Investopoly
Investopoly is a twice-weekly podcast designed to help you make better financial decisions and build wealth with clarity and confidence. Hosted by Stuart (tax adviser, financial adviser, and mortgage broker) and Campbell (senior financial adviser), each episode delivers concise, practical insights grounded in real-world strategy, research, methodologies, and case studies.
You will get two episodes each week: a main episode that deep-dives into a single wealth-building topic, and a Q&A episode that answers listener questions and real scenarios. Send your questions to questions@investopoly.com.au
We also write a weekly blog, and many podcast topics build on those ideas and frameworks. Stuart’s book, Wealth by Design, is out now in soft cover, e-book and audiobook: https://amzn.asia/d/08a4BmhI. His next book, Business by Design, written for business owners, is due mid 2027.
Investopoly
Ep 432: Bond ETFs vs 10-Year government bonds: Lock in or not?
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
10-year bonds near 5.2% look good, but I’d rather use subordinated debt ETFs. They pay about 1% more with almost no interest rate risk. A listener asked whether it’s time to lock in long-dated fixed-rate bonds now that yields are at their highest in about 15 years. In this episode, I explain duration and credit risk, why it’s hard to earn more than your starting yield, and how to measure the term premium properly. I then compare long-dated government bonds with subordinated debt ETFs such as SUBD and BSUB, and cover their risks: thin credit spreads and the money flowing in as bank hybrids wind down. I also explain the difference between running yield and yield to maturity, using the PIMCO global bond ETF (PGBF) the listener asked about.
00:00 Introduction
00:39 Listener question: Is it time to lock in duration?
01:31 What duration means
02:51 Why interest rates have become harder to forecast
04:35 10-year bonds at 5.2% vs a 4.6% cash rate
06:25 Spoiler: why I’d look elsewhere
06:47 Term premium explained using term deposits
08:03 Duration risk
10:02 Credit risk and credit spreads
13:05 Why holding to maturity doesn’t remove the risk
13:58 Why it’s hard to out-earn your starting yield
15:32 How to measure the term premium properly
17:50 Is today’s term premium above average?
19:47 What’s changed: the options now open to investors
20:59 Subordinated debt ETFs: BSUB and SUBD
24:54 Subordinated debt vs government bonds: an extra 1% or more
27:15 Why bank hybrids are being phased out
28:36 The risks: thin credit spreads and contagion
30:46 Moving up the credit scale: QPON and AGVT
31:02 Do bonds still protect a share portfolio?
32:24 Why we focus on absolute return
32:40 PGBF: running yield vs yield to maturity
34:41 Summing up
Read Stuart's latest book? He's only got 19 reviews on Amazon so far, if Wealth by Design helped you, leaving one would mean a lot: https://www.amazon.com.au/review/create-review?asin=192318654X
Run your own business?
Check out Business by Design, Stuart and Mena's show on starting, growing and exiting a business, at https://www.businessbydesignpodcast.com/
Our most popular free guides:
Over the years we've written hundreds of articles. These three bring our best thinking together on the topics that matter most right now: choosing a super fund, debt recycling, and navigating the new tax changes.
Got a question for the podcast?
Email us at questions@investopoly.com.au
Subscribe to my weekly blog:
Important
This podcast provides general information about finance, tax and credit. It doesn't take into account your specific objectives, financial situation or needs, so you need to assess whether it's relevant to your circumstances before acting on it. If you're not sure, speak to a licensed, trustworthy professional.
