Revolution 250 Podcast
Revolution 250 Podcast
Moral Capital: Foundations of British Abolitionism with Christopher L. Brown
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Why did an antislavery movement emerge at the time of the American Revolution, both in the American colonies and in Britain? Christopher Brown asks this question and many more in Moral Capital: Foundations of British Abolitionism. The American Revolution on both sides of the Atlantic brought together strands of thought and feeling which had been latent, as men and women grappled with questions of power and justice. Abolition was one way for Britons to restore their moral capital, and drew on many sources—economic, moral, religious. In a fascinating study Christopher Brown upends much of what we thought we knew about the antislavery movement, and allows us to see the 18th-century world with fresh eyes.
WEBVTT
00:00:00.981 --> 00:00:01.921
Good morning, everyone.
00:00:01.962 --> 00:00:03.523
Welcome to the Revolution Two-Fifty
00:00:03.563 --> 00:00:04.144
podcast.
00:00:04.184 --> 00:00:05.004
I'm Bob Allison.
00:00:05.065 --> 00:00:07.767
I chair the Rev Two-Fifty advisory group.
00:00:07.786 --> 00:00:09.788
We're a consortium of about seventy five
00:00:09.808 --> 00:00:11.429
groups in Massachusetts planning
00:00:11.449 --> 00:00:12.971
commemorations of the beginnings of
00:00:13.051 --> 00:00:14.413
American independence.
00:00:14.432 --> 00:00:16.795
And our guest today is Christopher Leslie
00:00:16.815 --> 00:00:17.175
Brown,
00:00:17.216 --> 00:00:19.216
who is a professor of history at Columbia
00:00:19.297 --> 00:00:22.500
University and the author of Moral Capital
00:00:22.780 --> 00:00:24.661
Foundations of British Abolitionism.
00:00:24.681 --> 00:00:26.044
So, Chris, thanks so much for joining us.
00:00:27.001 --> 00:00:29.060
It's so great to be here and to
00:00:29.080 --> 00:00:30.902
be in conversation with you, Bob.
00:00:30.922 --> 00:00:31.242
Thank you.
00:00:31.262 --> 00:00:32.182
You'll have to forgive me.
00:00:32.241 --> 00:00:33.201
I'm in New York City.
00:00:34.442 --> 00:00:36.862
It means that there's street noise
00:00:36.902 --> 00:00:37.423
sometimes.
00:00:37.463 --> 00:00:39.203
So the ambulance went by.
00:00:39.722 --> 00:00:39.823
OK.
00:00:39.843 --> 00:00:41.103
Great to be here.
00:00:41.122 --> 00:00:43.384
Good to have you.
00:00:43.884 --> 00:00:45.944
And your book really addresses one of
00:00:45.963 --> 00:00:48.604
these great questions that we have the
00:00:48.625 --> 00:00:50.384
British Empire taking control, really,
00:00:50.445 --> 00:00:52.265
of the transatlantic slave trade in the
00:00:52.325 --> 00:00:55.585
eighteenth century and also an anti-slave
00:01:02.841 --> 00:01:05.152
and what provokes it and why in the
00:01:05.191 --> 00:01:06.156
seventeen eighties.
00:01:18.430 --> 00:01:20.490
Why The Seventeen Agents?
00:01:20.510 --> 00:01:20.811
Yeah,
00:01:21.331 --> 00:01:24.751
so it's the puzzle that the book is
00:01:25.231 --> 00:01:26.352
trying to solve.
00:01:26.492 --> 00:01:28.533
And I think I just want to take
00:01:28.772 --> 00:01:32.894
one step backwards and just explain why
00:01:32.974 --> 00:01:37.915
this felt like something to write about.
00:01:37.956 --> 00:01:39.256
I think a lot of us have in
00:01:39.316 --> 00:01:40.637
our own experience
00:01:41.507 --> 00:01:43.810
that kind of tension between the things
00:01:43.850 --> 00:01:46.533
that we believe in and what we do.
00:01:48.075 --> 00:01:50.576
And there's all kinds of ways that we
00:01:50.617 --> 00:01:53.459
have kind of commitments to ideals in the
00:01:53.561 --> 00:01:54.221
abstract,
00:01:54.281 --> 00:01:55.822
but then when we're challenged in our
00:01:55.862 --> 00:01:56.524
daily lives,
00:01:56.563 --> 00:02:00.007
it's kind of how we sort of respond
00:02:00.027 --> 00:02:00.487
to those.
00:02:01.743 --> 00:02:02.805
respond to those challenges.
00:02:02.844 --> 00:02:06.248
So the whole book in some ways pivots
00:02:06.328 --> 00:02:07.188
on the problem,
00:02:07.289 --> 00:02:10.251
the distance between our moral sentiments
00:02:10.270 --> 00:02:11.312
and moral actions.
00:02:11.611 --> 00:02:13.894
And there was nothing especially,
00:02:14.674 --> 00:02:18.758
it doesn't take a lot of great insight
00:02:18.858 --> 00:02:22.099
to realize that holding people in slavery
00:02:22.159 --> 00:02:22.860
is wrong.
00:02:23.901 --> 00:02:27.123
But the benefits, individual benefits,
00:02:27.365 --> 00:02:28.164
national benefits,
00:02:28.185 --> 00:02:30.206
and imperial benefits were so substantial
00:02:31.118 --> 00:02:34.200
that it was very easy for people in
00:02:34.260 --> 00:02:35.461
Britain to overlook.
00:02:35.501 --> 00:02:36.762
So a lot of the project,
00:02:37.042 --> 00:02:38.883
the book was about trying to make sense
00:02:38.923 --> 00:02:43.585
of how that gap gets closed between moral
00:02:43.685 --> 00:02:45.906
sentiment and moral action.
00:02:46.846 --> 00:02:51.487
And basically it happens right in this
00:02:51.608 --> 00:02:52.027
moment,
00:02:52.168 --> 00:02:54.188
in the immediate aftermath of the American
00:02:54.229 --> 00:02:54.889
Revolution.
00:02:54.930 --> 00:02:57.570
And I really think that...
00:02:58.655 --> 00:03:02.616
part of the change is the ways that
00:03:04.096 --> 00:03:05.776
the relationship to slavery gets
00:03:05.836 --> 00:03:08.477
politicized in ways that it had never been
00:03:08.516 --> 00:03:09.016
before.
00:03:10.537 --> 00:03:15.518
The patriots on one side saying, you know,
00:03:15.538 --> 00:03:17.937
Britain is a nation of slave traders.
00:03:19.098 --> 00:03:21.158
And this is part of the, you know,
00:03:21.199 --> 00:03:24.019
we're engaged in a drive for liberty.
00:03:25.699 --> 00:03:27.039
And then on the other side, you know,
00:03:27.219 --> 00:03:27.560
British,
00:03:29.479 --> 00:03:32.421
opinion makers and politicians saying
00:03:32.861 --> 00:03:34.823
American slaveholders do not have a right
00:03:34.864 --> 00:03:38.346
to the kind of freedom they're aspiring
00:03:38.406 --> 00:03:38.566
to.
00:03:38.586 --> 00:03:39.347
So it's just,
00:03:39.387 --> 00:03:41.228
it's that particular kind of moment of
00:03:41.288 --> 00:03:45.372
crisis that brings the issue forward in a
00:03:45.431 --> 00:03:47.652
way that was really unprecedented.
00:03:47.793 --> 00:03:49.175
Right, right.
00:03:49.194 --> 00:03:50.855
You do say that the revolution offers up
00:03:50.996 --> 00:03:52.796
identifiable villains for each side.
00:03:52.817 --> 00:03:53.337
That's right.
00:03:55.399 --> 00:03:55.879
That's right.
00:03:56.985 --> 00:03:59.850
Yeah, so it's, I don't know.
00:03:59.871 --> 00:04:00.471
I mean,
00:04:00.651 --> 00:04:02.594
the way the world that we live in
00:04:02.694 --> 00:04:03.115
now,
00:04:04.479 --> 00:04:04.639
You know,
00:04:04.658 --> 00:04:06.139
we live in a world where there's a
00:04:06.199 --> 00:04:07.960
kind of an anti-slavery consensus.
00:04:07.979 --> 00:04:10.420
You will not find anyone anywhere making a
00:04:10.501 --> 00:04:12.521
positive argument for why slavery is a
00:04:12.562 --> 00:04:13.042
good thing.
00:04:13.081 --> 00:04:14.962
And we know that human trafficking exists
00:04:14.983 --> 00:04:16.343
in all kinds of different ways.
00:04:17.062 --> 00:04:18.283
But it's illegal, it's illicit,
00:04:18.363 --> 00:04:19.223
it's underground.
00:04:20.904 --> 00:04:24.946
And that sense that being invested in
00:04:25.026 --> 00:04:29.927
slavery is a sign of, you know,
00:04:29.987 --> 00:04:30.987
is stigmatized.
00:04:31.408 --> 00:04:33.629
is something to be embarrassed about or to
00:04:33.689 --> 00:04:35.209
try to explain or defend away,
00:04:35.249 --> 00:04:37.629
that's a direct consequence of the
00:04:37.670 --> 00:04:39.569
politics of the American Revolution.
