Finding Hope After Surviving Sibling Loss with Dr. Heidi Horsley

The Broken Pack: Stories of Sibling Loss

The Broken Pack: Stories of Sibling Loss
Finding Hope After Surviving Sibling Loss with Dr. Heidi Horsley
May 28, 2026 Episode 47
Dr. Angela Dean / The Broken Pack, LLC

In this episode of The Broken Pack: Stories of Sibling Loss, Dr. Angela Dean talks with surviving sibling Dr. Heidi Horsley. Heidi is Scott's big sister. Scott died about 40 years ago in a car accident at 17, alongside their 17-year-old cousin Matthew. Heidi is a licensed psychologist, an adjunct professor at Columbia University, and the co-founder, with her mother, of the Open to Hope Foundation.

Together they talk about the difference between sibling loss and parent loss, finding hope after a sudden death, and the way sibling loss reshapes identity, family roles, and decisions about the future. 

In this episode you will:

  • Hear Dr. Heidi Horsley's story of losing her younger brother Scott and her cousin Matthew, and the night the call came.
  • Listen to hear how the devastating loss changed her fundamentally and how how others reacted.
  • Learn why sibling loss is treated differently than parent loss and child loss, how family identity gets rewritten, and how purpose can emerge slowly after sudden death.
  • Be inspired by the community Dr. Horsley has built for other bereaved siblings, and the work she has carried out in Scott's memory for four decades.
  • Find hope in the kind of relationship Dr. Dean and Dr. Horsley describe in the episode, between siblings further along in grief and those still in early loss.


Connect with Dr. Heidi Horsley: Open to Hope

Content warning: This episode discusses sudden death and a fatal car accident.


Mentioned in the show:

Send us Fan Mail

Support the show

If you would like more information or to share your own sibling loss story, please contact Dr. Angela Dean at contact@thebrokenpack.com or go to our website, thebrokenpack.com.

Please like, subscribe, and share!

Please follow us:
Facebook:  @BrokenPack
Instagram:  @thebrokenpack
TikTok: @the_broken_pack
YouTube: @thebrokenpack

Sign-up for Wild Grief, our newsletter: https://thebrokenpack.substack.com/ 

Thank you!
Angela M. Dean, PsyD, FT, GTMR 

🐺Tony's Little Sister

Credits:

The Broken Pack: Stories of Sibling Loss is produced by Not Done Here Media.

IF TOMORROW STARTS WITHOUT ME
    Written by Joe Mylward and Brian Dean
    Performed by Fuji Sounds featuring Joe Mylward
    Courtesy of Not Done Here Records
    Licensed for use by The Broken Pack

Full song: https://fujisounds.music

Episode Artwork Finding Hope After Surviving Sibling Loss with Dr. Heidi Horsley 51:13 Episode Artwork Surviving Sibling Loss: Tough Love, Sudden Goodbye 56:39 Episode Artwork Half of Myself: A Surviving Sibling's Story of Losing Andy 55:43 Episode Artwork A Surviving Sibling's Story of Caregiving, Loss, and Finding Joy Again 58:41 Episode Artwork Brilliant Disguise: A Surviving Sibling's Memoir 47:10 Episode Artwork Shining a Light on Sibling Loss, Addiction, and Life's Little Pleasures 51:26 Episode Artwork A Christmas Loss. A Surviving Sibling Who Changes Lives. 57:15 Episode Artwork The Broken Pack Returns: Surviving Sibling Loss, Grief, & What's Next 14:27 Episode Artwork Sibling Grief, Potholes, & Scooter Safety: A Surviving Sibling's Advocacy 53:09 Episode Artwork Sibling Loss After a Tragic Accident: A Surviving Sibling Honors Her Sister's Compassion 1:12:41 Episode Artwork A Brother's Adderall Addiction & A Surviving Sibling's Loss & Love 45:16 Episode Artwork Sibling Loss & Love Beyond Death, An Enduring Bond 1:10:35 Episode Artwork Photography in the Shadows of Surviving Sibling Loss, Decades Later 48:43 Episode Artwork Life Interrupted: A Journey of Sibling Loss, Legacy, and Oral Cancer Awareness 52:23 Episode Artwork Navigating Loss Following Medical Aid In Dying as a Surviving Sibling 50:29 Episode Artwork A Sister, a Nephew, and the Grief That Had to Wait 43:26 Episode Artwork Surviving Sibling Loss & Stigma Following Addiction Related Death 37:03 Episode Artwork An Oncology Nurse's Sibling Loss Story 55:17 Episode Artwork Your Heart's Voice: Sibling Love, Intuition, & Loss 52:20 Episode Artwork The Echo of Sibling Grief: Decades Later 53:20 Episode Artwork Sibling Loss, Organ Donation & a Sister's Grief 54:44 Episode Artwork Sibling Suicide Loss: Surviving, Writing, & Loving in a Pandemic 57:34 Episode Artwork What Got Left Unsaid: A Surviving Sibling's First Year After Suicide 33:52 Episode Artwork Untimely, Unexpected, and Heartbreaking Complicated Circumstances in Sibling Loss 52:18 Episode Artwork Four and a Half Years: Dr. Chris Ban on Surviving Sibling Loss After Brain Cancer 41:58