Jersey Arts Podcast
The Jersey Arts Podcast presents in-depth, one-on-one conversations with the liveliest and most intriguing personalities in New Jersey’s arts scene. From the casts of hit shows to critically acclaimed film producers; from world-renowned poets to classically trained musicians; from groundbreaking dance visionaries to cutting-edge fine artists, our podcast connects you to what’s happening in your local arts community.
Jersey Arts Podcast
Kathryn Grody's Unexpected 3rd Act
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
It’s in the third act of a three-act story structure when everything comes to a head. The plot builds to its peak, the characters demonstrate development, and the audience/reader/listener experiences the story’s climax—and maybe even a moral.
If the third act is the culmination of everything leading up to it, then the third act of Kathryn Grody’s life has been a wild one. The 2-time Obie Award-winning actor, mother, grandmother, and wife of actor Mandy Patinkin, found new recognition in 2020 when her son posted a video of her and Patinkin that earned them a new overnight fan base. From that viral success developed the family’s Don't Listen to Us podcast, a TV pilot, and a one-woman show written and performed by Grody called The Unexpected 3rd—coming to George Street Playhouse October 13 through November 1st, 2026.
Thanks for listening!
- Subscribe to The Jersey Arts Podcast in your favorite podcast player.
The Jersey Arts Podcast is one medium of Feature Stories on Discover Jersey Arts (jerseyarts.com), where articles and videos also cover New Jersey’s vibrant arts and entertainment scene.
Discover Jersey Arts is presented by ArtPride New Jersey. The program was co-founded by, and is currently supported by funds from, the New Jersey State Council on the Arts.
- Subscribe to the Discover Jersey Arts' weekly e-newsletter to have stories delivered to your inbox.
- Follow and contact us @jerseyarts on Facebook, Instagram and Twitter.
Episode Setup: The Third Act
Maddie OrtonI'm Maddie Orton, and you're listening to the Jersey Arts Podcast. It's in the third act of a three-act story structure when everything comes to a head. The plot builds to its peak, the characters demonstrate development, and the audience, the reader, the listener experiences the story's climax, and maybe even a moral. If the third act is the culmination of everything leading up to it, then the third act of Kathryn Grody's life has been a wild one. The two-time Obie Award-winning actor, mother, grandmother, and wife of actor Mandy Patinkin found new recognition in 2020 when her son posted a video of her in Patinkin that earned them a new overnight fan base. From that viral success, developed the family's "Don't Listen to Us" podcast, a TV pilot, and a one-woman show written and performed by Grody called "The Unexpected 3rd." I chatted with Grody about all of this and more in advance of "The Unexpected 3rd" coming to George Street Playhouse October 13th through November 1st. Take a listen.
A One-Woman Show About Aging
Maddie OrtonKathryn, I'm so excited to talk to you. Thank you for taking the time to chat.
Kathryn GrodyWell, thank you for wanting to talk. That's always great. My favorite thing to do.
Maddie OrtonMine too. I'm very excited. So you wrote and perform a one-woman show called The Unexpected Third, which uses the tagline, and I love this, a radical rollicking rumination on the optimism of staying alive. So tell me a little bit about what the show explores.
Kathryn GrodyWell what that whole thing means. But you know, it was funny when I started doing it. It was like a friend of mine, uh, a director, um Michael Barakiva, where we did a workshop at Cleveland Play. He says, What does that mean, the unexpected third? Is the third kid? Is it baseball? You know, so we came up with all sorts of insane taglines, but that was the one that seemed to be mostly about what this was.
