{"version":"1.0.0","segments":[{"speaker":"Alexey ","startTime":0.0,"endTime":2.01,"body":"You know, I think that"},{"speaker":"Alexey ","startTime":0.0,"endTime":2.01,"body":"people are curious to learn how"},{"speaker":"Alexey ","startTime":2.01,"endTime":6.48,"body":"we bought a trillion-dollar"},{"speaker":"Alexey ","startTime":2.01,"endTime":6.48,"body":"hockey stick. Taliy, you've been"},{"speaker":"Alexey ","startTime":6.48,"endTime":10.74,"body":"learning this for quite some"},{"speaker":"Alexey ","startTime":6.48,"endTime":10.74,"body":"time already. And this was the"},{"speaker":"Alexey ","startTime":10.74,"endTime":15.12,"body":"topic of your speech during the"},{"speaker":"Alexey ","startTime":10.74,"endTime":15.12,"body":"international online forum,"},{"speaker":"Alexey ","startTime":15.42,"endTime":18.45,"body":"Global Crisis. We Are People. We"},{"speaker":"Alexey ","startTime":15.42,"endTime":18.45,"body":"Want To Live, which took place"},{"speaker":"Alexey ","startTime":18.45,"endTime":24.75,"body":"on May 7th, 2022. And I guess"},{"speaker":"Alexey ","startTime":18.45,"endTime":24.75,"body":"that, right now in our team,"},{"speaker":"Alexey ","startTime":24.75,"endTime":30.42,"body":"there's no other person who has"},{"speaker":"Alexey ","startTime":24.75,"endTime":30.42,"body":"the bigger and deeper knowledge"},{"speaker":"Alexey ","startTime":30.42,"endTime":34.47,"body":"than yourself. So what can we"},{"speaker":"Alexey ","startTime":30.42,"endTime":34.47,"body":"tell our guys, our listeners,"},{"speaker":"Alexey ","startTime":34.47,"endTime":34.92,"body":"today?"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":35.58,"endTime":39.12,"body":"Thank you so much,"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":35.58,"endTime":39.12,"body":"Alexey. So yeah, you know, when"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":39.12,"endTime":43.41,"body":"we found out that there is a"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":39.12,"endTime":43.41,"body":"huge backlash from anthropogenic"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":43.74,"endTime":47.49,"body":"justice warriors on Twitter"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":43.74,"endTime":47.49,"body":"against Creative Society,"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":47.49,"endTime":51.06,"body":"against our previous conference,"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":47.49,"endTime":51.06,"body":"which took place on December"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":51.06,"endTime":55.62,"body":"4th, 2021. And we were just"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":51.06,"endTime":55.62,"body":"curious, like, what's going on"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":55.62,"endTime":58.74,"body":"with these guys? Why are they so"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":55.62,"endTime":58.74,"body":"aggressive, like, you know, they"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":58.74,"endTime":62.85,"body":"really passionately started"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":58.74,"endTime":62.85,"body":"hating on us and trying to"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":62.85,"endTime":66.78,"body":"stigmatize us on Twitter,"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":62.85,"endTime":66.78,"body":"without even knowing what"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":66.78,"endTime":70.05,"body":"Creative Society is, without"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":66.78,"endTime":70.05,"body":"trying to learn what we"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":70.05,"endTime":76.41,"body":"represent. Right away we were"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":70.05,"endTime":76.41,"body":"stigmatized as some group"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":76.41,"endTime":80.28,"body":"financed by oil companies, which"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":76.41,"endTime":80.28,"body":"is ridiculous. I was like, wow,"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":80.31,"endTime":84.6,"body":"where is this coming from? And"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":80.31,"endTime":84.6,"body":"then I was, I was seeing that"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":84.6,"endTime":87.9,"body":"there's this guy, Michael E."},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":84.6,"endTime":87.9,"body":"Mann."},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":88.92,"endTime":93.48,"body":"That was the first time I heard"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":88.92,"endTime":93.48,"body":"about this guy. And he was also"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":93.51,"endTime":97.29,"body":"posting some dirt about Creative"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":93.51,"endTime":97.29,"body":"Society. And I see he got like,"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":97.32,"endTime":101.49,"body":"200,000 followers, and these"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":97.32,"endTime":101.49,"body":"guys are retweeting him, like,"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":101.52,"endTime":106.14,"body":"who's that guy? And then I said,"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":101.52,"endTime":106.14,"body":"that's how we picked up on this"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":106.17,"endTime":110.73,"body":"stuff that each one of these"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":106.17,"endTime":110.73,"body":"anthropogenic justice warriors,"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":110.76,"endTime":116.43,"body":"reposting this funny graph, some"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":110.76,"endTime":116.43,"body":"funny graphs, and then I started"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":116.43,"endTime":120.12,"body":"looking into them, I was like,"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":116.43,"endTime":120.12,"body":"Oh, wait, let me learn about"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":120.12,"endTime":124.71,"body":"this thing. So basically, in"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":120.12,"endTime":124.71,"body":"December, January, January 2022,"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":124.71,"endTime":130.02,"body":"I started looking into it. And"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":124.71,"endTime":130.02,"body":"then when we found out how much"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":130.92,"endTime":134.22,"body":"information about this hockey"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":130.92,"endTime":134.22,"body":"stick is over there. And"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":134.22,"endTime":137.31,"body":"basically, the whole"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":134.22,"endTime":137.31,"body":"anthropogenic movement started"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":137.31,"endTime":141.69,"body":"from this graph. And that's up"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":137.31,"endTime":141.69,"body":"until this day, basically, the"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":141.69,"endTime":144.99,"body":"main justification for spending"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":141.69,"endTime":144.99,"body":"tremendous amounts of money on"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":145.41,"endTime":149.16,"body":"fighting anthropogenic CO2,"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":145.41,"endTime":149.16,"body":"which is a ridiculously small"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":149.16,"endTime":156.48,"body":"amount, and people don't even"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":149.16,"endTime":156.48,"body":"know it's, it's 1% from 0.04 of"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":156.48,"endTime":157.29,"body":"a percent."