Celebrate Creativity

The Accelerants

George Bartley Season 5 Episode 591

Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.

0:00 | 28:20

Send a text

Welcome back. Verona is split by a feud. Romeo Montague and Juliet Capulet fall in love, marry in secret, and attempt to outrun a culture trained for violence.

Then comes the turning point: Tybalt confronts Romeo, Mercutio fights, Mercutio falls, Romeo kills Tybalt, and Romeo is banished. Juliet faces a forced marriage to Paris. A desperate plan depends on a message. The message fails. Tragedy follows.

Tonight we interview three figures who did not cause the feud—but who, in different ways, accelerate the catastrophe:
Mercutio: wit as weapon
The Nurse: love under pressure
Friar Laurence: good intentions, bad architecture

George (announcer tone):
A civic bulletin from Verona:

The Prince has threatened death for further public brawls.
Citizens pretend this will work because threats are easy to announce.

But the feud continues, because feuds are not ended by decrees.
They are ended by changed habits—
and habits are slower than anger.

Meanwhile, young men patrol their reputations like soldiers.
Servants learn violence as a dialect.
And in this atmosphere, a private love story becomes a public emergency.
Back to our guests.

George
I’m going to ask each of you the same guiding question:
Which moment did you tell yourself you were helping—when you were actually making it worse?
We’ll take you one at a time, and then—because this is theatre—we’ll let you answer each other.

Mercutio. You first.
“I thought I was keeping Romeo alive”

George
Mercutio, you’re not a Montague by blood. Not a Capulet.
And yet you are at the center of the storm. Why?

Support the show

Thank you for experiencing Celebrate Creativity.

Romeo and Juliet — The Accelerants: Mercutio, the Nurse, and Friar Laurence

Welcome to conversations with Shakespeare. You might say that today's episode is made up of conversations with the main supporting characters of Romeo and Juliet - individuals that also act as accelerants.

First let's hear from Mercutio.

MERCUTIO (bright, dangerous humor):
People blame love. I blame boredom.
Boredom is what makes boys draw steel just to feel alive.

And now the nurse, who is somewhat hurt and defensive

NURSE And people blame mothers and nurses—because it’s easy to blame the ones who stay behind.

And finally the well meaning friar Lawrence

FRIAR LAURENCE (low, weary):
If you have come to accuse, make a line.
But if you have come to understand—then we may begin.

George
Then we begin.

Welcome back. Verona is split by a feud. Romeo Montague and Juliet Capulet fall in love, marry in secret, and attempt to outrun a culture trained for violence.

Then comes the turning point: Tybalt confronts Romeo, Mercutio fights, Mercutio falls, Romeo kills Tybalt, and Romeo is banished. Juliet faces a forced marriage to Paris. A desperate plan depends on a message. The message fails. Tragedy follows.

Tonight we interview three figures who did not cause the feud—but who, in different ways, accelerate the catastrophe:
Mercutio: wit as weapon
The Nurse: love under pressure
Friar Laurence: good intentions, bad architecture

George (announcer tone):
A civic bulletin from Verona:

The Prince has threatened death for further public brawls.
Citizens pretend this will work because threats are easy to announce.

But the feud continues, because feuds are not ended by decrees.
They are ended by changed habits—
and habits are slower than anger.

Meanwhile, young men patrol their reputations like soldiers.
Servants learn violence as a dialect.
And in this atmosphere, a private love story becomes a public emergency.
Back to our guests.

George
I’m going to ask each of you the same guiding question:
Which moment did you tell yourself you were helping—when you were actually making it worse?
We’ll take you one at a time, and then—because this is theatre—we’ll let you answer each other.

Mercutio. You first.
“I thought I was keeping Romeo alive”

George
Mercutio, you’re not a Montague by blood. Not a Capulet.
And yet you are at the center of the storm. Why?

MERCUTIO:
Because I live in Verona.
And in Verona, if you’re not in the feud, the feud will still find you—
like rain.

George
You mock Romeo’s loves. You mock his melancholy. You mock the whole idea of devotion.
Why?

MERCUTIO (quick):
Because devotion is a door with a lock on it.
And boys like Romeo—sweet boys—walk into locked rooms and starve.

George
That sounds protective.

MERCUTIO (pauses):
It was protective.
Also—yes—it was vanity.
I liked being the clever one.
Cleverness is a throne in a city where you don’t own land.

George
When Romeo refuses to fight Tybalt, you step in.
Some say you do it for honor. Some say you do it because you can’t resist the drama.

Which is it?

