Middle Market Musings
Middle Market Musings
Episode 29 Matt Carroll, WestView Capital Partners
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Matt Carroll helps Andy and Charlie prove that Middle Market Musings is exactly as mature and insightful in 2023 as it was in 2022. Matt is a managing partner at WestView Capital Partners, a Boston-based private equity firm that recently closed on its $1 billion fifth fund. Matt has been a part of WestView since its inception in 2004. He charts the firm’s evolution into more intense pockets of industry focus while maintaining its stronghold as a leading investor of non-controlling equity. Matt ignites the discussion with his many passions – Boston College, family and helping younger people make their way in our business. He and Charlie swap Boston sports stories while Andy maintains a polite frozen smile.
Hello and welcome, ladies and gentlemen, to Middle Market Musings, a podcast dedicated to the people and ideas of the middle market. We're delighted that you have chosen to join us today. My name is Charlie Gifford of New Heritage Capital.
SPEAKER_03And I'm Eddie Greenberg of Greenberg Variations Capital. Our guest today is Matt Carroll, a managing partner at Westview Capital Park. Before we start, we'd like to thank our sponsors, New Heritage Capital and Greenberg Variations Capital, along with our media partner, Private Equity Professional Digest. We hope you enjoy this episode.
SPEAKER_02Matt Carroll, welcome to Middle Market Musings. How are you doing? I'm great.
SPEAKER_00Thanks for having me on, guys.
SPEAKER_02Did you lose a bet or something? I can't believe that you uh accepted our our our invitation to join us, but we're thrilled to grill you today and do everything we can to make you uncomfortable over the next 45 minutes. So thanks for uh agreeing to join us.
SPEAKER_00Absolutely. I'll survive it.
SPEAKER_02All right, I know you will. Okay, so let's let's dive in. First and foremost, the accent, is that Italian or well, I can't I can't exactly place it. Where's that from?
SPEAKER_00Why did I know that would be the first thing that you raised? Um even though we were brought up in the same general area. Um, no, I um I am from Boston. My family's from Boston. I've never lived away except a little bit professionally. The closer you grew up to Boston, the more harsh the accent is. And my family is originally from Malden, which is about as close to Boston as you can get without being in Boston. And we just progressively moved further away into the burbs. When I was little, my father helped us escape Malden, where he was from, and we went to Wakefield. And but now I live 35 miles away in Westford, and my daughters don't have accents and they mock mine. And a lot of the guys up there, if they didn't grow up in Lowell, they don't have an accent either. So I'm a little bit of a fish out of water, just 35 miles from where, you know, where I grew up.
SPEAKER_02I love it. I love it. And you know I give you heat because I know you can take it, but uh in all candor, you got a great story to tell, Matt. And uh you're incredibly self-deprecating, um, which uh resonates with me and resonates, I'm sure, with our audience.
SPEAKER_03But you Well, Char Charlie, in comparison to you, most people are self-deprecating. Yeah, right.
SPEAKER_02Well, but but Matt, let's start. I know uh we got we Boston College is uh some of your formative years. You mentioned you grew up in Malden. Tell us about uh what what happened at BC that turned you into uh Well before we go there, did did you go to high school?
SPEAKER_03Did you go to Malden Catholic?
SPEAKER_00No, no, it's so funny. I was just gonna say if my wife was editing this podcast, she would have come in and laughed and said, he didn't grow up in Malden. God, just stop it. Because I always say my family's from Malden, but I grew up in Wakefield. We left Malden when I was little. I am proud to say that that's where I came from, but in but but in clarity, I didn't grow up there. I grew up there in the summers because I asphalt paved for our family asphalt business. Um, but I lived in Wakefield. We got out of there. There was, you know, street corners that my father didn't want me standing on. So I thank him for that for the to this day. And to your Malton Catholic question, no, my dad was a Marine, didn't go to college. Only thing he knew was if I wanted to go to Boston College, which I found early and fell in love with, and I don't even know why, maybe because of Doug Flutie, like every other BC grad. But he said, you got to go to BC High. I said, we live in Wakefield, I'm not going to Dorchester. And I negotiated that back to Malden Catholic. And by the time eighth grade had come around, I had negotiated it back to Wakefield High School, which is all I wanted. And he went away on that topic and I went to Wakefield High.
