“Live from 43565: But What If?” - Tontogany’s Upcoming Performance

In this episode, Lavender Krupp and Callie Palmer explore the imaginative world of “what if” storytelling through the cast and crew of an alternate-reality play set in our beloved town of Tontogany.

In their upcoming production, Madge Brown, Hannah Grohowski, Hannah Bergfeld, and the rest of the lively crew dive into how a single changed decision, moment, or outcome can completely reshape a story. From reimagined endings to unexpected twists on familiar moments, this episode highlights the creative spark behind asking, “But what if?”

Whether you love theater, enjoy writing, or just find yourself wondering how life in Tontogany might have looked if things had gone differently, this performance—and this conversation—will leave you seeing every story, maybe even your own, in a whole new way.

* In addition, check out our previous episode about “Who Killed Olive Peony?”, the Tontogany Murder Mystery this cast and crew performed last summer for Tontogany’s 150th anniversary episode: https://open.spotify.com/episode/0EKqoe5rD04wMNqprC4Nzr?si=lFvye9bSTZ-OneRp34gRiA

* Madge Brown’s May 2024 feature episode: https://open.spotify.com/episode/7vUp6P9z8A98aOX1zRWewC?si=ZcX8-5Q5SMKYEI3ONp5ylQ

This episode was edited by Ace F. and sound recorded by Ollie S.

Intro/Outro Music: “Motivated” by Alex MakesMusic
Date Recorded: March 31st, 2026.

FOLLOW OUR SOCIALS:
Twitter: @OHS_RoundTable
Instagram: @ohs_roundtable
Email: podcast@otsegoknights.org
tiktok:  @ohs_roundtable
Student Video Show on YouTube: https://youtube.com/@lateknightsroundtablepodcast?feature=shared