When Failure Makes You Question Your Creative Calling

The Thriving Christian Artist

The Thriving Christian Artist
When Failure Makes You Question Your Creative Calling
Feb 17, 2026
Matt Tommey: Artist, Best-Selling Author, Speaker, Entrepreneur and Artist Mentor

Send a text

One honest mistake can feel like a verdict on your calling. We’ve been there—rejected shows, failed pieces, spirals of self-doubt—and we know how quickly disappointment tries to rewrite your identity. Today we walk through a clear, grace-filled path to recover emotionally and spiritually after creative setbacks, so you can return to the studio lighter, wiser, and free.

We start by naming how disappointment opens the door to lies and why artists are uniquely vulnerable when work feels personal. Then we draw a sharp line between conviction and condemnation: conviction invites growth and intimacy, while condemnation sentences you to shame. From there, we share a practical five-step process you can use any time things go sideways: separate facts from identity, expose condemnation out loud, re-anchor yourself in the truth of who you are in Christ, let the situation teach instead of torment, and take one simple step in the opposite spirit—whether that’s a sketch, an hour in the studio, or an honest conversation. Along the way, Matt shares a recent misstep from his own practice and how he stopped the spiral by returning to scripture, prayer, and small, faithful action.

You’ll also join us in a guided moment of prayer to hear God’s heart for you and ask for specific wisdom for your next step. We close by inviting testimony and community, because sharing your story breaks isolation and strengthens others to believe the truth. If you’re tired of letting one bad day redefine your worth, this conversation will help you build creative resilience, renew your mind, and create from God’s pleasure—not for it.

If this resonated, subscribe, leave a review, and share it with an artist who needs freedom today. Want deeper support? Explore our Foundations Course for Christian artists and start rebuilding on solid ground.

Fuel Your Creative Calling with Weekly Encouragement
Join thousands of Christian artists who are growing in faith, creativity, and purpose.

Subscribe to The Thriving Christian Artist Weekly and receive powerful, faith-filled content every week—designed to encourage your heart, spark your creativity, and equip you to walk boldly in your God-given calling as an artist.

👉 Click here. It’s free. It’s faith-filled. And it’s just for you.

Episode Artwork When Failure Makes You Question Your Creative Calling 13:29 Episode Artwork What Happens When You Say "Yes" To Your Creative Calling 8:50 Episode Artwork 5 Biblical Principles To Transform Your Creative Life 40:58 Episode Artwork The Gap Between Your Creative Calling & Confidence 8:20 Episode Artwork Seven Proven Ways Artists Are Earning More Now 25:26 Episode Artwork The Humility Trap 12:40 Episode Artwork 5 Steps to Rewire Your Brain for Creativity 13:10 Episode Artwork 5 Biblical Declarations To Break Shame And Build Unshakable Identity In Christ 12:44 Episode Artwork Why Your Art Makes God Smile Every Time 12:11 Episode Artwork 5 Encouraging Bible Verses Every Christian Artist Needs 40:22 Episode Artwork Why the Great Masters Never Worried If Their Art Was 'Christian Enough' (And Why You Shouldn't Either) 14:48 Episode Artwork 5 Steps to Create Art With The Holy Spirit (My Exact Process) 15:51 Episode Artwork 5 Signs God Is Calling You As An Artist 11:20 Episode Artwork Jesus The Artisan: Five Creative Principles For A Faithful Life 31:23 Episode Artwork How Nature, Faith & Art Bring Healing and Hope - An Interview with Nancy Thygesen 34:58 Episode Artwork 3 Ways to Overcome Creative Block (with Christ) 22:38 Episode Artwork Textile Artist Creates Works that Inspire Connection: An Interview with Pamela Loewen 30:08 Episode Artwork 3 Ways Seeing God as Artist Changes Everything 16:26 Episode Artwork Unlock the Secrets of Your Right Brain: An Interview with Karen DeLoach 30:33 Episode Artwork 5 Simple Steps to Creating Your Art With God 30:55 Episode Artwork Western Landscape Artist Paints God's Glory in the Sky: An Interview with Phil Bob Borman 38:43 Episode Artwork What Feels Like Delay May Be Divine Direction 21:36 Episode Artwork From Pain to Purpose through Creative Healing: An Interview with Karen Bulbuk 36:29 Episode Artwork 5 Ways to Honor God with Your Art 18:02 Episode Artwork Artist Reveals Secrets to Creating with Purpose in Multiple Genres: An Interview with Rob Dinwoodie 33:22