SPEAKER_02Matt, you mentioned asphalt business. That was your family business.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. Um, so uh prior, prior to that, um my uncle and my all my uncles owned a bar in Everett, and they sold that in the mid-80s to give my cousins a career and a life. Um, and they founded Carol Asphalt Paving in 1985 when I was 12. And all I wanted to do was be around my cousins who I idolized. You know, they were tough Malden kids, and I had grown up looking up uh to them. And so I started working as a laborer on the wheelbarrow for them when I was about 13. Um, and I carried that through the end of high school. Um, and so I would stay there, I would stay there many nights during the week. I would work with them all day. It was unbelievably hard. And and it it, you know, I don't want to overplay it, but it it's kind of comical. It's kind of like the scene in Goodwill Hunting. All I wanted to do was be with them and pave. And they would look at me, you know, smoking cigarettes, drinking Budweiser heavy beers, and go, You're going to college, Matthew. And I'd say, What do you know? No, I just want to be here, work the barrel with you guys. You know, and I was little, I didn't know, and that was never gonna happen. And so um they, I think from the from, you know, it's a little bit cliche, but from the perspective of doing things right and full and heavy work ethic, that was installed in me. Um, yes, by my own father, but more so by my cousins and specifically my cousin Greg, um, who passed away at a young age, and and that was the end of the asphalt business in in the in 2007. Um, and right down to what I preach to my kids, I have four daughters. Um he was maniacal about sweeping up properly. And so it's also a little cliche. It's like the admiral's speech, make your bed. My version of that has always been sweep properly. When my kids don't sweep properly, I said, How could you do anything else well in life? If you can't sweep properly, fulsome, firm, not leaving a drop, we we can't move on from there. So sweep up properly has always been my message. And I and they they were just they were intense, intense, hardcore blue-collar work ethic guys. And I try to bring that to my white-collar life.
SPEAKER_03Matt, you uh, you know, we know you had your sights set on Boston College for school and and and went there. Having had that background, you know, with easy fit when you arrived, immediate love affair, or you know, some uh some growing pains?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, no, easy fit. I I I think I have a personality I can fit right in with everybody. And I had I had friends from all four corners of the kinds of kids that go to BC. Um, did I gravitate to a lot of the kids from Mass? Yeah. Um were were we teased for that? Were we called the Massholes? Yes. Um, but I have friends from all over the country, some of my best friends from all over the country. I think, look, the fact is the the um BC was founded as a blue-collar school and it grew up and it continues to grow up, and it's a global, fantastic place. But even when I went in uh I graduated in '95, you know, there was a lot of kids there that grew up with some privilege. That was very eye-opening to me. I thought the Cape was Whitehorse Beach in Plymouth. And I and then I went to school and all my friends went to these schools called St. Sebastian's and Belmont Hill. And I, well, where's that? It was only 15 miles away from me. I didn't know what those places were. And then they had houses in these places called Dennisport and Brewster and Chatham. And I said, Well, really? I go to the Cape too. Oh, where do you go? Plymouth. Yeah, that's not the Cape, Matt. Oh, it isn't? Oh, okay. You know, so it was a little eye-opening, but it wasn't terrible.
SPEAKER_02That's some good uh Massachusetts geography humor for those that aren't listening to uh that aren't familiar. So, Matt, I did some crack desktop research, which our listeners know uh that I'm known for. Uh, and I see that on the Westview uh website that you graduated Magna cum laude from Boston College. Um, and while my Latin is a little lacking, I think that speaks to some uh some high intellectual horsepower uh on your part. So clearly that uh was time well spent at BC and you gained a lot out of it and you did and you excelled quite a bit there.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I guess a great experience. I um I again a little cliche, but I am forever thankful for what BC gave me. I'm super active there now. I I um I'm one of a short group of folks that advised the investment banking uh group at the school. I'm really active on a number of other fronts there. I'm on the tech council and another, a bunch of other stuff. Um, you know, it was everything someone like me needed, and that's what that school was originally built for. It was great. Um, if I gave an advertisement for BC, and I share this with Andy Boynton, the dean of the business school all the time. Um, their balanced core curriculum with a management degree builds a well-rounded human. I hope I'm a well-rounded human with a moral compass. I hope I came into BC with that, but that's what they stand for. I believe passionately in that. My oldest daughter's a sophomore there. Um, so yeah, it was a great, it was a great experience.
SPEAKER_02And I think the uh the business undergraduate business school is the Carroll School of Management. I'm just gonna go by that. I'm just gonna assume that was because of the philanthropic generosity uh of Matt Carroll. Or maybe we could just move on. Is that a coincidence, maybe? Or yeah, no, no, no, no relation. Okay, maybe someday.
SPEAKER_00There you go.