MERCUTIO:
Both.
Honor is the excuse.
Heat is the reason.

George
Say more.

MERCUTIO:
I thought Romeo had been bewitched.
That he’d become soft.
And I told myself: “I’ll shock him back into himself.”

George
And then?

MERCUTIO (voice turns darker):
Then steel met flesh.
And suddenly the joke wasn’t funny.

George
When you were wounded, you curse both houses.

MERCUTIO:
Yes. Because I finally saw the truth:
The feud doesn’t care who you are.
It eats whoever stands close enough.

George
So your “helping” moment was—

MERCUTIO:
When I chose to demonstrate courage instead of choosing to keep peace.
I told myself I was defending my friend.
But I was also defending my pride.

George
If you could speak to every young man who thinks a fight proves something—what would you say?

MERCUTIO:
I’d say:
A fight proves only that you were available to be ruined.

George
Picture it.

It’s hot. The kind of day that makes tempers itch.
Men are outside because inside is too close, too private, too honest.

Tybalt arrives like a lit fuse. He wants Romeo.
Romeo refuses—not out of cowardice, but out of new loyalty.
The refusal is misunderstood. Pride rises. The crowd gathers.
Words become a stage. Everyone performs. Everyone escalates.

And then a single mistake—one movement too close, one intervention too late—
and the play flips from comedy into catastrophe.
All right.

Now: the Nurse.
“I thought I was protecting Juliet”

George
Nurse, you raise Juliet more closely than her own mother does.
Your love is real. No one doubts it.
So let’s make this precise:
When did love become fear?

NURSE (blunt, wounded):
When the men started dying.

George
You are often played for comedy—earthy, talkative, nostalgic.
But you’re also a guardian in a world where girls are traded.

NURSE:
Exactly.
People laugh at me because I talk too much.
But talking is how you keep the darkness away.
Talking is how you keep a child from hearing footsteps.

George
You help Juliet meet Romeo. You carry messages. You enable the secret marriage.
Why?

NURSE:
Because Juliet glowed.
I have seen girls go dull from obedience—
like flowers kept in a box.
And when she spoke of Romeo, she was alive.

George
So you helped.

NURSE:
I did.

George
Then comes the banishment, the forced marriage to Paris, and Juliet’s refusal.
You advise her to marry Paris.

That moment breaks Juliet’s trust.
Why did you do it?

NURSE (painful honesty):
Because I panicked.

George
Because?

NURSE:
Because I couldn’t protect her anymore.
Not with jokes. Not with errands. Not with secret ladders of messages.
The house turned into a trap.
Her father’s anger was a door slamming.
And Romeo—Romeo was gone.
So I said the thing that felt like a lifeboat:
“Marry Paris. Live.”

George
Even if it kills the soul.

NURSE (whispers):
Even if.
George
So your “helping” moment was—

NURSE:
When I confused survival with safety.
I thought I was saving her body.
But I betrayed her truth.

George
Do you regret it?

NURSE:
Every day.
And the terrible part is—I still don’t know what the right advice was.
Because in that house, every option was dangerous.

George
Objection—says a listener:
“The Nurse betrayed Juliet. She’s basically the villain.”

Nurse?

NURSE (fierce):
Villain?
I carried love through enemy streets.
I risked my skin for that girl’s happiness.
I failed, yes.
But don’t call fear a villain.
Fear is what women are trained to drink with their milk.

George
And that is the tragedy:
the Nurse becomes a mirror of the world—
a world that teaches women to choose the least fatal option, not the most truthful one.



George
Friar Laurence, you marry Romeo and Juliet in secret.
You devise the potion plan.
Many see you as wise; many see you as reckless.
Tell me: what did you believe you were doing?

FRIAR LAURENCE (measured):
I believed I was redirecting a dangerous fire into a useful flame.

George
Meaning: turning passion into peace.

FRIAR LAURENCE:
Yes.
The city had tried threats.
Threats had failed. So when love appeared—unexpected, improbable—
I thought: “This might be the medicine.”

George
But you chose secrecy.

FRIAR LAURENCE:
Because openness would have killed it immediately.
I thought secrecy would shelter it long enough to become undeniable.

George
So your strategy depended on time.
FRIAR LAURENCE:
It did.

George
And then the duel day ruins your timetable.

FRIAR LAURENCE:
Yes.
I learned then what all planners learn:
human pride is faster than holy intention.

George
When Juliet comes to you desperate, you offer the potion plan.
Was that wisdom—or desperation dressed as wisdom?