00:04:40.930 --> 00:04:42.130
So yeah,
00:04:42.151 --> 00:04:43.870
it really is the seventeen seventies and
00:04:43.891 --> 00:04:46.052
seventeen eighties that it kind of comes
00:04:46.091 --> 00:04:48.273
to fruition.
00:04:48.312 --> 00:04:49.872
So why is this?
00:04:49.932 --> 00:04:51.132
I mean, I was telling you earlier,
00:04:51.153 --> 00:04:52.793
I had this experience taking a group of
00:04:52.834 --> 00:04:54.793
students to the Shirley Eustace House in
00:04:54.834 --> 00:04:55.475
Roxbury,
00:04:55.495 --> 00:04:56.975
home of the British royal governor,
00:04:57.014 --> 00:04:57.754
William Shirley.
00:04:57.834 --> 00:04:57.975
Yeah.
00:04:58.074 --> 00:04:59.055
You came here,
00:04:59.076 --> 00:05:00.755
you met with liveried servants,
00:05:07.483 --> 00:05:09.324
the British were abolitionists.
00:05:09.363 --> 00:05:09.483
Well,
00:05:09.504 --> 00:05:10.584
that's what the British wanted you to
00:05:10.624 --> 00:05:11.324
think too.
00:05:12.204 --> 00:05:13.944
That's right.
00:05:14.745 --> 00:05:18.047
There's that great line from somewhere in
00:05:18.127 --> 00:05:20.608
Eric Williams' work where he writes,
00:05:21.247 --> 00:05:22.769
you get the sense from the way the
00:05:22.788 --> 00:05:24.548
British talked about the subject that they
00:05:24.608 --> 00:05:27.209
had invented slavery so they could have
00:05:27.250 --> 00:05:30.911
the pleasure of abolishing it.
00:05:31.632 --> 00:05:32.492
For so long,
00:05:32.531 --> 00:05:35.913
the story about Britain and slavery was
00:05:35.954 --> 00:05:36.394
about
00:05:37.059 --> 00:05:39.579
the singularity of the British
00:05:39.660 --> 00:05:41.100
anti-slavery movement,
00:05:42.160 --> 00:05:44.221
the leadership and the suppression of the
00:05:44.261 --> 00:05:45.581
Atlantic slave trade,
00:05:46.822 --> 00:05:50.562
the choice that Parliament made in the
00:05:50.682 --> 00:05:54.264
year to pay out twenty million pounds to
00:05:54.824 --> 00:05:57.108
emancipate so all of that became a kind
00:05:57.127 --> 00:05:59.492
of story about britain's national identity
00:05:59.932 --> 00:06:01.394
and one that's come you know that come
00:06:01.514 --> 00:06:03.939
right down until you know relatively
00:06:03.978 --> 00:06:05.682
recent years so the students are not it's
00:06:05.742 --> 00:06:07.324
not surprising they would have that yeah
00:06:07.425 --> 00:06:07.644
yeah
00:06:24.872 --> 00:06:28.134
really do a good job of delimiting who
00:06:28.173 --> 00:06:31.315
he was and what his objective was in
00:06:31.355 --> 00:06:33.396
starting to attack slavery.
00:06:34.237 --> 00:06:34.557
Yeah.
00:06:35.218 --> 00:06:36.439
Yeah, Granville Sharp is a,
00:06:37.298 --> 00:06:41.901
he's a really eccentric character and very
00:06:41.982 --> 00:06:42.581
singular.
00:06:43.283 --> 00:06:43.822
You know,
00:06:43.843 --> 00:06:46.163
he's a kind of government bureaucrat.
00:06:46.244 --> 00:06:47.805
He worked at the Board of Ordinance of
00:06:47.865 --> 00:06:48.605
all places,
00:06:48.625 --> 00:06:50.447
which is responsible for munitions.
00:06:52.216 --> 00:06:53.877
But he was also the grandson of an
00:06:54.538 --> 00:06:57.860
archbishop and part of a very large
00:06:58.980 --> 00:06:59.519
family,
00:07:00.100 --> 00:07:01.740
well-placed in the Church of England,
00:07:03.201 --> 00:07:05.603
and had a kind of a really unusual
00:07:07.084 --> 00:07:09.124
sense of, I mean,
00:07:09.163 --> 00:07:10.944
everyone has a sense of right and wrong,
00:07:10.985 --> 00:07:13.206
but he has a very profound sense of,
00:07:13.706 --> 00:07:15.406
in his own individual life,
00:07:18.088 --> 00:07:20.750
very easy to get prompted by things that
00:07:20.769 --> 00:07:21.971
he felt were unjust.
00:07:21.990 --> 00:07:26.353
So he single-handedly tries to raise the
00:07:26.394 --> 00:07:28.696
question of whether slaveholding itself in
00:07:28.795 --> 00:07:29.656
England is legal.
00:07:30.658 --> 00:07:32.098
Some folks will know about that as the
00:07:32.158 --> 00:07:33.139
Somerset case.
00:07:33.860 --> 00:07:36.461
And then he uses that platform then to
00:07:36.562 --> 00:07:38.182
raise the broader question of whether
00:07:38.242 --> 00:07:39.584
slavery in the British Empire,
00:07:40.845 --> 00:07:41.805
if not legal,
00:07:43.848 --> 00:07:45.829
Whether it's moral, whether it's ethical,
00:07:45.889 --> 00:07:49.213
whether it helps explain the problems that
00:07:49.233 --> 00:07:51.675
the empire was experiencing.
00:07:51.757 --> 00:07:53.077
So in some ways,
00:07:54.019 --> 00:07:56.221
the anti-slavery movement in England
00:07:56.302 --> 00:07:57.423
really begins with him.
00:07:57.798 --> 00:07:59.259
And the thing about Sharp is that he
00:07:59.279 --> 00:08:00.141
had no ego.
00:08:01.482 --> 00:08:03.322
He really had no interest in trying to
00:08:03.343 --> 00:08:04.624
draw attention to himself.
00:08:04.644 --> 00:08:07.666
He was not self-mythologizing in any way.
00:08:09.048 --> 00:08:10.988
It really was a kind of a deep
00:08:11.149 --> 00:08:13.050
sense of personal commitment for him.
00:08:33.336 --> 00:08:34.758
for historians to get at this,
00:08:34.817 --> 00:08:37.559
even the local nature of this.
00:08:37.639 --> 00:08:38.200
Yeah.
00:08:38.320 --> 00:08:38.980
And it's a really,
00:08:39.041 --> 00:08:40.442
it was a really interesting part of
00:08:40.501 --> 00:08:41.942
working on this book, Bob,
00:08:41.962 --> 00:08:44.725
because I don't myself come from a
00:08:44.764 --> 00:08:45.926
religious background.
00:08:46.947 --> 00:08:48.587
I don't, you know, I'm not,
00:08:49.168 --> 00:08:51.530
I had to learn a lot about evangelical
00:08:51.571 --> 00:08:53.491
Christianity to write about it.
00:08:55.910 --> 00:08:57.493
the commitment in some ways was to try
00:08:57.533 --> 00:09:00.556
to see the world through their eyes.
00:09:01.235 --> 00:09:03.477
And it became really clear pretty early,
00:09:03.498 --> 00:09:04.919
and I wasn't the first one to see
00:09:04.960 --> 00:09:08.043
this, that the purposes,
00:09:08.903 --> 00:09:10.725
it's not just that evangelicals had
00:09:10.764 --> 00:09:11.985
religious motivations,
00:09:12.025 --> 00:09:13.447
they had religious purposes.
00:09:14.568 --> 00:09:17.831
They really wanted to promote the
00:09:17.871 --> 00:09:20.474
conversion to Christianity.
00:09:21.686 --> 00:09:22.886
for enslaved Africans,
00:09:22.927 --> 00:09:23.986
and they thought slaveholders were
00:09:24.006 --> 00:09:24.667
standing in the way.
00:09:24.687 --> 00:09:25.087
Correctly,
00:09:25.128 --> 00:09:26.368
they thought slaveholders were standing in
00:09:26.508 --> 00:09:27.869
the way.
00:09:27.969 --> 00:09:29.708
And so, in a lot of ways,
00:09:29.989 --> 00:09:33.270
what antislavery meant to them was to
00:09:33.350 --> 00:09:34.910
make, you know,
00:09:35.410 --> 00:09:38.373
much more sincere Christians of both
00:09:38.432 --> 00:09:41.453
slaveholders and enslaved Africans.
00:09:42.184 --> 00:09:44.868
And so when you see their work as
00:09:44.908 --> 00:09:47.770
an attempt to sacralize and Christianize
00:09:47.811 --> 00:09:48.451
the world,
00:09:50.052 --> 00:09:52.696
then some of the choices they make make
00:09:52.716 --> 00:09:53.537
a lot more sense.
00:10:23.350 --> 00:10:23.931
otherwise.