SPEAKER_03Matt, I know you you you started off in investment banking. Do you remember when private equity kept came into your field of vision as a as a thing that you might want to get into?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I um I I really got a little bit lucky, again, forever thankful for these little sort of forks in the road. Um, so like I said, you know, my dad, my dad was a Marine, um, but it's not like I grew up in the projects. My father and you know, retired as a CIO of Cumberland Farms. He was a you know, smart guy, and but he had no contacts in in the high rises of Boston, zero. Um, I was uh I cold called for a Merrill Lynn stockbroker all through college at night. Um, took the train downtown. I finance major, gonna be a stockbroker, right? I mean, everyone in my town of Westford thinks that's what I am, so okay, fine. Um, and then I went to work for Lehman Brothers and I was dialing with, you know, two phones at the end of some guy's desk, and it was awful. And I said to my my father, I said, this is like the worst thing in the world. He said, I want you to call this woman Janet Hennessy. And I called Janet. She'd been a longtime family friend, controller of a business my father worked at years ago. Well, she was a controller at this firm called Advent International in 1993, 94. And I went over to see her at lunch during my terrible Lehman cold calling experience, told her that, and she said, All right, I'm gonna give you an internship. Quit that thing, start here Monday. Great. I was like a file clerk wearing like a suit with like Nike Air Max. I, you know, I think I was wearing my father's gold tote, you know, uh socks. It was ridiculous. I think I might have even worn suspenders to work because I thought that's what you did. It was, you know, I look back and it's just absurd. But I was I was in the accounting group, which was like one floor down from the deal jocks, and I got just enough exposure to guys who are now the guys who run that business. You know, Peter Brook was still there, you know, the founder of our industry. Uh John Brooke, his son, was a VP. Um, all these guys, and one of them grabbed me and explained to me what we all take as given, and all the young people now take as given. The conveyor belt of how does one get into private equity is so obvious to every college, you know, junior and senior. It wasn't that. They just basically told me this very simple fact. They said, You don't get this, do you? And I said, What do you mean? You're gonna go off to one of these things called an investment bank, that's also called corporate finance, or you're gonna go to one of these management consultants, they're gonna use you for two or three years, then you're gonna come here and you're gonna pound away. And this isn't exactly their words, but and then we're gonna use you for two or three years for your youthful exuberance and effort. And no matter how good or bad you are, we're gonna pat you on the ass and out you go to uh to business school. And I is that what I do? Is that is that how I get the keys to the kingdom? Okay, great. I'm gonna go do one of these investment banking things. So I had this summer where I really didn't work on any investment teams. I ran an errand for a medical investing team. I you know, I did nothing, but it was just enough to have a little resume. I was calculating common stock equivalents or some, you know, really menial things. Um, but I got a few interviews because I had, you know, good enough grades. Not a lot of schools interviewed at BC like they do today. And I went down to a Super Saturday at Dean Witter Reynolds on the 65th floor of the World Trade Center. And that little blurb on the resume, you know, Advent International, they pulled me out of Super Saturday, walked me over to the MD in the private capital group, and boom, I was off to the races. Love it. Love it. So how long were you at Dean Witter for, Matt? Um, two years. And in fact, it was even a little less than that because at the end of my two-year, you know, standard commitment, Morgan Stanley merged with slash bought Dean Witter. And if you wanted to execute on your third year, you had to go up to 1585 Broadway. They were putting pagers on kids' hips. All I wanted, my sole goal was to come back to was to come back to Boston and go private equity. Before I took the Dean Witter um job, I was way down the line to go straight from college to Summit. And all those guys, I was going to be the grunt to the grunts. Those are all some of my best friends to this day, notably John Carroll over at Summit, who everyone thinks is my older brother, but he's just one of my best friends. Um, and Joe Trusty was a weave VP, um, became a great friend for years and a mentor. Um, gave me great advice in my career over time. But I knew I wanted private equity. So I was there, I was, everyone knew it. Matt Carroll's here in New York with his terrible accent for 730 days and he's gone. It was all to get to that private equity job. I didn't even have to do the full 730 days.
SPEAKER_02So two years in Dean Witter um slash Morgan Stanley, and then back to Boston. You got the your your goal of getting back to Boston and getting a job in private equity led you to Triumph Capital, right?
SPEAKER_00Yep, yep. They were kind of a newer name. They were the former Boston office of Drexel Burnham and um had gotten into the principal business in the early 90s, now had a traditional fund right when I came of about 600 million. And they were doing sort of structured equity control and non-control deals. That was the best opportunity I had here in Boston. A couple of great guys hired me. Mark Noonan, who was a Harvard hockey captain, Arlington guy, lit right up on me in my interview. The reason I got the job, I always say, is he asked, he asked me who my professors were at BC. And when I didn't name Father Frank Murphy, he said, Well, let's just check if you had this guy. And he dialed up Father Frank and said, I need you to pull a file. I want to see how this kid did in your class. And uh Father Frank said, I know that kid. He wore hockey pants every day and sat in the front row. He and he and he and he never missed class, and I get and he had an A-.
SPEAKER_02Wait, what the what the hell are hockey pants?
SPEAKER_00I mean, what do you know? Like windpants, you know. Ah, I didn't know those were hockey pants.