Rage Against Ageism
Kathryn GrodyAnd, you know, it started out some years ago, Maddie, as just me being pissed off at the um assumptions about white-haired people and older people in this culture is so obsessed with being under 30. And I mean the whole world is obsessed. You know, they used to have the hair dye thing, used to be does she or doesn't she? It was all about looking natural. And now it's all about being so proud of how unnatural you look, right? Sure. Let me tell you where you too can have 55 triple F bosoms, you too can have a mouth that looks, you know, like a cartoon. You too can have a face that doesn't move. And in some weird way, I I sometimes wonder if that isn't, besides making the pharmaceutical and beauty company zillions of dollars, making everybody afraid of a natural process if they're lucky enough to experience it, which is called this human aging thing. Yeah. All things living have a process of birth and living and dying. And if you're lucky, you get a lot of time. Uh, you're too young, Maddie, but there you should look this up. There is this extraordinary Twilight Zone episode with Rod Serling. Okay. He was so prescient. There was this, you know, planet, and there were these people, and at 21, they all got the same pig face.
Maddie OrtonOh, yes, I absolutely have not seen it, but it's iconic and I'm aware of it. Yeah.
Kathryn GrodyWell, it is so amazing because that's what I think of all the time. And you know, this gorgeous one young girl didn't want a pig face, she liked her own face.
Maddie OrtonYeah.
Kathryn GrodyAnd I think there is something so terrifying and infuriating and heart sickening about one telling everybody they have to have the same face, like we were used to and still do about the same body. You know, we've sometimes improved on that and sometimes not. The same face. And I find it really frightening when faces don't move. I mean, uh forgive me, I don't know.
Maddie OrtonWell, and as an actor, I'm it's kind of important.
Kathryn GrodyNo, it's well, to me it is, but I'm wondering if this is what we're being trained for, is to just go like this and not, you know. I mean, it's it's terrifying. I cannot tell you how many old friends will tap me on the shoulder and I'll look at them and I'll jump. And I pretend it's because I'm just surprised to see them, but I'm shocked at what I'm seeing. It's a windswept face, you know. Yeah, I know.
Maddie OrtonI know.
Kathryn GrodyIt's and you know, hey, Maddie, truthfully, there's some things that aesthetically are not my favorite things in the whole world. Sure. I've been I'm I'm as vain as a lot of people. I always thought, oh, I'm so lucky, you know, I got my great Aunt May's skin. And it's not bad, you know. I've avoided the sun because I'm terrified of it. So that was sort of lucky. But you know, I had these little lines around my mouth that I said to a very good friend who's an expert in this area, I said, Is there anything I can do about these? And she said, Well, the only thing to do for those is you could have them burned off. So I could go through a process where this layer of skin would be burnt, and then hiding for a month while a new layer of skin grew. And you know, Maddie, I just thought, you know what? Is it worth it? There's there's better things to do with my money, and there's better things to focus on, and I'm glad I have a mount that still works. Right. You know? Right. So the whole thing was initially a rebuttal and just I'm just so pissed off. And then as I've worked on it over the years, Maddie, it's just become, I must
When The Body Forces Honesty
Kathryn Grodysay, you know, I first did it publicly in the winter of '22, and we were still just coming out of COVID. Sure. And so people in the theater, everybody was amassed, and they were sort of giddy about being out together again. And when I first did it, it was just sort of like a stand up. I mean, it was interesting because five years ago, I really didn't feel any different than when I was 60 or 15. And it was kind of like, oh, this aging stuff is just bullshit. Yeah. Five years later, Maddie, there is some there is some truth to the actuality of it. And I have been uh forced, I felt I've been very lucky, you know. Um, and there's a whole section in the play where I'm like really trashing my mother-in-law, you know, for never exercising and eating garbage, and I'm not gonna be like her because I take care of this body and I'm gonna depart with all my original body parts. And then I say to people, well, in full transparency, guess what I have? A brand new ceramic joint, otherwise known as a hip replacement, and I can't stop talking about it either, you know. Um, stuff you have this illusion of what you're in control of.
Maddie OrtonYeah.
Kathryn GrodyAnd then things happen. And the impact also between what's happening in the world, which I talk about, and what is happening to your chosen kin and friends. I mean, I'm I'm pretty much losing a couple friends a month at this point. And if they're not dying, they're debilitated or they're having unexpected surgery. And um, and then you contrast that with what we seem to be out of control of with the world. You know. I was talking to a brilliant friend of mine the other day, Dr. Diane Meyer, who is a gerontologist and a palliative care person. And she said, Isn't it, and I'm gonna put this in the play, Maddie. Okay. She said, Isn't it amazing that as individuals, at least in America, we do everything we can to live as long as possible. We replace joints, we replace our faces with some other mask of a face that denies the age we are, we take 1,400 supplements and you don't do anything else except try and stay here and deny this aging process. But as a species, we seem not to be able to stop inventing things that can do us in. And I just thought that was such a brilliant observation and contrast, you know.
