How to Build a Specialty Practice That Outlasts Its Founders: Travis Brown of Rich and Cartmill

Know Your Risk and Insurance Coverage with RiskProNet

Know Your Risk and Insurance Coverage with RiskProNet
How to Build a Specialty Practice That Outlasts Its Founders: Travis Brown of Rich and Cartmill
Aug 04, 2026 Season 1 Episode 45
RiskProNet

Finding an insurance partner who actually understands the construction business, not just the construction policy, is rare. Rich and Cartmill, a Tulsa, Oklahoma based agency founded in 1922, has built its reputation on exactly that combination, pairing deep surety expertise with construction insurance across a practice that now makes up 40 percent of the firm's revenue.

Host Matt Sasso talks with Travis Brown, President of Rich and Cartmill, about the agency's century-long history, how its construction practice grew out of a 2003 merger, and why contractors who need bonds so often need matching insurance coverage. The conversation also covers how the firm has diversified into healthcare, senior living, and energy sector risk without losing its construction roots.

If you want a real look at how a century-old agency builds specialty practices and deep client relationships, this is the episode for you.

Timecodes:

0:02 – 1:34 | Welcome and introducing Rich and Cartmill
1:35 – 4:06 | How Travis and Matt connected through RiskProNet
4:07 – 6:38 | Founding the agency: 1922 and the Tulsa oil boom
6:39 – 7:59 | Three generations: Dick Toobner and Ryan Toobner
8:00 – 9:14 | Office locations and the Olathe, Kansas setup
9:15 – 10:47 | Building the construction practice: the 2003 merger
10:47 – 12:18 | Construction practice by the numbers: 21 producers, 40 percent of revenue
12:18 – 14:49 | Typical clients and Oklahoma's federal military base work
14:49 – 16:19 | Why bonding clients become insurance clients
16:19 – 17:52 | Surety 101: the Miller Act and bond types
17:52 – 18:42 | Memorable claims: the OKC arena and Murrah bombing recovery
18:43 – 20:44 | Beyond construction: healthcare, senior living, and medical malpractice
20:44 – 22:44 | Energy sector risk and roustabout contractors
22:44 – 24:59 | Closing thoughts: culture, legacy, and RiskProNet
24:59 – 25:21 | Outro

Resources:

Become a member at RiskProNet.com
Connect with Matt Sasso on LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/matthew-sasso-8161b752/
Connect with Travis Brown on LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/travis-brown-03aba59/
Connect with Rich and Cartmill on LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/company/rich-&-cartmill-inc/

Episode Artwork How to Build a Specialty Practice That Outlasts Its Founders: Travis Brown of Rich and Cartmill 25:27 Episode Artwork The Cluster Model That Beat the Big Guys: Sullivan's 70-Year Insurance Story 25:11 Episode Artwork How Moody Insurance Cut Proposal Time by 90% Using AI 20:14 Episode Artwork How Outmarket AI Is Transforming Insurance Workflows for Independent Agencies 28:01 Episode Artwork What’s Next for RiskProNet in 2026 with Executive Director, Matt Sasso 18:29 Episode Artwork Botanical Gardens & Risk Coverage: Glasshouses, Storms, and Slips with Kim Slager of BHS Insurance 22:06 Episode Artwork How Moody and M3 Are Solving Insurance’s Talent Problem 42:22 Episode Artwork Win in a Shrinking Apartment Insurance Market with Dustin Thome of Buckner Insurance 15:56 Episode Artwork 4 Generations, 1 Workforce: Solving the Insurance Talent Gap with Luis Rivera 25:15 Episode Artwork How the California Wildfires Changed Insurance Policies: Rate Reform and Recovery 30:10 Episode Artwork Agencies within Agencies: The Story of M3 Elevate with Matt Cranney - Part 2 36:21 Episode Artwork Agencies within Agencies: The Story of M3 Elevate with Matt Cranney - Part 1 20:33 Episode Artwork Disaster-Proofing Your Agency: Lessons from Houston with Cheryl Sanders 25:01 Episode Artwork Matt Sasso: Building a Stronger RiskProNet Community 17:20 Episode Artwork The Future of Insurance Brokerage: AI and Data with Erik Vandermause 35:42 Episode Artwork Unmasking the Insurance Industry in California with Jill Epstein of IIABCal 31:47 Episode Artwork How Specialization Transformed M3 Agency: Insights from Brad Reitzner - Part 2 25:54 Episode Artwork How Specialization Transformed M3 Agency: Insights from Brad Reitzner - Part 1 27:30 Episode Artwork Bridging the Gaps: Young Professionals and Women Working in Insurance with Kelsey Swingle-Robertson 31:07 Episode Artwork Unlocking the Secrets of Pharmacy Benefit Managers: Insights from Adam Aguilar 26:25 Episode Artwork How Parametric Insurance Is Changing the Game with Garrett Koehn 23:07 Episode Artwork Navigating 2024 with Webb Milward – Unveiling Trends, Transaction Value, and the Run vs. Build Mindset 41:47 Episode Artwork The Approach to Success When it Comes to Benefits and Communicating Rate Increases to Clients with John Melborn 38:33 Episode Artwork Bolton Street, Developing Programs, and Program Eligibility with Geraldine DelPrete from SterlingRisk 30:51 Episode Artwork Being an employee-centric agency and how that has contributed to CMR’s success with Travis Pearson 36:54