Build the Church

Planting Legacy in New York

Josh Roberie Season 2 Episode 7

Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.

0:00 | 26:43

Planting in Manhattan: Divine Timing, NYC Myths, & Pastoring at a Sustainable Pace | Ryan Schlachter

What happens when God calls you to plant a church in the heart of New York City—and lands you in the exact same ballroom where your grandmother ran a street ministry four decades earlier?

In this episode of the Build the Church Podcast, host Josh Roberie sits down with native New Yorker and lead pastor of Legacy Church NYC, Ryan Schlachter. Ryan shares the unbelievable story of launching Legacy Church in Manhattan, debunks common misconceptions about pastoring in big cities, and breaks down the practical systems needed to disciple people in a fast-paced, transient environment.

🎙️ Key Takeaways from This Episode:

  • The Power of God's Timing: The story behind planting in the Prince George Ballroom and honoring a family legacy that spans generations.
  • Debunking NYC Myths: Why New Yorkers are actually friendly (and family-oriented) despite the stereotypes.
  • Overcoming Transience: How to invest deeply in leaders even when you know they might eventually move away.
  • Setting the Pace of Ministry: Why matching the frantic speed of your city burns your team out—and how to build a culture of sustainable joy instead.
  • Being a Lighthouse: How to pastor in the middle of cultural friction without "clutching your pearls."
  • Neighborhood-Based Systems: How Legacy Church uses localized groups and weekly prayer to combat urban loneliness.

🔗 Resources & Links Mentioned:

  • This Episode's Sponsor: Try YourTeam Pro Tier free for 30 days at yourteam.church — Upgrade your Next Steps class with custom-branded, AI-powered personality assessments for volunteer matching!
  • Connect with Ryan: Follow Pastor Ryan Schlachter and team on social media or check out legacychurch.nyc.
  • Build the Church Podcast: Stay connected with Josh Roberie for practical advice, best practices, and encouragement to help you grow your church and go the distance in ministry.

If you enjoyed this episode, please take a moment to leave a rating and review on Apple Podcasts or Spotify—it helps other pastors and leaders find the show!


Support the show