71 - Ashes, Effort, and the Fear of Trying Too Hard

Theology In Pieces

Theology In Pieces
71 - Ashes, Effort, and the Fear of Trying Too Hard
Feb 05, 2026 Season 4 Episode 71
Slim and Malcolm

Send us a Question!

**As you may be able to tell...Malcolm's mic wasn't on for today's episode. You'll still hear him through Slim's mic, but its noticeably worse.  

All Apologies** Now, for the Episode...

When the Empire Demands Your Gaze, Fix Your Eyes on Christ.  We start with the killing of Minnesota nurse Alex Pretti by ICE agents and the rush to label, excuse, and move on. From media spin to the refusal to apologize even after video surfaces, we trace how propaganda thrives on the rightness of your side and how that rightness corrodes the social order and our humanity. Then we pivot to a harder task: learning to resist the outrage economy without going numb. Attention is formation. If we stare at empire all day, it will shape us.

That tension carries into our deep dive on discipleship and effort. Michael Horton argues: Disciplines don't Save. Christ Does. First we ask... who is making this argument?  He assigns the blame at the feet of John Mark Comer, but we wonder if this is just his own allergic reaction to any striving on the Christian's' part.  

With Lent on the horizon, we make a practical case for a season that trains love: prayer that reshapes attention, fasting that clears space for a greater good, and almsgiving that breaks greed’s grip. Ash Wednesday’s “remember you are dust” is not punishment; it’s clarity. When mortality is set against resurrection, repentance becomes hopeful, not heavy. Along the way we share listener mail on art and hypocrisy, talk through pastoral judgment on addressing current events, and laugh about our own cringey “stop trying so hard” era.

Let us know what you think!  

Video or no-video?

JD VANCE - no apologies 

Garret Bearanger - eyes back on Christ

https://www.christianitytoday.com/2026/01/disciplines-dont-save-christ-does/

Larry Norman - Fallen Angel


If this conversation helps you, follow the show, share it with a friend, and leave a review. Your support helps more people find thoughtful, grounded faith in a loud, fearful world.


For more information, you can follow us at
https://www.theologyinpieces.com/
Theology in Pieces on Instagram - @theologyinpieces

Email us by emailing hello@theologyinpieces.com

Malcolm Foley - on twitter @MalcolmBFoley
Slim Thompson on twitter @wacoslim

For more information on the church,
check us out at www.mosaicwaco.org or on instagram.

Episode Artwork 71 - Ashes, Effort, and the Fear of Trying Too Hard 1:09:52 Episode Artwork 70 - Two Corrupted Christianities in the Gospel Coalition 54:54 Episode Artwork 69 - BEST IN SHOW '25 1:28:05 Episode Artwork 68 - If God Pardons Like a President… Should That Worry Us? 1:07:20 Episode Artwork 67 - Why Can't We Be Friends? - With Rev. Dr. Erin Moniz 1:20:39 Episode Artwork 66 - DON’T FOCUS ON THE FAMILY : Emily McGowin on Building Households of Faith 1:07:28 Episode Artwork 65 - No Kings, No Thrones, No Plan & HOW to Rediscover the Beauty of the Word. 1:16:51 Episode Artwork 64 - Talking Politics & Christian Nationalism with Caleb Campbell 1:37:17 Episode Artwork 63 - Dissertations and Denominations w/ Rev. Dr. Mika Edmondson 1:21:07 Episode Artwork 62 - Becoming Gods: The Mystery of Theosis... Powered by Jesus. 55:46 Episode Artwork 61 - I STAND WITH ISRAEL? When Empires Claim His Name... 1:03:17 Episode Artwork 60 - Hanging by a Thread (Not Your Hair): End Times Q&A 1:06:04 Episode Artwork 59 - "t" 1:17:58 Episode Artwork 58 - Despair, Hope, & This Present Crisis 1:03:50 Episode Artwork 57 - Team Lamb vs. Team Dragon & The Politics of the Apocalypse. 1:11:26 Episode Artwork 56 - The Anti-Greed Gospel: A Revolutionary Conversation with Malcolm Foley on the Battle with Mammon. 1:25:00 Episode Artwork 55 - Don't Be Afraid of the Dark with Cody Balfour 1:06:45 Episode Artwork 54 - Christian Centrism, Power, and Justice with Adam Joyce 1:27:17 Episode Artwork 53 - Storytelling, Faith, and Curiosity with Stephen James 1:09:13 Episode Artwork 52 - Who Are Evangelicals, Again? With Dr. Ansley Quiros and Dr. Jacob Randolph 1:29:39 Episode Artwork 51 - How to Prepare for Civil War and Biblical Violence 1:18:32 Episode Artwork 50 - The Immigration Debate with Matthew Soerens 1:12:17 Episode Artwork 49 - Justice for All: The Intersection of Faith and Law with Kent Mckeever 54:47 Episode Artwork 48 - Politics and Third-Way-ism 56:51 Episode Artwork 47 - Whose Fault Is It Anyway? The Poor, Trump, and a Way Forward. 1:23:40