SPEAKER_03Matt, Triumph to Westview. Tell us how you got there and what Westview was like when you arrived.
SPEAKER_00So I did my three years at Triumph, and at the tail end of that time, um I decided I wasn't going to go back to business school, had an opportunity to stay at Triumph, but I was starting to sort of spend my time and thematically in healthcare services, healthcare outsourcing. And I had um I had brought in and led a deal I had no right doing at age 26, but they let me do it. It was a small check in a company called Logistic Air. Um and I, three months after I made that investment, I went and carried the CEO's bags as head of corporate development and was just kind of his lackey. And that that became my MBA um for the bulk of the next four years from like 00 to 04. And I didn't intend to do it that long. I wanted to get back into private equity, but candidly there wasn't a lot of spots. Um, I scraped and clawed a little bit, uh, didn't know when I'd get back in. And when we exited Logisticare in 04, I was starting to talk to some folks again, including my former uh boss and you know big brother Rick Williams, who's one of my Westview partners. And he said, Um, yeah, I can give you an opinion on those firms, but why don't you come to my house tonight? And he said, Look, I was about a week from calling you. I'm starting this firm Westview. I want you in from the first day. I'm doing it with Carlo von Schroeder, who's leaving Weston Presidio. We're both doing it super amically. The founders of those firms are investing. Um and what are we going to do? I said. Now, the fact is, is I probably would have followed Rick into the fire no matter what we were doing. But what he said was exactly what I wanted, and is exactly what I would tell you is the you know, the stock and trade of Westview then and today. So um the answer is what was Westview? Westview was nothing but an idea when I came. Um, and my partner Jonathan and I came with Carlo and Rick and our other partner, John Turner, and there were five of us at the start. And we started Westview, and the whole um idea was lower middle market control agnostic. Not a foreign topic to Charlie. We're we're competitors here and there, been friends for a long time about that. But um, the whole thing was that even in 04, forget about the last 18 years, private equity was growing up, maturing market segment. All of our peers, Summit TA, all the great names in Boston and everywhere else were raising bigger and bigger funds. And we looked at it that there was a pocket. It's hard to use the word a pocket or a void about private equity anymore.
SPEAKER_03But I I I think I think today invests, you know, financial speak calls it white space.
SPEAKER_00Okay. We can call it white space, green field, but it was a there was, and I and I would contend all maybe a little narrower, a pocket or a void um below those guys, and yet above the SBICs and fundless sponsors and other firms and little maybe VCs that can do $5, 10, or $15 million. So we we went out the first fund was about $200 million, and we were the $10 to $30 million check writing guys. Um, again, wedged between the high and the low from a size perspective. Um and fast forward to today, we're kind of 20 to 60 million because they've gone up. So our pocket has slid. We've remained true to lower middle market, so we come on the scene as low as 10 or 15 of revenue, play comfortably right up to 100, you know, 50 to 200 million of enterprise value. And um the fact is, is there wasn't, and to my shock and delight to this day, besides Charlie and I, there's not a lot of firms in the lower middle market that will genuinely do a minority recap, put predominantly, if not exclusively, liquidity capital in the front door, out the back into shareholder hands, and not take not need control of that owner-operator's baby. And that's not everything we do, but it's about half our deals are non-control. And even our control deals, the predominance of them, we own 60, maybe 70%. We want management teams who retain probably more equity than the market would bear.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, and we are very much cut from that same cloth as as you mentioned. We always say that control is a spectrum. And I think that the majority of investors out there see the quid pro quo of capitalism is I give you, Mr. CEO or Mrs. CEO, all this money and I get control in return. And we think that, and I know you guys feel the same way, that there is a middle ground to play. And um, look, if you have to fire this CEO, if you're a control investor, you're you're you're you're you're way behind the IRR clock. And so we think that finding it's more important to find people that are long-term bullish or as we say long-term greedy and want to invest and do a leverage buy-in, not a leverage buy out and and buy into that growth story.
SPEAKER_00So yeah, and and that I'll take it a step, I'll take it a step further. I I I go out on a, you know, on a on my soapbox on this, I say in the lower middle market, I think that many folks overvalue control. We don't use the word control premium. These folks are the company. Heck, sometimes they're the town the company's in. If you think that you're gonna wake up in an ivory tower in Boston or New York and decide to sell because you want to or you want to execute on something, good luck if you don't have the respect and the relationship with that management team and executing it. I've often jokingly referred to that as the pick your nose risk. If I wake up one day and I decide I want to sell some company and my management team's not on board and I send in the number one buyer, the best buyer that should own it, and I got this great company and I have control and aren't I grand, that strategic buyer walks into the conference room at my company, my CEO just has to pick their nose. I have lost how good was my control? I have defanged my control right there. So the most important thing you can do, have a relationship, earn their respect. Our tagline that I've used forever and folks have adopted is be helpful but unintrusive. Whether you own control or not, know your role, know what you can help at. Otherwise, leave them alone. I wish every company on Friday sent me an email on how their sales went. But if you're gonna call a CEO like that, That is never going to endear you to a lower middle market owner operator. They have too many things to do.