Welcome to the Investopoly Podcast. Our goal is to share easy to understand, evidence-based, holistic insights to help you master the game of building wealth. And thanks to Campbell for filling in to do the QA episode yesterday. Always good to have him on the podcast. And as I've threatened or promised, uh, we want him to do more of these podcasts as he gets maybe a little bit more time, doesn't have a lot of time to do them. But anyway, thanks to him and uh especially for filling in while I've been on leave for a couple of weeks. So I'm back and all refreshed to see the rest of the year out. And I'm thankful to say I've got a couple of really, well, I think a really good episode topics coming up, some ideas I thought about actually while I was on leave. Okay, let's get into today's episode because a listener recently asked me to cover long-dated fixed rate bonds. And the observation was that this listener shared is that I feel like it's starting to become attractive to start locking in some duration in Australia. And duration is a term that's used within the fixed interest market. I'm going to explain it and I'm going to talk. I'm going to answer this listener's question. And thank you for the question, by the way. You know, coming up with ideas for episodes can be the challenging thing. I want the episodes to be as useful to as wider audience as possible, but they've got to be in line with the overarching theme of this podcast, which uh is a rules-based, evidence-based approach to making good quality financial decisions. So if you have any ideas that fall within that ambit, of course, I'm always very open to receiving it. And you can leave uh comments in the blogs on the website or comments on YouTube and so forth, or send us an email, I'd love to hear from you. So, duration measures how sensitive a bond price is to interest rates. And so the idea that this listeners has come up with is if we are at the top or getting close to the top of the interest rate curve, or at least the top of the interest rate expectation curve, then potentially locking in fixed rate bonds now means that the bond price will rise as interest rate expectations fall. Remember, duration is how sensitive a bond price is to changes in interest rates. And so if we lock in when an interest rate, when rates are really low and then interest rates subsequently rise, and we've got a bond that's very sensitive to those changes, which means it's got a long maturity and a fixed rate, the value of my bond's going to be worth less, right? Because who wants my bond now when it's paying low interest rates and interest rates have substantially risen? But the reverse is true. So if I've got a bond that's where the interest rate is really attractive and then interest rates fall, my bond starts to become even more attractive because it's locked in at high interest rates. And so this is what this listener is asking me about. Do I think that's attractive? Do I think maturity and duration and these sorts of things are an attractive proposition in today's market? And so what I wanted to do for today's episode is really widen the question. And because, you know, I think the observation over the last uh particularly five or six years, can't believe it's six years since the start of COVID. So over the last five or six years, you know, I think forecasting interest rates has always been difficult, but I think it's it's become even more challenging. You know, I read an article a few years ago that said usually or pre-COVID, you would have to just interpret the data to try and work out what interest rates, what what a central bank might do with interest rates. But now you've got to also take into account their rhetoric, so their jawbony around what they're saying is now another piece of the puzzle that you've got to take into account because central banks over the last six years have probably in some way, in some parts, look to influence markets through their commentary more so than their actions. Well, I shouldn't say more so, or in addition to their actions, where previously that wasn't really the case, they would normally be relatively silent about what they may or may not do. And it's even more prevalent in the US, actually, where you know they've been talking at longer dated yield curve. So although they hiked interest rates only a few few weeks ago as they did in Australia or in the US, and they may not, but they may actually hike again. That's one of the elements that you need to really consider. So I think it's become even more difficult to sort of manage interest rate exposure and how sensitive investments can be to changes in interest rates. Now it's very clear to see what's driven this listener's question or to submit the question, because the 10-year government bond rate is now trading. As I record this on the 23rd of October, it's probably not going to change too much, but better to date it. The 10-year government bond rate is yielding around about 5.2, 5.25%. And it's really the highest starting yield that we've seen for roughly 15 years. And that's probably what, you know, people, this listener's probably thinking, well, yields are really high. Let's lock in some duration and maturity at that time. So really the cash rate today is 4.6%. Who knows? That might go to 4.85 in a couple of weeks' time on Melbourne Cup Day. I actually hope they do raise rates because and I mentioned this before that if they do it too slowly, it's almost feels like death by a thousand cuts. But I'd rather them knock