},{"speaker":"Alexey ","startTime":157.66,"endTime":160.81,"body":"Four 10 1000s of a"},{"speaker":"Alexey ","startTime":157.66,"endTime":160.81,"body":"percent. And we are talking like"},{"speaker":"Alexey ","startTime":160.81,"endTime":166.72,"body":"about this, like we've showed"},{"speaker":"Alexey ","startTime":160.81,"endTime":166.72,"body":"also video during the forum,"},{"speaker":"Alexey ","startTime":166.99,"endTime":171.61,"body":"showing in perspective, what are"},{"speaker":"Alexey ","startTime":166.99,"endTime":171.61,"body":"these like four tiny particles"},{"speaker":"Alexey ","startTime":171.88,"endTime":176.35,"body":"in the big mass of all other"},{"speaker":"Alexey ","startTime":171.88,"endTime":176.35,"body":"particles of gases in the"},{"speaker":"Alexey ","startTime":176.35,"endTime":177.43,"body":"atmosphere. Yeah."},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":177.0,"endTime":182.43,"body":"Yeah! Can you imagine"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":177.0,"endTime":182.43,"body":"it's four molecules out of a"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":182.43,"endTime":187.32,"body":"million of other molecules? Four"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":182.43,"endTime":187.32,"body":"molecules, that according to"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":187.32,"endTime":193.35,"body":"this, so-called, I don't even"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":187.32,"endTime":193.35,"body":"know what to call them the"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":193.35,"endTime":197.97,"body":"anthropogenic warriors, or"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":193.35,"endTime":197.97,"body":"haters or whatever you want to"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":197.97,"endTime":202.53,"body":"call them? That these people."},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":197.97,"endTime":202.53,"body":"Yeah, according to them, that's"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":202.53,"endTime":206.73,"body":"what causes global warming,"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":202.53,"endTime":206.73,"body":"which is, which doesn't make"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":206.73,"endTime":209.46,"body":"sense, even from a logical"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":206.73,"endTime":209.46,"body":"point. But then when we started"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":209.46,"endTime":212.88,"body":"to check in there, okay. They"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":209.46,"endTime":212.88,"body":"claim this as an evidence. So,"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":212.88,"endTime":217.35,"body":"where's this evidence common"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":212.88,"endTime":217.35,"body":"from? And I was, like, started"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":217.35,"endTime":223.92,"body":"checking into it. That was IPCC"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":217.35,"endTime":223.92,"body":"2001. Their, in their report,"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":223.95,"endTime":228.99,"body":"the third report by IPCC"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":223.95,"endTime":228.99,"body":"published this graph, the hockey"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":228.99,"endTime":235.05,"body":"stick, it was presented in"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":228.99,"endTime":235.05,"body":"Geneva in 2001. And it was, it"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":235.05,"endTime":238.38,"body":"was on the background, they had"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":235.05,"endTime":238.38,"body":"the stage and this graph was on"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":238.38,"endTime":242.91,"body":"the background, and it was"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":238.38,"endTime":242.91,"body":"published on the whole, all the"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":242.94,"endTime":247.32,"body":"papers they had over there. And"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":242.94,"endTime":247.32,"body":"then the very the year before"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":247.32,"endTime":250.74,"body":"the World Meteorological"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":247.32,"endTime":250.74,"body":"Organization published a very"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":250.74,"endTime":255.81,"body":"similar graph, and that that was"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":250.74,"endTime":255.81,"body":"presented as a consensus and"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":255.81,"endTime":260.4,"body":"there's a proof of unseen"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":255.81,"endTime":260.4,"body":"warming that started in the 20th"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":260.4,"endTime":265.65,"body":"century. And then I started"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":260.4,"endTime":265.65,"body":"checking the whole controversy."},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":266.4,"endTime":271.02,"body":"So it appears that when it came"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":266.4,"endTime":271.02,"body":"out, many people were very"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":271.02,"endTime":275.91,"body":"surprised because the whole"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":271.02,"endTime":275.91,"body":"study of paleoclimatology which"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":275.91,"endTime":281.61,"body":"is studying of ancient"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":275.91,"endTime":281.61,"body":"temperatures of the climate in"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":282.09,"endTime":287.31,"body":"ancient times, it basically"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":282.09,"endTime":287.31,"body":"hundreds and hundreds of"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":287.34,"endTime":292.29,"body":"researchers out there, including"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":287.34,"endTime":292.29,"body":"historical records, including"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":292.29,"endTime":298.92,"body":"the geological proofs, including"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":292.29,"endTime":298.92,"body":"archaeology, everything tells..."},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":299.04,"endTime":299.22,"body":"ice cores..."},{"speaker":"Alexey ","startTime":299.22,"endTime":301.95,"body":"Ice cores as well I"},{"speaker":"Alexey ","startTime":299.22,"endTime":301.95,"body":"guess all the... yeah"},{"speaker":"Alexey ","startTime":301.0,"endTime":337.54,"body":"And they needed like"},{"speaker":"Alexey ","startTime":301.0,"endTime":337.54,"body":"some sort of scientific proof."},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":301.65,"endTime":307.817,"body":"Yeah, you name it."