew Academy in Montreal, which had a tremendous impact on my family. Um, because I was surrounded in an um you know Torah Jews and Shoal and Orthodoxy. And also my parents grew, we we grew up in a small town, as I mentioned. So when you're in a small town, uh everybody matters. You you can't just hide. They need you for a minion, they need you for a minion. There's only nine people there. You gotta show up. And I remember getting called by the rabbi, get on my get on my bike, we need you for mincha, and and being involved with that. And so, you know, you always have this achrist, you feel this responsibility to the Jewish people immediately as soon as you're a young, a youngster. And then that grew and grew and grew. And I went to Yeshiva at Israel, and I realized there I had some tremendous encounters in Israel where I noticed that there were soldiers, so many soldiers, who were not as educated as they needed to be about Jewish history. They knew exactly what they were, they were fighting for their home, immediate home, their house.
SPEAKER_01Right.
SPEAKER_03Um, and the person's house next to them. But I don't think they fully understood. This is already, you know, 30 over 30 years ago. I think the education now is way, way better. But over 30 years ago, um, 40 years ago almost, um, they they were they didn't they didn't catch, they didn't understand the full gamut of their sacrifice and what they represented to Klaisrael in general. Uh, and so I would go down from my yeshiva, which was up the hill, go down to visit with soldiers, and I would teach soldiers Yiddish gite. And that really stuck with me. Really stuck with me that there were Jews out there that that even in Israel didn't know. I made a commitment when I was 17 years old, I'm 56, that I would dedicate my life to ensuring that young people would know who they are and where they come from. And that's really where it started. I've been doing NCSY for 32 years. It's the one and only job I ever had. I have a degree in marketing, business administration, and smicha. And I feel like the marketing and business administration administration and smicha together is exactly the beautiful combination of what really Yiddishkeit and outreach is really all about. It's about taking a beautiful product called Torah and packaging in a way that makes sense and is consumable to the broader audience. And so for literally 30, well, more than 35 years, it's the one and only thing I've been doing. I know that's boring, but that's that's that's been my focus since literally I was a 17-year-old boy.
SPEAKER_02I mean, that's quite amazing. First off, that your parents had the wherewithal and the drive inside of them to make sure that you and your sisters had a Jewish education and it was important to them. And then they learned more as you guys were also learning, and you kind of as a family became more observant. And because sometimes it could go the other way where the parents maybe aren't ready to take it on yet, and it can cause a little bit of tension in the home when the children want to do more, but the parents, yeah.
SPEAKER_03We see that all the time. That's why I'm I'm a great example when a parent is not does not my my parents looked at their growth as love for their children, not so much love for Hashem. Sure. And so it became love for Hashem and love for Judaism, but it was mostly love for the kids. The kids were they put us in Jewish school. So how can you say, and by the way, I I'm we encounter this all the time. Keep your yeah, keep your Yiddish guy. You know, you go, we're putting you in school, in Jewish school, but you know, you you leave that keeper at the door, you leave that, you know, those that religion that we don't do that in our family. We're sending you to school because we don't want you to be in public school. We want you to know something of who you are, we want you to marry a Jew, but that's where the line is for our family. My parents did not approach this situation like that. I really wanted us to embrace who we were and how who they were, and um, they got tremendous, tremendous nachas from from their three kids who are all from my mother's side, all married Jewish. Uh, Tunisians, Svartic usually are are better at that. And their children, some of religious and some are not. In my father's side, there were many. My father's one of six, there were lots of intermarriage. And my parents' children, us, we are the only from cousins, and we're the only from they would have the only from grandchildren of any of their siblings.
SPEAKER_00Wow.
SPEAKER_03Period. So that's that's a love for your children, and which translates into a love for Hashem, and you know, and it goes back again. Love for Shil Shashem turns into love for children.
SPEAKER_02It really does. And um, and Kolakovo to your parents that they were open and they loved you guys, and their love for Hashem did eventually grow through that. I also like what you said about using your background, your experience in marketing and business and your smicha, obviously, that you are using all of that in your role with NCSY and really packaging Judaism as something that is worthwhile and is important. And especially today when we're going through such challenges and there's so many attacks against the Jewish people. And it can be hard, I'm sure, you see kids struggling with this. And how do they manage, on the one hand, being proud to be a Jew, but then on the other hand, the outside world, oh, Jew, bad, Israel bad, and all of these things. How do you approach that in NCSY? How do you help anchor young people? Because you're dealing with uh teenagers and young uh what what age does NCSY start?
