What Are the Shoplifting Laws in New Jersey? - Adam M. Lustberg

From Lustberg Law Offices, LLC - What Are the Shoplifting Laws in New Jersey? explains how New Jersey defines shoplifting and classifies charges by the retail value of merchandise, with penalties that can range from six months in jail for items under $200 to up to ten years in prison for theft exceeding $75,000, updated Jan 2026 with local context for Hackensack and Bergen County.

This episode unpacks what counts as shoplifting under NJS 2C:20-11, including taking merchandise without paying, concealing items while still inside the store, transferring items into cheaper containers, altering or removing price tags, and removing or attempting to remove anti-theft devices. It also highlights how intent is central to these cases and why genuine mistakes, accidental nonpayment, or confusion at checkout can become key issues when the facts support that explanation.

Listeners will learn how New Jersey separates disorderly persons offenses handled in municipal court from indictable crimes prosecuted in Superior Court, with thresholds that can escalate a case to a fourth-degree crime ($200 to $500), third-degree crime ($500 to $75,000), or second-degree crime (over $75,000). The discussion also covers how prosecutors may aggregate multiple incidents as part of a continuing course of conduct, and how surveillance footage, loss prevention documentation, and witness statements are commonly used to build the state’s case.

The episode closes with practical consequences and options beyond the initial charge, including the statute of limitations, potential civil liability to retailers, and restitution orders. It also covers diversion programs for first-time offenders such as conditional dismissal and pretrial intervention (PTI), plus how expungement can seal a shoplifting record after specific waiting periods, and what steps are involved in filing a petition and obtaining judicial approval.

Lustberg Law Offices, LLC

1 University Plaza Dr #212, Hackensack, NJ 07601, United States

(201) 880-5311

https://www.google.com/maps?cid=17248268094099978177