SPEAKER_03My perspective as an investment banker, I think Charlie has heard me say this, is that while control is a spectrum, it's also a disposition. And you know, both both of your firms have been successful with you know slightly different dispositions that include the you know the kind of deference that you're talking about. But you know, when I'm relating to clients and I'm explaining that, I'm also explaining the other disposition, which is that if you're selling your business particularly at an elevated multiple in a change of control transaction uh to a buyout fund, they are punching that clock on realizing their IRR. And their theory of how they justified paying 11 or 12 times for the business does not include status quo all the way all the time. And you know, the the the good investors with that disposition, of course, are you know, they're respectful of owners and management who are who are sticking around. But if you do a deal with a control-minded investor, you need to be prepared for them to exercise the prerogatives of control.
SPEAKER_00No, I I don't disagree. We always say, you know, I always say, hey, that, you know, again, we do control deals, but I'll say, hey, doesn't make them bad people, doesn't make us right and them wrong. But that said, we're looking for managers who think with their stock certificate, not their W-2, and they are already punching the clock. They punch the clock every day. They operate with a sense of entrepreneurial urgency. They don't need me tasering them in the hip every week because my IRR clock has started. So again, you're right, it's a different disposition, it's a different flavor of ice cream. That's just, we're looking for folks that they get up every day and kick ass and and get after it. Not everyone does that.
SPEAKER_02You're listening to Middle Market Musings brought to you by New Heritage Capital and Greenbird Variations Capital.
SPEAKER_03Westview today, uh, how would you describe? I mean, just just control is a continuum. So is you know, degree of industry focus. Uh, much more industry focused now than I mean, you know, initially industry agnostic. How has that evolved?
SPEAKER_00When we started, if you sort of said what does Westview stand for, you'd be much more centered on lower middle market control agnostic. That remains absolutely as true now as it did then. But we were, in fact, to use the word that's kind of become a dirty word, we were a little more generalist. Um, but as everyone from myself and Jonathan and all my next group of folks came along, we've really built the firm and where our brand is more commonly known, but not by everyone, but most, 75-80% the continuum of software and services. So, with that, those are the sectors most commonly associated with growth equity. That term didn't even exist when we started. But what is growth equity anyway? It's sort of moderately levered or not levered at all, minority recaps. I mean, they're not really funding significant operating losses, building of factories, or working capital. It's really just another form of buyout with not a lot of leverage and oftentimes doing minority. That's what we were doing from the get-go. It's what Charlie's been doing. Um, what we've overlaid increasingly every year, it's an interesting interesting that you made that question, is we always point that out. We've become far more sector thematic. Early on, I had to be that way. I focus on healthcare technology and outsourcing revenue cycle and payer cost containment, which is where I came from with the logistic care thing. If you're going to be in healthcare, you better know what the heck you're talking about. You can't go running down to Nashville and be a generalist. They don't want to hear from you. And so you had to be more thematic. But what's happened is that's permeated all over the firm where we have pockets of expertise that, you know, to some, we look like a specialist fund. Some people would say, oh, they're revenue cycle, they're expert, healthcare technology, you know, payer services. Great. I'm proud of that. Manage IT services, we've got three IT MSPs. We look like some of the TMT funds, the great names around. We're not them. We're not trying to be them, but in certain verticals, we're a real someone. More recently in life sciences, we've done five life science outsourcing businesses, three in the last 15 months.
SPEAKER_02Now, what was the uh the size of the first uh Wesley fund? 195. And what is it now?
SPEAKER_00So um we just are closing on our target and hard cap of a billion dollars. Okay. And that's our fund five, 18 years after we started.
SPEAKER_02You don't usually hear people investing a billion out of a billion dollar fund as lower middle market investors. How do you maintain that tenacity and focus that created the success of investing out of a $195 million fund versus a billion dollar fund?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, no, it's a good question. You know, the funny thing is we're really proud of our growth. We've, you know, we went kind of just trajectory-wise, $195, $325, $440, $700, and now a billion. And on one hand, you know, I'm like I said, I'm proud of that, but that's pedestrian compared to some of our peers who, you know, went $200, $800, $1,500, $250. Um, I think our LPs love us for not doing that. Um, that we could have done that. It's not what we want to do. It's not what we stand for. It's not our brand, it's not our franchise. So we've grown, but prudently, but our average check size hasn't grown that much. Early on, we would bring in LPs a little more frequently. Um, so our check size has grown, but only a little bit. The pocket has slid right as funds that used to be at $800 are now running $4 billion funds. Um, and and lastly, and probably most uh importantly, and succinctly answering the question, in our first fund we made 11 investments. In this fund, we'll probably make about 16, 17 maybe. And in the next fund, we'll make 18 or 19.
