Investopoly
Investopoly is a twice-weekly podcast designed to help you make better financial decisions and build wealth with clarity and confidence. Hosted by Stuart (tax adviser, financial adviser, and mortgage broker) and Campbell (senior financial adviser), each episode delivers concise, practical insights grounded in real-world strategy, research, methodologies, and case studies.
You will get two episodes each week: a main episode that deep-dives into a single wealth-building topic, and a Q&A episode that answers listener questions and real scenarios. Send your questions to questions@investopoly.com.au
We also write a weekly blog, and many podcast topics build on those ideas and frameworks. Stuart’s book, Wealth by Design, is out now in soft cover, e-book and audiobook: https://amzn.asia/d/08a4BmhI. His next book, Business by Design, written for business owners, is due mid 2027.
Investopoly
Ep 433: ASX 200 or global shares: Where to put new money
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
I wouldn’t sell your Australian shares, but I’d put most new money into global shares. The ASX is concentrated, expensive, and slow-growing. The ASX 200 returned a solid 9.4% a year over the past decade, but that came mostly from banks and BHP, and the top 10 stocks now make up half the index. In this episode, I look at what’s likely to drive future returns: valuations, high dividend payout ratios, oligopolies, a 2% technology weighting, and weak per capita GDP and productivity growth. I also cover the case for keeping your existing Australian holdings, including franking credits, income, and population growth.
00:00 Introduction
00:40 Not anti-Australia, just an investment view
01:15 Past returns: the ASX vs global shares over 10 years
02:48 The real question: where should new capital go?
03:25 How concentrated the ASX 200 has become
05:04 Valuation: ASX vs global shares
05:40 CBA vs Alphabet: similar PE ratios, very different growth
07:06 An economy built on digging and shipping
08:40 High dividend payout ratios and the cost to growth
09:47 Franking credits and the case for retaining profits
11:04 Where’s the innovation?
13:39 Oligopolies and the lack of competition
14:34 The supermarket example
16:04 Where shareholder returns actually come from
17:07 Technology: 2% of the ASX vs 40% of the S&P 500
18:41 The wealth equation and compounding growth
19:16 Why Australia produces few large startups
22:51 Summing up the observations
23:10 GDP growth per capita: Australia vs the US
24:46 Labour productivity
26:54 The positives: reasons to keep Australian shares
29:41 What to do: keep existing holdings, direct new money globally
31:49 Next week: where share market returns come from
Related episodes:
Ep 397: Australian vs International Shares: Why the 45:55 split does not add up
https://investopoly.buzzsprout.com/2005600/episodes/18714304-ep-397-australian-vs-international-shares-why-the-45-55-split-does-not-add-up
Ep 432: Bond ETFs vs 10-Year government bonds: Lock in or not?
https://investopoly.buzzsprout.com/2005600/episodes/20012238-ep-432-bond-etfs-vs-10-year-government-bonds-lock-in-or-not
Q&A - Bucket company asset allocation: trust or company?
https://investopoly.buzzsprout.com/2005600/episodes/20011909-q-a-bucket-company-asset-allocation-trust-or-company
Optional:
Ep 318: Why does Australia’s share market always underperform?
https://investopoly.buzzsprout.com/2005600/episodes/15604297-ep-318-why-does-australia-s-share-market-always-underperform
Read Stuart's latest book? He's only got 19 reviews on Amazon so far, if Wealth by Design helped you, leaving one would mean a lot: https://www.amazon.com.au/review/create-review?asin=192318654X
Run your own business?
Check out Business by Design, Stuart and Mena's show on starting, growing and exiting a business, at https://www.businessbydesignpodcast.com/
Our most popular free guides:
Over the years we've written hundreds of articles. These three bring our best thinking together on the topics that matter most right now: choosing a super fund, debt recycling, and navigating the new tax changes.
Got a question for the podcast?