SPEAKER_03Four 14 to junior general. We have an alumni college campus. We have a junior's grade six, grade seven, grade eight, but our main core is teenagers 14 to like high school grade 12. Yeah. I mean, it's a great
Public School Clubs After October 7
SPEAKER_03question. You know, I'll tell you the negative side and then I'll tell you the what most people think we do, and I'll tell you what we really do. What's going on out there is we run a network of public school clubs in North America. It's about 400 clubs, maybe even 500 clubs today. I'm not even sure. Um, and in Canada specifically, we have 55 clubs or so. The clubs are called the Jewish Student Union. It's a network of clubs in which we go into non-Jewish private schools or public schools. And sometimes we have them actually in community schools as well, uh, across the country from Montreal to Vancouver. And you have this across all of North, all of America as well, for those of you who are listening from the States, tons, three, four hundred of them in the States, of course. It's all run through NCSY. And we we go into these public schools. I'll use the public school as an example, and we bring kosher pizza and we teach a little Torah, we do a tech ad activity. We just keep the Jewish kids Jewish. There's actually 30,000 kids or so that participate in this program in North America, which is a tremendous, uh, tremendous opportunity for us to reach them. Once October 7th happened, there was a massive surge that occurred where kids who had heard that we had clubs in a particular school down the street said, How do I get a club? How do we get a club in our school? We need a Jewish presence because we're getting clobbered over here. Our closest friends, and these are stories that are not only my own, the thousands of stories like this, but I'm a witness to dozens and maybe hundreds of, you know, my best friend who was my best friend in math, and we were classmates and we were in the same sports team, no longer talks to me. They uh friends turned on friends and uh isolated the Jewish kids. The teachers did the same, the principals didn't react properly, the trustees and the board of directors of schools were silent on this subject. So it was very, very painful. We worked with parents, we worked with kids, we worked with the schools, and it was a very terrible time. But that, and that's the truth, that that and that still happens to a degree. Kids are still asking for clubs, and that's an amazing thing that's happening. But in essence, you know, I I saw a beautiful idea the other day that, you know, of course, on Tish Shavasabhartammuz is the day in which the the the walls of Yushlaim were breached, and and that was a terrible moment because now the worst possible things could happen, which is what we know. The Horban were in the three weeks. But simultaneously, Yushalaim was a place of light, and Yushalim was a place of kidusha, and Yushalaim was a place of positivity, and so when the walls were breached, the light and the cadus was able. To also penetrate outside the walls of Yushalim and go way beyond just the city itself. And so what's happened is in the same exact way, as the walls were being broken around the sanity of humanity, Jews were getting clobbered. But at the same time, as those walls broke down around them, and as their culture broke down around them, they were able to become much stronger human beings, much stronger Jews, reinforced in a way that you couldn't imagine on October 6th. And so what's happening, there's massive surge of people wearing tefillin today and tits today and want to keep Shabbos today. And our greatest challenge in NCSY is no longer reach. Today, NCSY Canada reaches one of every four Jewish kids in the country. That was not true on October 6th, 2023. People are looking and seeking us out as much as we're seeking them out. And that is a massive opportunity versus a horrible. We have turned a terrible lemonade, lemon into lemonade. And um, and when I say just I'm speaking from I'm the CEO of NCSY Canada, but in NCSY in general, we have seen we have seen a lot of painful moments that continue to happen, but we have seen way more opportunities. As I speak to you right now, I'm not sure when this podcast will be released. There are almost 2,000 Jewish kids in Israel right now on NCSY summer programs, 300 of which from Canada. And they're having the time of their lives on 20 different NCSY programs. I mean, rockets were falling when they were applying. And rockets may still come while they're there, but the families and the kids are literally on fire in the most positive way.
SPEAKER_02That is so amazing to hear that because it it is it's a hard thing that we went through. And we really, all of Claudia Sorrow, we all felt it. But I think back, oh my gosh, what would I do if I was in public school around that time, October 7th, and that happened. And who would I turn to, you know? And it's so amazing to have your organization that really has been able to help young people connect and to feel like they're not alone and they have a place to turn and they have people who feel the same way and accept them and have the tradition of Torah, thousands of years history with us. It's just so amazing to see the growth there and Calekovode to the work that you're doing. You should continue to be well and be blessed.
SPEAKER_03Thank you. We're working very hard to continue the very important and essential work of reaching out to uh really to every single kid, every single family. It's a big deal. It's a big deal. Um, so yeah, we're we're uh we're still there are still struggles. Um, you know, kids still still don't know who we are or don't know how to connect, and they are isolated. Um and they don't know, they don't know they have options. They're just so distant. But um, yeah, we're making inroads, that's for sure.
SPEAKER_02And you mentioned that in Canada in particular, the students are coming from Montreal and then all the way west of Vancouver. Is there anything more east yet?
SPEAKER_03Not so much. Not not in the pro not really. Um the the re the only reason for that, it's it could be a flawed strategy. It's just that there is, you know, there is resources that are quite limited. And I had a policy that any community that has 5,000 Jews or more, which means that the population will have approximately 8% of teenagers. So let's just round it up to 10%. So maybe there's 500 kids in the entire city. So how many can we really target with the resources that we have? So if the community is 5,000 or more, I felt the responsibility to go out there and uh and reach out and put somebody that. We have a person in almost every province in every city that has 5,000 Jews, just in areas that don't have that, we haven't been able to focus on that yet, just yet.
SPEAKER_02Okay. That makes sense. How is NCSY funded? Maybe
Funding NCSY And Community Impact
SPEAKER_02for some of our audience who knows about NCSY, but they aren't exactly sure of all the ins and outs and how it how it works.
