Moral distress and the ethics of involuntary treatment

CMAJ Podcasts

CMAJ Podcasts
Moral distress and the ethics of involuntary treatment
Jan 12, 2026
Canadian Medical Association Journal

On this episode of the CMAJ Podcast, Dr. Mojola Omole and Dr. Blair Bigham examine the issues raised in a recent CMAJ commentary on Alberta’s Compassionate Intervention Act, which explores the ethical and clinical implications of this approach to involuntary treatment. As governments across Canada turn to coercive measures in response to the overdose crisis, the episode considers what these policies mean for patient autonomy, clinical practice, and the role of physicians in enforcing care.

Dr. Bonnie Larson, a family physician and addictions medicine specialist at the University of Calgary, joins the conversation to unpack the legislation. She explains how the Act allows individuals to be detained and treated even when they are deemed capable of making their own medical decisions. Dr. Larson describes how this represents a substantial departure from established principles of consent and autonomy, placing physicians in ethically complex positions and reshaping their role in care.

The discussion then turns to Massachusetts, where involuntary treatment for substance use has existed for decades under Section 35. Dr. Keren Ladin, a bioethicist and health services researcher at Tufts University, reveals the experiences of clinicians working within this framework. Drawing on her research, she describes how Section 35 has shaped clinical practice, contributed to moral distress among healthcare providers, and often resulted in people being treated in carceral rather than therapeutic settings.

Together, the guests reflect on what these policies reveal about how societies respond to addiction, the limits of coercive care, and the risks of prioritizing control over evidence-based, patient-centred treatment.

Comments or questions? Text us.

Join us as we explore medical solutions that address the urgent need to change healthcare. Reach out to us about this or any episode you hear. Or tell us about something you'd like to hear on the leading Canadian medical podcast.

You can find Blair and Mojola on X @BlairBigham and @Drmojolaomole

X (in English): @CMAJ
X (en français): @JAMC
Facebook
Instagram: @CMAJ.ca

The CMAJ Podcast is produced by PodCraft Productions

Episode Artwork Moral distress and the ethics of involuntary treatment 37:37 Episode Artwork ENCORE: New guidelines for managing hypertension in primary care 27:36 Episode Artwork Updated HIV prophylaxis guidelines: what clinicians need to know 36:47 Episode Artwork Diagnosis and management of celiac disease 26:55 Episode Artwork How physician identity influences income 28:02 Episode Artwork Black youth and access to mental health care 31:44 Episode Artwork Depression guideline: why universal screening isn’t recommended 27:54 Episode Artwork What to know about cannabis-induced psychosis 35:27 Episode Artwork Guideline offers roadmap for spinal and bulbar muscular atrophy care 29:32 Episode Artwork Understanding and supporting pregnant people facing homelessness 29:08 Episode Artwork Guideline on smoking cessation: what works in practice 34:28 Episode Artwork ENCORE: New guidelines for managing hypertension in primary care 27:36 Episode Artwork Fixing the flag: A new standard for diagnosing iron deficiency 32:26 Episode Artwork Measles in pregnancy and beyond 35:28 Episode Artwork New guidelines for managing hypertension in primary care 27:36 Episode Artwork Dengue and Oropouche infections are rising—what physicians need to know 31:00 Episode Artwork A history of medical mistrust and its echoes today 33:01 Episode Artwork How mifepristone changed abortion access, and how to prescribe it 35:28 Episode Artwork Stepping up: Canadian research in the shadow of cuts in the United States 25:12 Episode Artwork Perspectives on the new guideline for managing obesity in children 31:24 Episode Artwork ​​How short-term opioid prescriptions affect long-term outcomes 36:57 Episode Artwork The mortality risk and therapeutic potential of hallucinogens 31:03 Episode Artwork More access, more deaths: alcohol’s impact in the COVID-19 pandemic 31:12 Episode Artwork The major benefits of exercise for older adults 29:38 Episode Artwork Making healthcare accessible for patients with disabilities 37:40