Email us at questions@investopoly.com.au
Subscribe to my weekly blog:
Important
This podcast provides general information about finance, tax and credit. It doesn't take into account your specific objectives, financial situation or needs, so you need to assess whether it's relevant to your circumstances before acting on it. If you're not sure, speak to a licensed, trustworthy professional.
Hi, my name's Stuart Weams and welcome to the Investopoly Podcast. Our goal is to share easy to understand, evidence-based, holistic insights to help you master the game of building wealth. Okay, before we get into today's episode, I just wanted to apologize for yesterday's QA episode. If the audio quality wasn't as great as it could have been, we've moved into a new office. We have a dedicated room for recording podcasts. So you'd think the audio would be better than it historically has been. But anyway, I'm not sure what went wrong. It wasn't ideal. Hopefully this is much clearer, much better. Anyway, let's see how we go. Remember, I am an accountant, mortgage broker, and financial advisor, not a professional content producer or anything like that. Anyway, we're all gonna learn as we go, don't we? Okay, today I want to talk about the Australian share market. And I guess it's really about Australia as well and the economy and the settings and these sorts of things. And I just want to say from the outset, it's gonna be a bit anti-Australia today's episode. It's not anti-Australia as in the country, it's really anti-Australia, obviously, from an investment perspective. So I just want to say that up front because you know Australia's a fantastic country. We're very, very lucky to live here. Okay, it's not per but there's really a lot of other places in the world that uh, you know, worse off than what we are. So I just want to say that from the outset. The second point I want to make from the outset is this is about future expected returns, not past returns. So in the 10 years to the end of August, the ASX accumulation index, which includes dividends, so both growth and dividends, returned 9.4% per annum compounding, which isn't a bad return at all. Now, the Misky World Index or the Global Index returned 14%, mainly thanks to a stellar run by the US. So, okay, not as good as international markets, but I reckon if you invest in any investment and get 9.4%, you're gonna be pretty happy with that. I mean, at that rate, your money is gonna double every seven and a half years. That's a pretty good outcome. And it's pretty close to long run average as well. I mean, long run average is around 10%, both for international and Australian share markets. But as I've said a number of times, headline performance is good, but you've got to really understand what's driven the performance. And really, in Australia's perspective, it's really banks and resource companies that have delivered that great, pretty good return over the last decade or so. They've enjoyed substantial gains, upward revision of valuation multiples, these sorts of things. But, you know, where are the future returns going to come from? And but as investors, we've got to ask ourselves, can that repeat itself? How likely is it they're gonna have another 10 years of similar sort of returns? And the problem is the sectors, the remaining sectors and companies within the index probably just aren't large enough to really lift it or to have a a really big influence on future returns. So what I'd like to do today is just go through a few points that hopefully help inform you or at least help you form a view on what the Australian share market might deliver in the future. And hopefully what I'm trying to do here is help you work out if you're gonna contribute additional capital into share markets, where should that capital go? And that's always the key question. The key asset allocation question is you know, where do I invest and how much do I invest amongst all those different options? That's the decision you as an investor can control. You can't control markets, you can't control Trump, interest rates, Australian government, all that sort of stuff. It is what it is, but you can control where you're putting the money. And that arguably that's an investor's most important decision. Okay, let's get into it. Let's talk about the makeup of the ASX 200, which is the key index. Vanguard uses ASX 300, but doesn't really change the numbers that much. So financials and materials make up most of the index. So financials, which is really the big five banks, really the big four banks plus Macquarie will be most of that financials allocation. Anyway, financials make up 33% of the index. So one third is in financials, and with materials, that makes up another 27%. So together, that's 60% of the entire index. And it's even more concentrated than that in actual names, in actual companies. So the big four banks account for 25%, and BHP is another 10.5%. So you've got 35% or more than one third just in five stocks in two different sectors. In fact, it's worse than that. The top 10 stocks account for 50% of the index. So are you an index investor or are you just investing in large cap