SPEAKER_03Um, sure. Well, um, a percentage of of NCSY is the youth branch or arm of the Orthodox Union of the OU. So every time you buy an Oreo cookie, someone makes money in NCSY. Um so the salaries, um, like I'm an employee, let's say, of the OU, uh, and so they give us uh a certain allocation, but the vast majority, I'd say 90% of the money is raised locally in each community, each city. Um, so we we like in our region, we have to raise about six million dollars a year. Um, and every region has to do that. Every city has its own responsibilities. And it's raised by, you know, the two or three main things, which is the we do events, you know, golf tournaments and dinners and speakers. Um, and we we do personal one-on-one solicitations. And very often, especially in the last few years, we've seen people say, like, I see what's going on out there, how can I help? Those are my best friends because when you have to go ask for help, people are like, maybe they don't notice it or they're getting bombarded by other people. But I mean, I've tested this many, many times. But if I would ask most people in the Jewish world and say, tell me, list the top three challenges facing Am Israel. Tell me the top three things that face that our nation is challenged with every single day. Invariably, I'm gonna say 99%. People say the following three things, and not necessarily in this order. They'll say the safety of the Israel, assimilation intermarriage, and anti-Semitism worldwide. Well, when you invest in NCSY, you're almost saving three, you're knocking off three of those at the same time because you're sending literally thousands of kids to Israel, which begins a process of love and connection, which NCSY has a tremendous track record of not only people who visit for short time, but they translate those short times into university. A large percentage of our students go to state, go to go to Israel for school, and then they don't come back, which is an amazing thing for some. And then, you know, you're stopping anti-Semitism, or at least you're encouraging. I believe in educating about anti-Semitism, but I more believe in educating about Jewish identity. And I think actually Jewish identity is what the one of the things that stops anti-Semitism, believe it or not. We can again we can discuss it another time. Um, and of course, at uh assimilation intermarriage. I mean, no one's doing this better than us. So we're definitely stemming that tide. So yeah, so person says, I want to be involved in the crisis of Klysra and the opportunity of what's going on there in the Jewish people. Uh, NCSY is a really easy target.
SPEAKER_02Are there any educators who admire you or whom you admire?
SPEAKER_03I mean, I feel like the wrong answer is to pick one or two or five. There are just so many people who I listen to who have impacted my life over the years. Many of them are, you know, people who have helped me, you know, my earlier days and my earlier years, who gave me advice, tremendous Aitsa, who stood with me and stood by me, even when I was making all the mistakes in my 20s, and who gave me a lot of guidance. So it's not one, you know, it's not one person, not even one group in every area of my life. I have Rabanim that give me guidance in my personal life, and I have Rabbanum give me guidance in the in Ginoch and or in NCSY. And, you know, we have many people, but I don't have one row I can say, you know, has changed everything for me. I never had that. Maybe because I moved so many times. I'm not so many times. I moved from Montreal, I went to Yishima University for a few years, and I moved to Toronto. I don't have one particular person, but I I do have many people who have helped, guided me, and supported me all these years.
SPEAKER_02Going back to your role with NCSY and the fact that you mentioned you've been involved with NCSY for over 30 years. What are some big things or main things that you notice have changed over the course of those
Technology And The Attention Crisis
SPEAKER_02decades?
SPEAKER_00Oh loaded question. I know.
SPEAKER_03Well, I can think immediately my my brain went on fire here. But as I I'll start, you know, I'll start at the at the top, which I think everybody would say it's really technology. Technology is uh use the use of the phone from turning into a phone to what do they call a smartphone to really just a technological device that does everything for you. I mean, kids don't most kids don't use a phone that our generation would call phone as a phone. I mean, the last utility of it is a phone. So that is a big game changer because it's not just they have a phone, is that concentration, focus, and what they always say, you know, multitasking is so good, but I don't think so. Not when you have a phone in front of you, and I think that is a major game changer. Um person talking to a teenager or anybody with a phone in their hand, A, is is bifurcating their focus. And also if they're on their phone, well, they're I mean, even during class or teaching a shear, like I cannot speak to a group of kids if they have their phones exposed anywhere near them. I just cannot focus. I can't focus. Maybe they're doing a better job focusing, but I I don't believe that. So technology is a major, major difference. I don't think the information is getting there, just the distraction part. The second part of technology is that the influence that is hitting these kids at the most vulnerable years of their life is itself the greatest crisis. I, you know, I deal with we have a division in CSY called Sparks. That we were that's what we were talking about and that Shavuis um uh panel. And it talks about families from families that uh have maybe potential challenges with their with their kids and from Kaiden, Shabbat Shabbos and technology. And a kid today who goes to yeshiva is exposed to a hundred percent of what a kid in public school kid is exposed to. And that's frightening because when I was growing up, one of the like I went to went to high school, Hebrew Academy, whatever it was, I was Jewish education, a Torah education, and people were very homogeneous as far as as far as I didn't have access to this stuff. Like I didn't even know what that was going on. So even and and the non-religious kid probably also didn't know, but even he had more access, or if he knew more, I wasn't, I didn't know anything about it. Like I wasn't plugged in. Here, there's no such thing as hiding from celebrity lives, from I don't want to use negative words, but things that are uh, you know, very immoral on social media. It's coming from every angle, and the kids are are accessing it and they're becoming the worst part of it is they're becoming used to language, used to the lack of clothing. Again, I don't I don't want to say, I mean, they're getting used to a society that is so bereft of morality and ethics that this becomes their normal way, and that from and non-from kids are speaking language that is just not acceptable to a beautiful Jewish family. So the technology is a focus and two influence. It's a major issue. But on the positive side, uh, what's what we're seeing is also in our region specifically, we recognize that when I was in the earlier years of NCSY, and NCSY is still considered a youth organization, but you know, the parents of 30 years ago and the parents of today are really not the same parent. The parent of today, by the way, was raised also on Facebook and Instagram, and so a parent 30 years ago had a parent who was maybe much more engaged, much more traditional, Holocaust survivors
Parents Learning Alongside Their Kids
SPEAKER_03were still much more around. And so the parent of the generation knew what Yiddish Guide was, accepted it or didn't or rejected it, but they had a sense of what it looked like and what it is. Today we're finding that a lot of families, parents specifically, don't have the same education. And so when you're educating the kid, you're missing out big time when you're not also educating the parent, who's actually as hungry, sorry, more hungry than the child is is to absorb and to learn. So today we deal with this is one of the major changes in the last decade of our region, and specifically NCSY Canada does this. We run programs for parents. We have a Jewish family experience division. And in fact, I'm going to Israel on Sunday, God willing, to visit all of our students. And my wife is running something called TJJ for moms. She TJJ is the NCSY flagship trip that has actually 500 public school kids, uh, some day school kids that are in Israel right now. 500 kids, and 20 of their mothers are joining my wife on Sunday. And they're going to spend uh nine days on a birthright type trip to do chasset and also to visit their children who are having a simultaneous and parallel experience. That is a game changer, having a multi-generational educational experiences that speaks to the mother and the father and the child simultaneously. So when the kid comes back from a Shabbaton and says, That was the greatest Shabbos of my life, the kids have the parents have two reactions. They can say, Listen, that was very nice, but you know, we're we're not doing that next week. That was very nice. You had a beautiful Shabbos. Monk, we light Shabbos candles. That's not what we do around here. Or now they're saying, Well, that's so beautiful. Maybe let's spend, let's have Friday night dinner together. And together, you, me, Stephanie, we'll light Shabbos candles together because I just did it myself. That is a game changer.