Maddie OrtonWhat I'm
Cutting It Down Without Cutting Truth
Maddie Ortonwondering is there's so much to talk about in this area. How did you narrow this down into a one-person show and keep it under 10 hours? Because there's a lot to say about it.
Kathryn GrodyThat's a really good question, Maddie. And uh the most obvious answer is I have a very strict director, Timothy Mere, who I've done. This is my third solo show with her, and we've been working together. We've known each other for 50 years, Maddie, which is kind of shocking. You know, I remember I said to her recently, do you remember when I said I feel as if I've known you for 50 years when we first met, and now we really have known each other? Yeah. One, she's she feels very strongly. She's very happy if the show's one hour and 20 minutes. I feel it's fine if it's one hour and 25. She's you know, better than that's a reasonable wiggle room. That's not crazy. I mean, it's an interesting process because with each iteration, I want it to be current about what is happening now. Got it. You know, four years ago, I didn't talk about masked fascists roaming the streets, but now we have them roaming the streets, so I put that in. You know, four years ago I didn't have a new body part. Now that's in. Four years ago, I hadn't lost really important people in my life. So I have to deal with that too. And in some ways, I mean, part of this, part of the intention of this, Maddie, is to make young people like yourself not terrified of the aging process and not to think it's just like all 13-year-olds aren't alike, all two-year-olds aren't all alike, all 70-somethings aren't all alike. Right. And the aging process isn't all alike, you know?
Accidental Fame And Pandemic Connection
Maddie OrtonSo you have written three plays.
Kathryn GrodyI've written three solo shows, yeah.
Maddie OrtonAnd between your last play and this play, you and your husband, Mandy Patinkin, and your son Gideon have really blown up in a totally new way in sort of the influencer universe. You're also coming from a different perspective now. Right. How have those two aspects of your life influenced this creative process, if they have?
Kathryn GrodyWell, the whole social media thing, Maddie, has just been so shocking and remains so, because, and I talk about this too, that I am a living contradiction between how I feel about the form and my participation in it. Which I was completely accidental. I'm a digital idiot. And I really do feel that for all the hopeful connectedness that people started out believing this technology would bring, you just didn't have any idea about the fear and the madness and the viciousness of how our species can be when we're not face to face with each other.
Maddie OrtonSure.
Kathryn GrodyAnd, you know, this was a complete accident of COVID. If COVID hadn't happened, we wouldn't be having this discussion. And I would not be a known person. You know, it's very uh interesting to have this kind of public persona at the age of, you know, 78. And in some ways, Maddie, it's really phenomenal because, you know, for my 20s, 30s, 40s, 50s, and 60s, Maddie and early 70s, uh if I was known at all, you know, outside my little bubble of off-Broadway theater, I was known as Mandy Patinkin's wife and Diane Keaton's best friend. So that whenever anybody And you know, that was fine because I didn't want what either of them wanted.
Maddie OrtonRight.
Kathryn GrodyI wanted my little off-Broadway niche and to be able to have time between shows to be with my kids.
Maddie OrtonSure. And and also probably to go to the supermarket and not be harassed.