stocks? I'm not really sure. Compare that to the Misky World Index, the top 10 account for about 28%. And that's even after, you know, accounting for the fact that, you know, that includes some multi-trillion dollar companies in the US as well. So, you know, it really does show by comparison how concentrated the Australian market has become. And you know, also always talk about quality first and then price in terms of when investing, whether it's shares, property, whatever it might be. So quality is important. You want to have a quality index that gives you, you know, well-diversified exposure to multiple sectors and industries without too much concentration. Well, that's not the ACE. So far, we've established that's not the ASX. Let's talk about valuation. So the ASX 200 index is trading at around about 19 times on a forward PE basis. By comparison, global shares, again, about 18 times. Remembering that the global index is dominated by US large cap stocks, and some of them are trading at ridiculous PE ratios as well. So it really does put it in context. It's kind of failing a little bit, a reasonable amount, on both quality and price. Now let's dig a little bit deeper and give you some real-world examples. So you take CBA, for example, it represents more than 10% of the ASX 200 Unix. It's similar to BHB, about 10.5%. It's trading on a P ratio in the mid-20s. I mean, it depends on how you're using forward or trailing PE and which earnings you use. But it's really only, I mean, it's profitable, profitability growth is around 7%. So, you know, it's growing its profits, but like it's not a stellar growth company, let's be honest. I mean, you compare that to Alphabet, which is Google, it's trading on a similar PE ratio, but its profit growth is 30%. So you go, okay, maybe you can justify a mid-20s PE ratio because you got 30% profit growth. But why are those two businesses valued differently? Now you can argue that CBA is less risk than Google. And I think that there's an argument to be made there because it's really about risk and growth. But it does provide some context, right? Like you would you prefer to be an investor in Google or CBA at these current valuations? So that's financials, but you know, what about the resource companies, so BHP and so forth? I mean, they're heavily influenced by commodity prices and much of Australia's resources exported to China. So really their profitability depends on sort of global conditions and commodity cycles, really factors largely outside of the control of BHP. So that CASX 200 index, let's sort of cast a wider net and just look at the economy and the makeup of the economy. Because of course, if I'm investing in index, I'm a long-term investor. And sure, they may be the companies that dominate that index today, but that we know that changes over time. And over decades, it can change quite considerably. So let's look at Australia. I mean, Australia is resource rich. I mean, you talk about BHP and its reliance on China, but all we do, and it's not a new observation, plenty of people made or shared the same observation, but all we're doing is really digging the stuff out of the ground and exporting most of it to China, who then turns that into steel, machinery, consumer goods, really capturing most of the additional value and profit along the way. So, of course, we've got the resources and wealth to develop these raw materials in Australia and then export the final goods, but in the most part, we haven't done that. And actually, there's a Harvard's got a growth lab and it ranks countries, you know, depending on economic complexity. So, which really measures how diverse and sophisticated a country's exports are. And unfortunately, Australia ranks 74th out of 145 countries. So there's the evidence, that's the observation. Here's the evidence. And again, when you remember when you're investing in a geographical location, we're going to start thinking about these things, particularly since, you know, we don't have a lot of global businesses in Australia. Unlike, say, in the UK, where a lot of the businesses listed on the London Stock Exchange have global revenues. That's not true for in Australia. So we need to then think about how are these companies going to grow revenue within Australia and how good is Australia, how entrepreneurial is it, and so forth. So the fact that we're not manufacturing anything, creating much within the country from an investment perspective, again, doesn't make it look very attractive. Let's talk about dividends because sometimes high dividend yield has cited as like a positive associated with investing in Australia. And it can be a positive in some regards. But the problem for shareholders is that if you distribute 70, 80% of your profit, you don't have a lot of profit to reinvest. And ultimately, I mean, Buffett talks about it all the time. He doesn't want dividends. He wants a smart management team with a great business model to take those profits, reinvest, and grow the business. Ultimately, that's going to generate or hopefully generate more shareholder value over the long run. But that's not what Australian companies do. CBA paid