301. Should Is a Dirty Word (Here's Why)

Have you ever caught yourself thinking...

"I should be further along."

"They should know better."

"This shouldn't be happening."

At first glance, the word should seems harmless. But what if it's actually one of the biggest contributors to unnecessary stress, shame, and emotional dysregulation?

In this episode of The Kathie Owen Perspective, we explore why "should" is much more than a word—it's often the first sign that we've stopped observing reality and started negotiating with it.

You'll discover how our minds move from preferences to expectations, expectations to attachment, attachment to stories, and how those stories quietly shape our emotions, our leadership, our relationships, and our lives.

If you've ever struggled with perfectionism, overthinking, guilt, leadership pressure, relationship conflict, or feeling like life isn't unfolding the way you planned, this episode will give you a new perspective.

🎯 In This Episode, You'll Learn:

✨ Why the word "should" is often the first clue that you're arguing with reality.

🧠 How your mind creates stories to escape uncertainty—and why those stories often create unnecessary suffering.

💡 The hidden relationship between preferences, expectations, attachment, and emotional regulation.

🌱 Why non-attachment doesn't mean you stop caring—it means you stop demanding that life follow your script.

💪 What Radical Responsibility really means—and why it doesn't require carrying everyone else's emotions.

❤️ Why courage isn't about having certainty—it's about remaining present when certainty isn't available.

🔍 How to recognize the stories that keep your nervous system activated long after an event has ended.

🤝 Why replacing "should" with curiosity can transform your leadership, your relationships, and the way you speak to yourself.

🔄 A Simple Practice This Week

The goal isn't to stop saying the word should.

The goal is to notice it.

Every time you hear yourself thinking:

• I should...
• They should...
• This shouldn't...

Pause.

Ask yourself:

"Am I observing reality... or am I negotiating with it?"

That single question can interrupt the cycle of shame, reduce emotional reactivity, and help you respond with greater clarity and intention.

📖 Continue the Conversation

This episode is accompanied by a detailed blog post that expands on these ideas with additional insights and practical takeaways.

➡️ Read the companion article here:
www.kathieowen.com/blog/should-is-a-dirty-word

🎤 Human Patterns Under Pressure Live

Interested in bringing this conversation to your organization or attending an upcoming live event?

Learn more about Human Patterns Under Pressure Live, speaking engagements, and leadership workshops here:

➡️ https://www.kathieowen.com/live

👋 Let's Connect

If this episode resonated with you, I'd love to hear from you.

⭐ Follow the podcast.
⭐ Leave a review.
⭐ Share this episode with someone who needs to hear it.

Every conversation begins with awareness.

And awareness begins with observation.

Kathie Owen is a workplace consultant, speaker, and author of Human Patterns Under Pressure. She helps founders, executives, and leadership teams recognize the hidden behavioral patterns that influence leadership, communication, emotional regulation, and organizational culture under pressure. 

Through speaking engagements, workshops, and consulting, Kathie equips leaders to build healthier workplaces by understanding the human patterns that financial and operational metrics often miss.

The Kathie Owen Perspective

Helping leaders, founders, and professionals recognize the human patterns that shape leadership, culture, communication, and emotional regulation under pressure.

🌐 Website: https://www.kathieowen.com

📖 Articles & Bonus Resources: https://www.kathieowen.com/blog

🎤 Human Patterns Under Pressure Live
Join an upcoming live event to explore leadership psychology, nervous system regulation, and the hidden patterns that influence performance, relationships, and workplace culture.

📱 Connect with Kathie:
 • LinkedIn
• YouTube
• Facebook
• Instagram
• Pinterest

If this episode helped you see something differently, please follow the podcast, leave a review, and share it with someone who could benefit from the conversation.

Pressure doesn't define us. It reveals the patterns we've yet to observe.