Kathryn GrodyYeah, I mean, none of that, none of that um appealed to me and I didn't need it. You know, over the years, people would say to me, I mean, when I met Mandy, I was the more known off-Broadway person. I'm six years older. He was kind of the upcoming kid that was controversial, you know. And um, I mean, people would say, How do you feel when he did a Vita about the attention? I'd say, you know, as long as I get my 40% of attention from my little things, I'm fine. But those two can have the 150 they need, you know. Um but what's been interesting during COVID, Maddie, it felt like a service. Do you know? I mean, my son came home, he was working all across the country, but he couldn't do what he was doing. He had to come home. It was COVID. And when he asked us, you know, in April of 20, and that's a little j challenging now because when I did the play in 22, it was closer to that, and now we're further away. So I have to say, do y'all remember this? I don't think people have really spoken enough or dealt with how tech that that pandemic impacted our social behavior, our comfort with each other, the mistrust with all the bullshit online that people fall into uh combined to make us more comfortable in this form than in person. But he just asked us on April 16th of 2020 how we'd celebrated the anniversary of our first date, which we always celebrate. And he had just come home, Maddie. We were still walking six feet apart, you know. Oh my gosh, sure. And I said we'd had a huge fight. And I described the fight and the resolution, and then he said, Can I post this? I did not know what he was talking about, Maddie. I swear to you. And you know, our only social media at that time was a little tiny thing for the International Rescue Committee, IRC, because both of our grandparents were immigrants, so we feel very strongly about welcoming immigrants and still do. Absolutely. And so we're ambassadors for IRC, and Gideon was upset that it only had a couple thousand followers, you know, and he thought if he put something more personal on, that it would it would invite people to learn more about how they can support immigrants. So I said, I don't care. I mean, I had no idea what our talking about a fight on an anniversary was gonna appeal to anybody. And two days later, Maddie, he came and said, Well, this is really interesting. I said, What? He said, Well, you had 400,000 views. Oh my gosh. And I said, of what? Of what? You know, and then he explained this, and then we just went for there. And I will tell you truthfully, during COVID, it felt very good to do anything we could to make people feel in a community, feel less afraid, feel hopeful. And then it felt very good to work for the election. Right. Um, I would do anything. I did the most embarrassing things to get 18-year-olds to vote. I mean, you know, TikTok made Twitter look like Shakespeare at that time. I just couldn't be believed what I was asked to do. That's great. But we did it and we felt, you know, wow, we've recovered, and then of course, here we are again. Um, but I think it's really interesting. I think fame is so unhealthy for children and other living things. Maddie.
Maddie OrtonAre you experiencing that in a way? Well, how does that feel for you now? And how does that interact with the show itself? Like I assume there's a totally different audience coming to see you in addition to the audience that would normally see.
Kathryn GrodyWell, it's funny, I don't think I would have had as significant of an audience without social media.
Maddie OrtonHuh.
Kathryn GrodyYou know. Um, and it was interesting when we posted at the solo festival at New York Theater Workshop, which was kind of a festival, just very impromptually organized. What got people in was when we said there's a talk back afterwards. And suddenly we had to get to have the experience, to interact. And I live in a state of, you know, sort of semi-terror. If I see somebody and they act like they know me, and I think, oh my God, is it a cousin or is it somebody from high school or college that I don't remember? And then they say, Oh, no, no, I just know you from social media. And I feel very wonderful when somebody says, Thank you for getting me through the pandemic. That's great. And I feel wonderful when people talk about politics. Do you know?
Maddie OrtonMm-hmm.
Kathryn GrodyWhen it's just, you know, sort of being ridiculous.
Maddie OrtonOkay.
Kathryn GrodyI don't know what I feel to tell you the truth, Maddie. It is, I'll tell you the dangerous thing. I think for young people, this is why, you know, I met Diane before "Annie Hall ."
Maddie OrtonOkay. Oh, so you saw that.
Kathryn GrodyAnd any celebrity will tell you the people they met before that, before celebrity and after, the ones before celebrity are the ones you really trust, no matter what good friends you make. Because it's just they see you for who you are and not all that. Fancy shit. And um I have a strong definition of who I am. You know, it doesn't come from the outside, and it certainly did in the beginning, you know, I think.
Maddie OrtonI mean, for an actor, that's it's difficult, you know. It's weird looks are so tied to the product that is you.