SPEAKER_02That is a game changer. I think it's so important to include the parents also in the education. And like you mentioned, there are some parents who maybe didn't have the same day school upbringing, or maybe didn't even have the Jewish identity strongly embedded in them. That having this opportunity for them to be able to learn also really is eye-opening in that they can have that in a way to connect with their child, too. That they're both learning and growing in the in this area. That's really special.
SPEAKER_03Can I share a story? Is that okay? I know that's I won't even use the the say the names of the people, but the story is the following. A young girl got into got connected with NCSY about a decade ago, and she got really inspired. She went on this trip, actually, TJ J. She came back, she was on fire, she wants to learn, she wants to spend Shabbos, and she spent many, many Shabbos's in her home, Yuntives in her home, and her parents were actually very anti, very anti, and they actually pulled her back so hard that she actually never came back to NCSY again. She wanted to go to seminary, they never let her do it. Eventually, she went to university, she went out to Western, and we never really heard from her again. We found out later on that she married a non-Jew and she's doing, you know, whatever she ever's doing. Eventually, her mother actually, believe it or not, a few years later, heard about this NCSY sub mother trip mother trip to Israel. So the mother actually went on the trip. When the mother came home, she said, This is the greatest thing I ever saw in my life. I love this. And she started to come and learn. She had a younger, she had another sister, another daughter, and she begged the daughter to get involved in NCSY now. The daughter didn't want to go because she had other things in her on her in her life. But eventually, because of some scenario, her dance routine, whatever dance party, whatever it was, canceled. And she said, Okay, I'll come to one of NCSY programs. And she never left. She got involved, she became observant, she went to seminary, she became from, moved to Israel, and is married to a man who learns in colo. The parents were thrilled by that by this point, and they loved it so much that they themselves started to keep observance. They started keeping Shabbos and Yantiv and Kosher and all these different things as best as they could. When the daughter, who was pulled back from NCSY, saw that the mother and the father and now the sister were living a Torah Jewish life, she rejected, she remembered her time with NCSY a decade earlier. She said, How am I living this life? When I wanted to live that life, believe it or not, she divorced her non-Jewish husband. She is now married. She went to seminary in Israel. She is married to a man who learns in Kolo. And the non-religious parents are supporting two families uh today who live in Jerusalem and uh are learning full time.
SPEAKER_02Wow, that is an amazing story. That's a power of parents, that is powerful. So there is hope against the technology.
SPEAKER_03Yes, of course there is.
SPEAKER_02Because something, you know, we are raising young children and sometimes we just think it is very hard and to keep them focused and to keep them from not wanting to watch something or be on the phone. And we very much try to limit what they're watching and how long and everything. But it is very hard to not have it at all, first off, yeah, because we're using it for like right now, we're we're using it to use it for work and this and that. And we have family in Israel, so we're talking to them on WhatsApp and this and that. It's so it's I think the biggest challenge of our day with children is navigating the technology.
SPEAKER_03So absolutely. But you know, the greatest times that kids have today, and you can pull this out, these kids, is the four to six weeks that they go to summer camp. Summer camps do not allow phones, and the kids are thrilled. They're not missing out because everybody's not doing it. So it's amazing.
Phone Rules And Building A Shared Standard
SPEAKER_03You only have FOMO, fear of missing out when other people have it and you don't have it. But in camps, you know, so schools are now restricting it. As you see, the laws are changing in the states, and certainly it's changing in Canada under 16 and stuff like that. So you have to find the community that accepts the principles that you accept. Your friends should have families that you have should have the same thing. They should have principles that they just everybody in this group of this circle of friends cannot have a phone until they're 14, 15, whatever that is. And they're only allowed at certain hours of the day.