00:10:24.892 --> 00:10:26.653
Yeah, I mean, well, I mean,
00:10:26.673 --> 00:10:28.995
you've done great work on Equiano as well,
00:10:30.196 --> 00:10:33.018
you know, which advertisement,
00:10:33.038 --> 00:10:34.639
which I've used in class many times.
00:10:36.539 --> 00:10:37.941
But that's true.
00:10:39.822 --> 00:10:40.582
You know, I,
00:10:43.826 --> 00:10:46.086
there's often been a need to try to
00:10:46.768 --> 00:10:48.068
squeeze Equiano into
00:10:48.931 --> 00:10:53.052
into the tradition of the African-American
00:10:53.113 --> 00:10:54.673
slave market.
00:10:54.714 --> 00:10:54.953
You know,
00:10:55.254 --> 00:10:56.695
he spent very little time in North
00:10:56.735 --> 00:10:57.254
America.
00:10:58.475 --> 00:10:59.416
He really, you know,
00:10:59.436 --> 00:11:01.116
obviously was publishing for a British
00:11:01.297 --> 00:11:01.837
audience.
00:11:02.898 --> 00:11:05.078
His narrative is so crucial to the early
00:11:05.119 --> 00:11:06.879
stages of the British anti-slavery
00:11:06.940 --> 00:11:07.379
movement.
00:11:08.140 --> 00:11:10.042
And, you know, as you know well,
00:11:10.261 --> 00:11:14.063
it's just chock full of the language of
00:11:14.903 --> 00:11:17.586
the kind of Protestant reawakening, right?
00:11:18.386 --> 00:11:21.649
It's both a conversion narrative and it's
00:11:21.769 --> 00:11:23.910
a confessional of a kind.
00:11:23.951 --> 00:11:24.870
Yeah, yeah.
00:11:24.890 --> 00:11:26.753
Because he's involved in the slave trade
00:11:26.832 --> 00:11:29.495
and in slavery after he becomes free.
00:11:29.914 --> 00:11:31.115
That's right, that's right.
00:11:31.495 --> 00:11:32.135
And again,
00:11:32.155 --> 00:11:34.999
it points out some of the ways that
00:11:35.178 --> 00:11:37.019
slaveholding and slave trading were so
00:11:37.220 --> 00:11:41.923
built deeply into the world that even
00:11:41.964 --> 00:11:43.625
those who had been victims of it
00:11:44.875 --> 00:11:47.676
could then become, later in their lives,
00:11:47.755 --> 00:11:48.916
participants in it.
00:11:50.216 --> 00:11:51.076
And then in some ways,
00:11:51.216 --> 00:11:53.477
one of the things that precipitates the
00:11:53.538 --> 00:11:55.418
narrative, the writing narrative,
00:11:55.597 --> 00:11:57.818
is the experience with the Sierra Leone
00:11:57.879 --> 00:11:58.558
expedition.
00:11:59.038 --> 00:11:59.678
That's right.
00:12:00.559 --> 00:12:01.419
Yeah, that's right.
00:12:02.081 --> 00:12:05.102
Yeah, I mean, so the, he,
00:12:06.023 --> 00:12:07.962
he's really right there at all of the
00:12:08.043 --> 00:12:11.323
decision points for the early, you know,
00:12:11.364 --> 00:12:12.504
for the early movement.
00:12:12.583 --> 00:12:13.423
I mean, he, you know,
00:12:13.464 --> 00:12:16.865
he visits Quaker meeting houses at a time
00:12:16.884 --> 00:12:18.424
when they are just starting as a,
00:12:19.245 --> 00:12:22.426
as a religious body with themselves and
00:12:22.466 --> 00:12:24.086
slaveholders and slave traders.
00:12:24.106 --> 00:12:26.886
And he is curious,
00:12:27.006 --> 00:12:29.648
he recruited at one point some of the
00:12:29.668 --> 00:12:31.128
earliest missionary
00:12:32.303 --> 00:12:34.605
opportunities in West Africa.
00:12:34.645 --> 00:12:37.707
Reports on the Zong case, you know.
00:12:37.727 --> 00:12:41.409
So he's really kind of there as the
00:12:42.091 --> 00:12:46.374
subject of the live political issue.
00:12:46.474 --> 00:12:49.034
It's interesting, speaking of West Africa,
00:12:49.096 --> 00:12:51.096
one of the characters that I had never
00:12:51.116 --> 00:12:52.378
heard of until reading your book is
00:12:52.717 --> 00:12:54.078
Malachi Postlefleet.
00:12:54.278 --> 00:12:57.041
Again,
00:12:57.221 --> 00:12:59.682
writing before the American Revolution,
00:12:59.783 --> 00:13:00.283
but his
00:13:01.168 --> 00:13:03.692
has very complicated reasons for
00:13:03.711 --> 00:13:05.754
denouncing the slave trade he's hoping
00:13:05.774 --> 00:13:07.975
like equiano also built on this let's have
00:13:07.995 --> 00:13:10.198
these commercial ties with africa that
00:13:10.239 --> 00:13:12.221
this will actually be more beneficial than
00:13:12.260 --> 00:13:12.942
slave trade so
00:13:13.774 --> 00:13:15.735
For those who might not have known about
00:13:15.817 --> 00:13:17.116
Malachi Postlethwaite.
00:13:17.136 --> 00:13:18.759
No one, yeah,
00:13:19.678 --> 00:13:21.139
I feel like I kind of, yeah,
00:13:21.159 --> 00:13:22.100
Malachi Postlethwaite.
00:13:22.120 --> 00:13:23.261
So it's a Welsh name.
00:13:24.243 --> 00:13:27.404
And he is a, he's a kind of,
00:13:30.687 --> 00:13:34.190
he's an insider in the Royal Africa
00:13:34.230 --> 00:13:34.610
Company.
00:13:35.827 --> 00:13:38.009
when the Royal Africa Company is an
00:13:38.068 --> 00:13:40.049
increasingly failing concern.
00:13:40.831 --> 00:13:42.591
The British slave trade is increasingly
00:13:42.711 --> 00:13:44.091
run over the course of the eighteenth
00:13:44.131 --> 00:13:46.854
century by independent merchants rather
00:13:46.874 --> 00:13:48.934
than these large corporate bodies.
00:13:49.514 --> 00:13:51.355
And Postlethwaite is one of the most
00:13:51.436 --> 00:13:54.357
dedicated figures in the Royal Africa
00:13:54.378 --> 00:13:57.458
Company as it approaches bankruptcy.
00:13:57.980 --> 00:13:59.539
And he's got this idea that the Royal
00:13:59.600 --> 00:14:02.621
Africa Company can be rescued if it finds
00:14:02.682 --> 00:14:03.743
a different niche
00:14:04.850 --> 00:14:06.470
in Britain's West Africa trades.
00:14:07.030 --> 00:14:10.270
And so he starts arguing that Britain
00:14:10.311 --> 00:14:12.812
should invest in essentially creating
00:14:12.892 --> 00:14:16.852
plantation-like economies in West Africa
00:14:17.472 --> 00:14:18.774
that would make the slave trade
00:14:18.913 --> 00:14:20.214
unnecessary because you wouldn't need it.
00:14:20.474 --> 00:14:21.333
You wouldn't need Barbados.
00:14:21.354 --> 00:14:22.875
You wouldn't need South Carolina.
00:14:23.575 --> 00:14:26.475
West Africans cultivated sugar and cotton
00:14:26.515 --> 00:14:27.916
and rice in the back of indigo.
00:14:28.883 --> 00:14:30.443
in Africa itself.
00:14:30.923 --> 00:14:31.924
And so he sees this as a kind
00:14:31.965 --> 00:14:33.865
of alternative to the Atlantic slave
00:14:33.904 --> 00:14:34.245
trade.
00:14:35.525 --> 00:14:38.347
And it's one of these ways that a
00:14:38.447 --> 00:14:40.668
case is made against the Atlantic slave
00:14:40.708 --> 00:14:42.929
trade, not on moral grounds,
00:14:43.309 --> 00:14:45.130
but on the grounds that it gets in
00:14:45.171 --> 00:14:49.312
the way of what's far more profitable.
00:14:50.974 --> 00:14:54.916
So it's kind of an early visionary for
00:14:56.398 --> 00:14:58.119
empire.
00:14:58.198 --> 00:14:59.639
The sorts of things that European
00:14:59.679 --> 00:15:01.061
governments do in the late-nineteenth,
00:15:01.081 --> 00:15:03.582
early-twentieth century of establishing
00:15:03.623 --> 00:15:05.845
imperial governments and extracting
00:15:05.865 --> 00:15:08.365
commodities and all of those kinds of
00:15:08.405 --> 00:15:08.625
things.
00:15:08.807 --> 00:15:10.607
Apostle Thwaites is dreaming of that in
00:15:10.628 --> 00:15:12.109
the middle of the eighteenth century,
00:15:12.469 --> 00:15:14.629
and he's dreaming about it as a way
00:15:14.971 --> 00:15:18.393
of providing an alternative to the
00:15:18.432 --> 00:15:19.354
Atlantic slave trade.