FRIAR LAURENCE (after a beat):
Both.
I saw a girl cornered by her father.
I saw a marriage that would crush her.
And I chose a plan that required the whole world to behave rationally.

George
Which it never does.

FRIAR LAURENCE:
Never.

George
The messenger fails. Romeo never gets the letter.
Then you arrive at the tomb late.

Is the core tragedy that your plan failed…
or that you built a plan that could not survive reality?

FRIAR LAURENCE:
The second.
I built a fragile bridge over a river of violence.
And I was surprised when it collapsed.

George
So your “helping” moment was—

FRIAR LAURENCE:
When I chose cleverness over truth.
When I thought I could outwit the feud, rather than confront it.

George
Do you regret it?

FRIAR LAURENCE:
Yes.
And my regret is not only grief—
it is shame.
Because I loved the feeling of being necessary.

George
A brief thought for listeners:

In tragedies, the most dangerous phrase is not “I hate you.”
The most dangerous phrase is: “I have a plan.”

A plan is not evil.
But plans are seductive because they give the planner the feeling of control.

Friar Laurence is not a villain.
He is a human being who believed intelligence could replace honesty.
And the play punishes that belief—mercilessly.
George
Now we do what theatre does best: let you speak to each other.

Mercutio, you heard the Friar describe his plan as a bridge.
Your response?

MERCUTIO:
A bridge?
Father, you built a lace curtain and called it architecture.

FRIAR LAURENCE:
Mockery is easy. Responsibility is harder.

MERCUTIO:
Responsibility?
You married them in secret and thought the city would politely transform.

FRIAR LAURENCE (stern):
And you—
you treated violence as entertainment until it took you.

MERCUTIO (quiet, then sharp):
Fair.

George
Nurse, you advised Juliet to marry Paris.
What do you say to Friar Laurence, who offered a potion plan?

NURSE:
I say he had the luxury of risking a girl’s life in the name of a theory.

FRIAR LAURENCE:
I did not risk her lightly.

NURSE:
But you still risked her.

George
Mercutio—what do you say to the Nurse?

MERCUTIO:
I say she did what Verona teaches: choose the option that lets you sleep.
And then call it virtue.

NURSE (angered):
And what did you do?
You chose the option that made you look brave.

MERCUTIO (after a beat):
Touché.

George
Here is my question to all three of you:

If you could return to one moment—one moment only—
and change your action, what would you change?
MERCUTIO:
I would walk away from Tybalt.
I’d let my pride starve for once.

NURSE:
I would stand beside Juliet when her father raged.
Even if it meant losing my place.

FRIAR LAURENCE:
I would tell the truth earlier—
to the families, to the Prince, to the city.
And accept the consequences like a man, not hide behind holy walls.

George
And if the truth had caused immediate bloodshed?

FRIAR LAURENCE:
Then at least the bloodshed would have been honest—
not disguised as fate.

George
Listeners, notice what you’ve heard tonight.

Mercutio shows how wit can become a weapon, and pride can masquerade as loyalty.

The Nurse shows how love can be twisted by fear into betrayal—without malice.

Friar Laurence shows how intelligence can become self-deception when it avoids public truth.

The tragedy is not that any of them wanted harm.
The tragedy is that each believed their choice was the least dangerous available—
and in a broken society, “least dangerous” is still deadly.

George
This completes our character-arc for Romeo and Juliet.

Next, we will step back and ask a larger question:

Why do audiences keep returning to this play?
Not because we enjoy sorrow—
but because we recognize the pattern:

Private love is delicate.
Public hatred is organized.
And time is merciless.

Until then—be kinder than Verona.
And be slower than tragedy.

Fare you well.

[MUSIC OUT]


Thought for 58s
Absolutely—here’s a “Postmortem / Why We Keep Returning” wrap-up episode for Romeo and Juliet, written for your Will-alone format with built-in padding modules and clean cut points.

Postmortem Episode Transcript
Why we keep returning to Romeo and Juliet
(Host voice: William Shakespeare speaking directly to the audience.)

Use this as: a coda before moving to the next play, or a “Season 1 checkpoint.”
Built for trimming: Core Track + Add-On Modules + Listener Mail.

[0:00] Cold open (30–45 seconds)
George
You know what people often say about this play?

They say: “Ah yes, the balcony. The romance. The tragedy.”

But that’s like describing a storm by mentioning the umbrella.

Because the true power of this story is not that two young people love.
It’s that a whole city has practiced hate so well that love becomes a punishable offense.

And once you see that—
this stops being a teen romance and becomes something far more unsettling:

A tragedy about how communities train their children.