it on the head and not be too concerned about a small uptick in unemployment. Relatively, unemployment's still pretty low, unemployment rate's still pretty low. So let's just get it done this year with another rate increase. So the term premium, which is really the difference between the cash today's cash rate and the 10-year rate, is really the reward you get for locking in. Although it's not really the only number you need to think about because you need to think about what will the average cash rate, the time-weighted average cash rate be over the next 10 years. But really, it's an attractive starting rate. And so, really, the traditional way of looking at this would be well, why don't we buy 10-year bonds? Because the cash rate's only 4.6%. And 10-year bonds are we're going to get 5.2, 5.25%. So an extra 0.6 of a percent in terms of remuneration for taking a 10-year term risk. And that's what I want to look at today. Is it worth taking that duration? Is it worth taking that term risk? Are you being rewarded for it? And the conclusion I'm going to get to is I don't think it is. Not because history tells us it's not going to be attractive, but because there's there's better opportunities now that have only really been present for the last few years in ETF form that now investors can think about. So that's kind of, I guess, my spoiler alert, if you like, a little bit in terms of what I'm going to cover in today's episode. Now, in terms of term premium, what we need to think about is a little bit like term deposits. Most people are familiar with term deposits. And when we think about bonds, we can really relate them similar to term deposits. You know, if we look at a three-month term deposit, we'll get a certain interest rate. But if we lock in for 12 months and get a 12-month term deposit, typically you would expect a higher interest rate. And there might be two or three year term deposits out there and the interest rate would be higher again. And essentially, the investor, the person taking out the term deposit, is getting rewarded for locking their money in for longer. And it's the same for bonds that if you have bonds that have longer dated maturities, that investors obviously need to wait a long time to get their money back and they should therefore be rewarded for locking their money away. And that's what I want to, in simple terms, work out. Are you actually rewarded for locking your money away? And because you're locking your money away, you've got that longer maturity. You're going to have a higher sensitivity to changes in your interest rates. And the challenge we've had over the last few years, as I said, is interest rates have changed a lot and quite substantially. And that's had an impact on the fixed interest market. Okay, so there's two risks that we want to think about. You know, with a turn deposit, you've got your principal amount, and then you're going to get an interest payment, and turn deposits might pay interest quarterly or six monthly or maybe even annually in some circumstances, but the principal amount doesn't change, right? I'll put $100,000 in a turn deposit. And if it's a three-year turn deposit, I'll get $100,000 back in three years' time. Of course, inflation might eat away at that principle, but in dollar terms, it's the same. Bonds, however, can change in price. They have a par value. So you when you first take out a bond or buy a bond on the market, you might buy that bond for $100,000. You put $100,000 into it. If you hold it to maturity, you'll get your $100,000 back. But the market value of a bond can change between now and maturity. And it can change for two primary reasons. The first one is called duration risk. And that's really a change in interest rates. A bond that has fixed coupons, so fixed interest rate, and uh the longer the maturity is, the higher the duration risk. Because as you can imagine, if I bought a bond just in 2020 or 2021 when interest rates were, you know, close to zero, that was probably the most risky time because starting yields were really low. You know, the cash rate is essentially zero. So if I then locked in an interest rate for a 10-year bond at that time, today I'm looking back at that decision going, you're crazy, because now interest rates have risen substantially. Now the 10-year bond rate is over 5%. And that bond's going to look very unattractive. And so the market value of that bond will decline. And that's not a big deal if you're going to hold the bond to maturity, but it's a big deal in terms of opportunity cost. Of course, I'm getting paid a very low interest rate. So if the if I have a floating rate, which is a little bit like a variable rate, the same, same sort of terminology, then it's linked, it's going to be linked to a benchmark interest rate, which could be the bank bill swap rate or it could be the cash rate, but that's going to have less duration, but it will still have some duration risk depending on its maturity. So that's the duration or interest rate risk that is associated with the bond. The second risk is called credit risk, and that's the credit spread. So the risk-free rate is really the 10-year government bond rate. That's if I'm going to buy an Australian federal government bond for 10 years, it's essentially zero risk because I'm going to always get their money, get the money back. Highly rated government debt. You know, the chance of default, Australia defaulting on a bond, virtually zero, right? Can't be absolutely zero, but virtually zero. So