SPEAKER_03So, Matt, I I heard what you were saying before, and I thought, you know, well stated by you, describing the degree of industry focus that you've developed in selected uh silos. As you've done that and the uh funds have become larger, have you hired differently or engaged operating talent differently to kind of meet table stakes expectations uh with targets?
SPEAKER_00So, so so two things. Um, have we hired differently? No, but we talk about it all the time. How do we both remain flexible and able to platoon for one another, but also continue to deepen the sector theme? So, what that means is up at the partner level, you're incredibly thematic. Down through principal and VP, you're pretty thematic. You're not bouncing down the hall to do an industrial deal if you're the life sciences guy. And at associate, we keep it very generalist. I think it's great for the associates to get a broader experience. As I often say to folks when we bring them in, is say here's the good thing about Westview for you. When you leave here, if you leave here in two or three years, if you have made the decision in your mid to late 20s, you want to be buyout guy, you'll have done some of that experience here. You want to be growth equity guy or gal, you'll have that. So we have sort of a flexibility that I think for a young person offers a fantastic associate experience. But the but the answer is the older you are, the more thematic you are. That's part one. Part two, another really important question, and one we just spent the fall talking to people about, we have very distinctly not done operating partners, et cetera. Why? Our flavor of ice cream, the little pocket of what we're looking for, it's not that companies don't benefit from those, and I'm not negative selling that role. We have entrepreneurs who don't want that. Some want help, but not as heavier a touch. That tends to be what we're going after. And the fact is, is we've probably undersold one of the biggest badge of honors we have, is we've got well over 35 of our executives are investors in our fund. Those are resources that function. I I could, I could, I could write a I could add to my um website tomorrow, and I could make you think I have this huge operating partner network and I would be branded as such. The fact is, is we have them. They're just a slightly different version, a lighter touch version of operating partner.
SPEAKER_02Okay, so that's um a great segue into the next question because uh back to my crack desktop research. I was looking at your website. And one thing I've always thought uh interesting about the Westview model, and I I think it is a little bit different because by my count, I think you have 14 investment professionals or thereabouts, and six of which are at the managing partner or general partner level, which I think is is much less than you know your peer group. Um and so maybe you could take that idea. I know you don't list operating partners on the web on your website, but talk a little bit more about staffing. When you think about, I think it's around 22 portfolio companies and six GP management general partners, managing partners. How do you guys think about that? Because again, as compared to your peer group, I think from a headcount perspective, you guys are doing a lot more with less.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, well, I mean, simplistic math is I I I I forget the number of actives we have right now, but um, let's call it 20 or 22. I think you you might have counted it, but um if you think about that, that's three to five per partner. That's about right. So when folks asked us, they say, you know, well, how do you how do you do how do you do the next four or five years and you go make 18 or 19 investments? It's basically one in, one out.
SPEAKER_03Matt, what is uh your current role at Westview and how is it changing?
SPEAKER_00My partner Jonathan and I are are now managing partners coming into fund five. Um that's a a little bit much ado about nothing. We have a, by design, a very simplistic, non-bureaucratic operating model. We don't spend a lot of time running the firm, if you will. So my role really hasn't changed significantly. A little more active on day-to-day, but again, what is day-to-day? Day to day is go find and manage great investments and work with companies. But um, so it really hasn't changed much. You know, I uh like I'm on the investment committee. I'm one of four managing partners with Rick and Carlo, who, you know, early founders of the firm. Um, but ultimately we're all managing directors in that sense of the word. We are all out there to go make and run investments. Um, so that's really, you know, not a lot, not a lot changes.
SPEAKER_03Best manager of people you've ever worked with.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, you know, I would I would say John Shermian at Logistic Care, my mentor, he's been an investor in all our funds, super empowering of his people. Great, right? Standard issue kind of comment, but that's what he did, number one. And as a CEO, and I've taken this to all my CEOs, not that they all do exactly this, but I watched it both inside and outside Logistic Hair. He always had his musings, and it was musings from the corner office. And as Logistic Hair grew significantly, seven or eight times in revenue in the four years I was there, um, it kept everyone connected with the mission and rowing the boat. When I come into investments, oftentimes our CEOs know everyone's name. By the time we leave, absolutely not. How do they connect with the entire organization? Because you can't walk all the halls anymore. It's too many halls. So I always just love that element. A very simplistic thing was he wrote weekly, monthly from the corner office, what are we doing out there? We won an RFP. We did this, we're doing great in Virginia, we're doing that. So I just think those are two attributes that I really loved. And there's other attributes, but that I always took away as um fantastic.