To conclude the follow the previous episodes on Romeo and Juliet, I would like to share with you some thoughts about the play.

1) The tragedy of speed
George
This is a play where time behaves like an enemy with a stopwatch.

Events don’t “unfold.” They collapse.
A party, a vow, a marriage, a duel, an exile, a potion, a missed message—done.

And that speed is not a gimmick. It is the theme:
in a violent culture, life gets decided too fast.

2) Love doesn’t fail—systems fail
The lovers are not undone by a lack of feeling.
They’re undone by the machinery around them:

reputation culture
family honor
street violence treated as sport
adults who manage rather than listen
secrecy treated as “smart” because honesty seems impossible

Romeo and Juliet don’t die because love is weak. They die because hate is organized.

3) It’s a tragedy of communication
A missed letter—one delay—turns the whole story.
And that’s why modern audiences feel it in their bones:
we live surrounded by messages, yet misunderstanding still rules.

4) It’s about adolescence—but not in the dismissive sense
This play is “teenaged” not because it’s silly, but because it’s intense, immediate, identity-forging. The Folger describes it bluntly as the play most commonly taught in schools, and that matches its cultural position as the “first Shakespeare” for many readers. 

Romeo and Juliet is accessible as story. Even if the language trips you, the plot grabs you.
It’s built around young characters—students don’t have to imagine adulthood to enter it.

It teaches themes cleanly: love, conflict, peer pressure, identity, family obligation, consequences.
It shows how literature works: imagery, foreshadowing, tone-shift, irony, structure.
It rewards performance. Students can act it—read it aloud—and it becomes clearer.

And there’s a practical indicator too: getting back to the Folger - the Folger notes that their editions are widely used in American high schools, and Romeo and Juliet has been their top seller in multiple years. 

5) The play was a hit early, not just later
George
The record of printing tells you something about popularity.
There’s a 1597 quarto that describes the play as having been performed publicly “often (with great applause)”—in other words, it was already a crowd-pleaser. 

6) Textual oddities: “bad quarto” vs “good quarto”
The 1597 text is widely treated as unreliable/unauthorized.

The 1599 second quarto is longer and often called the “good quarto,” “newly corrected, augmented, and amended.” 

“This story was so popular people were already making bootlegs.”

7) Stagecraft was designed for speed
The Royal Shakespeare Company notes how the play suits the simple thrust stage: daylight performance, swift scene changes, the balcony as Juliet’s window, even a trapdoor used for the tomb. 
That stage reality explains the play’s pacing: it moves like a live event, not like a novel.

George
One more truth: Shakespearedid not invent the lovers from nothing.
A major English source was a narrative poem published in 1562 by Arthur Brooke, telling the tale of Romeus and Juliet. 

Shakespeare's craft was not “creating the plot.”
Shakespeare's craft was compressing it into theatre—
and turning it into a story about speed, public violence, and consequences.

George
Now, a few letters from our listeners—real in spirit, if not in ink.

Letter 1: “Is Romeo just dramatic?”
George
Yes—he is.
But the city also rewards drama in men and punishes stillness.
Romeo is a match; Verona is a house full of smoke.

Letter 2: “Is Juliet naïve?”
George
No. She is awake.
Her tragedy is that waking up happens inside a cage.

Letter 3: “Who is most responsible?”
George
If you want a single villain, you’ll miss the lesson.
The villain is the feud—the social habit everyone inherits and no one dismantles.

Letter 4: “Why not just run away?”
George
Because in their world, you don’t simply walk out of family, law, money, and reputation.
Leaving is not an act of romance—it’s an act of war.

Letter 5: “What should I watch for in a performance?”
George
Watch the hinge: the moment after Mercutio’s fall.
If the production doesn’t change temperature there, it hasn’t found the play.

George
So why do we keep returning?
Because we recognize the pattern.
A community teaches its children how to hate.
Two children try to invent a new language called love.
And time—merciless time—reveals what hate has already prepared.
That is not a museum piece.
That is a warning.

Fare you well.

Sources Include:  the complete works of William Shakespeare, Asimov’s Guide to Shakespeare: A Guide to Understanding and Enjoying the Works of Shakespeare by Isaac Asimov, Shakespeare: The Invention of the Human by Harold Bloom, Shakesfear and How to Cure It, an unpublished manuscript by Ralph Cohen, and ChatGPT four.

Thank you very much for listening to the previous four episodes regarding Romeo and Juliet.  Hopefully tomorrow we will completely finish up Romeo and Juliet by looking at Westside Story
[MUSIC OUT]