that's my risk-free rate. If I'm going to buy a bond from CBA, for example, or West Farmers, they're going to have a slightly higher credit risk than the Australian government does. Of course, there's some level of credit risk. That's what's called the credit spread. So the difference between the interest that CBA has to offer compared, and it might offer a bond at say 6.2%, and the government debt is offering a bond at 5.2%. So the credit spread, the difference between those two rates is 1%. And that 1% is to compensate you, the investor, for the credit risk. And the credit risk is that the issuer defaults, that they can't make the interest payments, that you don't get your principal back. Again, if we're lending to CBA or West farmers, I would argue that risk is still not zero, like it is with the Australian government, are still pretty low, right? But you might hear about something called private credit. Private credit is lending to corporations that can be very small, could even be small businesses, much smaller businesses than CBA and West farmers. And that's sometimes the credit risk in those sorts of instruments are very difficult to measure. We're not into, we don't invest in private credit. We just we don't think there's enough transparency there to be able to assess the risk. But that's where credit spreads can really widen. And in some of those bonds, those credit spreads could be three or four percent, five percent sometimes. And so if you're getting, you know, three or four, five percent above the benchmark interest rate, you're almost into sort of double digit returns, which on the face of it might look attractive, but not necessarily so much. So really they're the two things duration risk, which is really changes in interest rates and interest rate expectations and how long dated your bond is and whether it's variable or fixed in terms of the coupon. And the second one is credit spreads, that's the other thing that can change. Because, for instance, if I lend to CBA on a 10-year bond and my credit spread is fixed at 1%, which is sort of around about where it's going to be today. But if then for some reason, you know, the whole world goes into recession and bond investors become really worried about the health of the corporate environment and that, you know, if if a lot of companies are going bust, credit spreads will widen. And in that environment, you know, investors might say, Well, I don't want a 1% credit spread, I want a 2% credit spread. In that situation, the value of my bond is going to fall because the market has changed and credit spreads have widened, and that can have an impact on bond value. So you can see as a bond investor, you need to be conscious about these things. One argument, again, as I've used, could be, well, I don't really care. I'm going to hold the bond to maturity. And that might be the case, but remember, you might not always be in that position and also might not be economical to hold the bond to maturity. So again, going back to the COVID example, if I bought a government bond in 2021, for example, when the interest rates are zero, yes, I might be sitting on a paper loss today because the value of that bond, the market value of that bond has dropped. And I might say, I don't care, I'm going to hold it to maturity, but I'm still only picking up, you know, maybe a one or two percent yield on that bond where I could be getting a much better yield today. So the argument saying I'm gonna hold the bond to maturity doesn't always hold weight in terms of you still need to really think about interest rate risk and the impact on the market value of the bonds that we're investing in. Now, a lot of people in the fixed interest market say that your starting yield can have a very big impact on your future returns. So that is, and it's it's something to keep in in mind, and it's a really good rule of thumb if we're investing in bonds to really think carefully about. And the rule of thumb is it's very difficult to out-earn your starting yield. So by that I mean that if you buy a bond, oh let's say government bonds between 2019 and 2021, 10-year government bonds, the yield fell to about 1%. So if I bought a bond in 2019 to 2021 and got 1%, it's very hard to buy a bond at 1% and get more than 1% return. Your return's going to be probably your your ceiling is going to be 1%, right? Because the only way I'm going to earn better than 1% is if interest rates maybe go negative and the value of my bond increases, then I might be able to earn in excess of 1%. So if you think about today, when the 10-year government, Australian government bond rate is uh 5.2 to 5.25%, sort of in that sphere, it starts to look attractive because my maximum return is maybe around 5-ish percent, which isn't terrible. And even if the bonds fall in value, I'm still going to get probably a positive return, as opposed to buying a bond at 1%. So that's always something wise to keep in mind that my starting yield is an important metric to consider in terms of whether I'm attracted to investing in the bond market. And again, that rule of thumb that you can't very difficult to out-earn your starting yield is another good rule of thumb to, you know, the as a rules-based investor to really be thinking about in terms of, you know, future returns. Because yield is one thing. You know, if I'm getting a 5% income yield, that's great. But if the value of my bond is falling by 5%, then, you know, I'm sort of treading water or in fact in real terms with inflation going