Who Gets The Engagement Ring In Illinois? - Russell D. Knight

From Law Office of Russell D. Knight - Who Gets the Engagement Ring in Illinois? breaks down what really happens to engagement rings when love doesn't lead to marriage—or when it ends in divorce. This episode offers a clear look at Illinois law and how courts determine ownership of these symbolic and often valuable gifts when relationships end.

We explore the concept of replevin—defined in Black’s Law Dictionary as a legal action to repossess personal property wrongfully taken or detained—and how it applies to conditional gifts like engagement rings. Drawing on cases like Vann v. Vehrs and Harris v. Davis, the episode explains that the key issue in Illinois isn’t why the relationship ended, but who ended it. That act alone often determines who keeps the ring.

Listeners will also learn what happens when the ring has been sold or converted, triggering a different legal path that focuses on monetary compensation based on the ring’s market value, as clarified in Jensen v. Chicago & Western Indiana RR Co.. The nuances of inherited versus purchased rings also come into play, along with the role jewelers may play in documenting value.

For couples who did marry, the conversation shifts to divorce proceedings and how engagement rings and wedding bands are treated under Illinois’ marital vs. non-marital property laws, including insights from In re Marriage of Wojcicki and In re Marriage of Schmidt. Whether you're newly engaged, considering divorce, or just curious about legal intricacies, this episode offers essential knowledge from Law Office of Russell D. Knight to help you understand your rights and options.

Law Office of Russell D. Knight

1165 N Clark St #700, Chicago, IL 60610, United States

(773) 334-6311

https://www.google.com/maps?cid=13056420905624162796