A celebrated waterway can also be a wound. We open the Erie Canal’s familiar legend and find the story most of us never learned: how a triumph of engineering cut a dam through Haudenosaunee homelands, accelerated dispossession, and rewrote law, faith, and landscape in its wake. With Haudenosaunee leaders and scholars, we move from a condensed Thanksgiving Address into original instructions about water, winds, and the seven generations ethic, then confront the doctrine of Christian discovery—from papal bulls to Johnson v. M’Intosh—still echoing through U.S. property law.

Along the towpath, we trace the canal’s hidden cargo: land speculation, conflicts of interest, alcohol and other “mind changers,” and the quiet burial of treaty promises like Canandaigua’s “forever.” We connect those ruptures to the burned-over district, where new American religions—Latter-day Saints, Millerites, spiritualists, Shakers—flared as migrants grappled with dislocation and meaning. The canal didn’t just move grain; it moved imaginations, laws, and borders, often at the expense of communities who had long practiced diplomacy through the Great Law of Peace and the Two Row Wampum’s commitment to travel side by side without interference.

We also spotlight the Skä·noñh—Great Law of Peace Center’s work to flip the narrative on unceded Onondaga Nation territory, centering Indigenous values and living governance rather than artifacts. This is not nostalgia; it’s a practical invitation to measure progress by future faces, to see water as kin, and to treat treaties as living commitments. Press play to rethink what the Erie Canal made—and unmade—and to imagine a path from commemoration to repair. If this conversation moved you, subscribe, share it with a friend, and leave a review so more listeners can find these stories.

Support the show

View the transcript and show notes at podcast.doctrineofdiscovery.org. Learn more about the Doctrine of Discovery on our site DoctrineofDiscovery.org.