Everybody Speaks Music

Why Do We Quit Music Lessons? Part 1

May 10, 2023 Episode 104
Everybody Speaks Music
Why Do We Quit Music Lessons? Part 1
Show Notes

In today's episode, we cover the first three chapters of our 13-chapter series, aiming to understand the reasons behind students quitting music lessons.
We also recommend a resource that inspired today's episode, offering a deeper dive into the subject.
https://www.researchgate.net/publication/272886402_Students_who_quit_music_lessons_recent_research_and_recommendations_for_teachers
Our goal is to inspire individuals to continue growing as musicians in a way that best suits their needs, tastes, and artistic desires.

Todays episode covers sections 1-3

 1: Why Do Students Quit Music Lessons
 2: The evidence
 3:Benefits Of Music Lessons

Future episodes in this series will cover:
4: Teachers Point Of View 
5: Students Point Of View 
6: Motives and Motivation
7:Teacher Characteristics 
8:Family Socioeconomic Status
9: Parental Support & Home Environment 
10: Self-Efficacy, and Self-perception
11: Practicing and Achievement
12: Research Based Recommendations for Teachers 
13: Additional Ways To Support A Positive Outcome For Music Students 

1: Why Do Students Quit Music Lessons

  • Music teachers recognize that most students will eventually stop taking music lessons.
  • Reasons for stopping can include achieving primary goals or quitting prematurely.
  • Premature dropouts can have financial implications for the teaching profession and prevent students from experiencing the full benefits of music learning.
    • Researchers have identified several factors that contribute to student dropouts, including:
    • Initial and continuing motivation
    • Practicing habits and strategies
    • Teacher and family characteristics
    • Parenting styles
    • Students' self-concept and expectations for success.
  • The article aims to review research studies on why students quit music lessons prematurely and how teachers can identify at-risk students and prevent attrition in their studios.

2: The evidence 

  • Two large-scale studies conducted more than 20 years ago documented a clear trend in student dropouts as they grow older.
  • One study conducted by Daniel Stino gathered information from hundreds of independent music teachers and reported a sharp drop in students taking private lessons as they grow older.
  • Another study conducted by Music Teachers National Association in 1990 documented a large decline in studio enrollment between elementary and secondary school.
  • While there are no recent large-scale studies on lesson dropout rates, anecdotal evidence suggests that this trend still exists today.
  • It is important for music teachers to be aware of this trend and consider strategies to retain students as they grow older.

3: Benefits Of Music Lessons

  • Prematurely dropping music lessons prevents students from reaping the benefits of music study, which have been researched and found to be numerous.
  • Personal benefits of studying music include skill acquisition and development, personal growth, fulfilling a dream, and personal pleasure.
  • Children and parents perceive benefits such as development of discipline, concentration, and self-esteem from music study.
  • Studies have shown academic achievement, civic engagement, and personal benefits of music study for children and young people.
  • Arts and music education in childhood predicts the rate of participation and attendance of cultural events in adulthood, making it a vital element in the sustainability of a healthy and diverse cultural ecosystem in the nation.