{"version":"1.0.0","segments":[{"startTime":0.179,"endTime":4.318,"body":"someone struggles about trying to find a"},{"startTime":2.759,"endTime":7.979,"body":"definition of what is ethical and"},{"startTime":4.318,"endTime":10.259,"body":"ethical my my recommendation is is"},{"startTime":7.98,"endTime":13.76,"body":"something doesn't feel right the chances"},{"startTime":10.259,"endTime":13.759,"body":"are is because it's not right"},{"startTime":14.539,"endTime":21.179,"body":"it's a gray area which definitely needs"},{"startTime":17.699,"endTime":23.4,"body":"regulation 100 and the loan is to be"},{"startTime":21.179,"endTime":25.379,"body":"adapted to this new historical context"},{"startTime":23.399,"endTime":27.538,"body":"so that's why these arguments about all"},{"startTime":25.379,"endTime":29.399,"body":"but I know this is not the what did you"},{"startTime":27.539,"endTime":31.019,"body":"see the copyright infringement here well"},{"startTime":29.399,"endTime":33.0,"body":"yeah because you're longer in the pixels"},{"startTime":31.018,"endTime":34.738,"body":"you are mixing a lot you know if you're"},{"startTime":33.0,"endTime":37.439,"body":"still one pound from one million people"},{"startTime":34.738,"endTime":40.859,"body":"it's gonna be really hard to catch you"},{"startTime":37.439,"endTime":43.378,"body":"I feel fear even in young people about"},{"startTime":40.859,"endTime":46.738,"body":"should I study art or not"},{"startTime":43.378,"endTime":49.14,"body":"and there is a beautiful almost poetic"},{"startTime":46.738,"endTime":50.64,"body":"contradiction of all this that is yes"},{"startTime":49.14,"endTime":53.039,"body":"more than ever"},{"startTime":50.64,"endTime":56.759,"body":"double up like really now is the moment"},{"startTime":53.039,"endTime":61.62,"body":"where you have a voice like literally"},{"startTime":56.759,"endTime":64.378,"body":"um art in the last uh 20 years"},{"startTime":61.619,"endTime":68.459,"body":"um has been sadly quite driven even"},{"startTime":64.379,"endTime":70.799,"body":"either by let's say postmodern art or by"},{"startTime":68.459,"endTime":72.5,"body":"Massive Hollywood industry and video"},{"startTime":70.799,"endTime":75.54,"body":"games industry which has already"},{"startTime":72.5,"endTime":76.978,"body":"standards that this is your fans and you"},{"startTime":75.54,"endTime":78.609,"body":"go outside the fence you are not gonna"},{"startTime":76.978,"endTime":81.719,"body":"sell"},{"startTime":78.609,"endTime":83.64,"body":"[Music]"},{"startTime":81.719,"endTime":87.478,"body":"hi so a big Topic at the moment"},{"startTime":83.64,"endTime":88.859,"body":"obviously is AI chat GTP air mid journey"},{"startTime":87.478,"endTime":90.719,"body":"and all of these things including"},{"startTime":88.859,"endTime":93.359,"body":"there's actually a recent uh lawsuit"},{"startTime":90.719,"endTime":94.739,"body":"going on and I've got someone who's been"},{"startTime":93.359,"endTime":98.938,"body":"very much involved in this issue"},{"startTime":94.739,"endTime":100.739,"body":"Alvarado Martinez and um I wanted to get"},{"startTime":98.938,"endTime":102.478,"body":"him involved we're going to ask do our"},{"startTime":100.739,"endTime":104.459,"body":"usual discussion a little bit about his"},{"startTime":102.478,"endTime":107.459,"body":"career and so forth but what we also"},{"startTime":104.459,"endTime":109.919,"body":"really want to talk about is you know"},{"startTime":107.459,"endTime":112.379,"body":"what is going on what is what is air and"},{"startTime":109.92,"endTime":114.299,"body":"is it art is it is it just stealing"},{"startTime":112.379,"endTime":115.798,"body":"what's going on well first of all um"},{"startTime":114.299,"endTime":118.439,"body":"what do you do and how did you get into"},{"startTime":115.799,"endTime":120.118,"body":"the industry uh I just started in the"},{"startTime":118.438,"endTime":122.039,"body":"effects actually I started doing games"},{"startTime":120.118,"endTime":123.959,"body":"as a kid like all my life I was modding"},{"startTime":122.04,"endTime":125.28,"body":"games you know but at some point it's"},{"startTime":123.959,"endTime":126.718,"body":"like oh maybe I can make some money"},{"startTime":125.28,"endTime":129.36,"body":"doing something really that was really"},{"startTime":126.718,"endTime":130.978,"body":"and then I just decided to study 3D"},{"startTime":129.36,"endTime":134.099,"body":"animation in Madrid and then I went to"},{"startTime":130.979,"endTime":136.08,"body":"London I started working in in medical"},{"startTime":134.098,"endTime":138.479,"body":"animation actually a couple of years"},{"startTime":136.08,"endTime":140.219,"body":"which is quite interesting field uh and"},{"startTime":138.479,"endTime":142.019,"body":"then after two years it's like I want to"},{"startTime":140.219,"endTime":145.5,"body":"make movies I think that's why I started"},{"startTime":142.02,"endTime":147.319,"body":"my kind of tour for the classics London"},{"startTime":145.5,"endTime":149.939,"body":"companies NPC"},{"startTime":147.318,"endTime":152.399,"body":"ilm I've had enough time to do two"},{"startTime":149.939,"endTime":155.4,"body":"rounds around them I think we all know"},{"startTime":152.4,"endTime":156.599,"body":"what what we mean about this is sip it's"},{"startTime":155.4,"endTime":159.719,"body":"simple at the same time it's the only"},{"startTime":156.598,"endTime":161.459,"body":"way sometimes sadly you can progress uh"},{"startTime":159.719,"endTime":163.68,"body":"yeah you can be in a company 10 years"},{"startTime":161.459,"endTime":165.239,"body":"but I found the exciting the idea of"},{"startTime":163.68,"endTime":169.5,"body":"jumping to know different environments"},{"startTime":165.239,"endTime":172.739,"body":"and finally after their yeah a decade of"},{"startTime":169.5,"endTime":175.5,"body":"working VFX I decided to with Kobe when"},{"startTime":172.739,"endTime":178.378,"body":"cobit hit I just founded my my company"},{"startTime":175.5,"endTime":180.479,"body":"and moved to more game development"},{"startTime":178.378,"endTime":181.56,"body":"because I the last couple of years I was"},{"startTime":180.479,"endTime":183.78,"body":"quite involved in Virtual production"},{"startTime":181.56,"endTime":186.598,"body":"which is kind of the bridge right of"},{"startTime":183.78,"endTime":188.34,"body":"prayer time to video games and then I"},{"startTime":186.598,"endTime":190.378,"body":"founded my company making mirror Studios"},{"startTime":188.34,"endTime":193.739,"body":"where we do both things filmmaking"},{"startTime":190.378,"endTime":195.299,"body":"content but also video games in parallel"},{"startTime":193.739,"endTime":199.259,"body":"just to summarize I've been always doing"},{"startTime":195.3,"endTime":201.599,"body":"my own projects from again 10 years ago"},{"startTime":199.259,"endTime":203.28,"body":"I started doing Sumer which is a 10"},{"startTime":201.598,"endTime":205.679,"body":"minutes pilot about climate change"},{"startTime":203.28,"endTime":208.56,"body":"before climate change was you know to"},{"startTime":205.68,"endTime":211.439,"body":"find the focus of media right now uh and"},{"startTime":208.56,"endTime":214.519,"body":"then in 2020 I released a second one"},{"startTime":211.439,"endTime":214.519,"body":"which is the city of Junior"},{"startTime":217.318,"endTime":220.039,"body":"foreign"},{"startTime":230.439,"endTime":233.77,"body":"[Music]"},{"startTime":245.818,"endTime":248.06,"body":"foreign"},{"startTime":258.439,"endTime":263.219,"body":"like coming back to the past which is as"},{"startTime":261.358,"endTime":265.62,"body":"a kid doing little games some mods"},{"startTime":263.22,"endTime":268.02,"body":"finally I'm trying to you know convert"},{"startTime":265.62,"endTime":270.478,"body":"all together doing content and that's my"},{"startTime":268.019,"endTime":273.0,"body":"story brilliant so so you began working"},{"startTime":270.478,"endTime":274.86,"body":"with unreal actually in VFX was it were"},{"startTime":273.0,"endTime":275.879,"body":"you working with unreal yeah I worked in"},{"startTime":274.86,"endTime":278.1,"body":"the last two years I worked in military"},{"startTime":275.879,"endTime":280.68,"body":"production with unreal the last movie I"},{"startTime":278.1,"endTime":282.9,"body":"worked was actually Matrix Four and we"},{"startTime":280.68,"endTime":286.139,"body":"were working quite actively in set and"},{"startTime":282.899,"endTime":289.379,"body":"real engine uh we were building tools"},{"startTime":286.139,"endTime":292.139,"body":"but in my opinion uh I wanted to go"},{"startTime":289.379,"endTime":294.019,"body":"faster uh like I really wanted to"},{"startTime":292.139,"endTime":296.819,"body":"experiment more and there was a lot of"},{"startTime":294.019,"endTime":299.579,"body":"uh fear at that moment because of Kobe"},{"startTime":296.819,"endTime":301.8,"body":"and obviously I was excited about using"},{"startTime":299.579,"endTime":303.478,"body":"that time for r d but one thing is what"},{"startTime":301.8,"endTime":305.16,"body":"you want another thing is the budget and"},{"startTime":303.478,"endTime":308.519,"body":"how you look at the budget inside VFS"},{"startTime":305.16,"endTime":311.22,"body":"company and RND is something that is"},{"startTime":308.519,"endTime":313.439,"body":"very hard to sell internally so it was"},{"startTime":311.22,"endTime":314.94,"body":"like done I want to do more real-time"},{"startTime":313.439,"endTime":318.12,"body":"stuff I really believe we can deliver"},{"startTime":314.939,"endTime":320.759,"body":"final pixel not just previous or post"},{"startTime":318.12,"endTime":322.56,"body":"office I won't finally acceler and there"},{"startTime":320.759,"endTime":323.939,"body":"was a lot of asepticism not all the"},{"startTime":322.56,"endTime":326.399,"body":"people there is always you know in this"},{"startTime":323.939,"endTime":328.5,"body":"company there is always it's a little"},{"startTime":326.399,"endTime":331.739,"body":"bit of time consuming"},{"startTime":328.5,"endTime":333.3,"body":"um you need to convince too much"},{"startTime":331.74,"endTime":336.12,"body":"and that's why I'm starting to believe"},{"startTime":333.3,"endTime":338.4,"body":"in small teams to create way more"},{"startTime":336.12,"endTime":340.439,"body":"interesting content in this time which"},{"startTime":338.399,"endTime":343.5,"body":"is interesting about AI because someone"},{"startTime":340.439,"endTime":345.478,"body":"can argue like oh but AI can empower the"},{"startTime":343.5,"endTime":347.579,"body":"small teams to do big things you know"},{"startTime":345.478,"endTime":349.68,"body":"it's like one of the big topics I can"},{"startTime":347.579,"endTime":352.379,"body":"already Bridge with that of the AI"},{"startTime":349.68,"endTime":355.259,"body":"Defenders is is trying to use our"},{"startTime":352.379,"endTime":356.579,"body":"arguments in the past in their favor but"},{"startTime":355.259,"endTime":359.28,"body":"as a fallacy because there are many"},{"startTime":356.579,"endTime":360.719,"body":"fallacies it's like not because now ai"},{"startTime":359.279,"endTime":363.5,"body":"can make a video game let's say"},{"startTime":360.72,"endTime":366.6,"body":"illustration a card game for example"},{"startTime":363.5,"endTime":368.1,"body":"in two weeks means that is what we"},{"startTime":366.6,"endTime":370.68,"body":"wanted before"},{"startTime":368.1,"endTime":372.9,"body":"you know we want the other things we"},{"startTime":370.68,"endTime":375.538,"body":"want tools you know so yeah I I think"},{"startTime":372.899,"endTime":378.478,"body":"also I saw that one important aspect of"},{"startTime":375.538,"endTime":381.24,"body":"your post is you talk about"},{"startTime":378.478,"endTime":384.36,"body":"um being against the unethical use of AI"},{"startTime":381.24,"endTime":386.579,"body":"so let's let's talk about ethical and"},{"startTime":384.36,"endTime":388.319,"body":"unethical you actually"},{"startTime":386.579,"endTime":390.18,"body":"um I don't know this is a very big"},{"startTime":388.319,"endTime":392.58,"body":"subject and I did wonder when I was"},{"startTime":390.18,"endTime":394.199,"body":"thinking the best way to to start in but"},{"startTime":392.579,"endTime":395.699,"body":"I think there is let's let's look at"},{"startTime":394.199,"endTime":398.038,"body":"ethical use so for example on this"},{"startTime":395.699,"endTime":400.319,"body":"podcast I use resolve"},{"startTime":398.038,"endTime":402.12,"body":"um sometimes we have noise"},{"startTime":400.319,"endTime":403.919,"body":"um yeah people you know people talking"},{"startTime":402.12,"endTime":406.259,"body":"in the background not everyone has the"},{"startTime":403.918,"endTime":408.959,"body":"best microphone and recently a resolve"},{"startTime":406.259,"endTime":410.52,"body":"18 added this AI uh noise remove tool"},{"startTime":408.959,"endTime":411.839,"body":"and I run that and it's absolutely"},{"startTime":410.519,"endTime":413.698,"body":"brilliant I've removed like people"},{"startTime":411.839,"endTime":414.899,"body":"tapping on the table"},{"startTime":413.699,"endTime":416.759,"body":"um all kinds of things it's not perfect"},{"startTime":414.899,"endTime":418.739,"body":"if if their microphone isn't very good"},{"startTime":416.759,"endTime":420.84,"body":"and it's peaking you can't fix it but"},{"startTime":418.74,"endTime":423.259,"body":"it's way better than any of the things"},{"startTime":420.839,"endTime":426.538,"body":"any of the previous tools that I had so"},{"startTime":423.259,"endTime":430.68,"body":"that's I presume a pretty ethical use I"},{"startTime":426.538,"endTime":432.478,"body":"know that we've uh copycatting nuke a"},{"startTime":430.68,"endTime":434.038,"body":"lot of the time we might do"},{"startTime":432.478,"endTime":436.379,"body":"um I don't know a couple of frames where"},{"startTime":434.038,"endTime":439.079,"body":"we paint something into the eye and then"},{"startTime":436.379,"endTime":441.839,"body":"we replicate that across the sequence so"},{"startTime":439.079,"endTime":443.758,"body":"we might do previous Roto where you know"},{"startTime":441.839,"endTime":447.538,"body":"you go to a few frames and then you let"},{"startTime":443.759,"endTime":449.819,"body":"the AI rotor the rest of it so lots of"},{"startTime":447.538,"endTime":452.279,"body":"so you're not opposed to the technology"},{"startTime":449.819,"endTime":453.78,"body":"let's get let's be clear here there will"},{"startTime":452.279,"endTime":456.839,"body":"be a still bit on myself because I'm"},{"startTime":453.779,"endTime":459.418,"body":"working with four five six systems they"},{"startTime":456.839,"endTime":462.119,"body":"are related even the future models uh"},{"startTime":459.418,"endTime":464.219,"body":"each day with an estate transfer for"},{"startTime":462.12,"endTime":466.74,"body":"example in Houdini where you use web"},{"startTime":464.22,"endTime":468.96,"body":"action collapse so basically I draw a"},{"startTime":466.74,"endTime":472.319,"body":"little maze and then I can expand a"},{"startTime":468.959,"endTime":475.318,"body":"little mess into millions of variations"},{"startTime":472.319,"endTime":478.86,"body":"that is my Maze and I'm doing variations"},{"startTime":475.319,"endTime":481.319,"body":"of my own input and I think that if"},{"startTime":478.86,"endTime":482.879,"body":"someone struggles about trying to find a"},{"startTime":481.319,"endTime":486.479,"body":"definition of what is ethical and"},{"startTime":482.879,"endTime":488.819,"body":"ethical my my recommendation is is"},{"startTime":486.478,"endTime":491.219,"body":"something doesn't feel right the chances"},{"startTime":488.819,"endTime":493.259,"body":"are is because it's not right"},{"startTime":491.22,"endTime":495.599,"body":"you know it's like we need to try to"},{"startTime":493.259,"endTime":497.699,"body":"abstract a bit of the circle and maybe"},{"startTime":495.598,"endTime":500.399,"body":"the law is not written maybe the terms"},{"startTime":497.699,"endTime":503.28,"body":"of conditions are a bit abstract it's a"},{"startTime":500.399,"endTime":505.318,"body":"matter of do you feel this is right"},{"startTime":503.279,"endTime":507.239,"body":"um what happened with our community is"},{"startTime":505.319,"endTime":509.098,"body":"that not all the people even myself is"},{"startTime":507.24,"endTime":512.219,"body":"not completely ready in the legal field"},{"startTime":509.098,"endTime":514.139,"body":"to to defend or to all the things but"},{"startTime":512.219,"endTime":516.719,"body":"it's about the sense when you have"},{"startTime":514.139,"endTime":519.179,"body":"millions of people and you have an Intel"},{"startTime":516.719,"endTime":520.979,"body":"revolt on Earth station saying this is"},{"startTime":519.179,"endTime":522.538,"body":"not right even if sorry I can't"},{"startTime":520.979,"endTime":524.639,"body":"articulate I don't want to have a"},{"startTime":522.538,"endTime":526.86,"body":"linguistic battle right now I just feel"},{"startTime":524.639,"endTime":528.659,"body":"something is not right I think it's a"},{"startTime":526.86,"endTime":531.12,"body":"it's important to have a bit of empathy"},{"startTime":528.659,"endTime":532.62,"body":"or saying uh look I know you don't have"},{"startTime":531.12,"endTime":534.899,"body":"the tools to articulate what you are"},{"startTime":532.62,"endTime":537.179,"body":"thinking but I I heard you and I"},{"startTime":534.899,"endTime":538.62,"body":"understand we should talk about this so"},{"startTime":537.179,"endTime":540.719,"body":"that's that's my take on that it's like"},{"startTime":538.62,"endTime":542.399,"body":"yeah I can I can put the line off I can"},{"startTime":540.72,"endTime":544.139,"body":"put a red line in the middle this is"},{"startTime":542.399,"endTime":546.419,"body":"ethical and unethical and start to just"},{"startTime":544.139,"endTime":550.319,"body":"put different concepts but I do believe"},{"startTime":546.419,"endTime":551.879,"body":"that when millions of people talk is"},{"startTime":550.32,"endTime":554.339,"body":"because something is off"},{"startTime":551.879,"endTime":556.32,"body":"and then we start to need to debate what"},{"startTime":554.339,"endTime":558.6,"body":"is exactly what is off enough literally"},{"startTime":556.32,"endTime":562.019,"body":"we start to see how lawyers are"},{"startTime":558.6,"endTime":564.899,"body":"transpiring the reasons that ourselves"},{"startTime":562.019,"endTime":566.7,"body":"by intuition noticed so first the"},{"startTime":564.899,"endTime":569.278,"body":"intuition and later we just make the"},{"startTime":566.7,"endTime":572.64,"body":"concrete