The Odyssey's Best Moments: Yes It Might Surprise You (There Are Many)

The movie many are hating on for the wrong reasons!  This is not the movie they think it is.

Cloud of Witnesses, Jeremy Jeremiah, James St Simon, Michael, and Mario Andrew, break down the most unforgettable moments from Christopher Nolan’s The Odyssey and why the homecoming story hits harder when the music, visuals, and symbols keep pointing back to love and loss. We wrestle with the film’s biggest moral turn: the fear of an outside enemy flips into the recognition that we might be the problem.

• the siren song motif returning at the reunion with Penelope
• Odysseus holding on to the pin as a symbol of home
• the dog recognizing Odysseus and what that reveals
• the claustrophobia and horror of the Trojan horse
• Nolan’s visual storytelling through light, color, and disorientation
• “the people from the sea” as a mirror for self-deception
• Nolan’s modern guilt theme contrasted with Homer’s cosmic order
• mythic heroes with clear morality versus modern conflicted heroes


Questions about Orthodoxy? Please check out our friends at Ghost of Byzantium Discord server: https://discord.gg/jRXxRaqK9

Please prayerfully consider supporting Cloud of Witnesses: https://www.patreon.com/c/CloudofWitnesses

Find Cloud of Witnesses on Instagram, X.com, Facebook, and TikTok.

Audio: https://cloudofwitnessesradio.buzzsprout.com

Please leave a comment with your thoughts!

Transcript

Cold Open On War And Identity

SPEAKER_00 0:00

The men coming from the shore the sea, right? The changing society forever. I thought that was so well done and such a great moment from Nolan that to my mind that almost puts the film above a seven off right off the bat.

SPEAKER_03 0:17

The reality of what it would have been like to be inside the Trojan horse was also very claustrophobic. Yeah. Very frightening. It was, you know, yeah, it was fucking, you know, like spoiler alert.

SPEAKER_02 0:31

You know, we thought you were the people at the sea. No, we're Greeks. You know? It's like, oh wait, but they are you.

SPEAKER_01 0:38

Having this perception of an external enemy or an external problem. And coming to the realization that it's you.

Welcome And Channel Mission

unknown 0:44

Yeah.

SPEAKER_00 0:44

Hi, welcome to Cloud of Witnesses. Jeremy Jeremiah here. We're really excited about this episode. This episode is created with you in mind. Please, if you're enjoying this content, give this video a like, hit that subscribe button, and most importantly, if you can, ring that bell. It does help others find this content as well. Cloud of Witnesses is all about making Christian content that is hopefully edifying to you and it's building up the kingdom of God. Please stick around to the end if you can. Thank you so much for being here. Enjoy.

Sirens Theme And Marriage Longing

SPEAKER_00 1:15

You mentioned the relationship between Odysseus and Penelope. I thought that one of the most beautiful and poignant moments of this film is the juxtaposition of the siren song. That moment, which I thought was very well done. Odysseus doesn't plug his ears. He hears the sirens, and it was so well put in the film. I forget the exact wording, but it was, you know, he heard everything a man would ever want to hear, and also all the things a man can never hear or doesn't want to hear. Something like that. Mario pointed it out so well. Towards the end of the film, when Odysseus is about to be reunited to his wife, who has waited 20 years faithfully for him, the same theme, the musical score that was during the moments of the sirens comes back up. And you get this very powerful um reminder of all those things a man wants to hear. Here's his beautiful wife who's waiting for him for 20 years, and also all the things he can't or doesn't want to hear, which is the men that he's lost, the death, the suffering, um the betrayals, you know, all these things, right? The men coming from the shore, the sea, right? The changing society forever. I thought that was so well done and such a great moment from Nolan that to my mind, that almost puts the film above a seven off right off the bat.

The Pin The Dog The Homecoming

SPEAKER_00 3:00

What were your guys' thoughts in terms of some of the hallmarks of the film? Where are some of the moments of the film that you're still holding on to right now that you're like, man, this was a moment in the film for me?

