Evil Twins: True Crime Cases That Will Haunt You Artwork

Everything Vaguely Paranormal

Are you a fan of the unknown? Do you revel in the mysterious, the unexplained, and the eeriness of the paranormal world? Indulge in our chilling collection of paranormal podcasts, where you’ll immerse yourself in creepy stories and ghost adventures like never before. From supernatural shows exploring UFOs, witchcraft, and mysteries that defy explanation, to folklore and legends that echo through the ages, Everything Vaguely Paranormal Podcast encapsulates the essence of what makes the paranormal genre so captivating! Unveil the secrets of haunted places and uncharted territories, guided by experts in shadow people, spirits, true crimes, demons, devils, and cryptids, as we delve fearlessly into the depths of the unknown.
Embark on mind-bending journeys through the enigmatic realm of conspiracies, questioning the very fabric of reality. Come have a laugh and hear a spine-chilling adventure along the way. Unlock the gateway to the other side and embrace the mysteries that lie beyond our comprehension, as new episodes drop weekly on Wednesdays.

All Episodes

Everything Vaguely Paranormal

Evil Twins: True Crime Cases That Will Haunt You

December 17, 2025 • Shelly Pruitt, Ryan Roberts, and Blake Smith • Season 5 • Episode 215

Send us a text

This episode dives into the chilling world of evil twins through true crime cases where identical siblings become entangled in murder, deception, and psychological conflict. We explore the disturbing stories of Gregg and Jeff Henry, Betty Wilson and Peggy Lowe, plus other twin cases that challenge investigators and unsettle entire communities. These accounts reveal how mirrored identities complicate evidence, blur motives, and spark intense public fascination. Each story exposes the darker side of twin dynamics and the eerie complications that arise when blame becomes impossible to separate by appearance alone. Prepare for a suspense-filled deep dive into some of the most unnerving twin cases ever recorded.

Watch the video version here: https://youtube.com/live/G17yCokOYYM

Don't forget, you can watch us live on Tuesday nights at 8PM CST - U.S. on YouTube and Facebook!

Support the Show:
Patreon (Bonus Content)

Follow us on Social Media:
YouTube Channel
Facebook Fan Page
Instagram Fan Page
X (formerly Twitter)
TikTok Fan Page

"After Dark with EVP" (Use code "AFTERDARK25" for 25% off an annual subscription)
https://bit.ly/46GOmAz

Submit Your Story, Comments, or Questions:
theevppod@gmail.com