out about 70% of their cash profit, NAB about 73%, Westpac 76%, but it's not unique to the banks. BHP distributed 72%, West Farmers around 80% of earnings. Really, I mean, I would argue that's lazy business, right? These businesses should have opportunity to reinvest, grow their businesses, expand their businesses to generate more shareholder value. Now, of course, one of the reasons why, or at least the reasons cited why, they pay out is really because franking credits, a lot of people say, well, because Australians get the benefit of that pass-through tax credit, you know, that investors really value franking credits. And if, for example, CBA decided to stop paying out 77% of cash profit through dividends, maybe the share price is going to drop. Well, maybe, but also maybe if they do it for a few years and reinvest it and generate even more value and more profit growth, maybe in fact they'll find that, you know, it's not such a bad thing to do. And CSL's probably the only outlier here. I mean, it hasn't had a great couple of years, CSL, in terms of share price, but it's been one where it's always had a very low dividend yield, partly probably because of its valuation, but it's reinvested the business and grown the business. Now, a high dividend payout ratio isn't necessarily a bad thing. I mean, if if the board and the business don't actually have something good to do with the money, of course, give it back to shareholders. But and it could mean that you're in a mature industry and there is really no, there are really no growth prospects. But I would say for most of those really large cap companies, I'm surely there's some opportunities, either globally or domestically, they could reinvest into to grow the business. As I said, CSL's the exception. Goodman Group, same sort of thing. Aristocrat, same thing. They've historically retained a greater share to fund sort of innovation acquisitions and international expansion. And unfortunately, the lack of innovation is really obvious, I think, in the market. I mean, you take the banks, the banks earn so much money, it's insane. Like CBA earned $11 billion in the 26th financial year. Now they've invested heavily in technology, but a lot of that's gone into increasing efficiency, protecting customers, you know, more sort of regulatory improvements and these sorts of things. It's not really innovation. And if you have a look in financial services, most of the innovation has occurred overseas. So you think about businesses like Stripe, WISE, Aiden, they're all sort of payment, online payment, you know, WISE is foreign exchange, Stripe is credit cards, Aiden's a payment platform. So they've they've all developed sort of globally financial services businesses that are very competitive, often challenging sort of traditional banks. Even Afterpay, for example, which is Australian, really came out, emerged outside the banking sector, so it didn't come through the banks. So it's interesting, isn't it? I mean, they've got the resources to do it to back, and I know they do back, you know, some startups and they've got some sort of emerging capital out. They're doing some of it. But I really think they could have tried to at least be a little bit more innovative and, you know, maybe put some of that profit to better use. I mean, protecting your existing business and protecting existing profits, yes, good, it's important, but really growing the profit base, you know, growing more than 7%. Well, I think that the answer is that, you know, can you back a stripe? Can you back a wise? These sorts of things. And you might say, look, Stuart, they're not going to develop products that are going to cannibalize their existing business. And that can be true. But if you, if anyone's read Jim Collins's Good to Great, you know, most of those companies actually did, in fact, that. They realized that they were in an industry that was low growth. They pivoted, they developed additional products or went down sort of aligned industries and exactly grew great businesses exactly like that. So it does happen and it's possible. But really, the broad problem is that Australia has a lot of large companies in there in the index, and they're very good at generating consistent profit, maybe not a lot of huge amount of profit growth, and they're happy to distribute a lot of those profits, but their capability of reinvesting and creating growth, which is really what we want as investors. Well, actually, I should say their opportunity to do so is substantial, but whether they've done so or there's no actually no evidence of them doing so is what I'm trying to say. So why don't we see more innovation in Australia? Well, there's, you know, that saying necessity is the mother of invention in that, you know, you've got to be put in a position to really, like if you're put in a position where you've got a major problem, it forces you to develop and innovate and get yourself out of that problem. That's really what that saying is trying to say. So maybe one of the reasons that Australian companies less to tend to be less innovative than their counterparts is that they don't have to be. If you think