That Tech Pod
Welcome to That Tech Pod, a podcast co-hosted by Laura Milstein, Gabi Schulte and Kevin Albert. Each Tuesday, That Tech Pod will feature in depth discussions about data privacy, cybersecurity, eDiscovery, and tech innovations with heavy hitters in the industry. Subscribe so you don't miss an episode! Visit thattechpod.com for more information.
That Tech Pod
Ranking the eDiscovery Hosting Platforms: The REAL Truth Behind the Marketing Hype With Phil Shellhaas
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Today on That Tech Pod, Laura, Gabi, and Kevin talk to Phil Shellhaas, Executive Vice President of eDiscovery Services. Phil brings two decades of litigation support experience to his leadership role at Trustpoint.One. Most recently he served as Senior Director of Legal Services for Trustpoint’s Electronic Discovery Services organization, where he strategically advised some of the world’s largest corporations about data reduction optimization. During his career, Phil has held several organizational roles, with specialized proficiency in reprographics, imaging/scanning, electronic discovery, ASP services, computer forensics, and sales management. Phil has managed, consulted and engineered solutions for a variety of large litigation and investigative matters, including pharmaceutical, industrial, technology, construction and FCPA.
This week's sponsor:
The diversity and dispersion of digital information continue to grow while the legal and regulatory environments become more challenging. Organizations are seeking innovative solutions to help them manage legal and compliance risks, streamline business processes, and reduce cost. From pre-litigation information management to post-matter data disposition, the EY Forensic team’s offers deep rooted knowledge of the latest eDiscovery technology and cross domain advisory experience through the entire eDiscovery life cycle. In the past year, EY was named a leader in the "IDC MarketScape: Worldwide eDiscovery Services 2021 Vendor Assessment” for its subject matter expertise, its global network, and its remote capabilities. EY can help shape the lens to provide a broader picture of your data and discovery story.Learn more about the eDiscovery solutions from EY at www.ey.com/forensics
It's December giving month at That Tech Pod:
This week's charity:
Support the expansion of Tsharka Elementary School to serve all the children in this Tibetan village located in the remote Himalayan region of Dolpo, Nepal. Currently, the school is filled to capacity with 60 students. There are 120 children in Tsharka Village. New classrooms are being built and more teachers must be hired. The International Community Development Foundation seeks money to complete four new classrooms, repair the existing school building, and pay salaries for three new teachers.
Donate here.
Hey Tech Pod listeners! This is Gabby Schulte. I am here with Laura Millstein, my co-host, and we are popping into your podcast feeds because we have some exciting end of the year charitable uh call to actions, if you will. Laura, what the hell am I talking about right now?
SPEAKER_00Oh man, this is exciting. Before we dive into this episode, before we tell you who we're talking to and all that fun stuff, we decided for the month of December to make it a giving month, make it a charity month. You have Hanukkah, you have Christmas, you have Kwanza, you have any holiday that you choose to celebrate, choose not to celebrate. You can invent your own holiday, you could do Kwanzmaka. Festivus for the rest of us, baby. Ooh, there it is! Anything that you want, this is the month to celebrate or to be sad about it. Either way, we're for you. We've decided to pick a charity every week that we are going to donate to and that we are going to encourage others to donate to. So each week we will tell you, here's the charity we picked and here's why we picked it. So this week we picked a really random charity. It has nothing to do with dough, but it looks nice. It looks like a kind thing. Yeah, so this charity is the and I'm sure I'm doing it wrong. It's a school in Tibet. It's an elementary school in Tibet where people come out and we're donating to help build the school. We're donating to help pay for teachers for the school. And if you're like, why a random school in Tibet? It's because it looks like a really nice charity. This is a nonprofit organization that really works to help educate students in areas where they don't have education. They don't have the ability to go to school. They don't have the ability to do anything. So there's 120 children in the Tasharka village, and that's where this elementary school is. And this nonprofit is trying to build new classrooms, they're trying to get teachers hired, they're trying to really help these kids develop a foundation, and they don't have the money to do it. So we decided that TechPod is going to do our first December charity to the Teosharka Tibetan Elementary School in Dolfo, Nepal. And I apologize if I'm pronouncing all of this wrong. I'm new to the charity, but it looks cool and I'm excited about it. How do you feel, Gabby?
SPEAKER_01Laura, I am so touched and honored that you have shared your charity with me and our listeners, and I'm just so excited about this endeavor. I think it's such a great idea in whatever way, shape, or form you spend the last month of 2022. I think giving should be a part of it. So um, like Laura said, each week we will have a different charity for you. And we're gonna put the links to each charity in the show notes and in our mail out. If you don't if you don't already subscribe to the mail out, I don't know what you're doing, you should go to www.techbot.com and sign up. Sign up. Um, so yeah, and you know, we're gonna be back here. I love your charity, Laura. I think that's such a good idea to bet. Why not? Um, and why not? Uh yeah, so with that said, back to the show. I'm Gabby Schulte, and you know what? I don't know that much about technology.
