Is Jesus Red or Blue? & What Identity Drives You?

When the world feels like it’s constantly pulling you to pick a side, it’s easy to mistake outrage for righteousness and tribal loyalty for faithfulness. In this episode of The Sacred Gentleman Podcast, Steve Baumgartner explores how political, cultural, and national identities can quietly replace our deepest calling — our identity as disciples of Jesus Christ.

This conversation isn’t about telling you which political position to take. It’s about helping you examine who is shaping your spirit, what you are becoming, and whether Christ is truly your highest allegiance. You’ll learn how to recognize when anger feels holy but isn’t, how contempt disguises itself as conviction, and how to engage real-world issues with truth, courage, and love — without losing your soul in the process.
________________________________________
🔥 In This Episode, You’ll Learn:
•Why outrage can feel righteous but slowly harden your heart
•The difference between being a good citizen and a faithful disciple
•How partisan identity becomes dangerous when it replaces conscience
•Signs your identity may be getting hijacked
•How to tell the truth without cruelty and love without compromise
•A practical framework for responding with discernment instead of reaction
________________________________________
📖 Scripture Referenced:
•John 18:33–38 — My kingdom is not of this world
•Matthew 22:37–40 — The greatest commandments
•Micah 6:8 — Act justly, love mercy, walk humbly
•James 1:19–20 — Be quick to listen, slow to speak, slow to anger
•Matthew 5:9 — Blessed are the peacemakers


⏱️ Timestamps – What Identity Drives You?
00:00 — When outrage starts to feel righteous
01:08 — The question we don’t want to ask: right action, wrong spirit
02:15 — Minneapolis tension and why it matters spiritually
03:05 — Testing my own heart in the middle of the chaos
04:05 — Your deepest identity is not American — it’s in Christ
04:55 — This moment reveals what we worship
06:00 — Facts, narratives, and why everyone wants a side
07:15 — It’s not just political — it’s personal
08:05 — How pressure shows up in comments, group chats, work, and church
10:05 — When it follows you home
11:20 — Passivity vs. harshness (the two traps men fall into)
12:50 — The real root: identity
13:05 — Citizen, partisan, disciple
14:40 — Responsibility, seduction, surrender
15:45 — When citizenship becomes a god
16:15 — Symptom #1: Rage that feels holy
18:00 — Symptom #2: Contempt that feels justified
19:10 — Symptom #3: When Jesus starts sounding like your politics
21:05 — Why this warning matters
21:45 — My confession: I wanted a villain
22:30 — How social media hijacked my morning
24:10 — Watching myself lose my spirit in the comments
26:10 — A friend’s words that exposed me
29:00 — Discernment vs. reaction
30:00 — Human dignity, law, and accountability can all be true
31:00 — Engage like a disciple, not a tribal spokesman
31:45 — The real spiritual cost of hate
32:25 — Truth without cruelty, love without compromise
33:15 — Jesus before Pilate (John 18)
34:30 — What Jesus refuse