00:15:19.374 --> 00:15:21.375
So people could argue against the Atlantic
00:15:21.394 --> 00:15:23.897
slave trade on all kinds of grounds that
00:15:23.937 --> 00:15:25.717
were not primarily
00:15:26.738 --> 00:15:27.879
moral or ethical.
00:15:28.019 --> 00:15:31.360
I'm wondering, again,
00:15:31.379 --> 00:15:33.321
it's the question I always have with the
00:15:33.461 --> 00:15:35.541
later abolitionists in the nineteenth
00:15:35.581 --> 00:15:36.121
century,
00:15:36.562 --> 00:15:38.402
how do you convince people who are not
00:15:38.422 --> 00:15:40.503
themselves going to be slaves that slavery
00:15:40.663 --> 00:15:41.503
is wrong?
00:15:41.844 --> 00:15:44.403
And you show these different arguments
00:15:44.423 --> 00:15:45.325
that people are making,
00:15:45.384 --> 00:15:48.725
like Haaslethwait and someone like Maurice
00:15:53.826 --> 00:15:57.647
others who are making this argument for
00:15:57.866 --> 00:15:59.187
against the slave trade,
00:15:59.226 --> 00:16:01.366
but it's not necessarily because this is
00:16:01.407 --> 00:16:03.087
good for those who are enslaved.
00:16:04.148 --> 00:16:08.129
So one of the working questions for Moral
00:16:08.168 --> 00:16:08.989
Capital, Bob,
00:16:09.028 --> 00:16:14.690
was when men or women opposed slavery or
00:16:14.730 --> 00:16:16.309
the slave trade in Britain,
00:16:17.250 --> 00:16:18.551
what were they trying to do?
00:16:18.571 --> 00:16:19.350
Right.
00:16:20.201 --> 00:16:25.692
Because it's a mistake to assume that when
00:16:25.751 --> 00:16:29.700
people are pursuing agendas of this kind,
00:16:31.259 --> 00:16:33.380
that the only motivation or the only
00:16:33.500 --> 00:16:36.061
reason that they're drawn to it is because
00:16:36.760 --> 00:16:39.422
they have moral or ethical issues with
00:16:39.481 --> 00:16:40.221
slavery and the slave trade.
00:16:40.241 --> 00:16:41.342
I mean, that's there too,
00:16:41.863 --> 00:16:44.543
but often it's attached to some other
00:16:44.604 --> 00:16:45.024
purpose.
00:16:45.043 --> 00:16:46.583
So the evangelicals,
00:16:46.663 --> 00:16:48.764
it's about spreading Christianity.
00:16:48.804 --> 00:16:49.764
With Apostle Slade,
00:16:49.784 --> 00:16:53.505
it's about finding alternatives to the
00:16:53.525 --> 00:16:55.125
Atlantic slave trade that might be more
00:16:55.166 --> 00:16:55.787
profitable,
00:16:55.807 --> 00:16:56.647
that could rescue
00:16:57.746 --> 00:17:00.188
a failing corporation like the Royal
00:17:00.269 --> 00:17:01.048
Africa Company.
00:17:01.548 --> 00:17:02.610
For Morris Morgan,
00:17:03.990 --> 00:17:08.073
he's writing after Britain has acquired
00:17:09.192 --> 00:17:11.294
substantial new territories after the
00:17:11.354 --> 00:17:12.214
Seven Years' War,
00:17:12.234 --> 00:17:13.615
which Americans know as the French and
00:17:13.635 --> 00:17:14.215
Indian War.
00:17:15.236 --> 00:17:18.817
And he's looking at the problem of how
00:17:18.837 --> 00:17:22.839
does Britain extend its reach into the
00:17:22.880 --> 00:17:25.162
tropical world where
00:17:26.084 --> 00:17:29.247
Europeans have settled unsuccessfully
00:17:29.406 --> 00:17:29.686
often.
00:17:29.767 --> 00:17:33.170
The idea was that Europeans died in hot
00:17:33.210 --> 00:17:33.851
climates,
00:17:33.931 --> 00:17:36.232
that Africans were better suited for these
00:17:36.272 --> 00:17:36.653
places.
00:17:36.673 --> 00:17:38.354
That's part of the reason why slavery
00:17:38.374 --> 00:17:39.315
supposedly existed.
00:17:39.875 --> 00:17:42.377
So Morgan's idea was we can do two
00:17:42.397 --> 00:17:43.117
things at once.
00:17:43.157 --> 00:17:47.521
We can expand empire and undermine slavery
00:17:48.282 --> 00:17:51.265
if we turn blacks into essentially
00:17:51.325 --> 00:17:53.146
colonists for the British empire,
00:17:53.948 --> 00:17:54.387
liberate
00:17:55.269 --> 00:17:56.991
you know, arm them, you know,
00:17:57.071 --> 00:17:59.474
give all the rights of colonial subjects
00:17:59.954 --> 00:18:02.057
and let them push into what we now
00:18:02.097 --> 00:18:04.580
think of as the deep south, you know,
00:18:04.601 --> 00:18:06.663
the sort of the Gulf Coast, you know,
00:18:06.782 --> 00:18:09.145
extend the reach into, you know,
00:18:09.185 --> 00:18:11.347
modern day Texas or other parts of the
00:18:11.387 --> 00:18:12.028
Caribbean, right?
00:18:12.048 --> 00:18:13.230
So the idea was to...
00:18:13.931 --> 00:18:15.051
emancipate, yes,
00:18:15.112 --> 00:18:18.234
but emancipate with the idea of expanding
00:18:18.275 --> 00:18:21.297
the empire into places where European
00:18:21.356 --> 00:18:22.938
settlers have been hesitant to go.
00:18:23.038 --> 00:18:23.999
So, you know,
00:18:24.118 --> 00:18:26.681
anti-slavery could serve imperial purposes
00:18:26.861 --> 00:18:29.423
as well as undermine them.
00:18:29.503 --> 00:18:29.624
Right.
00:18:29.723 --> 00:18:31.045
And sometimes we look at that,
00:18:31.125 --> 00:18:32.405
and here they'll be contesting with the
00:18:32.445 --> 00:18:34.166
French and the Spanish empires,
00:18:34.247 --> 00:18:35.788
but we look at that and then denigrate
00:18:36.288 --> 00:18:37.869
their cause itself, the reason itself,
00:18:37.890 --> 00:18:39.351
because they're doing this not for the
00:18:39.411 --> 00:18:41.032
moral reasons we would prefer,
00:18:41.093 --> 00:18:42.134
but for the reasons
00:18:43.305 --> 00:18:46.646
they have.
00:18:46.666 --> 00:18:46.807
Yeah.
00:18:46.987 --> 00:18:47.146
I mean,
00:18:47.467 --> 00:18:49.228
I'm one of these people who I'm not
00:18:49.268 --> 00:18:51.189
sure there's ever such thing as a purely
00:18:51.308 --> 00:18:53.450
moral or ethical act,
00:18:53.529 --> 00:18:55.250
especially when you're talking about
00:18:55.750 --> 00:18:57.873
things that are beyond the interpersonal.
00:19:00.034 --> 00:19:02.434
And one of the other sort of broader
00:19:02.494 --> 00:19:06.257
points that became very important in the
00:19:06.317 --> 00:19:09.318
book is to show some of the ways
00:19:09.358 --> 00:19:09.659
that
00:19:10.432 --> 00:19:12.955
know when people take action that we
00:19:13.477 --> 00:19:17.422
understand to be moral and ethical it's in
00:19:17.481 --> 00:19:20.705
part because how you see yourself
00:19:21.586 --> 00:19:24.349
individually and collectively is an
00:19:24.390 --> 00:19:25.811
important part of
00:19:26.657 --> 00:19:28.279
you know, how people live in the world.
00:19:28.599 --> 00:19:29.740
And that's not a bad thing.
00:19:29.800 --> 00:19:29.980
I mean,
00:19:30.020 --> 00:19:32.544
wanting to feel better about yourself can
00:19:32.584 --> 00:19:33.865
lead to all sorts of good,
00:19:34.065 --> 00:19:35.566
can lead to all sorts of good,
00:19:36.227 --> 00:19:37.127
you know, actions.
00:19:37.587 --> 00:19:39.109
But it's important to recognize that
00:19:39.130 --> 00:19:41.071
there's a self-reflective part of it,
00:19:41.372 --> 00:19:42.712
self-reflective part of it,
00:19:43.134 --> 00:19:45.836
is that it feels good to do good.
00:19:45.855 --> 00:19:47.257
That's right, yeah.
00:19:47.978 --> 00:19:49.019
That is one of the critical,
00:19:49.058 --> 00:19:51.181
we are really venturing into the realm now
00:19:51.221 --> 00:19:52.001
of theology
00:20:02.342 --> 00:20:04.804
What does that empire mean?
00:20:04.903 --> 00:20:05.704
Yeah, that's right.
