Blind Spots and Better Leaders with Jill Macauley

Definitely, Maybe Agile

Definitely, Maybe Agile
Blind Spots and Better Leaders with Jill Macauley
Dec 12, 2025 Season 3 Episode 203
Peter Maddison and Dave Sharrock

What happens when your greatest strength becomes your biggest blind spot? In this episode, Peter and Dave sit down with Jill Macauley, COO of Behavioral Essentials, to explore how self-awareness shapes better leadership. They dig into why even talented leaders struggle with identity shifts, how generational expectations are changing the workplace, and why the best coaches focus on small tweaks rather than complete overhauls. From the reluctant engineer-turned-manager to the chef who can't slow down, this conversation gets real about the grief of letting go of old identities and the messy work of looking in the mirror.

This week´s takeaway: 

  1. Your gifts become your blind spots when overused. That strength that got you promoted? It might be working against you now. The key is recognizing when speed becomes recklessness, when confidence becomes rigidity, or when expertise becomes tunnel vision.
  2. Identity shifts are a grieving process. Moving from individual contributor to leader to leader of leaders isn't just a promotion. It requires letting go of the identity you've built your career on, and that loss is real. Give yourself (and others) permission to struggle with it.
  3. Skip the woo-woo, ask "why" instead. Self-reflection doesn't have to feel soft or abstract. Simple questions like "Why did I react that way?" or "What role am I playing in this?" are pragmatic tools that work in any meeting, with any team.
Episode Artwork Blind Spots and Better Leaders with Jill Macauley 35:18 Episode Artwork Rethinking HR as a product with Josh Hill 40:54 Episode Artwork AI Tools for Product Managers: Beyond Just Writing User Stories 19:43 Episode Artwork Generative AI Readiness with Justin Trombold 40:40 Episode Artwork How AI is Transforming Banking Customer Service with Rick Delisi 43:07 Episode Artwork Empowering Organizations from the Inside with Barbara Whittmann 38:44 Episode Artwork Navigating Change Through Leadership and Culture with Hanna Bauer 48:23 Episode Artwork Stay Close to Your Customers (And Your Why) with Hussein Hallak 38:32 Episode Artwork Why Dedicated Teams FAIL (And What Actually Works Instead) 25:08 Episode Artwork How AI is Transforming UX and Agile Teams with Nick Cawthon 29:02 Episode Artwork The Hidden Problem With Customer Journey Mapping 17:59 Episode Artwork One Pizza Teams vs Two Pizza Teams: When Size Actually Matters 34:00 Episode Artwork Product Diseases and Vision-Driven Development with Radhika Dutt 36:29 Episode Artwork AI Agents: Friend or Foe? 16:19 Episode Artwork What Your Employees Are Really Thinking with James Warren 36:04 Episode Artwork Why Lean Startup Isn't Dead (And When You Need Something Bigger) 18:40 Episode Artwork Risk & Agile – Why Moving Fast Doesn’t Have to Break Things 19:09 Episode Artwork Cybersecurity Insights with Peter Buckley 27:20 Episode Artwork There Are No Safe Bets in Business Anymore 14:07 Episode Artwork AI and Knowledge Management with Derek Crager 30:47 Episode Artwork Building Remote Teams Through Culture with Leandro Cartelli 37:24 Episode Artwork Why Executive Buy-In Needs Both Strategy AND Tactics 15:50 Episode Artwork Product Manager Impact with Shobhit Chugh 33:28 Episode Artwork From Vision to Execution with Mark Reich 34:15 Episode Artwork Flow States in Remote Teams with Steven Puri 38:15