Kathryn GrodyYeah, but I was always a character actress, Maddie. I was never, you know, a looks actress. And I was a theater person and not a movie person. Right. You know, I understand that. I mean, uh, there's this whole thing that Howard Hawkes once said about film that people that love being photographed emit a kind of chemistry that the the camera picks up. And I'm one of those people, I look at that cameraman and I think I turn into flat Stanley. I don't know if you know those children's books. I mean, it's
From Internet Audience To Live Theater
Kathryn Grodylike I'm looking for the audience, do you know? Interesting. The audience, the people is what makes sense to me. I have huge respect for people that do gorgeous work in movies and television, and I'm grateful that my husband has learned that form because I find it exhausting, Maddie. I mean, when we did our pilot, you know, I didn't remember that my my ears were connected to my son and his fellow director, you and Wright. Oh. And I would always go, why are we doing this again?
Maddie OrtonAnd then they'd come. Then he would go, hot mic, hot mic.
Kathryn GrodyHot mic, hot mic, and they'd come, they'd come running and say, Well, there was a mic, or there was a boom, or there was a shadow. And I go, Oh, right, you know, but well, I'm in this in this form. It's just me and the people in the audience, do you know? And it's a little scary. Maddie, this is the biggest theater I've done.
Maddie OrtonOh, wonderful.
Kathryn GrodyIt is the biggest theater. With this show. With this show, it's the biggest theater. And I have to do, we're re-staging it because when I did it at the solo fest at New York Theater Workshop, we had a more portable set. So we restaged it for Marin Shakespeare, where we did it in March, and then we had that production for the Solo Fest at New York Theater Workshop in May and June. And now it's been July, August, September, three enormous months, which may not seem long, but I got pneumonia. And I haven't done my workout routine. And I just did a little dancing for two minutes before this interview and was huffing and frigging puffing. And you know. And you're the only one on stage. That's uh, everyone on stage.
Maddie OrtonYeah.
Adapt, Don’t Surrender To Reality
Maddie OrtonWhat is the takeaway for you about the idea of your unexpected third act?
Kathryn GrodyI have a line about adapting, not surrendering to the new realities. Do you know? And I feel that the message, um, you know, uh, one of my great surprises with this show, Maddie, I thought people over 50 would relate, you know. But I've been surprised by the people in their 20s, 30s, and 40s. Because a beautiful 36-year-old woman came up to me. I wish I'd gotten her name. She said, Catherine, it's my 36th birthday, and the gift you gave me as you made getting older look exciting. That's amazing. And that's just amazing. Or a young woman, 45, came up to me and said, I have to tell you the impact. I canceled my first Botox appointment tomorrow. Isn't that amazing?
Maddie OrtonYou know, what's funny to me is I I was looking at this and it reminded me of something that my grandmother told me once, which I was visiting her and she was hanging with a friend of hers. They were probably both in there early to like early mid 80s at the time. And I remember them talking about the age that they felt.
Kathryn GrodyYeah.
Maddie OrtonAnd it was really interesting to me because I was probably in my early 20s, and my grandmother was a very unorthodox person in many ways. But she and her friend basically said, Well, I'm still 16. And I went, Wow, that's really interesting. And as I get older, I feel the same way. I think it's so funny that that person called me ma'am because I'm 16. That's so weird.
Kathryn GrodyWell, just wait. Maddie, but um you know Norman Lear said my favorite thing when he was ninety-five, somebody asked him how old he felt. And he thought about it for a minute and he said, I feel the same age as whoever I'm talking to. Interesting. And you know, it is it's a very funny thing, Maddie. I will tell you, uh, you have a flash bulletin on this. The last birthday that I was freaked out about was my 50th.
Maddie OrtonOkay.