SPEAKER_00And I'm Laura Milstein, and I know so much about technology that I'm excited to just learn even more. Gabby, I'm excited for this episode today.
SPEAKER_01Laura, why are you so excited for this episode?
SPEAKER_00I think this one is very unique. So it we've done some e-discovery episodes, obviously, and a lot of them hit or miss, but this one is gonna be controversial. I think a lot of people listening are going to end up hating us at the end, or maybe loving us, or really, I don't know. But we gotta, we're gonna really do this.
SPEAKER_01So Okay, well explain to everybody what's the premise of what's the purpose of this episode today.
SPEAKER_00I just I'm giddy. So every time we talk about e-discovery, we dive into a platform, whether it's relativity or iPros Eclipse or iConnect Xera, any of these. And we talk to people that are actually using them, or maybe they're breaking down how does this e-discovery work? What is the e DRM? Whatever. Great knowledge, great stuff. But today we're gonna actually get nasty with it. When I say nasty with it, it doesn't mean you can't see Gabby's doing this like head bob thing because she knows we're about to get nasty with it. But we are gonna get nasty with it because this time is not, we're non-biased. So Gabby and I are not saying we prefer X platform over Y platform. We aren't talking about the vendor side of it. So it's not a company that happens to sell platforms. This one, we're gonna actually be talking to Phil, who's our guest today, on the actual platforms Relativity, Reveal, Everlaw, Disco, iConnect, iPro, just all of the companies that aren't selling to the vendors. I mean, they might be, but they're selling directly to people. And we want to ask the real questions. Are they all the same? Is a box a box, essentially? What is the difference? And tell us more about the actual companies. Like, I want somebody who's coming on, who's giving his honest opinion or her honest opinion, but in this case his, about the actual companies. And if you're listening and you work for any company that we talk about in this, whether it's cloud nine or I don't know, any of them. I'm like newx, whoever we end up talking about today, if you work for one of those companies and you disagree with what Phil is sharing, come on our show and tell us why. We'd be happy to talk about it. We won't excited to dive in.
SPEAKER_01Dialogue and debate respectfully. Yeah.
SPEAKER_00Respectfully. I think it's gonna be good. I'm just I'm excited to have like some real talk where we're not being friendly, we're not, you know, we're not trying to come out and insult any of these companies. But there's no friendliness. No, this is a this is like tech we hate right here. And it's not that we hate it, we want to know the truth. Like, should we hate it? Do you hate it? Who hates it?
SPEAKER_01Hate it and why? Do you disagree? Do you love it? Tell us why. So that's that's where we're here. All right, let's get started. I'm excited. So we talked to heavy hitters in the industry to help us break down all of these topics and more. Laura, today, who are we talking to?
SPEAKER_00Today we are talking to Phil Shellhouse, who has over two decades of litigation support experience to his leadership role as executive vice president eDiscovery services at Trust Point. Most recently, he served as a senior director of legal services for Trust Point's electronic discovery services organization, where he strategically advised some of the world's largest corporations about data reduction optimization. During his career, Phil has led several organizational roles with specialized proficiency in imaging and scanning, electronic discovery, ASP services, computer forensic, and sales management. Phil has managed, consulted, and engineered solutions for a variety of large litigation and investigative matters, including pharmaceutical, industrial, technology, construction, and FCPA. Phil, welcome to the show.
SPEAKER_03Thank you so much for having me.
SPEAKER_01Absolutely. So, Phil, yeah, we're super excited to dive in. This is gonna be a little bit of a spicy episode. But before we do all that, just tell us a little bit about you, um, how you got uh your journey into e-discovery. I, full disclosure, had no idea what e-discovery was before I started this podcast. Laura had to uh explain it to me like I was five. So uh yeah, tell us. Tell us your journey.
SPEAKER_03So, you know, it really goes back to before we called it e-discovery. I would call it more litigation support or even as old as it is, litigation copying back then. Um, and like many in the industry, I stumbled into a company that was doing copying for large law firms in Washington, DC. And I put a shirt and tie on in high school and delivered boxes to paralegals of of copies and learned that there was this thing called litigation support along the way. And from there, of course, it's been a lineage of papers now uh was being scanned as opposed to copying, and then it was turning into we all have computers and we email constantly every day, and those those documents were electronic to begin with. So hence the electronic discovery. And that's kind of been my path, like many people in the industry uh along the way.
