{"version":"1.0.0","segments":[{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":0.285,"endTime":0.975,"body":"Hello, and welcome to"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":0.975,"endTime":1.755,"body":"the fire science show."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1.755,"endTime":2.805,"body":"Episode 57."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":3.105,"endTime":6.645,"body":"Hope your guys are having"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":3.105,"endTime":6.645,"body":"a great summertime and some"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":6.645,"endTime":9.795,"body":"fire science in between"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":6.645,"endTime":9.795,"body":"will not hurt for sure."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":10.38,"endTime":13.233,"body":"Today I have a subject"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":10.38,"endTime":13.233,"body":"that's quite difficult and,"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":13.476,"endTime":16.296,"body":"me as well, I don't have"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":13.476,"endTime":16.296,"body":"great expertise in this."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":16.506,"endTime":19.537,"body":"So I, I was very happy to"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":16.506,"endTime":19.537,"body":"learn firsthand from the world,"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":19.537,"endTime":22.656,"body":"leading the expert, and the"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":19.537,"endTime":22.656,"body":"topic is structural fire doing"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":22.662,"endTime":24.127,"body":"and structural fire modeling."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":24.322,"endTime":27.557,"body":"in fact, I've invited"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":24.322,"endTime":27.557,"body":"professor Thomas Gernay from"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":27.557,"endTime":29.386,"body":"John Hopkins university to."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":29.827,"endTime":32.226,"body":"Bring me in line , on"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":29.827,"endTime":32.226,"body":"the, how structural"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":32.226,"endTime":33.337,"body":"fire engineering works."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":33.337,"endTime":35.587,"body":"What's the newest"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":33.337,"endTime":35.587,"body":"developments in this field."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":36.126,"endTime":38.19,"body":"And, what's the future"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":36.126,"endTime":38.19,"body":"in front of that."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":38.685,"endTime":41.835,"body":"Thomas is well known for his"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":38.685,"endTime":41.835,"body":"considerable amount of knowledge"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":42.135,"endTime":45.435,"body":"put into the world of structural"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":42.135,"endTime":45.435,"body":"fire engineering literature."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":45.765,"endTime":48.735,"body":"And he's involved with"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":45.765,"endTime":48.735,"body":"one of the primary"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":48.735,"endTime":51.255,"body":"structural fire engineering"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":48.735,"endTime":51.255,"body":"codes that is severe."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":51.805,"endTime":54.415,"body":"so he has first hand"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":51.805,"endTime":54.415,"body":"knowledge, not only from"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":54.415,"endTime":55.455,"body":"the perspective of a."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":55.825,"endTime":58.135,"body":"Researcher structural"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":55.825,"endTime":58.135,"body":"engineer, but also as"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":58.135,"endTime":62.0,"body":"someone who's developing new"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":58.135,"endTime":62.0,"body":"tools  for us all to use."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":62.0,"endTime":63.68,"body":"So that's a really"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":62.0,"endTime":63.68,"body":"great perspective."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":63.68,"endTime":66.8,"body":"And you'll see through"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":63.68,"endTime":66.8,"body":"the interview that we are"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":66.92,"endTime":69.83,"body":"touching and referring to"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":66.92,"endTime":69.83,"body":"that all the time, because"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":69.83,"endTime":71.6,"body":"his perspective is unique."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":71.973,"endTime":74.429,"body":"So I hope that despite the"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":71.973,"endTime":74.429,"body":"little summer slack, most"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":74.429,"endTime":78.899,"body":"of us have, we can join me"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":74.429,"endTime":78.899,"body":"in this episode and learn a"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":78.899,"endTime":82.759,"body":"bit about the importance of"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":78.899,"endTime":82.759,"body":"structural fire engineering."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":84.959,"endTime":87.389,"body":"And the role that it"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":84.959,"endTime":87.389,"body":"plays in a performance"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":87.389,"endTime":88.619,"body":"based design framework."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":89.069,"endTime":89.399,"body":"Okay."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":89.459,"endTime":91.769,"body":"I guess that's enough"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":89.459,"endTime":91.769,"body":"of introduction."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":92.099,"endTime":93.059,"body":"It's a good episode."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":93.059,"endTime":94.739,"body":"You want to listen"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":93.059,"endTime":94.739,"body":"it to the end?"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":95.309,"endTime":96.749,"body":"It's well worth it."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":96.809,"endTime":99.599,"body":"So let's spin the intro"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":96.809,"endTime":99.599,"body":"and jump into the episode."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":122.866,"endTime":123.606,"body":"Hello, everybody."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":123.606,"endTime":125.316,"body":"Welcome to the"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":123.606,"endTime":125.316,"body":"Fire Science Show."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":125.736,"endTime":126.726,"body":"You guys ask."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":126.726,"endTime":128.406,"body":"And I deliver here with me, Dr."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":128.406,"endTime":130.656,"body":"Thomas Gernay from John"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":128.406,"endTime":130.656,"body":"Hopkins University."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":130.701,"endTime":131.301,"body":"Hey, Thomas."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":131.431,"endTime":133.291,"body":"Hey,"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":131.431,"endTime":133.291,"body":"Wojciech, how are you?"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":133.491,"endTime":134.201,"body":"I'm very good."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":134.201,"endTime":136.301,"body":"I'm very happy to"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":134.201,"endTime":136.301,"body":"have you on the"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":136.421,"endTime":136.691,"body":"just, how are you?"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":136.931,"endTime":137.768,"body":"And finally talk with"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":137.794,"endTime":140.824,"body":"someone about numerical"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":137.794,"endTime":140.824,"body":"modeling of structures."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":141.154,"endTime":143.205,"body":"for a nice start."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":143.365,"endTime":145.885,"body":"I've heard there was a"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":143.365,"endTime":145.885,"body":"really nice event lately"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":145.885,"endTime":148.321,"body":"in Italy, summer school"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":145.885,"endTime":148.321,"body":"on, structural modeling."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":148.321,"endTime":152.221,"body":"And I keep hearing about"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":148.321,"endTime":152.221,"body":"this event from everywhere."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":152.491,"endTime":154.381,"body":"Like everyone is telling"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":152.491,"endTime":154.381,"body":"me how great it was."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":154.381,"endTime":156.776,"body":"And, I know the viewpoint"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":154.381,"endTime":156.776,"body":"of participants."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":156.776,"endTime":159.806,"body":"Uh, you were one of the"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":156.776,"endTime":159.806,"body":"speakers there, so, so maybe"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":160.106,"endTime":161.546,"body":"you can, uh, bring me in line."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":161.546,"endTime":164.216,"body":"What, what happened in"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":161.546,"endTime":164.216,"body":"Italy or unless what happens"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":164.216,"endTime":165.296,"body":"in Italy stays in Italy."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":165.296,"endTime":165.596,"body":"I dunno."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":167.401,"endTime":169.378,"body":"No, I'm happy"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":167.401,"endTime":169.378,"body":"to, tell you all about it."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":169.408,"endTime":171.238,"body":"And first of all, thank"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":169.408,"endTime":171.238,"body":"you so much for having me."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":171.243,"endTime":172.168,"body":"It's a great pleasure."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":172.168,"endTime":173.698,"body":"And I'm a, I'm a"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":172.168,"endTime":173.698,"body":"fan of your show."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":174.208,"endTime":176.791,"body":"So yes, we had this week"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":174.208,"endTime":176.791,"body":"long, uh, summer school"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":176.796,"endTime":178.201,"body":"in Como one of the."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":178.436,"endTime":180.626,"body":"You know, best places"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":178.436,"endTime":180.626,"body":"in the world, really,"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":180.656,"endTime":181.826,"body":"really nice location."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":182.166,"endTime":185.456,"body":"in may, that was organized , by"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":182.166,"endTime":185.456,"body":"dear colleagues at the Polytech"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":185.456,"endTime":188.806,"body":"in Milan, Roberto Felicetti"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":185.456,"endTime":188.806,"body":"Patrick Bamonte and Jean-Marc"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":188.806,"endTime":190.136,"body":"Franssen  was also involved."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":190.616,"endTime":194.636,"body":"So the goal was to bring"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":190.616,"endTime":194.636,"body":"together, 10 speakers, , for,"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":194.653,"endTime":197.213,"body":"each of them delivering"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":194.653,"endTime":197.213,"body":"you have day lecture."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":197.953,"endTime":201.266,"body":"Topic, you know, of their"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":197.953,"endTime":201.266,"body":"expertise and have, , PhD"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":201.266,"endTime":203.911,"body":"students and researchers"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":201.266,"endTime":203.911,"body":", from all over, get the"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":203.911,"endTime":207.451,"body":"ability to either come in"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":203.911,"endTime":207.451,"body":"person or attend remotely."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":207.871,"endTime":210.931,"body":"And it was very,"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":207.871,"endTime":210.931,"body":"interactive and productive."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":210.931,"endTime":214.051,"body":"It was very nice to be in a room"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":210.931,"endTime":214.051,"body":"together and being able, not"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":214.051,"endTime":216.341,"body":"only to, teach about a topic."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":217.061,"endTime":220.855,"body":"Close to what I've been"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":217.061,"endTime":220.855,"body":"interested recently, but also"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":220.855,"endTime":224.065,"body":"get the feedback and discussion"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":220.855,"endTime":224.065,"body":"and get to know what all these"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":224.065,"endTime":226.015,"body":"researchers are, working on."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":226.495,"endTime":229.585,"body":"And I mean, definitely lots"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":226.495,"endTime":229.585,"body":"of, very exciting, topics"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":230.015,"endTime":231.545,"body":"looking at new problems."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":231.665,"endTime":234.675,"body":"so just all  this structural"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":231.665,"endTime":234.675,"body":"fire engineering community"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":234.675,"endTime":235.905,"body":"coming together was great."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":236.045,"endTime":239.978,"body":"Um, Yeah, I got , to talk"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":236.045,"endTime":239.978,"body":"about, the burnout resistance"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":239.978,"endTime":243.518,"body":"of structures, which is a"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":239.978,"endTime":243.518,"body":"topic I've been researching"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":243.518,"endTime":245.108,"body":"for quite a long time."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":245.108,"endTime":250.868,"body":"Actually, that started with my"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":245.108,"endTime":250.868,"body":"PhD work, where I worked on the"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":250.898,"endTime":254.708,"body":"development of, numerical model"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":250.898,"endTime":254.708,"body":"for the behavior of concrete"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":254.738,"endTime":256.538,"body":"activity, temperature, and."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":257.608,"endTime":260.098,"body":"Paid particular attention"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":257.608,"endTime":260.098,"body":"to what happens during"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":260.098,"endTime":261.478,"body":"the cooling down phases."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":261.538,"endTime":264.448,"body":"We wanted to make sure"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":261.538,"endTime":264.448,"body":"that we were capturing,"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":264.478,"endTime":267.405,"body":"uh, irreversible processes"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":264.478,"endTime":267.405,"body":"and damage and transient"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":267.405,"endTime":269.385,"body":"creep and all these stuff."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":269.505,"endTime":273.965,"body":"And so with these models, then"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":269.505,"endTime":273.965,"body":"we became able to model more"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":273.965,"endTime":276.724,"body":"accurately what happened during"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":273.965,"endTime":276.724,"body":"cooling and whether there was"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":277.414,"endTime":278.854,"body":"a risk of delayed failure."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":279.004,"endTime":279.864,"body":"And since then it."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":280.739,"endTime":284.099,"body":"Evolved into modeling all"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":280.739,"endTime":284.099,"body":"types of structures during"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":284.099,"endTime":286.761,"body":"heating and cooling and,"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":284.099,"endTime":286.761,"body":"developing a framework to"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":286.766,"endTime":288.891,"body":"understand when there is a"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":286.766,"endTime":288.891,"body":"risk of delayed collapse."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":288.896,"endTime":290.226,"body":"So that, that was about,"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":290.401,"endTime":290.701,"body":"Italy."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":291.05,"endTime":291.9,"body":"that's a great topic."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":291.9,"endTime":293.94,"body":"And I, I have a feeling"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":291.9,"endTime":293.94,"body":"we're gonna touch on it"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":293.94,"endTime":295.29,"body":"a lot in this episode."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":295.29,"endTime":297.9,"body":"And I've asked about the"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":295.29,"endTime":297.9,"body":"summer school because there's"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":297.9,"endTime":301.12,"body":"a lot of, young fire engineers"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":297.9,"endTime":301.12,"body":"listening, a lot of, uh,"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":301.15,"endTime":304.72,"body":"researchers, uh, students"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":301.15,"endTime":304.72,"body":"graduates, postgraduates,"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":305.08,"endTime":306.37,"body":"PhD, students posts."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":307.16,"endTime":310.19,"body":"If you ever wonder if"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":307.16,"endTime":310.19,"body":"it is worth to go summer"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":310.19,"endTime":311.69,"body":"school, it is worth it."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":311.75,"endTime":312.14,"body":"Totally."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":312.444,"endTime":315.513,"body":"from my experiences with summer"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":312.444,"endTime":315.513,"body":"schools, it is absolutely"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":315.513,"endTime":319.623,"body":"amazing way to, to get the"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":315.513,"endTime":319.623,"body":"knowledge probably the best"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":319.623,"endTime":322.653,"body":"way, even better than my"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":319.623,"endTime":322.653,"body":"podcast, I would say  but yeah."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":323.733,"endTime":324.033,"body":"that."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":324.393,"endTime":324.693,"body":"Okay."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":324.753,"endTime":326.288,"body":"Uh, so, let's go back."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":326.938,"endTime":327.778,"body":"PhD thesis."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":327.778,"endTime":330.628,"body":"You said you were developing"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":327.778,"endTime":330.628,"body":"numerical models, and I"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":330.628,"endTime":334.048,"body":"also know you are involved"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":330.628,"endTime":334.048,"body":"in development of SAFIR®"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":334.318,"endTime":338.398,"body":"of the more popular codes"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":334.318,"endTime":338.398,"body":"in structural engineering."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":338.638,"endTime":341.588,"body":"So as we venture into"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":338.638,"endTime":341.588,"body":"the world of, numerical"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":341.588,"endTime":343.418,"body":"modeling and structural"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":341.588,"endTime":343.418,"body":"fire engineering, maybe you"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":343.423,"endTime":346.628,"body":"can tell me like the story,"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":343.423,"endTime":346.628,"body":"why there was a need for a."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":346.843,"endTime":350.883,"body":"New codes to be built or"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":346.843,"endTime":350.883,"body":"just wanted a new ya and,"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":350.973,"endTime":354.603,"body":"and yeah,  and the home"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":350.973,"endTime":354.603,"body":"had Italy coast from that."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":354.933,"endTime":356.433,"body":"Well, that's a good"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":354.933,"endTime":356.433,"body":"motivation too."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":358.573,"endTime":360.253,"body":"Well, certainly"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":358.573,"endTime":360.253,"body":"I'm happy , to tell this"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":360.253,"endTime":363.203,"body":"story because I think, it's"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":360.253,"endTime":363.203,"body":"a nice one and a timely one."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":363.203,"endTime":365.749,"body":"So, my PGTs is situat."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":365.754,"endTime":370.269,"body":"So we are talking about like"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":365.754,"endTime":370.269,"body":"2009, 2012, that range and,"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":370.489,"endTime":373.498,"body":"The, the tensile membrane"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":370.489,"endTime":373.498,"body":"action was a big topic."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":373.624,"endTime":375.844,"body":"since I would say one,"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":373.624,"endTime":375.844,"body":"one decade earlier, right?"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":375.844,"endTime":378.694,"body":"It had originated with the"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":375.844,"endTime":378.694,"body":"observations at Cardington"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":378.694,"endTime":383.194,"body":"in the 1990s with the Bre and"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":378.694,"endTime":383.194,"body":"all the research in the UK"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":383.194,"endTime":386.314,"body":"and professor Wang, professor"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":383.194,"endTime":386.314,"body":"Bailey, you know, doing those."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":386.404,"endTime":389.594,"body":"Semi, , findings the"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":386.404,"endTime":389.594,"body":"beginning of two thousands."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":390.044,"endTime":393.244,"body":"And so, it, it became clear"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":390.044,"endTime":393.244,"body":"that there was really, a need"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":393.244,"endTime":396.471,"body":"to be able to model, entire"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":393.244,"endTime":396.471,"body":"structural systems and, the"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":396.476,"endTime":399.531,"body":"behavior, and not only the"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":396.476,"endTime":399.531,"body":"structural frame, but that the"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":399.531,"endTime":403.628,"body":"behavior of concrete and the"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":399.531,"endTime":403.628,"body":"concrete slabs, became also"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":403.658,"endTime":406.268,"body":"something that, that matters and"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":403.658,"endTime":406.268,"body":"that influenced the response."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":406.408,"endTime":408.358,"body":"So with"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":406.408,"endTime":408.358,"body":"the tonsil membrane actions,"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":408.358,"endTime":412.428,"body":"you mean , the way how slabs"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":408.358,"endTime":412.428,"body":"will respond to the load, how"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":412.428,"endTime":415.338,"body":"they would carry the forces"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":412.428,"endTime":415.338,"body":"in the building and how"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":415.338,"endTime":418.128,"body":"important part they take in"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":415.338,"endTime":418.128,"body":"like the general structural"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":418.128,"endTime":419.208,"body":"stability of the building."