00:20:07.626 --> 00:20:09.929
It's weird because to write about the
00:20:09.989 --> 00:20:12.550
history of moral experience and ethical
00:20:12.810 --> 00:20:13.451
experience,
00:20:14.051 --> 00:20:17.776
how people wrestle with the notions of
00:20:17.935 --> 00:20:20.818
right and wrong in their own lives in
00:20:20.858 --> 00:20:21.578
the past,
00:20:22.319 --> 00:20:24.162
it's not about trying to make judgments.
00:20:24.182 --> 00:20:26.022
It's about trying to understand
00:20:27.269 --> 00:20:30.211
how people in real time make the judgments
00:20:30.231 --> 00:20:31.492
and choices that they make.
00:20:33.015 --> 00:20:34.635
We're talking with Christopher Leslie
00:20:34.675 --> 00:20:35.016
Brown,
00:20:35.036 --> 00:20:37.077
who is a professor of history at Columbia
00:20:37.157 --> 00:20:37.817
University,
00:20:37.877 --> 00:20:40.440
where he's for about twenty years and
00:20:40.640 --> 00:20:42.761
author of Moral Capital Foundations of
00:20:42.801 --> 00:20:43.982
British abolitionism.
00:20:44.002 --> 00:20:45.223
And
00:21:12.869 --> 00:21:14.471
what's happening is far important.
00:21:14.490 --> 00:21:15.672
Why isn't it?
00:21:16.211 --> 00:21:16.451
Yeah,
00:21:16.471 --> 00:21:18.232
so this is the group of Anglican
00:21:18.313 --> 00:21:19.153
evangelicals.
00:21:19.173 --> 00:21:20.914
The person who's most well known,
00:21:21.394 --> 00:21:23.156
of course, is William Wilberforce.
00:21:23.717 --> 00:21:30.260
But Wilberforce's politics and purpose was
00:21:30.402 --> 00:21:34.403
nurtured in a circle of pretty elite and
00:21:34.523 --> 00:21:35.585
well-placed,
00:21:36.184 --> 00:21:38.106
devout men and women who
00:21:39.932 --> 00:21:41.893
in the years after the American Revolution
00:21:41.972 --> 00:21:45.953
decided that modernizing Britain was
00:21:46.013 --> 00:21:47.413
becoming too secular,
00:21:48.233 --> 00:21:52.256
that the church was more concerned with
00:21:52.476 --> 00:21:55.615
its institutional power rather than really
00:21:56.297 --> 00:22:00.817
encouraging a sense of devotion to the
00:22:00.877 --> 00:22:01.117
faith.
00:22:01.417 --> 00:22:03.778
Too much of religion had become very rote,
00:22:04.699 --> 00:22:06.660
habitual without having the kind of the
00:22:06.680 --> 00:22:07.619
real substance to it.
00:22:08.259 --> 00:22:09.461
And Hannah Moore is one of these people
00:22:09.480 --> 00:22:16.146
who had been a real celebrated poet and
00:22:18.088 --> 00:22:19.289
writer for the theater.
00:22:19.609 --> 00:22:22.732
She was a kind of a literary phenomenon.
00:22:22.992 --> 00:22:25.055
And she has this kind of awake, like,
00:22:25.075 --> 00:22:26.476
there's got to be more to life than
00:22:26.516 --> 00:22:26.796
this.
00:22:27.916 --> 00:22:30.298
And she's part of this group that's
00:22:30.378 --> 00:22:31.701
looking for ways to
00:22:32.864 --> 00:22:36.765
bring religion into the public square in a
00:22:36.845 --> 00:22:38.325
way that's not off-putting.
00:22:39.766 --> 00:22:43.506
And this group at Barham Court kind of
00:22:44.507 --> 00:22:48.807
recognizes that opposing slavery can be a
00:22:49.008 --> 00:22:53.429
way of doing something that
00:22:54.767 --> 00:22:58.548
looks and is moral and is concerned with
00:22:59.089 --> 00:23:00.810
rights and liberty and justice,
00:23:01.451 --> 00:23:03.952
but can also sort of teach people the
00:23:04.032 --> 00:23:08.836
value of pursuing religious ends in
00:23:08.875 --> 00:23:10.957
addition to, you know, the sordid,
00:23:12.077 --> 00:23:14.259
you know, money getting or, you know,
00:23:14.278 --> 00:23:15.960
the sort of the, you know,
00:23:16.000 --> 00:23:17.621
going to the theater or reading novels,
00:23:17.661 --> 00:23:18.402
those kinds of things.
00:23:18.942 --> 00:23:21.263
They have this idea that
00:23:22.326 --> 00:23:24.931
They can merge evangelicalism and the
00:23:24.971 --> 00:23:27.773
pursuit of liberty into one purpose,
00:23:27.834 --> 00:23:29.797
and they see anti-slavery as a way of
00:23:29.856 --> 00:23:30.397
doing that.
00:23:30.817 --> 00:23:32.099
And they're very self-conscious about
00:23:32.119 --> 00:23:32.259
this.
00:23:32.279 --> 00:23:32.401
I mean,
00:23:32.421 --> 00:23:33.761
this notion that they're going to be the
00:23:33.801 --> 00:23:34.763
running meat of the Negroes,
00:23:34.784 --> 00:23:36.065
that it's sort of the grand charter of
00:23:36.145 --> 00:23:36.685
African liberty.
00:23:36.705 --> 00:23:36.846
Right.
00:23:37.267 --> 00:23:39.048
is going to be written in this little
00:23:39.087 --> 00:23:39.988
village in Kent.
00:23:40.407 --> 00:23:42.169
I mean, it's very self-conscious.
00:23:42.348 --> 00:23:42.528
I mean,
00:23:42.548 --> 00:23:44.329
they really think we're going to do great
00:23:44.349 --> 00:23:46.349
things and everybody's going to know us
00:23:46.390 --> 00:23:47.911
for the great things that we did and
00:23:47.931 --> 00:23:50.192
we're going to show Christ's action in the
00:23:50.211 --> 00:23:50.491
world.
00:23:50.511 --> 00:23:51.112
I mean, they're very,
00:23:51.172 --> 00:23:52.752
very self-aware about this.
00:23:53.173 --> 00:23:53.792
So in some ways,
00:23:53.833 --> 00:23:55.574
they couldn't be more thrilled that,
00:23:55.634 --> 00:23:55.933
in fact,
00:23:55.973 --> 00:23:57.815
they end up getting remembered that way a
00:23:57.875 --> 00:23:58.855
century and a half later.
00:24:00.215 --> 00:24:02.057
The story that they want to tell about
00:24:02.096 --> 00:24:03.978
themselves becomes a story that's told
00:24:04.077 --> 00:24:09.181
about them for many generations on.
00:24:09.421 --> 00:24:13.163
Are there any black people at the court
00:24:13.262 --> 00:24:14.084
as part of this?
00:24:14.523 --> 00:24:17.945
Yeah, not really.
00:24:17.965 --> 00:24:19.487
This is something that I really want to
00:24:19.606 --> 00:24:24.730
emphasize that the moral capital and many
00:24:24.769 --> 00:24:26.270
studies of the British anti-slavery
00:24:26.310 --> 00:24:27.531
movement more generally,
00:24:29.531 --> 00:24:31.192
have a very specific task,
00:24:31.633 --> 00:24:34.574
which is to try to make sense of,
00:24:34.594 --> 00:24:36.575
to put it in the crudest possible terms,
00:24:37.994 --> 00:24:40.395
why white people in Britain decided that
00:24:40.455 --> 00:24:42.435
black people in the colonies were worth
00:24:42.476 --> 00:24:43.217
worrying about.
00:24:44.896 --> 00:24:48.057
There's a whole broader issue about the
00:24:48.137 --> 00:24:50.298
opposition to slavery and the slave trade
00:24:51.023 --> 00:24:53.006
which comes from enslaved Africans or free
00:24:53.026 --> 00:24:54.386
Black people in the empire.
00:24:54.446 --> 00:24:56.749
So this is actually a very narrow,
00:24:58.529 --> 00:24:59.490
incredibly important,
00:24:59.510 --> 00:25:01.553
but narrow aspect of a much broader
00:25:01.653 --> 00:25:02.113
subject.
00:25:03.775 --> 00:25:05.895
And for the most part,
00:25:06.537 --> 00:25:09.019
the British abolitionists tend not to be
00:25:09.078 --> 00:25:11.800
especially concerned about what Black
00:25:11.840 --> 00:25:13.222
people want for themselves.
00:25:13.863 --> 00:25:14.083
Right.
00:25:14.323 --> 00:25:15.703
They have an idea of, you know,
00:25:16.704 --> 00:25:19.106
of a kind of an emancipatory politics that
00:25:19.146 --> 00:25:22.128
will also serve their notion of what free
00:25:22.169 --> 00:25:23.210
people should do,
00:25:24.250 --> 00:25:25.692
which includes a certain kind of
00:25:26.492 --> 00:25:27.173
gratitude.
00:25:27.192 --> 00:25:29.515
You know, almost many,
00:25:29.615 --> 00:25:33.337
many wealthy families had
00:25:36.603 --> 00:25:37.782
black servants,
00:25:37.803 --> 00:25:39.324
some of whom were kind of free or
00:25:39.403 --> 00:25:40.384
sort of enslaved.
