Legal Issues In Policing

E97| A pervert, a penis & a parking lot. Public place or private space?

Season 4

Provide your feedback here. Anonymously send me a text message.

In this episode, Mike discusses the Saskatchewan Court of Appeal decision R. v. Harpold, 2024 SKCA 26, where a plain clothed police officer saw a man masturbating in his car in the parking lot of a mall as she walked by it and looked through the driver’s window. When this went to trial, the man argued his vehicle was not a “public place" for the purpose of an indecent act charge. Is a private motor vehicle parked in a public place itself a public place for the purpose of the “indecent act” provision? Does the express or implied “access” as of right or by invitation required in the meaning of “public place” require physical access, or is visual access sufficient?  Listen to find out what Saskatchewan’s top court ruled. 

Regina Police Service press release

Edmonton Service press release

R. v. Desylva, 2025 ABKB 130

Thanks for listening! Feedback welcome at legalissuesinpolicing@gmail.com