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":419.208,"endTime":421.998,"body":"So not just the frame,"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":419.208,"endTime":421.998,"body":"but also everything"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":421.998,"endTime":422.928,"body":"that connects the frame."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":423.346,"endTime":423.976,"body":"Exactly."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":423.976,"endTime":424.306,"body":"Yes."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":424.306,"endTime":424.726,"body":"Good point."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":424.726,"endTime":425.896,"body":"So let me backtrack."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":425.901,"endTime":426.346,"body":"Exactly."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":426.346,"endTime":430.646,"body":"So at, the Cardington what"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":426.346,"endTime":430.646,"body":"was done is that, uh, in"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":430.646,"endTime":434.637,"body":"the 1990s, the Bre, , they"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":430.646,"endTime":434.637,"body":"tested entire buildings."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":434.646,"endTime":435.066,"body":"Yeah."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":435.276,"endTime":436.956,"body":"Subjected"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":435.276,"endTime":436.956,"body":"to natural fire, right."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":436.956,"endTime":437.646,"body":"To a fire."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":437.646,"endTime":440.126,"body":"And so that was the first"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":437.646,"endTime":440.126,"body":"or one of the first time,"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":440.126,"endTime":442.436,"body":"you know, that they really"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":440.126,"endTime":442.436,"body":"investigated the behavior"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":442.441,"endTime":445.526,"body":"of the structural system as"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":442.441,"endTime":445.526,"body":"opposed to testing isolated"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":445.646,"endTime":447.266,"body":"members in, in furnaces."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":447.746,"endTime":450.746,"body":"And what was observed is"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":447.746,"endTime":450.746,"body":"that the behavior as a whole"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":451.076,"endTime":455.216,"body":"was much more favorable and"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":451.076,"endTime":455.216,"body":"you had this redundancy and"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":455.216,"endTime":457.796,"body":"those alternate load pass"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":455.216,"endTime":457.796,"body":"that you could activate."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":457.796,"endTime":459.596,"body":"So you end up with structurally."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":459.62,"endTime":462.679,"body":"Behavior that's more robust"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":459.62,"endTime":462.679,"body":"than you would predict based"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":462.679,"endTime":464.759,"body":"on single members' behavior."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":465.229,"endTime":468.859,"body":"For example, you could leave"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":465.229,"endTime":468.859,"body":"some of the steel beams with"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":468.859,"endTime":470.509,"body":"no thermal insulation, right?"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":470.509,"endTime":474.466,"body":"They would, have exhibit large"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":470.509,"endTime":474.466,"body":"deflections, but when you"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":474.466,"endTime":477.191,"body":"get those large deflections"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":474.466,"endTime":477.191,"body":"in the floors that, go with"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":477.196,"endTime":478.361,"body":"them, that deflect with them."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":478.611,"endTime":481.281,"body":", you start activating tension"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":478.611,"endTime":481.281,"body":"in the reinforcement."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":481.311,"endTime":483.051,"body":"That's embedded in the concrete."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":483.741,"endTime":486.111,"body":"And so this steel"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":483.741,"endTime":486.111,"body":"reinforcement remains cold."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":486.116,"endTime":488.151,"body":"It's protected, by , the"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":486.116,"endTime":488.151,"body":"concrete of the slab."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":488.583,"endTime":491.613,"body":"But if it is designed properly,"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":488.583,"endTime":491.613,"body":"now you can carry the loads,"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":491.986,"endTime":495.086,"body":"with, this alternate load pass"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":491.986,"endTime":495.086,"body":"and this, uh, in this deformed"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":495.086,"endTime":498.566,"body":"shape, which becomes really"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":495.086,"endTime":498.566,"body":"interesting because it means"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":498.566,"endTime":499.766,"body":"you have a robust behavior."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":499.766,"endTime":502.196,"body":"That's really embedded in the"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":499.766,"endTime":502.196,"body":"structure that doesn't require."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":502.806,"endTime":504.753,"body":"Insulation from the"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":502.806,"endTime":504.753,"body":"thermal election."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":505.596,"endTime":509.126,"body":"so with this realization,"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":505.596,"endTime":509.126,"body":"they started to be, you know,"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":509.226,"endTime":512.346,"body":"development of numerical"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":509.226,"endTime":512.346,"body":"models to try reproduce this"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":512.346,"endTime":516.036,"body":"behavior and understand it,"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":512.346,"endTime":516.036,"body":"and then work toward design"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":516.041,"endTime":517.426,"body":"methods, analytical methods."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":518.046,"endTime":520.756,"body":"but SAFIR was already around"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":518.046,"endTime":520.756,"body":"and I want , to come back a"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":520.756,"endTime":523.786,"body":"little bit later on how it had"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":520.756,"endTime":523.786,"body":"been, uh, developed originally."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":523.786,"endTime":524.056,"body":"Right."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":524.386,"endTime":527.836,"body":"But when I started my PhD, , I"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":524.386,"endTime":527.836,"body":"would say the behavior of"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":527.836,"endTime":531.466,"body":"concrete had not been so"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":527.836,"endTime":531.466,"body":"important before, before 2009."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":531.806,"endTime":534.402,"body":"But, , there started to be"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":531.806,"endTime":534.402,"body":"all this research on Tenile"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":534.402,"endTime":537.435,"body":"membrane action and, large scale"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":534.402,"endTime":537.435,"body":"European research projects."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":537.435,"endTime":539.955,"body":"And we really wanted to"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":537.435,"endTime":539.955,"body":"have something rub robust"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":539.955,"endTime":542.295,"body":"and accurate to capture"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":539.955,"endTime":542.295,"body":"what was happening in"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":542.3,"endTime":544.035,"body":"those concrete floors."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":544.125,"endTime":546.555,"body":"Uh, when they were undergoing"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":544.125,"endTime":546.555,"body":"transmembrane action,"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":546.555,"endTime":549.345,"body":"large displacement heating"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":546.555,"endTime":549.345,"body":"and cooling and so on."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":549.705,"endTime":551.265,"body":"So that was really"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":549.705,"endTime":551.265,"body":"the motivation to"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":551.265,"endTime":552.615,"body":"fill this gap in the."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":553.23,"endTime":557.517,"body":"Computational, modeling tools"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":553.23,"endTime":557.517,"body":"at that time to have, actual"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":557.607,"endTime":561.357,"body":"models for concrete in multi"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":557.607,"endTime":561.357,"body":"Excel, stress date, subjected to"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":561.357,"endTime":562.767,"body":"heating and cooling and so on."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":563.502,"endTime":563.562,"body":"Hmm."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":563.704,"endTime":566.734,"body":"so before that it"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":563.704,"endTime":566.734,"body":"means SAFIR was, was already run"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":566.734,"endTime":569.677,"body":"and those software as well, of"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":566.734,"endTime":569.677,"body":"course, to start modeling, you"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":569.677,"endTime":571.357,"body":"know, structural fire behavior."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":571.357,"endTime":574.784,"body":"And I think that started"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":571.357,"endTime":574.784,"body":"in the late 1980s and"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":574.784,"endTime":576.554,"body":"mostly in the 1990s."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":577.394,"endTime":582.487,"body":"The idea was that, of course, to"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":577.394,"endTime":582.487,"body":"achieve fire safety of the built"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":582.487,"endTime":585.487,"body":"environment, you have those"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":582.487,"endTime":585.487,"body":"different layers, of safety that"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":585.487,"endTime":586.652,"body":", you want to rely on, right?"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":586.657,"endTime":589.352,"body":"So you want prevention, you"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":586.657,"endTime":589.352,"body":"want, active fire protection"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":589.352,"endTime":592.609,"body":"and so on, but as a last"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":589.352,"endTime":592.609,"body":"resort, you really have the"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":592.609,"endTime":594.529,"body":"structural, uh, fire response."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":595.835,"endTime":598.574,"body":"For quite some times, Al"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":595.835,"endTime":598.574,"body":"engineers did not really"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":599.084,"endTime":602.844,"body":"focus much on the structural"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":599.084,"endTime":602.844,"body":"fire response and fire"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":602.844,"endTime":606.624,"body":"protection engineers probably"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":602.844,"endTime":606.624,"body":"had the oversimplified way"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":606.624,"endTime":609.294,"body":"of thinking about structural"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":606.624,"endTime":609.294,"body":"fire response and my PG"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":609.294,"endTime":610.624,"body":"advisor,  Jean-Marc Franssen."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":611.219,"endTime":615.482,"body":"Told me the story of first time"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":611.219,"endTime":615.482,"body":"he, visited to the us, I think."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":615.482,"endTime":618.889,"body":"And he, he, he got to, he was"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":615.482,"endTime":618.889,"body":"a young engineer expert in"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":618.889,"endTime":621.919,"body":"structural fire behavior, but"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":618.889,"endTime":621.919,"body":"starting, and he got to speak"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":621.919,"endTime":624.629,"body":"with, somebody working on the"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":621.919,"endTime":624.629,"body":"fire dynamics, fire protection"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":624.634,"endTime":627.359,"body":"engineer, and basically"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":624.634,"endTime":627.359,"body":"they were asking, okay, can"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":627.359,"endTime":629.939,"body":"you tell me the critical"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":627.359,"endTime":629.939,"body":"temperature of your structure?"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":629.939,"endTime":630.119,"body":"Right."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":630.119,"endTime":631.439,"body":"Because I can do"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":630.119,"endTime":631.439,"body":"the heat transfer."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":631.439,"endTime":632.639,"body":"I can find the temperature."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":632.639,"endTime":633.779,"body":"So if you tell."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":634.434,"endTime":636.744,"body":"The temperature at which"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":634.434,"endTime":636.744,"body":"your restric first, you"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":636.744,"endTime":637.494,"body":"know, we are all set."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":637.494,"endTime":640.644,"body":"We don't need to look more into"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":637.494,"endTime":640.644,"body":"the structural fire response."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":640.964,"endTime":643.96,"body":"So it was this idea that,"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":640.964,"endTime":643.96,"body":"it's a purely thermal"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":643.96,"endTime":646.39,"body":"problem, basically, which"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":643.96,"endTime":646.39,"body":"is, is not, of course."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":646.6,"endTime":648.37,"body":"And yeah,"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":646.6,"endTime":648.37,"body":"but it still is treated like"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":648.37,"endTime":653.192,"body":"that in many cases, we are"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":648.37,"endTime":653.192,"body":"drawing isotherms  inside, beams"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":653.192,"endTime":657.602,"body":"or, even the concept of Charing"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":653.192,"endTime":657.602,"body":"depth loss of, area of, timber."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":657.794,"endTime":658.304,"body":"Parts."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":658.574,"endTime":661.307,"body":"So it still is, in a"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":658.574,"endTime":661.307,"body":"way considered like"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":661.307,"endTime":662.047,"body":"a thermal problem."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":662.407,"endTime":666.097,"body":"And if you think about it,"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":662.407,"endTime":666.097,"body":"like, let me tap to what"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":666.097,"endTime":667.687,"body":"you said in Cardington."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":667.687,"endTime":670.837,"body":"They did for the first"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":667.687,"endTime":670.837,"body":"time, the full building, but"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":670.837,"endTime":673.717,"body":"Cardington was like in 1990s"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":670.837,"endTime":673.717,"body":"and we were doing structural"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":673.717,"endTime":677.377,"body":"fire engineering for a hundred"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":673.717,"endTime":677.377,"body":"years back then we've we've"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":677.377,"endTime":678.727,"body":"been doing it with furnaces."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":679.462,"endTime":682.319,"body":"In the furnace in essence,"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":679.462,"endTime":682.319,"body":"unless you have a loaded"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":682.319,"endTime":684.209,"body":"element, that's a little"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":682.319,"endTime":684.209,"body":"different when you have"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":684.329,"endTime":684.389,"body":"So."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":684.569,"endTime":688.282,"body":"element"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":684.569,"endTime":688.282,"body":"and on how you, connect the"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":688.282,"endTime":691.252,"body":"element to the furnace in terms"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":688.282,"endTime":691.252,"body":"of what, what the free end"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":691.252,"endTime":692.782,"body":"is, and then how it can react."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":692.782,"endTime":695.242,"body":"But in, in a great"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":692.782,"endTime":695.242,"body":"simplification, the fire"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":695.242,"endTime":696.262,"body":"test is a thermal test."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":696.292,"endTime":697.342,"body":"Like essentially."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":697.537,"endTime":700.777,"body":"Test the thermal behavior"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":697.537,"endTime":700.777,"body":", of your system and all the"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":701.197,"endTime":705.517,"body":"criteria you have are in a"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":701.197,"endTime":705.517,"body":"way related to the terminal"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":705.517,"endTime":708.907,"body":"response, especially the"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":705.517,"endTime":708.907,"body":"insulation and, the capability"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":708.907,"endTime":712.177,"body":"to, to keep the smoke sealed"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":708.907,"endTime":712.177,"body":"in inside the compartment,"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":712.177,"endTime":714.057,"body":"not spread through cracks."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":714.057,"endTime":714.117,"body":"So."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":715.797,"endTime":719.017,"body":"We are still , very in"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":715.797,"endTime":719.017,"body":"the element and, and"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":719.017,"endTime":720.427,"body":"thermal response paradigm."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":720.968,"endTime":724.08,"body":"so you want to say that that"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":720.968,"endTime":724.08,"body":"numerical modeling was a"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":724.08,"endTime":728.04,"body":"way to break this paradigm"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":724.08,"endTime":728.04,"body":"or, or escape it in a way."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":728.459,"endTime":729.267,"body":"Absolutely."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":729.267,"endTime":730.377,"body":"Yes, you are right."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":730.377,"endTime":733.737,"body":"We are still relying on"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":730.377,"endTime":733.737,"body":"this, uh, simplification in"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":734.127,"endTime":736.737,"body":"most of the case and, , very"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":734.127,"endTime":736.737,"body":"largely in the field."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":737.157,"endTime":740.427,"body":"And as you say, numerical"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":737.157,"endTime":740.427,"body":"modeling is actually a way to"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":740.467,"endTime":743.627,"body":"overcome the simplification"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":740.467,"endTime":743.627,"body":"and, start investigating"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":743.627,"endTime":747.737,"body":"the actual, anticipated"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":743.627,"endTime":747.737,"body":"structural response under."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":748.907,"endTime":749.897,"body":"Thermal demands."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":750.317,"endTime":755.74,"body":"And that is important because we"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":750.317,"endTime":755.74,"body":"observed that in many case, the"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":755.74,"endTime":758.96,"body":"thermal approach itself or the"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":755.74,"endTime":758.96,"body":"element, approach and looking at"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":758.96,"endTime":762.494,"body":"these ISO terms does not, answer"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":758.96,"endTime":762.494,"body":"important question or does not"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":762.494,"endTime":766.12,"body":"really, predict what the NC"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":762.494,"endTime":766.12,"body":"two behavior is going to be."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":766.48,"endTime":769.93,"body":"So the tenal membrane action"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":766.48,"endTime":769.93,"body":"was kind of the first, a very"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":769.93,"endTime":773.44,"body":"remarkable example of that,"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":769.93,"endTime":773.44,"body":"where you can actually leave."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":774.45,"endTime":777.565,"body":"the temperature go much higher"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":774.45,"endTime":777.565,"body":"in, some of, in part of your"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":777.565,"endTime":780.775,"body":"structural frame and still"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":777.565,"endTime":780.775,"body":"have a very robust behavior."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":780.955,"endTime":784.402,"body":"And so that opens the door"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":780.955,"endTime":784.402,"body":"to, not only optimization and"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":784.402,"endTime":787.555,"body":"economic savings in terms of,"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":784.402,"endTime":787.555,"body":"thermal installation, but also"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":787.975,"endTime":791.219,"body":"understanding really the safety"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":787.975,"endTime":791.219,"body":"level of your, building, as"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":791.219,"endTime":792.599,"body":"well as having a behavior."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":792.599,"endTime":796.229,"body":"That's very robust because this"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":792.599,"endTime":796.229,"body":"road bearing Capac is really"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":796.229,"endTime":797.519,"body":"embedded in the structure."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":798.059,"endTime":800.639,"body":"There are many other examples"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":798.059,"endTime":800.639,"body":"where numerical modeling."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":801.079,"endTime":804.704,"body":"Give you, information that"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":801.079,"endTime":804.704,"body":"is inaccessible with, uh,"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":804.704,"endTime":808.054,"body":"element testing and, based"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":804.704,"endTime":808.054,"body":"on the thermal response."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":808.054,"endTime":810.67,"body":"So I mentioned briefly that"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":808.054,"endTime":810.67,"body":"I was talking about burnout"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":810.67,"endTime":813.145,"body":"resistance, uh, during , the"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":810.67,"endTime":813.145,"body":"summer school in Como."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":813.165,"endTime":814.905,"body":"And actually we can"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":813.165,"endTime":814.905,"body":"rebound on this."