about Australia, many industries are dominated by only a handful of large companies. And we tend to call them oligopolies instead of a monopoly. Monopoly's one, but oligopoly is just a handful of companies. So if you think about banking, for example, top five banks, really top big four banks, if you like, on a retail basis, communications, Telstra major, supermarkets, Woolies and Coles, Airlines, Virgin and Qantas, energy retailing insurance. You know, competition is pretty limited. In fact, if we look at the supermarkets, back in March 25, the ACC released inquiry that said that the supermarket industry was highly concentrated, yeah, duh, but there was limited incentives for Coles and Woolworths to compete aggressively on price. That's what the ACC said. And if you have a look at the market share, Woolys has got about 38%, Kohl's about 29%, and Aldi about 9%. That's 76% of the market, that's an oligopoly. So that's the observation and the evidence. The ACC also found that Australian supermarkets were among the most profitable in the world. Now, as an Australian consumer, that's bad news. But for investors, historically, that has been good news. Like if you think about it, higher profit margins lead to more reliable dividend income streams, better valuations, potentially more growth in terms of expansion of multiple if you know if we're in an industry where we're quite protected. But of course, there's a downside to this as well is necessity is a mother of all inventions. Like if we're in an industry and we've got to really compete, we're gonna get better. We're either gonna win or we're gonna die. And we want to invest in the winners. That's what the indexing does. It ultimately holds the winners and the losers fall out of the index. And that's how we make a return. So really, yes, the lack of competition, yeah, can you can make an argument it's good for shareholders in the short term. In the longer term, my argument would be we're gonna have a lot of lazy companies. Or at least companies that aren't necessarily as strong and as good as they are, as they could be. And I think in business, you're either growing or you're dying, right? There's no in-between, there's no just sort of treading water. So you've either got to go healthful other and innovate and become the best you can be, or you may as well just sort of give up and walk away. And remember, from a shareholder's perspective, there's only two ways we're gonna get a return: either a growth in profit or an expansion in valuation multiple. So we can get an expansion in valuation multiple multiple if we've got higher growth or less risk, but it comes back to growing profit. So if we're in mature industries with a significant market share, there's only so much profit growth we're actually gonna get. And then we've got to innovate to find further profit growth. And I just don't think we're there because as I said, a lot of those industries are oligopolies. There's not enough competition to create that innovation. You tend to have then more lazy businesses. And remember, that's an unattractive combination for investors because we've got modest profit growth and then a little prospect of higher valuations because of the lower growth, and the valuations are already pretty stretched as it is. That really equals lower returns. Okay, the next observation is around technology. Technology accounts for about 2% of the ASX 200 index compared to 40% of the SP 500 index. So of course, Australia doesn't have nil technology exposure. It's got companies like Techwise, it's been in the media over the last few years, not great media. Zero, and share price hasn't done so great recently. Technology One, Next DC is a data center company not doing so great. Yeah, so we've got some exposure, but if you think about, you know, the likes of NVIDIA, Apple, Microsoft, you know, these businesses are really at the forefront of technology innovation, AI, all these sorts of stuff, have enormous enormous market caps, investing enormous amounts in AI. And you've just got to think, I mean, who knows who's the winners are gonna be? You think NVIDIA, Apple, Microsoft, one of them probably won't win over the next 10, 20 years, but really you've got to be in it to win it. And you don't need to pick technology. I don't think we need to be tech investors. The index will work it as I said. And some of the tech companies are trading at relatively attractive PEs relative to the industry. So I've mentioned previously Google, for example, or Alphabet. Its profit has been strong, profit growth has been strong, and it's, I think, at a at an attractive PE. I'm not a direct share investor, so I'm advocating, but I'm saying is we can still invest in technology and US technology without necessarily exposing the portfolio to huge risk, huge valuation risk. But we're not going to get that exposure in Australia. And I think that's a big problem because of course technology as the industry is certainly going to be a driver of growth. And remember, the easiest way to build wealth is compounding capital growth. Remember the wealth formula, which is investable surplus cash flow multiplied by investment