standing of this is unethical"},{"startTime":569.278,"endTime":574.5,"body":"so that's why in my case it's like I use"},{"startTime":572.639,"endTime":576.419,"body":"me Germany the first months as I think"},{"startTime":574.5,"endTime":578.879,"body":"many of us when this happened like well"},{"startTime":576.419,"endTime":581.579,"body":"it's so cool and you enter into this"},{"startTime":578.879,"endTime":583.439,"body":"kind of dopamine Loop of let's put"},{"startTime":581.58,"endTime":586.379,"body":"prompts and it's like oh it's called a"},{"startTime":583.44,"endTime":589.7,"body":"bit noisy but our school uh until one"},{"startTime":586.379,"endTime":591.899,"body":"day uh talking with a developer about"},{"startTime":589.7,"endTime":596.06,"body":"GPT I need I needed to wait to that"},{"startTime":591.899,"endTime":598.5,"body":"moment to realize so uh no shame if you"},{"startTime":596.059,"endTime":600.539,"body":"realize this later what is important is"},{"startTime":598.5,"endTime":602.94,"body":"to know this at some point and this guy"},{"startTime":600.539,"endTime":606.12,"body":"told me uh because I saw hey look I did"},{"startTime":602.94,"endTime":608.7,"body":"a procedural maze using chat GDP in"},{"startTime":606.12,"endTime":611.1,"body":"python or I can't remember and he told"},{"startTime":608.7,"endTime":612.54,"body":"me that's great but I I don't want to"},{"startTime":611.1,"endTime":615.659,"body":"use it because I don't know where this"},{"startTime":612.539,"endTime":619.559,"body":"snippet is taken from I was like boom"},{"startTime":615.659,"endTime":621.24,"body":"like wow that makes sense uh yeah"},{"startTime":619.559,"endTime":623.039,"body":"we can argue but if it's a collage or"},{"startTime":621.24,"endTime":624.899,"body":"it's not a collage it's not exactly the"},{"startTime":623.039,"endTime":628.139,"body":"same but it is true that that has been"},{"startTime":624.899,"endTime":630.659,"body":"extracted from from a place a coherence"},{"startTime":628.139,"endTime":632.759,"body":"that has no permission and when that"},{"startTime":630.659,"endTime":634.919,"body":"moment happened when this guy told me"},{"startTime":632.759,"endTime":637.799,"body":"this about the Snippets and stuff in in"},{"startTime":634.919,"endTime":639.259,"body":"this procedural text generated is what"},{"startTime":637.799,"endTime":642.12,"body":"just completely"},{"startTime":639.259,"endTime":645.36,"body":"changed my mindset and noticed that oh"},{"startTime":642.12,"endTime":648.74,"body":"this works for image for music for text"},{"startTime":645.36,"endTime":652.32,"body":"for cooking it doesn't matter it's"},{"startTime":648.74,"endTime":656.22,"body":"extracting the work and identity passion"},{"startTime":652.32,"endTime":658.26,"body":"years fears goals of others"},{"startTime":656.22,"endTime":659.639,"body":"because that's another I can't divert in"},{"startTime":658.259,"endTime":662.639,"body":"many topics like"},{"startTime":659.639,"endTime":664.919,"body":"it's not just about the coherence"},{"startTime":662.639,"endTime":667.919,"body":"between one pixel here another pixel"},{"startTime":664.919,"endTime":670.319,"body":"here and a trace and what is a cat and"},{"startTime":667.919,"endTime":674.159,"body":"what is a dog it is also about you are"},{"startTime":670.32,"endTime":677.579,"body":"stealing Gears of choices"},{"startTime":674.159,"endTime":681.719,"body":"that ended in a picture there that pixel"},{"startTime":677.578,"endTime":683.578,"body":"there is not just like a RGB color that"},{"startTime":681.72,"endTime":686.82,"body":"picture that is there because this guy"},{"startTime":683.578,"endTime":688.5,"body":"lives 20 years on Art so you are"},{"startTime":686.82,"endTime":690.36,"body":"stealing more than that if you think"},{"startTime":688.5,"endTime":692.278,"body":"about it so that's that's the dangers of"},{"startTime":690.36,"endTime":694.259,"body":"this the the cholesterol is important"},{"startTime":692.278,"endTime":696.24,"body":"because obviously as we said the artists"},{"startTime":694.259,"endTime":698.819,"body":"don't necessarily understand the legal"},{"startTime":696.24,"endTime":700.2,"body":"ramifications but lawyers and judges and"},{"startTime":698.82,"endTime":702.0,"body":"and juries don't necessarily understand"},{"startTime":700.2,"endTime":703.14,"body":"how the art industry works and they"},{"startTime":702.0,"endTime":704.82,"body":"don't necessarily understand how the"},{"startTime":703.139,"endTime":706.559,"body":"technology works so what I thought was"},{"startTime":704.82,"endTime":708.72,"body":"interesting and and you shared this link"},{"startTime":706.559,"endTime":711.539,"body":"and we'll share a link in um in the"},{"startTime":708.72,"endTime":712.98,"body":"description but you mentioned in the"},{"startTime":711.539,"endTime":714.419,"body":"legal system they actually describe the"},{"startTime":712.98,"endTime":716.399,"body":"diffusion model"},{"startTime":714.419,"endTime":720.599,"body":"and they describe it as you said earlier"},{"startTime":716.399,"endTime":722.759,"body":"as a digital collage so if I don't want"},{"startTime":720.6,"endTime":724.379,"body":"to go too deeply into like neither of us"},{"startTime":722.759,"endTime":726.539,"body":"are lawyers and I don't necessarily want"},{"startTime":724.379,"endTime":728.879,"body":"to um essentially it might even affect"},{"startTime":726.539,"endTime":731.458,"body":"the court case in in some way but my"},{"startTime":728.879,"endTime":733.98,"body":"understanding is that the basis of their"},{"startTime":731.458,"endTime":736.559,"body":"basic argument is this is a digital"},{"startTime":733.98,"endTime":738.48,"body":"college and the way the way the the"},{"startTime":736.559,"endTime":741.119,"body":"diffusion model works is it takes a"},{"startTime":738.48,"endTime":743.879,"body":"complex image it breaks it down into"},{"startTime":741.12,"endTime":746.639,"body":"noisier versions and then rebuilds it"},{"startTime":743.879,"endTime":748.98,"body":"from the noise very much like jpeg"},{"startTime":746.639,"endTime":750.12,"body":"compression or MP4 compression if you"},{"startTime":748.98,"endTime":753.24,"body":"think about the temporal compression"},{"startTime":750.12,"endTime":755.039,"body":"that you have between frames in an h264"},{"startTime":753.24,"endTime":760.259,"body":"file that we're all kind of familiar"},{"startTime":755.039,"endTime":761.519,"body":"with I would think in this industry so"},{"startTime":760.259,"endTime":763.019,"body":"um in a very similar way it's taking"},{"startTime":761.519,"endTime":764.82,"body":"this image down obviously it may be"},{"startTime":763.019,"endTime":767.879,"body":"using multiple sources and not just one"},{"startTime":764.82,"endTime":770.82,"body":"image but all of those Source images are"},{"startTime":767.879,"endTime":773.519,"body":"something that somebody created and"},{"startTime":770.82,"endTime":775.98,"body":"distributed and freed and there is and"},{"startTime":773.519,"endTime":778.44,"body":"as our understanding is that neither"},{"startTime":775.98,"endTime":781.139,"body":"midnight the created submit Journey nor"},{"startTime":778.44,"endTime":782.459,"body":"the creators of stable diffusion have"},{"startTime":781.139,"endTime":784.32,"body":"actually"},{"startTime":782.458,"endTime":785.819,"body":"been very"},{"startTime":784.32,"endTime":788.579,"body":"um"},{"startTime":785.82,"endTime":791.0,"body":"what would you say very specific in"},{"startTime":788.578,"endTime":793.559,"body":"looking for images that are free to use"},{"startTime":791.0,"endTime":796.139,"body":"I mean you I mean if I if you're"},{"startTime":793.559,"endTime":797.638,"body":"creating a dnp I mean DMP artist yeah"},{"startTime":796.139,"endTime":799.019,"body":"will be familiar with this you go on to"},{"startTime":797.639,"endTime":801.18,"body":"Flicker and you you check the"},{"startTime":799.019,"endTime":803.22,"body":"permissions and you find photos that"},{"startTime":801.179,"endTime":805.559,"body":"have commercial use that the"},{"startTime":803.22,"endTime":807.18,"body":"photographer has said you can take this"},{"startTime":805.559,"endTime":809.518,"body":"you can cut it up and then you might"},{"startTime":807.179,"endTime":810.958,"body":"take some pictures of mountains and you"},{"startTime":809.519,"endTime":812.94,"body":"know just as that human artists could"},{"startTime":810.958,"endTime":814.319,"body":"potentially that DMP could potentially"},{"startTime":812.94,"endTime":817.38,"body":"be breaching copyright if you're just"},{"startTime":814.32,"endTime":818.879,"body":"taking anyone's photos yeah um it's no"},{"startTime":817.379,"endTime":820.32,"body":"different than if it's being done"},{"startTime":818.879,"endTime":823.578,"body":"automatically and you're just typing in"},{"startTime":820.32,"endTime":826.86,"body":"a prompt let's make Advocate uh"},{"startTime":823.578,"endTime":830.159,"body":"for a second uh this kind of another"},{"startTime":826.86,"endTime":832.079,"body":"father said it's not what the AI is not"},{"startTime":830.159,"endTime":833.958,"body":"what humans do learning and then"},{"startTime":832.078,"endTime":837.299,"body":"reproducing blah blah"},{"startTime":833.958,"endTime":838.879,"body":"because obviously AI it doesn't learn"},{"startTime":837.299,"endTime":840.838,"body":"basically just follow statistical"},{"startTime":838.879,"endTime":842.879,"body":"patterns and then recognize this"},{"startTime":840.839,"endTime":846.3,"body":"coherence and they repeat that we we"},{"startTime":842.879,"endTime":848.338,"body":"have a ingestion of data and if maybe be"},{"startTime":846.299,"endTime":850.979,"body":"that they you know we had a fight with"},{"startTime":848.339,"endTime":852.66,"body":"our girlfriend boyfriend or we don't"},{"startTime":850.98,"endTime":854.7,"body":"have breakfast we're a bit more angry"},{"startTime":852.659,"endTime":856.259,"body":"and then our stroke is a bit more weak"},{"startTime":854.7,"endTime":858.6,"body":"and you know there are many things when"},{"startTime":856.259,"endTime":861.299,"body":"we are seeing information from the world"},{"startTime":858.6,"endTime":862.86,"body":"we got a complex Machinery that"},{"startTime":861.299,"endTime":864.778,"body":"we don't even understand how to start"},{"startTime":862.86,"endTime":866.339,"body":"with you know we are close to send"},{"startTime":864.778,"endTime":868.439,"body":"Rockets to the moon but we don't know"},{"startTime":866.339,"endTime":870.779,"body":"anything about our brain I mean we know"},{"startTime":868.44,"endTime":872.579,"body":"about our rainbow we really are start to"},{"startTime":870.778,"endTime":874.679,"body":"transpire now for example there are many"},{"startTime":872.578,"endTime":876.059,"body":"studies that say that the best way of"},{"startTime":874.679,"endTime":878.638,"body":"learning and memorizing is through"},{"startTime":876.059,"endTime":881.479,"body":"emotions that's why we remember things"},{"startTime":878.639,"endTime":885.959,"body":"that they are related with drama or Joy"},{"startTime":881.48,"endTime":888.12,"body":"than random book of History you know"},{"startTime":885.958,"endTime":890.099,"body":"because our emotions are involved in the"},{"startTime":888.12,"endTime":892.74,"body":"process of learning you don't need to"},{"startTime":890.1,"endTime":895.32,"body":"cheer up the machine AI to say come on"},{"startTime":892.74,"endTime":897.24,"body":"you are doing well to do better job or"},{"startTime":895.32,"endTime":899.459,"body":"you don't need to kill another Computing"},{"startTime":897.24,"endTime":901.56,"body":"in front of the machine AI to be sad and"},{"startTime":899.458,"endTime":903.239,"body":"then make better jobs the AI is gonna"},{"startTime":901.559,"endTime":907.219,"body":"work no matter what it's a process it's"},{"startTime":903.24,"endTime":910.519,"body":"a statistical process so but"},{"startTime":907.22,"endTime":913.62,"body":"that AI learns in the same way of humans"},{"startTime":910.519,"endTime":916.86,"body":"law is always written in the historical"},{"startTime":913.62,"endTime":920.339,"body":"context and the circumstances when"},{"startTime":916.86,"endTime":922.199,"body":"copyright law was created AI existed but"},{"startTime":920.339,"endTime":924.12,"body":"it was not something to consider at the"},{"startTime":922.198,"endTime":926.159,"body":"moment it was some modifications in"},{"startTime":924.12,"endTime":928.379,"body":"different countries per use case but"},{"startTime":926.159,"endTime":930.179,"body":"nothing like really to consider in a"},{"startTime":928.379,"endTime":931.62,"body":"bigger scale"},{"startTime":930.179,"endTime":934.259,"body":"um"},{"startTime":931.62,"endTime":935.459,"body":"take that example and let's imagine that"},{"startTime":934.259,"endTime":937.078,"body":"uh"},{"startTime":935.458,"endTime":940.379,"body":"as humans"},{"startTime":937.078,"endTime":943.5,"body":"our Revolution brought us big clothes"},{"startTime":940.379,"endTime":945.778,"body":"like knives that they can kill people"},{"startTime":943.5,"endTime":949.019,"body":"I can tell you that in a modern society"},{"startTime":945.778,"endTime":951.059,"body":"there will be laws about our big Nails"},{"startTime":949.019,"endTime":953.879,"body":"because they can kill people like you"},{"startTime":951.059,"endTime":955.979,"body":"need to cut your nails for example you"},{"startTime":953.879,"endTime":958.5,"body":"know where I'm going so the reason of"},{"startTime":955.98,"endTime":960.36,"body":"this argument is uh we need to"},{"startTime":958.5,"endTime":962.639,"body":"understand that if air is a trouble now"},{"startTime":960.36,"endTime":964.259,"body":"not because there is no law written"},{"startTime":962.639,"endTime":966.36,"body":"it means like you can do whatever"},{"startTime":964.259,"endTime":968.278,"body":"because law can have also retroactive"},{"startTime":966.36,"endTime":970.379,"body":"actions"},{"startTime":968.278,"endTime":972.958,"body":"um this means that now because AI has"},{"startTime":970.379,"endTime":974.639,"body":"the potentiality of doing this in mass"},{"startTime":972.958,"endTime":976.138,"body":"production that's the big difference of"},{"startTime":974.639,"endTime":978.0,"body":"doing a Photoshop and doing a copyright"},{"startTime":976.139,"endTime":980.459,"body":"infringement and copy pasting some"},{"startTime":978.0,"endTime":982.799,"body":"images with copyright or doing this in a"},{"startTime":980.458,"endTime":984.119,"body":"massive scale with also pixel"},{"startTime":982.799,"endTime":985.799,"body":"laundering which makes the things more"},{"startTime":984.12,"endTime":987.659,"body":"complicated because you are stealing"},{"startTime":985.799,"endTime":990.419,"body":"from billions or millions or thousands"},{"startTime":987.659,"endTime":994.198,"body":"so it's a gray area which definitely"},{"startTime":990.419,"endTime":996.0,"body":"needs regulation 100 and the loan is to"},{"startTime":994.198,"endTime":998.159,"body":"be adapted to this new historical"},{"startTime":996.0,"endTime":1000.019,"body":"context so that's why these argument is"},{"startTime":998.159,"endTime":1001.159,"body":"about all but I know this is not the"},{"startTime":1000.019,"endTime":1003.019,"body":"what did you see the copyright"},{"startTime":1001.159,"endTime":1004.639,"body":"infringement here well yeah because"},{"startTime":1003.019,"endTime":1006.62,"body":"you're longer in the pixels you're"},{"startTime":1004.639,"endTime":1008.659,"body":"mixing a lot you know if you're still"},{"startTime":1006.62,"endTime":1010.519,"body":"one pound from one million people it's"},{"startTime":1008.659,"endTime":1012.559,"body":"gonna be really hard to catch you"},{"startTime":1010.519,"endTime":1013.879,"body":"because stealing a very small amount of"},{"startTime":1012.559,"endTime":1016.578,"body":"money this is like when people Express"},{"startTime":1013.879,"endTime":1018.439,"body":"300 in in different accounts in"},{"startTime":1016.578,"endTime":1019.638,"body":"Switzerland and it's very hard to catch"},{"startTime":1018.44,"endTime":1022.16,"body":"them because they don't raise the bar"},{"startTime":1019.639,"endTime":1024.338,"body":"this is the same you are spreading so"},{"startTime":1022.159,"endTime":1027.859,"body":"much the infringement in so many parts"},{"startTime":1024.338,"endTime":1029.958,"body":"that who who who what is the copyright"},{"startTime":1027.859,"endTime":1031.879,"body":"infringement because in many in many"},{"startTime":1029.959,"endTime":1035.419,"body":"places for example if you want to report"},{"startTime":1031.88,"endTime":1038.48,"body":"a copyright infringement United Station"},{"startTime":1035.419,"endTime":1039.62,"body":"Etc uh you need to be the owner of the"},{"startTime":1038.48,"endTime":1042.338,"body":"copyright"},{"startTime":1039.619,"endTime":1045.678,"body":"to"},{"startTime":1042.338,"endTime":1047.119,"body":"report that but you see the"},{"startTime":1045.679,"endTime":1049.22,"body":"contradiction here"},{"startTime":1047.119,"endTime":1052.339,"body":"it's hard because there are thousands"},{"startTime":1049.22,"endTime":1054.798,"body":"you need to create systems in like a"},{"startTime":1052.339,"endTime":1056.899,"body":"action class like hey we all feel that"},{"startTime":1054.798,"endTime":1058.579,"body":"our work is being used so there are many"},{"startTime":1056.9,"endTime":1060.74,"body":"complexities and what I'm trying to say"},{"startTime":1058.579,"endTime":1062.24,"body":"is like we need to adapt to the current"},{"startTime":1060.74,"endTime":1063.259,"body":"circumstances and stop thinking about"},{"startTime":1062.24,"endTime":1066.679,"body":"the past"},{"startTime":1063.259,"endTime":1069.679,"body":"although there are specific cases where"},{"startTime":1066.679,"endTime":1071.62,"body":"um someone has specifically used the"},{"startTime":1069.679,"endTime":1075.919,"body":"prompt"},{"startTime":1071.619,"endTime":1077.659,"body":"a living artist a working artist I would"},{"startTime":1075.919,"endTime":1080.6,"body":"like some I've seen I really like this"},{"startTime":1077.66,"endTime":1082.759,"body":"portfolio I want to I want to create a"},{"startTime":1080.599,"endTime":1084.558,"body":"picture of a rabbit in the style of this"},{"startTime":1082.759,"endTime":1086.599,"body":"artist and then of course it's"},{"startTime":1084.558,"endTime":1088.339,"body":"generating that and clearly they've"},{"startTime":1086.599,"endTime":1090.74,"body":"specified the name of the artist and so"},{"startTime":1088.339,"endTime":1093.619,"body":"there