SPEAKER_03 3:11

I agree with you on on that, it was one of the most emotional uh moments where I felt moved uh in that conversation. Um where he was explaining like, and even kind of how Calypso mentions that he held on to that, that's right, you know, that pin from his wife the whole time, and he wouldn't let that go. And even when he was shipwrecked, that's one thing he wouldn't let go. It it held him to the end, right? The coming home element. And then when he finally comes home and he has that conversation with her, it was very emotional. It was, it was that was that scene was done very well. Um the part that really got me was the dog. When he comes home and only the dog recognizes him and you know is wagging his tail, and then his son kind of that was the moment that it clicked for him. Um, I thought that was done very well. Yeah, as

Inside The Trojan Horse Terror

SPEAKER_03 4:06

well. Um the reality of what it would have been like to be inside the Trojan horse was also very claustrophobic, yeah, very frightening. Very visceral. It was, you know, yeah, it was evocative, you know, like uh like how awful it would have been uh to be in there, and even you know how heavy it is and probably sunk in the sand and people were drowning in there, like it's it must have been dreadful. Um, so that touch of when they all finally come down from the horse and they're kind of their their feet are wobbly, they haven't, you know, that's a very good touch.

Nolan’s Visual Storytelling In Battle

SPEAKER_03 4:42

Absolutely. The invasion of of Troy was done stunningly, and his contrast of they have the dark armor, the Trojans have the light armor, and what that's visually communicating. I think those are Nolan's strong points. That visual storytelling, the way he can use lighting, he can use color contrasts, he can use um the what you see as a story, or that's definitely some of his strengths.

SPEAKER_00 5:11

And I think it does the slow motion, the music, yeah.

SPEAKER_03 5:14

Yeah, it elevates the quality of the story 100%. Yeah, even the lightning uh on the ship when it was like the shipwreck was happening, and you can like it was all uh very uh like it it brings you into that moment and has you feeling what those people are feeling because you're so disoriented, and yeah, he does a very good job with that.

SPEAKER_00 5:35

He really

The People From The Sea Twist

SPEAKER_00 5:36

did.

SPEAKER_01 5:36

Yeah, I think one of my favorite parts, again, spoiler alert, um you know, throughout the whole film, they're so concerned about the people from the sea. They're coming around, they're gonna destroy civilization, everything we know is gonna collapse because of these people out there. And then when Odysseus, who's still disguised, is talking to his wife and explaining what they did in Troy, um, just violating, you know, trust and and this deception that they pulled on them. And he, you know, he's realizing that um because of that decision he made has led to all of these other consequences. And she realized, she says, Oh, you're the people from the sea. You know, I I really like that idea that we've talked about several times on the podcast before of having this perception of an external enemy or an external problem and coming to the realization that it's you.

SPEAKER_00 6:33

Yeah.

SPEAKER_01 6:34

Um, I think that's a really important message. I thought that that scene was was really good. Yeah, yeah.

Nolan’s Guilt Lens Versus Homer

SPEAKER_03 6:41

Mario? Oh, so sorry. Yeah, I want to I wanted to piggyback off of that because I feel like that was a that was very much a Christopher Nolan insert. That when you read the book, you'll find it doesn't align with Greek thought. Yeah. They don't have any guilt about war. Yeah. Because to them that war was justified, you know, in a way. Because Odysseus has to stand by his choice as a king because he made it so that he so that he can come home. If if he would have uh if he wouldn't have aligned himself with Agamemnon, then they would have came to Ithaca next after Troy. Sure. You know, and so him his decision to go was so that he could have a home to come back to. And that was a compromise. And that was a compromise. And I think everyone would even appreciate that compromise after he does return home. And he returns home triumphantly, no doubt broken, but triumphantly and and reordered with the gods. When you take that element away, you have to have some kind of well, what was his growth? His growth was Oppenheimer's growth. It was Dunkirk's growth. It's every film that Christopher Nolan has done, like for the last few years, that Jeff pointed this out. I'm like, that's so true. It's the, you know, um learning that we are the enemy. Yeah, that we found the enemy, and the enemy is me, right? Um, which is um it's it's not it's not the the Odyssey story. Um and I feel like it very much aligns with modern sentiments, but it it changed the spark of the story. Sure. So that it has that like you know, like Count of Monte Cristo is one of those great stories of like coming home and having revenge on the people who who like who ruined your life. Odysseus's is is better because of the gods' involvement in all of that. The gods justified his retribution so that it wasn't revenge, it was retribution, it was justice, and it was divine justice, and he was a harbinger of that. But that was determined because of the god's involvement in the cosmic order of things. He had to realign himself to that cosmic order, remove the cosmic order, remove a real moral sense of justice, and I feel like you get where you are now, and it's like, well, how is any word justified? Is any nation supposed to stand for anything, you know? Um and I feel like Nolan is inserting that, where Homer I don't think did.

