Fair is the Four Letter Word: Why Chasing Fairness Keeps People Stuck in Divorce

Divorce Coaches Academy

Divorce Coaches Academy
Fair is the Four Letter Word: Why Chasing Fairness Keeps People Stuck in Divorce
Jan 07, 2026 Season 1 Episode 192
Tracy Callahan and Debra Doak

Send Us a Message (include your contact info if you'd like a reply)

Fair sounds virtuous, but it’s the quiet saboteur of many divorce negotiations. We pull back the curtain on how fairness language derails progress, fuels story stacking, and turns negotiations into a tribunal of the past instead of a plan for the future. When each person holds a private definition of “fair,” the gap widens, defensiveness rises, and workable options get torpedoed—not because they fail the kids or the law, but because they fail a sense of symmetry.

We make the case for a different target: good enough. That doesn’t mean settling for less; it means designing an agreement that functions under stress, reduces future touch points, and keeps emotional reengagement to a minimum. You’ll hear how to stress-test proposals with real-life questions—what happens when communication breaks down, when one parent is tired, or when compliance wobbles—and why agreements should be built for human behavior, not ideal behavior. We also draw a clear boundary: courts and mediation structures allocate responsibility and create enforceable terms; they don’t repair emotional inequity. Trying to extract justice from a system built for decisions guarantees frustration.

If you’re a divorce professional or coach, we share practical tools to help clients move from moral certainty to strategic flexibility, normalize disappointment as part of transition, and measure success by fewer future conflicts. And if you’re navigating divorce yourself, this conversation offers a steady off-ramp: stop chasing perfect balance and start building sustainable peace. 

Ready to trade fairness for function and finally get finished? 

Subscribe, share this episode with a colleague or friend, and leave a review with your biggest takeaway or question—we’d love to hear what “good enough” looks like for you.

Learn more about DCA® or any of the classes or events mentioned in this episode at the links below:

Website: www.divorcecoachesacademy.com
Instagram: @divorcecoachesacademy
LinkedIn: divorce-coaches-academy
Email: DCA@divorcecoachesacademy.com

Episode Artwork Fair is the Four Letter Word: Why Chasing Fairness Keeps People Stuck in Divorce 21:23 Episode Artwork Diversity in Divorce Coaching: A Reflection on Access, Trust, and Effectiveness 31:57 Episode Artwork Artificial Intelligence and Divorce Coaching: Will AI Take Our Jobs or Help Us Do Them Better? 25:29 Episode Artwork The Most Dangerous Sentence in Divorce 23:21 Episode Artwork Roadmap To A Sustainable ADR Divorce Coaching Practice 36:22 Episode Artwork Reframing Conflict in Divorce Coaching: From Pathology to Pragmatism 18:59 Episode Artwork ​​​​Preparing for Divorce Month: Coaching for an Exit Strategy 40:20 Episode Artwork When Men Divorce: Exploring the Male Experience in Divorce Coaching 37:03 Episode Artwork Navigating Divorce When Family Advice Clashes With Resolution 30:39 Episode Artwork How Thoughtful Parenting Plans Reduce Conflict And Protect Kids 39:30 Episode Artwork Defining Divorce Coaching: Role, Boundaries, and Impact 25:08 Episode Artwork The Power of Mentorship: Guiding Growth in the Divorce Coaching Journey 24:34 Episode Artwork Breaking the Cycle: How Confirmation Bias Keeps Divorcing Couples Trapped in Conflict 35:28 Episode Artwork Inside New Zealand’s FDR Shake-Up: Free Mediation, Fewer Supports, and the Case for Coaching 34:20 Episode Artwork Fear-Driven Divorce: Unpacking Client Anxieties 23:12 Episode Artwork Brick by Brick: Divorce Lessons from the Three Little Pigs 17:59 Episode Artwork Waiting for Sorry: Moving Beyond Apologies in Divorce 20:40 Episode Artwork When Drinking Concerns Meet Custody: The Soberlink Solution 32:41 Episode Artwork The Unexpected Professionals Reshaping Divorce Support with Canadian Director Dori Braddell 24:25 Episode Artwork Who's On My Side? Helping Clients Navigate Conflicts with Their Divorce Team 24:31 Episode Artwork Why Some Divorces Cost $3,000 and Others Cost $300,000 24:48 Episode Artwork Clients, Credibility, and Cashflow: Real Talk About The Time It Takes to Build Your Business 17:37 Episode Artwork Nesting Sounds Nice… But Does It Actually Work? 25:40 Episode Artwork When Empathy Becomes Too Heavy: Managing Compassion Fatigue in Divorce Coaching 30:58 Episode Artwork The Courts Can't Heal Heartbreak: It's an Inside Job 35:39