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":815.325,"endTime":819.252,"body":", so if you start looking at,"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":815.325,"endTime":819.252,"body":"the structural response to"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":819.252,"endTime":821.982,"body":"how the different phases"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":819.252,"endTime":821.982,"body":"of the fire, and you're"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":821.982,"endTime":824.622,"body":"interested in maintaining"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":821.982,"endTime":824.622,"body":"stability to full burn out."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":826.172,"endTime":829.082,"body":"Because, uh, structural"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":826.172,"endTime":829.082,"body":"collapse would not be acceptable"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":829.082,"endTime":832.309,"body":"because you're concerned about,"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":829.082,"endTime":832.309,"body":"fire service intervention"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":832.529,"endTime":833.952,"body":"or, resilience and so on."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":834.436,"endTime":838.225,"body":"then you, you start, uh,"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":834.436,"endTime":838.225,"body":"having to model what happens"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":838.405,"endTime":841.285,"body":"during the different phases,"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":838.405,"endTime":841.285,"body":"including during the cooling"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":841.765,"endTime":844.395,"body":"and the notion of critical"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":841.765,"endTime":844.395,"body":"temperature really does not."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":845.045,"endTime":848.852,"body":"Makes more se much sense"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":845.045,"endTime":848.852,"body":"anymore, because you will have a"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":848.852,"endTime":851.702,"body":"delayed temperature increase in"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":848.852,"endTime":851.702,"body":"different parts of the section."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":851.702,"endTime":854.619,"body":"And you have, for example, if"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":851.702,"endTime":854.619,"body":"we, if we think about a timber"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":854.619,"endTime":857.615,"body":"section, you might have the"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":854.619,"endTime":857.615,"body":"Charing that stops, but you"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":857.615,"endTime":860.585,"body":"still have the heat wave that"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":857.615,"endTime":860.585,"body":"goes throughout the core of"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":860.59,"endTime":864.019,"body":"the section, which will lead"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":860.59,"endTime":864.019,"body":"to additional, reduction of"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":864.019,"endTime":865.169,"body":"the load bearing capacity."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":865.702,"endTime":865.942,"body":"maybe."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":866.056,"endTime":868.352,"body":"temperatures is lower than"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":866.056,"endTime":868.352,"body":"the charring temperature,"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":868.352,"endTime":871.929,"body":"but still higher than what"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":868.352,"endTime":871.929,"body":"the material can, really"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":871.929,"endTime":874.905,"body":"support without, being, I"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":871.929,"endTime":874.905,"body":"would say, damaged or reduced."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":875.565,"endTime":878.362,"body":"So in that sense, you really"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":875.565,"endTime":878.362,"body":"need this capability to"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":878.362,"endTime":882.192,"body":"model, structures in fire,"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":878.362,"endTime":882.192,"body":"because either you want"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":882.192,"endTime":885.642,"body":"to quantify safety, you"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":882.192,"endTime":885.642,"body":"want to optimize design."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":885.972,"endTime":889.422,"body":"You want to look at stability"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":885.972,"endTime":889.422,"body":"to full burnout or many other"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":889.427,"endTime":890.622,"body":"other situations really."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":891.002,"endTime":892.712,"body":"Other"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":891.002,"endTime":892.712,"body":"thing that immediately comes to"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":892.712,"endTime":896.972,"body":"my mind, I is traveling fires"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":892.712,"endTime":896.972,"body":"and, , the concept of, of like"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":896.972,"endTime":898.592,"body":"four hour fire resistance."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":898.592,"endTime":901.502,"body":"Like there, there is"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":898.592,"endTime":901.502,"body":"like, no way fire can"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":901.532,"endTime":904.222,"body":"be in the same place for"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":901.532,"endTime":904.222,"body":"four hours is like that."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":904.552,"endTime":905.482,"body":"That would be."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":906.122,"endTime":909.162,"body":"Insane amount of fuel"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":906.122,"endTime":909.162,"body":"load in one place."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":909.402,"endTime":913.422,"body":"Actually you can, um, have fun"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":909.402,"endTime":913.422,"body":"and try to do the calculations."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":913.825,"endTime":916.255,"body":", we were once calculating"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":913.825,"endTime":916.255,"body":"how much fuel load you"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":916.255,"endTime":919.298,"body":"would need, to, to create"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":916.255,"endTime":919.298,"body":"standard condition, on."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":919.953,"endTime":923.073,"body":"A ceiling of an airport"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":919.953,"endTime":923.073,"body":"and we came to conclusion."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":923.073,"endTime":926.153,"body":"It would have to be like"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":923.073,"endTime":926.153,"body":"literally stacks of, trucks"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":926.153,"endTime":929.783,"body":"filled with like Ikea furniture"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":926.153,"endTime":929.783,"body":"on top of each other, reaching"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":929.783,"endTime":933.773,"body":"almost the ceiling to, to"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":929.783,"endTime":933.773,"body":"have this four hour fire at"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":933.778,"endTime":935.363,"body":"this super tall position."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":935.363,"endTime":937.133,"body":"But now, now back"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":935.363,"endTime":937.133,"body":"to traveling fires."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":937.341,"endTime":940.58,"body":"I had an episode with Guillermo"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":937.341,"endTime":940.58,"body":"Rein about traveling fires and"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":940.97,"endTime":943.61,"body":"everyone's highly recommended"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":940.97,"endTime":943.61,"body":"to go back to that one I'll link"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":943.61,"endTime":946.49,"body":"in the, in the show notes to"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":943.61,"endTime":946.49,"body":"learn about the method itself."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":946.495,"endTime":950.275,"body":", the thing is that there"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":946.495,"endTime":950.275,"body":"is tons of possible"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":950.275,"endTime":951.535,"body":"outcomes of the fires."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":951.535,"endTime":954.505,"body":"There are fires that will travel"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":951.535,"endTime":954.505,"body":"very quickly, which means they"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":954.505,"endTime":956.995,"body":"will be very high intensity"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":954.505,"endTime":956.995,"body":"fires, but they will burn"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":956.995,"endTime":958.045,"body":"through the fuel very quickly."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":958.615,"endTime":961.285,"body":"There will be fires that"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":958.615,"endTime":961.285,"body":"are slow, which burn slowly"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":961.345,"endTime":964.075,"body":"through the fuel, but"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":961.345,"endTime":964.075,"body":"they also spread slower."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":965.07,"endTime":967.75,"body":"And they can go from left to"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":965.07,"endTime":967.75,"body":"right from right to left from"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":967.75,"endTime":969.4,"body":"middle out, from out to middle."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":969.758,"endTime":972.506,"body":"there there's hundreds"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":969.758,"endTime":972.506,"body":"of, or, or there's"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":972.506,"endTime":973.8,"body":"limitless amount of, ways."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":973.805,"endTime":975.93,"body":"How, how a fire can go"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":973.805,"endTime":975.93,"body":"through the building."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":976.35,"endTime":978.09,"body":"Even if you're not"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":976.35,"endTime":978.09,"body":"modeling, if you, if"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":978.095,"endTime":978.66,"body":"you're just swimming some."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":979.695,"endTime":981.845,"body":"Saw the fire behavioral"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":979.695,"endTime":981.845,"body":"as travelling fires,"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":981.865,"endTime":982.885,"body":"such as simplified model."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":983.275,"endTime":985.735,"body":"And now, now you end up"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":983.275,"endTime":985.735,"body":"with hundreds or thousands"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":985.735,"endTime":988.459,"body":"or tens of thousands of"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":985.735,"endTime":988.459,"body":"scenarios to investigate."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":988.459,"endTime":990.619,"body":"And there is absolutely"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":988.459,"endTime":990.619,"body":"like your fire resistance"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":990.619,"endTime":991.579,"body":"is just one data point."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":992.419,"endTime":992.949,"body":"is it."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":993.245,"endTime":993.725,"body":"that's your"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":993.755,"endTime":993.995,"body":"That's."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":994.03,"endTime":996.845,"body":"point to"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":994.03,"endTime":996.845,"body":"one time temperature relation."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":997.61,"endTime":1000.931,"body":"In a certain amount of"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":997.61,"endTime":1000.931,"body":"time within this boundary"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1000.931,"endTime":1003.661,"body":"conditions of this particular"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1000.931,"endTime":1003.661,"body":"furnace in this particular"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1003.666,"endTime":1006.241,"body":"laboratory, that is pretty"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1003.666,"endTime":1006.241,"body":"much the answer you have,"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1006.241,"endTime":1009.361,"body":"and you have 10,000 scenarios"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1006.241,"endTime":1009.361,"body":"to go through and compare."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1009.631,"endTime":1012.871,"body":"So no, no way you can relate"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1009.631,"endTime":1012.871,"body":"that, or we try, but it's"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1012.871,"endTime":1016.441,"body":"hard while in numerical"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1012.871,"endTime":1016.441,"body":"modeling, you can probably"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1016.441,"endTime":1019.081,"body":"just test them all or just"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1016.441,"endTime":1019.081,"body":"figure out which are the."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1020.041,"endTime":1020.131,"body":"It's."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1020.241,"endTime":1022.461,"body":"you also"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1020.241,"endTime":1022.461,"body":"have experiences in, in this"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1022.461,"endTime":1025.431,"body":"application , or what was"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1022.461,"endTime":1025.431,"body":"it also something you have"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1025.431,"endTime":1028.491,"body":"considered back then when"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1025.431,"endTime":1028.491,"body":"you joined the SAFIR team?"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1028.491,"endTime":1030.596,"body":"I guess traveling fires was"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1028.491,"endTime":1030.596,"body":"not the thing because , I"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1030.596,"endTime":1034.46,"body":"think it was just about to"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1030.596,"endTime":1034.46,"body":"begin, in, in this time, but"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1034.94,"endTime":1038.96,"body":"you short, hot or long cold"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1034.94,"endTime":1038.96,"body":"Euro code fires, localized"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1038.96,"endTime":1040.07,"body":"fires were there for sure."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1040.17,"endTime":1040.92,"body":"Absolutely."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1041.28,"endTime":1043.95,"body":"It's a great point to"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1041.28,"endTime":1043.95,"body":"bring, because I was"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1043.95,"endTime":1045.18,"body":"telling the story of the"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1045.395,"endTime":1045.665,"body":"Hmm."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1045.93,"endTime":1048.67,"body":"protection"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1045.93,"endTime":1048.67,"body":"engineer, who ask us for, one"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1048.67,"endTime":1051.85,"body":"critical temperature as if it"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1048.67,"endTime":1051.85,"body":"would summarize the response"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1051.85,"endTime":1055.66,"body":"of the structure, but we"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1051.85,"endTime":1055.66,"body":"structural engineers also, uh,"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1055.72,"endTime":1060.155,"body":"may tend to oversimplify and"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1055.72,"endTime":1060.155,"body":"ask, you know, Fire dynamician,"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1060.295,"endTime":1062.965,"body":"uh, to, to provide us with"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1060.295,"endTime":1062.965,"body":"a standard fire curve and"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1062.965,"endTime":1065.905,"body":"think that it'll capture all"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1062.965,"endTime":1065.905,"body":"the possible fire behaviors."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1065.905,"endTime":1067.705,"body":"And we can work only with that."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1067.71,"endTime":1068.965,"body":"And of course"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1067.71,"endTime":1068.965,"body":"that's not the case."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1068.965,"endTime":1071.785,"body":"And as Guillermo is, is"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1068.965,"endTime":1071.785,"body":"shown with, , some papers"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1071.79,"endTime":1072.565,"body":"where he showed that the."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1072.785,"endTime":1076.055,"body":"Traveling fires can challenge"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1072.785,"endTime":1076.055,"body":"the structure to, to an"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1076.055,"endTime":1077.165,"body":"extent that is different."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1077.258,"endTime":1080.005,"body":"and in some cases more"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1077.258,"endTime":1080.005,"body":"on than, uh, I would say"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1080.005,"endTime":1083.695,"body":"compartment fire conditions,"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1080.005,"endTime":1083.695,"body":"and also the opposite, where"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1083.7,"endTime":1088.221,"body":"there are many situations"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1083.7,"endTime":1088.221,"body":"where once you model The fire"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1088.581,"endTime":1092.031,"body":"behavior based on what we"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1088.581,"endTime":1092.031,"body":"call the physically based fire"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1092.421,"endTime":1094.251,"body":"formally called natural fires."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1094.671,"endTime":1097.611,"body":"You find that the conditions"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1094.671,"endTime":1097.611,"body":"may be less on than with"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1097.616,"endTime":1100.618,"body":"the, standard fire or"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1097.616,"endTime":1100.618,"body":"full post flashover fire."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1100.618,"endTime":1102.954,"body":"And that also opens,"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1100.618,"endTime":1102.954,"body":"opportunities , for"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1103.164,"endTime":1104.724,"body":"design optimization or."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1105.054,"endTime":1107.334,"body":"Even enabling"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1105.054,"endTime":1107.334,"body":"architectural designs."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1107.334,"endTime":1111.074,"body":"When, you know, if an architect"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1107.334,"endTime":1111.074,"body":"wants some exposed steel, or"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1111.074,"endTime":1114.284,"body":"exposed timber and, and it"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1111.074,"endTime":1114.284,"body":"really makes sense to look at"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1114.289,"endTime":1116.924,"body":"what are the realistic fire"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1114.289,"endTime":1116.924,"body":"scenarios that could develop"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1116.924,"endTime":1119.894,"body":"in this type of structure"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1116.924,"endTime":1119.894,"body":"and then, , investigate the"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1119.894,"endTime":1123.654,"body":"response of those structure,"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1119.894,"endTime":1123.654,"body":"those fires rather than look."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1123.828,"endTime":1125.958,"body":"What we are using in"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1123.828,"endTime":1125.958,"body":"standard furnace test."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1125.958,"endTime":1126.408,"body":"Exactly."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1126.768,"endTime":1127.548,"body":"So, absolutely."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1128.028,"endTime":1128.88,"body":"To your point."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1128.928,"endTime":1133.448,"body":"this development of structural"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1128.928,"endTime":1133.448,"body":"fire engineering also, worked"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1133.658,"endTime":1137.048,"body":"alongside developments of"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1133.658,"endTime":1137.048,"body":"fire models for structural"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1137.048,"endTime":1139.538,"body":"engineers and a lot of the."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1139.806,"endTime":1143.354,"body":"In the end, impact that it has"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1139.806,"endTime":1143.354,"body":"had on, on practice and where"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1143.354,"endTime":1147.554,"body":"really we could see a value"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1143.354,"endTime":1147.554,"body":"of adopting these analysis was"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1147.554,"endTime":1151.034,"body":"linked not only to a better"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1147.554,"endTime":1151.034,"body":"understanding of the structural"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1151.034,"endTime":1154.181,"body":"fire response, but also, more"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1151.034,"endTime":1154.181,"body":"realistic representation of"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1154.181,"endTime":1156.071,"body":"what, fire scenarios might be."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1156.641,"endTime":1158.112,"body":"So that's, I think"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1156.641,"endTime":1158.112,"body":"that that's key."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1159.481,"endTime":1162.661,"body":"But I, I think more generally,"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1159.481,"endTime":1162.661,"body":"to your point also, I wanted"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1162.661,"endTime":1166.401,"body":"to compare with what we do"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1162.661,"endTime":1166.401,"body":"in, standardized furnace"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1166.401,"endTime":1170.211,"body":"testing versus what numerical"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1166.401,"endTime":1170.211,"body":"models enable us to do."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1170.211,"endTime":1173.781,"body":"So in civil engineering"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1170.211,"endTime":1173.781,"body":"and buildings, we are"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1173.781,"endTime":1176.274,"body":"not dealing with, mass"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1173.781,"endTime":1176.274,"body":"production product, right?"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1176.274,"endTime":1180.294,"body":"We are not building iPhones or,"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1176.274,"endTime":1180.294,"body":"or cars, uh, where we have the"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1180.294,"endTime":1183.844,"body":"luxury to, build a few specimens"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1180.294,"endTime":1183.844,"body":"that we will test for scale,"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1183.844,"endTime":1185.854,"body":"because we are just building,"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1183.844,"endTime":1185.854,"body":"you know, millions of them."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1186.329,"endTime":1188.669,"body":"On the opposite"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1186.329,"endTime":1188.669,"body":"buildings are all unique."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1190.424,"endTime":1193.664,"body":"It'll never be an option to"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1190.424,"endTime":1193.664,"body":"build an entire building aside"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1193.724,"endTime":1196.721,"body":"the actual building we want"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1193.724,"endTime":1196.721,"body":"to use and set it on, on fire."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1196.736,"endTime":1197.186,"body":"mm-hmm"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1197.231,"endTime":1199.721,"body":"what we are doing"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1197.231,"endTime":1199.721,"body":"in a sense is that we are just"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1200.201,"endTime":1203.531,"body":"taking a few components and, and"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1200.201,"endTime":1203.531,"body":"applying a standardized furnace"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1203.531,"endTime":1206.411,"body":"test and extrapolating that"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1203.531,"endTime":1206.411,"body":"it'll inform us on the behavior"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1206.416,"endTime":1208.138,"body":"of the, of the full, building."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1208.568,"endTime":1211.781,"body":"As if I would say in a car"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1208.568,"endTime":1211.781,"body":"crash, worse in this test, we"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1211.781,"endTime":1214.321,"body":"are just testing, you know, the,"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1211.781,"endTime":1214.321,"body":"the bumper , and maybe , a few"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1214.321,"endTime":1216.661,"body":"components, and then trying to"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1214.321,"endTime":1216.661,"body":"understand how the car would"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1216.666,"endTime":1218.668,"body":"react in the actual, crush test."