are cases where this connection is"},{"startTime":1090.74,"endTime":1096.62,"body":"much is much more direct yeah and just"},{"startTime":1093.619,"endTime":1099.079,"body":"trying to to me that the debate is like"},{"startTime":1096.619,"endTime":1100.399,"body":"orbit I mean if you are like it's like"},{"startTime":1099.079,"endTime":1102.319,"body":"there is no even debate there's like"},{"startTime":1100.4,"endTime":1105.74,"body":"you're being a for my"},{"startTime":1102.319,"endTime":1108.439,"body":"excuse me that doesn't that that is like"},{"startTime":1105.74,"endTime":1110.96,"body":"you know like stupid"},{"startTime":1108.44,"endTime":1113.6,"body":"the I'm just trying even to to go into"},{"startTime":1110.96,"endTime":1115.64,"body":"the corner cases like uh gray areas"},{"startTime":1113.599,"endTime":1117.558,"body":"where people try to defend now with new"},{"startTime":1115.64,"endTime":1120.2,"body":"every week There's a new fallacy about"},{"startTime":1117.558,"endTime":1121.579,"body":"this and it's like dude you are you are"},{"startTime":1120.2,"endTime":1123.919,"body":"falling not in the argument you're"},{"startTime":1121.579,"endTime":1128.178,"body":"falling in the basic of logic logical of"},{"startTime":1123.919,"endTime":1130.16,"body":"of uh Greek philosophy of if it's big it"},{"startTime":1128.179,"endTime":1132.2,"body":"doesn't mean necessarily hey you know if"},{"startTime":1130.16,"endTime":1133.88,"body":"it's in the street it's raining in the"},{"startTime":1132.2,"endTime":1135.08,"body":"street is wet it doesn't mean because"},{"startTime":1133.88,"endTime":1136.94,"body":"it's raining it could be because someone"},{"startTime":1135.079,"endTime":1138.5,"body":"is cleaning the street so they are"},{"startTime":1136.94,"endTime":1141.32,"body":"failing in the basic concept when they"},{"startTime":1138.5,"endTime":1142.88,"body":"say oh but machine learning is is"},{"startTime":1141.319,"endTime":1145.099,"body":"learning like you oh but this is like"},{"startTime":1142.88,"endTime":1147.86,"body":"photography oh but what is the"},{"startTime":1145.099,"endTime":1150.439,"body":"difference of this and you using a AI"},{"startTime":1147.859,"endTime":1153.259,"body":"you know to do a new patch or something"},{"startTime":1150.44,"endTime":1155.058,"body":"it's like hold a second and I think"},{"startTime":1153.259,"endTime":1158.48,"body":"that's the important effort we should"},{"startTime":1155.058,"endTime":1160.22,"body":"put in in not trying to debate in the in"},{"startTime":1158.48,"endTime":1163.16,"body":"the higher standards but going to the"},{"startTime":1160.22,"endTime":1165.319,"body":"bottom and see what is the logic of this"},{"startTime":1163.16,"endTime":1168.5,"body":"argument you are trying to defend"},{"startTime":1165.319,"endTime":1171.439,"body":"because it falls you know"},{"startTime":1168.5,"endTime":1173.599,"body":"so I mean my wife always says that you"},{"startTime":1171.44,"endTime":1175.34,"body":"know the the people in England for"},{"startTime":1173.599,"endTime":1176.959,"body":"example don't study philosophy and that"},{"startTime":1175.339,"endTime":1180.319,"body":"she sees that they they need to study"},{"startTime":1176.96,"endTime":1182.48,"body":"logic and and that a lot of the failings"},{"startTime":1180.319,"endTime":1184.639,"body":"are just logical fallacies but"},{"startTime":1182.48,"endTime":1186.98,"body":"specifically in on this issue you"},{"startTime":1184.64,"endTime":1189.86,"body":"actually um posted an article where you"},{"startTime":1186.98,"endTime":1191.179,"body":"went through I think you chose 10"},{"startTime":1189.859,"endTime":1192.918,"body":"um I think I could bring it up if you"},{"startTime":1191.179,"endTime":1195.38,"body":"want or if you if you have it to handle"},{"startTime":1192.919,"endTime":1197.48,"body":"I remember we could go for it so you you"},{"startTime":1195.38,"endTime":1199.039,"body":"posted 10 specific fallacies I wonder if"},{"startTime":1197.48,"endTime":1200.96,"body":"we could go through those the most"},{"startTime":1199.038,"endTime":1203.24,"body":"popular one you mentioned is it's like"},{"startTime":1200.96,"endTime":1206.6,"body":"photography oh yeah they're photography"},{"startTime":1203.24,"endTime":1208.519,"body":"one I mean that's like I'm surprised"},{"startTime":1206.599,"endTime":1210.619,"body":"that they use this fallacy because I"},{"startTime":1208.519,"endTime":1211.94,"body":"think they just saw that in another post"},{"startTime":1210.619,"endTime":1213.558,"body":"and said oh I got now my winning"},{"startTime":1211.94,"endTime":1216.38,"body":"argument I'm gonna put this everywhere"},{"startTime":1213.558,"endTime":1219.259,"body":"and everyone is gonna love it but if you"},{"startTime":1216.38,"endTime":1221.9,"body":"see first there was no like a real fight"},{"startTime":1219.259,"endTime":1224.24,"body":"if you see historically seeing of"},{"startTime":1221.9,"endTime":1227.6,"body":"painters going against machine against"},{"startTime":1224.24,"endTime":1229.819,"body":"uh cameras and burning cameras and you"},{"startTime":1227.599,"endTime":1232.759,"body":"know I'm gonna show everyone that didn't"},{"startTime":1229.819,"endTime":1235.159,"body":"happen there was some friction like but"},{"startTime":1232.759,"endTime":1237.98,"body":"an artistic friction more like this is"},{"startTime":1235.16,"endTime":1241.519,"body":"hard or this is not r no one was saying"},{"startTime":1237.98,"endTime":1244.16,"body":"you are stealing our art you use the"},{"startTime":1241.519,"endTime":1245.9,"body":"camera to to portray the nature or the"},{"startTime":1244.16,"endTime":1248.12,"body":"world or humans but you were not going"},{"startTime":1245.9,"endTime":1250.34,"body":"with your camera to do picture of the"},{"startTime":1248.119,"endTime":1252.5,"body":"Mona Lisa and saying this is this is my"},{"startTime":1250.339,"endTime":1254.119,"body":"work this is the Mona Lisa now it's mine"},{"startTime":1252.5,"endTime":1256.4,"body":"because I make a picture that's the"},{"startTime":1254.119,"endTime":1259.459,"body":"first thing the second thing is like a"},{"startTime":1256.4,"endTime":1261.44,"body":"camera is gonna work by its own yeah"},{"startTime":1259.46,"endTime":1263.538,"body":"with its own mechanical pieces back in"},{"startTime":1261.44,"endTime":1265.88,"body":"the days I know it's digital but same"},{"startTime":1263.538,"endTime":1267.859,"body":"it's gonna work by its own maybe a bit"},{"startTime":1265.88,"endTime":1271.46,"body":"of software that maybe a little bit of"},{"startTime":1267.859,"endTime":1274.219,"body":"AI of on databases of Kodak or or Canon"},{"startTime":1271.46,"endTime":1276.86,"body":"but all internally and you don't need to"},{"startTime":1274.22,"endTime":1280.279,"body":"fit billions of images in a camera"},{"startTime":1276.859,"endTime":1283.759,"body":"to make it work uh with no permission"},{"startTime":1280.279,"endTime":1287.2,"body":"and no consent and no notification so"},{"startTime":1283.759,"endTime":1289.64,"body":"the the to me the camera fallacy is like"},{"startTime":1287.2,"endTime":1291.259,"body":"I could do better I can try better"},{"startTime":1289.64,"endTime":1294.559,"body":"fallacies I don't want to give them the"},{"startTime":1291.259,"endTime":1296.9,"body":"the the the tools but I I can't find way"},{"startTime":1294.558,"endTime":1300.139,"body":"better policies not to speak about the"},{"startTime":1296.9,"endTime":1301.4,"body":"horse versus cars it's like dude what"},{"startTime":1300.14,"endTime":1303.919,"body":"the hell are you talking about that's"},{"startTime":1301.4,"endTime":1305.419,"body":"even more hilarious like having said"},{"startTime":1303.919,"endTime":1307.28,"body":"that having said that about the horse"},{"startTime":1305.419,"endTime":1310.22,"body":"and the car I would say that"},{"startTime":1307.279,"endTime":1313.099,"body":"you know that we have Motorcars but we"},{"startTime":1310.22,"endTime":1315.14,"body":"have a lot of laws governing the use of"},{"startTime":1313.099,"endTime":1316.699,"body":"Motorcars we have speed limits we have"},{"startTime":1315.14,"endTime":1319.58,"body":"the requirement that you carry Insurance"},{"startTime":1316.7,"endTime":1321.259,"body":"the point we have um you you know you"},{"startTime":1319.579,"endTime":1322.699,"body":"can't you have limits on parking yeah"},{"startTime":1321.259,"endTime":1325.038,"body":"you have limits on where you can put a"},{"startTime":1322.7,"endTime":1326.419,"body":"road you have to pay Road tax"},{"startTime":1325.038,"endTime":1328.099,"body":"um there are all these different laws"},{"startTime":1326.419,"endTime":1330.259,"body":"there were also early laws for example"},{"startTime":1328.099,"endTime":1331.459,"body":"at the beginning of uh cars in England"},{"startTime":1330.259,"endTime":1332.72,"body":"they had this thing called the Red Flag"},{"startTime":1331.46,"endTime":1334.159,"body":"act where you actually had to have"},{"startTime":1332.72,"endTime":1336.44,"body":"someone walking in front of your car"},{"startTime":1334.159,"endTime":1338.6,"body":"carrying two red flags and waving them"},{"startTime":1336.44,"endTime":1341.12,"body":"so that you wouldn't run people over and"},{"startTime":1338.599,"endTime":1343.639,"body":"since then we've added traffic lights uh"},{"startTime":1341.119,"endTime":1345.879,"body":"you know double yellow lines uh box"},{"startTime":1343.64,"endTime":1349.4,"body":"Junctions all kinds of things that that"},{"startTime":1345.88,"endTime":1352.1,"body":"control and litigate the use of cars so"},{"startTime":1349.4,"endTime":1355.22,"body":"there was a problem when cars were just"},{"startTime":1352.099,"endTime":1358.339,"body":"zooming around with with the same laws"},{"startTime":1355.22,"endTime":1360.679,"body":"as Horses but at a higher speed and that"},{"startTime":1358.339,"endTime":1363.859,"body":"did require changes to the way Society"},{"startTime":1360.679,"endTime":1365.48,"body":"was organized and possibly"},{"startTime":1363.859,"endTime":1367.459,"body":"possibly not you know that's obviously"},{"startTime":1365.48,"endTime":1370.279,"body":"different in Holland has a different set"},{"startTime":1367.46,"endTime":1372.5,"body":"of priorities uh to the United States"},{"startTime":1370.279,"endTime":1374.298,"body":"where the United States"},{"startTime":1372.5,"endTime":1376.94,"body":"did everything to make the car the"},{"startTime":1374.298,"endTime":1378.98,"body":"priority and in Holland they decided to"},{"startTime":1376.94,"endTime":1380.538,"body":"make pedestrians a priority and the car"},{"startTime":1378.98,"endTime":1382.038,"body":"is"},{"startTime":1380.538,"endTime":1383.48,"body":"um is secondary so there are different"},{"startTime":1382.038,"endTime":1385.339,"body":"different ways of approaching these"},{"startTime":1383.48,"endTime":1387.558,"body":"these issues but every new technology"},{"startTime":1385.339,"endTime":1388.879,"body":"has required some kind of legal"},{"startTime":1387.558,"endTime":1390.74,"body":"framework"},{"startTime":1388.88,"endTime":1393.2,"body":"Okay so we've talked about photography"},{"startTime":1390.74,"endTime":1394.7,"body":"and the horse what's the next fallacy I"},{"startTime":1393.2,"endTime":1397.4,"body":"guess they again I but they already"},{"startTime":1394.7,"endTime":1399.319,"body":"mentioned this one how humans learn in"},{"startTime":1397.4,"endTime":1401.78,"body":"the same way that AI"},{"startTime":1399.319,"endTime":1404.96,"body":"I mean just don't repeat myself and to"},{"startTime":1401.779,"endTime":1406.879,"body":"summarize uh no that's not true they"},{"startTime":1404.96,"endTime":1409.038,"body":"want to make to look like that like hey"},{"startTime":1406.88,"endTime":1411.44,"body":"this is ice cream but just way faster so"},{"startTime":1409.038,"endTime":1412.519,"body":"what is the problem first is this way"},{"startTime":1411.44,"endTime":1414.74,"body":"faster"},{"startTime":1412.519,"endTime":1416.9,"body":"if you can learn to let the speed coming"},{"startTime":1414.74,"endTime":1419.058,"body":"back to the idea of how low is"},{"startTime":1416.9,"endTime":1421.038,"body":"contextual and historical if you can"},{"startTime":1419.058,"endTime":1422.658,"body":"learn with a glimpse about the world and"},{"startTime":1421.038,"endTime":1423.558,"body":"having that knowledge I can tell you"},{"startTime":1422.659,"endTime":1426.5,"body":"already"},{"startTime":1423.558,"endTime":1428.599,"body":"uh copyright will work different"},{"startTime":1426.5,"endTime":1431.0,"body":"I can tell you that if you are a machine"},{"startTime":1428.599,"endTime":1433.359,"body":"of learning you have for example uh"},{"startTime":1431.0,"endTime":1435.98,"body":"augmented the bio"},{"startTime":1433.359,"endTime":1437.719,"body":"or whatever tips in in your brain that"},{"startTime":1435.98,"endTime":1439.64,"body":"they are extended that's going to be"},{"startTime":1437.72,"endTime":1441.679,"body":"regulated because you saw the movie"},{"startTime":1439.64,"endTime":1443.72,"body":"kataka"},{"startTime":1441.679,"endTime":1446.12,"body":"I haven't actually seen it yet but I'm"},{"startTime":1443.72,"endTime":1448.4,"body":"sure it talks about transhumanism and"},{"startTime":1446.119,"endTime":1451.099,"body":"how technology separates Humanity"},{"startTime":1448.4,"endTime":1454.519,"body":"because now uh basically you can choose"},{"startTime":1451.099,"endTime":1456.319,"body":"your baby to be a smarter stronger and"},{"startTime":1454.519,"endTime":1458.48,"body":"better in many things you know a bit of"},{"startTime":1456.319,"endTime":1461.658,"body":"Nazi comparison there"},{"startTime":1458.48,"endTime":1463.7,"body":"um and and the Dilemma of if you can"},{"startTime":1461.659,"endTime":1466.64,"body":"learn to that speed"},{"startTime":1463.7,"endTime":1468.98,"body":"maybe you you know the copyright law"},{"startTime":1466.64,"endTime":1471.08,"body":"also works in the frame of what is fair"},{"startTime":1468.98,"endTime":1472.7,"body":"for the entire Market if you have"},{"startTime":1471.079,"endTime":1474.74,"body":"something that is able to break a market"},{"startTime":1472.7,"endTime":1476.72,"body":"that has millions of jobs"},{"startTime":1474.74,"endTime":1478.88,"body":"you mostly will have problems in the in"},{"startTime":1476.72,"endTime":1480.679,"body":"the legal frame at some point"},{"startTime":1478.88,"endTime":1481.64,"body":"um and I think need Journey know this"},{"startTime":1480.679,"endTime":1483.38,"body":"already"},{"startTime":1481.64,"endTime":1485.538,"body":"I was reading actually a couple of hours"},{"startTime":1483.38,"endTime":1488.96,"body":"ago the tens of conditions of my journey"},{"startTime":1485.538,"endTime":1491.44,"body":"like uh they are incredible and it looks"},{"startTime":1488.96,"endTime":1494.48,"body":"like written not I"},{"startTime":1491.44,"endTime":1497.779,"body":"looks written like a uh I don't know"},{"startTime":1494.48,"endTime":1500.36,"body":"like the nieces of someone or like I I"},{"startTime":1497.779,"endTime":1502.599,"body":"saw your I saw your post actually it's"},{"startTime":1500.359,"endTime":1505.099,"body":"quite funny yes it says like"},{"startTime":1502.599,"endTime":1507.019,"body":"someone else's intellectual property and"},{"startTime":1505.099,"endTime":1508.699,"body":"that costs money we're gonna come find"},{"startTime":1507.019,"endTime":1511.099,"body":"you and collect the money from you what"},{"startTime":1508.7,"endTime":1513.019,"body":"kind of money to do other stuff yeah I"},{"startTime":1511.099,"endTime":1515.24,"body":"should read it more in a sort of like uh"},{"startTime":1513.019,"endTime":1519.079,"body":"like The Sopranos right like what kind"},{"startTime":1515.24,"endTime":1520.94,"body":"of wording in a in a let's say Silicon"},{"startTime":1519.079,"endTime":1522.98,"body":"Valley company is that what kind of"},{"startTime":1520.94,"endTime":1524.84,"body":"wording is that and that tells you"},{"startTime":1522.98,"endTime":1527.419,"body":"already that can transpire the kind of"},{"startTime":1524.839,"endTime":1529.099,"body":"people is behind it I mean"},{"startTime":1527.419,"endTime":1531.08,"body":"I welcome technology I welcome"},{"startTime":1529.099,"endTime":1533.859,"body":"everything I work with technology every"},{"startTime":1531.079,"endTime":1538.158,"body":"day with AI machine learning uh"},{"startTime":1533.859,"endTime":1540.619,"body":"procedural tools uh but deal don't don't"},{"startTime":1538.159,"endTime":1542.059,"body":"lose the touch don't lose the touch with"},{"startTime":1540.619,"endTime":1544.459,"body":"the people and don't lose the touch with"},{"startTime":1542.058,"endTime":1546.859,"body":"the artists you are using for your"},{"startTime":1544.46,"endTime":1549.2,"body":"product don't lose uh the common sense"},{"startTime":1546.859,"endTime":1551.0,"body":"because I think it's a dangerous path in"},{"startTime":1549.2,"endTime":1553.159,"body":"the long term and we are in this the"},{"startTime":1551.0,"endTime":1556.339,"body":"last three years has become the"},{"startTime":1553.159,"endTime":1559.278,"body":"the the years of egocentric CEOs"},{"startTime":1556.339,"endTime":1561.678,"body":"everywhere with big dreams about saving"},{"startTime":1559.278,"endTime":1564.2,"body":"humanity and no one is asking for being"},{"startTime":1561.679,"endTime":1565.94,"body":"safe here you want to save Humanity yes"},{"startTime":1564.2,"endTime":1567.44,"body":"put the resources in other stuff no one"},{"startTime":1565.94,"endTime":1570.2,"body":"asks you to to do this kind of"},{"startTime":1567.44,"endTime":1572.6,"body":"generative or whatever that by the way"},{"startTime":1570.2,"endTime":1574.519,"body":"another fallacy is oh this is for"},{"startTime":1572.599,"endTime":1576.678,"body":"research purposes no this is not for"},{"startTime":1574.519,"endTime":1578.658,"body":"research purposes anymore you work one"},{"startTime":1576.679,"endTime":1580.46,"body":"year in research for research purposes"},{"startTime":1578.659,"endTime":1582.62,"body":"to to be able to collect data with no"},{"startTime":1580.46,"endTime":1586.88,"body":"legal implications but right now you are"},{"startTime":1582.619,"endTime":1589.519,"body":"you are charging your users and you are"},{"startTime":1586.88,"endTime":1592.7,"body":"adding even a business model that says"},{"startTime":1589.519,"endTime":1594.139,"body":"that you own the digital assets well"},{"startTime":1592.7,"endTime":1596.558,"body":"yeah it's like the same thing another"},{"startTime":1594.14,"endTime":1599.299,"body":"fallacy and this is a fallacy made