},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":301.65,"endTime":307.817,"body":"Everything says that there were"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":307.941,"endTime":314.355,"body":"periods much warmer than it is"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":307.941,"endTime":314.355,"body":"right now, before the"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":314.479,"endTime":321.88,"body":"anthropogenic CO2 was even a"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":314.479,"endTime":321.88,"body":"thing. And the period is called"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":322.004,"endTime":329.775,"body":"medieval warm period, which was"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":322.004,"endTime":329.775,"body":"about 800 years ago and further"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":329.898,"endTime":337.423,"body":"into the past. And funny thing"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":329.898,"endTime":337.423,"body":"that IPCC, IPCC was looking to"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":337.0,"endTime":407.5,"body":"Yes, exactly. And who was"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":337.0,"endTime":407.5,"body":"Michael Mann at that time, he"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":337.547,"endTime":345.318,"body":"get rid of this period like they"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":337.547,"endTime":345.318,"body":"purposely since at least since"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":345.442,"endTime":353.213,"body":"1995, they were spreading emails"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":345.442,"endTime":353.213,"body":"around their community, openly"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":353.337,"endTime":360.861,"body":"saying, we have to get rid, it's"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":353.337,"endTime":360.861,"body":"a quote, it's a quote that's"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":360.985,"endTime":368.633,"body":"coming from an interview of one"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":360.985,"endTime":368.633,"body":"of American geologists. And he"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":368.756,"endTime":376.158,"body":"says, I'm getting this email"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":368.756,"endTime":376.158,"body":"from one of the representatives"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":376.281,"endTime":383.436,"body":"from IPCC and he says, we have"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":376.281,"endTime":383.436,"body":"to get rid of Medieval Warm"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":383.559,"endTime":391.331,"body":"period. And this is exactly what"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":383.559,"endTime":391.331,"body":"Michael Mann did in his graph."},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":391.454,"endTime":398.979,"body":"And not too many people know"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":391.454,"endTime":398.979,"body":"that his graph came out first in"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":399.102,"endTime":406.257,"body":"Nature magazine in 1998, just"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":399.102,"endTime":406.257,"body":"one year, even less than one"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":406.38,"endTime":413.659,"body":"year after Kyoto Protocol was"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":406.38,"endTime":413.659,"body":"signed. But signing the Kyoto"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":407.5,"endTime":412.06,"body":"was a young researcher here, he"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":407.5,"endTime":412.06,"body":"had the degree in math. So he"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":412.06,"endTime":417.91,"body":"knew how to draw graphs, he knew"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":412.06,"endTime":417.91,"body":"exactly how to adjust the graphs"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":413.782,"endTime":421.307,"body":"Protocol in Japan was one thing"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":413.782,"endTime":421.307,"body":"where some ministers just did"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":417.91,"endTime":422.95,"body":"to get the result that was"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":417.91,"endTime":422.95,"body":"expected. And what he did he"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":421.43,"endTime":428.832,"body":"it. Al Gore, Vice President of"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":421.43,"endTime":428.832,"body":"the United States, was there,"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":422.98,"endTime":428.56,"body":"exactly satisfied the political"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":422.98,"endTime":428.56,"body":"demand it's basically, basically"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":428.62,"endTime":434.23,"body":"politicians opened the market,"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":428.62,"endTime":434.23,"body":"the market request to get this"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":428.955,"endTime":436.233,"body":"one of the main guys who pushed"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":428.955,"endTime":436.233,"body":"for it, but then the second"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":434.23,"endTime":437.62,"body":"kind of a graph, and he"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":434.23,"endTime":437.62,"body":"presented exactly what they"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":436.356,"endTime":443.758,"body":"part, they had to ratify it in"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":436.356,"endTime":443.758,"body":"Parliaments around the world."},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":437.62,"endTime":442.57,"body":"wanted. The problem was that"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":437.62,"endTime":442.57,"body":"exactly the same year, two other"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":442.57,"endTime":448.18,"body":"researchers used the very same"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":442.57,"endTime":448.18,"body":"data the, tree ring data, two,"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":443.881,"endTime":451.53,"body":"And for that they need, they had"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":443.881,"endTime":451.53,"body":"to change the public opinion."},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":448.27,"endTime":452.14,"body":"and they drew the graphs that"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":448.27,"endTime":452.14,"body":"looked nothing like hockey"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":452.14,"endTime":457.48,"body":"stick, and that was the problem."