backwards. Okay, let's talk about term premium. And term premium is really going back to the analogy that I use for term deposits, it's really the difference between what a three-month term deposit is going to pay you and what a 12-month and what a two-year term deposit is going to pay you, and comparing those different interest rates. And of course, if you get a higher interest rate for longer term, that's your term premium. And that's what we need to really be thinking about. And if I'm going to take a term premium, sorry, if I'm going to invest in longer dated or longer term bonds, typically they're going to have more duration. So more interest rate sensitivity to changes in interest rate expectations. So if I'm going to accept more risk, because obviously the risk of the value of the bond changing or market value of the bond changing, then I need to be compensated for that risk. And so that's what we're trying to work out when we're looking at what term premium is. Now, as I said at the beginning of today's episode, it's not as simple as just comparing what is the 10-year bond rate and what is the current cash rate. Because if you did that comparison, 5.2 is the 10-year bond rate, 4.6 is currently the RBA cash rate, so 0.6 of a percent. But that assumes then, that comparison assumes that the cash rate's not really going to change. So, really, what we need to do is consider what does the market expect the average cash rate to be? Now that that's a subjective analysis. Of course, it's going to be different, and you'd have to do some research on, you know, what do the commentators expect, what are the economists expect, what do the bond traders expect. I I'd probably rather listen to a bond trader than an economist, because a bond trader is really taking a position. They're putting their money where their mouth is. The alternate way to look at it is to try and think about what is the neutral cash rate. So the neutral cash rate is when it's neither expansionary or contractionary from an RBA perspective. No one really knows what the neutral cash rate is, and it can change over time as well. So that's a little bit difficult. It's a bit of a black box. Christopher Joy, who runs Koulibar Capital and he writes for the AFR every weekend, I kind of like not all of his commentary, but some of his commentary, has very strong opinions, so you've got to put that in context. But what he does know, so I'll I'll listen to him certainly about his commentary with respect to fixed interest markets. Although sometimes I do think he talks his own book. So sometimes I'm a bit concerned. I'm not suggesting he's doing this, but I'll in the back of my mind I think, why is he saying this? Is it because he took a position? He wants to talk that position into his favor. Anyway, he's an expert in bond trading and Kouabar Capital probably trade, you know, one of the most, probably the most significant traders of bonds in Australia, at least that I'm aware of. So he wrote recently in AFR that he thinks the term premium is around about 0.9 of a percent. And that implies that the average, the time-weighted average cash rate, will be about 4.3% over the next 10 years. And so we can make a decision whether that's uh that's relevant. But really, since 1999, he said the term premier has averaged about half a percent. So the 10-year term premier, half a percent, long-term average, today, 0.9 of a percent. And this is the core of the question that came from the podcast listener is look at that. It's attractive or it looks attractive at the moment. Should we start accepting some term risk? Should we go longer in duration and will it work in our favor? Because of course, if that term premium is overstated and we buy the bonds today, if it mean reverts back to half a percent, the value of our bonds will increase. And so not only will we pick up the 5% yield, but we'll it pick up an expansion in market value. And then if we sell those bonds on the market before they mature, you know, we'll pick pick up that additional return. So what do I think? Do I think it's an attractive because there's the metrics? And I'm not going to argue against where it sits relative to history because that's the data, right? It's an evidence-based podcast. I acknowledge that's the case. But what I think's changed for investors is not really that analysis, is the options, right? If we ever think about what investors could do, say 10 years ago or even five years ago to some extent, if they wanted to earn a higher return, they could invest in turn deposits and then compare, you know, three-month maturity versus two-year maturity and look at those sort of that whether that compensation's there. Although the banks, you know, they're very quick to pass on RBA rate hikes to mortgage holders, but not so much, not as quick to pass it on to term deposit holders when it happens. So sometimes you've got to worry about, you know, whether the competition is fierce enough in Australia to earn that higher premier. Or they could look to government bonds. The Vanguards had a government bond managed fund, index fund for many, many years. They were generally the two sort of options that someone could maybe look for more duration or more yield by going for longer-term instruments. But now we've got a couple of ETFs that allow us to invest in what's called subordinated debt. So banks and corporates will issue senior debt and senior secured debt. So they're the they've got sort of first right of repayment if the business goes