return and efficiency multiplied by time. Investment return and efficiency is how much is your return and how much do you get to reinvest each year? Remember, if we get compounding capital growth, we don't pay capital gains tax until we sell it. That's very powerful. So technology or the absence of technology as a sector in Australia is not ideal. Now, if we can widen the net even further beyond that, beyond the current economy, why doesn't Australia produce more, have more successful startups? I mean, it's got some, Canva's a big one more recently. You know, it's not like there's none. And, you know, Australia has produced a lot of innovative products and so forth. But, you know, we're such a lucky country, we've got such good education and conditions in the most part. You know, what why, why aren't we more entrepreneurial? So, firstly, I think the banking industry doesn't really support startups. I mean, if you want to go and borrow to start a business or to buy an existing business and you don't have real estate as security as in a house or an investment property, just secure the loan, you're gonna you're gonna struggle. I mean, you might get a little bit of money, but you're not gonna get very much money at all. And that's been spoken about in terms of, you know, whether there should be a greater onus on big Australian banks to support the small business sector more than what they do. And I think it makes sense. It's a really interesting observation if you think about it. There's some when the banks report bad debts, quite often it's to property developers or really large corporates where they've lent, you know, $300 million to a business, maybe even a listed business, that never was never making money to begin with, and they've had to write off 300 million. Whereas you've got an entrepreneur out there, you know, that has a great idea that probably has a really good chance of being successful, but they won't lend to them. And it's always annoyed me a little bit. Secondly, I think there's a culture in Australia, I think, you know, of accepting kind of entrepreneurial risk and accepting of failure. And I think, for example, in the US, that it's seen as a valuable learning exercise, good on you how to go. In Australia, there's a bit of a tall poppy syndrome, you know, if you're just trying to stick your head out a little bit too far. Again, I don't want to be really negative with Australia, but there is a cultural difference between here and the US. Thirdly, the tax position doesn't is a problem as well. I mean, they're not really the tax settings don't really encourage entrepreneurialism. Well, firstly, we've got a flat tax rate. Of course, when we're individuals, if we earn $20,000, we won't pay any tax. And then if we earn between $20,000 and $45,000, we'll pay a little bit of tax, about 17%, I think it is. So it's encouraging people to go out and earn a little bit more incrementally. Whereas a flat tax rate, you know, if you if you've got to turn over less than $10 million, you're gonna pay 25%. Well, BHP generates billions of dollars of profit. It pays 30%. How's that fair? Like, shouldn't it be marginal? Like the first couple hundred grand you make in a business should be taxed at lower than the next couple hundred thousand you might make in profit. And notwithstanding that, the CGT is a problem as well, particularly post 1 July 27, because indexation doesn't help. You if you start a business from scratch, your cost base is zero. So indexation doesn't really help. And then, yes, the government's changed the rules so that you can use the small business CGT discount. So you can have a 50% discount. So you're still going to pay 23.5%. But the problem is you've got the $10 million turnover cap. So it's like the government's saying, okay, we'll tax you less if you're relatively successful. But if you're going to be really successful in growing a business, and remember it, a $10 million turnover, I mean, in some businesses, that's huge. But in a product-based business, depending on the type of products you're selling, if you're selling cars or, you know, a high value product, $10 million isn't necessarily a big benchmark to reach. So essentially, if it's over 10 million, you don't get that discount, essentially you're going to pay 47% of your capital gain out in tax. So the tax settings are like, well, you know, start a business, but don't be too, you know, don't be too successful. Sort of penalizes, you know, becoming too successful, if you like. I think we need to have better tax systems to create more innovation in Australia, really grow that small business sector. Okay, so essentially my observations are that there's little innovation in Australia, both from the large cap companies that certainly have the financial resources and ability to innovate, but also from a startup perspective in terms of culturally lending settings and taxation settings. So that's the observation. Let's go back to the evidence. Okay, so there's two bits of evidence that I'd like to share to sort of support this thesis. The first one is GDP growth, because GDP growth is really trying to measure the economic engine