SPEAKER_00I think that's that is the like, how did you get into the industry? Like I'm looking for in five years when someone says, Oh, I took e-discovery in college. I'm like, what? No, you didn't know what's going on. That's gonna happen. You know, I hate to say it, we're old. Yeah, I know, I know. I was like, ah, we all started with like, well, we were scanning some documents and then um and so with that being said, eDiscovery is new and not new anymore. And so we really are excited to have you on as Gabby and I were chatting. I am so pumped for this episode. I love eDiscovery, I've been in the field forever. And all of us that have been in the field forever, we have had experience with all of the different platforms. And there's just now there's so many that you have to ask, are they different? What's better than the other? And so we're excited to have you on to really like get nasty with us, tell us the truth because people, all a lot of the podcasts in eDiscovery are company-owned. I know that Reveal has one, I know iConnect has one, I don't know which other companies, but a lot of them have their own podcasts. And one of the reasons that we wanted to do this podcast is because we're not company-owned and we are not biased and we want to let other people have their opinions and tell us the truth on these. And so I'm just gonna dive right into relativity. If you're listening and you don't know what relativity is, they are the most well-known uh e-discovery platform in the industry. They are the quote industry standard. But the question now becomes how long do they remain that? And does them being the industry standard, does that mean that innovation has stagnated? And what does that look like to you, Phil?
SPEAKER_03I you know, I would agree. I mean, they're certainly the king of the hill, if you will, and they probably have been for the last decade, I would suggest. Most of us who came up the same way I did were we lived through the era of it was all proprietary tools, right? So the kings of the mountain at that time were folks and companies that had the development resources to kind of build your own platform and then go out and market it to the to the marketplace. Um, what relativity did at the early onset was there was a lot of e-discovery providers that didn't have the dollars to put behind building their own platform. And so they were able to kind of create this channel. The challenge, I think, is that, and I I would suspect that many people in that channel, which I would say that is the vendor community that licenses relativity and resells it to their both corporate legal departments and law firm customers, um, is that they're making the move to the cloud. And so from an economic perspective for a lot of the providers, it's changed the dynamics a little bit. We have to, we have to buy gigabytes from relativity in order to resell them to the marketplace. And so if you can buy more up front, well, you get a better strike price. You get the volume discount, uh, and therefore you can be more competitive in the marketplace. I think that along with the economic changes of the industry, there's so much private equity that's gone through the industry and gobbled up all of these companies and they've done roll-ups. So um they need data. They need to feed the beast of data hosting because that's the economic model that most of the providers have built their built their businesses on. Uh, and so that that presents challenges going to relativity one. And I think a lot of vendors' postures right now is they what whether big or small, is they would certainly put data into their relativity on-prem or server footprint first and relativity one second, but you kind of have to do relativity one to go along with the industry. And that presents challenges. I know there's frustrations there, and I know some of the larger providers have decided that they're going to, you know, re-engage on their proprietary platforms that they've either inherited through one of the acquisitions they made or that they developed years ago and kind of it sat on the shelf for a while. Um, it's a hedge, probably, is what that is.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. No, I I think everything you're saying does make a lot of sense. But even with all this, I think a lot of the competitors to relativity saw opportunity when they came out with RHEL One because the pricing structure was pretty high at the beginning, may still be. I'm not sure. But because of this, I think a lot of people saw this and said, I'm gonna come in here and I'm gonna take over. And a lot of companies started doing intense marketing to make themselves seem like they're actually the next relativity. They're bigger than relativity, they're better than relativity. But when you look at the numbers, even now, relativity still has about 80% of the market share. And I think that's something to question. Is marketing real? Is it not? And I see Gabby lining up because it looks like she's gonna ask about something like that.
SPEAKER_03I know what company you're gonna say. So go, Gabby, say it.
SPEAKER_00All right, go Gabby, do it.
SPEAKER_01Let's talk about another big one, Reveal. I reveal the company named Reveal.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, they've put a lot of marketing dollars um here recently.
SPEAKER_00Um, and and nothing, nothing negative to say about the company or the marketing, but but I do question that. So just not questioning the company, but yeah, tell tell us your thoughts on it. Yeah, tell us your thoughts about reveal.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, I mean, I think uh to make a splash, you probably uh on the marketing side, to make a splash, you probably have to put dollars behind marketing, right? Whether it's brandishing every pillar at the Hilton in New York for legal tech uh elevator, whatever it might be, having speaking engagements, putting people on panels. You know, in our industry historically, that has been the core marketing strategy, I would say. I'm not I don't want to weigh in on whether I think it's the most successful or not successful. It's just what has been done historically in this space, you know, outside of putting a banner ad on the legal tech news email that goes out uh every afternoon at 5 p.m. I mean, I've been signed up for that thing for so many years. You know, it's it kind of it's one of those that it just comes in every day, five o'clock. There it is. But I see who advertises on there who wouldn't. I it's it's my competition. It's people that I know I know people at most of the competition as well. Is it real? I think they've definitely had momentum. There's been some big service providers that have signed up, and I think again, that's kind of like that hedge. Whether you build it yourself or you go license something else or have an alternative, that's the choice that these vendors are kind of being boxed into. But full disclosure, their model is the same as relativity one. It's buy data from them to put in their cloud and you know, resell to the marketplace. So I think there's with a new provider that's an incumbent, if you are that it's really trying to go after the incumbent, the challenge is that these are software companies, not services companies. And they implicitly don't do services, and there's a gap there. You need professionals that can run the platforms. I know specifically there's definitely a shortfall in the marketplace of people who are proficient in reveal, unlike relativity. That's one of the advantages relativity has. It's why they're the king of the hill. Everybody knows how to work it. Even the lowest level attorney that isn't gonna do any technical things, they're just gonna go in and review documents. Well, they know how to do it in root in in relativity, whereas they may not have at least logged in and experienced trying to get a batch out of reveal. Now, it may sound simple and it may only be a two-step process, but they still have to learn it. And when you have to learn something, there might be a reluctance. So I think those are the challenges from a feature function perspective. They seem to be keeping pace with everything that relativity is added and even have maybe a few more that because of their purchases of the analytics engines that they bought with Brain Space and Next LP. And we'll see, they're in the midst of releasing their new release. They they do they they definitely had, I guess, perceived and um at least there were some outspoken folks in terms of their review, the review side capabilities, not the processing engines and not getting the data in, and not even the analytical engines, because I think per most people would say that it's probably a 50-50 coin flip on whether or not people like Brain Space versus an XLP outside of the folks that have kind of standardized on relativity analytics. And again, some of this is just my opinion. I I think that they were light on the review side, and theoretically, anyways, it's supposed to be fixed in their newer releases. So we'll see how that shakes out.