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1219.013,"endTime":1220.954,"body":"and besides all"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1219.013,"endTime":1220.954,"body":"buildings are different."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1220.959,"endTime":1222.604,"body":"So you, you would test"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1220.959,"endTime":1222.604,"body":"the bumper and you"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1222.609,"endTime":1223.624,"body":"would extrapolate that."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1223.704,"endTime":1226.101,"body":"Maybe it's, it, it informs"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1223.704,"endTime":1226.101,"body":"you on the, the open,"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1226.101,"endTime":1229.791,"body":"last try on the BME BMW"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1226.101,"endTime":1229.791,"body":"series five the same way."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1229.791,"endTime":1229.987,"body":"Right."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1230.424,"endTime":1233.094,"body":"so we are never going to"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1230.424,"endTime":1233.094,"body":"do that for ex experimental"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1233.274,"endTime":1234.264,"body":"testing for the building."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1234.264,"endTime":1236.964,"body":"So really computational"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1234.264,"endTime":1236.964,"body":"models make a lot of sense"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1236.964,"endTime":1240.294,"body":"because there you can build"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1236.964,"endTime":1240.294,"body":"these, you know, digital"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1240.294,"endTime":1242.964,"body":"twins and challenge them"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1240.294,"endTime":1242.964,"body":"against, lots of, , types of"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1242.964,"endTime":1245.364,"body":"conditions and all those fire"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1242.964,"endTime":1245.364,"body":"scenarios that you mentioned."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1245.614,"endTime":1246.634,"body":"I"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1245.614,"endTime":1246.634,"body":"would put one more thing"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1246.634,"endTime":1247.834,"body":"on, on standard testing."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1248.214,"endTime":1251.124,"body":"Many people don't like this"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1248.214,"endTime":1251.124,"body":"way of talking about standard"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1251.184,"endTime":1254.991,"body":"testing, but, it is in a"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1251.184,"endTime":1254.991,"body":"way, a reality you have"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1254.996,"endTime":1256.151,"body":"to consider standardized."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1257.346,"endTime":1261.936,"body":"in relation to product it is a"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1257.346,"endTime":1261.936,"body":"standardized product testing."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1262.626,"endTime":1265.176,"body":"was never meant to be"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1262.626,"endTime":1265.176,"body":"a test of a building."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1265.176,"endTime":1269.796,"body":"It wasn't because it fits so"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1265.176,"endTime":1269.796,"body":"tightly within the framework of"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1269.796,"endTime":1273.816,"body":"product being certified before"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1269.796,"endTime":1273.816,"body":"it is delivered to the market."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1274.236,"endTime":1276.633,"body":"So the market understands"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1274.236,"endTime":1276.633,"body":"the, that stands the core"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1276.633,"endTime":1278.073,"body":"characteristics of the product."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1278.673,"endTime":1281.646,"body":"And that's exactly the"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1278.673,"endTime":1281.646,"body":"need that, fire testing"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1281.646,"endTime":1283.426,"body":"in laboratory, caters for."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1283.851,"endTime":1287.631,"body":"And therefore, because we"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1283.851,"endTime":1287.631,"body":"have this as a standard"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1287.751,"endTime":1290.024,"body":"product testing, the."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1290.439,"endTime":1294.209,"body":"Manufacturers use this as"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1290.439,"endTime":1294.209,"body":"a ranking tool or, know,"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1294.209,"endTime":1295.409,"body":"it's a way to compete."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1295.409,"endTime":1297.329,"body":"Ah, my product has"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1295.409,"endTime":1297.329,"body":"this classification."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1297.329,"endTime":1300.149,"body":"Yours has other ones,"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1297.329,"endTime":1300.149,"body":"so mine is better."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1301.149,"endTime":1305.729,"body":"It, gives you a fairly easy"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1301.149,"endTime":1305.729,"body":"way to, overlook the market."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1305.759,"endTime":1309.989,"body":"Others, like only one product"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1305.759,"endTime":1309.989,"body":"that has this specific barter"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1309.989,"endTime":1311.129,"body":"and every other is where."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1311.129,"endTime":1313.469,"body":"So, so I lose this"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1311.129,"endTime":1313.469,"body":"one and it also."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1313.794,"endTime":1317.921,"body":"It's a very attractive way for"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1313.794,"endTime":1317.921,"body":"nonspecialist stakeholders,"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1318.004,"endTime":1320.428,"body":"to, to put a product because"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1318.004,"endTime":1320.428,"body":"they, they have no idea, but"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1320.433,"endTime":1323.428,"body":"the code says this product of"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1320.433,"endTime":1323.428,"body":"this characteristic is just"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1323.428,"endTime":1324.388,"body":"enough for your building."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1324.388,"endTime":1328.795,"body":"So, so like this is a"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1324.388,"endTime":1328.795,"body":"whole framework fit around."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1328.886,"endTime":1332.816,"body":"Delivering products to market"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1328.886,"endTime":1332.816,"body":"that cater to specific needs"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1332.816,"endTime":1335.276,"body":"and can be distinguished"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1332.816,"endTime":1335.276,"body":"by the characteristics."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1335.606,"endTime":1340.426,"body":"Whereas a building does not have"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1335.606,"endTime":1340.426,"body":"a, a single, uh, response, fire,"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1340.426,"endTime":1342.196,"body":"fire resistance characteristic."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1342.503,"endTime":1345.593,"body":"uh, like you said, it can"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1342.503,"endTime":1345.593,"body":"burn and, and collapse in"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1345.593,"endTime":1347.363,"body":"probably thousands of ways."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1348.343,"endTime":1350.728,"body":"of them will be"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1348.343,"endTime":1350.728,"body":"different, very specific."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1350.948,"endTime":1354.838,"body":"And the job of structural"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1350.948,"endTime":1354.838,"body":"engineer like you is, to"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1354.838,"endTime":1359.651,"body":"make sure that in a probable"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1354.838,"endTime":1359.651,"body":"scenarios, it, does, not"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1359.651,"endTime":1363.491,"body":"collapse or, or that,"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1359.651,"endTime":1363.491,"body":"um, maybe even more that."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1363.933,"endTime":1365.733,"body":"There is no"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1363.933,"endTime":1365.733,"body":"disproportionate collapse."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1365.733,"endTime":1367.113,"body":"Like very small fire."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1367.113,"endTime":1369.723,"body":"Doesn't collapse it because"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1367.113,"endTime":1369.723,"body":"if you, if a meter strikes"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1369.723,"endTime":1373.563,"body":"your building, then it's"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1369.723,"endTime":1373.563,"body":"not gonna probably survive."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1373.563,"endTime":1374.773,"body":"So, here, is this."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1374.858,"endTime":1379.538,"body":"Fork between the product"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1374.858,"endTime":1379.538,"body":"market and the building market."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1379.928,"endTime":1381.818,"body":"It's just in ice of many people."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1381.818,"endTime":1384.918,"body":"It's the same market where"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1381.818,"endTime":1384.918,"body":"it not necessarily is."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1385.128,"endTime":1388.831,"body":"However, I, I still find but"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1385.128,"endTime":1388.831,"body":"you still don't do structural"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1388.831,"endTime":1391.801,"body":"engineering like that for"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1388.831,"endTime":1391.801,"body":"every single building."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1391.801,"endTime":1395.641,"body":"Right there, there, there are"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1391.801,"endTime":1395.641,"body":"like, cake type buildings that"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1395.641,"endTime":1396.904,"body":"you just take from the book,"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1397.534,"endTime":1398.284,"body":"Absolutely."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1398.284,"endTime":1399.064,"body":"And so, yeah."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1399.214,"endTime":1401.524,"body":"Also let me make a"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1399.214,"endTime":1401.524,"body":"few things clear."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1401.674,"endTime":1403.774,"body":"first of all, I mean,"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1401.674,"endTime":1403.774,"body":"standardized for testing"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1403.774,"endTime":1406.054,"body":"is tremendously important"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1403.774,"endTime":1406.054,"body":"and it has delivered"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1406.234,"endTime":1407.734,"body":"the baseline of safety."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1407.734,"endTime":1408.034,"body":"Right?"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1408.034,"endTime":1410.529,"body":"It's been a great"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1408.034,"endTime":1410.529,"body":"answer , to a true problem."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1410.529,"endTime":1412.929,"body":"At the beginning of the"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1410.529,"endTime":1412.929,"body":"20th century, it has."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1413.454,"endTime":1415.554,"body":"Product amazing benefits."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1415.944,"endTime":1419.214,"body":"And even for us, you know,"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1415.944,"endTime":1419.214,"body":"working on computational"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1419.214,"endTime":1423.234,"body":"modeling, experimental testing"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1419.214,"endTime":1423.234,"body":"is absolutely crucial component"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1423.234,"endTime":1425.184,"body":"to validate our models."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1425.184,"endTime":1427.68,"body":"Whenever new material"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1425.184,"endTime":1427.68,"body":"are developed, we need"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1427.68,"endTime":1430.587,"body":"the data, we cannot just,"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1427.68,"endTime":1430.587,"body":"extrapolate material models."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1430.747,"endTime":1432.517,"body":"We have to have those,"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1430.747,"endTime":1432.517,"body":"those data points."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1432.787,"endTime":1433.867,"body":"So all this absolutely."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1433.867,"endTime":1434.017,"body":"And so."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1435.232,"endTime":1436.162,"body":"As we speak."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1436.212,"endTime":1438.612,"body":", I would say push on the"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1436.212,"endTime":1438.612,"body":"limitations to make clear,"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1438.662,"endTime":1441.092,"body":"why we do what we do and"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1438.662,"endTime":1441.092,"body":"what's the value added."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1441.092,"endTime":1444.154,"body":"But, it doesn't mean that"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1441.092,"endTime":1444.154,"body":"there are lots of, rational."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1444.214,"endTime":1447.327,"body":"So for continuing doing those,"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1444.214,"endTime":1447.327,"body":"those standardized tests, but"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1447.86,"endTime":1450.894,"body":"I mean, I agree with what you"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1447.86,"endTime":1450.894,"body":"said, it's really in, going"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1450.894,"endTime":1454.29,"body":"further than, certifying these"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1450.894,"endTime":1454.29,"body":"products and understanding"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1454.56,"endTime":1458.364,"body":"or hating, the behavior of,"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1454.56,"endTime":1458.364,"body":"of these, you know, beams and"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1458.364,"endTime":1459.834,"body":"columns and doors and so on."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1460.61,"endTime":1462.05,"body":"How do we scale that up?"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1462.17,"endTime":1466.52,"body":"And how do we re interrogate"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1462.17,"endTime":1466.52,"body":"the true safety level of"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1466.58,"endTime":1468.26,"body":"the assembly of the system?"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1468.56,"endTime":1471.74,"body":"Once we build the building out"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1468.56,"endTime":1471.74,"body":"of these components, and that"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1471.74,"endTime":1475.94,"body":"is something that we don't have"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1471.74,"endTime":1475.94,"body":"the luxury to look at true full"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1475.94,"endTime":1478.94,"body":"scale experimental testing,"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1475.94,"endTime":1478.94,"body":"because in civil engineering,"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1479.18,"endTime":1481.07,"body":"we are building unique."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1481.875,"endTime":1482.445,"body":"Objects."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1482.445,"endTime":1482.685,"body":"Right."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1483.045,"endTime":1486.169,"body":"So, I argue that computational"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1483.045,"endTime":1486.169,"body":"modeling is really the tool"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1486.169,"endTime":1489.259,"body":"to, bridge this gap and to"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1486.169,"endTime":1489.259,"body":"go to that, , higher level."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1489.529,"endTime":1492.642,"body":"And as you said, there"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1489.529,"endTime":1492.642,"body":"are many ways that, a fire"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1492.642,"endTime":1493.872,"body":"can challenge a structure."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1494.642,"endTime":1497.812,"body":"And we need to make sure that"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1494.642,"endTime":1497.812,"body":"what we are building is, robust"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1497.932,"endTime":1501.502,"body":"when it's in, I mean, the"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1497.932,"endTime":1501.502,"body":"true conditions and subjected"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1501.502,"endTime":1503.152,"body":"to physically based fire."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1503.632,"endTime":1505.882,"body":"And when we are looking at"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1503.632,"endTime":1505.882,"body":"performance subjectives that"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1505.882,"endTime":1510.195,"body":"might go beyond, standardized"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1505.882,"endTime":1510.195,"body":"rating or one or two standard"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1510.195,"endTime":1514.605,"body":"for resistance, but we might"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1510.195,"endTime":1514.605,"body":"need to demonstrate survival to"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1514.605,"endTime":1517.732,"body":"full burnout or, the fact that"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1514.605,"endTime":1517.732,"body":"the damage remains localized."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1517.732,"endTime":1518.932,"body":"And we don't have this kind of."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1519.242,"endTime":1521.192,"body":"Progressive collapses you"},{"speaker":". Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1523.515,"endTime":1527.072,"body":"And, in the"},{"speaker":". Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1523.515,"endTime":1527.072,"body":"interface between fire testing"},{"speaker":". Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1527.102,"endTime":1528.832,"body":"and, , full scale behavior."},{"speaker":". Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1529.402,"endTime":1530.542,"body":"You use fire testing"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1530.542,"endTime":1530.885,"body":"were, uh,"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1530.542,"endTime":1530.885,"body":"referring to and so on."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1530.885,"endTime":1530.886,"body":"Yes."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1530.886,"endTime":1530.887,"body":"And."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1531.652,"endTime":1535.162,"body":"and, , as a way to obtain,"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1535.162,"endTime":1538.302,"body":", data on, on the materials"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1535.162,"endTime":1538.302,"body":"on structural behavior."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1538.822,"endTime":1540.922,"body":"But in the end, , when"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1538.822,"endTime":1540.922,"body":"you go into numerical"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1540.922,"endTime":1542.897,"body":"modeling, of a building."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1543.077,"endTime":1547.187,"body":"If we can jump in into"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1543.077,"endTime":1547.187,"body":"that part, you still like"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1547.192,"endTime":1549.827,"body":"using the standard curve"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1547.192,"endTime":1549.827,"body":"as your boundary condition?"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1549.827,"endTime":1552.617,"body":"Or would you go like with"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1549.827,"endTime":1552.617,"body":"your code, your localized"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1552.617,"endTime":1557.21,"body":"fire, how do you like you,"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1552.617,"endTime":1557.21,"body":"you have your properties of"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1557.21,"endTime":1558.23,"body":"your materials and stuff."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1558.23,"endTime":1561.86,"body":"How do you define fire in, in"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1558.23,"endTime":1561.86,"body":"structural for engineering then?"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1562.47,"endTime":1565.254,"body":"."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1562.47,"endTime":1565.254,"body":"Thomas Gernay: So when we,"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1565.254,"endTime":1568.334,"body":"for, , predicting the behavioral"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1565.254,"endTime":1568.334,"body":"infrastructure and fire."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1568.334,"endTime":1570.434,"body":"And as you said"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1568.334,"endTime":1570.434,"body":"before, it's not for."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1571.079,"endTime":1573.563,"body":"Every, small building or"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1571.079,"endTime":1573.563,"body":"every case, but when we do"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1573.563,"endTime":1577.893,"body":"so usually we frame it in"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1573.563,"endTime":1577.893,"body":", the context of performance"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1577.893,"endTime":1579.633,"body":"based, fire design, right?"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1579.638,"endTime":1582.933,"body":"So it means that we"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1579.638,"endTime":1582.933,"body":"start by, uh, setting up"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1583.023,"endTime":1585.633,"body":"objectives, performance"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1583.023,"endTime":1585.633,"body":"objectives for design."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1585.633,"endTime":1587.133,"body":"So explicitly we have to"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1587.253,"endTime":1587.313,"body":"Mm."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1587.463,"endTime":1589.953,"body":"define what we"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1587.463,"endTime":1589.953,"body":"are trying to achieve or what"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1589.953,"endTime":1593.399,"body":"we want, what conditions we"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1589.953,"endTime":1593.399,"body":"want, the, to survive , and."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1594.614,"endTime":1598.388,"body":"Failure means and what, a"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1594.614,"endTime":1598.388,"body":"successful design is, because"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1598.388,"endTime":1600.348,"body":"that will be different,"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1598.388,"endTime":1600.348,"body":"for whole structures."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1600.828,"endTime":1603.704,"body":"As I said before, for some,"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1600.828,"endTime":1603.704,"body":"we may want to demonstrate"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1603.709,"endTime":1607.814,"body":"survival to full burn out of the"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1603.709,"endTime":1607.814,"body":"fires and for those a certain"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1607.814,"endTime":1609.494,"body":"duration of stability or."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1610.109,"endTime":1611.609,"body":"Yet other objectives."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1611.999,"endTime":1616.079,"body":"So then at the, the second step,"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1611.999,"endTime":1616.079,"body":"we will work on design fires."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1616.139,"endTime":1619.139,"body":"And in this context of"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1616.139,"endTime":1619.139,"body":"performance based fire design,"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1619.144,"endTime":1622.059,"body":"usually we don't rely on the"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1619.144,"endTime":1622.059,"body":"standard, fire curve, which"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1622.059,"endTime":1624.069,"body":"really has another purpose."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1624.369,"endTime":1627.369,"body":"So once we are going with"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1624.369,"endTime":1627.369,"body":"modeling, we are interested"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1627.369,"endTime":1631.361,"body":"in, Trying to predict realistic"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1627.369,"endTime":1631.361,"body":"or physically based fires that"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1631.361,"endTime":1634.211,"body":"that would develop given the"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1631.361,"endTime":1634.211,"body":"conditions and what we know of"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1634.211,"endTime":1635.981,"body":"the inputs for the building."