},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":452.14,"endTime":457.48,"body":"IPCC definitely wanted Mann's"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":457.48,"endTime":462.28,"body":"graph. But they couldn't ignore"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":457.48,"endTime":462.28,"body":"the other graphs that came out"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":462.28,"endTime":465.58,"body":"the very same year and were"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":462.28,"endTime":465.58,"body":"published in Nature magazine as"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":465.58,"endTime":467.95,"body":"well. So what they did they"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":465.58,"endTime":467.95,"body":"gathered"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":468.98,"endTime":473.39,"body":"all these researchers, three of"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":468.98,"endTime":473.39,"body":"them, Michael Mann, and they put"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":473.39,"endTime":477.89,"body":"him in charge of the whole"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":473.39,"endTime":477.89,"body":"commission. And they added two"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":477.89,"endTime":482.12,"body":"more guys in there. Keith"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":477.89,"endTime":482.12,"body":"Briffa. He was one of the much"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":482.12,"endTime":485.36,"body":"more experienced researchers,"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":482.12,"endTime":485.36,"body":"first of all, because Michael"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":485.36,"endTime":489.47,"body":"Mann at the time, when he"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":485.36,"endTime":489.47,"body":"published his hockey stick, you"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":489.62,"endTime":493.34,"body":"didn't even have the PhD in"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":489.62,"endTime":493.34,"body":"climatology."},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":494.74,"endTime":499.69,"body":"He was basically a no name in"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":494.74,"endTime":499.69,"body":"the community. And then all of a"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":499.69,"endTime":504.64,"body":"sudden, he becomes the main star"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":499.69,"endTime":504.64,"body":"of IPCC, in charge of the whole"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":504.64,"endTime":510.07,"body":"commission, who's working on"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":504.64,"endTime":510.07,"body":"this political resume for 2001"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":510.07,"endTime":514.3,"body":"for upcoming research. How"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":510.07,"endTime":514.3,"body":"exactly it was cooked, the whole"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":514.3,"endTime":518.29,"body":"kitchen, we found out only 10"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":514.3,"endTime":518.29,"body":"years later, 10 years later,"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":518.29,"endTime":522.91,"body":"when Climategate emails were"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":518.29,"endTime":522.91,"body":"published online. And that's a"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":522.91,"endTime":529.57,"body":"story that blew minds of"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":522.91,"endTime":529.57,"body":"everyone who was at least a"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":529.57,"endTime":532.78,"body":"little bit curious about what's"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":529.57,"endTime":532.78,"body":"going on with it, especially a"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":532.78,"endTime":537.01,"body":"scientists, scientists who could"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":532.78,"endTime":537.01,"body":"never even think that something"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":537.01,"endTime":538.27,"body":"like this is possible."},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":539.38,"endTime":543.91,"body":"But I have to say that there"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":539.38,"endTime":543.91,"body":"were curious people, especially"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":543.91,"endTime":548.32,"body":"people who know about math, one"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":543.91,"endTime":548.32,"body":"of them was Steve McIntyre from"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":548.32,"endTime":552.25,"body":"Canada, and he basically from"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":548.32,"endTime":552.25,"body":"early 2000s, he started"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":552.25,"endTime":556.63,"body":"debunking the whole hockey"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":552.25,"endTime":556.63,"body":"stick, because the when he saw"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":556.63,"endTime":562.06,"body":"it, and I have to say that"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":556.63,"endTime":562.06,"body":"Canadian government was mailing,"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":562.06,"endTime":565.93,"body":"basically using mail. They sent"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":562.06,"endTime":565.93,"body":"this hockey stick graph into"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":565.93,"endTime":572.92,"body":"each household in Canada to"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":565.93,"endTime":572.92,"body":"prove that this law has to be"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":572.92,"endTime":576.37,"body":"passed in Parliament, it has to"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":572.92,"endTime":576.37,"body":"be ratified, the Kyoto Protocol,"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":576.37,"endTime":579.37,"body":"and they wanted to change public"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":576.37,"endTime":579.37,"body":"opinion. And they used the"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":579.37,"endTime":583.27,"body":"hockey stick graph from 2001"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":579.37,"endTime":583.27,"body":"IPCC report as their main"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":583.27,"endTime":587.38,"body":"justification. And when he"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":583.27,"endTime":587.38,"body":"received this. First of all, it"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":587.38,"endTime":591.49,"body":"contradicts everything Canadians"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":587.38,"endTime":591.49,"body":"learned in school. Because they"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":591.52,"endTime":596.26,"body":"know that it used to be much"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":591.52,"endTime":596.26,"body":"warmer, that's when Vikings came"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":596.26,"endTime":599.47,"body":"from all the way from Norway,"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":596.26,"endTime":599.47,"body":"from Sweden."},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":599.47,"endTime":604.99,"body":"They came 1000 years ago to"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":599.47,"endTime":604.99,"body":"Greenland, they saw it was green"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":604.99,"endTime":608.56,"body":"because because it was warm, it"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":604.99,"endTime":608.56,"body":"was green back then the whole"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":608.56,"endTime":609.07,"body":"island."},{"speaker":"Alexey ","startTime":609.31,"endTime":611.05,"body":"And because it is"},{"speaker":"Alexey ","startTime":609.31,"endTime":611.05,"body":"Greenland."