Kathryn GrodyI was freaked out. I talk about it in the play. I just couldn't imagine being that old. You know, I haven't thought about, you know, 60, 65, 70, 75. I don't feel any different. This upcoming birthday has staggered me. The number of eight zero is I mean, there is a reality about the limited amount of time, do you know, that I can't sort of be vague about anymore. But I don't want to focus. I don't want to, if I've got five years left or ten years, I don't want to be afraid of the quality of those years, and I don't want to be focused on it. But something weird has happened, and I think it's my attitude, which I've got to get back into being into not mattering of what number you are, because suddenly I'm in cabs in New York City, and when I get out, four times the drivers have run out to help me out. And I'm like, that's a version of your ma'am, you know? It's like, what the hell has happened that three months ago did not happen at all. That didn't happen to me once when I was doing the play four times a week for six weeks. Not at all. So do you think it's the aura you're giving on? I think there might be some aura I'm giving out, or maybe a weird way I'm getting into the cab, or the fact that I'm, you know, haven't done my usual whatevers, you know. But I think um my takeaway that you asked is I love the idea, Maddie, of being forever unfinished. I'm in a constant state of evolution. Who, you know, who I was 50 years ago is not who I was, you know, who you are 20, 30, 40, it's all different. It's like that thing that you all your all your skin cells change every seven years or something. Right. I don't see why that should stop. You know, I want to surprise myself, I want to have new experiences. I, and believe me, I think part of what has changed as I lose friends, as I have more physical challenges or the world, I want to acknowledge that. This is not a friggin' Hallmark card, you know. But I want also to put the darkness and the fear, okay, yeah. You know, I mean, the other day, for the first time in my entire life, I used my hands to get at my arms to get out of a chair. And I went, when the hell did that happen? Well, so it happened that moment. It was a very low chair. Um and I went, so what? I'm upright.
Maddie OrtonRight.
Kathryn GrodyI'm upright and I'm walking on my own, you know? I mean, I think that like your grandmother, the image that you have of yourself, the shocking thing is you experience yourself very differently than how people on the outside. Somebody took a video of my son, took a video of me playing soccer with my four-year-old grandchild. And I I imagined myself really, but I was kind of hunchy. And it shocked the shit out of me, you know. Um and you know, the the effort to proceed with curiosity and enthusiasm and what I say in here, exuberance. And and if you're having a bad day, you know, okay. I friggin' hate, I am so shocked that I have hearing things. I didn't listen to one rock concert. I never listened to friggin' music. I cannot believe this. I don't like it. It's one of the few things I'm embarrassed about. If it's public, kind of, you know, my poor husband said, Do you have uh your hearing aids? And I said they're accessories. They're freaking accessories. And that's my business. And it's nobody, you know, and you know what, Maddie? Now I say in public in the show, hey, right, instead of thinking of these as a humiliation, think of this as an announcement. I'm not opting out of the common conversation. Right. I'm not gonna absolve myself of it. I have things to say and I have things to learn. You know?
Maddie OrtonIt sounds to me like so much of what your perspective is and your show is about focuses on viewpoint, on realigning your perspective and re-sort of defining what each of these aspects of aging is creating.
Kathryn GrodyYeah. And that you can define it for yourself and your own circumstances. Do you know?
Maddie OrtonYeah, I love that.
Kathryn GrodyAnd I feel that I just want to encourage everybody to evolve at any age and not assume that they should do something, do you know, because of a number that they are or that they are limited by that number. You know, and and whatever limitations there are, then you adapt.
Curtain Call And How To Listen
Maddie OrtonThank you so much for doing this interview. It was great to talk to you, and I'm so excited for your show.
Kathryn GrodyThank you, Maddie. I hope you can come and please come backstage and say hi, or wherever they have me say hi.
Maddie OrtonKathryn Grody will perform "The Unexpected 3rd" from October 13th through November 1st at George Street Playhouse. For more information, visit GeorgeStreetPlayhouse.org. If you like this episode, be sure to give us a review, subscribe, and tell your friends. A transcript of this podcast, as well as links to related content and more about the arts in New Jersey, can be found on jerseyarts.com. The Jersey Arts Podcast is presented by Art Pride New Jersey, advancing a state of creativity since 1986. The show is co-founded by and currently supported by funds from the New Jersey State Council on the Arts. This episode was hosted, produced, and edited by yours truly, Maddie Orton. Executive producer is Jim Atkinson. Special thanks to Kathryn Grody and George Street Playhouse. I'm Maddie Orton for the Jersey Arts Podcast. Thanks for listening.