by"},{"startTime":1596.558,"endTime":1601.879,"body":"with intention which is a scary by mid"},{"startTime":1599.298,"endTime":1605.119,"body":"Journey saying if you pay the business"},{"startTime":1601.88,"endTime":1606.08,"body":"fee or whatever is that you own the"},{"startTime":1605.119,"endTime":1609.079,"body":"assets"},{"startTime":1606.079,"endTime":1611.72,"body":"but owning the assets doesn't mean that"},{"startTime":1609.079,"endTime":1613.278,"body":"you have the copyright of the asset well"},{"startTime":1611.72,"endTime":1614.659,"body":"this this t-shirt is not a marble"},{"startTime":1613.278,"endTime":1617.359,"body":"teacher but I could have perfectly here"},{"startTime":1614.659,"endTime":1620.299,"body":"a marble to share and it's my t-shirt"},{"startTime":1617.359,"endTime":1621.918,"body":"with a Marvel logo is my t-shirt but"},{"startTime":1620.298,"endTime":1624.918,"body":"that doesn't mean now because I bought"},{"startTime":1621.919,"endTime":1626.72,"body":"this Marvel t-shirt and I now can you"},{"startTime":1624.919,"endTime":1629.0,"body":"know do marble products and say this is"},{"startTime":1626.72,"endTime":1630.98,"body":"a Marvel original that's that's right"},{"startTime":1629.0,"endTime":1634.099,"body":"and some people don't understand that"},{"startTime":1630.98,"endTime":1638.538,"body":"ownership is not the same that copyright"},{"startTime":1634.099,"endTime":1640.399,"body":"writes copyrights so I under and that's"},{"startTime":1638.538,"endTime":1641.9,"body":"the beauty of the world like I I don't"},{"startTime":1640.4,"endTime":1645.679,"body":"know how many people read this war is"},{"startTime":1641.9,"endTime":1647.36,"body":"lonely copy rights yeah you know this is"},{"startTime":1645.679,"endTime":1648.86,"body":"one of the good things about I guess we"},{"startTime":1647.359,"endTime":1652.579,"body":"got from German you can just stick words"},{"startTime":1648.859,"endTime":1654.619,"body":"together and make new words yeah yeah so"},{"startTime":1652.579,"endTime":1656.0,"body":"yeah that was I I again I've been back"},{"startTime":1654.619,"endTime":1658.339,"body":"and forth with fallacies every single"},{"startTime":1656.0,"endTime":1660.919,"body":"time I see one of them is like and it's"},{"startTime":1658.339,"endTime":1662.48,"body":"like a kind of shock like you you read"},{"startTime":1660.919,"endTime":1664.1,"body":"that and it's like okay something is not"},{"startTime":1662.48,"endTime":1665.72,"body":"right here and then you start to analyze"},{"startTime":1664.099,"endTime":1668.839,"body":"and it's like okay this is this is"},{"startTime":1665.72,"endTime":1671.12,"body":"stupid and the beauty of this is like uh"},{"startTime":1668.839,"endTime":1672.319,"body":"the the community or the AI browser"},{"startTime":1671.119,"endTime":1675.678,"body":"whatever you want to call it because"},{"startTime":1672.319,"endTime":1678.439,"body":"again I use AI but I try to use the"},{"startTime":1675.679,"endTime":1679.94,"body":"common sense they I think they are"},{"startTime":1678.44,"endTime":1683.36,"body":"running out of fallacies at some point"},{"startTime":1679.94,"endTime":1685.1,"body":"but I see the same like all fallacies in"},{"startTime":1683.359,"endTime":1686.839,"body":"the last two months"},{"startTime":1685.099,"endTime":1689.298,"body":"um and it's like this has been already"},{"startTime":1686.839,"endTime":1690.74,"body":"talked we we need to move forward to the"},{"startTime":1689.298,"endTime":1692.9,"body":"next state"},{"startTime":1690.74,"endTime":1695.9,"body":"um we maybe want to welcome Ai and"},{"startTime":1692.9,"endTime":1699.2,"body":"generative images at some point but we"},{"startTime":1695.9,"endTime":1702.019,"body":"need to discuss how with you know the"},{"startTime":1699.2,"endTime":1702.919,"body":"community that empowered this and to"},{"startTime":1702.019,"endTime":1704.119,"body":"start with"},{"startTime":1702.919,"endTime":1705.98,"body":"uh"},{"startTime":1704.119,"endTime":1707.959,"body":"um yeah another another interesting"},{"startTime":1705.98,"endTime":1710.9,"body":"thing I I think hiring for my company"},{"startTime":1707.96,"endTime":1713.179,"body":"because we need modelers um"},{"startTime":1710.9,"endTime":1714.919,"body":"um animator rigors and and the problem"},{"startTime":1713.179,"endTime":1718.1,"body":"of many platforms like you can't filter"},{"startTime":1714.919,"endTime":1720.08,"body":"AI so it's become really hard to find"},{"startTime":1718.099,"endTime":1723.199,"body":"Talent right now link and then never it"},{"startTime":1720.079,"endTime":1726.798,"body":"never works uh let's say uh a platform"},{"startTime":1723.2,"endTime":1728.179,"body":"uh empowered to Showcase art let's say"},{"startTime":1726.798,"endTime":1731.0,"body":"that I mean talking with LinkedIn people"},{"startTime":1728.179,"endTime":1733.58,"body":"as well and they know that but it now"},{"startTime":1731.0,"endTime":1735.74,"body":"it's it was extremely hard because uh"},{"startTime":1733.579,"endTime":1738.579,"body":"there was a mix of AI topics which I"},{"startTime":1735.74,"endTime":1741.679,"body":"appreciate but also AI"},{"startTime":1738.579,"endTime":1744.74,"body":"Whisperers or artists or whatever they"},{"startTime":1741.679,"endTime":1747.559,"body":"want to call themselves I because I was"},{"startTime":1744.74,"endTime":1749.9,"body":"quite involved in the topic of AI I only"},{"startTime":1747.558,"endTime":1752.119,"body":"got that fed in my"},{"startTime":1749.9,"endTime":1754.159,"body":"in my world so I couldn't see the"},{"startTime":1752.119,"endTime":1756.379,"body":"artists in the world there and it was"},{"startTime":1754.159,"endTime":1759.02,"body":"really really hard to find to hire this"},{"startTime":1756.38,"endTime":1761.299,"body":"time or to find this Talent so I end up"},{"startTime":1759.019,"endTime":1763.639,"body":"in the last two weeks to literally it"},{"startTime":1761.298,"endTime":1766.639,"body":"looks rude but every single thing I saw"},{"startTime":1763.64,"endTime":1768.32,"body":"a AI generative pose with images I just"},{"startTime":1766.64,"endTime":1770.899,"body":"needed to block that person"},{"startTime":1768.319,"endTime":1772.22,"body":"um remove the connection because first I"},{"startTime":1770.898,"endTime":1775.579,"body":"don't believe he's gonna bring me"},{"startTime":1772.22,"endTime":1778.278,"body":"opportunities in my field and second is"},{"startTime":1775.579,"endTime":1779.599,"body":"boring the real talent of artists they"},{"startTime":1778.278,"endTime":1782.119,"body":"are looking for a job and they have the"},{"startTime":1779.599,"endTime":1785.119,"body":"talent so I needed to do a proactive"},{"startTime":1782.119,"endTime":1788.0,"body":"exercise of filtering myself all the eye"},{"startTime":1785.119,"endTime":1789.459,"body":"in the platform so I just hope tools"},{"startTime":1788.0,"endTime":1794.298,"body":"like again Facebook"},{"startTime":1789.46,"endTime":1797.36,"body":"LinkedIn Twitter is able to filter or to"},{"startTime":1794.298,"endTime":1799.038,"body":"um somehow categorize what is AI and"},{"startTime":1797.359,"endTime":1801.139,"body":"what is not because you know Instagram"},{"startTime":1799.038,"endTime":1802.038,"body":"also is a place where you can hire"},{"startTime":1801.14,"endTime":1804.98,"body":"people"},{"startTime":1802.038,"endTime":1806.96,"body":"and sometimes I'm wasting time in"},{"startTime":1804.98,"endTime":1808.519,"body":"checking is this AI or not and you are"},{"startTime":1806.96,"endTime":1811.399,"body":"zooming in and it's like okay this is AI"},{"startTime":1808.519,"endTime":1813.98,"body":"next one if you pile up all these number"},{"startTime":1811.398,"endTime":1816.558,"body":"of minutes you you waste a lot of time"},{"startTime":1813.98,"endTime":1818.778,"body":"now finding talents and that is why the"},{"startTime":1816.558,"endTime":1822.74,"body":"reward of artestation was not only about"},{"startTime":1818.778,"endTime":1825.44,"body":"the no AI tag it was about dude if you"},{"startTime":1822.74,"endTime":1827.419,"body":"like so much AI do a AI station and put"},{"startTime":1825.44,"endTime":1830.48,"body":"all the AI there I'm trying to hire"},{"startTime":1827.419,"endTime":1832.278,"body":"concert parties now don't waste my time"},{"startTime":1830.48,"endTime":1834.2,"body":"on that you know what I mean don't don't"},{"startTime":1832.278,"endTime":1836.72,"body":"don't let everything in because then"},{"startTime":1834.2,"endTime":1838.819,"body":"it's not attestation anymore it's a tech"},{"startTime":1836.72,"endTime":1843.319,"body":"station or it's an area or a mixer"},{"startTime":1838.819,"endTime":1847.339,"body":"station yeah station and this actually"},{"startTime":1843.319,"endTime":1849.439,"body":"brings um one of the other the one of"},{"startTime":1847.339,"endTime":1851.538,"body":"the other fallacies that I I've heard"},{"startTime":1849.44,"endTime":1853.88,"body":"which is the idea that artists are being"},{"startTime":1851.538,"endTime":1856.278,"body":"elitist by"},{"startTime":1853.88,"endTime":1856.94,"body":"um trying to exclude"},{"startTime":1856.278,"endTime":1858.319,"body":"um"},{"startTime":1856.94,"endTime":1860.778,"body":"they're trying to so there's almost like"},{"startTime":1858.319,"endTime":1863.359,"body":"a form of discrimination uh that they"},{"startTime":1860.778,"endTime":1865.339,"body":"compare it to uh you know discriminating"},{"startTime":1863.359,"endTime":1866.778,"body":"against someone with disabilities that"},{"startTime":1865.339,"endTime":1868.519,"body":"you're you're saying because you can do"},{"startTime":1866.778,"endTime":1871.339,"body":"art you're excluding those people that"},{"startTime":1868.519,"endTime":1872.778,"body":"don't have that artistic ability"},{"startTime":1871.339,"endTime":1874.639,"body":"um I thought would be worth talking"},{"startTime":1872.778,"endTime":1876.919,"body":"about that because it's clearly not the"},{"startTime":1874.64,"endTime":1879.88,"body":"same thing I mean I I don't know a"},{"startTime":1876.919,"endTime":1882.679,"body":"profession that has been less liked that"},{"startTime":1879.88,"endTime":1884.72,"body":"let's put aside Banks is a modern art"},{"startTime":1882.679,"endTime":1886.88,"body":"okay because that's a niche of the other"},{"startTime":1884.72,"endTime":1890.778,"body":"and I can agree that kind of elitist but"},{"startTime":1886.88,"endTime":1894.679,"body":"art usage history I mean I've heard"},{"startTime":1890.778,"endTime":1897.5,"body":"anecdot in in uh in Augustine I was 12"},{"startTime":1894.679,"endTime":1899.899,"body":"years old in uh everybody back at the"},{"startTime":1897.5,"endTime":1901.398,"body":"school and I was writing uh I did rap"},{"startTime":1899.898,"endTime":1903.798,"body":"music and I was doing like a little"},{"startTime":1901.398,"endTime":1906.038,"body":"poetry song ramsing in the book on the"},{"startTime":1903.798,"endTime":1908.839,"body":"economic book and the teacher"},{"startTime":1906.038,"endTime":1910.339,"body":"near near me and was like what are you"},{"startTime":1908.839,"endTime":1911.24,"body":"doing it's like no I'm just writing you"},{"startTime":1910.339,"endTime":1913.158,"body":"know obviously I was not paying"},{"startTime":1911.24,"endTime":1914.96,"body":"attention to the class so she was pissed"},{"startTime":1913.159,"endTime":1917.72,"body":"off and she told me I got this in my"},{"startTime":1914.96,"endTime":1919.579,"body":"mind like artists end up starving you"},{"startTime":1917.72,"endTime":1921.679,"body":"know that she told me that you know what"},{"startTime":1919.579,"endTime":1923.24,"body":"what a teacher she told me that I was"},{"startTime":1921.679,"endTime":1925.399,"body":"like why shocked like oh artists are"},{"startTime":1923.24,"endTime":1927.019,"body":"very poor people so that's the image"},{"startTime":1925.398,"endTime":1929.239,"body":"actually and that's the real thing on"},{"startTime":1927.019,"endTime":1932.058,"body":"History like artists are not Elites are"},{"startTime":1929.24,"endTime":1936.919,"body":"actually people who are passionate that"},{"startTime":1932.058,"endTime":1938.538,"body":"they love to share is is respectfully uh"},{"startTime":1936.919,"endTime":1941.179,"body":"I myself"},{"startTime":1938.538,"endTime":1943.879,"body":"station your people are posting are for"},{"startTime":1941.179,"endTime":1945.919,"body":"free I mean that that's what happens and"},{"startTime":1943.88,"endTime":1947.778,"body":"it's not always to find a job sometimes"},{"startTime":1945.919,"endTime":1950.179,"body":"it's because we feel excited yeah"},{"startTime":1947.778,"endTime":1951.44,"body":"there's a bit of ego but I agree that if"},{"startTime":1950.179,"endTime":1955.34,"body":"you are an artist there is a little bit"},{"startTime":1951.44,"endTime":1957.558,"body":"of ego involved but ego a bit of figure"},{"startTime":1955.339,"endTime":1961.22,"body":"or self-esteem doesn't mean that you are"},{"startTime":1957.558,"endTime":1963.139,"body":"elitist I myself share my knowledge on a"},{"startTime":1961.22,"endTime":1964.94,"body":"stream six hours streaming showing all"},{"startTime":1963.14,"endTime":1966.32,"body":"the blueprints and all the work and"},{"startTime":1964.94,"endTime":1968.24,"body":"answering all the questions what the"},{"startTime":1966.319,"endTime":1969.678,"body":"hell are you talking about another thing"},{"startTime":1968.24,"endTime":1972.14,"body":"is your laziness that's another story"},{"startTime":1969.679,"endTime":1974.298,"body":"but that's not our problem man you know"},{"startTime":1972.14,"endTime":1976.88,"body":"and then the the accessibility or"},{"startTime":1974.298,"endTime":1979.639,"body":"disability in art clearly they don't"},{"startTime":1976.88,"endTime":1982.46,"body":"know about history of art or Frida Kahlo"},{"startTime":1979.64,"endTime":1984.74,"body":"or Van Gogh or Beethoven what the"},{"startTime":1982.46,"endTime":1986.899,"body":"that's open working music almost deaf"},{"startTime":1984.74,"endTime":1988.88,"body":"Goya got a sickness that was when he did"},{"startTime":1986.898,"endTime":1991.278,"body":"the black painting was was dying"},{"startTime":1988.88,"endTime":1993.559,"body":"there and he did art with suffering and"},{"startTime":1991.278,"endTime":1996.679,"body":"pain people pain with feet if"},{"startTime":1993.558,"endTime":1999.918,"body":"they need to Art is not about"},{"startTime":1996.679,"endTime":2001.84,"body":"the result is about the the Journey of"},{"startTime":1999.919,"endTime":2003.88,"body":"being able to do something"},{"startTime":2001.839,"endTime":2007.0,"body":"are you talk are you telling me that now"},{"startTime":2003.88,"endTime":2008.919,"body":"if someone can type a prompt trust me"},{"startTime":2007.0,"endTime":2012.398,"body":"they will find ways of expressing even"},{"startTime":2008.919,"endTime":2014.278,"body":"better than that even better than that I"},{"startTime":2012.398,"endTime":2017.199,"body":"can feel more excitement on a kid"},{"startTime":2014.278,"endTime":2020.14,"body":"drawing on a paper"},{"startTime":2017.2,"endTime":2021.94,"body":"that typing realistic that they don't"},{"startTime":2020.14,"endTime":2025.179,"body":"know you what that means you know what I"},{"startTime":2021.94,"endTime":2026.919,"body":"mean so it's that's another that's a"},{"startTime":2025.179,"endTime":2029.32,"body":"kind of insulting fallacy because they"},{"startTime":2026.919,"endTime":2031.778,"body":"are trying to appeal to that we are"},{"startTime":2029.319,"endTime":2034.298,"body":"heartless or we don't care about"},{"startTime":2031.778,"endTime":2036.579,"body":"accessibility and and that's a kind of"},{"startTime":2034.298,"endTime":2039.22,"body":"inferious one because it's like dude you"},{"startTime":2036.579,"endTime":2041.74,"body":"are on the on the anti-position on the"},{"startTime":2039.22,"endTime":2044.38,"body":"opposite of what we really are as a"},{"startTime":2041.74,"endTime":2045.278,"body":"community and historically speaking you"},{"startTime":2044.38,"endTime":2047.32,"body":"know"},{"startTime":2045.278,"endTime":2049.96,"body":"could be some people if you do if you"},{"startTime":2047.319,"endTime":2051.519,"body":"post a bad drawing you're you're gonna"},{"startTime":2049.96,"endTime":2052.96,"body":"you're gonna critique it but you're"},{"startTime":2051.519,"endTime":2056.398,"body":"gonna be"},{"startTime":2052.96,"endTime":2059.139,"body":"supportive yeah"},{"startTime":2056.398,"endTime":2060.94,"body":"critique or or but that's not a"},{"startTime":2059.139,"endTime":2062.5,"body":"gatekeeper that's actually you know"},{"startTime":2060.94,"endTime":2066.398,"body":"there are good feedback but feedback"},{"startTime":2062.5,"endTime":2070.418,"body":"whatever but this kind of uh portraying"},{"startTime":2066.398,"endTime":2071.98,"body":"uh artists Gatekeepers dude now"},{"startTime":2070.418,"endTime":2075.519,"body":"technology"},{"startTime":2071.98,"endTime":2077.858,"body":"has been a gatekeeper well known in the"},{"startTime":2075.519,"endTime":2080.98,"body":"big tech companies you think the Google"},{"startTime":2077.858,"endTime":2083.079,"body":"Google code is shared with Microsoft and"},{"startTime":2080.98,"endTime":2084.94,"body":"Microsoft shares with meta"},{"startTime":2083.079,"endTime":2086.559,"body":"they are Gatekeepers they are actually"},{"startTime":2084.94,"endTime":2088.599,"body":"they get Keepers because they know there"},{"startTime":2086.559,"endTime":2090.159,"body":"is a big portion of the market there and"},{"startTime":2088.599,"endTime":2093.639,"body":"the one that kids with the best AI"},{"startTime":2090.159,"endTime":2095.019,"body":"generative text or search engine"},{"startTime":2093.639,"endTime":2098.619,"body":"it's going to take the entire Market"},{"startTime":2095.019,"endTime":2100.96,"body":"it's all in so don't don't focus on us"},{"startTime":2098.619,"endTime":2104.32,"body":"about gatekeeper because taking a"},{"startTime":2100.96,"endTime":2106.78,"body":"grabbing a pencil is anyone can buy a"},{"startTime":2104.32,"endTime":2108.338,"body":"one half a dollar pencil and everyone"},{"startTime":2106.78,"endTime":2110.76,"body":"can take a paper and you know you can"},{"startTime":2108.338,"endTime":2113.259,"body":"draw in the in the works of your"},{"startTime":2110.76,"endTime":2115.66,"body":"in the works of their rooms I mean it's"},{"startTime":2113.26,"endTime":2117.64,"body":"like it's just it's another it's a big"},{"startTime":2115.659,"endTime":2119.5,"body":"one it's not a"},{"startTime":2117.639,"endTime":2121.059,"body":"it's a big fallacy