Only One Mic Podcast

Discipline or Abuse? Alabama Teacher Fired After Shocking Video

• One Mic • Season 15 • Episode 10

Share episode

Send us a text

A viral arrest. A painful video. A community torn between what raised us and what may have harmed us. We open the mic on a hard question: where does discipline end and abuse begin? Using the Nicole Staples case as a flashpoint, we walk through what the footage shows, how the law views willful abuse, and why many households still see physical punishment as a badge of love and protection. Then we move past outrage into clarity: what real discipline looks like when the goal is learning, safety, and respect that lasts.

SPEAKER_00:

All right, question. What's the difference between discipline and straight up abuse? Because depending on how you grow up, this answer hits very different. Peace. Peace. Peace. Peace, family, and I hope that you're feeling well and blessed today. You're tuned into the sound of the Only One Mic Podcast, Mic Drop Show, where we break down today's biggest moves in culture and community through conversation that matters. I'm your host, Carl Gerard, and I appreciate you locking in with me. Whether you've been following every episode or this is your first time tuning in, this space is about truth, clarity, and conversation that truly matters. And I'm not here to tell you what to think, family. I'm just here to lay it out for you. All right, so now I'm gonna pose this question again, y'all. What's the difference between discipline and straight-up abuse? I asked this question because this one is burning up the internet after Nicole Staples. An Alabama teacher of the year was arrested after a video surfaced of her beating her 12-year-old son with a belt more than 20 times, folks. She also dragged him by the hair, was yelling profanities at him, and shoved him into a wall. Now, to give you more context context on this one, I wanted to play a clip, courtesy of WEAR Channel 3 News, detailing the alleged abuse by Miss Staples. Check this out.

SPEAKER_02:

The video was clandestinely captured by another family member who has given us permission to show it to you. It appears to be a parent attempting to physically discipline her child. The Sheriff's Office now confirms the woman is the mother of the 12-year-old son that is about to be struck with a strap for about 22 times, the beating lasting about 15 seconds, and it is difficult to watch. The woman then pulls the child up from the sofa by his hair, then unleashes a torrent of profanity. This video has also been viewed by investigators with the Mobile County Sheriff's Office, who identify her as 44-year-old Randy Nicole Staples of Graham Bay. But some viewers may recognize her as Mrs. Nicole Staples, a second grade teacher at Cottage Hill Christian Academy. This is her booking picture from Mobile Metro Jail earlier this evening after being charged with felony willful abuse.

SPEAKER_03:

People are entitled to discipline their children how they choose, but that went well beyond discipline. It was sickening to see somebody that just could, you know, repeatedly, you know, strike their child and then snatch them by the hair and yell and cuss at him. You know, and then I think the last strike was across his arms. Just that that was there was never any question or doubt that she was ultimately going to be arrested.

SPEAKER_02:

Sheriff Bird says making the video even more confounding is Staples' reputation at Cottage Hill Christian Academy, which in May posted on Facebook that she had been chosen teacher of the year.

SPEAKER_03:

And and it's you know almost like a uh dual personality, and because uh by all accounts, I'm told that she is a good teacher and well respected, but yet you know what happens in the home is is clearly the opposite of that.

SPEAKER_02:

The sheriff says this is very much an ongoing investigation, and that DHR is involved and is dealing with the children. He says he expects more to be uncovered as the investigation continues.

SPEAKER_03:

We did discuss this in depth with the district attorney, you know, Keith Blackwood, and you know, decided on on the appropriate charges, and you know, she she will face justice.

SPEAKER_00:

All right. So in uh in that conversation, guys, I want you to also you know take note that he said that um the sheriff was talking about how you know she's teacher of the year, and we know that to be true, and that you know, I guess it's like a stark difference between the classroom and and being at home, which hey guys, teachers are are people too, so um, it's not like she's running around beating the kids in the classroom or nothing like that. So this is something that happened in her home with her son. And if you like me, you're probably wondering like what exchange did she have with her son that led up to this? I mean, because mama blocked out for a minute, and we don't know what was said, what was done that got her to this point. Um, and again, I don't know all the situation about it, but um, you know, I I want to be of the mind to think that she's not coming home and just beating this kid like 22 times with a belt and shoving up against walls and cursing just for no reason. It had to be something that led up to this. So let's hear from Nicole Staples' son Jackson Staples on what he believes led to his brother being beaten. Check this out.

SPEAKER_01:

Something about he was done and cleaning the kitchen like he supposed to be, left, went to the neighbor's house, come back, and then it transpired into that.

SPEAKER_00:

All right, so let's be real, y'all. Plenty of households, especially in our communities, folks, physical discipline is normal. It's it's normal in some cases, and a lot of people will tell you, man, this kept me out the penitentiary. Belt, switches, shoes, some of us grew up on that. But what do we see in this video? Was it just a whooping? Was it a mother's rage? Like I said before, the mom just blackout for a minute. So, where does discipline end and abuse begin? Is it the number of hits? Is it the anger behind it, the bruises it leaves, the fear, the intention, or the aftermath of the whole thing? Because some people say, just like I just said, I got whooped as a kid, it turned out fine. Others say, nah, man, that stuff stays with you forever. And honestly, both can be true. So I mean if you want to think about it, about your own household growing up, did you feel corrected or did you feel scared? I listen, I'm telling you, guys, a lot of times you grow up in your in your crib, man, you need that fear and that respect of your parent. Um, you know, because as we see with today's youth that's running around crazy out here, whether you're coming from a good home or not, you know I mean, somewhere down the line that that discipline was lost in that. You know what I mean? Um, you know, so what was it teaching you during that time of discipline? That was just my opinion, y'all. But what what what was it teaching you about, you know, about this? Or was this or was it just about somebody losing control in that situation? And but furthermore, if you're a parent right now, how do you handle discipline in your home? I mean, if you were if you were a person that got beat or whatever, you know what I mean? Do you repeat what you grew up with, or do you just say that's a cycle I'm gonna break? So I'm gonna discipline my kid differently. Now, again, this isn't about judging anybody. We don't know what again, what happened to uh um you know Miss Staples and her son, what was the exchange behind that? I know her older son said that you know she used to beat him like that. And if we all told these stories of when we got beat as children or discipline, as you want to say, um we can all look at it and say, like, oh, mom and dad was bargaining. But hey, look, we that that particular discipline probably helped us out. We don't know if we got Jazzy in a situation and we deserve that. We don't know. So, you know, there's a difference between raising a child and hurting one, you know what I mean? And this particular video, it forces us to look in the mirror and ask hard questions. So I want you to do me this favor hit me up, direct message, comments, emails. I want to hear from you. Discipline versus abuse, y'all. Where is the line on this? All right, the only one mic podcast is available on all major platforms you stream your podcasts on. So wherever you listen, we're there. Be sure to check out our YouTube channel to catch up on the past and current episodes. And don't forget to rate the show and hit that subscribe button. And I believe they have something now called a hype button. If you see that, hit that too. Because it helps the channel more than you know, guys. It helps it more than you know. Follow and connect with us on Instagram and X at the only one Mike P1, Facebook and LinkedIn at the only one mic podcast. Or you can email us at the only one mic zero zero at gmail.com. Call or text at 302-367-7219. Your voice, your questions, your take could be featured on the show. Again, guys, we want to know from you where do you think the line is drawing at with discipline and abuse? What's the difference? Is there a difference? How was it when you were growing up? How are you raising your kids right now? Let us know what you think. Call Gerard, the only one mic podcast, mic drop show, signing off. Peace.