How physician identity influences income

CMAJ Podcasts

CMAJ Podcasts
How physician identity influences income
Nov 17, 2025
Canadian Medical Association Journal

This episode of the CMAJ Podcast explores how physician identity can influence patient expectations, and how those expectations may contribute to gender, race, and immigration status pay gaps. The discussion builds on the CMAJ article “Family physician pay inequality: a qualitative study exploring how physician responses to perceived patient expectations may explain gender, race, and immigration status pay differences”.

Dr. Monika Dutt, a family physician, public health and preventive medicine specialist, and PhD candidate in health policy at McMaster University, explains how the study’s interviews with 55 family physicians across Ontario revealed patterns linking patient expectations to physician identity. She describes how gender and cultural background influence the types of visits physicians are asked to provide, and how these interactions may affect their earnings under fee-for-service models.

Dr. Meredith Vanstone, professor in the Department of Family Medicine at McMaster University, outlines how physicians adapt to explicit and inferred patient expectations and the income implications that follow. She discusses how these expectations are shaped by identity and why the resulting adjustments in care can lead to financial penalties for some physicians while improving patient relationships and trust.

The guests highlight how remuneration structures can either amplify or mitigate these inequities. They suggest that moving toward salary or time-based models could help reduce the impact of physician identity on income while supporting equitable, patient-centred care.

For more information from our sponsor, go to medicuspensionplan.com

Comments or questions? Text us.

Join us as we explore medical solutions that address the urgent need to change healthcare. Reach out to us about this or any episode you hear. Or tell us about something you'd like to hear on the leading Canadian medical podcast.

You can find Blair and Mojola on X @BlairBigham and @Drmojolaomole

X (in English): @CMAJ
X (en français): @JAMC
Facebook
Instagram: @CMAJ.ca

The CMAJ Podcast is produced by PodCraft Productions

Episode Artwork How physician identity influences income 28:02 Episode Artwork Black youth and access to mental health care 31:44 Episode Artwork Depression guideline: why universal screening isn’t recommended 27:54 Episode Artwork What to know about cannabis-induced psychosis 35:27 Episode Artwork Guideline offers roadmap for spinal and bulbar muscular atrophy care 29:32 Episode Artwork Understanding and supporting pregnant people facing homelessness 29:08 Episode Artwork Guideline on smoking cessation: what works in practice 34:28 Episode Artwork ENCORE: New guidelines for managing hypertension in primary care 27:36 Episode Artwork Fixing the flag: A new standard for diagnosing iron deficiency 32:26 Episode Artwork Measles in pregnancy and beyond 35:28 Episode Artwork New guidelines for managing hypertension in primary care 27:36 Episode Artwork Dengue and Oropouche infections are rising—what physicians need to know 31:00 Episode Artwork A history of medical mistrust and its echoes today 33:01 Episode Artwork How mifepristone changed abortion access, and how to prescribe it 35:28 Episode Artwork Stepping up: Canadian research in the shadow of cuts in the United States 25:12 Episode Artwork Perspectives on the new guideline for managing obesity in children 31:24 Episode Artwork ​​How short-term opioid prescriptions affect long-term outcomes 36:57 Episode Artwork The mortality risk and therapeutic potential of hallucinogens 31:03 Episode Artwork More access, more deaths: alcohol’s impact in the COVID-19 pandemic 31:12 Episode Artwork The major benefits of exercise for older adults 29:38 Episode Artwork Making healthcare accessible for patients with disabilities 37:40 Episode Artwork Diagnosing and managing necrotizing fasciitis 34:38 Episode Artwork Antimicrobial resistance and the shift to shorter courses of antibiotics 39:58 Episode Artwork ENCORE: AI versus physicians: who’s better at spotting high-risk patients? 32:46 Episode Artwork Scurvy and the challenge of food insecurity 33:04