there is no even how"},{"startTime":2119.5,"endTime":2123.338,"body":"to take that"},{"startTime":2121.059,"endTime":2125.199,"body":"campers"},{"startTime":2123.338,"endTime":2129.519,"body":"and"},{"startTime":2125.199,"endTime":2131.679,"body":"so I get angry I guess sometimes it's"},{"startTime":2129.519,"endTime":2134.019,"body":"like oh my God this is It's a passion I"},{"startTime":2131.679,"endTime":2136.0,"body":"mean it's a passion has have you felt"},{"startTime":2134.019,"endTime":2137.8,"body":"that sort of uh working on this issue"},{"startTime":2136.0,"endTime":2139.539,"body":"has taken away time because obviously"},{"startTime":2137.8,"endTime":2141.94,"body":"you're running a business you've started"},{"startTime":2139.539,"endTime":2144.639,"body":"the business yeah yeah indeed my"},{"startTime":2141.94,"endTime":2146.5,"body":"girlfriend already it was on Christmas I"},{"startTime":2144.639,"endTime":2148.779,"body":"was a bit away from work so I got the"},{"startTime":2146.5,"endTime":2151.42,"body":"tablet and I got and it's like oh and"},{"startTime":2148.78,"endTime":2153.28,"body":"this is happening now uh but I also told"},{"startTime":2151.42,"endTime":2155.2,"body":"my girlfriend like"},{"startTime":2153.28,"endTime":2157.359,"body":"whatever we do now is going to Define"},{"startTime":2155.199,"endTime":2159.279,"body":"many things in the future and this is"},{"startTime":2157.358,"endTime":2162.219,"body":"not about fear about losing my job I"},{"startTime":2159.28,"endTime":2163.599,"body":"draw like I drove I should be the"},{"startTime":2162.219,"endTime":2167.019,"body":"last one worried about this I can't use"},{"startTime":2163.599,"endTime":2169.9,"body":"AI to don't hide concept artists uh I"},{"startTime":2167.019,"endTime":2173.619,"body":"could be the first one right now but to"},{"startTime":2169.9,"endTime":2176.8,"body":"me uh it was like again like I always"},{"startTime":2173.619,"endTime":2178.0,"body":"end up by in companies in the effects as"},{"startTime":2176.8,"endTime":2181.839,"body":"well"},{"startTime":2178.0,"endTime":2184.659,"body":"um I I maybe it's a Spaniard Legacy or"},{"startTime":2181.838,"endTime":2187.0,"body":"something I can't I can't stop talking"},{"startTime":2184.659,"endTime":2189.759,"body":"if I feel something is not right and I"},{"startTime":2187.0,"endTime":2192.76,"body":"don't want to see myself as uh trying to"},{"startTime":2189.76,"endTime":2194.8,"body":"defend it's just even maybe my ego like"},{"startTime":2192.76,"endTime":2198.04,"body":"if I see something wrong it's like deal"},{"startTime":2194.8,"endTime":2199.78,"body":"shut the f because this is not correct"},{"startTime":2198.039,"endTime":2201.639,"body":"um and that's why I started to take a"},{"startTime":2199.78,"endTime":2203.68,"body":"bit of my time"},{"startTime":2201.639,"endTime":2205.719,"body":"um and because I knew I was going to end"},{"startTime":2203.679,"endTime":2207.759,"body":"up in some debates with people I I"},{"startTime":2205.719,"endTime":2210.399,"body":"talked with people from stability Fusion"},{"startTime":2207.76,"endTime":2212.5,"body":"we perform a journey developers uh other"},{"startTime":2210.4,"endTime":2214.24,"body":"programmers to understand better I knew"},{"startTime":2212.5,"endTime":2216.219,"body":"I was going to have some debates so I"},{"startTime":2214.239,"endTime":2218.799,"body":"not also spend time on social media"},{"startTime":2216.219,"endTime":2222.699,"body":"about arguing but also about studying"},{"startTime":2218.8,"endTime":2224.38,"body":"law and diffusion models basically a bit"},{"startTime":2222.699,"endTime":2225.879,"body":"at least to have the basic knowledge of"},{"startTime":2224.38,"endTime":2227.44,"body":"understanding until what point is"},{"startTime":2225.88,"endTime":2230.079,"body":"stealing or not"},{"startTime":2227.44,"endTime":2231.76,"body":"uh so yeah it took time but now that I"},{"startTime":2230.079,"endTime":2234.76,"body":"got the picture now the things are"},{"startTime":2231.76,"endTime":2237.28,"body":"rolling by its own it's like you do the"},{"startTime":2234.76,"endTime":2239.2,"body":"first push of the car and now things are"},{"startTime":2237.28,"endTime":2241.06,"body":"now like in a good page we need to keep"},{"startTime":2239.199,"endTime":2242.739,"body":"fighting of course no one needs to relax"},{"startTime":2241.059,"endTime":2244.9,"body":"right now but there are good news"},{"startTime":2242.739,"endTime":2247.539,"body":"happening we saw the action suit the"},{"startTime":2244.9,"endTime":2250.48,"body":"action classes already happening and we"},{"startTime":2247.539,"endTime":2251.32,"body":"saw media like vert said the wired media"},{"startTime":2250.48,"endTime":2253.659,"body":"is"},{"startTime":2251.32,"endTime":2255.7,"body":"we are happy that milia is actually not"},{"startTime":2253.659,"endTime":2258.039,"body":"in our favor or not it's more like it's"},{"startTime":2255.699,"endTime":2260.019,"body":"involved that's enough being involved is"},{"startTime":2258.039,"endTime":2262.358,"body":"all what we need later they can have"},{"startTime":2260.019,"endTime":2264.94,"body":"their opinion or columnist but at least"},{"startTime":2262.358,"endTime":2267.519,"body":"they are involved and we see our"},{"startTime":2264.94,"endTime":2272.139,"body":"community quite United"},{"startTime":2267.519,"endTime":2273.82,"body":"from every kind of uh tragedy or circus"},{"startTime":2272.139,"endTime":2275.019,"body":"time but circumstances we can always"},{"startTime":2273.82,"endTime":2277.78,"body":"find"},{"startTime":2275.019,"endTime":2280.239,"body":"uh you know that kind of good thing that"},{"startTime":2277.78,"endTime":2282.94,"body":"emanated from this circumstances and I I"},{"startTime":2280.239,"endTime":2286.118,"body":"never seen our community maybe when the"},{"startTime":2282.94,"endTime":2289.96,"body":"green uh chromas happened like years ago"},{"startTime":2286.119,"endTime":2292.3,"body":"with the Life of Pi or uh the Ukraine"},{"startTime":2289.96,"endTime":2295.119,"body":"war as well the our community just"},{"startTime":2292.3,"endTime":2298.0,"body":"reacted very well but this one is crazy"},{"startTime":2295.119,"endTime":2301.119,"body":"the AI the score now I think is no AI"},{"startTime":2298.0,"endTime":2303.88,"body":"disco is over I don't know 15 000 or 10"},{"startTime":2301.119,"endTime":2307.3,"body":"000. last time one month ago was was 10K"},{"startTime":2303.88,"endTime":2310.96,"body":"and it's growing it's quite United so it"},{"startTime":2307.3,"endTime":2313.42,"body":"took time but now I feel like uh okay"},{"startTime":2310.96,"endTime":2315.22,"body":"you can step away a bit you don't need"},{"startTime":2313.42,"endTime":2316.599,"body":"to I just remove all the connections of"},{"startTime":2315.219,"endTime":2318.759,"body":"AI so"},{"startTime":2316.599,"endTime":2320.14,"body":"you know and it was a smile because I I"},{"startTime":2318.76,"endTime":2321.64,"body":"checked today what they are doing they"},{"startTime":2320.139,"endTime":2324.338,"body":"still with the same Loop so"},{"startTime":2321.639,"endTime":2327.639,"body":"whatever and they will find the reality"},{"startTime":2324.338,"endTime":2331.838,"body":"at some point in their life I hope so"},{"startTime":2327.639,"endTime":2333.639,"body":"so okay so let's um let's go a bit about"},{"startTime":2331.838,"endTime":2335.98,"body":"what um"},{"startTime":2333.639,"endTime":2338.799,"body":"do you know who how do you feel the the"},{"startTime":2335.98,"endTime":2340.9,"body":"no AI movement began"},{"startTime":2338.8,"endTime":2344.14,"body":"because obviously people were angry and"},{"startTime":2340.9,"endTime":2347.079,"body":"annoyed but there was this is clearly a"},{"startTime":2344.139,"endTime":2348.519,"body":"yeah in some sense coordinated people"},{"startTime":2347.079,"endTime":2350.8,"body":"have have actually began working"},{"startTime":2348.519,"endTime":2354.099,"body":"together in it you know in a not"},{"startTime":2350.8,"endTime":2355.9,"body":"completely disorganized way I believe if"},{"startTime":2354.099,"endTime":2357.519,"body":"I need to record because I I think for"},{"startTime":2355.9,"endTime":2361.119,"body":"everyone I started in a different moment"},{"startTime":2357.519,"endTime":2363.639,"body":"but I think the trigger was to see uh"},{"startTime":2361.119,"endTime":2366.099,"body":"one specific post this is my opinion or"},{"startTime":2363.639,"endTime":2367.659,"body":"my perception one specific post that"},{"startTime":2366.099,"endTime":2371.619,"body":"went to the main page"},{"startTime":2367.659,"endTime":2373.659,"body":"ant station and was AI generated"},{"startTime":2371.619,"endTime":2375.46,"body":"and each one I started to see this kind"},{"startTime":2373.659,"endTime":2377.019,"body":"of no AI I can't remember the artists"},{"startTime":2375.46,"endTime":2378.94,"body":"I'm going to be very bad with names but"},{"startTime":2377.019,"endTime":2381.159,"body":"there was one artist I didn't know AI"},{"startTime":2378.94,"endTime":2385.119,"body":"logo first time and then I started to"},{"startTime":2381.159,"endTime":2387.098,"body":"see that after this uh AI in the"},{"startTime":2385.119,"endTime":2390.82,"body":"community which is when you see"},{"startTime":2387.099,"endTime":2394.359,"body":"sometimes and there was one big Ai No AI"},{"startTime":2390.82,"endTime":2398.68,"body":"were there in a big frame proportion on"},{"startTime":2394.358,"endTime":2401.019,"body":"Art station so I think that click that"},{"startTime":2398.679,"endTime":2402.519,"body":"contradiction like it's like a slap in"},{"startTime":2401.019,"endTime":2404.079,"body":"the face it has something maybe that"},{"startTime":2402.519,"endTime":2406.42,"body":"happens in the smaller spaces here and"},{"startTime":2404.079,"endTime":2408.88,"body":"there is like whatever but seeing this"},{"startTime":2406.42,"endTime":2411.22,"body":"like boring like literally it's so"},{"startTime":2408.88,"endTime":2413.019,"body":"humiliating you think about it the"},{"startTime":2411.219,"endTime":2415.48,"body":"proportion of the scale of the different"},{"startTime":2413.019,"endTime":2417.639,"body":"picture depending on how much engagement"},{"startTime":2415.48,"endTime":2420.699,"body":"they create and this is a fallacy made"},{"startTime":2417.639,"endTime":2423.159,"body":"by with intention which is a scary by"},{"startTime":2420.699,"endTime":2426.399,"body":"mid Journey saying if you pay the"},{"startTime":2423.159,"endTime":2427.659,"body":"business fee or whatever is that you own"},{"startTime":2426.4,"endTime":2430.66,"body":"the assets"},{"startTime":2427.659,"endTime":2433.299,"body":"but owning the assets doesn't mean that"},{"startTime":2430.659,"endTime":2434.858,"body":"you have the copyright of the asset well"},{"startTime":2433.3,"endTime":2436.24,"body":"this this t-shirt is not a marble"},{"startTime":2434.858,"endTime":2438.699,"body":"teacher but I could have perfectly here"},{"startTime":2436.239,"endTime":2441.879,"body":"a marble to share and it's my Edition"},{"startTime":2438.699,"endTime":2443.5,"body":"with a Marvel or his mighty shirt but"},{"startTime":2441.88,"endTime":2446.5,"body":"that doesn't mean now because I bought"},{"startTime":2443.5,"endTime":2448.358,"body":"this Marvel t-shirt and I now can you"},{"startTime":2446.5,"endTime":2450.4,"body":"know do marble products and say this is"},{"startTime":2448.358,"endTime":2452.559,"body":"a Marvel original product that's that's"},{"startTime":2450.4,"endTime":2455.68,"body":"and some people don't understand that"},{"startTime":2452.559,"endTime":2460.119,"body":"ownership is not the same that copyright"},{"startTime":2455.679,"endTime":2461.98,"body":"writes copy writes so I under and that's"},{"startTime":2460.119,"endTime":2463.539,"body":"the beauty of the world like I I don't"},{"startTime":2461.98,"endTime":2466.24,"body":"know how many people read this word is"},{"startTime":2463.539,"endTime":2469.019,"body":"lonely copy writes"},{"startTime":2466.239,"endTime":2469.019,"body":"you know"},{"startTime":2471.159,"endTime":2476.139,"body":"yeah yeah"},{"startTime":2473.219,"endTime":2477.519,"body":"so yeah that was I again I've been back"},{"startTime":2476.139,"endTime":2479.858,"body":"and forth with fallacies every single"},{"startTime":2477.519,"endTime":2482.5,"body":"time I see one of them is like and it's"},{"startTime":2479.858,"endTime":2484.0,"body":"like a kind of shock like you you read"},{"startTime":2482.5,"endTime":2485.26,"body":"that and it's like okay something is not"},{"startTime":2484.0,"endTime":2487.179,"body":"right here and then you just have to"},{"startTime":2485.26,"endTime":2488.44,"body":"analyze and it's like okay this is this"},{"startTime":2487.179,"endTime":2491.259,"body":"is stupid"},{"startTime":2488.44,"endTime":2493.3,"body":"um the beauty of this is like uh the the"},{"startTime":2491.26,"endTime":2495.28,"body":"community or the AI Pros or whatever you"},{"startTime":2493.3,"endTime":2498.76,"body":"want to call it because again I use AI"},{"startTime":2495.28,"endTime":2500.44,"body":"but I try to use the common sense"},{"startTime":2498.76,"endTime":2502.78,"body":"um they I think they are running out of"},{"startTime":2500.44,"endTime":2505.42,"body":"fallacies at some point but I see the"},{"startTime":2502.78,"endTime":2506.74,"body":"same like all fallacies in the last two"},{"startTime":2505.42,"endTime":2508.42,"body":"months"},{"startTime":2506.739,"endTime":2510.879,"body":"um and it's like this has been already"},{"startTime":2508.42,"endTime":2512.38,"body":"talked we we need to move forward to the"},{"startTime":2510.88,"endTime":2514.48,"body":"next stage"},{"startTime":2512.38,"endTime":2517.48,"body":"um we maybe want to welcome Ai and"},{"startTime":2514.48,"endTime":2520.78,"body":"generative images at some point but we"},{"startTime":2517.48,"endTime":2523.78,"body":"need to discuss how with you know the"},{"startTime":2520.78,"endTime":2526.839,"body":"community that Empower this and to start"},{"startTime":2523.78,"endTime":2530.32,"body":"with it doesn't work we are more monkeys"},{"startTime":2526.838,"endTime":2532.659,"body":"than uh altruists sadly I mean it's my"},{"startTime":2530.32,"endTime":2535.18,"body":"it's not like a negative Vision but"},{"startTime":2532.659,"endTime":2537.219,"body":"you're at sapiens or you see about the"},{"startTime":2535.179,"endTime":2538.838,"body":"biology and and you see that we are"},{"startTime":2537.219,"endTime":2540.759,"body":"still monkeys we just one day started to"},{"startTime":2538.838,"endTime":2542.559,"body":"walk into legs put some clothes and"},{"startTime":2540.76,"endTime":2544.96,"body":"within now we are smart but"},{"startTime":2542.559,"endTime":2547.0,"body":"mom in bad circumstances what is other"},{"startTime":2544.96,"endTime":2548.92,"body":"trust me people is gonna steal people is"},{"startTime":2547.0,"endTime":2551.559,"body":"gonna harass"},{"startTime":2548.92,"endTime":2553.659,"body":"uh people is gonna copy people is gonna"},{"startTime":2551.559,"endTime":2555.639,"body":"try to copy manipulate to don't look"},{"startTime":2553.659,"endTime":2557.379,"body":"like they copy it so"},{"startTime":2555.639,"endTime":2560.5,"body":"when all this happened is when the"},{"startTime":2557.38,"endTime":2562.599,"body":"things started to just go crazy like"},{"startTime":2560.5,"endTime":2565.9,"body":"and now I think it's more stable because"},{"startTime":2562.599,"endTime":2569.019,"body":"low finally a media finally is taking a"},{"startTime":2565.9,"endTime":2572.32,"body":"more uh a slow and well-cooked and"},{"startTime":2569.019,"endTime":2573.9,"body":"articulated uh Movement we also almost"},{"startTime":2572.32,"endTime":2577.599,"body":"hit the"},{"startTime":2573.9,"endTime":2580.3,"body":"270k needed for the for loving in in USA"},{"startTime":2577.599,"endTime":2584.2,"body":"the Europe go fund as well is about to"},{"startTime":2580.3,"endTime":2586.539,"body":"reach the maximum so things are built"},{"startTime":2584.199,"endTime":2588.338,"body":"and that's a good sign because I did"},{"startTime":2586.539,"endTime":2590.079,"body":"politics back in the days"},{"startTime":2588.338,"endTime":2592.48,"body":"um and one thing is dangerous about"},{"startTime":2590.079,"endTime":2595.24,"body":"politics and your"},{"startTime":2592.48,"endTime":2597.28,"body":"um arguments is if you look very angry"},{"startTime":2595.239,"endTime":2599.078,"body":"all the time that's perfect because you"},{"startTime":2597.28,"endTime":2600.579,"body":"look like an angry artist and they put"},{"startTime":2599.079,"endTime":2603.16,"body":"you in the corner"},{"startTime":2600.579,"endTime":2605.98,"body":"so the fight is solved I would not obey"},{"startTime":2603.159,"endTime":2608.799,"body":"the the the motion should start to"},{"startTime":2605.98,"endTime":2611.38,"body":"translate into actions little by little"},{"startTime":2608.8,"endTime":2613.72,"body":"and we can start debate about if this is"},{"startTime":2611.38,"endTime":2617.26,"body":"something that is you know like bad or"},{"startTime":2613.719,"endTime":2619.659,"body":"or we can call out but we need just to"},{"startTime":2617.26,"endTime":2624.099,"body":"maybe Reserve that energies into"},{"startTime":2619.659,"endTime":2627.639,"body":"uh educating ourselves uh getting ready"},{"startTime":2624.099,"endTime":2629.98,"body":"um prepare low action suits prepare uh"},{"startTime":2627.639,"endTime":2632.199,"body":"talking with a lawyer prepare uh knowing"},{"startTime":2629.98,"endTime":2634.42,"body":"about the how this technology works"},{"startTime":2632.199,"endTime":2636.039,"body":"and I think that's already happening so"},{"startTime":2634.42,"endTime":2637.539,"body":"that's in general good news I just did"},{"startTime":2636.039,"endTime":2638.739,"body":"that kind of summary of what I felt in"},{"startTime":2637.539,"endTime":2641.858,"body":"the last two months I think we already"},{"startTime":2638.739,"endTime":2643.779,"body":"in Plateau but it's a good Plateau I"},{"startTime":2641.858,"endTime":2646.119,"body":"think it's a good moment now the view is"},{"startTime":2643.78,"endTime":2648.4,"body":"very much a kind of Lord of the Flies"},{"startTime":2646.119,"endTime":2650.318,"body":"view of humanity which I don't"},{"startTime":2648.4,"endTime":2653.079,"body":"necessarily agree with I mean even"},{"startTime":2650.318,"endTime":2656.019,"body":"within animals you get some sort of"},{"startTime":2653.079,"endTime":2658.78,"body":"altruistic action so even if we are"},{"startTime":2656.019,"endTime":2661.719,"body":"monkeys