SPEAKER_01 9:13

I kind of like that aspect of his movies, though. Like, and you see it whether it's the Odyssey or Batman, where the hero is he's kind of conflicted, like there's real tension and grip like within the hero.

SPEAKER_00 9:29

The reluctant hero.

SPEAKER_01 9:30

Yeah, in a way, yeah. Because to me, that's just more reflective of reality. Like, we don't have people, even if we see them as a hero historically, it wasn't that they were just all good, it wasn't that they were like you know, perfect, but they have like this this internal conflict and these tensions of like, well, I had to do this in Troy for you know to save Ithaca, but also understanding like the things we did in Troy were horrible, you know, like war is terrible, it had to be done, but it's also this terrible thing that happened, and so he's like has this internal tension that he's he's dealing with. I that's the part that I like about his movies, is like there's just like a grit to it that is missing in a lot of other movies where it's just like the hero is just ideal, he's perfect, he's like everybody wants to be just like him. And I think I like Nolan's movies where it just kind of brings it, it brings it into reality a little bit more.

SPEAKER_00 10:28

That's

Mythic Heroes Versus Modern Heroes

SPEAKER_00 10:29

interesting. Peter Jackson did did the same thing with Aragorn. The Aragorn of the book is much more an Odysseus type character. He is this um emblematic, you know, noble. C. S. Lewis talks about this. It's why we love fairy tale, right? It's why we love myth, because he says, this is C. S. Lewis, he says, in myth, the characters wear their morality on the outside. In other words, when you see Aragorn, you see nobility, right? You see truth and honesty and bravery, right, as a an ideal, almost like Plato's ideals, right? Whereas in a Nolan-esque, in a more modern story, in a Peter Jackson Lord of the Rings, the character is struggling with what we struggle with in the real world, right? It's a good point. I think both are valid and useful. Um, but it is important to notice they are very different things. I do want to hear Mario's favorite part of the film.

SPEAKER_02 11:32

Oh, uh, well, I would say I'm on this kind of the same as Mike. Like I love that they were the people at the sea. And actually, watching it the second time, they hinted it all throughout the movie. Like, even in the first village, they come in pillage, spoiler alerts. You know, we thought you were the people at the sea. No, we're Greeks, you know. And it's like, oh wait, but they are, you know, and it's constantly being hinted at until the very end when you kind of get told that by Odysseus, that's Penelope. Yeah, that's that was probably my favorite part. Yeah. Um, because I think we all do have that internal struggle where we think like, oh, they're the problem, they're the problem, they're the problem, really. It's me.

SPEAKER_00 12:10

And that comes back to the divine, right? The the grand story. And we talked about this when I countered you, James. I said, is it isegesis? When we realized that it we are all part of the grand story, right? We are part of the divine story here and now, and and and Homer's Odyssey is part of that.

Patreon And Closing Thanks

SPEAKER_00 12:31

Look at that, you made it to the end. Remember, all of our Patreons enjoy early access to episodes as well as uncut, unedited versions, including this episode here. You can go see the full thing over on our Patreon right now. It is the best way to support Cloud of Witnesses. It helps us keep the lights on, keeps the cameras rolling, and we thank you so much for being here right now. Please share with friends and family. We hope to see you on the next one. God bless you, and bye bye.