of a particular country, of course. And, you know, again, if we're investing in this country and revenues are going to be generated from this country, that's going to be important to think about. So let's compare it to the largest developed global economy in the world, which obviously is the US. So when we look at GDP growth, Australia on dollar terms grew by 2.1% compared to 2.2% in the US. You go, okay, Australia's doing okay, but that's not really a fair comparison because we've expanded our population. Of course, that's been well documented in terms of immigration numbers and so forth. So let's look at it on a per capita basis. And let's look at it by quarter by quarter over the last year. So in the September quarter on a per capita basis, Australia is 0.4 of a percent, US is 2.1. So that's US is sort of broadly in line with, you know, its dollar value increase, but obviously the growth in Australia pretty poor. Uh 0.9 versus 1.6 in December quarter, 1% versus 2.3% in March quarter, and June quarter was 0.7 versus 1.9 almost 2% as well. So it shows that our economy is really growing at less than half the rate than the US economy is on a per capita basis. So we can wind address these numbers because of course, you know, if we grow the population, it looks like we're growing the economy, but we've got to be careful about getting seduced by those numbers. They're not the real numbers. That's not the real problem though. And and productivity, labor productivity, which is measured really by the output per hour. So if I work an hour, what is my output? And my economic output, what are if someone in the US works an hour, what is their economic output? We need productivity growth. And particularly with technology, we should expect to see productivity growth. Well, it is absolutely terrible. So again, quarter by quarter. September 25 quarter, 0.8 of a percent for Australia, 2.5% for the US. December, same trend, 1% versus 2.5%. March, terrible, 0.3 of a percent versus almost 3% in the US. Three times the productivity. Maybe it's AI in the US, I don't really know. And June is is even worse. The productivity rate went back 0.2 of a percent, actually declined productivity, and US was 2.2%. Now it's been well documented that productivity has been really poor in Australia. People might blame the the non-market sector, so the public service for that and you know, just employing more and more public service. But this is this is just the market sector. This is not the total economy. And in I'm looking at US non-farm payrolls productivity as well. So I'm trying to compare, like with like these two measures in the US and Australia aren't perfectly comparable, but it gives you a sense of the theme. You know, what is the economy doing? Is it growing? Why is it not growing? And like I think it comes back down to I think like with many things, I don't think we can point to one thing why we don't have enough GDP growth and enough productivity growth in Australia. And, you know, politically people are gonna throw stones and say, like, it's immigration, it's the government's fault, etc., etc. It's like many things, it's probably a whole bunch of different things that are contributing to it. But it doesn't matter. Like it doesn't really matter so much for investors. It is what it is, right? We make the observations in terms of lack of competition, concentration, lack of ability to earn global revenues, limited growth prospects, therefore, oligopoly behavior, lack of investment, all these sorts of things. And we said they're the observations and we say, okay, the economy is not growing. And so I think it's it's pretty bad news, really, for the Australian share market. Now, I don't want to be, I want to be balanced, I don't want to be all negative about the ASX. I mean, I'll sort of sum it up at the end of course, but let's talk about what are the positives. Why would you retain your existing Australian investments? Might not contribute more new capital to it, but why would you retain your existing investments? Well, firstly, franking credits. That's about a percent in terms of return after tax return. Depending on the investor, it's going to vary, of course. But also banking income, yes, it's not very tax effective, but it does reduce the risk of investment because if I'm banking five or six percent in income, then I only need, you know, maybe five, four or five percent in growth to be really happy with long-term returns. Whereas if I'm getting virtually no income, then I'm really relying all on growth. So on that basis, just purely on that factor, you go, well, maybe having higher income does reduce growth. Secondly, the resource sector, they're good. I mean, the BHP is a good company, it's good at what it does, it's got sound economics. You know, the price gains alone in the 26th financial year were about 48% or thereabouts. So, you know, it's really strong price growth. So, you know, if you are backing a sector, at least, you know, that that company sector certainly has it's huge and it's got a strong track record. Third, population growth. I know I cited it as a way of, well, maybe I position it as a negative. I