00:25:40.744 --> 00:25:42.866
It wasn't unusual to see black people in
00:25:42.926 --> 00:25:43.247
England.
00:25:43.807 --> 00:25:45.008
I don't know off the top of my
00:25:45.127 --> 00:25:46.930
head whether Wilbur Forrest, Adam Moore,
00:25:46.950 --> 00:25:50.531
some of those folks had black essentially
00:25:50.612 --> 00:25:52.353
servants slash slaves.
00:25:53.253 --> 00:25:54.674
I don't think that group did.
00:25:55.972 --> 00:25:56.834
But it certainly would not have been
00:25:56.874 --> 00:25:57.894
uncommon in their world.
00:25:58.694 --> 00:25:59.155
Interesting.
00:25:59.175 --> 00:26:02.518
Another of the characters or the figures,
00:26:02.597 --> 00:26:03.659
and this is James Ramsey,
00:26:03.679 --> 00:26:06.580
who does have a background in the West
00:26:06.661 --> 00:26:06.941
Indies.
00:26:06.980 --> 00:26:08.122
Can you tell us a little bit about
00:26:08.182 --> 00:26:08.342
him?
00:26:08.882 --> 00:26:09.262
Yeah,
00:26:09.462 --> 00:26:11.784
so he ends up being a major figure
00:26:12.904 --> 00:26:14.605
in Moral Capital.
00:26:18.000 --> 00:26:20.201
I believe at the early stages is no
00:26:20.261 --> 00:26:23.163
less important than Thomas Clarkson and
00:26:23.263 --> 00:26:26.385
one before us and Olaudah Equiano and some
00:26:26.425 --> 00:26:30.108
of the other folks who, you know,
00:26:30.128 --> 00:26:31.890
people today might be more familiar with.
00:26:31.910 --> 00:26:32.089
So, I mean,
00:26:33.330 --> 00:26:36.192
he's kind of the eighteenth century
00:26:36.251 --> 00:26:38.513
version of a whistleblower in the sense
00:26:38.554 --> 00:26:39.233
that he, you know,
00:26:39.253 --> 00:26:41.115
he resided in the British Caribbean
00:26:42.757 --> 00:26:44.798
uh you know more than two decades he
00:26:45.278 --> 00:26:48.182
he served as a doctor and a clergyman
00:26:48.701 --> 00:26:52.305
he was himself a slave owner um and
00:26:52.566 --> 00:26:52.786
he
00:26:55.450 --> 00:26:58.971
really came to the view that his peers
00:26:59.151 --> 00:27:01.571
were completely morally bankrupt,
00:27:02.913 --> 00:27:08.414
that there was a way to practice slavery,
00:27:08.434 --> 00:27:10.556
to put it in twentieth century terms,
00:27:10.576 --> 00:27:12.016
that was kinder and gentler,
00:27:13.297 --> 00:27:16.817
that there's no reason why slave owners
00:27:16.857 --> 00:27:18.838
could not take more interest in the
00:27:19.378 --> 00:27:23.180
spiritual and other welfare of the people
00:27:23.220 --> 00:27:24.201
that they owned.
00:27:24.941 --> 00:27:27.823
And so he really sort of pushed for
00:27:27.923 --> 00:27:30.084
many years, living in the Caribbean,
00:27:30.163 --> 00:27:31.884
of let's just try to make this a
00:27:31.944 --> 00:27:32.765
gentler system.
00:27:32.805 --> 00:27:34.486
Let's just ameliorate slavery a little
00:27:34.526 --> 00:27:34.605
bit.
00:27:34.645 --> 00:27:37.027
What if we just recognize that these
00:27:37.047 --> 00:27:39.028
people ought to have basic human rights,
00:27:39.108 --> 00:27:40.088
even if we own them?
00:27:40.449 --> 00:27:40.628
Like,
00:27:40.949 --> 00:27:43.030
does this not look like an anti-slavery
00:27:43.070 --> 00:27:43.451
position
00:27:44.718 --> 00:27:45.578
at our time at all.
00:27:45.598 --> 00:27:47.380
And it wasn't an anti-slavery position,
00:27:47.400 --> 00:27:50.102
but it was a slavery-critical position.
00:27:50.721 --> 00:27:55.365
And as he became more and more frustrated
00:27:55.384 --> 00:27:56.145
with his peers,
00:27:56.326 --> 00:27:58.567
he got more and more radicalized.
00:28:00.048 --> 00:28:03.711
And he began to see it as symptomatic
00:28:03.790 --> 00:28:05.372
of a broader problem of the British
00:28:05.432 --> 00:28:05.952
Empire,
00:28:06.452 --> 00:28:11.056
in which colonial elites took no interest
00:28:11.476 --> 00:28:12.936
in anything besides
00:28:15.198 --> 00:28:16.659
profits and enriching themselves.
00:28:17.578 --> 00:28:21.060
And so it turned him into an advocate
00:28:21.101 --> 00:28:23.761
for much broader kinds of imperial
00:28:23.821 --> 00:28:24.442
reforms,
00:28:25.002 --> 00:28:29.003
one of which for him was ameliorating
00:28:29.044 --> 00:28:29.503
slavery.
00:28:30.585 --> 00:28:31.984
And so he's the kind of bridge to
00:28:32.005 --> 00:28:33.945
people like Hannah Moore and Wilberforce
00:28:33.986 --> 00:28:35.027
of sort of saying, hey,
00:28:35.047 --> 00:28:37.867
this is a system which is
00:28:39.231 --> 00:28:42.178
so beyond the pale morally and ethically
00:28:42.919 --> 00:28:44.501
that it's really deserving of reform.
00:29:08.355 --> 00:29:10.218
something that gives them a consistency.
00:29:10.238 --> 00:29:11.358
And it's really important, Bob.
00:29:11.398 --> 00:29:13.020
It's not that they're insincere.
00:29:14.222 --> 00:29:16.905
It's not that they don't mean what they
00:29:17.026 --> 00:29:17.405
say.
00:29:18.086 --> 00:29:20.109
I mean, they are genuinely troubled.
00:29:21.892 --> 00:29:22.913
by slaveholding,
00:29:22.952 --> 00:29:24.653
and they're especially troubled by slave
00:29:24.673 --> 00:29:25.074
trading.
00:29:25.733 --> 00:29:27.654
I mean, they're really hostile to it.
00:29:28.435 --> 00:29:30.777
But they're hostile to it as part of
00:29:30.817 --> 00:29:32.877
a broader set of things that they're
00:29:32.938 --> 00:29:34.138
concerned about.
00:29:34.179 --> 00:29:35.819
Sometimes it says, like,
00:29:35.839 --> 00:29:37.060
there was a way of writing about
00:29:37.141 --> 00:29:39.362
abolitionists as if they woke up in the
00:29:39.402 --> 00:29:40.722
morning and they were abolitionists,
00:29:40.742 --> 00:29:41.903
and they were abolitionists through
00:29:41.942 --> 00:29:43.763
breakfast and lunch and the whole day,
00:29:44.144 --> 00:29:45.525
and they went to bed as abolitionists
00:29:45.545 --> 00:29:46.865
without taking into account
00:29:47.388 --> 00:29:49.009
all the other things that matter to them.
00:29:49.029 --> 00:29:50.309
And if you want to make sense of
00:29:50.349 --> 00:29:52.111
why people do what they do,
00:29:53.632 --> 00:29:56.472
you want to know how their political
00:29:56.532 --> 00:29:57.973
priorities relate to their other
00:29:58.013 --> 00:29:58.554
priorities,
00:29:59.295 --> 00:30:00.634
some of which are very personal,
00:30:00.654 --> 00:30:01.875
some of which are interpersonal,
00:30:02.336 --> 00:30:04.676
some of which are even subconscious.
00:30:05.738 --> 00:30:09.239
And explaining the choices people make
00:30:09.539 --> 00:30:11.580
means taking on board all those different
00:30:11.961 --> 00:30:12.901
sets of concerns.
00:30:21.730 --> 00:30:22.952
write the narrative.
00:30:22.992 --> 00:30:23.614
That's right.
00:30:23.733 --> 00:30:24.194
That's right.
00:30:24.255 --> 00:30:24.836
And, you know,
00:30:25.156 --> 00:30:27.701
I am doing this kind of work.