I mean if chimpanzees and bonapo"},{"startTime":2658.78,"endTime":2664.599,"body":"are closest relatives are quite nice"},{"startTime":2661.719,"endTime":2666.098,"body":"actually like they're it's hard because"},{"startTime":2664.599,"endTime":2668.2,"body":"there's chimpanzees and there's there's"},{"startTime":2666.099,"endTime":2670.78,"body":"bonapose and bonapose tend to be a lot"},{"startTime":2668.199,"endTime":2672.818,"body":"more passive a lot more uh collaborative"},{"startTime":2670.78,"endTime":2674.98,"body":"and chimpanzees can be a lot more brutal"},{"startTime":2672.818,"endTime":2678.099,"body":"so we you know we can have both of these"},{"startTime":2674.98,"endTime":2679.96,"body":"aspects in our makeup well I think you"},{"startTime":2678.099,"endTime":2682.42,"body":"are right is that you know you can't you"},{"startTime":2679.96,"endTime":2685.659,"body":"do need some sort of"},{"startTime":2682.42,"endTime":2687.28,"body":"social regulation yeah some kind of and"},{"startTime":2685.659,"endTime":2689.618,"body":"and some of this is not just going to be"},{"startTime":2687.28,"endTime":2692.079,"body":"legal because one thing I was thinking"},{"startTime":2689.619,"endTime":2693.76,"body":"is that we do talk about"},{"startTime":2692.079,"endTime":2695.98,"body":"using copyrighted images without"},{"startTime":2693.76,"endTime":2698.5,"body":"permission the the unfortunate aspect is"},{"startTime":2695.98,"endTime":2700.358,"body":"that we also produce a lot of work which"},{"startTime":2698.5,"endTime":2701.559,"body":"um where we don't own the copyright I"},{"startTime":2700.358,"endTime":2703.539,"body":"mean for example if you're a concept"},{"startTime":2701.559,"endTime":2706.0,"body":"artist and you work for Disney or Marvel"},{"startTime":2703.539,"endTime":2707.5,"body":"or any large company you are handing"},{"startTime":2706.0,"endTime":2710.98,"body":"over the copyright of that concept art"},{"startTime":2707.5,"endTime":2713.5,"body":"so in theory it's your choice a large"},{"startTime":2710.98,"endTime":2716.98,"body":"but in very large company could then"},{"startTime":2713.5,"endTime":2720.099,"body":"yeah use work from artists that they've"},{"startTime":2716.98,"endTime":2722.8,"body":"employed in the past and generate new"},{"startTime":2720.099,"endTime":2724.78,"body":"work in perpetuity yeah and this is you"},{"startTime":2722.8,"endTime":2727.18,"body":"know an issue that previously did not"},{"startTime":2724.78,"endTime":2728.44,"body":"exist because if they like your work and"},{"startTime":2727.179,"endTime":2730.719,"body":"they've wanted more of it they would"},{"startTime":2728.44,"endTime":2732.88,"body":"have to hire you again but in theory"},{"startTime":2730.719,"endTime":2736.179,"body":"they they could they liked your work"},{"startTime":2732.88,"endTime":2738.519,"body":"they generate an AI model based upon"},{"startTime":2736.179,"endTime":2740.858,"body":"your work that you've done for hire for"},{"startTime":2738.519,"endTime":2743.44,"body":"the past 10 years and they stop hiring"},{"startTime":2740.858,"endTime":2744.94,"body":"you so there are some issues where there"},{"startTime":2743.44,"endTime":2746.2,"body":"might be a moral argument against but"},{"startTime":2744.94,"endTime":2747.7,"body":"the legal argument's gonna be much more"},{"startTime":2746.199,"endTime":2749.618,"body":"difficult because in terms of copyright"},{"startTime":2747.699,"endTime":2752.858,"body":"ownership we're talking about ownership"},{"startTime":2749.619,"endTime":2755.2,"body":"buy a company and of course whenever we"},{"startTime":2752.858,"endTime":2756.94,"body":"sign up for a service or a social media"},{"startTime":2755.199,"endTime":2758.919,"body":"platform we click that button that says"},{"startTime":2756.94,"endTime":2761.2,"body":"I agree to the terms and conditions but"},{"startTime":2758.92,"endTime":2762.639,"body":"very rarely do people read all of them"},{"startTime":2761.199,"endTime":2766.239,"body":"no of course"},{"startTime":2762.639,"endTime":2768.159,"body":"um which also is is one thing like terms"},{"startTime":2766.239,"endTime":2770.5,"body":"and conditions if you start to see how"},{"startTime":2768.159,"endTime":2772.179,"body":"they are evolving the last five years uh"},{"startTime":2770.5,"endTime":2773.559,"body":"there is always like a summary of the"},{"startTime":2772.179,"endTime":2775.838,"body":"terms and conditions and then the"},{"startTime":2773.559,"endTime":2778.838,"body":"extended terms and conditions which is a"},{"startTime":2775.838,"endTime":2779.98,"body":"good practice for companies like hey you"},{"startTime":2778.838,"endTime":2781.599,"body":"don't need to read this but at least"},{"startTime":2779.98,"endTime":2783.039,"body":"know that we can use this we're gonna do"},{"startTime":2781.599,"endTime":2785.318,"body":"this and we're gonna do that I agree"},{"startTime":2783.039,"endTime":2787.719,"body":"with it okay yeah it's more reliable"},{"startTime":2785.318,"endTime":2790.9,"body":"like in the in the last 20 years the"},{"startTime":2787.719,"endTime":2794.199,"body":"terms and conditions were just a file of"},{"startTime":2790.9,"endTime":2796.358,"body":"legal circumstances that no one right of"},{"startTime":2794.199,"endTime":2797.439,"body":"course uh but I believe that that is"},{"startTime":2796.358,"endTime":2799.239,"body":"Gonna Change"},{"startTime":2797.44,"endTime":2801.818,"body":"um the the big difference even yeah"},{"startTime":2799.239,"endTime":2804.578,"body":"companies now can can"},{"startTime":2801.818,"endTime":2806.199,"body":"um produce your your content that you"},{"startTime":2804.579,"endTime":2808.78,"body":"work on you work on these companies like"},{"startTime":2806.199,"endTime":2811.779,"body":"Marvel Disney but"},{"startTime":2808.78,"endTime":2813.64,"body":"um first I think law is gonna come at"},{"startTime":2811.78,"endTime":2816.22,"body":"some point I don't see a big company"},{"startTime":2813.639,"endTime":2819.699,"body":"risking so much on that"},{"startTime":2816.219,"endTime":2822.699,"body":"a line of production is I think"},{"startTime":2819.699,"endTime":2824.98,"body":"companies get a lot about public opinion"},{"startTime":2822.699,"endTime":2828.399,"body":"because it's where money goes and back"},{"startTime":2824.98,"endTime":2830.079,"body":"slash is a dangerous thing I not know"},{"startTime":2828.4,"endTime":2832.18,"body":"how to position myself in the cancer"},{"startTime":2830.079,"endTime":2833.5,"body":"culture or not but it is true that"},{"startTime":2832.179,"endTime":2835.48,"body":"companies move"},{"startTime":2833.5,"endTime":2838.539,"body":"you know with hip depending on how the"},{"startTime":2835.48,"endTime":2840.818,"body":"public uh sees things in general even"},{"startTime":2838.539,"endTime":2843.519,"body":"the higher Fire actors and actors"},{"startTime":2840.818,"endTime":2845.559,"body":"depending on that I don't see and that's"},{"startTime":2843.519,"endTime":2847.659,"body":"why I also insist not just in the legal"},{"startTime":2845.559,"endTime":2849.88,"body":"but but also in the public opinion path"},{"startTime":2847.659,"endTime":2851.739,"body":"about AI not trying to manipulate people"},{"startTime":2849.88,"endTime":2854.318,"body":"about their eye but just giving them the"},{"startTime":2851.739,"endTime":2856.299,"body":"facts of what is going on if people feel"},{"startTime":2854.318,"endTime":2859.779,"body":"that something is not right"},{"startTime":2856.3,"endTime":2863.56,"body":"I don't know if um that's gonna hold"},{"startTime":2859.78,"endTime":2866.74,"body":"over time in big companies using AI for"},{"startTime":2863.559,"endTime":2869.44,"body":"generative images companies you say for"},{"startTime":2866.739,"endTime":2871.479,"body":"everything I keep them for a statistics"},{"startTime":2869.44,"endTime":2873.099,"body":"and see what new Netflix series is going"},{"startTime":2871.48,"endTime":2874.96,"body":"to be successful in the models and"},{"startTime":2873.099,"endTime":2877.3,"body":"prediction and research resistant"},{"startTime":2874.96,"endTime":2879.4,"body":"investment everyone everyone is used AI"},{"startTime":2877.3,"endTime":2883.68,"body":"I'm talking more about the idea of doing"},{"startTime":2879.4,"endTime":2886.24,"body":"a IP a new character a new Marvel hero"},{"startTime":2883.679,"endTime":2889.118,"body":"based on a prompt where you are gonna"},{"startTime":2886.239,"endTime":2891.039,"body":"put the style of someone there or you"},{"startTime":2889.119,"endTime":2893.8,"body":"are gonna try to use prompts that they"},{"startTime":2891.039,"endTime":2895.119,"body":"are somehow using already existing"},{"startTime":2893.8,"endTime":2899.14,"body":"Heroes"},{"startTime":2895.119,"endTime":2901.78,"body":"I don't see a company big one doing that"},{"startTime":2899.139,"endTime":2904.48,"body":"otherwise you can't use you can't do a"},{"startTime":2901.78,"endTime":2906.64,"body":"new superhero if you don't tell the AI"},{"startTime":2904.48,"endTime":2908.8,"body":"where to look at you know what I mean it"},{"startTime":2906.639,"endTime":2910.179,"body":"has a contradiction it's like in the"},{"startTime":2908.8,"endTime":2911.98,"body":"moment you put a prompt you are telling"},{"startTime":2910.179,"endTime":2913.419,"body":"the AI where should I look at should I"},{"startTime":2911.98,"endTime":2915.46,"body":"look at the station should I look at"},{"startTime":2913.42,"endTime":2919.18,"body":"Pinterest should I look a Canon camera"},{"startTime":2915.46,"endTime":2921.338,"body":"or IMAX maybe or Marvel you need somehow"},{"startTime":2919.179,"endTime":2922.838,"body":"always to go to this to this border"},{"startTime":2921.338,"endTime":2926.078,"body":"there so"},{"startTime":2922.838,"endTime":2929.019,"body":"yeah I mean some of the more interesting"},{"startTime":2926.079,"endTime":2930.039,"body":"stuff I ever saw anyone do using mid"},{"startTime":2929.019,"endTime":2932.739,"body":"Journey"},{"startTime":2930.039,"endTime":2934.239,"body":"yeah it's actually fictional films I I"},{"startTime":2932.739,"endTime":2934.959,"body":"I've gonna say something that I thought"},{"startTime":2934.239,"endTime":2936.578,"body":"was"},{"startTime":2934.96,"endTime":2939.579,"body":"actually kind of interesting that they"},{"startTime":2936.579,"endTime":2942.339,"body":"took for example that Star Trek was"},{"startTime":2939.579,"endTime":2945.16,"body":"based on a 1920s never produced German"},{"startTime":2942.338,"endTime":2947.858,"body":"movie made by weird slang and so it had"},{"startTime":2945.159,"endTime":2949.96,"body":"so this this fictional movie and they"},{"startTime":2947.858,"endTime":2952.059,"body":"they clearly wrote an actual background"},{"startTime":2949.96,"endTime":2954.519,"body":"story of this that fitzlang tried to"},{"startTime":2952.059,"endTime":2958.0,"body":"produce something that was called Star"},{"startTime":2954.519,"endTime":2960.28,"body":"Trek basically but in German and then uh"},{"startTime":2958.0,"endTime":2961.659,"body":"uh Anthony was never able to finish it"},{"startTime":2960.28,"endTime":2963.22,"body":"and that was the inspiration for Star"},{"startTime":2961.659,"endTime":2965.019,"body":"Trek and they created this fictional"},{"startTime":2963.219,"endTime":2967.299,"body":"story and then they had generated these"},{"startTime":2965.019,"endTime":2968.92,"body":"images in the style of Fritz slang which"},{"startTime":2967.3,"endTime":2970.96,"body":"were very much like Star Trek with a"},{"startTime":2968.92,"endTime":2973.72,"body":"spaceship and and these German"},{"startTime":2970.96,"endTime":2977.079,"body":"expressionist style actors and it was"},{"startTime":2973.719,"endTime":2980.019,"body":"based on obviously metropolis and and uh"},{"startTime":2977.079,"endTime":2983.22,"body":"oh yeah Star Trek itself so"},{"startTime":2980.019,"endTime":2986.858,"body":"I you know there was this interesting"},{"startTime":2983.219,"endTime":2989.139,"body":"that what it wasn't interesting use of"},{"startTime":2986.858,"endTime":2991.358,"body":"of something but of course they're still"},{"startTime":2989.139,"endTime":2994.239,"body":"taking images where I presume at that"},{"startTime":2991.358,"endTime":2995.858,"body":"point the the plaintiff would be clearly"},{"startTime":2994.239,"endTime":2997.379,"body":"Star Trek I mean if this is not if this"},{"startTime":2995.858,"endTime":3000.838,"body":"is not commercial and it's a Facebook"},{"startTime":2997.38,"endTime":3002.46,"body":"joke then it may have some use but it"},{"startTime":3000.838,"endTime":3004.318,"body":"can't you've still got mid Journey has"},{"startTime":3002.46,"endTime":3006.72,"body":"wider issues as we've been discussing"},{"startTime":3004.318,"endTime":3009.96,"body":"where material is just coming from all"},{"startTime":3006.719,"endTime":3012.779,"body":"over the place however uh that could be"},{"startTime":3009.96,"endTime":3014.818,"body":"a use uh right now uh I I rather prefer"},{"startTime":3012.78,"endTime":3016.68,"body":"to wait what uh law has to say"},{"startTime":3014.818,"endTime":3018.779,"body":"internationally about all this but it is"},{"startTime":3016.679,"endTime":3021.659,"body":"true that when the field settled down a"},{"startTime":3018.78,"endTime":3024.48,"body":"bit I believe that inspiration is a good"},{"startTime":3021.659,"endTime":3026.159,"body":"use of AI generative images hopefully"},{"startTime":3024.48,"endTime":3029.818,"body":"with"},{"startTime":3026.159,"endTime":3032.338,"body":"um a non-copyrighted material like I see"},{"startTime":3029.818,"endTime":3035.88,"body":"this kind of mix of I don't know Debbie"},{"startTime":3032.338,"endTime":3037.858,"body":"Fincher Meets World War Z3 and you mixed"},{"startTime":3035.88,"endTime":3040.559,"body":"the Star Wars or whatever and then it"},{"startTime":3037.858,"endTime":3043.019,"body":"spits out like this kind of Horror of"},{"startTime":3040.559,"endTime":3046.078,"body":"all these are images but at least"},{"startTime":3043.019,"endTime":3048.539,"body":"stimulates ideas like if I want to see"},{"startTime":3046.079,"endTime":3050.099,"body":"patterns of again everyone puts"},{"startTime":3048.539,"endTime":3053.4,"body":"Fibonacci some people I think discover"},{"startTime":3050.099,"endTime":3055.019,"body":"what is Fibonacci in the last year or"},{"startTime":3053.4,"endTime":3057.139,"body":"golden radio and things like some people"},{"startTime":3055.019,"endTime":3061.44,"body":"is reading the dictionary of art finally"},{"startTime":3057.139,"endTime":3062.639,"body":"uh okay that's that's a use of I can"},{"startTime":3061.44,"endTime":3064.44,"body":"it's the same way that you go to"},{"startTime":3062.639,"endTime":3067.019,"body":"Pinterest or third station and you put"},{"startTime":3064.44,"endTime":3069.78,"body":"in your purif work of others and you"},{"startTime":3067.019,"endTime":3071.88,"body":"check time to time no one in VFX I mean"},{"startTime":3069.78,"endTime":3074.099,"body":"myself I try to download preferences to"},{"startTime":3071.88,"endTime":3077.22,"body":"be honest just because I got my masters"},{"startTime":3074.099,"endTime":3078.359,"body":"uh when I learn art and I like how they"},{"startTime":3077.219,"endTime":3079.919,"body":"work they just take five minutes"},{"startTime":3078.358,"endTime":3081.96,"body":"references and they close Google and"},{"startTime":3079.92,"endTime":3084.059,"body":"they start working so you stimulate"},{"startTime":3081.96,"endTime":3087.119,"body":"memory and your your own connections"},{"startTime":3084.059,"endTime":3088.68,"body":"rather than AI hand connection but let's"},{"startTime":3087.119,"endTime":3090.66,"body":"imagine some people my girlfriend itself"},{"startTime":3088.679,"endTime":3093.299,"body":"like uses reference and had pure Rave"},{"startTime":3090.659,"endTime":3097.578,"body":"with a lot of work of Riot game blizzard"},{"startTime":3093.3,"endTime":3097.579,"body":"you know like copyright material uh"},{"startTime":3101.539,"endTime":3107.159,"body":"can work very nicely at least to"},{"startTime":3103.858,"endTime":3109.558,"body":"stimulate the first trigger like you saw"},{"startTime":3107.159,"endTime":3111.739,"body":"this Monty Python sketch where they"},{"startTime":3109.559,"endTime":3114.3,"body":"offer conversations rather than dinner"},{"startTime":3111.739,"endTime":3115.679,"body":"so you go to dinner and they offer you"},{"startTime":3114.3,"endTime":3117.42,"body":"want to talk about philosophy you will"},{"startTime":3115.679,"endTime":3119.46,"body":"prefer about politics and they offer a"},{"startTime":3117.42,"endTime":3122.7,"body":"menu of conversations I think it's a"},{"startTime":3119.46,"endTime":3125.119,"body":"good trigger to oh yeah something like"},{"startTime":3122.699,"endTime":3127.679,"body":"this and then you check that"},{"startTime":3125.119,"endTime":3130.5,"body":"a couple of prompts and then just start"},{"startTime":3127.679,"endTime":3132.899,"body":"working in your stuff but you don't you"},{"startTime":3130.5,"endTime":3135.599,"body":"don't use that material you just"},{"startTime":3132.9,"endTime":3137.519,"body":"put your take there the first and rough"},{"startTime":3135.599,"endTime":3139.619,"body":"cut of Star Wars"},{"startTime":3137.519,"endTime":3141.838,"body":"had footage from World War II so it"},{"startTime":3139.619,"endTime":3144.059,"body":"actually had pilot footage so one of you"},{"startTime":3141.838,"endTime":3146.818,"body":"know and the Trench Run was based on you"},{"startTime":3144.059,"endTime":3149.339,"body":"know the Dam Busters so it had actual"},{"startTime":3146.818,"endTime":3151.679,"body":"footage from World War II Pilots for the"},{"startTime":3149.338,"endTime":3154.139,"body":"dog fights they had no VFX for the"},{"startTime":3151.679,"endTime":3155.94,"body":"X-Wing they hadn't been produced yet so"},{"startTime":3154.139,"endTime":3157.618,"body":"they did this first edit with this car"},{"startTime":3155.94,"endTime":3159.358,"body":"and obviously"},{"startTime":3157.619,"endTime":3160.44,"body":"that was limited when they were showing"},{"startTime":3159.358,"endTime":3161.639,"body":"it to producers because a lot of"},{"startTime":3160.44,"endTime":3163.318,"body":"producers didn't understand it someone"},{"startTime":3161.639,"endTime":3165.118,"body":"like Spielberg in the audience was like"},{"startTime":3163.318,"endTime":3167.039,"body":"I love this this is gonna this is gonna"},{"startTime":3165.119,"endTime":3169.019,"body":"make a million dollars this can be"},{"startTime":3167.039,"endTime":3171.42,"body":"actually made a lot more than a