SPEAKER_03You know, I can't remember, Charlie, uh uh which one of us came up with the name Metal Market New Things. So it was kind of was it like a group thing?
SPEAKER_02I just want to be very clear for the those listening. Andy was bitching about that the name, and uh it was my persistence that finally paid off, and I'm glad that I did.
SPEAKER_03Charlie kept taking polls of of different constituencies until he he found one that supported middle market musings. My candidate, I have to say I'm I'm on board with musings now, but what do you think of this? My my name was middle market mixtape.
SPEAKER_02It's just like mixtape is too close.
SPEAKER_00It's just I'm a slang guy too. That's coming from a slang. But you're also you're gonna suggest like your college girlfriend made you the mixtape.
SPEAKER_03That was that was that was exactly that was exactly the vibe I was going for. But I'm on board now. This the the this is sale, but I guess this is a characteristically backhanded way of saying that middle market musings was all my friend Charlie's doing.
SPEAKER_02And he uses the term friend loosely. I was gonna say, you know, Matt, talking to you and and uh is it's always a pleasure. It reminds me of talking to a guy that I think a lot of people in Boston looked up to as kind of the the kind of the the a mentor to many, and that's Marty Mannion of of Summit. Um, and you remind me a lot of him. And Marty, for our listeners, ran Summit's investment committee for 25 plus years, and I feel very fortunate to call him a friend. And I've been threatening to try to drag him onto middle market musings, and hopefully one day uh I'll be uh successful in doing so. But you also mentioned, you know, the summit model, which is interesting. I always feel like it's similar to how you all talk about your business. How how do you compare it um, you know, with what you do in talking to your your buddy JC over there, um who I know is a very senior guy as well.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. Um, well, so like I said, I I you know I started early just as a wee intern at Advent. I almost went to Summit. I've always had just fantastic respect for the heritage of private equity in this town. And it really starts with Advent Summit TA. So I I always, you know, Summit broke my heart when they didn't hire me as an associate. Um, and we won't go there. We can do that one over a beer. Um, but I there was always such great things about their model that I loved. And and and number one is the hustle and the picking up the phone. And that's obviously evolved. There's a lot more people who do that. We still do that. We're just a little more targeted to answer your question and selective or sniper shot and thematic with our calling because we don't do it at scale. I think you either have to do it at absolute scale like they do, or very targeted. We've chosen very targeted. So there's a lot of parallels. And in fact, I mean, I'm not embarrassed to say it. We were there to try to fill not the void they left, but the pocket that that they left behind. You know, you know, one of our LPs said, you know what we love? Closest thing we've seen in years to old school summit TA. I was flattered. Interesting. That's interesting. And and then, and then they said, no, number number two, best all weather strategy we've seen in a while. And I said, you know what? You you you get us. That's what I want people to see about us. We invest in managed, profitable growth businesses, sleep at night businesses. Everyone can make a mistake. We've had a couple. These are good, solid growers. Um, I also hold Marty Mannion up like a god because of who he was all these years as I aspired to try to be someone in this business or whatever. And just funny that you mentioned him. I barely know him. I've always known him just a little bit. Um, and a couple of years ago, I went uh golfing with a bunch of my buddies, including JC, and Marty came and they threw out some foursoms, and next thing you know, poor Marty Mannion was stuck with me for two out of three rounds. And it was pouring rain at Streamsong. And he was probably like, What the hell am I doing here with all these younger guys running around in the rain, having a few beers? And yet he and he probably didn't know this because I certainly wouldn't let on and I wouldn't act this way. But I was almost, I don't get starstruck, but I was starstruck because he's Marty Mannion. He never knew that. I don't know if he'll ever hear this. I hope he never does.
SPEAKER_02Uh well, your secret's safe with me. Uh, I think the only people listen to this are like, you know, one or two of my uh uh relatives or Andes as well. So, but anyway, that's a great story. I appreciate you saying that.
SPEAKER_03It's uh nice to hear. It makes me wonder if uh tomorrow you couldn't work in private equity or in the finance industry, what would you do?
SPEAKER_00Um, I I my wife tells me all the time that she thinks I should do it starting tomorrow. Um, I have always had a side hustle, and that side hustle is, and I know you think it's gonna be oh, I said you think I'm gonna say I sell I sell Jordan sneakers.
SPEAKER_02Wait a minute, let us guess.
SPEAKER_00Um my side hustle has always been that I go out of my way with my time and effort to help young kids get into this business, not just BC kids, Bentley kids, Babson kids, the schools I was going to, if BC didn't let me in, and I put a lot of kids into this business, and I always say every day, build your bank account and your funeral line. And I'm building my funeral line.