SPEAKER_01I appreciate all of that. And you know, another one other criticism that that we've been hearing about reveal is that it's it's very top-heavy. There's high-profile hires and throwing a lot of money at AI, but not a lot of investment in support, um, which kind of goes with a little bit of what you were saying. So, like, what do you agree with that criticism? Do you disagree? Um, and it's okay if you don't like want to really start the other.
SPEAKER_03You know, I know a few folks there due to them acquiring a company that I was intimately familiar with. Uh, Laura knows some of that as well. Uh so I know some of those folks. I don't think that they reach the level of senior executives or anything like that. So, but I I know your the the point you're making. I mean, there's definitely some folks that would I would be considered I would consider them part of kind of the marketing marketing regime, if you will, right? Every company does that. Uh or at least most any company that's large enough to expend the dollars does that. And these are folks that are experienced in the industry, go on panels, have something to say, certainly one that's gonna point people in the direction of their product. But I think it actually goes back to the gap between software and then service, right? So for years, our model, the vendor model, was we're gonna license technology. Yes, we will standardize on a few platforms, but it it at least allows you to say that there's some level of agnosticism to it, right? So that we can actually put a client in the proper platform given the circumstances and what they need to accomplish, right? So whether it was put it in reveal or relativity or back in the day, maybe an iConnect or an iPro or Eclipse or something like that, or which analytics engine do I want to use for this particular project? We could look at the scenario of the client and the specifics, and we could put them in the right workflow. And so we call that SaaS, software as a service, right? Because we wrapped it with services a lot, whether it was technical people, developers, senior project managers, junior project analysts, you know, everybody's kind of got their model of the the names of the personnel, but it's an army of people who are really good at what they do and are great problem solvers. And that's the key to delivery in this space. I've said it for years. If you want happy customers, it really is because the three of us today could go out and license technology and start a company, form the LLC, go on legal Zoom, get a get get a company.
SPEAKER_00It would be too successful. It would be like I know we would be like, oh God, we would make too much money, we wouldn't even know what to do. It would be crazy.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, but you need the people to actually execute on the delivery of the service. So a reveal doesn't do that. They're a software company, just like a relativity is a software company. Now, relativity is a little bit more mature in the marketplace, so yeah, their layers of support are a little bit better, but you can put a ticket in with relativity support if you're an RCA and you have a problem, and you may not get an answer for 24 hours in terms of what the actual problem is, and then you may learn it's a bug and they're working on it. It's a known issue, known software to exact, whatever it might be. Every company goes through that. I don't care who you are. Microsoft does it on a regular basis, right? We all know that. So that's the gap that we see in the marketplace. That's why service providers, I think, will always be needed, regardless of whether it's the cloud. Model where I have to buy gigabytes and resell them, or it's on my servers and I can be a little bit more price competitive probably and deliver the services. The one issue on the relativity front is that the more time that goes by, the more gap in terms of the features and functions in relativity one versus what's in server. So the the periods of updates to the server model are probably going to continue to get longer and the gap will increase, and that will present challenges.
SPEAKER_01The diversity and dispersion of digital information continue to grow while the legal and regulatory environments become more challenging. Organizations are seeking innovative solutions to help them manage legal and compliance risks, streamline business processes, and reduce cost. From pre-litigation information management to post-matter disposition, the eY Forensic team offers deep-rooted knowledge of the latest e-discovery technology and cross-domain advisory experience through the entire e-discovery life cycle. In this past year, EY was named a leader in the IDC marketscape Worldwide eDiscovery services 2021 vendor assessment for its subject matter expertise, its global network, and its remote capabilities. EY can help shape the lens to provide a broader picture of your data and discovery story. Learn more about the eDiscovery solutions from EY at www.ey.com slash forensics. Now, back to the show.