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1636.461,"endTime":1641.321,"body":"And so we might have to check"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1636.461,"endTime":1641.321,"body":"both post slash over fires and"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1641.651,"endTime":1645.574,"body":"localized slash traveling fires,"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1641.651,"endTime":1645.574,"body":"depending on the geometry of"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1645.579,"endTime":1648.384,"body":"the compartment, ventilation"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1645.579,"endTime":1648.384,"body":"conditions, the fuel and."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1648.978,"endTime":1652.308,"body":"it is not enough to consider"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1648.978,"endTime":1652.308,"body":"one design fire because there"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1652.308,"endTime":1655.801,"body":"are so, so many uncertainties"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1652.308,"endTime":1655.801,"body":"involved, a robust performance"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1655.801,"endTime":1659.341,"body":"based design will rely on,"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1655.801,"endTime":1659.341,"body":"uh, a series of design fires"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1659.341,"endTime":1662.084,"body":"and, and look at the effects"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1659.341,"endTime":1662.084,"body":"of variation of these inputs."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1662.744,"endTime":1666.284,"body":"Usually it's good practice to,"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1662.744,"endTime":1666.284,"body":"in any case, check a localized."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1667.039,"endTime":1669.199,"body":"That might be very close"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1667.039,"endTime":1669.199,"body":"to a column, for example,"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1669.349,"endTime":1671.389,"body":"which will always occur"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1669.349,"endTime":1671.389,"body":"at the beginning, right."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1671.389,"endTime":1674.029,"body":"At the early stage of the"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1671.389,"endTime":1674.029,"body":"fire and then the, the"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1674.029,"endTime":1676.669,"body":"full growth and development"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1674.029,"endTime":1676.669,"body":"of that fire, possibly"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1676.669,"endTime":1678.049,"body":"transitioning to flashover."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1678.563,"endTime":1681.503,"body":"we know of course, for example,"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1678.563,"endTime":1681.503,"body":"ventilation assumptions"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1681.533,"endTime":1683.123,"body":"will have a big impact also."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1683.123,"endTime":1684.449,"body":"So, there is some guidance."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1685.189,"endTime":1687.506,"body":"to look at when,"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1685.189,"endTime":1687.506,"body":"windows will, break."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1687.746,"endTime":1690.619,"body":"And so how, you can have"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1687.746,"endTime":1690.619,"body":"your, ventilation condition"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1690.649,"endTime":1693.859,"body":"suddenly change when the gas"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1690.649,"endTime":1693.859,"body":"temperature reaches a certain"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1693.859,"endTime":1695.239,"body":"value, these type of things."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1695.929,"endTime":1699.229,"body":"Um, so first performance"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1695.929,"endTime":1699.229,"body":"objectives, second design fires."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1699.234,"endTime":1701.539,"body":"And then we go with, the"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1699.234,"endTime":1701.539,"body":"tur marts to response"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1701.653,"endTime":1702.503,"body":"of, of the structure"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1702.503,"endTime":1702.983,"body":"itself."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1703.343,"endTime":1703.643,"body":"Yes."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1703.713,"endTime":1705.333,"body":"you have"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1703.713,"endTime":1705.333,"body":"the assumptions, but you don't"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1705.333,"endTime":1706.953,"body":"have them fire modeling yet."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1707.283,"endTime":1710.209,"body":"So you would go with"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1707.283,"endTime":1710.209,"body":"like some simple, hand"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1710.209,"endTime":1712.249,"body":"calculations, the model."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1712.279,"endTime":1715.609,"body":"I don't think CFD, but because"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1712.279,"endTime":1715.609,"body":"I think that would be very rare."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1715.969,"endTime":1718.339,"body":"So how you go from"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1715.969,"endTime":1718.339,"body":"assumptions to thermal?"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1719.476,"endTime":1720.136,"body":"You're right."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1720.196,"endTime":1723.526,"body":"I didn't mention it, but no, we"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1720.196,"endTime":1723.526,"body":"have access to the full suite"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1723.531,"endTime":1726.166,"body":"of tools there so we can do."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1726.234,"endTime":1729.684,"body":"Analytical methods, kind"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1726.234,"endTime":1729.684,"body":"of OC code barometric fire"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1729.984,"endTime":1732.354,"body":"that we have commonly used."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1732.354,"endTime":1735.324,"body":"For example, in probabilistic,"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1732.354,"endTime":1735.324,"body":"risk assessment analysis."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1735.324,"endTime":1737.994,"body":"We want a lot of scenarios"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1735.324,"endTime":1737.994,"body":"and really look at this"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1737.994,"endTime":1741.144,"body":"variability of conditions"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1737.994,"endTime":1741.144,"body":"for localized fire."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1741.384,"endTime":1741.744,"body":"Yes,"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1741.954,"endTime":1743.034,"body":"go"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1741.954,"endTime":1743.034,"body":"traveling fire, like we've"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1743.034,"endTime":1745.674,"body":"mentioned before, where you"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1743.034,"endTime":1745.674,"body":"would have a plethora of"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1745.674,"endTime":1749.324,"body":"scenarios, which are like,"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1745.674,"endTime":1749.324,"body":"pregenerated for your geometry"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1749.329,"endTime":1752.294,"body":"with a very simple model"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1749.329,"endTime":1752.294,"body":"of different complexity,"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1752.294,"endTime":1753.434,"body":"depending which you use."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1753.464,"endTime":1753.674,"body":"Yeah."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1754.004,"endTime":1754.224,"body":"And."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1754.304,"endTime":1754.844,"body":"Absolutely."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1754.844,"endTime":1757.784,"body":"So analytical model for"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1754.844,"endTime":1757.784,"body":"post flashover or traveling"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1757.784,"endTime":1759.854,"body":"fire or localized fire."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1759.854,"endTime":1762.044,"body":"So in the Euro code, , we"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1759.854,"endTime":1762.044,"body":"are usually relying on"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1762.044,"endTime":1763.214,"body":"models in the Euro code."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1763.574,"endTime":1767.054,"body":"you have Hasemi you have, uh,"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1763.574,"endTime":1767.054,"body":"Heskestad you have now locafi"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1767.474,"endTime":1770.231,"body":"will be included in the next,"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1767.474,"endTime":1770.231,"body":"version of Euro code, which is"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1770.231,"endTime":1775.071,"body":"a solid flame model to capture"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1770.231,"endTime":1775.071,"body":"the, heat, radiation to a member"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1775.071,"endTime":1776.691,"body":"that is outside of the fire."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1777.216,"endTime":1780.036,"body":"we have, sort of traveling"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1777.216,"endTime":1780.036,"body":"fire models that you mentioned"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1780.036,"endTime":1782.576,"body":"also with some very elegant"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1780.036,"endTime":1782.576,"body":"and, and relatively simple"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1782.576,"endTime":1786.949,"body":"solutions, but we also use"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1782.576,"endTime":1786.949,"body":"FDS and, actually one of the."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1788.344,"endTime":1791.254,"body":"Not so recent anymore, but"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1788.344,"endTime":1791.254,"body":"relatively recent development"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1791.254,"endTime":1794.664,"body":"in severe was to facilitate"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1791.254,"endTime":1794.664,"body":"the transfer between,"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1794.738,"endTime":1799.021,"body":"output data from FDS and the"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1794.738,"endTime":1799.021,"body":"thermal structural analysis."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1799.441,"endTime":1802.591,"body":"So usually there are two"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1799.441,"endTime":1802.591,"body":"techniques that we would use,"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1802.649,"endTime":1804.961,"body":"to couple, CFD simulation."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1804.961,"endTime":1807.421,"body":"And I'm talking about FDS"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1804.961,"endTime":1807.421,"body":"interchangeably because"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1807.421,"endTime":1810.624,"body":"that's really the most common,"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1807.421,"endTime":1810.624,"body":"with, uh, FVM analysis."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1811.164,"endTime":1814.404,"body":"We can use the concept of"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1811.164,"endTime":1814.404,"body":"about surface temperature"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1814.404,"endTime":1816.264,"body":"developed by, by Wickstrom"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1814.404,"endTime":1816.264,"body":"and we've done that."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1816.264,"endTime":1818.604,"body":"So we have all those"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1816.264,"endTime":1818.604,"body":"sensors around or switch."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1819.234,"endTime":1821.214,"body":"We need to make sure we have"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1819.234,"endTime":1821.214,"body":"enough of them to capture"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1821.214,"endTime":1824.244,"body":"thermal gradients to capture,"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1821.214,"endTime":1824.244,"body":"shadow effect and so on."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1824.314,"endTime":1824.434,"body":"Hmm."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1824.724,"endTime":1826.854,"body":"And, uh, but"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1824.724,"endTime":1826.854,"body":"if, when we are looking at."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1827.499,"endTime":1829.359,"body":"Modeling a larger structure."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1829.359,"endTime":1832.719,"body":"For example, we've used in"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1829.359,"endTime":1832.719,"body":"open car park simulation and"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1832.724,"endTime":1835.179,"body":"these type of things where"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1832.724,"endTime":1835.179,"body":"we have lots of structural"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1835.179,"endTime":1837.913,"body":"members and, we would"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1835.179,"endTime":1837.913,"body":"need a lot of, of sensors."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1838.333,"endTime":1842.889,"body":"We have also, the option to"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1838.333,"endTime":1842.889,"body":"use, automatic, interface file."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1843.399,"endTime":1846.289,"body":"So, it was developed with"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1843.399,"endTime":1846.289,"body":"the developers of FDS."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1846.289,"endTime":1849.709,"body":"Actually, we can ask"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1846.289,"endTime":1849.709,"body":"FDS to write a transfer"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1849.709,"endTime":1852.619,"body":"file as a output of the"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1849.709,"endTime":1852.619,"body":"simulation that will."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1853.019,"endTime":1856.829,"body":"Output the, the gas, temperature"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1853.019,"endTime":1856.829,"body":"and radiant intensity along"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1857.069,"endTime":1859.206,"body":"lots of directions, in space."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1860.138,"endTime":1863.078,"body":"I mean, special coordinates"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1860.138,"endTime":1863.078,"body":"in a domain that we define"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1863.438,"endTime":1868.148,"body":"and SAFIR can read this"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1863.438,"endTime":1868.148,"body":"transfer file and, uh, use"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1868.148,"endTime":1872.078,"body":"that as input thermal boundary"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1868.148,"endTime":1872.078,"body":"conditions for the heat transfer"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1872.078,"endTime":1873.398,"body":"analysis in the sections."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1873.428,"endTime":1876.218,"body":"And that is the advantage"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1873.428,"endTime":1876.218,"body":"that it's automatized."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1876.248,"endTime":1880.298,"body":"So it's well suited when you"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1876.248,"endTime":1880.298,"body":"have a big structure and, uh,"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1880.298,"endTime":1882.488,"body":"it captures the shadow effect."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1882.488,"endTime":1884.888,"body":"It, it sees the view angles"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1882.488,"endTime":1884.888,"body":"and, and everything to capture"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1884.888,"endTime":1886.168,"body":"radiation, , appropriately."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1886.303,"endTime":1887.073,"body":"This is brilliant."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1887.109,"endTime":1888.369,"body":"I didn't know about that."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1888.369,"endTime":1892.943,"body":"I actually, uh, I'm like in"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1888.369,"endTime":1892.943,"body":"ANSYS ecosystem, so, I know."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1893.118,"endTime":1897.291,"body":"A bit on FDS because,"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1893.118,"endTime":1897.291,"body":"my I have to follow"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1897.521,"endTime":1897.761,"body":"All of"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1897.891,"endTime":1900.788,"body":"but I'm"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1897.891,"endTime":1900.788,"body":"not like everyday user of, FDS"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1900.788,"endTime":1902.048,"body":"outside of scientific research."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1902.498,"endTime":1904.209,"body":"And this, sounds like,"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1902.498,"endTime":1904.209,"body":"really like, Really nice"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1904.209,"endTime":1905.739,"body":"development sometime ago."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1905.739,"endTime":1905.949,"body":"I was"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1905.964,"endTime":1906.054,"body":"that."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1906.279,"endTime":1908.079,"body":"like, what"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1906.279,"endTime":1908.079,"body":"has changed in like last 10"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1908.084,"endTime":1911.349,"body":"years when I work in this field"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1908.084,"endTime":1911.349,"body":"and not that much has changed,"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1911.349,"endTime":1914.516,"body":"but this is something like"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1911.349,"endTime":1914.516,"body":"really a huge quality of life,"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1914.519,"endTime":1920.639,"body":"improvement that really allows"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1914.519,"endTime":1920.639,"body":"you for less, uh, connection"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1920.639,"endTime":1925.529,"body":"between your fluid and structure"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1920.639,"endTime":1925.529,"body":"That that's very interesting."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1925.889,"endTime":1927.469,"body":"And have you tried anything."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1928.256,"endTime":1931.916,"body":"in the, in, I know in"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1928.256,"endTime":1931.916,"body":"ANSYS ecosystem, I, I"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1931.926,"endTime":1935.036,"body":"have not have not mastered"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1931.926,"endTime":1935.036,"body":"this functionality yet."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1935.456,"endTime":1937.856,"body":"One of my colleagues in"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1935.456,"endTime":1937.856,"body":"the office is playing,"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1937.856,"endTime":1940.286,"body":"but we have like, two-way"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1937.856,"endTime":1940.286,"body":"coupled interactions."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1940.291,"endTime":1944.043,"body":"So if like, the structure,"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1940.291,"endTime":1944.043,"body":"let's say you have a steel"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1944.043,"endTime":1947.903,"body":"sheet roof, and if the"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1944.043,"endTime":1947.903,"body":"roof fails, you have a."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1948.618,"endTime":1951.408,"body":"And that hole is then"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1948.618,"endTime":1951.408,"body":"transferred from my structural"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1951.408,"endTime":1953.088,"body":"model to fluid model."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1953.088,"endTime":1956.748,"body":"So the fluid model in, in"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1953.088,"endTime":1956.748,"body":"incorporates the, the way"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1957.168,"endTime":1960.044,"body":"how, uh, this hole would,"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1957.168,"endTime":1960.044,"body":"change the flow fields."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1960.361,"endTime":1963.691,"body":"but I guess that that's quite"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1960.361,"endTime":1963.691,"body":"complicated, probably difficult,"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1963.811,"endTime":1966.318,"body":"especially if you have, solvers,"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":1963.811,"endTime":1966.318,"body":"not within the one ecosystem."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1966.685,"endTime":1967.933,"body":"It"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1966.685,"endTime":1967.933,"body":"is complicated."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1967.993,"endTime":1970.573,"body":"That's something we, we"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1967.993,"endTime":1970.573,"body":"have not addressed yet,"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1970.693,"endTime":1973.393,"body":"but it is relevant for"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1970.693,"endTime":1973.393,"body":"certain applications."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1973.393,"endTime":1974.383,"body":"You mentioned an example."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1974.383,"endTime":1976.959,"body":"There are, of course other"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1974.383,"endTime":1976.959,"body":"example where this, Two"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1976.959,"endTime":1980.033,"body":"way feedback or two way"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1976.959,"endTime":1980.033,"body":"coupling, makes sense."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1980.273,"endTime":1983.823,"body":"I would say fundamentally,"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1980.273,"endTime":1983.823,"body":"when I'm describing this, these"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1983.823,"endTime":1987.543,"body":"developments, it really comes"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1983.823,"endTime":1987.543,"body":"from a, a realization our behalf"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1987.543,"endTime":1990.843,"body":"and people working in structural"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1987.543,"endTime":1990.843,"body":"fire engineering, that a lot"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1990.843,"endTime":1993.899,"body":"of the advances and the gaps"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1990.843,"endTime":1993.899,"body":"were at the intersection of"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1993.899,"endTime":1996.779,"body":"the disciplines as is often"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1993.899,"endTime":1996.779,"body":"the case in, you know, in"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1997.019,"endTime":1998.009,"body":"engineering and science."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1998.009,"endTime":1998.369,"body":"So."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1998.969,"endTime":2001.639,"body":"I told you earlier, the"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":1998.969,"endTime":2001.639,"body":"story of the fire protection"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2001.639,"endTime":2004.099,"body":"engineers, who asked for the"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2001.639,"endTime":2004.099,"body":"critical temperature and the,"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2004.249,"endTime":2006.829,"body":"the structural engineer who"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2004.249,"endTime":2006.829,"body":"asked for the, the standup,"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2006.904,"endTime":2008.854,"body":"Fire resistance or fire curve."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2009.274,"endTime":2013.688,"body":"So, we saw that value was in,"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2009.274,"endTime":2013.688,"body":"connecting those two words and"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2013.688,"endTime":2018.368,"body":"making it easier in terms of the"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2013.688,"endTime":2018.368,"body":"numerical modeling ecosystem to"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2018.428,"endTime":2021.698,"body":"bridge and couple the advanced"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2018.428,"endTime":2021.698,"body":"fire models with the advanced,"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2022.008,"endTime":2023.328,"body":", structural simulations."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2023.568,"endTime":2026.988,"body":"So we are putting a lot of"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2023.568,"endTime":2026.988,"body":"efforts on these, and right"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2026.988,"endTime":2029.508,"body":"now we have all these options"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2026.988,"endTime":2029.508,"body":"for the one way, coupling from"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2029.508,"endTime":2030.738,"body":"the fire to the structure."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2031.068,"endTime":2033.258,"body":"What you describe is,"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2031.068,"endTime":2033.258,"body":"is very interesting."