Ep124: Heels, Health, and HR Headaches - The Dress Code Lawsuit Every Employer Should Know

HR Stories Podcast - A Lesson in Every Story!

HR Stories Podcast - A Lesson in Every Story!
Ep124: Heels, Health, and HR Headaches - The Dress Code Lawsuit Every Employer Should Know
May 06, 2025 Episode 124
John Thalheimer, MS Org Leadership and Chuck Simikian, SPHR, SHRM-SCP

Send us a text

What happens when a company's dress code walks straight into a lawsuit? In this eye-opening episode, Chuck and John unpack the real-life legal battle between a cocktail server and MGM National Harbor over mandatory high heels, disability discrimination, and a rigid appearance policy.

This isn’t just about shoes. It’s a cautionary tale for HR professionals and small business owners alike. We break down the legal pitfalls of gendered dress codes, the requirements of the ADA, and the importance of honoring medical accommodations. With real court rulings, evolving workplace fashion trends, and clear HR compliance tips, this episode will help you audit your dress code policies, avoid discrimination claims, and stay ahead of costly employment law violations.

The team also touches on the following topics and more:

  • Poorly formatted resumes can be the death of your job application
  • There’s an apparent lack of will to work - how to make sure you’re creating an environment that people want to work in and, more importantly, stay in!
  • The difficulty of pushing unpopular HR policies and the rise of HR being forced to push policies they don’t agree with.

Visit TeamAtHRStories.com to see all of our workshops and offerings to help you feel confident in your HR decisions. 

Support the show

Our new book...The Ultimate Guide to HR: Checklists Edition is now AVAILABLE!

Go to
UltimateGuidetoHR.com to Get HR Right: and Avoid Costly Mistakes. Certified and approved for 3 SHRM Recertification Credits.

Join the HR Team of One Community on Facebook or visit TeamAtHRstories.com and sign up for emails so you can be the first to know about new things we have coming up.

You can also follow us on Instagram and TikTok at @HRstoriesPodcast

Don't forget to rate our podcast, it really helps other people find it!

Do you have a situation or topic you’d like the team to discuss? Are you interested in having Chuck or John talk to your team or Emcee your event? You can reach the Team at Email@TeamAtHRStories.com for suggestions and inquiries.

The viewpoints expressed by the characters in the stories are not necessarily that of The Team at HR Stories. The stories are shared to present various, real-world scenarios and share how they were handled by policy and, at times, law. Chuck and John are not lawyers and always recommend working with an employment lawyer to address concerns.

Episode Artwork Ep124: Heels, Health, and HR Headaches - The Dress Code Lawsuit Every Employer Should Know 39:17 Episode Artwork Ep123: Q&A - Smelly Lunch and Consistent Callouts 20:26 Episode Artwork Ep122: Burnout, Stress & Leadership – What HR Needs to Hear Right Now 43:12 Episode Artwork Ep121: Q&A - Retaliation against HR, demotion compensation, and mixed employment 16:55 Episode Artwork Ep120: Updates from the EEOC - Lawful DEI in the Trump Era 46:50 Episode Artwork Ep119: Q&A - The Nitty Gritty of Overtime 17:45 Episode Artwork Ep118: Pay Discrimination & Retaliation - How to Avoid Costly Mistakes 32:06 Episode Artwork Ep117: Q&A - Medical Disclosures & Unauthorized Charges 23:38 Episode Artwork Ep116: HR on Trial - The Importance of Good Record Keeping 44:26 Episode Artwork Ep115: Listener Q&A - We Answer Your Questions: When HR gets messy and complicated 25:16 Episode Artwork Ep114: Beating the Challenges of Being a CHRO 43:39 Episode Artwork Ep113: Listener Q&A - We Answer Your Questions: Life & Death - Acknowledging Key Life Moments 22:34 Episode Artwork Ep112: Perceived Bias and Promotion Troubles - Keeping Hiring Legal & Clear 42:01 Episode Artwork EP111: Listener Q&A - We Answer Your Questions: Working without paperwork, Layoff Difficulty, and Passive Aggression 27:28 Episode Artwork Ep110: Remote Work Legal Complexity - State Laws vs Company Location 51:05 Episode Artwork Ep109: Listener Q&A - We Answer Your Questions: Employee Statuses and Preparing for the Next Role 27:50 Episode Artwork Ep108: Trump's HR Impacts - What to Expect From the Next Administration 32:17 Episode Artwork Ep107: The LIVE Edition! How These Checklists Can Improve Your 2025 & Beyond 53:04 Episode Artwork Ep106: When Audits Come Knocking - Start 2025 On The Right Foot 40:49 Episode Artwork Ep105: 2024 Top 10 Q&A! 51:44 Episode Artwork Ep104: From the Holiday Vault - Revisiting the Poor Working Conditions of the North Pole 22:25 Episode Artwork Ep103: Grandma Got Fired, Not Retired - How Trader Joe's learned that Niceness can Backfire 53:27 Episode Artwork Ep102: Listener Q&A - We Answer Your Questions: After Hours Tasks and Getting Fired on Leave 20:00 Episode Artwork Ep101: Questions and Lessons from the News - Topics You'll Give a Hoot About 48:45 Episode Artwork Ep100: The Big 100 - HR Stories Podcast Celebrates 100 Episodes 48:27