SPEAKER_00You know, you're like, and then why he missed the catch is because he forgot about his teammates on the field. I can't do it, but you have an incredible voice for all of this, and I love it. I I feel like you touched upon so much that I want to throw a lot at you right now. So I want to talk about Disco, Everlaw, and iConnect in a few different forms based on what you said. One, I want to start with the marketing. We talked about, you mentioned Reveal spending a lot on marketing at Legal Tech, et cetera. Disco spent tons of money at marketing when they first came out. Disco is the year before. And Disco has now gone public and made a lot of changes. And I think Disco was sort of the cool platform when they came out. They did great marketing. They're they're sort of, it just looked awesome. But the question then becomes did they stop developing it? Do they not fix it? The other issue that I hear a lot of people say with Disco is that it's sort of like um, you know, Comcast. When you have an issue, you call and you're calling a 1-800 number. You wait on hold, you don't get that service. But the i face does look really cool. Everlot also came out around the same time. Very pretty surface face, everything looks great. But then you have a company like iConnect. Um, Gabby and I had talked to Ian Campbell a while ago, the CEO of iConnect, and we had even brought up how people used to call it iCannot. So they went and they tried to make all these changes. They bought Centio uh for AI, but what happened to it? And they made changes just to make it look a lot prettier and cooler. And their platform is really great and designed with video footage. You can insert videos in it, and I think they do great with that. But their buttons are placed in such a different form that it's almost not aesthetically pleasing. So, how do you feel about the different platforms aesthetically? What do you think? Do you think it makes a difference? Do you think marketing helps? Do you think people spend too much on marketing and then not enough on like fixing the surface? What are your thoughts on all of that? And I know I'm I'm throwing several companies at you.
SPEAKER_03And I'm there's been a lot of changes over the course of time. There was a time. Obviously, iConnect was like the first, we used to call it online review database. That's how dated it is, right? That was it available in the marketplace that a law firm, legal service provider could license and then utilize for hosting data and databases for clients. Heck, I mean, my history with it is that I remember when it was uh SQL backed, I remember when it was Oracle backed. I mean, it they went through different iterations. And then they went to Zara. And I remember that era as well. I happen to be at a provider that did do an upgrade to the Zara platform, which was their complete rebuild of the entire user interface. And it was right around that time when the iPad came out, right? So it was cool. It was coded in HTML5. People could use any browser to do it, and it just looked different. But I also remember going in and saying there was a there was a bug in it. I I can't remember specifically what it was. I think you could get stuck in a batch. You couldn't get out of a batch and go back to it, or it was something really simple that you would think would be like, you know, this is framework like blocking and tackling 101 to use a sports analogy that they kind of forgot when they did the master upgrade of it. And that's iConnect. I mean, I think they've struggled a little bit with market share, is my perception of it, not knowing the intimate details. Haven't been a licensee of that platform in pro in well over 14 years or so. It's hard to keep track of time anymore. Stop counting at 10. But it it was one of the foundational pieces of the industry, and they just got passed by by relativity because they were adding features and functions. I don't know that iConnect's been out there big time on the marketing front. Now, the cloud providers, back to your initial question, they definitely did a big push. And the reason was that they were trying to gobble up market share because they didn't have armies of sales reps and they were purely, again, software they're a cloud-based software company. I don't know that they ever touted big armies of project managers to support their clients. The idea was DIY, do it yourself, which is nice for smaller customers. If you make the interface simple enough, then most people should be able to figure it out. And they they probably prefer the non-complex matters with the easy customers that are just going to go in. They want to upload one PST file, they want to review the documents, and they want to push out some PDFs. I think like disco, you know, and I don't know that anybody knows the full truth unless you've worked within that organization. And I generally don't go on a podcast to, you know, bash the competition. We've certainly gone up against them before. It appears as if there's an army of people behind the curtain that's processing the data and creating PDFs and pushing them up into the database. And it's part of their service. I think where they're struggling, to your point, about them going public. And there's plenty of people on LinkedIn and different blog posts in the industry that have chimed in about this. So I certainly don't want to steal anybody's thunder, but it's pretty clear that they're getting knocked in their valuation because when they first went public, people saw it as a software play. Uh, another Silicon Valley incubated company that's got a really cool technology and it's going to take over the legal industry. And then it turned out that they were doing manage a bunch of managed review services, and it was a significant portion of the revenue. And the next thing you know, they got valued like a services company. And that valuation went way down, and so did their stock price. And so that's a challenge for them. It doesn't necessarily mean that the platform is terrible. I think that there's probably plenty of customers where it probably works great for them. That's the industry. And I think, you know, Everlaw, another cloud provider, you could throw logical cloud nine, next point now is an up-and-comer who's really come up with really low pricing to try to get kind of that small to mid-size law firm to engage with them. But again, where they struggle is services. You know, I know specifically, I won't name which one of those four platforms it is, but we've had some customers who a law firm has made a decision to go with it uh globally, and they've come back and sent us data back to put into a database so that they have services wrapped around it. Because what they were missing was the services. Not that the features and functions weren't good enough. They just need the people. They need uh expertise on call and ready to support them.