},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":611.0,"endTime":615.56,"body":"Exactly! They also went"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":611.0,"endTime":615.56,"body":"to Vineland, which is north of"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":615.56,"endTime":620.12,"body":"Canada and which was, which was"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":615.56,"endTime":620.12,"body":"forest back then, like people"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":620.12,"endTime":624.11,"body":"don't realize it was forest, it"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":620.12,"endTime":624.11,"body":"was forest and that forest"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":624.56,"endTime":629.72,"body":"burned down in 15th century. And"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":624.56,"endTime":629.72,"body":"it never grew back. Because"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":629.72,"endTime":633.29,"body":"right now it's Arctic. So there"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":629.72,"endTime":633.29,"body":"is no forest growing in Arctic,"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":633.29,"endTime":636.98,"body":"it's too cold. But prior to 15th"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":633.29,"endTime":636.98,"body":"century, there was a huge"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":636.98,"endTime":641.24,"body":"forest. And there is a lot of"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":636.98,"endTime":641.24,"body":"evidence, it's like a very well"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":641.24,"endTime":645.29,"body":"known fact, it doesn't align"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":641.24,"endTime":645.29,"body":"with their hockey stick graph,"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":645.29,"endTime":648.32,"body":"which says it was oh, it was"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":645.29,"endTime":648.32,"body":"flat temperature all the way"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":648.68,"endTime":651.86,"body":"back into the past. So Steve"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":648.68,"endTime":651.86,"body":"McIntyre, when he saw that he"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":651.86,"endTime":655.22,"body":"was like, wait, let me verify"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":651.86,"endTime":655.22,"body":"it. Let me check what data was"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":655.22,"endTime":659.03,"body":"used, because it doesn't make"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":655.22,"endTime":659.03,"body":"any sense. And he requested the"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":659.03,"endTime":664.61,"body":"data. And Mann published the"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":659.03,"endTime":664.61,"body":"data that he used. But the thing"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":664.61,"endTime":669.65,"body":"is, no one was able to draw the"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":664.61,"endTime":669.65,"body":"same graph using the same data."},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":669.65,"endTime":673.34,"body":"So the question was like, what"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":669.65,"endTime":673.34,"body":"was the algorithm? How did you"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":673.34,"endTime":677.87,"body":"set the algorithm to make the"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":673.34,"endTime":677.87,"body":"hockey stick graph? And that's"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":677.87,"endTime":682.13,"body":"when Mann refused to provide the"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":677.87,"endTime":682.13,"body":"algorithm. And that was the"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":682.13,"endTime":685.37,"body":"first red flag that was like,"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":682.13,"endTime":685.37,"body":"wait, wait, wait, what's going"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":685.37,"endTime":686.03,"body":"on in here?"},{"speaker":"Alexey ","startTime":686.51,"endTime":690.38,"body":"So he said, like, I had"},{"speaker":"Alexey ","startTime":686.51,"endTime":690.38,"body":"a proprietary algorithm that I"},{"speaker":"Alexey ","startTime":690.38,"endTime":704.12,"body":"cannot disclose. But this is the"},{"speaker":"Alexey ","startTime":690.38,"endTime":704.12,"body":"graph that it produces, so it is"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":695.75,"endTime":699.643,"body":"Can you imagine anyone"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":695.75,"endTime":699.643,"body":"else any, any scientist would be"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":699.714,"endTime":704.174,"body":"proud to show that take a look"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":699.714,"endTime":704.174,"body":"at my algorithm, I created this."},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":704.245,"endTime":708.775,"body":"And this is such a game changer"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":704.245,"endTime":708.775,"body":"in the industry. I presented it,"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":706.88,"endTime":737.27,"body":"the correct one."},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":708.846,"endTime":713.377,"body":"it changed everything. But this"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":708.846,"endTime":713.377,"body":"guy did everything to hide where"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":713.447,"endTime":717.837,"body":"to find the algorithm. And what"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":713.447,"endTime":717.837,"body":"what else he did, he was asked"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":717.907,"endTime":722.013,"body":"to show r2 regression and what"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":717.907,"endTime":722.013,"body":"is r2 regression? It's like"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":722.084,"endTime":726.402,"body":"imagine when we have a lot of"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":722.084,"endTime":726.402,"body":"dots on the on the diagram, and"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":726.473,"endTime":730.579,"body":"we have to draw the line that"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":726.473,"endTime":730.579,"body":"would be right in the middle"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":730.65,"endTime":734.827,"body":"between all the dots, right? So"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":730.65,"endTime":734.827,"body":"we want to basically make a"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":734.897,"endTime":739.216,"body":"graph out of like a lot of data."},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":734.897,"endTime":739.216,"body":"Once we have the result, the"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":739.286,"endTime":743.251,"body":"graph, we want to do the"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":739.286,"endTime":743.251,"body":"regression testing, we want to,"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":743.322,"endTime":746.72,"body":"again, regress and create those"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":743.322,"endTime":746.72,"body":"dots, the error."},{"speaker":"Alexey ","startTime":746.0,"endTime":750.78,"body":"Yeah, like like we did"},{"speaker":"Alexey ","startTime":746.0,"endTime":750.78,"body":"at school, right to verify if we"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":746.0,"endTime":759.2,"body":"It's a school 101. It's,"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":746.0,"endTime":759.2,"body":"third grader knows you have to"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":750.867,"endTime":755.3,"body":"solved the problem correctly, we"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":750.867,"endTime":755.3,"body":"do the regression."