SPEAKER_02I think you had mentioned that actually at the panel over Shavuot, that there's some schools or some parents who get together and they say, okay, for this grade, or you know, we're gonna all join together and sign a sign something and say that we're not gonna allow our children to have access to a phone. And the there was a previous um gentleman I interviewed, Rabbi Noah Mirof, and he mentioned that too at his school in Phoenix, that a bunch of the grades the parents have gotten together and they've written a contract and an agreement, and they've said we are not gonna allow our students, our children, to have cell phones. And there's such power when you know that there are other families backing that up. Um, because we've discussed this, my husband and I, about, you know, because our kids will ask, you know, when can we get phones? When can we do this? And they see some of their cousins have phones or some of their friends have phones. And we just don't feel the need for them to have it. Our oldest is almost 10. And we've said, not now, when maybe when you're 16, we can reevaluate when you're able to pay for it and you understand the depth of having it. And we said we're doing this to protect you. And I think you had mentioned to your daughter that you were giving her an incentive for not having a phone or not being on TikTok or this. That's right.
unknownThat's right.
SPEAKER_03That's how I feel bad for your kids because you guys are great educators, so they're not going to get away with anything. But I'll tell you something. I am shocked by how parents deal with cell phones is completely different than they deal with almost anything else. Those same families, they would never move to a community where nobody was show more shabbas. The reason they want to go, they they live in a community that's kosher, Mick Vos and Schulz is because the community is also part of the solution. So if you are a person who keeps Shabbos but no one else keeps Shabbos, of course your kid's not gonna keep Shabbos. So you have to create a community of like-minded individuals who believe what you believe and are growth-oriented. So you can't tell your kid you can't use the phone and everybody else using the phone. It's just not gonna work. But you can't create an environment where nobody uses the phone or everybody uses the phone at a certain time or at a certain age or at a certain time, you know, program. It boggles my mind that parents that are not just parents, and I know parents are struggling with this, but they don't see the same thing they would do for almost any environment they don't do when it comes to technology.
SPEAKER_02It's it's very true. And it's really, it's so hard today. It's so hard. Navigating it is just very challenging.
SPEAKER_03Well, I hope they sue Mark Zuckerberg and the rest of them in court as much as they can get for creating this environment without any Ghadarim and any, you know, any there this is in court now, all this stuff that they manipulate in the brains of young people to uh people are not able to make distinctions between reality and and technology or whatever, the fake world that they live in. Yeah, it's a very big difference, very big problem.
SPEAKER_02It's very big. And and they've known for a long time that this was happening and what it's doing, and then the bullying that you know the a child never escapes it because it's now it's online, you know, it never goes away. It's just such a mess.
unknownYeah.
SPEAKER_02And the AI, like you're right. There's so much you can't tell the difference anymore of what's AI, what's not, and it's just it's not going away, right?
SPEAKER_03Technology, what's happened here is it's not going away. But I've noticed in the last few months that there has been legislation passed in many countries, many cities, where they're not allowing kids under a certain age to have access to social media, and schools are actually limiting phones, and actually the kids own computer. Schools are now supported. Computers because they want to limit, because kids have figured kids are very smart, obviously, you know, they're very smart. Whatever you can do, they can do better. Um, and they, you know, if you took away the cell phone, so they figured out how to use their computers to get access whatever they need. So, but Nuskells are getting onto that. So that's amazing. So, but I mean, that's not going to stop. The problem with that, of course, is that there's this desire among kids to just have access to information that their friend has. So if nobody has the access to information, so that kid's life is much more calm and the family's calmer. But if somebody has that information, so everybody, you know, and you go to school the next day, and if they did you see that, did you hear about that? Did you watch that video? Did you see that concert? Did you listen to that song? And the kid, they weren't plugged in, that kid feels like a second-class citizen. And so they're going to do everything they can to access that same information. Uh, what's happening very often in families is that even if the parent says to the nine-year-old, you cannot have a cell phone yet, you cannot be on social media. If there's a 14-year-old in the house, it's a direct connection to the same stuff the parents desperately trying to keep the kid away from.
SPEAKER_00So right.
SPEAKER_03So I'm I'm not sure if you're familiar with it. I mean, people are familiar with this. If they're not yet familiar with this, if they haven't hopped and they haven't caught on to what is going on in their own home, when your child is in their room alone, um, they are not doing crossword puzzles. Just to remind everybody out there that this is what they're doing. And they're doing it on Chabbis, and they're doing it on Yuntiv's. Kids do not sleep three to four hours on Chavez exclusively on Chabbus afternoons or months each, you know, go out from the dinner table and run to their rooms to sleep. They are very often, not everybody, God forbid, but uh large percentage of kids today, unfortunately, even on Shabbos, are communicating or using their phones uh to watch movies, to, you know, whatever it is. So, what can parents do? This is a big issue. Number one, parents need to be role models to their children. You you cannot ask your kid to be off social media when you're not on off social media. You cannot ask your kid to not have a phone at the table when you're on the phone at the table. You cannot ask your kid to not grab the phone the first 10 seconds as they wake up if that's the same thing you do when you wake up. The first thing most human beings do is check their phones. If you don't do that, uh and share that with your children. So maybe they won't do that. But if you do do that, it's very hard to argue with your child. Hey, you know, you have controls. I'm an adult, you know, I'm okay. You're not okay. I'm not sure if that's true. So we're all pretty much addicted to this stuff.
SPEAKER_00So we are.