million"},{"startTime":3169.019,"endTime":3173.159,"body":"dollars but this is meant to be you know"},{"startTime":3171.42,"endTime":3174.539,"body":"a massive success"},{"startTime":3173.159,"endTime":3176.94,"body":"um whereas a producer couldn't"},{"startTime":3174.539,"endTime":3179.159,"body":"understand it now you could imagine"},{"startTime":3176.94,"endTime":3181.2,"body":"but not for the final film but that that"},{"startTime":3179.159,"endTime":3183.719,"body":"would might be a YouTube AI could I"},{"startTime":3181.199,"endTime":3185.818,"body":"imagine My Starship fighting the way"},{"startTime":3183.719,"endTime":3189.058,"body":"like in these uh these World War II"},{"startTime":3185.818,"endTime":3190.679,"body":"dogfights maybe a kind of crappy image"},{"startTime":3189.059,"endTime":3192.359,"body":"but then you can show to production you"},{"startTime":3190.679,"endTime":3195.96,"body":"know if you've worked in VFX you know"},{"startTime":3192.358,"endTime":3198.119,"body":"exactly how many iterations we show you"},{"startTime":3195.96,"endTime":3200.22,"body":"know we know that that whole phase where"},{"startTime":3198.119,"endTime":3202.099,"body":"they're like I know what I want when I"},{"startTime":3200.219,"endTime":3205.618,"body":"see it and"},{"startTime":3202.099,"endTime":3207.78,"body":"you know I I could imagine it would be"},{"startTime":3205.619,"endTime":3210.838,"body":"great to to use something like AI for"},{"startTime":3207.78,"endTime":3213.0,"body":"that stage of the process of like okay"},{"startTime":3210.838,"endTime":3214.92,"body":"what like this I like that like this"},{"startTime":3213.0,"endTime":3217.559,"body":"like that and then we'll do it properly"},{"startTime":3214.92,"endTime":3219.838,"body":"yeah you're not still in"},{"startTime":3217.559,"endTime":3223.079,"body":"you are pitching and basically you can"},{"startTime":3219.838,"endTime":3225.599,"body":"even create jobs uh I think it's a smart"},{"startTime":3223.079,"endTime":3228.119,"body":"way of using that that's why I always"},{"startTime":3225.599,"endTime":3231.0,"body":"put in the headline no no it's not AI is"},{"startTime":3228.119,"endTime":3234.539,"body":"no to the unethical use of AI because"},{"startTime":3231.0,"endTime":3237.3,"body":"again going back to politics"},{"startTime":3234.539,"endTime":3239.94,"body":"the way you can get things done in"},{"startTime":3237.3,"endTime":3242.039,"body":"politics is not being against but being"},{"startTime":3239.94,"endTime":3244.98,"body":"in favor of something"},{"startTime":3242.039,"endTime":3247.5,"body":"but you define what exactly you mean by"},{"startTime":3244.98,"endTime":3249.179,"body":"that in this case let's use AI in a way"},{"startTime":3247.5,"endTime":3251.219,"body":"that doesn't affect artists doesn't"},{"startTime":3249.179,"endTime":3254.399,"body":"steal from artists"},{"startTime":3251.219,"endTime":3257.039,"body":"and doesn't break an entire economy in"},{"startTime":3254.4,"endTime":3262.92,"body":"the in the in the art field animation"},{"startTime":3257.039,"endTime":3264.838,"body":"and bfx video games card games you know"},{"startTime":3262.92,"endTime":3267.358,"body":"um and that's that's the exercise I"},{"startTime":3264.838,"endTime":3269.42,"body":"would say the exercise is not that and"},{"startTime":3267.358,"endTime":3273.779,"body":"it's hard because I understand I always"},{"startTime":3269.42,"endTime":3276.3,"body":"advocate of the idea of disrupt first"},{"startTime":3273.78,"endTime":3278.22,"body":"um build later"},{"startTime":3276.3,"endTime":3280.14,"body":"um otherwise people don't care"},{"startTime":3278.219,"endTime":3281.338,"body":"um this is the sadness of social media"},{"startTime":3280.139,"endTime":3283.019,"body":"sometimes you need to be a little"},{"startTime":3281.338,"endTime":3284.46,"body":"sensationalist or a little bit you know"},{"startTime":3283.019,"endTime":3286.858,"body":"like extreme"},{"startTime":3284.46,"endTime":3288.96,"body":"to be heard and then okay now that you"},{"startTime":3286.858,"endTime":3291.299,"body":"listen to me it's like hello I'm here"},{"startTime":3288.96,"endTime":3294.358,"body":"you scream people shut up and then you"},{"startTime":3291.3,"endTime":3297.72,"body":"start talking normal so I think now"},{"startTime":3294.358,"endTime":3301.219,"body":"people hurt us now we got the voice now"},{"startTime":3297.719,"endTime":3304.439,"body":"we can articulate better what we want"},{"startTime":3301.219,"endTime":3306.48,"body":"and if we do this a little bit aside of"},{"startTime":3304.44,"endTime":3309.179,"body":"emotions I think we are gonna get"},{"startTime":3306.48,"endTime":3313.26,"body":"further and farther and farther"},{"startTime":3309.179,"endTime":3318.118,"body":"because now the media eyes the legal"},{"startTime":3313.26,"endTime":3321.599,"body":"eyes are the AI eyes are from us and our"},{"startTime":3318.119,"endTime":3323.818,"body":"reactions and we need to look like we"},{"startTime":3321.599,"endTime":3326.94,"body":"are gonna fight for this with all what"},{"startTime":3323.818,"endTime":3329.4,"body":"we got and you are not gonna put us in"},{"startTime":3326.94,"endTime":3331.019,"body":"an emotional corner like luditis or"},{"startTime":3329.4,"endTime":3333.119,"body":"whatever they want to to tell because"},{"startTime":3331.019,"endTime":3335.759,"body":"the fight is going to be long but the"},{"startTime":3333.119,"endTime":3337.2,"body":"fight is fair and it will happen you"},{"startTime":3335.76,"endTime":3338.819,"body":"know historically I think in the"},{"startTime":3337.199,"endTime":3340.199,"body":"following years we will see changes in"},{"startTime":3338.818,"endTime":3341.88,"body":"low"},{"startTime":3340.199,"endTime":3344.399,"body":"um and that's my take that's why I'm"},{"startTime":3341.88,"endTime":3346.619,"body":"slowing down the emotional part because"},{"startTime":3344.4,"endTime":3348.539,"body":"in Christmas I was on fire I can't tell"},{"startTime":3346.619,"endTime":3352.079,"body":"you that I would like I was seeing so"},{"startTime":3348.539,"endTime":3354.0,"body":"many things I guess like man this is uh"},{"startTime":3352.079,"endTime":3355.38,"body":"but now it's like you know I've been"},{"startTime":3354.0,"endTime":3358.8,"body":"contacting Sherry dance I've been"},{"startTime":3355.38,"endTime":3360.3,"body":"contacting uh different lawyers I was"},{"startTime":3358.8,"endTime":3361.8,"body":"reading about different laws in"},{"startTime":3360.3,"endTime":3363.42,"body":"different countries and also stable"},{"startTime":3361.8,"endTime":3365.519,"body":"efficiency and this is my exercise and"},{"startTime":3363.42,"endTime":3367.68,"body":"it's the exercise I recommend to every"},{"startTime":3365.519,"endTime":3370.5,"body":"artist because I think it's quite"},{"startTime":3367.679,"endTime":3372.179,"body":"important to understand the model so"},{"startTime":3370.5,"endTime":3374.219,"body":"yeah so I hate to use a face we're not"},{"startTime":3372.179,"endTime":3375.539,"body":"ladies because I studied history and I"},{"startTime":3374.219,"endTime":3377.519,"body":"know that the luddites weren't"},{"startTime":3375.539,"endTime":3379.739,"body":"anti-technology themselves they were"},{"startTime":3377.519,"endTime":3382.8,"body":"Artisans who replaced by child labor"},{"startTime":3379.739,"endTime":3384.299,"body":"unskilled labor in factories"},{"startTime":3382.8,"endTime":3385.619,"body":"um they lived in a society where they"},{"startTime":3384.3,"endTime":3387.059,"body":"didn't have to vote they didn't have any"},{"startTime":3385.619,"endTime":3388.74,"body":"welfare so when they lost their jobs"},{"startTime":3387.059,"endTime":3390.96,"body":"they actually starved many of them did"},{"startTime":3388.739,"endTime":3393.239,"body":"stuff so they're violent reaction to"},{"startTime":3390.96,"endTime":3395.76,"body":"factories there literal throwing spanner"},{"startTime":3393.239,"endTime":3397.139,"body":"in the works was a was a case of them"},{"startTime":3395.76,"endTime":3400.14,"body":"not having rights"},{"startTime":3397.139,"endTime":3402.299,"body":"in this case we have rights we have but"},{"startTime":3400.139,"endTime":3403.558,"body":"most of us uh depend obviously we have a"},{"startTime":3402.3,"endTime":3405.42,"body":"worldwide audience the rights are going"},{"startTime":3403.559,"endTime":3409.5,"body":"to vary as well but we have certain"},{"startTime":3405.42,"endTime":3412.079,"body":"rights and we have certain protections"},{"startTime":3409.5,"endTime":3414.42,"body":"um and therefore we can we can we can"},{"startTime":3412.079,"endTime":3416.4,"body":"articulate our arguments and we can you"},{"startTime":3414.42,"endTime":3418.559,"body":"know fight for things through various"},{"startTime":3416.4,"endTime":3419.22,"body":"sort of legal channels"},{"startTime":3418.559,"endTime":3422.339,"body":"um"},{"startTime":3419.219,"endTime":3424.379,"body":"but again the aim is as we've I think"},{"startTime":3422.338,"endTime":3427.558,"body":"we've been quite clear we're not opposed"},{"startTime":3424.38,"endTime":3429.48,"body":"to what I'm we're not posted technology"},{"startTime":3427.559,"endTime":3431.519,"body":"in fact we did a we did it very early on"},{"startTime":3429.48,"endTime":3434.338,"body":"uh we did a live"},{"startTime":3431.519,"endTime":3435.96,"body":"um podcast led by Sophie where we had a"},{"startTime":3434.338,"endTime":3438.838,"body":"discussion about IO quite early on with"},{"startTime":3435.96,"endTime":3441.0,"body":"artists and uh art teachers and and"},{"startTime":3438.838,"endTime":3442.558,"body":"various people and some were quite in"},{"startTime":3441.0,"endTime":3444.239,"body":"favor some were using it for pitches"},{"startTime":3442.559,"endTime":3445.92,"body":"some were using it for all kinds of"},{"startTime":3444.239,"endTime":3447.598,"body":"things but"},{"startTime":3445.92,"endTime":3449.7,"body":"um you know once you start as you said"},{"startTime":3447.599,"endTime":3451.26,"body":"once you've seen some of the the issues"},{"startTime":3449.699,"endTime":3453.96,"body":"that come up people deliberately"},{"startTime":3451.26,"endTime":3456.059,"body":"imitating somebody's style"},{"startTime":3453.96,"endTime":3458.639,"body":"um you know and again this query of"},{"startTime":3456.059,"endTime":3460.079,"body":"where did they get the data set and you"},{"startTime":3458.639,"endTime":3463.558,"body":"know did they have the right to that"},{"startTime":3460.079,"endTime":3465.599,"body":"data set then we we start to sort of see"},{"startTime":3463.559,"endTime":3468.119,"body":"some of the sort of kind of the problems"},{"startTime":3465.599,"endTime":3469.98,"body":"yeah and it's just about resolving those"},{"startTime":3468.119,"endTime":3472.079,"body":"so that we can move forward like you"},{"startTime":3469.98,"endTime":3474.3,"body":"know like we can we can drive a car but"},{"startTime":3472.079,"endTime":3476.16,"body":"we can't just drive at 200 miles an hour"},{"startTime":3474.3,"endTime":3478.38,"body":"through a residential area yeah having"},{"startTime":3476.159,"endTime":3480.42,"body":"come full circle I guess I I would just"},{"startTime":3478.38,"endTime":3483.66,"body":"like to let you articulate what you"},{"startTime":3480.42,"endTime":3485.28,"body":"believe is an ethical use of AI ways in"},{"startTime":3483.659,"endTime":3487.799,"body":"which artists could take advantage of"},{"startTime":3485.28,"endTime":3490.019,"body":"this technology in ways in which the"},{"startTime":3487.8,"endTime":3492.96,"body":"data sets could be created in a manner"},{"startTime":3490.019,"endTime":3494.94,"body":"that does not infringe upon people's"},{"startTime":3492.96,"endTime":3498.599,"body":"Artistic Endeavors"},{"startTime":3494.94,"endTime":3501.78,"body":"yeah again AI I'm I'm first of all yeah"},{"startTime":3498.599,"endTime":3503.88,"body":"even generative images Technologies not"},{"startTime":3501.78,"endTime":3506.22,"body":"even AI it's more like machine learning"},{"startTime":3503.88,"endTime":3508.559,"body":"because AI is intelligence and there is"},{"startTime":3506.219,"endTime":3509.279,"body":"not a real intelligence there"},{"startTime":3508.559,"endTime":3512.46,"body":"um"},{"startTime":3509.28,"endTime":3516.72,"body":"so about ethical uses again is a matter"},{"startTime":3512.46,"endTime":3518.579,"body":"of the line will be I think"},{"startTime":3516.719,"endTime":3520.078,"body":"written"},{"startTime":3518.579,"endTime":3522.0,"body":"it's going to happen in the following"},{"startTime":3520.079,"endTime":3523.619,"body":"years because we are still trying to"},{"startTime":3522.0,"endTime":3525.298,"body":"find our positions even big companies"},{"startTime":3523.619,"endTime":3526.5,"body":"are trying to take the temperature of"},{"startTime":3525.298,"endTime":3529.679,"body":"the people to see where they position"},{"startTime":3526.5,"endTime":3531.92,"body":"themselves so I I do believe in the"},{"startTime":3529.679,"endTime":3534.48,"body":"common sense I do believe in that"},{"startTime":3531.92,"endTime":3535.619,"body":"strongly like you feel something is"},{"startTime":3534.48,"endTime":3538.019,"body":"wrong it's most likely because it's"},{"startTime":3535.619,"endTime":3540.119,"body":"wrong as simple as that and there is a"},{"startTime":3538.019,"endTime":3542.46,"body":"bit of exercise there to be to abstract"},{"startTime":3540.119,"endTime":3544.92,"body":"from your will and something that you"},{"startTime":3542.46,"endTime":3547.019,"body":"like and AI can be pretty addictive to"},{"startTime":3544.92,"endTime":3548.7,"body":"pretty addictive to the point that you"},{"startTime":3547.019,"endTime":3550.139,"body":"can lose the control of your own opinion"},{"startTime":3548.699,"endTime":3552.48,"body":"about the technology because you want"},{"startTime":3550.139,"endTime":3554.039,"body":"the the pump the the hype of pressing"},{"startTime":3552.48,"endTime":3556.98,"body":"against the front"},{"startTime":3554.039,"endTime":3559.139,"body":"so my my point is"},{"startTime":3556.98,"endTime":3563.42,"body":"um in the way you say for example is uh"},{"startTime":3559.139,"endTime":3567.42,"body":"to to brainstorm uh to build a"},{"startTime":3563.42,"endTime":3571.079,"body":"procedural Menses using my own"},{"startTime":3567.42,"endTime":3572.4,"body":"um original pieces of little Mesa"},{"startTime":3571.079,"endTime":3574.98,"body":"something I just do voice function"},{"startTime":3572.4,"endTime":3578.76,"body":"collapse which is a kind of primitive AI"},{"startTime":3574.98,"endTime":3581.159,"body":"so I can create more of that to do more"},{"startTime":3578.76,"endTime":3584.52,"body":"of your own creation which I think is"},{"startTime":3581.159,"endTime":3586.679,"body":"not quite exciting to be honest I rather"},{"startTime":3584.519,"endTime":3588.059,"body":"enjoy more creating new business by my"},{"startTime":3586.679,"endTime":3590.879,"body":"own I'm making all the millions of"},{"startTime":3588.059,"endTime":3594.119,"body":"choices that are involved in a creative"},{"startTime":3590.88,"endTime":3598.14,"body":"work but I really prefer"},{"startTime":3594.119,"endTime":3599.4,"body":"um if I want to have a final say on that"},{"startTime":3598.139,"endTime":3600.42,"body":"um because I'm pretty sure there are"},{"startTime":3599.4,"endTime":3602.88,"body":"many"},{"startTime":3600.42,"endTime":3606.0,"body":"students many people Juniors that they"},{"startTime":3602.88,"endTime":3608.039,"body":"want to jump into the industry many fans"},{"startTime":3606.0,"endTime":3611.46,"body":"of art that they are worried about what"},{"startTime":3608.039,"endTime":3613.98,"body":"is going to be next and I feel fear even"},{"startTime":3611.46,"endTime":3615.42,"body":"in young people about should I study art"},{"startTime":3613.98,"endTime":3618.838,"body":"or not"},{"startTime":3615.42,"endTime":3621.24,"body":"and there is a beautiful almost poetic"},{"startTime":3618.838,"endTime":3622.679,"body":"contradiction of all this that is yes"},{"startTime":3621.239,"endTime":3625.139,"body":"more than ever"},{"startTime":3622.679,"endTime":3628.919,"body":"double up like really now is the moment"},{"startTime":3625.139,"endTime":3633.318,"body":"where you have a voice like literally"},{"startTime":3628.92,"endTime":3636.539,"body":"um art in the last uh 20 years"},{"startTime":3633.318,"endTime":3637.98,"body":"has been sadly quite driven either"},{"startTime":3636.539,"endTime":3641.4,"body":"either by"},{"startTime":3637.98,"endTime":3643.139,"body":"let's say postmodern art or by Massive"},{"startTime":3641.4,"endTime":3646.2,"body":"Hollywood industry and video games"},{"startTime":3643.139,"endTime":3647.818,"body":"industry which has already standards but"},{"startTime":3646.199,"endTime":3650.098,"body":"this is your fans and if you go outside"},{"startTime":3647.818,"endTime":3651.838,"body":"the fence you are not gonna sell so we"},{"startTime":3650.099,"endTime":3654.0,"body":"got already a style of superheroes we"},{"startTime":3651.838,"endTime":3655.679,"body":"got already a style of formula movie"},{"startTime":3654.0,"endTime":3658.858,"body":"that is gonna work and we need to put"},{"startTime":3655.679,"endTime":3660.719,"body":"the exact amount of Darkness or joy in"},{"startTime":3658.858,"endTime":3662.519,"body":"this movie in our heroes in our color"},{"startTime":3660.719,"endTime":3665.879,"body":"palettes because this is how we are"},{"startTime":3662.519,"endTime":3668.639,"body":"gonna sell merchandising everything so"},{"startTime":3665.88,"endTime":3671.039,"body":"that is good I work on Marvel I work on"},{"startTime":3668.639,"endTime":3673.379,"body":"Disney I work on these movies okay I can"},{"startTime":3671.039,"endTime":3675.659,"body":"put a bit of my opinion on this but you"},{"startTime":3673.38,"endTime":3677.94,"body":"are still uh more like a crafter"},{"startTime":3675.659,"endTime":3680.039,"body":"sometimes we're all artists but we are"},{"startTime":3677.94,"endTime":3683.28,"body":"crafting whatever we have from dailies"},{"startTime":3680.039,"endTime":3685.558,"body":"or from the client or from someone who"},{"startTime":3683.28,"endTime":3687.42,"body":"is fear from production that oh we need"},{"startTime":3685.559,"endTime":3689.339,"body":"to put brighter because this is gonna"},{"startTime":3687.42,"endTime":3692.7,"body":"need to be PG"},{"startTime":3689.338,"endTime":3695.159,"body":"now there is a historical event that"},{"startTime":3692.699,"endTime":3698.578,"body":"talks about us about our passion about"},{"startTime":3695.159,"endTime":3700.078,"body":"our identity so now you have