00:30:27.760 --> 00:30:28.383
You are
00:30:29.747 --> 00:30:32.829
it's interpretive yeah you have you know
00:30:32.890 --> 00:30:35.030
and you as you know you you're going
00:30:35.070 --> 00:30:37.472
through every single shred of document
00:30:37.573 --> 00:30:40.756
evidence all different kinds of materials
00:30:40.776 --> 00:30:43.337
to try to figure out in this case
00:30:43.357 --> 00:30:45.159
what was going on with these people yeah
00:30:45.440 --> 00:30:46.701
um you know and i feel like i've
00:30:46.740 --> 00:30:47.942
got a pretty good i got a pretty
00:30:47.961 --> 00:30:49.323
good read on them but i would not
00:30:49.383 --> 00:30:51.564
be surprised and in fact i would be
00:30:51.704 --> 00:30:53.945
pleased folks come behind me and sort of
00:30:53.965 --> 00:30:54.487
say you know what
00:30:56.678 --> 00:30:57.939
you said about hannah moore okay but i
00:30:57.959 --> 00:30:59.119
think there's something else that's going
00:30:59.140 --> 00:31:01.803
on there with her yeah um so it's
00:31:01.903 --> 00:31:04.005
always a process of discovery and
00:31:04.045 --> 00:31:07.027
interpretation it really is we're talking
00:31:07.047 --> 00:31:09.048
with christopher leslie brown professor of
00:31:09.068 --> 00:31:10.891
history at columbia and author of moral
00:31:10.931 --> 00:31:13.093
capital foundations of british
00:31:13.212 --> 00:31:16.996
abolitionism and another another of the
00:31:17.056 --> 00:31:19.038
pieces that is really fascinating here is
00:31:19.357 --> 00:31:22.240
when we here in um the united states
00:31:28.782 --> 00:31:31.644
India, Barbados, but Senegambia,
00:31:32.003 --> 00:31:34.125
as you call it,
00:31:34.224 --> 00:31:36.625
it's a place up the Senegal River,
00:31:36.726 --> 00:31:39.287
and that also figures naturally in this
00:31:39.307 --> 00:31:39.666
story.
00:31:42.953 --> 00:31:44.835
I don't think there was a greater
00:31:44.875 --> 00:31:46.275
surprise, Bob,
00:31:46.535 --> 00:31:52.257
than when I started seeing references in
00:31:52.277 --> 00:31:55.817
the records to the British province of
00:31:55.877 --> 00:31:56.518
Senegambia.
00:31:59.038 --> 00:32:01.640
it was one of these things where i
00:32:01.980 --> 00:32:03.421
i came across it because i was looking
00:32:03.480 --> 00:32:04.861
i was interested in the beginnings of
00:32:04.941 --> 00:32:07.321
sierra leone right now which is the
00:32:08.083 --> 00:32:11.064
combination of a refuge sanctuary for
00:32:11.163 --> 00:32:14.285
former slaves um you know left with the
00:32:14.325 --> 00:32:16.066
british during the american revolution
00:32:16.125 --> 00:32:17.346
it's also supposed to be a kind of
00:32:17.365 --> 00:32:21.067
a demonstration colony in a way for um
00:32:21.107 --> 00:32:22.929
a british beachhead in west africa that
00:32:22.949 --> 00:32:24.608
would be a kind of site for fighting
00:32:24.648 --> 00:32:25.950
the atlantic slave trade so it's all of
00:32:25.970 --> 00:32:26.170
those
00:32:26.750 --> 00:32:27.471
different things.
00:32:27.510 --> 00:32:29.011
And as I was going through this early
00:32:29.051 --> 00:32:29.972
Sierra Leone stuff,
00:32:30.012 --> 00:32:31.335
I kept seeing these references to the
00:32:31.375 --> 00:32:32.596
province of Senegambia.
00:32:33.997 --> 00:32:35.959
And there is no such a thing.
00:32:37.961 --> 00:32:40.423
And you go into the secondary literature
00:32:40.482 --> 00:32:41.703
as it existed at the time,
00:32:43.025 --> 00:32:44.747
and there was literally no reference to
00:32:44.826 --> 00:32:44.886
it.
00:32:46.040 --> 00:32:47.241
Pushed back a little further,
00:32:47.382 --> 00:32:49.323
the scholarship from the nineteen teens,
00:32:49.403 --> 00:32:50.242
nineteen twenties,
00:32:50.303 --> 00:32:52.824
nineteen thirties had some passing
00:32:52.864 --> 00:32:54.345
references, some pages to it.
00:32:55.204 --> 00:32:55.846
So, I mean,
00:32:55.905 --> 00:32:59.146
it turned out that Britain established a
00:32:59.186 --> 00:33:03.028
colonial project in West Africa in the
00:33:03.088 --> 00:33:04.930
seventeen sixties, seventeen seventies.
00:33:06.106 --> 00:33:08.028
nobody knew anything about yeah i mean
00:33:08.048 --> 00:33:09.470
it's actually pretty amazing in the late
00:33:09.509 --> 00:33:11.310
twentieth century to discover a colonial
00:33:11.351 --> 00:33:12.771
project that nobody never heard of it's
00:33:12.791 --> 00:33:16.453
amazing and you know it was one of
00:33:16.515 --> 00:33:19.155
these things where i started to dig into
00:33:19.195 --> 00:33:22.459
a little bit and this is much bigger
00:33:22.499 --> 00:33:24.319
than anything that i can deal with right
00:33:24.380 --> 00:33:27.362
now but it was but it clearly had
00:33:27.442 --> 00:33:30.765
some relationship to this broader issue of
00:33:31.909 --> 00:33:34.471
different kinds of commercial and imperial
00:33:34.550 --> 00:33:39.753
ambitions in West Africa that were related
00:33:39.794 --> 00:33:41.816
in some ways to anti-slavery thought.
00:33:42.256 --> 00:33:43.557
So I needed to deal with it from
00:33:43.596 --> 00:33:46.939
that point of view.
00:33:47.720 --> 00:33:48.220
But yeah, I mean,
00:33:48.259 --> 00:33:49.480
so I've actually been spending a fair
00:33:49.500 --> 00:33:51.561
amount of time over the years
00:33:52.594 --> 00:33:54.194
building out an understanding of the
00:33:54.234 --> 00:33:56.816
province of Senegal because it's a it's a
00:33:56.855 --> 00:34:00.277
colonial project that not only was
00:34:00.317 --> 00:34:03.397
forgotten by historians but it was almost
00:34:03.518 --> 00:34:06.499
immediately forgotten at the time so you
00:34:06.558 --> 00:34:08.739
go through so it's the basic story is
00:34:08.780 --> 00:34:11.061
that it's created in the aftermath of the
00:34:11.101 --> 00:34:14.061
seven years war to try to control access
00:34:14.081 --> 00:34:16.061
to certain kinds of commercial markets
00:34:16.161 --> 00:34:17.623
especially to keep France out
00:34:18.583 --> 00:34:20.585
It's a province colony only in Maine.
00:34:20.605 --> 00:34:21.927
There's never more than a few dozen
00:34:21.967 --> 00:34:23.547
British people there at any given time.
00:34:24.128 --> 00:34:26.411
It's a casualty of the American Revolution
00:34:26.451 --> 00:34:29.893
because France returns to the region after
00:34:29.914 --> 00:34:32.936
it enters the war with the British and
00:34:32.956 --> 00:34:35.139
destroys the remnants of it.
00:34:35.960 --> 00:34:37.862
And this is the part that's amazing about
00:34:37.922 --> 00:34:38.021
it.
00:34:38.523 --> 00:34:39.643
Within a decade,
00:34:40.936 --> 00:34:42.637
There is no reference in Britain.
00:34:42.677 --> 00:34:47.097
It's as if it never existed.
00:34:47.157 --> 00:34:48.079
And as you know well,
00:34:48.639 --> 00:34:50.480
there are mountains and mountains of
00:34:50.619 --> 00:34:52.800
information testimony collected about
00:34:52.940 --> 00:34:54.541
Britain's trade in Africa and the slave
00:34:54.561 --> 00:34:55.902
trade and all of that.
00:34:56.902 --> 00:34:59.702
No one ever acknowledges that this thing
00:34:59.923 --> 00:35:00.724
ever existed.
00:35:02.222 --> 00:35:05.182
And so there's an interesting story there
00:35:05.262 --> 00:35:08.605
about a collective national forgetting of
00:35:08.664 --> 00:35:10.786
what's essentially a kind of a disaster of
00:35:11.045 --> 00:35:14.228
an imperial experiment that everyone
00:35:14.268 --> 00:35:16.489
involved decides it's just worth not
00:35:16.528 --> 00:35:17.168
talking about.
00:35:18.489 --> 00:35:20.070
So, yeah.
00:35:20.311 --> 00:35:23.172
So it's a really strange moment in British
00:35:23.211 --> 00:35:23.652
imperial history.
00:35:23.672 --> 00:35:24.472
Your book opens up.
00:35:32.228 --> 00:35:33.668
i don't know about i don't know about
00:35:33.728 --> 00:35:35.170
movies but there are a lot of there
00:35:35.210 --> 00:35:38.492
are a lot of threads that that i
00:35:38.512 --> 00:35:40.373
that i i would have liked to pursue
00:35:40.653 --> 00:35:43.436
but you know it's a long book i
00:35:43.456 --> 00:35:44.836
don't think anybody wants a five hundred
00:35:44.876 --> 00:35:47.599
page book to be any longer um but
00:35:47.619 --> 00:35:49.199
there's a lot of things that i i
00:35:51.014 --> 00:35:52.414
I opened up that I didn't get a
00:35:52.474 --> 00:35:53.655
chance to address in the way that I
00:35:53.695 --> 00:35:54.235
might have liked.