Transcript

0:00

Should is a dirty word. I have been saying that for years. People laugh when I say it, but I'm actually serious because I've noticed something. Almost every time I hear myself say the word should, I'm no longer looking at reality. I'm arguing with it. I should be further along. They should know better. My team should understand. My kids should appreciate me. This shouldn't be happening. Have you ever noticed how quickly one little word can change your entire emotional state? Because here's what I've observed. Reality isn't usually what creates our suffering. It's our negotiation with reality, and that negotiation almost always begins with one word: should. Welcome to the Kathie Owen Perspective podcast. My name is Kathie Owen. I'm a workplace consultant, speaker, and author of Human Patterns Under Pressure. For over 20 years, I've studied what pressure reveals about people, leaders, and organizations, because pressure doesn't create character. Pressure reveals the patterns that were already there. Now, if you've listened to me for any length of time, you probably know I'm fascinated by one question: How does something as simple as one word create so much pressure? That's the word, pressure. Because let's be honest, the word should isn't what hurts us. It's what comes with it. Think about what happens in your own mind. Reality happens. Maybe someone doesn't call you back. Maybe a meeting gets canceled. Maybe your business grows slower than you expected. Maybe your child makes a decision you wouldn't have made. Those are just events. They're neutral until we begin adding meaning. The mind steps in almost immediately. "That shouldn't have happened. They should know better. I should have seen this coming." And before we know it, we've left reality. We've entered a conversation with ourselves. That's where the pressure begins. Not in the event, but in the meaning we've assigned to the event. And once that meaning takes hold, something else quietly follows. Expectation, attachment, guilt, shame. And think about guilt for a moment. Most of us have experienced it. We made a mistake, we apologize. Maybe we even make it right. But instead of letting go, we carry it, we replay it, we punish ourselves with it. "I should have known. I shouldn't have done that. I should be better than this." And notice what's happening. The event is over, but the mind keeps reliving it. The nervous system doesn't know the difference between something happening right now and something you're replaying over and over in your head, so it continues reacting. That's why emotional regulation isn't just about calming yourself down. It's about becoming aware of the stories you're continuing to feed your own nervous system. And that brings me to something I've been observing in my own life: preferences. For years, I had preferences about almost everything. How people should treat me, how quickly my business should grow, how conversations should go, how leadership should look, how relationships should unfold. I didn't realize it at the time, but those preferences were quietly shaping how I experienced reality. Now, there's nothing wrong with having preferences. They're natural. The problem begins when we become attached to them. Because once I'm attached to a preference, it doesn't take long before that preference becomes an expectation. And expectations are interesting. In fact, I talk about expectations in one of my speeches. I say, "Expectations are a funny thing." They're often just unspoken agreements we've made with ourselves that no one else knows exists. When reality doesn't match that expectation, something shifts inside of us. We become frustrated, disappointed, sometimes even ashamed. Not because reality is wrong, but because reality didn't follow the script we had already written in our minds. Lately, I've been experimenting with something different. Instead of deciding ahead of time how I want every situation to unfold, I've been trying to stay open, curious, observant. I've noticed that when loosening my grip on my preferences, I experience more peace. Not because life suddenly got easier, but because I'm no longer arguing with it, and that's different from not caring. I still care deeply. I still prepare. I still work hard. I still have goals. But I'm learning that peace doesn't come from getting everything I prefer. It comes from meeting reality as it is before deciding what it means. The next principle is radical responsibility. And I want to be careful here because this principle is often misunderstood. Radical responsibility doesn't mean taking responsibility for everything. In fact, for many years, that's exactly what I did. I took responsibility for other people's emotions, other people's reactions, other people's choices. If someone was upset, I felt like I had to fix it. If something went wrong, I assumed I had done something wrong. That isn't responsibility. That's over-responsibility, and that takes a lot of energy. Radical responsibility is much simpler than that. It means I become responsible for what actually belongs to me. My thoughts, my behavior, my words, my reactions, the stories I create. When I catch myself saying, "They should," I pause because now I have a choice. I can continue trying to manage another person's behavior, or I can become curious about my own. That's where my power lies. Not in controlling other people, 'cause that's not gonna happen. Not in making life unfold the way I expected, but in choosing how I respond to what is happening right now. I learned that responsibility isn't heavy. It's actually freeing because the moment I stop carrying what was never mine to carry, I have more energy for what is. That's where emotional regulation begins. Not by controlling your emotions, but by taking responsibility for the stories that are creating them. When we observe the story instead of automatically believing it, our nervous system has room to settle. We become less reactive, more present, more thoughtful, more intentional. That's emotional regulation. It's not the absence of emotion, it's the ability to stay present with reality without letting every story pull you away from it. The final principle is courage, and I think this might be the hardest one because it takes courage to let go of the word should. It takes courage to admit that maybe the story in your mind isn't the whole story. It takes courage to sit in uncertainty without rushing to fill in the blanks. Our minds don't like uncertainty. They want answers. They want certainty. They want to know who's right, who's wrong, and what everything means. But courage says, "Maybe I don't know yet." That's uncomfortable, and that's okay because discomfort isn't the enemy, shame is. One thing I've noticed is that when we don't just should on ourselves, we should on other people, too. As leaders, as parents, as spouses, as friends, you should already know this. You should be doing more. You shouldn't feel that way. Most of the time, those words aren't spoken with bad intentions. But think about how they land. They can quietly communicate you're already falling short. As leaders, one of the greatest gifts we can give another person isn't another should, it's curiosity. Instead of saying, "You should have done this," what if we ask, "What got in the way?" Instead of saying, "You shouldn't feel that way," what if we asked, "Help me understand." Curiosity opens conversations, should often closes them. The same is true for the conversation you have with yourself. How many times have you told yourself, "I should be further along. I should have figured this out by now. I shouldn't be struggling"? What if you replace judgment with observation? What if, instead of asking, "What's wrong with me?" you asked, "What am I noticing?" That single shift changes everything. So this week, I have a challenge for you. Don't try to eliminate the word should. Just become aware of it. Notice when you say it to yourself. Notice when you say it to someone else. Notice when someone says it to you. And before you believe it, pause, because every should is a clue that you've left reality and entered negotiation with it. It's an invitation to become curious, to practice non-attachment, to take radical responsibility, to choose courage over certainty. Because emotional regulation doesn't begin when your emotions show up. It begins the moment you notice the story your mind is creating, and from that place, you get to choose your response. So today, I wanna leave you with this observation. Don't should on yourself, and don't should on other people because every time we use that word, we're usually asking reality or another human being to become someone they're not in this moment. Observation creates change. Shame rarely does. All right. This has been the Kathie Owen Perspective Podcast. Until next time, stay curious, observe without judgment, and remember, pressure doesn't define you. It simply reveals the patterns that have been waiting to be seen.