},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":759.23,"endTime":762.65,"body":"do the regression test to make"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":759.23,"endTime":762.65,"body":"sure you didn't do a mistake."},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":762.68,"endTime":767.99,"body":"You didn't make a mistake. But"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":762.68,"endTime":767.99,"body":"what Mann says, I believe it's a"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":767.99,"endTime":771.86,"body":"quote he said, It would be"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":767.99,"endTime":771.86,"body":"ridiculous to even think that I"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":771.86,"endTime":774.74,"body":"need to do r2 regressions. Are"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":771.86,"endTime":774.74,"body":"you kidding me?"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":775.76,"endTime":781.46,"body":"This, like, wow, like, this was"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":775.76,"endTime":781.46,"body":"like a huge red flag. That's"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":781.46,"endTime":784.58,"body":"when everyone knew something"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":781.46,"endTime":784.58,"body":"super fishy in there."},{"speaker":"Alexey ","startTime":784.97,"endTime":789.86,"body":"And how did McIntyre"},{"speaker":"Alexey ","startTime":784.97,"endTime":789.86,"body":"say, when I first saw this"},{"speaker":"Alexey ","startTime":789.86,"endTime":792.11,"body":"graph, I immediately felt it was"},{"speaker":"Alexey ","startTime":789.86,"endTime":792.11,"body":"like,"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":793.94,"endTime":795.47,"body":"It smelled,"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":796.88,"endTime":806.18,"body":"Smelled the rat. It smelled"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":796.88,"endTime":806.18,"body":"fishy. But what was what was one"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":806.18,"endTime":809.39,"body":"of the very important things"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":806.18,"endTime":809.39,"body":"that Steve McIntyre is a"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":809.39,"endTime":814.61,"body":"brilliant mathematician. And his"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":809.39,"endTime":814.61,"body":"whole career after he graduated"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":814.61,"endTime":819.35,"body":"from the University of Toronto"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":814.61,"endTime":819.35,"body":"with a math degree his plant in,"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":819.83,"endTime":825.86,"body":"in mining industry, where his"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":819.83,"endTime":825.86,"body":"work was to do statistic"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":826.07,"endTime":826.97,"body":"analysis"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":827.98,"endTime":832.9,"body":"in the very similar field, and"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":827.98,"endTime":832.9,"body":"what he had to do, he had to"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":832.9,"endTime":836.11,"body":"deal his whole career with a lot"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":832.9,"endTime":836.11,"body":"of people who were trying to"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":836.11,"endTime":841.27,"body":"draw similar graphs, which would"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":836.11,"endTime":841.27,"body":"show let's say, higher"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":841.75,"endTime":846.22,"body":"expectations for their potential"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":841.75,"endTime":846.22,"body":"minings. So he had to take the"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":846.25,"endTime":850.27,"body":"original data and verify it. And"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":846.25,"endTime":850.27,"body":"this is exactly what he did."},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":850.54,"endTime":855.88,"body":"After Mann refused to provide"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":850.54,"endTime":855.88,"body":"the actual algorithms. What"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":856.66,"endTime":861.91,"body":"Steve did here, he digged into"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":856.66,"endTime":861.91,"body":"the code. And in the leftovers"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":861.91,"endTime":865.3,"body":"in the hidden folders of the"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":861.91,"endTime":865.3,"body":"code, he found out the"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":865.33,"endTime":869.41,"body":"classified folder which Mann"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":865.33,"endTime":869.41,"body":"didn't want to publish, but"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":869.41,"endTime":873.97,"body":"somehow, it just sneaked into"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":869.41,"endTime":873.97,"body":"that archive. And in that"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":873.97,"endTime":881.17,"body":"folder, he saw that Michael Mann"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":873.97,"endTime":881.17,"body":"was using specific settings on"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":881.17,"endTime":885.64,"body":"his algorithm which use the"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":881.17,"endTime":885.64,"body":"primary component for the 20th"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":885.64,"endTime":890.74,"body":"century and the primary"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":885.64,"endTime":890.74,"body":"component was the data the proxy"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":890.74,"endTime":895.66,"body":"data from North American pine,"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":890.74,"endTime":895.66,"body":"which is super sensitive to CO2"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":895.66,"endTime":900.55,"body":"changes. And this is exactly the"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":895.66,"endTime":900.55,"body":"reason why it cannot be used as"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":900.55,"endTime":901.06,"body":"the..."},{"speaker":"Alexey ","startTime":901.33,"endTime":904.45,"body":"Reference for these"},{"speaker":"Alexey ","startTime":901.33,"endTime":904.45,"body":"calculations."