the tool"},{"startTime":3698.579,"endTime":3703.019,"body":"now you can use the talent doesn't"},{"startTime":3700.079,"endTime":3706.2,"body":"matter if you're through you draw good"},{"startTime":3703.019,"endTime":3708.719,"body":"or bad if you do good or bad 3D you can"},{"startTime":3706.199,"endTime":3711.48,"body":"now find who you are through ART more"},{"startTime":3708.719,"endTime":3715.199,"body":"than ever it's a kind of identity seek"},{"startTime":3711.48,"endTime":3717.838,"body":"more than job seeking artem economy"},{"startTime":3715.199,"endTime":3720.118,"body":"never works so well okay but let's start"},{"startTime":3717.838,"endTime":3722.4,"body":"with that from his I mean like even"},{"startTime":3720.119,"endTime":3725.76,"body":"DaVinci needed to work from from a"},{"startTime":3722.4,"endTime":3727.798,"body":"Christianity and he was a troll he was"},{"startTime":3725.76,"endTime":3730.04,"body":"trolling you remember the in the I don't"},{"startTime":3727.798,"endTime":3732.659,"body":"know that in English"},{"startTime":3730.039,"endTime":3735.119,"body":"the painting and you can see that he did"},{"startTime":3732.659,"endTime":3737.399,"body":"all God as a brain saying God is in the"},{"startTime":3735.119,"endTime":3740.22,"body":"brain actually so he was a troll he used"},{"startTime":3737.4,"endTime":3742.26,"body":"art as a way of fighting for his ideas"},{"startTime":3740.219,"endTime":3744.118,"body":"and now you've had the opportunity I"},{"startTime":3742.26,"endTime":3747.059,"body":"know this is a big take for someone who"},{"startTime":3744.119,"endTime":3749.46,"body":"is 18 years old yeah"},{"startTime":3747.059,"endTime":3752.22,"body":"wasn't it Michelangelo this capitalists"},{"startTime":3749.46,"endTime":3753.838,"body":"you know okay now oh that is interesting"},{"startTime":3752.219,"endTime":3757.5,"body":"yeah I don't know there's the"},{"startTime":3753.838,"endTime":3759.558,"body":"translation in Chapel no sorry I think"},{"startTime":3757.5,"endTime":3759.559,"body":"um"},{"startTime":3759.96,"endTime":3763.338,"body":"DaVinci"},{"startTime":3761.519,"endTime":3765.9,"body":"no Michelangelo yeah"},{"startTime":3763.338,"endTime":3769.318,"body":"sorry uh do you want to say it again"},{"startTime":3765.9,"endTime":3771.539,"body":"just to not say him again"},{"startTime":3769.318,"endTime":3773.699,"body":"um I think it's a good point it sounds"},{"startTime":3771.539,"endTime":3774.679,"body":"silly if you said the wrong artist no no"},{"startTime":3773.699,"endTime":3777.419,"body":"this is"},{"startTime":3774.679,"endTime":3780.118,"body":"uh but we can't see how art is"},{"startTime":3777.42,"endTime":3783.059,"body":"historically uh use their talent not"},{"startTime":3780.119,"endTime":3785.039,"body":"just to get the money from you know uh"},{"startTime":3783.059,"endTime":3789.059,"body":"different institutions but also to put"},{"startTime":3785.039,"endTime":3792.119,"body":"their ideas uh like Michelangelo in La"},{"startTime":3789.059,"endTime":3794.22,"body":"Capilla 16 and you can see how the God"},{"startTime":3792.119,"endTime":3796.079,"body":"is itself inside a brain with the"},{"startTime":3794.219,"endTime":3798.0,"body":"perfect shape of our brain I mean the"},{"startTime":3796.079,"endTime":3801.48,"body":"message is clear God is in the brain"},{"startTime":3798.0,"endTime":3804.42,"body":"period so he was he was always fighting"},{"startTime":3801.48,"endTime":3806.639,"body":"like that like goja uh he was always"},{"startTime":3804.42,"endTime":3808.98,"body":"working for the royalty and he hated"},{"startTime":3806.639,"endTime":3812.279,"body":"royalty he always painted all the royal"},{"startTime":3808.98,"endTime":3814.619,"body":"family like really needed some extra"},{"startTime":3812.28,"endTime":3817.68,"body":"time in school you know"},{"startTime":3814.619,"endTime":3819.539,"body":"um now there is a historical event and"},{"startTime":3817.679,"endTime":3821.279,"body":"you can just art obviously don't spend"},{"startTime":3819.539,"endTime":3823.619,"body":"your honor just always put in no AI art"},{"startTime":3821.28,"endTime":3827.4,"body":"in creative ways but at least to find"},{"startTime":3823.619,"endTime":3828.66,"body":"who you are and even if it's not gonna"},{"startTime":3827.4,"endTime":3830.76,"body":"make you money in the very beginning"},{"startTime":3828.659,"endTime":3833.699,"body":"trust me in the long run"},{"startTime":3830.76,"endTime":3836.88,"body":"your name is more important than your"},{"startTime":3833.699,"endTime":3840.058,"body":"art and people don't buy art or don't"},{"startTime":3836.88,"endTime":3843.119,"body":"consume art just because the vignette or"},{"startTime":3840.059,"endTime":3846.18,"body":"the shot is because you and you are the"},{"startTime":3843.119,"endTime":3849.96,"body":"voice so AI can't do that because I'm"},{"startTime":3846.179,"endTime":3851.879,"body":"not gonna feel empathetic or I want to"},{"startTime":3849.96,"endTime":3853.679,"body":"know the history of this microchip or"},{"startTime":3851.88,"endTime":3855.72,"body":"this tensor core I want to know what is"},{"startTime":3853.679,"endTime":3858.0,"body":"coming from and his past no but I can't"},{"startTime":3855.719,"endTime":3860.039,"body":"feel empathy about you about you as an"},{"startTime":3858.0,"endTime":3861.9,"body":"artist so now is the moment of doing"},{"startTime":3860.039,"endTime":3863.818,"body":"more art than ever now is the moment to"},{"startTime":3861.9,"endTime":3868.079,"body":"try to be a bit different to do less"},{"startTime":3863.818,"endTime":3870.42,"body":"maybe you know monsters with four horns"},{"startTime":3868.079,"endTime":3872.88,"body":"and big teeth or new superheroes and"},{"startTime":3870.42,"endTime":3875.579,"body":"maybe trying to find who am I what I"},{"startTime":3872.88,"endTime":3878.039,"body":"want to tell here so that's my little"},{"startTime":3875.579,"endTime":3880.5,"body":"note about this because some people is"},{"startTime":3878.039,"endTime":3882.779,"body":"afraid about studying or not studying"},{"startTime":3880.5,"endTime":3885.96,"body":"art or dedicated to art or not and I"},{"startTime":3882.78,"endTime":3887.94,"body":"would say Yeah more than ever right"},{"startTime":3885.96,"endTime":3891.298,"body":"now let's stop this and next thing just"},{"startTime":3887.94,"endTime":3893.88,"body":"do your show duacom do animation"},{"startTime":3891.298,"endTime":3895.5,"body":"find your style find who you are and try"},{"startTime":3893.88,"endTime":3897.838,"body":"to tell me why should I care about you"},{"startTime":3895.5,"endTime":3899.579,"body":"more than Ai and trust me you are gonna"},{"startTime":3897.838,"endTime":3902.46,"body":"win this fight and the long and right"},{"startTime":3899.579,"endTime":3905.64,"body":"yes for sure we we need more artists"},{"startTime":3902.46,"endTime":3907.74,"body":"creating uh we we you know I mean"},{"startTime":3905.639,"endTime":3909.539,"body":"I think that's true very lots of"},{"startTime":3907.739,"endTime":3911.459,"body":"talented people I mean our art station"},{"startTime":3909.539,"endTime":3914.46,"body":"itself it would"},{"startTime":3911.46,"endTime":3916.44,"body":"you know sort of Corral people into this"},{"startTime":3914.46,"endTime":3919.26,"body":"kind of like you know manga cyberpunk"},{"startTime":3916.44,"endTime":3921.38,"body":"girls with big boobs and in bikinis with"},{"startTime":3919.26,"endTime":3924.48,"body":"with big guns and swords"},{"startTime":3921.38,"endTime":3926.88,"body":"everything all over size and AI can do"},{"startTime":3924.48,"endTime":3928.559,"body":"that but you know AI art station already"},{"startTime":3926.88,"endTime":3930.358,"body":"was problematic and that it was correct"},{"startTime":3928.559,"endTime":3931.68,"body":"it was corralling artists into this"},{"startTime":3930.358,"endTime":3933.9,"body":"certain style you would see that the"},{"startTime":3931.679,"endTime":3935.879,"body":"Arts that were getting views because"},{"startTime":3933.9,"endTime":3938.039,"body":"they were not necessarily Innovative for"},{"startTime":3935.88,"endTime":3940.079,"body":"or particularly in spot many of them"},{"startTime":3938.039,"endTime":3942.48,"body":"were technically incredible"},{"startTime":3940.079,"endTime":3944.579,"body":"but do you know do you know anyone that"},{"startTime":3942.48,"endTime":3948.059,"body":"entered the industry"},{"startTime":3944.579,"endTime":3950.818,"body":"yes to do the copy of do you know I I I"},{"startTime":3948.059,"endTime":3952.559,"body":"don't maybe I'm wrong but I don't see I"},{"startTime":3950.818,"endTime":3954.358,"body":"see always like a story when I was a kid"},{"startTime":3952.559,"endTime":3956.4,"body":"I was playing this game when I watched"},{"startTime":3954.358,"endTime":3958.98,"body":"this movie and I wanted to do that"},{"startTime":3956.4,"endTime":3961.44,"body":"I don't see like yeah I want to do what"},{"startTime":3958.98,"endTime":3964.019,"body":"artist Asian people do exactly"},{"startTime":3961.44,"endTime":3967.079,"body":"that's more like a mark a market shaping"},{"startTime":3964.019,"endTime":3969.719,"body":"but not the real inside artists but"},{"startTime":3967.079,"endTime":3971.7,"body":"maybe this fact that we have been"},{"startTime":3969.719,"endTime":3974.939,"body":"in a sense"},{"startTime":3971.699,"endTime":3977.159,"body":"work being following me trying to follow"},{"startTime":3974.94,"endTime":3979.798,"body":"the algorithms of social platforms are"},{"startTime":3977.159,"endTime":3982.798,"body":"having a sense been behaving more like"},{"startTime":3979.798,"endTime":3984.358,"body":"Ai and and a bit like how you know I"},{"startTime":3982.798,"endTime":3985.92,"body":"mean I know it was a fallacy when we're"},{"startTime":3984.358,"endTime":3987.779,"body":"talking about the copyright but when you"},{"startTime":3985.92,"endTime":3989.4,"body":"talk about the photography and art you"},{"startTime":3987.78,"endTime":3990.96,"body":"know after you had photography you had"},{"startTime":3989.4,"endTime":3993.119,"body":"artists like Picasso who could draw"},{"startTime":3990.96,"endTime":3994.858,"body":"realistically but yeah there was a"},{"startTime":3993.119,"endTime":3996.42,"body":"certain there was a certain sudden"},{"startTime":3994.858,"endTime":3997.739,"body":"realization Point there's I don't"},{"startTime":3996.42,"endTime":4000.559,"body":"there's no point if I want something"},{"startTime":3997.739,"endTime":4002.239,"body":"that looks like a tree I mean I can I"},{"startTime":4000.559,"endTime":4005.119,"body":"can take a picture and it looks like a"},{"startTime":4002.239,"endTime":4007.639,"body":"tree but I if I want to create something"},{"startTime":4005.119,"endTime":4010.18,"body":"new I can create it and so suddenly you"},{"startTime":4007.639,"endTime":4012.379,"body":"had this move away from you know"},{"startTime":4010.179,"endTime":4014.96,"body":"necessarily the strict interpolation of"},{"startTime":4012.38,"endTime":4016.579,"body":"realization and so why do I want a"},{"startTime":4014.96,"endTime":4018.74,"body":"picture of a shoe what what do I feel"},{"startTime":4016.579,"endTime":4021.559,"body":"when I look at a tree or what do I when"},{"startTime":4018.739,"endTime":4023.779,"body":"I see a bull why why is that what what"},{"startTime":4021.559,"endTime":4025.819,"body":"is it about a bull that is that is"},{"startTime":4023.78,"endTime":4027.92,"body":"interesting or a chicken yeah I mean I"},{"startTime":4025.818,"endTime":4029.719,"body":"don't know if the gomberg history of art"},{"startTime":4027.92,"endTime":4031.94,"body":"there's a story of art there's a there's"},{"startTime":4029.719,"endTime":4034.459,"body":"a brilliant side by side of Picasso's"},{"startTime":4031.94,"endTime":4036.26,"body":"drawing of 13 of a chicken which is"},{"startTime":4034.46,"endTime":4038.42,"body":"perfectly realistic looks like a"},{"startTime":4036.26,"endTime":4040.88,"body":"beautiful looks like a chicken yeah and"},{"startTime":4038.42,"endTime":4042.74,"body":"then he's pretty crazy"},{"startTime":4040.88,"endTime":4044.9,"body":"um adult kind of interpretive chicken"},{"startTime":4042.739,"endTime":4047.719,"body":"which looks file is realistic almost"},{"startTime":4044.9,"endTime":4050.18,"body":"looks more childlike but it tells you"},{"startTime":4047.719,"endTime":4051.919,"body":"like this chicken is angry and this"},{"startTime":4050.179,"endTime":4054.259,"body":"chicken is gonna pick you and you're"},{"startTime":4051.92,"endTime":4056.42,"body":"like oh whoa whoa look look watch out"},{"startTime":4054.26,"endTime":4058.4,"body":"for that chicken yeah yeah either they"},{"startTime":4056.42,"endTime":4060.68,"body":"always create six fingers hyper"},{"startTime":4058.4,"endTime":4062.42,"body":"realistic faces with six fingers and"},{"startTime":4060.679,"endTime":4065.239,"body":"wellness is less expressive Than The"},{"startTime":4062.42,"endTime":4067.519,"body":"Simpsons that four fingers and they're"},{"startTime":4065.239,"endTime":4069.979,"body":"hilarious and it's super easy to"},{"startTime":4067.519,"endTime":4072.98,"body":"draw so I just worried that maybe we end"},{"startTime":4069.98,"endTime":4075.26,"body":"up in another that icing our cubism uh"},{"startTime":4072.98,"endTime":4077.179,"body":"thingy an artist like they want to fight"},{"startTime":4075.26,"endTime":4079.339,"body":"the opposite would be like completely"},{"startTime":4077.179,"endTime":4082.399,"body":"abstract which I don't care but it is to"},{"startTime":4079.338,"endTime":4084.92,"body":"that we need somehow to find uh it's sad"},{"startTime":4082.4,"endTime":4086.72,"body":"but it is true that Arc is also a weapon"},{"startTime":4084.92,"endTime":4088.579,"body":"um sorry we are gonna leave now in a"},{"startTime":4086.719,"endTime":4090.858,"body":"circumstances where we need a bit of"},{"startTime":4088.579,"endTime":4094.64,"body":"extra effort let's accept that it's"},{"startTime":4090.858,"endTime":4097.219,"body":"gonna happen uh but also with optimism"},{"startTime":4094.639,"endTime":4100.88,"body":"because I believe in the long run I"},{"startTime":4097.219,"endTime":4102.079,"body":"crave him for art I really want more and"},{"startTime":4100.88,"endTime":4104.719,"body":"I'm super happy that I remove"},{"startTime":4102.079,"endTime":4106.579,"body":"connections of AI prompters on link and"},{"startTime":4104.719,"endTime":4109.759,"body":"in that now I start to see more"},{"startTime":4106.579,"endTime":4111.92,"body":"animation tests more Concepts and oh wow"},{"startTime":4109.759,"endTime":4114.56,"body":"this is cool I appreciate more"},{"startTime":4111.92,"endTime":4116.119,"body":"art than before I think R is gonna raise"},{"startTime":4114.56,"endTime":4118.4,"body":"the value"},{"startTime":4116.119,"endTime":4120.798,"body":"um AI can create so much millions of"},{"startTime":4118.399,"endTime":4123.858,"body":"images that you think about the offer on"},{"startTime":4120.798,"endTime":4127.1,"body":"demand economic lows when you have of"},{"startTime":4123.859,"endTime":4129.259,"body":"offer the demand just goes down down and"},{"startTime":4127.1,"endTime":4132.02,"body":"the price is very low when you have"},{"startTime":4129.259,"endTime":4135.619,"body":"something more unique the price diamonds"},{"startTime":4132.02,"endTime":4139.52,"body":"gold the price Rises now so I do believe"},{"startTime":4135.619,"endTime":4142.039,"body":"that if you put more effort into rather"},{"startTime":4139.52,"endTime":4143.359,"body":"than doing a copycat of whatever you saw"},{"startTime":4142.039,"endTime":4144.439,"body":"in the last 10 years of Artic station"},{"startTime":4143.359,"endTime":4147.92,"body":"and think"},{"startTime":4144.439,"endTime":4149.479,"body":"what I think about this or what IP what"},{"startTime":4147.92,"endTime":4151.64,"body":"I want I want to create or what kind of"},{"startTime":4149.479,"endTime":4153.979,"body":"Animation style is going to define a bit"},{"startTime":4151.64,"endTime":4156.98,"body":"better myself"},{"startTime":4153.979,"endTime":4159.858,"body":"then you will have a beautiful options"},{"startTime":4156.979,"endTime":4161.899,"body":"to be recognized but chance to build a"},{"startTime":4159.859,"endTime":4162.739,"body":"very important interesting career I"},{"startTime":4161.899,"endTime":4165.198,"body":"would say"},{"startTime":4162.738,"endTime":4167.238,"body":"brilliant and I think that's a great"},{"startTime":4165.198,"endTime":4168.198,"body":"place to to stop the discussion I'd love"},{"startTime":4167.238,"endTime":4169.459,"body":"to get you back and talk a bit about"},{"startTime":4168.198,"endTime":4172.399,"body":"your company obviously we've been"},{"startTime":4169.46,"endTime":4174.439,"body":"specific on on this on this debate but I"},{"startTime":4172.399,"endTime":4176.179,"body":"would um as as more comes out I would"},{"startTime":4174.439,"endTime":4179.0,"body":"love to talk about your entrepreneurism"},{"startTime":4176.179,"endTime":4180.56,"body":"and how you got involved with that so"},{"startTime":4179.0,"endTime":4182.238,"body":"yeah we'll definitely have you back at"},{"startTime":4180.56,"endTime":4184.039,"body":"some point on the show yeah I think that"},{"startTime":4182.238,"endTime":4186.559,"body":"was a fantastic point to end I'd love to"},{"startTime":4184.039,"endTime":4189.019,"body":"thank you for your time thank you and um"},{"startTime":4186.56,"endTime":4191.12,"body":"we'll speak to you soon thank you so"},{"startTime":4189.02,"endTime":4194.36,"body":"much and and everyone posts your"},{"startTime":4191.119,"endTime":4196.579,"body":"comments questions and demands in the in"},{"startTime":4194.359,"endTime":4198.259,"body":"the uh in the comment section or if"},{"startTime":4196.579,"endTime":4200.0,"body":"you're on an audio platform you can"},{"startTime":4198.26,"endTime":4201.739,"body":"always head over to our website onto"},{"startTime":4200.0,"endTime":4204.56,"body":"YouTube or you can contact us on"},{"startTime":4201.738,"endTime":4206.839,"body":"LinkedIn or any of the social platforms"},{"startTime":4204.56,"endTime":4208.84,"body":"because we're pretty much everywhere not"},{"startTime":4206.84,"endTime":4211.88,"body":"really on Facebook but everywhere else"},{"startTime":4208.84,"endTime":4213.8,"body":"and uh including Mastodon"},{"startTime":4211.88,"endTime":4215.98,"body":"um have a great evening and speak to you"},{"startTime":4213.8,"endTime":4215.98,"body":"soon"},{"startTime":4222.319,"endTime":4225.319,"body":"foreign"},{"startTime":4271.699,"endTime":4274.869,"body":"[Music]"}]}