SPEAKER_01Going back to reveal, you know, as we all know, the slogan is all in on AI. What about traditional review? It seems like it's still pretty prevalent in the industry. Tell us where that factors in and how that impedes some of these companies.
SPEAKER_03You know, I think I mean, obviously, there's a massive review market, and there's many folks who are doing it, whether it's law firms, even, you know, even reviewers within a corporate legal department. There's companies like Trust Point. We will provide attorneys, uh managing attorneys, QC team lead. You know, you can do different levels of delivery when it comes to review. Some law firms hire lawyers from a company like Trust Point or others. There's plenty of staffing companies out there, they just want the bodies, and then the law firm manages that review. So there's a huge market for that. The question is, how does that come together with AI? It's absolutely being utilized. I mean, again, full disclosure, Reveal bought next LP. The companies that I've been with have utilized that platform as one of the analytic engines. We've used a lot of the various ones along the way, whether it's relativity analytics. I mean, uh, we had eras where we were testing out AFI, uh, Centio. There's been many along the way. Heck, I can go all the way back and say I was using a 10X. In fact, the company I was with was the first company to license anything from content analyst in the legal discovery space. So, I mean, it goes way back. That technology's been around for a long time. And I recall, gosh, that probably would have been early 2000s, sitting in front of an attorney doing a little pitch meeting and telling them about all the great things we could do with concept clustering and telling them that they're going to go from an average document calls per hour from 50 to 150. And I almost got stormed out of there. If they had had bouncers, I would have been on the concrete, you know, because that didn't want to be heard at that time. It wasn't, it was way too progressive at that point.
SPEAKER_00Phil, I have to just jump in. Is concordance still a thing?
SPEAKER_03As you're talking inside, it is, but it got bought. So if you recall, all of LexisNexis's suite of e-discovery products was bought by Cloud9. Um, now Cloud9 has gone through an exercise of re-engineering the processing application to try to build a newx beater, I'll call it.
SPEAKER_00So let's let's actually ask about that. If we're gonna talk cloud nine, can we do a cloud nine meets newix? Because cloud nine acquired law, then recently they acquired ESI Analyst, which we had had Trent Um Livingston on our show at one point to talk about ESI. Didn't see it coming with Cloud9 acquiring them, but also didn't see them acquiring Law, which was at one point like the company standard of processing. Then you look at Nuix, who then acquired Ringtail, which when you look at Ringtail, if you know how to use Ring Tail, cool, great platform, I guess. But if you don't know how to use Ring Tail, I mean the training on that's like 700 hours. What? So I know we've taken up tons and tons of your time, and I could keep you forever, but I think, yeah, can you before we let you officially like live your life, can you break down more since I saw you getting there and I was like, yes, yes, I want.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, I mean, you added a few things in there. Number one, you know who likes ringtail is database geeks because it's pretty cool when you know how to work it. That was the historical statement there. And you know, I mean, look, and Nuics is struggling, right? So they're in the market, there's a lot of stuff going around that organization, but at its core, it was seen as kind of the the best kind of core processing engine. You know, the original GUI was basically DOS. You know, you had to be a programmer to run it, but then they put a GUI around it and they've done a good job. At least they had done a good job until kind of the wheels started falling off the last couple of years, it seems. And again, that's just based on what's in the news. So we all see it, right? So I don't have any intimate knowledge of that. The cloud nine thing was definitely interesting. I think the Lexus suite of e-discovery products, I think they were just tired of holding on to those things. And so they just saw an opportunity to get rid of it. It wasn't their core business. They had been talking about upgrading and integrating law and concordance for like a decade and never did it. They just never could get it done. And I think probably to your point, maybe they didn't put the development dollars around it. Not that they were out there doing a lot of marketing. So I don't know that they were wasting it on other stuff. I just think that they had other core businesses that were more important and was their core revenue stream. So it kind of got lost and sat on the shelf. Trust me, and I'm an old concordance person, you know. I mean, I I'm sitting here at my computer right now and I got to remind myself to go pack and re-index, you know, because that's what we did. We've looked at that, and I I give them, I give Cloud9 a little credit. They were one of the first to kind of build a cloud model and then publish pricing. That's pretty gutsy to do because anybody could see it. I, you know, technically I would be competition to them and to publish pricing, that's a pretty gutsy move, I'd say, from a marketing perspective. It's certainly you're not spending a lot of money to do it, it's just it's the risk of doing it, right? You know, the one thing without knowing the economics of each of these companies, now, if they're public, then we get to see their 10Ks, we get to see the quarterly filings. That's always fun reading for us eDiscovery geeks, you know, what's going on at at Disco, what's going on at KL. We can see it. And it doesn't look good on paper. So that's the struggle. It's like, well, how long can that keep going? Companies in this space, litigation support providers, they're not used to losing money quarter over quarter. It's not a Silicon Valley startup where we're gonna wait until we're gonna have profits in year 11 or something. That's not how our businesses have been built. Again, because we're software as a service, we have services wrapped around it. When you're just software, I get it. You can probably get away with some of that. Some of these folks have a lot of money pumped behind them, and I just wonder when do the wheels fall off. And I know I'm gonna take it to a completely different era area, but there is a we're in this kind of recessionary, inflationary period right now. And I think of all the roll-ups that have been done, there's companies that have been recapitalized five times over. Now they do that, so they can go out and buy another company, and then new private equity guys come in. But all of that gets put on the balance sheet on debt. And that's a challenge when interest rates are going up. Because I just think, what is the debt service on a massive company that has, you know, that's the equivalent of what 10 years ago was five different companies in the marketplace? All that debt is sitting there and they have to make debt service payments. Is that gonna be a factor in our space? I don't know the answer. I but I I think about it and it concerns me because I hate to say it, even though I compete against a lot of these folks, I have a lot of friends at these places, people that I've come up along the ranks with. You know, you never want to see your friends have issues. Um, I love a good, you know, friendly competition. You know, there's enough market share out there for all of us.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, no, we love that too. And um, I think those are valid, valid concerns. We lied. We have one last question for you. Um I want you to tell us a little bit about like what you see coming down the pipeline. Tell us about some trends. Um, you know, take us a couple years down the road. And yeah, give us give us your fortune-telling scoop.