},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":904.72,"endTime":907.66,"body":"Yes, exactly! We don't"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":904.72,"endTime":907.66,"body":"want super sensitive stuff to be"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":907.66,"endTime":910.51,"body":"in there, because we want"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":907.66,"endTime":910.51,"body":"something that generally"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":911.08,"endTime":915.76,"body":"represents the information. He,"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":911.08,"endTime":915.76,"body":"Michael Mann used exactly,"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":915.76,"endTime":921.88,"body":"specifically this one. And when"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":915.76,"endTime":921.88,"body":"he was making his graph, he"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":921.88,"endTime":927.91,"body":"basically made the graph which"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":921.88,"endTime":927.91,"body":"in regression testing, simply"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":927.97,"endTime":933.91,"body":"was creating that field of dots"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":927.97,"endTime":933.91,"body":"out of which, in 99% of times,"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":934.69,"endTime":940.15,"body":"out of those red noise numbers"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":934.69,"endTime":940.15,"body":"created from his graph, it would"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":940.15,"endTime":946.36,"body":"create the similar graph hockey"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":940.15,"endTime":946.36,"body":"stick shaped graph, as well. So"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":946.36,"endTime":951.31,"body":"once Steve McIntyre found found"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":946.36,"endTime":951.31,"body":"out he offered Nature magazine"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":951.37,"endTime":956.68,"body":"to publish this article in which"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":951.37,"endTime":956.68,"body":"he explained how exactly the"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":956.74,"endTime":960.64,"body":"there was a mistake in the"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":956.74,"endTime":960.64,"body":"algorithms that was producing"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":960.67,"endTime":966.19,"body":"this kind of a hockey stick"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":960.67,"endTime":966.19,"body":"shaped graphs out of basically"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":966.22,"endTime":972.55,"body":"any random red noise numbers."},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":966.22,"endTime":972.55,"body":"And Nature magazine answered"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":972.55,"endTime":978.76,"body":"that they would only allow 500"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":972.55,"endTime":978.76,"body":"letters for such an article. So"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":978.76,"endTime":982.0,"body":"he went to General Research"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":978.76,"endTime":982.0,"body":"Letters, and he published this"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":982.24,"endTime":988.57,"body":"article on which their response"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":982.24,"endTime":988.57,"body":"from Michael Mann was that he's"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":988.57,"endTime":991.45,"body":"not going to present any"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":988.57,"endTime":991.45,"body":"regression testing and he"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":991.45,"endTime":995.47,"body":"doesn't care about some graphs"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":991.45,"endTime":995.47,"body":"and and that it was published in"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":995.47,"endTime":998.53,"body":"General Research Letters, which"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":995.47,"endTime":998.53,"body":"is not even that much big of a"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":998.53,"endTime":1002.88,"body":"paper. So he never actually even"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":998.53,"endTime":1002.88,"body":"tried to prove that his graph,"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":1003.21,"endTime":1009.06,"body":"like makes sense. What happened"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":1003.21,"endTime":1009.06,"body":"next was also we found out from"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":1009.06,"endTime":1014.16,"body":"the Climategate emails that"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":1009.06,"endTime":1014.16,"body":"other magazines that were"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":1014.16,"endTime":1019.92,"body":"publishing research researches,"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":1014.16,"endTime":1019.92,"body":"even from astrophysicists, like"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":1019.92,"endTime":1023.88,"body":"the one that was published by"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":1019.92,"endTime":1023.88,"body":"astrophysicist from Harvard"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":1023.88,"endTime":1026.85,"body":"University where they were"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":1023.88,"endTime":1026.85,"body":"claiming that according to the"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":1026.85,"endTime":1031.53,"body":"solar cycles, there was a much"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":1026.85,"endTime":1031.53,"body":"warmer, Medieval Warm Period."},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":1032.04,"endTime":1036.93,"body":"And what happened in the texts"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":1032.04,"endTime":1036.93,"body":"between Michael Mann and his"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":1037.2,"endTime":1041.19,"body":"clique, or how Steve McIntyre"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":1037.2,"endTime":1041.19,"body":"called them the hockey team."},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":1042.54,"endTime":1048.66,"body":"They were discussing how to"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":1042.54,"endTime":1048.66,"body":"discredit how to stigmatize the"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":1048.66,"endTime":1053.4,"body":"astrophysicist who published an"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":1048.66,"endTime":1053.4,"body":"article which contradicts their"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":1053.4,"endTime":1057.27,"body":"anthropogenic theory, and among"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":1053.4,"endTime":1057.27,"body":"the things they discussed, they"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":1057.3,"endTime":1062.19,"body":"said, maybe we could call them"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":1057.3,"endTime":1062.19,"body":"astrologists. Maybe we can the"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":1062.19,"endTime":1066.81,"body":"reference, reference to them as"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":1062.19,"endTime":1066.81,"body":"astrologists as if they would"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":1066.81,"endTime":1071.55,"body":"use tarot readings or, you know,"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":1066.81,"endTime":1071.55,"body":"some crystal ball to predict the"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":1071.55,"endTime":1076.83,"body":"temperatures in the past, or to"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":1071.55,"endTime":1076.83,"body":"recreate the graphs of the past"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":1076.83,"endTime":1081.72,"body":"centuries. Like this is"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":1076.83,"endTime":1081.72,"body":"ridiculous. It's like no one"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":1081.72,"endTime":1086.58,"body":"even tried to dig into like, is"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":1081.72,"endTime":1086.58,"body":"it a legitimate research? Does"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":1086.58,"endTime":1091.35,"body":"it make sense their only agenda"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":1086.58,"endTime":1091.35,"body":"was to stigmatize and discredit"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":1091.35,"endTime":1094.26,"body":"them. That's the only thing they"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":1091.35,"endTime":1094.26,"body":"cared about."