SPEAKER_03Yeah. So big problem. So I I think part of it is being truthful and honest about it, that it is an addictive device and it's designed to be addictive, like it's using your humanity against yourself, right? Every the dopamine hit, the dopamine hit. We've all learned about that. So I think what people have to do is first of all be honest and recognize it for what it is, and then try to come to some terms with your children, with yourself. You know, yeah, two hours a day, one hour a day, you know, only these sites have filters. I mean, uh parents without that have the kids have a phone without any filter whatsoever, is literally bringing in the schmutz of the planet into your home. You know, it's just a shocking, it's shocking that um either they don't know, they don't care, or they're totally okay with it, which I don't know which one is the worst crime, honestly. So um, so I think that's what parents have to do. Come some to come to realization that it is a problem, kid has access, limit the access, limit the time, try to have family time where there's no phone around or distractions. These are very important things, they're basic today. It's like talking to if I told this, if I had told this to my parents, like, you know, like how let's have dinner together without a phone, they go, What do you mean? What phone? What are you talking about? The phone was hanging on the wall with a rope, and you know, if it didn't ring, you weren't on the phone, you know, they they wouldn't relate to this. But today it's a completely different thing. I know as I'm rambling on, but that that major technology is a major issue. But on the other hand, on the other hand, on the other hand, right? Technology is an incredible asset. You know, you can learn Tauron technology and using technology right away. I'm not sure if that's where you were going with this, but there is tremendous amount of benefits.
SPEAKER_02That's what I was gonna go, actually. Yeah, yeah.
SPEAKER_03I mean, there's tremendous amount of benefits also using technology to say it's Usser Legombray, you know, like that's wrong, also. It's not user. It's just like everything else. There's schmutz out there and there's gutless and beauty out there. And the, you know, discerning person has to come to terms with who they are, what they're trying to become, what they want to do, what they want to let inside their brains, uh, through their, you know, through their eyes, and and take the best things possible and remove all the uh the schmutz, the garbage. But a parent has to use that also, use technology to teach, to learn, to explore, to, you know, you I always my line all the time is that you don't have to be dumb for very long anymore. You know, and somebody asks you a question in 10 seconds. I I I mean, I can have 50 answers to that question. I uh you know, you take a picture of something. I was just away, whatever, in Central America and Costa Rica. I took a picture of something and it tells you the tree, the fruit of the tree, you know, where how do you, you know, what kind of drink you could use from it, or what you could eat from it? It's amazing today. So technology is fantastic if you use it to its uh greatest height.
SPEAKER_02It's so true. Uh and going off of that, how can we help our children and our students realize some of the dangers and the pitfalls that can come from the use of technology if you if used in a bad way or wrong way?
SPEAKER_03Well, first of all, I think kids actually, as you probably know, and many, many of you listening know this, that camps are really amazing, overnight camps, particularly no telephone zone, uh, where they don't have phones um almost the entire summer. Like if you go for three to four, five, six weeks, no phone. You could only use a camp line to visit, you know, to call your parents once a week, whatever for Shabbos. Uh, and these are secular camps to religious camps, no phone. And I can tell you for a fact that the kids are the happiest they've ever been over the course of the year. They kids know how poisonous this is to them. And yet they are not capable of resisting the pressure, that it's really a pure almost a peer pressure factor of information gathering and and being part of looped in, you know, uh fear of missing out, FOMO, and all that. They're just so kids, you know, kids know that they don't want this, but until until the structures of society, the religious Jewish structures or secular structures get out there and say, this is you, you cannot have a phone until you are your brain is somewhat developed, which I'm not even sure now what age that is. That could be 35 at this point. I don't really know. I know I'm joking. But if it's you know 14, 13, 12, I don't know, nobody should have a cell phone until they hit high school. Nobody in your society, no one in your friends' circle, nobody. And so that's the the the kids will thank you for it. I have I know there are studies about this, and I've seen this in my own life, that kids whose parents do not sanction them, do not what's the right word, come down on them when they do something wrong, do not argue with them, do not scream at them sometimes, do not have rules and regulations. Those kids are upset at their parents for not giving them guidance when they needed it most at the time when they needed it most in their youth. But and when they're yelling at when you're telling your kid, hey, you can't do this, you can't do it, they're very upset. But what 10 years later, thank you, mom, thank you, dad, for what you did for me because I I know my friends that didn't have that kind of parenting, they're a mess today. They're maybe off the derich. They're not, you know, their their minds are shot, they're on whatever they're doing. You were more restrictive, but you also gave me guidance, and I had a focus of what it was life was supposed to be, and you helped me get there. Kids are desperate for direction, and they're desperate for your parents to be parent and parent them in the way they need to be. For that.
SPEAKER_02It's and I feel like it ties in with the Pasuk from Ishlay, chapter 22, verse six, right? Kanochlana R Alpidako, Gamki Yafkim Loya Sor Mimana. And that we're leading them on their path. And how does that apply for you and the work that you do?
SPEAKER_03Which part? Because uh yelling at parents, we do that all day long. Um, what what what part do you mean? Me specific hanochlana. I mean, I mean,
Helping Teens Through Their Hardest Years
SPEAKER_03that's in youth work. What we're trained is to see the potential of each one of these kids. We do not see the kid for usually my I also share this with many. Yeah, we usually NC Swy, we usually see kids at the worst part of their lives.
SPEAKER_01I see.
