Keating Chambers: The Podcast

TCC150 Series: Episode 4 - Marchant v Caswell [1976]

October 25, 2023 Keating Chambers
TCC150 Series: Episode 4 - Marchant v Caswell [1976]
Keating Chambers: The Podcast
More Info
Keating Chambers: The Podcast
TCC150 Series: Episode 4 - Marchant v Caswell [1976]
Oct 25, 2023
Keating Chambers

This is the fourth in a series of podcasts coming this year, all recorded to celebrate 150 years of the Technology and Construction Court (TCC). In each episode, Keating barristers will choose one leading case from the TCC and review its significance. 

In this special episode Sam Townend KC chairs a discussion between counsel who acted in the first reported case on ten year new-build home insurance policies, Marchant v Caswell [1976] 2 EGLR 23, Lord Grabiner KC (One Essex Court), Professor John Uff, and Dr Christopher Thomas KC.  The participants explain the key facts and summarise the principles derived from the case as well as discussing practice in the 1970s and the development of the TCC in the last 50 years.  

Please see below the time stamps of this episode:
0:00 - Introduction 
3.59 - Case summary 
9.43 - Introduction of speakers
18.35 - First Issue- whether the ten year new-build home warranty is a covenant running with the land? 
26.03 - Second Issue- whether liability under the Policy is triggered by notice of minor damage? 
32.43 - Third Issue- whether actual or constructive notice is sufficient to trigger liability, notwithstanding an express requirement for notice in writing? 
40.06 - Fourth Issue- enforceability of the arbitration agreement in a consumer insurance policy 
43.02 – Consequentials 
45.05- Practice in the 1970s and the development of the TCC

Please note that this podcast does not constitute legal advice and should not be relied on as such.

Show Notes

This is the fourth in a series of podcasts coming this year, all recorded to celebrate 150 years of the Technology and Construction Court (TCC). In each episode, Keating barristers will choose one leading case from the TCC and review its significance. 

In this special episode Sam Townend KC chairs a discussion between counsel who acted in the first reported case on ten year new-build home insurance policies, Marchant v Caswell [1976] 2 EGLR 23, Lord Grabiner KC (One Essex Court), Professor John Uff, and Dr Christopher Thomas KC.  The participants explain the key facts and summarise the principles derived from the case as well as discussing practice in the 1970s and the development of the TCC in the last 50 years.  

Please see below the time stamps of this episode:
0:00 - Introduction 
3.59 - Case summary 
9.43 - Introduction of speakers
18.35 - First Issue- whether the ten year new-build home warranty is a covenant running with the land? 
26.03 - Second Issue- whether liability under the Policy is triggered by notice of minor damage? 
32.43 - Third Issue- whether actual or constructive notice is sufficient to trigger liability, notwithstanding an express requirement for notice in writing? 
40.06 - Fourth Issue- enforceability of the arbitration agreement in a consumer insurance policy 
43.02 – Consequentials 
45.05- Practice in the 1970s and the development of the TCC

Please note that this podcast does not constitute legal advice and should not be relied on as such.