mean, it's a negative on a per capita basis in terms of measuring economic value. But at the end of the day, increasing population is still good for the economy. It increases demand for housing, credit, consumer goods. You know, if you've got a slow-growing economy, that's not great. You've first got to grow the population and then the economy. That's why I think to turn Victoria around won't be as challenging. I'm gonna say there's no challenges there, as challenging because Victoria, for whatever reason, still has really strong population growth. And so that's good. You know, that's you really need that kind of economic engine to sort of push the economy forward. And finally, global markets aren't without their concentration risk as well and valuation risk. I mean, again, looking to the US, major large cap stocks, some trading on pretty lofty PE ratios. You look at NVIDIA or some of the AI sort of stuff. I mean, how much of this is actually going to generate long-term economic value for shareholders? You can't sit there and go, all of it's gonna be good well invested. There's gonna be some money wasted. I mean, once if someone comes out with a chip or a tool or something or technology that requires far less power. You know, what happens to these data centers? What is all the investment? Technology is evolving so quickly. I think it's really difficult to say, look, over the next five, 10 years, this investment's uh certainly gonna pay a handsome return. I think there's gonna be a lot of money wasted. So, you know, that that's not without its risk either. So I'm not trying to form a view to say, look, the ASX is terrible, the global markets are without risk. They've all got their risks, but I think it's really important to sit back and go, what future returns? Yes, the past returns have been good. And when you look over 40-year returns, they're good too. Because I think over the next 40 years, maybe it's difficult. I think some of these things could unwind over the next 40 years or turn around. So it's really what will medium to slightly longer term returns be? So let's say five to 10 years. That's what I'm sort of looking at. So what do you do? Well, it's not an argument for selling Australian shares. If you have an Australian exposure in your portfolio in your super fund or you've got existing shares and you're happy with the performance, so if you've got a fundamental index, QOS or A200, just traditional index or X20, one of these funds that are really fundamentally sound, keep it. I don't think it's really you need to go and sell it. Again, if we're very long-term investors, I think it's hard to uh go against history and say, you know, one particular geographical market's gonna underperform. It's really the whole idea behind this podcast is really about making a case for allocation of new capital. And exactly what Campbell discussed in February, so episode 397, which was Australia versus International, why the 45-55 split doesn't add up. And that was really a case of, you know, what about investing more globally? And I think this really just adds to it, particularly given the news more recently around population growth, GDP growth, productivity. They're all a concern. And everything I've spoken about, I think, you know, personally and both professionally from an investment perspective, it's concerning, both for an Australian and for an investor. But it's really about thinking very carefully about every additional dollar I put into investment. You want that dollar to work as hard as possible for you. Once that dollar is committed, assuming you've followed all the evidence-based rules, it's then just sticking with that investment for many, many decades. So don't necessarily go and sell your Australian ETFs. But in terms of additional capital, what you can do is dilute them by putting most of your capital into global markets. Not advice, of course, never advice in the podcast. I don't know your circumstances, just information only. Okay, next next week's episode is going to be about sharing some share market insights with you. So, how do markets behave? Where do returns come from? And my thesis behind this episode was really helping people understand how returns are generated. Because quite often we go, yeah, low-cost indexing, it's cheap, it does pretty well, it beats active managers, and it's very convenient and simple. So there's certainly some benefits, but let's understand why indexing works. So that's what I want to talk about next week. Just a reminder we've got the resource website. I'm gonna start building out. I know I need to produce the, I was gonna come up with a XL financial model to sort of trek whether you're on track for retirement. And that's still on the to-do list, of course. Uh fortunately, I've got to record this wealth by design book audio. I'll be finished that over the next week or so and uh I'll get on to that. But investopoly.com.au is the resource page there that we're going to really build out over the next couple of months. Anyway, thanks for being with us. Until next week. Bye for now.
People on this episode
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.