SPEAKER_03Adolescent is the worst part very often for many kids, very difficult, very challenging. That they're not comfortable in who they are, they're not comfortable in their own skin, they're not comfortable yet, they don't know who they are. And so we're watching that, you know, from the time they're 11, 12 till they're 16, 17, and we're watching this incredible, you know, light develop. Um, and the kid themselves don't even realize, you know, what they, you know, who they are, what they're gonna be one day. But that's the training that those of us who are in Kirou over in Genoch, we're able to see beyond the surface there. So yeah, we see a kid, we give them a lot of love and attention, and we give them uh hope. Uh hope that don't worry, uh that you know what maybe what you're going through now is pretty stinky, but um don't worry. You're you're gonna you're gonna get through this. We're gonna get through this together. Uh, it could be anti-Semitism, it could be uh choices of friends, it could be a break, a breakup with a boyfriend or girlfriend, it could be parenting issues. We're there for kids. I mean, in every single scenario you can think of, uh NCSY is dealing with that with these kids, because it's not just the Nishama we deal with, we deal with the the whole the goof, you know, the person itself. So we we look to that kid and say, okay, what does this kid need today? What does this kid need from me today? And so most of the time it's um it's uh um a listening ear, uh, and a heart that's open and uh at a place where they can feel safe and be themselves. That's a big, big deal. It's a small deal out there, maybe, but it is a very big deal. If kids come back and say, This is this is what saved my life, this place, this Shabbaton, this person, that we hear that. That's what keeps people like myself for 35 years coming back. Is that to work for NGS Y, let's say, is that you hear that every day of your life, which is a very powerful thing.
SPEAKER_02That is powerful. And like you had mentioned, it's a tough period, you know, they're changing hormones and all these things. And I also just feel like the climate that we're living in today is I know every generation has their struggles, but sometimes it seems like some of the things we're going through are just so difficult. And we see the rise in anti-Semitism and this and that, and it I feel for these kids post-October 7th and dealing with that, and some of them going to public school and feeling like, wow, I had friends, all of a sudden it just shifted. And CSY, it meets such a need and gives them that community that I'm sure they just really meets that core of who they are and helps them.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, more. I mean, we we didn't realize that, you know, until you know, until the world shifted, uh, we didn't realize that's really part of what the organization is all about. It wasn't really fighting anti-Semitism. Um, that's that wasn't really the thing. Um uh, but today, uh I can't say we fight anti-Semitism, but one way we fight anti-Semitism is by giving these kids a sense of belonging and who they are, because they're starting to they're starting to believe the narrative. You know, you are a murderer, you are killed a child killer, you are the pariah of society. You these are the things that these kids who are, you know, not in, let's say, in the Jewish core of the Jewish community, they're on their peripheries or their public schools, whatever. When they start hearing this over and over again, they're the one there was uh there was a boy that came to a Shabbaton and he was wearing a cross, um, jewelry cross. And I said, What's uh what's with the jewelry? She goes, What are you talking about? He's wearing a cross. I said, Yeah, I know, but you don't have to wear, I mean, like you're this is a NCSY event. You you register for a Jewish, Jewish, you know, Jewish poor environment. What's with the cross? He goes, What do you mean? This is what this is my jewelry. I all my friends wear this. This is what we wear. So like I am sensitive to that. I didn't tell him to take it off. Um, I just I just realized what are we dealing with over here when they're starting to hear, you know, you're not you're not with them, you're with us. Us is like, we're the Catholics, we're the Muslims, we're the, you know, you're you're no longer with us, with them, you're with us. Uh so that's what we started to deal with on October 8th, which was, yeah, you're don't listen to that garbage. We, there's a whole other world over here. You may not have plugged into Judaism before, but we are right here for you. Just turn the corner. There's a room in your school called the Jewish Student Union. And in that room, in that club after school or during lunch, there are 30 kids, 40 kids, 50 kids just like you, who are plugged into the Jewish world and who weren't plugged in on October 6th. But that's what we've been doing, you know, everywhere. It's 400, 500 Jewish clubs today. I think 150, 175 of them open since October 7th, which is an amazing thing. Opened by kids, by the way. Who I made to mention this, kids themselves are asking us, can you please? Our friend has a thing down the street. Can you open a Jewish club?
SPEAKER_00That's amazing.
SPEAKER_03It is something very unique. Again, we didn't, I don't think anybody thought about that until this wasn't really uh this wasn't kind of the response that NCSY does. We really do Jewish identity, but this is also this is a response of Jewish identity, is you're gonna have to teach this kid who they really are.
SPEAKER_02Sure. Wow, that just uh I like uh goosebumps there, just um hearing that it's it's such incredible work that you do with NCSY and you know how Shen should continue to bless you to keep it up and um it's really amazing. Uh just uh one last question.
What Jewish Education Must Become
SPEAKER_02What do you think successful Jewish education will look like in the future? Or what do you think we ought to do as educators and parents to make Jewish education continue to be successful?
SPEAKER_03Wow, that's a great question. I I think the idea, we see this in many areas. The idea of mass education, I think it's uh uh, you know, yesterday's theory of education, 30 kids in a room hoping for the best. I I think that's probably that that's gonna need to change a little bit. I know that's incredibly expensive, almost impossible to pull off.
SPEAKER_00And a little controversial now.
SPEAKER_03What's that?
SPEAKER_00And a little controversial.