00:35:54.856 --> 00:35:55.956
It's one of the great things about a
00:35:55.976 --> 00:35:57.436
book like this is it opens up lots
00:35:57.496 --> 00:35:59.358
of things that then someone else can pick
00:35:59.438 --> 00:36:00.039
up.
00:36:00.079 --> 00:36:01.119
That's what you hope for.
00:36:01.358 --> 00:36:02.880
Yeah.
00:36:17.737 --> 00:36:18.378
Yeah, I mean,
00:36:19.780 --> 00:36:24.224
I think Clarkson shows another aspect
00:36:24.525 --> 00:36:27.807
about how social movements begin,
00:36:27.827 --> 00:36:29.309
and that was really one of my driving
00:36:29.349 --> 00:36:29.969
concerns,
00:36:30.371 --> 00:36:33.474
was trying to understand how do
00:36:33.554 --> 00:36:34.233
successful,
00:36:34.295 --> 00:36:36.797
powerful social movements get their start.
00:36:37.777 --> 00:36:39.880
I think it's very easy to assume that
00:36:39.940 --> 00:36:40.701
people will
00:36:42.068 --> 00:36:42.307
You know,
00:36:42.947 --> 00:36:45.668
that starting a powerful political,
00:36:46.048 --> 00:36:47.170
anybody who tries to do the work as
00:36:47.190 --> 00:36:48.849
an activist knows how difficult it is.
00:36:49.751 --> 00:36:51.630
But they so rarely succeed in the way
00:36:51.650 --> 00:36:53.612
that the British antislavery movement did
00:36:53.652 --> 00:36:55.873
in terms of its political influence and
00:36:55.913 --> 00:36:58.074
popular reach that understanding how they,
00:36:58.934 --> 00:36:59.193
you know,
00:36:59.534 --> 00:37:01.755
how it originates is not only about trying
00:37:01.795 --> 00:37:03.956
to understand the making of the modern
00:37:03.996 --> 00:37:05.036
world, the fall of slavery,
00:37:05.056 --> 00:37:06.597
but also just trying to understand sort of
00:37:07.318 --> 00:37:08.538
a kind of a certain kind of dynamic
00:37:08.577 --> 00:37:09.478
and political history.
00:37:09.498 --> 00:37:14.161
And Clarkson is that guy who's that young
00:37:14.221 --> 00:37:15.942
man in a hurry who, you know,
00:37:17.722 --> 00:37:18.983
it was a real discovery.
00:37:19.063 --> 00:37:20.664
One of the many discoveries I had was
00:37:20.724 --> 00:37:23.284
realizing that so many of the key figures
00:37:23.985 --> 00:37:27.246
were young men in their early twenties who
00:37:27.347 --> 00:37:27.626
were
00:37:28.690 --> 00:37:30.371
and being young in the early twenties and
00:37:30.391 --> 00:37:31.751
the eighteenth century and the
00:37:31.952 --> 00:37:33.413
twenty-first century are not the same
00:37:33.452 --> 00:37:36.195
thing, but who saw,
00:37:38.235 --> 00:37:40.056
who had a kind of an idea for
00:37:40.097 --> 00:37:43.059
the person they wanted to be and the
00:37:43.139 --> 00:37:44.940
world that they wanted to make,
00:37:46.280 --> 00:37:50.043
and saw anti-slavery as this kind of
00:37:50.222 --> 00:37:52.284
mission for themselves that they thought
00:37:52.364 --> 00:37:53.704
could be a life mission.
00:37:55.068 --> 00:37:57.550
And so Clarkson throws himself into it in
00:37:57.590 --> 00:37:59.971
a way of a kind of person who
00:38:00.050 --> 00:38:03.132
is ambitious for his goal,
00:38:03.152 --> 00:38:05.253
but also ambitious for himself.
00:38:06.273 --> 00:38:06.853
And, you know,
00:38:06.913 --> 00:38:08.853
Wilberforce is similar in some ways.
00:38:08.893 --> 00:38:10.635
Even Hannah Moore is similar in some ways.
00:38:10.655 --> 00:38:14.675
These are young folks who really see,
00:38:15.715 --> 00:38:16.016
like,
00:38:16.036 --> 00:38:17.916
who just are imagining a kind of a
00:38:17.996 --> 00:38:21.057
transformation that's national,
00:38:21.097 --> 00:38:21.777
that's imperial,
00:38:21.797 --> 00:38:23.259
that's also deeply personal.
00:38:24.556 --> 00:38:26.056
And so I do think that that's an
00:38:26.076 --> 00:38:26.817
important way,
00:38:26.836 --> 00:38:28.677
a part of understanding where movements
00:38:28.737 --> 00:38:31.476
come from, some of that youthful energy.
00:38:31.617 --> 00:38:33.018
And Clarkson is, you know,
00:38:33.038 --> 00:38:34.737
essentially one of the first professional
00:38:34.838 --> 00:38:35.237
activists.
00:38:35.257 --> 00:38:36.898
I mean, he spends his entire life,
00:38:37.498 --> 00:38:37.858
you know,
00:38:38.219 --> 00:38:40.438
pushing anti-slavery causes until his,
00:38:41.039 --> 00:38:43.519
you know, death, you know,
00:38:43.619 --> 00:38:45.460
I guess in his mid-seventies,
00:38:45.500 --> 00:38:46.099
late seventies.
00:38:46.119 --> 00:38:46.239
I mean,
00:38:46.260 --> 00:38:47.701
he's a professional abolitionist his
00:38:47.740 --> 00:38:48.481
entire life.
00:38:49.641 --> 00:38:51.362
He's the exception to what I said about
00:38:51.382 --> 00:38:52.402
waking up and going to bed.
00:38:52.483 --> 00:38:52.682
I mean,
00:38:52.744 --> 00:38:55.344
he is an abolitionist every hour of his
00:38:55.385 --> 00:38:56.306
life, basically.
00:38:57.626 --> 00:38:59.668
So, yeah, it's a really interesting,
00:38:59.688 --> 00:39:00.909
he's an interesting story.
00:39:00.929 --> 00:39:01.248
Yeah.
00:39:01.268 --> 00:39:05.672
And your book has a lot of really
00:39:05.711 --> 00:39:06.452
interesting stories.
00:39:12.141 --> 00:39:14.081
the foundations of British abolitionism.
00:39:14.503 --> 00:39:15.802
So thanks so much for joining us.
00:39:15.902 --> 00:39:16.583
It's great, Bob.
00:39:16.623 --> 00:39:18.063
It's wonderful to be a part of this.
00:39:18.123 --> 00:39:19.523
And thank you for having me.
00:39:19.963 --> 00:39:20.403
My pleasure.
00:39:20.423 --> 00:39:22.003
And I want to thank Jonathan Lane,
00:39:22.023 --> 00:39:23.804
our producer, the man behind the curtain.
00:39:23.824 --> 00:39:24.405
And every week,
00:39:24.425 --> 00:39:26.405
we thank folks who are regular listeners.
00:39:26.505 --> 00:39:27.846
And if you're in one of these places
00:39:27.885 --> 00:39:29.746
and want some of our Revolution Two-Fifty
00:39:29.786 --> 00:39:31.786
swag, send Jonathan an email,
00:39:31.806 --> 00:39:33.806
jlane at revolutiontwofivo.org.
00:39:34.626 --> 00:39:35.847
And if you're not in one of these
00:39:35.887 --> 00:39:37.168
places and want to connect with
00:39:37.208 --> 00:39:37.668
Jonathan's,
00:39:41.239 --> 00:39:41.958
And this week,
00:39:41.978 --> 00:39:44.079
I want to thank our listeners in the
00:39:44.119 --> 00:39:46.181
great state of New Hampshire, in Warner,
00:39:46.260 --> 00:39:48.501
Manchester, and Lebanon, and Bangor,
00:39:48.541 --> 00:39:50.643
Maine, Tallahassee, Florida, Meridian,
00:39:50.742 --> 00:39:52.804
Idaho, Springfield, New Jersey,
00:39:52.864 --> 00:39:54.505
and Springfield, Massachusetts,
00:39:54.565 --> 00:39:57.065
and also in New Jersey, Wayne, Hillsboro,
00:39:57.106 --> 00:39:59.067
and East Brunswick, as well as Brunswick,
00:40:04.001 --> 00:40:06.643
Nairobi, Doha, Madrid, Singapore,
00:40:06.664 --> 00:40:10.188
Montreal, Barcelona, Erfurt and Thuringia.
00:40:10.208 --> 00:40:11.929
When you were talking about kind of
00:40:11.949 --> 00:40:12.909
reformation themes,
00:40:12.949 --> 00:40:14.632
I thought about our listeners in Erfurt.
00:40:14.652 --> 00:40:14.871
I love it.
00:40:14.891 --> 00:40:15.813
I love it.
00:40:16.653 --> 00:40:18.675
London and Tel Aviv and Ponte,
00:40:18.695 --> 00:40:20.938
Wales and Sydney and New South Wales.
00:40:20.978 --> 00:40:21.918
Thank you all for joining us.