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2033.364,"endTime":2037.714,"body":"future development that"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2033.364,"endTime":2037.714,"body":"can possibly, you know, is"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2037.744,"endTime":2039.691,"body":"making even more important."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2039.698,"endTime":2044.018,"body":"and I would say timely now"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2039.698,"endTime":2044.018,"body":"with, the use of compostable"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2044.018,"endTime":2047.893,"body":"building materials and this"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2044.018,"endTime":2047.893,"body":"tension between sustainability"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2047.953,"endTime":2050.549,"body":"and, fire safety that,"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2047.953,"endTime":2050.549,"body":"that we are observing."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2050.549,"endTime":2054.099,"body":"And professor Luke Biby had"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2050.549,"endTime":2054.099,"body":"the, had the great, uh, Position"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2054.099,"endTime":2058.179,"body":"paper on this, the fact that"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2054.099,"endTime":2058.179,"body":"we are innovating fast to"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2058.179,"endTime":2061.899,"body":"address the climate emergency,"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2058.179,"endTime":2061.899,"body":"and we are doing those changes"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2061.904,"endTime":2064.729,"body":"in the way we build structure"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2061.904,"endTime":2064.729,"body":"and we use material and, and"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2064.734,"endTime":2067.326,"body":"we have, the example with"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2064.734,"endTime":2067.326,"body":"facets, the example with mass"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2067.326,"endTime":2071.116,"body":"timber and so on, and they are"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2067.326,"endTime":2071.116,"body":"implications for, fire safety."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2071.146,"endTime":2074.086,"body":"And we need to make sure while"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2071.146,"endTime":2074.086,"body":"we address this very important."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2074.424,"endTime":2075.564,"body":"Momentous, right."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2075.894,"endTime":2079.074,"body":"A challenge of climate crisis"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2075.894,"endTime":2079.074,"body":"that also, it's not at the"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2079.074,"endTime":2080.754,"body":"expense of public safety."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2081.264,"endTime":2083.844,"body":"And I think computation"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2081.264,"endTime":2083.844,"body":"modelling is a tremendous"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2083.844,"endTime":2086.364,"body":"hole to play there because"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2083.844,"endTime":2086.364,"body":"innovation goes so fast."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2086.364,"endTime":2089.408,"body":"We need to predict what, the"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2086.364,"endTime":2089.408,"body":"implications are going to be"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2089.408,"endTime":2092.721,"body":"and what challenges it poses"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2089.408,"endTime":2092.721,"body":"for fire, behavior, including"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2092.991,"endTime":2094.551,"body":"structural fire behavior."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2095.306,"endTime":2098.096,"body":"But in some cases, there"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2095.306,"endTime":2098.096,"body":"might be a question of"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2098.546,"endTime":2100.666,"body":"two-way coupling that you"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2098.546,"endTime":2100.666,"body":"were describing it's abuse,"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2100.666,"endTime":2103.846,"body":"that exposed timber is going"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2100.666,"endTime":2103.846,"body":"to fuel the fire and affect"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2103.846,"endTime":2106.426,"body":"the fire dynamic as well as"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2103.846,"endTime":2106.426,"body":"having, you know, the load"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2106.426,"endTime":2107.989,"body":"bearing function that it has."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2107.989,"endTime":2108.469,"body":"And so on."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2108.859,"endTime":2111.133,"body":"And there are, there are"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2108.859,"endTime":2111.133,"body":"other examples where, you"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2111.133,"endTime":2114.033,"body":"might have the switch response"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2111.133,"endTime":2114.033,"body":"affect , the biodynamics"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2114.083,"endTime":2115.208,"body":", and thermal environment."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2115.868,"endTime":2118.118,"body":"It's also important"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2115.868,"endTime":2118.118,"body":"in, um, other."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2118.453,"endTime":2121.369,"body":"Questions, for example, I"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2118.453,"endTime":2121.369,"body":"would say compartmentation"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2121.369,"endTime":2126.629,"body":"issues and even, , failure of"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2121.369,"endTime":2126.629,"body":"non load bearing, uh, walls"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2126.629,"endTime":2129.599,"body":"and compartment boundaries,"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2126.629,"endTime":2129.599,"body":"that this is also something"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2129.604,"endTime":2132.359,"body":"that right now we cannot"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2129.604,"endTime":2132.359,"body":"really predict with those"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2132.364,"endTime":2133.499,"body":"computational models, but."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2134.964,"endTime":2137.124,"body":"As we were talking about"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2134.964,"endTime":2137.124,"body":"traveling fire, it might"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2137.124,"endTime":2141.121,"body":"be interesting to have the"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2137.124,"endTime":2141.121,"body":"capability to, predict if due"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2141.121,"endTime":2144.481,"body":"to large deflections of the"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2141.121,"endTime":2144.481,"body":"road bearing structure, it might"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2144.486,"endTime":2148.128,"body":"damage some, non road bearing"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2144.486,"endTime":2148.128,"body":"wards, and then the fire can"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2148.128,"endTime":2149.418,"body":"travel to the next component."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2149.418,"endTime":2152.451,"body":"So there are still lots of, very"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2149.418,"endTime":2152.451,"body":"interesting and, uh, challenging"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2152.451,"endTime":2153.371,"body":"questions to explore."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":2153.543,"endTime":2156.923,"body":"For me, one"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":2153.543,"endTime":2156.923,"body":"of the most interesting is the"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":2156.923,"endTime":2160.096,"body":"behavior of, of glazing because"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":2156.923,"endTime":2160.096,"body":"it's something that, we are"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":2160.096,"endTime":2163.158,"body":"very highly reliant on in our."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":2164.341,"endTime":2167.851,"body":"and, and not always, we're"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":2164.341,"endTime":2167.851,"body":"very explicit about it because,"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":2167.941,"endTime":2171.211,"body":"uh, we just assume an opening"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":2167.941,"endTime":2171.211,"body":"factor, which is usually related"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":2171.211,"endTime":2175.621,"body":"to the glazed area, assuming"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":2171.211,"endTime":2175.621,"body":"that it's gonna fall off, which"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":2175.626,"endTime":2177.301,"body":"not necessarily is the case."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":2177.301,"endTime":2180.818,"body":"And, uh, modern glazing is,"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":2177.301,"endTime":2180.818,"body":"is showing more changes."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":2180.833,"endTime":2183.143,"body":"Did you have any solutions"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":2180.833,"endTime":2183.143,"body":"for that in, in SAFIR like"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":2183.143,"endTime":2184.673,"body":"special models or, or something?"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2185.573,"endTime":2187.553,"body":"We don't"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2185.573,"endTime":2187.553,"body":"explicitly model, usually"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2187.553,"endTime":2189.816,"body":"the glazing, we don't,"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2187.553,"endTime":2189.816,"body":"we don't model, non"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2189.816,"endTime":2190.966,"body":"road bearing, members."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2190.966,"endTime":2192.526,"body":"So tradition is a very"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2192.556,"endTime":2193.306,"body":"practical answer."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2193.306,"endTime":2193.426,"body":"Sorry."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":2193.631,"endTime":2194.351,"body":"Sorry."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":2194.351,"endTime":2198.861,"body":"So that goes back to the, your"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":2194.351,"endTime":2198.861,"body":"assumptions and , the thermal"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":2198.861,"endTime":2202.081,"body":"model that is run before , the"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":2198.861,"endTime":2202.081,"body":"thermal structural model."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":2202.261,"endTime":2202.471,"body":"Yeah."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2202.906,"endTime":2203.566,"body":"That's right."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2203.626,"endTime":2207.091,"body":"So, a practical answer is that"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2203.626,"endTime":2207.091,"body":"there, there is, , a guidance"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2207.291,"endTime":2211.071,"body":"in the Luxembourg annex"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2207.291,"endTime":2211.071,"body":"to the Eurocode, which is."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2211.659,"endTime":2214.379,"body":"Just pragmatic, way"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2211.659,"endTime":2214.379,"body":"of approaching this"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2214.379,"endTime":2217.306,"body":"question of, glazing and,"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2214.379,"endTime":2217.306,"body":"changing ventilation."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2217.606,"endTime":2220.996,"body":"So in the Luxem book annex,"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2217.606,"endTime":2220.996,"body":"they give a temperature of the"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2220.996,"endTime":2225.376,"body":"gas at which a certain ratio"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2220.996,"endTime":2225.376,"body":"of the windows get broken,"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2225.586,"endTime":2228.106,"body":"depending on the type, if"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2225.586,"endTime":2228.106,"body":"it's simple, double, triple"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2228.136,"endTime":2229.366,"body":"glazing or reinforced glazing."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2230.521,"endTime":2232.441,"body":"They also prescribe"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2230.521,"endTime":2232.441,"body":"doing a few scenarios."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2232.441,"endTime":2234.841,"body":"So for example, they would"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2232.441,"endTime":2234.841,"body":"say we're in a scenario where"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2234.871,"endTime":2239.011,"body":"90% of your windows are opened"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2234.871,"endTime":2239.011,"body":"from the start and then another"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2239.011,"endTime":2240.391,"body":"scenario where they are closed."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2240.751,"endTime":2241.754,"body":"But I don't know."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2241.754,"endTime":2246.164,"body":"I remember 30% that opens when"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2241.754,"endTime":2246.164,"body":"the gas go to 200 degrees,"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2246.164,"endTime":2249.404,"body":"C and then 90% when it goes"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2246.164,"endTime":2249.404,"body":"to 300 degrees C it just"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2249.404,"endTime":2252.824,"body":"gives you a framework such"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2249.404,"endTime":2252.824,"body":"that you, first of all, you"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2252.824,"endTime":2256.544,"body":"check different scenarios"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2252.824,"endTime":2256.544,"body":"because we know the fire."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2256.617,"endTime":2259.031,"body":"conditions, the demand"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2256.617,"endTime":2259.031,"body":"will be very different"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2259.031,"endTime":2260.081,"body":"depending on those inputs."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2260.321,"endTime":2262.571,"body":"So again, one design"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2260.321,"endTime":2262.571,"body":"fire is not enough."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2262.914,"endTime":2265.068,"body":"and also while you have"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2262.914,"endTime":2265.068,"body":"some guidance, everybody"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2265.068,"endTime":2267.738,"body":"does, you know, the same"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2265.068,"endTime":2267.738,"body":"and, and it's, it is linked."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2267.743,"endTime":2270.854,"body":"It is correlated to, failure"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2267.743,"endTime":2270.854,"body":"temperature of glazing"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2270.854,"endTime":2272.984,"body":"based on thermal gradients"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2270.854,"endTime":2272.984,"body":"on the, on the surface."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2273.404,"endTime":2274.484,"body":"But it's not a detailed"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2274.484,"endTime":2274.964,"body":"modeling"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2274.964,"endTime":2276.764,"body":"of the, of, of the"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2274.964,"endTime":2276.764,"body":"class behavior."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":2276.769,"endTime":2278.366,"body":"for"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":2276.769,"endTime":2278.366,"body":"this robust, answer this."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":2279.176,"endTime":2281.076,"body":"was also not aware of"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":2279.176,"endTime":2281.076,"body":"the Luxemburg annext."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":2281.096,"endTime":2285.176,"body":"I, I need to check that out"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":2281.096,"endTime":2285.176,"body":"because it, it is something that"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":2285.206,"endTime":2286.853,"body":"I'm recently very interested at."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":2287.213,"endTime":2290.033,"body":"I'm also, uh, about to organize"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":2287.213,"endTime":2290.033,"body":"the nice guest on, on the"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":2290.033,"endTime":2291.863,"body":"glazing in, in the podcaster."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":2291.863,"endTime":2293.938,"body":"There's also an"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":2291.863,"endTime":2293.938,"body":"episode to look for."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":2294.424,"endTime":2297.214,"body":"now I wanted to ask you,"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":2294.424,"endTime":2297.214,"body":"like, where is it going?"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":2297.594,"endTime":2299.964,"body":"Is there any particular"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":2297.594,"endTime":2299.964,"body":"direction that,"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":2299.999,"endTime":2301.918,"body":"structural FSC modeling is"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2302.083,"endTime":2302.203,"body":"How you"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":2302.458,"endTime":2304.078,"body":"or"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":2302.458,"endTime":2304.078,"body":"SAFIR is, is heading?"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":2304.468,"endTime":2306.058,"body":"Like how, how do you guys"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2306.193,"endTime":2306.643,"body":"guys more"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":2306.783,"endTime":2307.768,"body":"the future?"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":2308.038,"endTime":2311.448,"body":"Will it be like more"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":2308.038,"endTime":2311.448,"body":"simulations, more answers"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":2311.818,"endTime":2317.208,"body":"more probabilistic approach,"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":2311.818,"endTime":2317.208,"body":"or maybe rather, into root of"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":2317.268,"endTime":2319.758,"body":"optimization and trying to find."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":2320.688,"endTime":2324.378,"body":"The cheapest, non collapsible"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":2320.688,"endTime":2324.378,"body":"structure you can build"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2324.543,"endTime":2324.903,"body":"you can.,"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":2325.438,"endTime":2326.158,"body":"your boundaries."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":2326.368,"endTime":2329.458,"body":"I wonder what, what's the"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":2326.368,"endTime":2329.458,"body":"hot topic now in the world"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":2329.458,"endTime":2330.928,"body":"of structural fire engineers."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2331.391,"endTime":2332.978,"body":"that's"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2331.391,"endTime":2332.978,"body":"great question."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2332.978,"endTime":2335.531,"body":"Of course, we are working"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2332.978,"endTime":2335.531,"body":"really on a range of"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2335.621,"endTime":2338.141,"body":"problems and always trying"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2335.621,"endTime":2338.141,"body":"to move that forward."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2338.381,"endTime":2342.311,"body":"I think high level I'm, I'm"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2338.381,"endTime":2342.311,"body":"really convinced that numerical"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2342.311,"endTime":2346.961,"body":"modeling is, is a key enabler"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2342.311,"endTime":2346.961,"body":"of, you know, everything we do"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2346.961,"endTime":2349.964,"body":"in, in, in civil engineering"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2346.961,"endTime":2349.964,"body":"to engineering is, we want."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2350.077,"endTime":2351.641,"body":"Provide two things."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2351.641,"endTime":2354.191,"body":"We want to provide the"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2351.641,"endTime":2354.191,"body":"tools, really the ecosystem"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2354.191,"endTime":2355.931,"body":"that people can go."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2355.931,"endTime":2358.841,"body":"And it's, it's robust, it's"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2355.931,"endTime":2358.841,"body":"validated it's state of the art"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2358.841,"endTime":2362.351,"body":"and you can run those software"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2358.841,"endTime":2362.351,"body":"to predict the response."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2362.501,"endTime":2364.536,"body":"And we also work , on"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2362.501,"endTime":2364.536,"body":"the framework, which"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2364.536,"endTime":2365.586,"body":"is to understand how."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2366.201,"endTime":2369.088,"body":"Computational modeling, can"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2366.201,"endTime":2369.088,"body":"support and is linked to"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2369.088,"endTime":2372.118,"body":"performance based design to"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2369.088,"endTime":2372.118,"body":"probabilistic risk assessment"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2372.118,"endTime":2374.528,"body":"and these type of, very"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2372.118,"endTime":2374.528,"body":"important approaches that"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2374.533,"endTime":2376.864,"body":"are used in not only fire"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2374.533,"endTime":2376.864,"body":"safety engineering, but in"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2376.864,"endTime":2378.604,"body":"general in structural design."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2378.934,"endTime":2379.234,"body":"So."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2379.639,"endTime":2383.449,"body":"In the future, what, what we"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2379.639,"endTime":2383.449,"body":"are really focusing on now, I"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2383.449,"endTime":2386.749,"body":"would say maybe, , three things"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2383.449,"endTime":2386.749,"body":"that I, I want to highlight."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2387.229,"endTime":2390.679,"body":"The first one is that there"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2387.229,"endTime":2390.679,"body":"are always new, , materials"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2390.684,"endTime":2393.889,"body":"and innovations that come on"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2390.684,"endTime":2393.889,"body":"the market that are considered"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2393.889,"endTime":2397.339,"body":"and understanding the fire"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2393.889,"endTime":2397.339,"body":"safety implications of these"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2397.399,"endTime":2399.206,"body":"are really, critical and."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2400.396,"endTime":2404.023,"body":"Because if we don't, it can,"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2400.396,"endTime":2404.023,"body":"hinder the implementation"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2404.023,"endTime":2405.239,"body":"of these in the market."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2405.239,"endTime":2407.519,"body":"So, I mean, we have, you"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2405.239,"endTime":2407.519,"body":"know, amazing people doing"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2407.519,"endTime":2410.399,"body":"developments to, bring these"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2407.519,"endTime":2410.399,"body":"new materials to, uh, maybe"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2410.579,"endTime":2413.089,"body":"be more, environmentally"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2410.579,"endTime":2413.089,"body":"friendly, but we, we need to"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2413.089,"endTime":2414.439,"body":"be able to, to apply them."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2414.439,"endTime":2416.343,"body":"So we need to understand,"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2414.439,"endTime":2416.343,"body":"What the implication"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2416.343,"endTime":2417.363,"body":"is for fire safety."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2417.693,"endTime":2420.683,"body":"And so that, implies being"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2417.693,"endTime":2420.683,"body":"able to model the thermal"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2420.683,"endTime":2423.113,"body":"mechanical properties, the"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2420.683,"endTime":2423.113,"body":"behavior of those materials."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2423.533,"endTime":2426.773,"body":"In some cases, when it's,"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2423.533,"endTime":2426.773,"body":"combustible material, it is, I"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2426.773,"endTime":2428.363,"body":"mean, other challenges as well."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2428.573,"endTime":2432.263,"body":"And then how do we model the,"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2428.573,"endTime":2432.263,"body":"these in structural system and,"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2432.287,"endTime":2433.763,"body":"building simulations, right?"