SPEAKER_03Wow, do you have another hour?
SPEAKER_00Oh, well, on that, tell us if you don't mind, which one of these companies do you think will not be here down the line? And you can be scared and not want to share that. But if you're like, I think this company will be gone, I think these companies won't merge, I think only this one company will remain. That kind of future telling would be super.
SPEAKER_03I'm not sure. I think, well, number one, I think Nux is gonna get bought. Seems to be some news sputtering through the industry. I don't know that all of it was supposed to be public, but it was made public by the Australian stock exchange or whatever the heck they call it over there. So there's certainly some interesting stuff there. So I think they're gonna get bought. Possibly, I think an iConnect could get bought, to be honest with you. I know they got some capital, fresh capital here recently, but normally those things get turned over. So the question is, is there a provider out there that wants to use that as a hedge against relativity or relativity one? And there's certainly some big ones. The problem with that is that it's hard for a service provider to buy an iConnect because their clients are service providers, and that would cause all kinds of problems with it, right? Same issue with like relativity. You can't buy relativity because there's you know 79 or 110 service providers and advisories and consultant companies that are using that platform, right? So you're buying up a bunch of competitors and it just wouldn't work there either. I'm not sure about disco. I mean, I see the stock price and they may be able to survive, but uh when you get a multi-billion dollar valuation and I I you know you see the quarterly reports, that scares me. So I don't know what the the the off ramp for them is necessarily, you know, because whoever buys it, there's still a significant amount of debt on on that company, or at least the the people who put the money up at the beginning are gonna take a bath. So and we've seen that before. We've seen when private equity has come in and bought a company, put debt on the balance sheet, and then all it takes is a little bit of a cash flow episode and the company can't make payroll. And we've heard rumors along the years. I won't name, but we've heard some big companies where you know they were on the brink of it and they needed some fresh capital in order to kind of weather the storm. And all it takes is everybody in this industry who's been doing this long enough knows that there's those big whales out there of matters and millions of dollars of uh invoices get backed up and they get outstanding for 300 days, and that's a challenge to cash flow. I don't know about the other cloud providers. The one nice thing about developing a software in the cloud is that yes, you have infrastructure costs on a monthly basis for being supported in the cloud, but in terms of overhead, it's not like I mean, a service provider has much more overhead because we've got armies of people all over the place, and people are expensive. And if they're not on projects, engaged on projects, billing their time, then they can implode, certainly. But you can always write size. The cloud providers are in a little bit of a better spot because it's a little bit more of a fixed cost probably to run those businesses. But you see with like the discos, I mean, they clearly are having a struggle gaining enough revenue to offset their costs.
SPEAKER_01Well, Phil, this has been so illuminating. Uh, we thank you for your time. It's it's been an honor and a privilege.
SPEAKER_03We've I mean I've really enjoyed it. Thank you so much.
SPEAKER_00An honor and a privilege.