bust. Subordinated debt sits underneath that capital. So senior holders get paid first and then subordinated holders. But a lot of these bonds are issued by the banks, right? So you've got a form of view on what your credit risk is. If you think CBA is there's very little chance of CBA falling over or going bust, then you'd probably don't really care whether you're a senior holder or whether you're a subordinate holder. Now, theoretically, of course, there should be a margin difference there because I am taking slightly theoretical risk, but let's talk practically really about the risk. If CBA falls over or goes bust, we probably have bigger things to worry about in that situation than you know, bond prices and yields and credit risk. So BetaShares has subordinated debt ETF, the ticket code. Is B sub, B S U B, and Van Eck has a um subordinate debt fund as well. It's called Sub D, S U B D. So they're sort of two examples, if you like. The BetaShares one has an all-in yield of 5.96% at the moment, and a running yield of 6.3%, and a modified duration of 0.2 years. So 0.2 years means that it's very insensitive to, or it's not, what's the best way to say it? It's not sensitive to changes in interest rates. It's virtually got zero duration, which means it doesn't have interest rate risk, but it still has, you know, the credit spread risk that's always there with any corporate bonds. It's got an average credit rating of A minus, which is still very high, high quality credit. So, you know, the chance of default is very, very, very low. The reason why the, I just want to explain all-in yield, or sometimes it's called yield to worst or yield to maturity, is as I said, about 6%, but the running yield is 6.3%. And the reason for that is so it's paying 6.3% in real income. But the reason the all-in yield is lower is that some of these bonds, their market value is above par. So for example, their par value will be $100. They might be trading at $102, for example. That's fine now, but as the bond gets closer to maturity, it's going to trade closer to the par value, which means that the investor is going to experience a capital loss, so a capital decline. And so the all-in yield or yield to maturity or yield to worst, depending on what the terminology they use, is the one to look at because that's really your worst case scenario is a 6% return. You're going to get a 6.3% kind of income return. But if these bonds start maturing or get closer to maturity, that might decline. The chances are is that it depends if the the fund holds those bonds to maturity or if they can actually trade them on the secondary market. So that loss may never eventuate, but that's something to really look out for. The difference between BetaShares and Van Eck, Van Eck has some regional and foreign-rated banks where BetaShares just has the top-tier banks in Australia. But the Van Eck one still has a, in fact, a higher credit rating of A, slightly higher yield and with slightly more credit risk. We prefer typically we use Van X fund just because it has that slightly higher yield, slightly higher return. So we typically use Sub D. They're very similar sort of products. The important thing, it's all floating rates. So, you know, if the RBA hikes in November, your yield will rise by the same amount. So it's perfectly linked to whatever the RBA does, which means that there's no risk like with turn deposits, as I said, you're really uh reliant on competition, the banking market to get a better rate, whereas this is very transparent and flow straight to you. So this is puts duration risk and term premier in context, right? If I can go and buy an Australian government bond and I'm gonna earn 5.2%, I can earn an extra 1% return by buying or putting my money into a subordinated debt ETF like the two that I just described, and I can earn an extra 1%. Now, why am I earning the extra 1%? Well, because I'm taking the credit risk. But what credit risk is there really? I'm not saying it's zero risk. I have to sit here, we've got to sit here and acknowledge there's some theoretically and practically there's additional risk relative to what is essentially a risk-free government bond. But am I that risk adverse that I'm prepared to take a 1% haircut and earn a slightly lower return? If we look at the government bond ETFs, they actually tend to earn a, because they're going to hold a variety of different bonds, they're going to earn a yield of around 5%. So actually the difference is about 1.3% in terms of earnings. Am I prepared to take a slightly higher level of credit risk and no duration? So I've got no sensitivity to changes in interest rates. I think that is a better proposition than going for longer dated bonds, whether they're longer dated corporate debt or whether it's government debt. And it's not because I think that the premium isn't there, that the term premium isn't there. Clearly, it's an attractive moment to invest in government bonds. What I'm saying is that these subordinated ETF funds haven't been around that long. They were only launched in, well, Van X was launched in 2019. So just before COVID, if you like. So again, this is only just a sort of new revelation. You could buy, you know, if you're a wholesale investor, you could buy subordinated debt on the secondary market through a broker, over-the-counter broker, but that's not available to everyone. You've got to be a wholesale investor to do that. But these subordinate ETFs, much more liquid, very, very cost effective, very diversified. So a