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2433.763,"endTime":2436.373,"body":"So that's, that's really"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2433.763,"endTime":2436.373,"body":"the fir the first point."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2436.777,"endTime":2437.809,"body":"the second one is."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2438.314,"endTime":2440.984,"body":"As I was just hitting at,"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2438.314,"endTime":2440.984,"body":"working on the frameworks."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2441.254,"endTime":2444.284,"body":"So I'm very interested in"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2441.254,"endTime":2444.284,"body":"performance based fire design,"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2445.034,"endTime":2449.094,"body":"which means how do we go,"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2445.034,"endTime":2449.094,"body":"about this, this process of"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2449.274,"endTime":2451.164,"body":"defining performance objectives."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2451.164,"endTime":2452.724,"body":"So already lots of questions."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2452.724,"endTime":2453.951,"body":"What is, appropriate?"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2454.366,"endTime":2457.453,"body":"Performance level, what"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2454.366,"endTime":2457.453,"body":"kind of, targets reliability"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2457.693,"endTime":2458.983,"body":"should we strive for?"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2458.983,"endTime":2461.153,"body":"What, are the implications"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2458.983,"endTime":2461.153,"body":"of looking at resilience"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2461.158,"endTime":2463.793,"body":"of the built environment"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2461.158,"endTime":2463.793,"body":"against fire, multi hazard?"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2463.793,"endTime":2466.553,"body":"So lots of questions they"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2463.793,"endTime":2466.553,"body":"already, then once we have the"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2466.553,"endTime":2469.223,"body":"performance objective, we have"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2466.553,"endTime":2469.223,"body":"to define the design fires."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2469.228,"endTime":2470.303,"body":"And we've talked about that."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2470.308,"endTime":2473.663,"body":"There are also lots of"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2470.308,"endTime":2473.663,"body":"scenarios and how, uh, do"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2473.663,"endTime":2475.943,"body":"we know which one to select"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2473.663,"endTime":2475.943,"body":"and then how do we make."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2476.478,"endTime":2479.481,"body":"Easy to, develop these"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2476.478,"endTime":2479.481,"body":"and interface them with"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2479.481,"endTime":2480.141,"body":"the SIM with the Al"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2480.441,"endTime":2481.101,"body":"simulation."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":2481.311,"endTime":2482.861,"body":"I love"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":2481.311,"endTime":2482.861,"body":"how the challenge is like"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":2482.861,"endTime":2486.491,"body":"at the philosophical level,"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":2482.861,"endTime":2486.491,"body":"not necessarily related to"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":2486.491,"endTime":2490.268,"body":"like, transferring loads or,"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":2486.491,"endTime":2490.268,"body":"or modeling, uh, non-linear"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":2490.268,"endTime":2491.798,"body":"thermal behavior materials."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":2491.798,"endTime":2495.008,"body":"No, we really have to sort out"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":2491.798,"endTime":2495.008,"body":"the scenarios and objectives."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":2495.473,"endTime":2496.793,"body":"This is the number"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2497.108,"endTime":2497.198,"body":"Well,"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":2497.488,"endTime":2498.503,"body":"like the need."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":2498.503,"endTime":2500.303,"body":"I, I really love how you"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":2498.503,"endTime":2500.303,"body":"positioned it because"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":2500.303,"endTime":2502.969,"body":"it echos so well with so"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":2500.303,"endTime":2502.969,"body":"much that has been said"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":2502.969,"endTime":2504.019,"body":"in the, in the podcast."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":2504.019,"endTime":2506.089,"body":"I absolutely love it, but"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":2504.019,"endTime":2506.089,"body":"sorry for interrupting."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":2506.089,"endTime":2506.899,"body":"You continue this."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2507.154,"endTime":2508.504,"body":"No,"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2507.154,"endTime":2508.504,"body":"no, thanks APRI."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2508.504,"endTime":2509.674,"body":"But yeah, I think it's key."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2509.854,"endTime":2510.304,"body":"Absolutely."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2510.304,"endTime":2512.344,"body":"It's both the tools"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2510.304,"endTime":2512.344,"body":"and the framework."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2512.349,"endTime":2513.424,"body":"How do we use the tool?"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2513.424,"endTime":2516.304,"body":"We want to think very hard about"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2513.424,"endTime":2516.304,"body":"that as well because providing"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2516.309,"endTime":2517.324,"body":"the tools is not enough."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2517.714,"endTime":2518.974,"body":"We want it to be robust."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2518.974,"endTime":2522.024,"body":"We want it to, make sense in"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2518.974,"endTime":2522.024,"body":"terms of the risk assessment"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2522.024,"endTime":2523.284,"body":"and the performance and so on."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2523.284,"endTime":2526.704,"body":"So working on the design fire,"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2523.284,"endTime":2526.704,"body":"still on, in my performance"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2526.704,"endTime":2527.784,"body":"base for design, right."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2527.784,"endTime":2529.704,"body":"And then on the"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2527.784,"endTime":2529.704,"body":"structural modeling."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":2530.004,"endTime":2530.224,"body":"Mm."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2530.584,"endTime":2531.634,"body":"There"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2530.584,"endTime":2531.634,"body":"is a lot we can do."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2531.634,"endTime":2534.104,"body":"We've worked a lot, this"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2531.634,"endTime":2534.104,"body":"last decade and before,"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2534.104,"endTime":2536.444,"body":"but there are, there, there"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2534.104,"endTime":2536.444,"body":"are still things we cannot"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2536.444,"endTime":2538.741,"body":"do, modeling a CLT floor."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2538.784,"endTime":2541.038,"body":"we don't really have the"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2538.784,"endTime":2541.038,"body":"element to do that, right now."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2541.038,"endTime":2544.038,"body":"So, but it's, it's used people"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2541.038,"endTime":2544.038,"body":"build buildings with that."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2544.038,"endTime":2547.213,"body":"So if we want to model this"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2544.038,"endTime":2547.213,"body":"structural system, That will"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2547.213,"endTime":2548.443,"body":"be something more practical."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2548.443,"endTime":2551.179,"body":"We, we need a PhD to"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2548.443,"endTime":2551.179,"body":"look at a PhD student."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2551.179,"endTime":2555.079,"body":"I made to look for three, four"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2551.179,"endTime":2555.079,"body":"years at how do we develop the"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2555.079,"endTime":2558.379,"body":"type of, shell elements and the"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2555.079,"endTime":2558.379,"body":"material model and, and C on"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2558.379,"endTime":2559.819,"body":"for this or Tropic behavior."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2559.824,"endTime":2561.889,"body":"So they are also this kind"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2559.824,"endTime":2561.889,"body":"of questions of course,"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2561.889,"endTime":2562.609,"body":"that we are working on."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2563.269,"endTime":2563.979,"body":"And so first was."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2564.084,"endTime":2566.214,"body":"You know, new materials,"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2564.084,"endTime":2566.214,"body":"enabling that S on"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2566.214,"endTime":2568.284,"body":"the framework, the per"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2566.214,"endTime":2568.284,"body":"performance based design,"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2568.284,"endTime":2569.634,"body":"also probabilistic."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2570.024,"endTime":2572.394,"body":"I've not talked that much"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2570.024,"endTime":2572.394,"body":"about it, but I've worked a"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2572.399,"endTime":2576.358,"body":"lot with some incredibly smart"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2572.399,"endTime":2576.358,"body":"colleagues, just Ruben van"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2576.358,"endTime":2580.658,"body":"Coile and Danny Hopkin, whom"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2576.358,"endTime":2580.658,"body":"had here Negar Elhami-Khorasni"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2581.348,"endTime":2584.088,"body":"a good friend and amazing"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2581.348,"endTime":2584.088,"body":"researcher from university"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2584.088,"endTime":2586.278,"body":"of Buffalo and others."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2586.278,"endTime":2588.718,"body":"And together we, we teamed"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2586.278,"endTime":2588.718,"body":"up because , it's a very."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2588.988,"endTime":2591.854,"body":"Big challenge to move,"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2588.988,"endTime":2591.854,"body":"structural fire engineering,"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2591.918,"endTime":2595.098,"body":"into the probability risk"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2591.918,"endTime":2595.098,"body":"assessment framework and make"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2595.098,"endTime":2598.438,"body":"it, very, consistent in terms"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2595.098,"endTime":2598.438,"body":"of how we think about risk,"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2598.738,"endTime":2601.108,"body":"what type of reliability"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2598.738,"endTime":2601.108,"body":"we design for and on."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2601.468,"endTime":2604.348,"body":"And because it requires"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2601.468,"endTime":2604.348,"body":"exploring a range of"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2604.348,"endTime":2607.558,"body":"scenarios, also computational"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2604.348,"endTime":2607.558,"body":"modeling is the natural"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2607.588,"endTime":2608.998,"body":"tools to, to go around it."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2608.998,"endTime":2609.178,"body":"Right."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2609.808,"endTime":2612.828,"body":"And so the first thing I"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2609.808,"endTime":2612.828,"body":"would say, , when you ask"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2612.828,"endTime":2614.508,"body":"me about what's the future."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2615.228,"endTime":2617.928,"body":"It's really more forward looking"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2615.228,"endTime":2617.928,"body":"now, maybe I'm talking about"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2618.048,"endTime":2623.748,"body":"20, 30 years down the road,"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2618.048,"endTime":2623.748,"body":"but I'm, I think we have this"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2624.048,"endTime":2628.398,"body":"capability for modeling the"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2624.048,"endTime":2628.398,"body":"non-linear response thermals"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2628.398,"endTime":2631.878,"body":"to try in multiphysics of"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2628.398,"endTime":2631.878,"body":"buildings against fire."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2631.883,"endTime":2635.548,"body":"And that is great, but right"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2631.883,"endTime":2635.548,"body":"now it still requires a lot of"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2635.553,"endTime":2640.038,"body":"expertise and it's only done for"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2635.553,"endTime":2640.038,"body":"some kind of iconic structures"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2640.038,"endTime":2642.078,"body":"when you have the time and"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2640.038,"endTime":2642.078,"body":"money and, and expertise."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2643.298,"endTime":2647.408,"body":"Many people are working on"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2643.298,"endTime":2647.408,"body":"other aspects of, uh, the"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2647.408,"endTime":2650.588,"body":"built environment with digital"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2647.408,"endTime":2650.588,"body":"tools, with numerical tools."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2650.588,"endTime":2654.818,"body":"So we have linear, real, uh,"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2650.588,"endTime":2654.818,"body":"software for the response, but"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2655.148,"endTime":2658.592,"body":"more broadly we have BIM and"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2655.148,"endTime":2658.592,"body":"we have, the ability to track,"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2658.611,"endTime":2662.686,"body":"the construction process and"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2658.611,"endTime":2662.686,"body":"moving forward, we need to do"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2662.686,"endTime":2666.766,"body":"more about circular economy"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2662.686,"endTime":2666.766,"body":"and sustainability reusability."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2666.766,"endTime":2667.846,"body":"So probably there will be."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2668.356,"endTime":2672.016,"body":"Digital ecosystems to track"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2668.356,"endTime":2672.016,"body":"really all the components"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2672.016,"endTime":2674.536,"body":"of these buildings and"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2672.016,"endTime":2674.536,"body":"how they go together."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2674.536,"endTime":2675.016,"body":"And so on."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2675.496,"endTime":2678.436,"body":"I think that in the future,"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2675.496,"endTime":2678.436,"body":"we should be able to."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2679.051,"endTime":2683.281,"body":"Again, interface and couple and"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2679.051,"endTime":2683.281,"body":"put together these different"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2683.281,"endTime":2685.121,"body":"types of, numerical models."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2685.181,"endTime":2690.011,"body":"And basically I think we will"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2685.181,"endTime":2690.011,"body":"move toward having digital"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2690.041,"endTime":2693.947,"body":"twins for all, complex objects,"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2690.041,"endTime":2693.947,"body":"Aircrafts buildings and so on."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2693.947,"endTime":2696.591,"body":"And maybe we'll have, in the"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2693.947,"endTime":2696.591,"body":"metaverse or, or whatever."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2696.591,"endTime":2698.631,"body":"We have the same"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2696.591,"endTime":2698.631,"body":"cities that we have."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2698.941,"endTime":2699.361,"body":"Here."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2699.391,"endTime":2703.244,"body":"but with, this digital twin"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2699.391,"endTime":2703.244,"body":"object that allows us to"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2703.244,"endTime":2706.064,"body":"track all the resources,"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2703.244,"endTime":2706.064,"body":"components and so on, but"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2706.064,"endTime":2710.024,"body":"also to inigate the response"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2706.064,"endTime":2710.024,"body":"against extreme hazards,"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2710.024,"endTime":2711.734,"body":"fire, earthquakes, and so on."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2712.124,"endTime":2714.524,"body":"And as the condition are"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2712.124,"endTime":2714.524,"body":"changing, climate is changing."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2714.524,"endTime":2716.594,"body":"We can change the stress"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2714.524,"endTime":2716.594,"body":"source and we can change"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2716.594,"endTime":2717.584,"body":"the demand and so on."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2718.064,"endTime":2718.784,"body":"But I."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2719.644,"endTime":2723.544,"body":"Structural fire modeling"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2719.644,"endTime":2723.544,"body":"cannot stay apart from all"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2723.544,"endTime":2725.014,"body":"those other digital efforts."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2725.014,"endTime":2727.797,"body":"And basically we should have"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2725.014,"endTime":2727.797,"body":"a, a digital ecosystem where"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2727.857,"endTime":2730.857,"body":"we put everything together"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2727.857,"endTime":2730.857,"body":"for modeling buildings and"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2730.857,"endTime":2733.227,"body":"ensuring they are sustainable"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2730.857,"endTime":2733.227,"body":"and they are resilient."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":2733.478,"endTime":2735.024,"body":"Based"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":2733.478,"endTime":2735.024,"body":"on my experience with"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":2735.054,"endTime":2738.264,"body":"how BIM is incorporated"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":2735.054,"endTime":2738.264,"body":"actually the, the structural"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":2738.264,"endTime":2741.384,"body":"engineering part makes a lot"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":2738.264,"endTime":2741.384,"body":"of sense to, to couple that."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":2741.384,"endTime":2744.081,"body":"So maybe it's not even,"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":2741.384,"endTime":2744.081,"body":"maybe it's not even decades."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":2744.081,"endTime":2747.441,"body":"Maybe it's just years ahead"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":2744.081,"endTime":2747.441,"body":"of us to, to have a, at least"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":2747.471,"endTime":2748.801,"body":"this part coupled because."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":2749.766,"endTime":2753.696,"body":"Coupling with, with CD modeling"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":2749.766,"endTime":2753.696,"body":"is probably a little harder"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":2753.696,"endTime":2755.376,"body":"because of other challenges."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":2755.802,"endTime":2760.282,"body":"the main being, you build"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":2755.802,"endTime":2760.282,"body":"model for a certain purpose"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":2761.349,"endTime":2765.249,"body":"architect drawing the building"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":2761.349,"endTime":2765.249,"body":"or engineer drawing, their"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":2765.579,"endTime":2768.369,"body":"structural model has a different"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":2765.579,"endTime":2768.369,"body":"purpose than CFD engineer."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":2768.429,"endTime":2770.882,"body":"It's just that simple"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":2768.429,"endTime":2770.882,"body":"and that problematic."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2771.251,"endTime":2771.851,"body":"Absolutely."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2771.851,"endTime":2776.601,"body":"It still requires a lot of human"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2771.851,"endTime":2776.601,"body":"thinking to know how to model"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2776.871,"endTime":2780.111,"body":"a structure for the purpose"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2776.871,"endTime":2780.111,"body":"of structural for engineering,"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2780.116,"endTime":2782.451,"body":"because you have to think about"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2780.116,"endTime":2782.451,"body":"the heat transfer problem,"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2782.811,"endTime":2784.071,"body":"then the structural response."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2784.076,"endTime":2786.861,"body":"So you, discretized your"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2784.076,"endTime":2786.861,"body":"structuring in a certain"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2786.866,"endTime":2790.821,"body":"way, and it's not just lines"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2786.866,"endTime":2790.821,"body":"on, on a sheet of paper that"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2790.871,"endTime":2793.306,"body":"you can extra, you have to"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2790.871,"endTime":2793.306,"body":"have a kind of information"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2793.306,"endTime":2796.846,"body":"and data that today we"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2793.306,"endTime":2796.846,"body":"don't have in, in other."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2797.436,"endTime":2801.039,"body":"Pieces of this digital workflow,"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2797.436,"endTime":2801.039,"body":"but as I look, you know,"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2801.039,"endTime":2804.369,"body":"back decades and then I look"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2801.039,"endTime":2804.369,"body":"forward several decades, I'm"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2804.369,"endTime":2807.249,"body":"sure we'll find solutions for"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2804.369,"endTime":2807.249,"body":"this kind of challenges, but"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2807.609,"endTime":2810.879,"body":"indeed it's, it's not trivial"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2807.609,"endTime":2810.879,"body":"because as you say you right"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2810.879,"endTime":2814.449,"body":"now, each of these tools"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2810.879,"endTime":2814.449,"body":"have very specific purpose."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2814.809,"endTime":2818.169,"body":"And so you have to have an"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2814.809,"endTime":2818.169,"body":"engineer who think about what's"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2818.169,"endTime":2819.819,"body":"the right modeling approach."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2820.359,"endTime":2821.949,"body":"To target this purpose."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2821.949,"endTime":2825.309,"body":"And so to replace or to, to"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2821.949,"endTime":2825.309,"body":"harmonize that, which requires"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2825.309,"endTime":2826.662,"body":"some, lots of research."