SPEAKER_01So the thing about this episode, we said it at the top. We want to be non-biased. So we had someone on saying, you know, opinions about uh a lot of platforms and companies. So if you work for one of these companies or you use uh one of the platforms that we mentioned today and you disagree with what was said, come on the show. Email us at contact at thattigpod.com. We would love to have you on and uh continue this combo. So I am here with Laura and our education expert Kevin. Um we just talked to Phil Shellhaas, uh eDiscovery, extraordinaire with so many opinions. Uh tell me your tech takeaways, Laura and Kev.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, um Gabby, he he was a good one to come on the show because it's hard to get somebody to talk about these subjects. I do think he was diplomatic to an extent, and I could see Kev at points where everybody on here can't necessarily see, but we could see Kev at points like you could get, you know, you could see him getting a little. Um so I'm excited to hear your opinion, Kevin. But I do also, for everybody listening, you know, we don't have any negative opinions. I mean, Kev, my, but Gabby and I think very highly of most of the eDiscovery companies. So nothing negative about any of the companies that we talked about. Um, in fact, you know, we've talked to a lot of the people. We've had on um David Horrigan from Relativity, we've had Trent um from ESI, which is now Cloud9, we had on Ian Campbell from iConnect. So nothing negative of any of the companies that we're talking about. We are genuinely non-biased and trying to get real feedback. But Kev, can you tell us, do you think that what Phil was saying is it real feedback? Do you think that he's just being a little too diplomatic? Or how did you feel about uh about the episode? Because I I like Phil a lot and I think he's very knowledgeable and very smart. But that that is my big question.
SPEAKER_02Uh agreed. I think you know, though he definitely had a lot of opinions. There was definitely a lot that was said there. Um, you know, and I think, you know, from his perspective of you know, kind of the rankings of the platforms, I kind of feel the same way that, you know, relativity is you know the premier in the industry, they're you know the longest, you know, out there, they're the top you know dog type of thing. And then you have the you know the next level down, you know, the reveals, the iConnects, the discos, you know, Everlong, what have you. And it is interesting to kind of hear his perspective on that. You know, from my perspective as a user of these platforms, you know, I definitely have my you know opinions. Um I definitely think the brain space and XLP pieces of reveal are certainly cool. But as he said, you know, they definitely have left behind some of the traditional pieces of review. Um, and so it is interesting to kind of hear that from you know a non-biased, you know, from an independent person um and what have you. You know, same thing with iConnect. I was an iConnect user back in the day forever, you know, same like he, but it's amazing how you know you don't really hear about them that much anymore. Um and so for me, you know, it is, you know, kind of interesting to hear that same perspective. Um, you know, I I am also nervous about disco. You know, you watch the public filings, like he said, um, and you wonder, you know, can they survive? Um, you know, you they got this massive influx of money, and then what, you know, and now they're just definitely um, you know, crumbling. Um, you know, the newicks piece, um, I had um obviously heard the same sort of industry gossip uh that he had that they are um likely gonna get bought. And you know, you wonder who's gonna make that investment. Um, you know, his statement that, you know, somebody like iConnect is kind of teed up to be bought is pretty interesting because he's definitely right. You wonder who's gonna take that leap, um, who's gonna buy that. You know, is it gonna be um, you know, a law firm? You know, is it gonna be a company, you know, like you know, his, like a service provider, or even like a big four, or even like the next tier down of the big four, like the FTIs or the concilio-sized companies. Um, you know, from my perspective, it's really interesting to kind of wonder um what's out there because um, you know, a lot of the pieces that he hit on really, you know, hit home for me.
SPEAKER_00I agree, Kev. And I and I also wish and that we had asked about iPro. I don't know why we didn't ask about iPro because you come from Eclipse to now their desktop version and a lot of the the they recently made a few acquisitions themselves. So I am curious. Do you have any last thoughts on iPro? Um, just just for people since we we didn't touch upon that one, and and I think we should have.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, I mean, again, it's a it's it's similar to a tool that has been you know around forever that has gone through so many different acquisitions and so many different iterations over time. Um, because you're right, you know, they were, you know, a lot of different tools back in the day. They were one of those tools that was originally like a scanning software that became, you know, became a review platform that then became um you know an interface out there, you know, and kind of moved around in the industry to kind of figure out sort of what was their place. Um and you're right, they have done a lot over the last years and have built some kind of neat little niche products, um, but you don't really hear about them that much in the marketplace of review platforms. Um, but but you know, it's amazing to still hear how many people still use Eclipse and still use some of these platforms. Um, and so it's one that's just definitely got legs. It's definitely one that's on surprise is still around to a certain degree. Um, you know, but uh as a person who's used it, you know, it definitely has its place. Um, you know, I definitely was a summation iBlaze uh, you know, person back in the day, you know, um, because you had sort of a where you were concordance user, we were a summation user back in the day, you had kind of different sides. Um, and so it's kind of interesting to see sort of how these companies, some of these companies have survived for, you know, more than 15, 20 years at this point. Um, you know, when I started in this industry, there wasn't really a review platform out there. And so it's amazing how far we've come um in in you know what is what I feel like is a short amount of time. But as I think about it, it's you know essentially 20 years.
SPEAKER_01Speaking of platforms, um, you can check us out at our platform, aka our website, at www.techpod.com. Uh check us out on LinkedIn, all the social medias at that tech pod. Uh, follow us there, be our friend. Also, you can go to Spotify, Apple Podcasts, wherever you listen to this podcast, and give us a five star rating andor review. We would love you forever, and we will see you next time. See you next time.