superior option than holding bonds directly in most circumstances. We do do some direct bond trading on secondary markets. It can work, particularly when understanding credit risk. But here, what we're comparing is do we want to go for a 10-year bond, a longer duration, longer maturity instrument? Are we quite comfortable with something that has no interest rate risk? A little bit of credit risk, I'll put that in averted commerce, and more than a percent higher return. The other alternative to subordinated debt was to go down the credit chain one further step and invest in hybrids, hybrid securities. But ASIC changed the rules around hybrid securities and banned the banks issuing them to retail investors. So that hybrid market is now shrinking. It'll run out until 2032, I think. There's only about 17 bank hybrids left that have been traded on the ASX. So we used to, we used to use, you know, hybrid securities as another way of capturing additional yield, and also because they paid him some imputation credits. But we're a little bit, we're not uncomfortable with that market, but that market is shrinking uh in terms of diversification and so forth. There is better shares has a bank hybrids ETF as well. Still pretty attractive. It's not bad, but it's something that you really want to think about in terms of how that runoff looks like and whether you'll just end up being a direct, almost a direct hybrid owner given the there'll be quite a bit of maturity happening over the next few years. I wanted to mention it because it's something that I've mentioned previously in previous podcast episodes, but that's why we're more focused on subordinated debt. It's very liquid, huge market, very cost effective, and I think relatively good, attractive yielding returns. Okay, as subordinated debt investors, there are a couple of risks that we need to be concerned with. The first one is credit spreads. So T2 debt, which is subordinated debt, currently has credit spreads of about 110 to 145 basis points. So that's 1.1 to 1.45%. That is relatively thin compared to where credit spreads have been historically. So if credit spreads normalize, but then the bond value could reduce. As we know, many of these subordinated bond issuances are actually trading above par value. And I think the reason they're trading above par value is just because of demand. They're attractive instruments issued by banks that are very, very safe. And I think most investors are saying, look, we don't think that materially there's a lot of risk difference between saying holding CBA bonds versus government bonds, and we're happy to pick up the higher spread. So the demand is pushing that credit spread thinner. The question is, will that demand change? I don't think so, but it could. And it's something to call out. Of course, what's happened in France over the last few weeks where credit spreads have widened, particularly on government debt. And just because, you know, people are worried about the amount of sovereign debt that France holds, sometimes events like that, well, they at least are contained to France at the moment, sometimes they can spread throughout the bond market. So sometimes sentiment can change, you know, in other countries as well. So that's a risk as well, that if sentiment around corporate debt changes, then it could impact Australian investors. Don't forget, there's a lot, there's been a lot of people holding hybrid securities, and that money has had to find a new home as that hybrid market winds down. And I think a lot of that money has gone into subordinated debt. So the chance of, I mean, the thing is if investors abandon subordinated debt, where else are they going to put their money? Well, they can put it into government securities, of course, but whether that's likely, I think you've got to really think about. But it's good to at least think always think about your downside. So if you're concerned about the credit risk and those credit margins widening, you can move up the credit scale and go for senior debt. So Betishares has a senior debt bond fund, bank bond fund. Its uh ticket code is coupon, so Q P O N. And it also has an Australian government bond fund. Its ticket code is AGVT. All these links are in the blog on the website, of course. The government bond fund pays around 5%. So again, you can move, you know, up the credit scale in terms of getting lower risk and more protection, but it's going to come at a cost. And, you know, whether whether you want to do that, of course, that's something you want to think about. The other thing to think about too is typically bonds are used in a portfolio to create negative correlation, which means that, you know, if the share market was to fall, typically the value of bonds rise. Because in a risk-off appetite, people go, well, I don't want to invest in shares anymore. I'm going to put all my money into bonds. And so, you know, that demand into bonds pushes prices higher. And typically that's traditionally why we have a mixture of fixed income and shares in a portfolio. However, it's not always the case. Remember, back in 2022, the share market crashed, but also government bonds fell as well. The value of bonds fell, the value of corporate bonds fell. And so we were in a situation where both those asset classes were falling, which is not ideal. It's only happened two or three times in the last hundred years, but it's not a guarantee, right? And that's the thing we've got to work out that there's a lot of challenge around interest rate