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":2826.777,"endTime":2828.697,"body":"And how"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":2826.777,"endTime":2828.697,"body":"you feel about emergence of"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":2828.697,"endTime":2831.777,"body":"AI as a support tool in the"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":2828.697,"endTime":2831.777,"body":"structural fire engineering."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2831.826,"endTime":2832.996,"body":"I'm"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2831.826,"endTime":2832.996,"body":"glad you bring that up."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2833.001,"endTime":2834.976,"body":"That that could definitely help."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2834.981,"endTime":2838.031,"body":"I think, we are still, Playing"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2834.981,"endTime":2838.031,"body":"with the concept and trying to"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2838.031,"endTime":2840.401,"body":"see where opportunities lie."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2840.401,"endTime":2845.551,"body":"But if we start, being"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2840.401,"endTime":2845.551,"body":"systematic about the data and"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2845.551,"endTime":2850.444,"body":"collecting and classifying the"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2845.551,"endTime":2850.444,"body":"data,  I don't see why AI could"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2850.444,"endTime":2853.834,"body":"not help in this field the way"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2850.444,"endTime":2853.834,"body":"it has helped in, in others."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2853.834,"endTime":2854.074,"body":"Right."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2854.074,"endTime":2854.614,"body":"So, uh,"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2855.226,"endTime":2858.262,"body":"I think we are still"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2855.226,"endTime":2858.262,"body":"relatively in, the early"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2858.262,"endTime":2861.652,"body":"stage of the, the field of"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2858.262,"endTime":2861.652,"body":"structural fire engineering."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2862.012,"endTime":2864.649,"body":"And we are still, looking at"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2862.012,"endTime":2864.649,"body":"these philosophical questions"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2864.649,"endTime":2865.759,"body":"that you were mentioning, right."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2865.759,"endTime":2868.159,"body":"That at the high level, we"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2865.759,"endTime":2868.159,"body":"still don't have really the"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2868.164,"endTime":2871.444,"body":"answers about oh, We do have"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2868.164,"endTime":2871.444,"body":"the answers, but we have to"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2871.444,"endTime":2874.687,"body":"think, hard about the scenarios"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2871.444,"endTime":2874.687,"body":"and the performance objectives."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2874.687,"endTime":2878.101,"body":"In all case, it's not really"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2874.687,"endTime":2878.101,"body":"codified yet, but as this"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2878.101,"endTime":2881.041,"body":"become embraced more and"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2878.101,"endTime":2881.041,"body":"more, and as we move to a more"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2881.041,"endTime":2884.707,"body":"systematic there, I think that,"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2881.041,"endTime":2884.707,"body":"AI could also, uh, come in"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2884.707,"endTime":2885.157,"body":"and help."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":2885.403,"endTime":2886.587,"body":"I"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":2885.403,"endTime":2886.587,"body":"hate doing this podcast."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":2886.592,"endTime":2889.227,"body":"Like, you know, I ask"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":2886.592,"endTime":2889.227,"body":"people to talk about their"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":2889.227,"endTime":2892.077,"body":"fancy tools and the most"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":2889.227,"endTime":2892.077,"body":"impressive stuff they've"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":2892.077,"endTime":2893.577,"body":"done and it always ends up."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":2893.577,"endTime":2895.167,"body":"Like we don't understand"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":2893.577,"endTime":2895.167,"body":"our objectives."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":2895.167,"endTime":2896.397,"body":"Well, fire."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":2896.597,"endTime":2897.557,"body":"Safety's horrible."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":2897.977,"endTime":2900.177,"body":"We need to start"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":2897.977,"endTime":2900.177,"body":"our objectives guys."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":2900.177,"endTime":2900.657,"body":"Come on."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":2900.707,"endTime":2901.457,"body":", I want more."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":2901.717,"endTime":2904.647,"body":"Exciting stuff in the"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":2901.717,"endTime":2904.647,"body":"podcast just bragging"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":2904.647,"endTime":2905.787,"body":"about how we don't."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":2905.817,"endTime":2908.727,"body":"But yeah, that is"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":2905.817,"endTime":2908.727,"body":"the sad reality.."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":2908.787,"endTime":2913.587,"body":"Like that is truth that"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":2908.787,"endTime":2913.587,"body":"we spend so much money"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":2913.592,"endTime":2918.477,"body":"and effort on many, many"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":2913.592,"endTime":2918.477,"body":"fancy things and minuscule"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":2918.477,"endTime":2920.907,"body":"improvements in secondary"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2921.167,"endTime":2921.257,"body":"Where."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":2922.407,"endTime":2923.157,"body":"where."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":2923.942,"endTime":2927.932,"body":"We don't have a fundamental"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":2923.942,"endTime":2927.932,"body":"question answered."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":2927.932,"endTime":2931.952,"body":"Like, do we want our structures"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":2927.932,"endTime":2931.952,"body":"to resist burnout or not?"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":2931.957,"endTime":2933.752,"body":"And, and how to"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":2931.957,"endTime":2933.752,"body":"choose if we want it."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":2934.079,"endTime":2937.222,"body":"we have not answered the"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":2934.079,"endTime":2937.222,"body":"question of what design fire"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":2937.222,"endTime":2941.609,"body":"and that what probability is,"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":2937.222,"endTime":2941.609,"body":"is, for this building and how it"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":2941.609,"endTime":2942.929,"body":"would be for another building."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":2943.309,"endTime":2945.186,"body":"It's Overwhelming,"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":2943.309,"endTime":2945.186,"body":"but I'm happy."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":2945.186,"endTime":2946.656,"body":"We have lots of work."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":2946.746,"endTime":2948.876,"body":"Uh, future of fire"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":2946.746,"endTime":2948.876,"body":"engineers is bright."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2949.636,"endTime":2951.946,"body":"Well, these"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2949.636,"endTime":2951.946,"body":"are complex questions, but"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2951.976,"endTime":2954.886,"body":"to some extent, because there"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2951.976,"endTime":2954.886,"body":"is such a multiplicity of,"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2955.246,"endTime":2958.396,"body":"of buildings and projects"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2955.246,"endTime":2958.396,"body":"and, uh, jurisdictions"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2958.476,"endTime":2959.326,"body":"and, and everything."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2959.326,"endTime":2959.506,"body":"Right."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2959.506,"endTime":2963.646,"body":"I think what is key is to really"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2959.506,"endTime":2963.646,"body":"move forward in providing the"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2963.651,"endTime":2965.776,"body":"tools and the framework to."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2966.086,"endTime":2968.996,"body":"Post approach these questions"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2966.086,"endTime":2968.996,"body":"in a systematic way."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2969.026,"endTime":2971.846,"body":"Once we make the decision,"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2969.026,"endTime":2971.846,"body":"we want to go that way such"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2971.846,"endTime":2974.816,"body":"as performance based, and"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2971.846,"endTime":2974.816,"body":"then the tools to enable the"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2974.816,"endTime":2977.919,"body":"assessments to be rigorous"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2974.816,"endTime":2977.919,"body":"and rooted in the physics."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2977.919,"endTime":2979.899,"body":"And that's really"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2977.919,"endTime":2979.899,"body":"what computational"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2979.899,"endTime":2980.919,"body":"modeling does that."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2980.924,"endTime":2983.529,"body":"It gives you an understanding"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2980.924,"endTime":2983.529,"body":"of the physics of the problem in"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2983.529,"endTime":2986.439,"body":"terms of how the fire is going"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2983.529,"endTime":2986.439,"body":"to develop and then how the"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2986.439,"endTime":2989.369,"body":"structure is going , to respond,"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2986.439,"endTime":2989.369,"body":"right, as opposed to taking"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2989.509,"endTime":2990.899,"body":"a simplified model, which is."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2991.549,"endTime":2994.699,"body":"Useful for benchmarking, but"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2991.549,"endTime":2994.699,"body":"which does not give you these"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2994.699,"endTime":2997.879,"body":"insights and the sensitivity"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2994.699,"endTime":2997.879,"body":"and so on, but it's true"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2997.879,"endTime":2999.889,"body":"that then you move to the"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2997.879,"endTime":2999.889,"body":"higher level and it becomes"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":2999.889,"endTime":3001.509,"body":"a human decision problem."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":3001.509,"endTime":3004.209,"body":"And so we cannot formalize"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":3001.509,"endTime":3004.209,"body":"it the same way as"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":3004.209,"endTime":3005.199,"body":"engineers, because."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":3005.386,"endTime":3007.642,"body":"You need to speak with"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":3005.386,"endTime":3007.642,"body":"the stakeholders and it'll"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":3007.642,"endTime":3010.222,"body":"depend on the economics and"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":3007.642,"endTime":3010.222,"body":"on the social and so on."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":3010.732,"endTime":3014.452,"body":"So, uh, it's, it's true that"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":3010.732,"endTime":3014.452,"body":"it can seem frustrating, but"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":3014.452,"endTime":3017.782,"body":"to some extent, I think it's,"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":3014.452,"endTime":3017.782,"body":"once you move the needle from"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":3017.782,"endTime":3021.772,"body":"the, the engineering problem to,"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":3017.782,"endTime":3021.772,"body":"to all of the technical social"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":3021.772,"endTime":3023.499,"body":"problems that, is just different"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":3023.499,"endTime":3024.649,"body":"different considerations."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":3024.714,"endTime":3026.934,"body":"I"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":3024.714,"endTime":3026.934,"body":"wonder if in 50 years we'll"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":3026.934,"endTime":3031.127,"body":"still be thinking Mindset"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":3026.934,"endTime":3031.127,"body":"of fire resistance and,"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":3031.257,"endTime":3032.627,"body":"and how, how we'll develop."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":3032.667,"endTime":3035.397,"body":"I'm happy to view as"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":3032.667,"endTime":3035.397,"body":"this develops Thomas."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":3035.42,"endTime":3037.0,"body":"that was a great talk to you."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":3037.0,"endTime":3041.125,"body":"I'm very thankful for taking me"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":3037.0,"endTime":3041.125,"body":"into the world , of structural"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":3041.125,"endTime":3044.935,"body":"fire engineering and I'm,"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":3041.125,"endTime":3044.935,"body":"I'm sure it was interesting,"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":3045.235,"endTime":3047.605,"body":"probably more interesting to"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":3045.235,"endTime":3047.605,"body":"non-structural fire engineers,"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":3048.025,"endTime":3051.265,"body":"because we finally got an"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":3048.025,"endTime":3051.265,"body":"insight to how you guys do your."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":3052.061,"endTime":3053.459,"body":"so, yeah, huge."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":3053.459,"endTime":3053.833,"body":"Thanks."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":3053.855,"endTime":3057.525,"body":"and, I hope to see you"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":3053.855,"endTime":3057.525,"body":"here again with another"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":3057.555,"endTime":3059.115,"body":"interesting subject"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":3059.2,"endTime":3059.86,"body":"Well, thank you."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":3059.86,"endTime":3061.54,"body":"It was just really"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":3059.86,"endTime":3061.54,"body":"my, my pleasure."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":3061.54,"endTime":3064.09,"body":"I had lots of fun discussing"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":3061.54,"endTime":3064.09,"body":"and I hope to see you soon."},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":3064.12,"endTime":3064.66,"body":"They may be at the"},{"speaker":"Thomas Gernay","startTime":3064.66,"endTime":3065.17,"body":"summer school."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":3065.895,"endTime":3066.855,"body":"that I would love that."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":3066.855,"endTime":3067.875,"body":"Thank you very much."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":3068.836,"endTime":3071.716,"body":"And that's end of this episode,"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":3068.836,"endTime":3071.716,"body":"I thought about making a"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":3071.716,"endTime":3072.946,"body":"fancy out ultra as usual."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":3072.946,"endTime":3076.216,"body":"But in fact, the end of"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":3072.946,"endTime":3076.216,"body":"this discussion has pretty"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":3076.221,"endTime":3077.266,"body":"much covered it all."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":3077.686,"endTime":3081.306,"body":"We're talking about"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":3077.686,"endTime":3081.306,"body":"fancy tools, , AI, bam"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":3081.306,"endTime":3082.866,"body":"integration, and other stuff."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":3082.866,"endTime":3085.986,"body":"While we don't have objectives"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":3082.866,"endTime":3085.986,"body":"and design scenarios fixed, and"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":3085.986,"endTime":3090.359,"body":"that's  kind of devastating,"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":3085.986,"endTime":3090.359,"body":"really, I feel really sad about"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":3090.359,"endTime":3094.049,"body":"the fact that we still do not"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":3090.359,"endTime":3094.049,"body":"have this seemingly simple,"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":3094.049,"endTime":3097.169,"body":"but as Thomas said, quite"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":3094.049,"endTime":3097.169,"body":"complex stuff figured out."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":3097.169,"endTime":3100.259,"body":"And if you're a researcher"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":3097.169,"endTime":3100.259,"body":"in the field and you want"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":3100.264,"endTime":3104.399,"body":"to find a place where you"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":3100.264,"endTime":3104.399,"body":"can make great impact, well,"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":3104.909,"endTime":3109.066,"body":"there it is  this is a much"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":3104.909,"endTime":3109.066,"body":"needed place for research."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":3109.456,"endTime":3111.886,"body":"And while we are developing"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":3109.456,"endTime":3111.886,"body":"that structural fire"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":3111.886,"endTime":3114.106,"body":"engineering is there to help"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":3111.886,"endTime":3114.106,"body":"us understand the behavior"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":3114.111,"endTime":3115.156,"body":"of the whole structures."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":3115.606,"endTime":3118.366,"body":"We hope we've pretty"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":3115.606,"endTime":3118.366,"body":"well highlighted."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":3118.366,"endTime":3120.526,"body":"The difference between the"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":3118.366,"endTime":3120.526,"body":"performance of a member"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":3120.796,"endTime":3123.076,"body":"performance of a single"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":3120.796,"endTime":3123.076,"body":"element in your building and"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":3123.076,"endTime":3126.393,"body":"the performance of the whole"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":3123.076,"endTime":3126.393,"body":"building itself at The example"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":3126.393,"endTime":3129.423,"body":"of Cardington and a membrane"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":3126.393,"endTime":3129.423,"body":"action in the slabs , is"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":3129.423,"endTime":3130.833,"body":"a perfect example of that."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":3131.183,"endTime":3132.543,"body":"How, how different it is."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":3132.543,"endTime":3135.993,"body":"Like if we just focus on"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":3132.543,"endTime":3135.993,"body":"performance of single members,"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":3135.993,"endTime":3138.663,"body":"as we usually do, how do you"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":3135.993,"endTime":3138.663,"body":"understand the performance"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":3138.663,"endTime":3139.473,"body":"of the whole structure?"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":3139.503,"endTime":3140.763,"body":"How it will behave in the fire?"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":3140.773,"endTime":3142.933,"body":"Will it behave better,"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":3140.773,"endTime":3142.933,"body":"will behave worse."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":3143.383,"endTime":3143.623,"body":"Yeah."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":3143.683,"endTime":3147.738,"body":"Luckily the current experiences"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":3143.683,"endTime":3147.738,"body":"that they usually behave better."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":3147.738,"endTime":3151.638,"body":"And Thomas mentioned that these"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":3147.738,"endTime":3151.638,"body":"actions that were found made"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":3151.638,"endTime":3152.628,"body":"the buildings more robust."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":3152.628,"endTime":3157.068,"body":"So even some requirements"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":3152.628,"endTime":3157.068,"body":"could have been softened down"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":3157.248,"endTime":3158.868,"body":"on the secondary members."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":3159.048,"endTime":3161.648,"body":"It's really interesting how"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":3159.048,"endTime":3161.648,"body":"understanding fire science"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":3161.648,"endTime":3165.181,"body":"can significantly improve the"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":3161.648,"endTime":3165.181,"body":"way, how we design structures."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":3165.181,"endTime":3166.171,"body":"Some has also mentioned."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":3166.601,"endTime":3168.671,"body":"New Euro codes coming up."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":3168.881,"endTime":3172.381,"body":"And, for those who don't know,"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":3168.881,"endTime":3172.381,"body":"Euro codes is a series of"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":3172.386,"endTime":3173.911,"body":"standards in European union."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":3173.911,"endTime":3177.264,"body":"They're free to access,"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":3173.911,"endTime":3177.264,"body":"publicly available and they"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":3177.264,"endTime":3182.314,"body":"have, Plenty of information"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":3177.264,"endTime":3182.314,"body":"on structural engineering and"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":3182.314,"endTime":3185.554,"body":"structural fire engineering"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":3182.314,"endTime":3185.554,"body":"with all modern materials."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":3185.944,"endTime":3187.834,"body":"I really found interesting"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":3185.944,"endTime":3187.834,"body":"that he mentioned, uh,"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":3187.834,"endTime":3190.384,"body":"Luxemburg annex to eurocode,"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":3187.834,"endTime":3190.384,"body":"which covers glass."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":3190.384,"endTime":3193.714,"body":"And I must really jump into that"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":3190.384,"endTime":3193.714,"body":"because , it's super interesting"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":3193.714,"endTime":3194.914,"body":"topic to me at this point."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":3195.434,"endTime":3199.224,"body":"I hope it was not too heavy for"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":3195.434,"endTime":3199.224,"body":"summer break, but, , I guess,"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":3199.224,"endTime":3200.574,"body":", fire science , is just great."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":3200.604,"endTime":3203.019,"body":"Even if it's even if it's"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":3200.604,"endTime":3203.019,"body":"hard, it's still great."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":3203.349,"endTime":3206.889,"body":"I hope you've enjoyed this"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":3203.349,"endTime":3206.889,"body":"episode and I hope to see"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":3206.889,"endTime":3210.231,"body":"you and I hope to see you"},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":3206.889,"endTime":3210.231,"body":"here again next Wednesday."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":3210.381,"endTime":3210.831,"body":"Thank you."},{"speaker":"Wojciech Wegrzynski","startTime":3210.831,"endTime":3211.431,"body":"Cheers."}]}