},{"speaker":"Alexey ","startTime":1093.85,"endTime":1096.1,"body":"And everyone else for"},{"speaker":"Alexey ","startTime":1093.85,"endTime":1096.1,"body":"that matter. Yeah."},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":1097.49,"endTime":1100.82,"body":"Yeah, as I mentioned"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":1097.49,"endTime":1100.82,"body":"before, there were three"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":1100.82,"endTime":1108.17,"body":"different researchers published"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":1100.82,"endTime":1108.17,"body":"in Nature magazine in 1998. And"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":1108.2,"endTime":1112.88,"body":"all of them used proxy data from"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":1108.2,"endTime":1112.88,"body":"tree rings. And all of them were"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":1112.94,"endTime":1115.85,"body":"showing that there were"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":1112.94,"endTime":1115.85,"body":"different periods in previous"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":1115.85,"endTime":1120.68,"body":"times exactly, besides the"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":1115.85,"endTime":1120.68,"body":"hockey stick graph. But"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":1120.68,"endTime":1123.89,"body":"basically what they did in"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":1120.68,"endTime":1123.89,"body":"preparation of the IPCC report,"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":1123.89,"endTime":1128.75,"body":"they, they erased all the data"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":1123.89,"endTime":1128.75,"body":"that was showing the decline in"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":1128.75,"endTime":1134.57,"body":"temperatures in 20th century. So"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":1128.75,"endTime":1134.57,"body":"they simply trimmed the graph,"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":1135.08,"endTime":1138.83,"body":"around 1960s, when the tree"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":1135.08,"endTime":1138.83,"body":"rings were showing the decline"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":1138.83,"endTime":1142.1,"body":"in the temperatures. And this is"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":1138.83,"endTime":1142.1,"body":"such a big thing. Because think"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":1142.1,"endTime":1146.33,"body":"about it this way, the"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":1142.1,"endTime":1146.33,"body":"temperatures in previous times"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":1146.33,"endTime":1151.49,"body":"showing the variability, but"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":1146.33,"endTime":1151.49,"body":"they go down in numbers in 20th"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":1151.49,"endTime":1156.95,"body":"century, when thermometer data"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":1151.49,"endTime":1156.95,"body":"goes up, what it proves, it"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":1156.95,"endTime":1162.2,"body":"basically shows that either your"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":1156.95,"endTime":1162.2,"body":"graph doesn't make sense, like"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":1162.23,"endTime":1167.57,"body":"or your research, maybe it's a"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":1162.23,"endTime":1167.57,"body":"bad data, or maybe you didn't"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":1167.57,"endTime":1171.11,"body":"calculate it right? Because if"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":1167.57,"endTime":1171.11,"body":"we know that temperatures go up"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":1171.41,"endTime":1175.52,"body":"in 20th century, then we cannot"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":1171.41,"endTime":1175.52,"body":"just trim the piece that"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":1175.79,"endTime":1179.54,"body":"declines in temperatures from"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":1175.79,"endTime":1179.54,"body":"tree rings data, but that's"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":1179.54,"endTime":1184.04,"body":"exactly what they did. And"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":1179.54,"endTime":1184.04,"body":"there, they never even"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":1184.07,"endTime":1189.2,"body":"considered why, why that tree"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":1184.07,"endTime":1189.2,"body":"data goes declining in the 20th"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":1189.2,"endTime":1194.33,"body":"century. And then the main thing"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":1189.2,"endTime":1194.33,"body":"they tried to hide it and the"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":1194.33,"endTime":1198.11,"body":"whole email, their main email"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":1194.33,"endTime":1198.11,"body":"was regarding hiding the decline"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":1198.11,"endTime":1202.64,"body":"and that's what all the buzz was"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":1198.11,"endTime":1202.64,"body":"about. Oh, But what will also be"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":1202.64,"endTime":1207.29,"body":"found and found out from the"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":1202.64,"endTime":1207.29,"body":"Climategate emails that the that"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":1207.32,"endTime":1213.41,"body":"IPCC was basically pushing the"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":1207.32,"endTime":1213.41,"body":"scientists to publish Mann's"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":1213.59,"endTime":1218.99,"body":"graph, that hockey stick shaped"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":1213.59,"endTime":1218.99,"body":"graph as their main one and hide"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":1218.99,"endTime":1223.52,"body":"all the data that was not in"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":1218.99,"endTime":1223.52,"body":"line with it. So when they"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":1223.52,"endTime":1227.3,"body":"published their graph, it was"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":1223.52,"endTime":1227.3,"body":"presented as the consensus of"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":1227.3,"endTime":1230.48,"body":"the scientists where in fact,"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":1227.3,"endTime":1230.48,"body":"there were huge"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":1230.51,"endTime":1236.15,"body":"misunderstandings and huge"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":1230.51,"endTime":1236.15,"body":"contradictions in the scientific"},{"speaker":"Taliy","startTime":1236.15,"endTime":1237.02,"body":"community itself."}]}