SPEAKER_02That in all honesty, that doesn't surprise me. I thought your wife was gonna say a teacher, because I feel like you're incredibly generous with your time. And if I was a 25, 26, 28, 7 year old, I can't think of a better person to work for than a guy like you. And I think again, that you know, back to the Marty thing and not to blow so much sunshine your way and his way. You guys have that in common. You're always thinking about look, we're we we operate in an apprenticeship business, and you're only going to be as talented. Well, your talent will be really come to the forefront if you're mentored by people that take the time to help you along the way. So I'm not surprised that your wife said that.
SPEAKER_03So I I uh advise a uh a group of kids at the University of Delaware in the private markets club. And it's you know also been a great experience. And Charlie and I actually did a podcast with them where we we interviewed one another. And uh by the end of it, even they were bored.
SPEAKER_02Okay, so Matt, you know, bringing this conversation full circle, dying to know about your relationships with your cousins who drank Bud Heavies and smoking cigarettes. Do they look at you and be like, ah, there's the suit? And look at him, he's not one of us anymore. Or how is your relationship? You know, you you're done good, man. You're done real good. And how is it? What's that relationship like?
SPEAKER_00Um so I don't, I guess I don't 100% know. And I operate and carry myself every day in fear of how they would judge me more than anyone listening to this. That I never act that way, that I'm never that way. Um you know, um my cousin Greg, who ran the paving company, he died of cancer young and had two kids in in Maldon. You got me. And um you know, so one of my one of my one of my real big things was I always felt like you know, how would he shit how would he judge me? And um so I put his two kids to Arlington Catholics before I had really made any real money and get them out of Malden the same way I did. And so I just sorry, I I just always operate that way with all my I a lot of cousins, like a lot of family, you know, I would never ever want them to think anything other than he's the same old hammerhead, funny guy that we grew up with. You know, they're the only ones that call me Matthew, you know, he's the same Matthew, he's a good guy, he's been super generous, you know, just I'm the same person, you know, I don't act any different. Um but I but but it is funny. You sorry, you strike a chord. I just I care more about how my family thinks of me. You know, my I'm I'm I know they're proud and they cheer me on, but I would never ever want them to think anything other than 100% humility and gratitude for that, you know.
SPEAKER_03That was great. We might want to end on that, but just in case we want to end on a lighter note, I'm gonna I'm gonna ask the two of you a uh a question. Um as you both may be aware, uh Boston has had greater than average distinction in professional sports in the in the past 20 years. So, question to each of you most memorable in-person Boston sports event or personal encounter with a Boston athlete.
SPEAKER_02I I've been uh over very uh fortunate to have witnessed a lot, but there's nothing like your first time. No, Andy, not that first time. But the uh Pats 0-1 Super Bowl when they were 14-point dogs to the greatest show on turf in New Orleans, and I went down there with my old man uh and my brother, thinking that you know, no, not a chance in hell they're gonna beat the Rams, and they pulled off that upset. Uh, I I don't think anything else compares to that, for me at least.
SPEAKER_00Um years after he retired, I ended up in a uh in a bar in Lowell, um having a beer with Mickey Ward, who to me was like a god in a different way than Marty Manion was a god. Um, because I'm a huge boxing fan. Uh funny enough, what was Mickey Ward's job growing up? He paved roads, mostly highways, operated the steamroller. But um, and again, you just sort of I almost didn't want to meet him. I didn't want to hang out with him because to me he was this god, and now I was just hanging out with a dude. And um, but that was fun.
SPEAKER_02Hey, Matty, was uh Mickey Ward wearing suspenders when you saw him or not? Like you did on your first day of work? No suspenders. No, no, no, yeah. Well, listen, um not surprisingly, I think the uh this last 45 minutes has been uh well, first there'll be 45 minutes, you never get back, but uh from our perspective, 45 minutes really well spent. So grateful for your uh willingness to engage with us here and uh wish you and your partners continued great success.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, thank you. Same to you guys. I appreciate it. And oh, by the way, you're on time on budget. In fact, one minute under. That's pretty impressive.
SPEAKER_01That's not me.
SPEAKER_00That's another trait we didn't hit on on me. Late to everything by three minutes. Terrible, terrible habit.
SPEAKER_03Thank you for joining us for this episode of Middle Market Musics. We'd like to extend our sincere thanks to Matt Carroll for joining us today, as well as our sponsors, New Heritage Capital and Greenberg Variations Capital. Thanks as well to our editor, Jason Zapolla. If you enjoyed today's podcast, we'd encourage you to like and follow Middlemarket Musics on Spotify, Apple, or whichever provider you use to access podcasts. And of course, feel free to share with your friends. Thanks again, and look forward to catching you on the next one.