The Summer I Turned Pretty

These Books Made Me

These Books Made Me
The Summer I Turned Pretty
Jun 26, 2025 Season 5 Episode 5
Prince George's County Memorial Library System

Send us a text

2 brothers, 1 girl, 0 chance we're onboard with this love triangle. In The Summer I Turned Pretty, we follow Isabel "Belly" Conklin, who hasn't had much luck with boys finding her attractive, especially the one boy she's been pining over for forever, Conrad Fisher. That all changes the summer she turns 16, where not only does she catch Conrad's attention, but also the attention of his younger brother, Jeremiah. Add in a third love interest, Cam Cameron, and what follows is a messy summer for Belly where she's navigating her feelings, her newfound attractiveness, and her insecurities. 

In this episode, we talk about pretty privilege, the damaging effects of the broody guy trope and the depiction of female friendships. Heather clocks Jennie Han's age as a fellow Xennial (she's really not 60, guys), Hannah tells us about the Westermarck effect and we find out Hawa really doesn't read our group chat. We may not be onboard with this brother love triangle but the book gave us a lot to talk about. 

These Books Made Me is a podcast about the literary heroines who shaped us and is a product of the Prince George's County Memorial Library System podcast network. Stay in touch with us via Twitter @PGCMLS with #TheseBooksMadeMe, on Instagram @TheseBooksMadeMe or by email at TheseBooksMadeMe@pgcmls.info. For recommended readalikes and deep dives into topics related to each episode, visit our blog at https://pgcmls.medium.com/.

Episode Artwork The Summer I Turned Pretty 1:28:03 Episode Artwork Sweet Valley High: Double Love and Teacher Crush 1:15:42 Episode Artwork The Birchbark House 1:11:46 Episode Artwork Little House on the Prairie Series 1:14:39 Episode Artwork The Hate U Give 1:16:11 Episode Artwork Survivor: These Books Made Me Part 2 45:04 Episode Artwork Survivor: These Books Made Me Part 1 1:06:54 Episode Artwork Gabi, a Girl in Pieces Part 2 49:45 Episode Artwork Gabi, a Girl in Pieces Part 1 1:00:02 Episode Artwork Akata Witch 1:18:13 Episode Artwork Anastasia Krupnik 1:12:40 Episode Artwork The Baby-sitters Club: Claudia, Part 2 56:17 Episode Artwork The Baby-Sitters Club: Claudia Part 1 1:02:09 Episode Artwork Front Desk 1:04:48 Episode Artwork Jacob Have I Loved 1:13:34 Episode Artwork Bonus Episode: a Peer Health Educator discusses Forever 33:45 Episode Artwork Forever 1:03:11 Episode Artwork The Bluest Eye 1:06:26 Episode Artwork Bonus Episode: Interview with an archer 46:37 Episode Artwork The Hunger Games 1:02:16 Episode Artwork Hispanic Heritage Month: How the Garcia Girls Lost Their Accents Rerelease 1:07:18 Episode Artwork Hispanic Heritage Month: The House on Mango Street Rerelease 1:09:45 Episode Artwork Blubber 1:06:36 Episode Artwork Bonus Episode: Dr. Mike Duncan discusses the science in A Wrinkle in Time 23:48 Episode Artwork A Wrinkle in Time 1:12:50