SPEAKER_03And controversial? Good. Okay. Uh, I think the problem was is that it's not really speaking to the masses anymore. I think what's happened is that the kids are not sort of I think maybe when you're sitting in a classroom 30 years ago and you listen to the teacher, so the teacher was informative and you got everything you needed from this one person. That's not the that's not true anymore. So the the smartest kid person in the room is not often the teacher anymore. Um, and so the the the classroom has to flip in some way. I I'm not sure exactly. There's that con academy where you study beforehand, you know, I'm familiar with that. You study beforehand and you come to class with the answers already, and then you discuss what you learned. There's things like that. We've actually attempted this a little bit in NCSY where we flip the classroom a little bit, try to learn beforehand, prepare in advance and come. Yeah, there are ways to do that. I think that's that's one area I would I would look at. Uh I think another area is also, I mean, if we're talking about Jewish school system, I think what's happened here is that the the the the the not the context, but the text in which we learnt when I was a kid, Homesh Navi, Halacha, whatever that is, very relevant, very important. You have to learn all that stuff for sure. But I think today, halakhalamaisa, much more practical. What does Torah mean to me now in my life today? It might not have been as uh a burning desire in those days. It may not have mattered maybe 30 years ago, but today, why does that matter? Like, why, why don't I, why, why don't I, why can't I eat a Burger King? I need to know what that is. Like, what's the problem with that? And don't tell me because pig makes you live less years, uh, that which for some reason people believe. Like, it's not true. Jews do not live longer because we do not eat chazer. In fact, we probably die sooner because we eat cholent. Um, but but I I think I think they have we'd have to review a little bit of how we deliver the Torah, halakhalamaisa, to to that actually practically this is what it looks like. Not an ox goring an ox, but a car hitting a car. Um, that kind of language, I'm sure it's I'm sure it's being done out there. And I think those who do it like that probably a lot more success with their kids, making it very, very practical. How does this mean what does this mean to me is today's modern language? I think that Torah can do that. Uh it's not a Torah, it's the educators have to realize they have to pivot the language to be relevant to kids today. I think that's a very important, important addition today. I think I probably could think of a few more, but I'm I think I've outdone my uh my welcome here. Okay.
SPEAKER_02It is. Um, it's very important and how to apply it. And I I I do see that uh our generation, the kids today are wanting to know why and how does this, how is this relevant for me? You know, why should I learn this? And so I think that's critical of what you said and how we can approach it in our Jewish schools and to help kids stay connected. And um, I actually interviewed uh someone recently, and he was saying that he lives in Israel and he's noticing a huge drop-off of kids, especially once they reach high school, because of technology and all these things. Some of them just figure why do I have to sit in school and learn this all day when I can learn in my own time and and I can use the internet or whatever, and then I can work a business or do other things on the side, and that my time is much more useful.
SPEAKER_03And everything could be and Gemini could be summarized for you in uh six lines, and you don't have to read the book. You can get the entire Coles be Cole's notes now. That's a joke. You're not gonna use Cole's notes or Cliff Notes, that's never gonna happen again.
SPEAKER_02Isn't that crazy? It's crazy. It's crazy.
SPEAKER_03But I I'll leave it with one last thing. I yeah, I I you know, it used to be that there used to be conversations with with teenagers, young adults, that, you know, I'm not gonna be religious, I'm not gonna believe in you know your religion, our religion, because I I can't I can't understand how it's possible that God, your God, can kill six million Jews during the Holocaust. Like I I can't I can't square that in my mind, and therefore, and because of that, I cannot be a religious person. Now, I never I don't understand that argument. I I've had that argument or discussions with countless people. Uh, it's usually just an excuse for everything, you know, where was God in the Holocaust is an excuse for me to eat uh, you know, at the McDonald's. I mean that had nothing to do with nothing, but that's what they do. The the what the what's happening today is that nobody even cares about the question. And others, nobody is saying, where is that God? It's not even a topic of conversation. Uh the Holocaust is I I don't it's not definitely not irrelevant, but it is not as relevant as it ever has been uh to the young generation. They're not looking back like that. They've got their own problems. 75 years ago is you know, 10 lifetimes ago. Um, and no one's asking these questions. There's there's no debate anymore. Even if the debate was insane, the there was no no one is talking about these things anymore because they're not seeing Yiddish guite as an irrelevant as God, Yiddishkite as relevant. Judaism is relevant to their day-to-day. So they're not they're not grappling with the questions that they used to grapple with. I haven't heard the question about like, you know, where was God in the Holocaust, and therefore, you know, I'm not gonna be religious or believe in anything. I haven't heard that in a decade. More. Because they don't, no one's no one's even like at least it was a discussion. You could talk about God. God was in the conversation. Now it's it's almost gone. So making Torah relevant, Judaism relevant, bringing God back into the equation. Those are the things I would do the most.
SPEAKER_02Thank you, Rabbi Black, so much. I really do appreciate you taking the time. I know you got a busy schedule.
SPEAKER_03And my pleasure. Absolutely. I look forward to hearing this on uh on your podcast.
SPEAKER_02All right, take care, and all the best. Almost uh Khadesh Tovelu here.
SPEAKER_03That's it. Yeah. Oh my gosh, that's true. Yes, yes.
SPEAKER_02Wild. The time just goes.
SPEAKER_03Absolutely. And it's also early this year, so it doesn't help.
SPEAKER_02But yeah, it is true. All right, take care.
SPEAKER_03Thank you. Take care, bye.