It is often debated which is a better investment, property or shares. It is my thesis that property is an okay investment, but not as good as shares. However, when you factor in gearing (the ability to borrow to invest), property becomes a wonderful investment – better than shares. 

Property versus shares

The main advantages of shares (compared to property) include: 

§  You can outsource the management of a share portfolio to an advisor. However, as a property investor, you may need to spend time to work with your managing agent to deal with tenant issues and/or property maintenance/repairs. 

§  Shares can generate a stable level of income with no (or few) related expenses. For example, the ASX200 index has yielded circa 4.5% p.a. for a long time. 

§  Shares are liquid and have low entry and exit costs e.g., no stamp duty, real estate agent fees, etc. This means you can invest and divest in small increments. 

The main advantages of property include: 

§  Most investors feel comfortable borrowing to invest in property, which means you don’t need to make a large upfront cash contribution to be able to invest. 

§  The assets tangibility can make investors feel more comfortable. 

§  You don’t need ongoing financial advice after you have purchased the property. 

§  Investment-grade property provides most of its return in capital growth in return for less income, which is tax effective. 

We can debate the pros and cons of shares and property until we are blue in the face, but I think it’s a meaningless debate. It’s like debating which golf club is better. They are all different and you need more than one club to play well. 

How do returns compare? 

My thesis is that it’s not property that makes property investing so effective. It’s the gearing that does a lot of the heavy lifting. Therefore, an investors decision is not whether to invest in property or shares. Their decision is whether to borrow to invest or not. If it is appropriate to borrow, and they can do so safely, then borrowing to invest in property will likely generate the highest return.  

I financially modelled borrowing to invest in a property, holding the property for 25 years, and selling it to realise the cash proceeds after repaying the loan and paying for capital gains tax (my assumptions are in the footnote[1]). Whilst the investor doesn’t need to make a cash contribution (as they borrow the entire cost of the property), they do have to pay for the holding costs i.e., shortfall between net rental income and mortgage interest. The internal rate of return calculates what return you generate from paying for these holding costs in return for making a capital gain in 25 years’ time. I calculated the internal rate of return to be 13.96% p.a. which is very attractive (see chart below). 

How much does gearing help? 

The return from borrowing to invest in property is so high because of the impact of gearing. That is, an investors cash contribution (i.e., holding costs) is relatively small compared to the capital gains, after tax. If I eliminated the impact of gearing, the investors internal rate of return falls to 7.41% p.a., because the investor must contribute a huge sum of cash at the beginning. Therefore, gearing adds 6.55% towards the total return as depicted below. 

CHART

If we compare that to investing in shares i.e., invest over $1m into the share market in one hit, hold it for 25 years and then sell the whole portfolio, the investors internal rate of return would be 10.29% p.a., which is much better (almost 3% p.a.) than an ungeared property investment. 

How

My new book out in mid-2026: To join the pre-order waitlist and get a bonus. More info go to: https://prosolution.com.au/book-preorder-bonus

Do you have a question for the podcast? Email us at questions@investopoly.com.au.

If you're interested in working with our team and me, discover how we can work together here: https://prosolution.com.au/family-office-services

If this episode resonated with you, please leave a rating on your favourite podcast platform.

Subscribe to my weekly blog: https://prosolution.com.au/stay-connected

IMPORTANT: This podcast provides general information about finance, taxes, and credit. This means that the content does not consider your specific objectives, financial situation, or needs. It is crucial for you to assess whether the information is suitable for your circumstances before taking any actions based on it. If you find yourself uncertain about the relevance or your specific needs, it is advisable to seek advice from a licensed and trustworthy professional.