changes, I think, now, inflation, getting inflation under control, you know, how aggressive central banks and how well central banks are doing in that regard. And that's just another fact that we've got to sort of navigate today. So, as I've spoken about before, we prefer to go for absolute return. So for most of our clients, we're not really concerned about creating negative correlation. We just want what's the highest return for lowest risk. And typically that's going to be from the share market. So, of course, this podcast is for people that are interested in investing in fixed interest, but really that's always been our focus. So we're not going to invest in bonds for negative correlation. One, because it's not always going to be there, it's not guaranteed. But two, because we want to maximize longer-term returns. I also just want to add another note, another little footnote, because the listener that gave me the idea for today's episode also asked about a specific ETF. And so the ticker code of the ETF that the this person asked is PGBF, which is a PIMCO. And PIMCO is is, I think, one of the largest um fixed interest managers in the world. Uh, they've got a global bond active ETF. So as I said, PGBF. And the listener said it's paying more than 7%. Well, actually, the the yield to maturity is 7.26% when I looked at it, but actually the income it's paying is closer to 4%. So it's really important to understand running yield and yield to worst or yield to maturity. The reason why the yield to maturity for this fund is higher than the running yield is because a lot of the bonds are trading at a discount, a discount to their par value. Now, of course, if the investor or if the fund holds those bonds to maturity, I don't know how long. Well, the average maturity period for that fund is 6.7 years. So if you're happy to hold that that ETF for really the next 10 years, you may actually end up earning 7% return. But the market might discount those bonds below, you know, the market value might sit below par value for for a very long time and you might not actually get the return. So it's very, very important when you're looking at ETF funds, fixed interest funds, to understand the terminology, understand the risks, and understand what return will you really, what cash return will you really get from investing in this fund. Of course, in a fund like this, where the bonds are trading below market value, it's actually pretty attractive. But there's nothing to say that the market value can't fall any further as well. I mean, if they're holding a lot of junk debt, you know, very low-rated debt, although it's got an average credit rating of AAA, but if they're holding a lot of junk debt or some junk debt, that it might even fall further. So there's no guarantees with this. It's an actively managed fund. It's not something we would be interested in, but something to the reason I'm bringing up is that it's important to understand those two terminologies in terms of YouTube maturity and running yield. So, really to sum up today's podcast, yes, we acknowledge that the term premier is above average. Well, we don't know how much above average because it's very difficult to measure. It is, but certainly it's attractive relative to historic standards. That would suggest that introducing duration into a portfolio could actually be a good thing. But we think there's alternatives such as subordinated debt ETFs that give us zero, virtually zero interest rate risk, some credit spread risk, but relative to the alternatives, which are you know government bond fund or even going up the credit scale, we believe that it gives us a perfect balance between risk and return and that we pick up a really good quality return. If you think about it, if the RBA hikes uh again in November, you're going to be getting about six and a half percent income off these ETFs. Pretty good for zero duration risk in terms of no sensitivity to future changes in interest rates. We think that's a pretty compelling proposition. But of course, as I said, you know, this is this podcast is great for people that have already decided they want some of their portfolio in defensive investments and some in shares. If you haven't made that decision, again, our the way we think about it typically is, you know, if you've got a if you're happy to deal with the volatility from from year to year, and really what you want to do is just maximize your average return between now and retirement, and that time period is many years and many decades, then go for absolute return. Don't worry about bonds. You're probably better off putting all your money in the share market. And over the very long, it's going to have higher volatility, but over the longer run, it's most likely to have higher returns as well. But even if you are in that camp, always good to learn about alt, I think, alternative asset classes like bonds and understand them a little bit better. If the time comes that you want to, you've got some money and you're not prepared to put it in the market and you just want to park up for a little while as using those subordinated ETF subordinated debt ETFs can be a good solution for that. Okay, I'm gonna leave it there for today. Normally I tease what I'm gonna talk about next week, but since I've only just come back from leave, I haven't even written the blog yet. So who knows what next week's episode's gonna be. But until then, bye for now.
People on this episode
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.