The Couch Critics

From Feel-Good to Feel-Weird: A Christmas Movie Deep Dive

Season 5 Episode 106

Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.

0:00 | 27:58

"Send us a Text!"

In this festive episode, Lexie and Nathan dive into four very different holiday films: The Christmas Chronicles, Noel, Silent Night, and The Great Rupert — and let’s just say… not all Christmas movies land on the “nice” list.

They kick things off with The Christmas Chronicles, praising its energetic adventure, sharp humor, and that scene-stealing take on Santa that brought genuine holiday magic. Then they rewind the clock to The Great Rupert, celebrating its old-school charm, heartfelt storytelling, and the surprisingly delightful acrobatic squirrel that won them over.

But when it comes to Noel and Silent Night, the stockings are noticeably emptier. Lexie and Nathan unpack why Noel felt more saccharine than sincere, and why Silent Night’s bleak, end-of-the-world holiday tone left them cold rather than contemplative. From uneven scripts to tonal whiplash, they don’t hold back on what didn’t work.

It’s a lively, honest conversation full of laughs, a little frustration, and a reminder that even when a movie misses the mark, it still makes for a spirited discussion.

Follow us:

Facebook - Couch Critic Podcast

Instagram - @thecouchcriticpod

Podcasts we love

Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.

Is THIS For Kids? Artwork

Is THIS For Kids?

Jonathan 'Bearded' Blevins and Katie 'MrsRuvi' Ruvalcaba
Film Bros. Championship Podcast - Film Discussion; Top Films of a year in a genre Artwork

Film Bros. Championship Podcast - Film Discussion; Top Films of a year in a genre

Throw the Knife Productions - Film Bros / Top Films of Year / Film Discussion