The Astors and the Ghosts of Mackinac Island (Part One)

Unsinkable: The Titanic Podcast

Unsinkable: The Titanic Podcast
The Astors and the Ghosts of Mackinac Island (Part One)
Oct 07, 2025
L.A. Beadles

The Astor family name conjures images of Gilded Age opulence and tragedy—perhaps most famously embodied by John Jacob Astor IV, who perished aboard the Titanic in 1912. But the roots of one of America's first great fortunes stretch back much further, to the late 18th century when German immigrant John Jacob Astor built a fur trading empire that spanned from the Great Lakes to the Pacific Northwest. His American Fur Company turned remote outposts like Mackinac Island into crucial commercial hubs, fundamentally shaping the economic development of the American frontier. Over multiple generations, the Astors transformed their wilderness wealth into New York real estate, political influence, and cultural prestige, creating a dynasty that helped define what it meant to be American aristocracy but all built on the backs of the enslaved, the poor, the immigrants. Their story is one of ambition, innovation, and the complex legacy of fortunes built on both opportunity and exploitation during a pivotal era in American history. Part One explores the roots of all this. Part Two will explore the spiritual, physical, and cultural ghosts and legacies of Mackinac Island itself.

The Root article I mentioned about slavery and NYC: https://www.theroot.com/how-slave-labor-made-new-york-1790895122

To support the pod and purchase the books I recommended:

*Peter Stark’s Astoria: https://bookshop.org/a/80949/9780062964663

*Anderson Cooper’s Astor: https://bookshop.org/a/80949/9781482992199

Support the show

Support Unsinkable on Patreon for as little as $1/month: https://www.patreon.com/unsinkablepod

Or buy me a coffee!: https://www.buymeacoffee.com/labeadles

Buy Unsinkable shirts here!: https://www.bonfire.com/unsinkable-the-first-t-shirt/

Support the pod via my Bookshop Storefront: https://bookshop.org/shop/unsinkablepod

Find me on Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/unsinkablepod/

Episode Artwork The Astors and the Ghosts of Mackinac Island (Part One) 52:33 Episode Artwork What If: Captain Smith Survived? (w/ Pablo O'Hana) 46:24 Episode Artwork State of the Podcast w/ L.A. (+ Season Five Coming SOON!) 15:24 Episode Artwork What If: Titanic Had Enough Lifeboats? w/ Pablo O'Hana 45:49 Episode Artwork The Gorgeous Liberation of One Rose Dawson 50:11 Episode Artwork What If: James Cameron's Titanic Flopped?! (w/ Pablo O'Hana) 47:06 Episode Artwork What If: Robert Ballard Never Found the Wreck of Titanic? (with Pablo O'Hana) 54:33 Episode Artwork What If: Bruce Ismay Never Boarded Titanic? (with Pablo O'Hana) 1:06:42 Episode Artwork Introducing New Episodes From Unsinkable: What If 0:45 Episode Artwork Unsinkable: Harriet Tubman 1:23:32 Episode Artwork An Obsession with Size and Luxury! The White Star Line and Titanic's Marketing, featuring Pablo O'Hana 1:27:42 Episode Artwork On Site with "Titanic: An Immersive Voyage," featuring Exhibit Director John Zaller 45:33 Episode Artwork Hurricane Helene Update--We're Safe! 5:00 Episode Artwork Death to "Guilty Pleasures": Titanic, Things Girls Love, and Claiming our Space in Mass Media 1:05:32 Episode Artwork We Need to Talk About RMS Titanic Inc., with Special Guest Pablo O'Hana 1:35:41 Episode Artwork An Amazing Disney Deep-Dive with Jamie Didawick 1:47:44 Episode Artwork Season Finale: Three Years with Titanic 44:49 Episode Artwork This is Not a Door: Titanic's Iconic Movie Prop and its New Home at Titanic Museum Attraction 49:31 Episode Artwork Michael "Ty" Joseph (Yusuf), Titanic's "Miracle Boy" 39:21 Episode Artwork Titanic at 112 + Unsinkable Live at Pigeon Forge! 1:27:14 Episode Artwork Cross-post with Salem The Podcast: Titanic Survivor Elizabeth Lines 1:25:37 Episode Artwork An Interview with Actor Cotter Smith: Unpacking Senator Smith + the Titanic Inquiry's Legacy 41:53 Episode Artwork Revisiting The Six + the Stories of Titanic's Chinese Passengers, with Steven Schwankert 1:10:04 Episode Artwork An Emergency Titanic Meeting, with Pablo O'Hana! 1:29:57 Episode Artwork From 3,000 Miles Away: Artie Moore and a Wireless Dream 44:17