Chulin 62

Daf Yomi 

Transcript

SPEAKER_00 0:02

We're starting third to last word on the bottom of Samh Allah Baze where we left off yesterday. Omar Rivnachman. Rivnachman says the following. So we came up yesterday, we're in the middle of Parake of Trefus, where we're discussing the Simani Tahara as it relates specifically in our Sagir right now by Oifais. The Mishnah started discussing Simani Tahara by Behemoth and Chayas, Mafra Sisparshas, Shah Shesa, Malazgeira. The difference Simani Tahara by Behemoth, where we know you need both, right? And Simani Tahara are the same by a chaya. Lamafkamina, we were going through them. Afkamina is to know the difference between a behemoth and a chaiya is the chalev. That was a previous daffit, right? We got into the Simani Tahara of a Oif, which the Mishnah told me Loinamruvatara. They weren't said in the Tahar. The Haqam explained. And we explained yesterday, obviously it's Darais. It's just that the Khachamim were the ones that were mefarashid. It doesn't say it explicitly in the ta'arah. Now these Simani Tahara of the Oifis, we learnt there are four Simani Tahara. Can I get that? There's four Simani Tumma. It's the same Simon. It's just does it have it, does it not have it. If it doesn't have it, it's Simon Tumma. If it does have it, it's a simon, or the opposite, depending on what it is. But there are four Simani Tahara, or we could call it four Simani Tumma if it has these qualities of Tumma. And that is learnt out as we saw yesterday from the Nesher. The Nesher is some translate, most translate as the eagle. And the eagle has the quintessential four Simone Tumma. That all four of these things are going to be Simone Tumma. Now, do you have to have all of the Simone Tumma to be Tame, like an eagle? Or do you have to have all of the Simone Tahara to be Tara, like Tarim? Or no? Or is somewhere in between would also be Tara, somewhere in between it would also be Tame. So we saw yesterday the way we passkin is basically you can't be like a Nesher. Nesher is the prime example. If you're like a Nesher, you have zero out of four Simone Tahara, it's gonna be a problem. You're gonna be Tame. If you have even one out of four Simone Tahara, then it's gonna be a kosher bird. Granted and taken that it's not from the 24 that the Tara listed explicitly. We learned yesterday the tar listed 24 non-kosher birds specifically. 20 out of the 24 have have three out of four Simone Toma. Or Simone Tahara, really, they're just missing one. Two out of the four have two out of the four. Or sorry, one out of four, the Iriv has two out of the four. The remaining two, the Paris and the Osnial, have one out of the four, and the Nesher is the only one that has zero out of the four, and that's how we get to the 24. So again, if you have one Simon Tahara, that's gonna be good enough, you're gonna be a kosher bird, unless you're one of the 24. The Tara explicitly stated explicitly that although they have some Simone Tahara, there's still gonna be a problem. So with that, we're gonna start off today that Omar ibn Nachmarnachman said, Hayya Baki Bahen Mishmasin. If someone was in the wild somewhere, I don't know, and he found the bird. And this bird had one sim in Tahara. So as we just said, one sim and tahara is gonna be good enough. One sim and tara is gonna mean it's a kosher bird. Unless it's what? Unless it's one of the 24. Now, if it has one of the Simone Tahara, is it any of the 24? No, obviously not. It's not 20 of them, because 20 of them have three out of the four. If it only has one of the Simone Tahara, then it's obviously either a kosher bird or it's the Paris or the Aznia. Because the Paris and the Aznia are two of the non-kosher birds that have one out of four Simone Tahara. So someone finds, someone finds a bird that has one Simon Tahara, is it a kosher bird or not? So Ramnachman is basically about to say, we'll read it inside in a second. As long as you know what a Paris and Osnia is, and as long as you know this is not the Paris Osnia, then it's good to go. Very good. So I bucket the Anush Maisin. If you know what a Paris of Osnio or Asnia is, and you know their names, and you would know that this is not a Paris and not an Osnio, then Iif above a simana tar, then as long as then if you find the If that has one simon tahara, it's gonna be tar. As long as you know it's not the Paris and the Osnio. How do you know if you're a Bucky and you're a Bucky Bahnwish Massan, you know, you know that this is not the Paris of Aznia, which is the only Ifais Timaeus that have one out of four. So this animal has what this If is one out of four and it's not the Paris Osnia, you're good to go. It's gonna be tar. Loya e Bakibahenwishmasan. If you're not sure what the Paris and the Osnia are, then visimon tami. Then but if it only has one seminar, it's gonna be tomai. Why? Because it might be the Paras and Osnia. Paras and Osnia were refers in the tar that they're Ifeis Tamaeus, right? But Vishne Simonim Tar, however. But if it has two Simone tahara, then it's gonna be tar. Why? Because two Simone tahara already is uh not a Parason Osnia. Parasnia already only have one. Either other birds, you're right, there's only one other bird though. There's only one oif tame that has two out of four simonim. Again, 20 of them have three out of four, two of them have one out of four, and one of them, the Nesher has zero out of four, right? But only one of them has two out of four. Which one is that? The Iriv. Hushiakar Iriv. That's why you have to know what an Iriv is. A raven, that's pretty common, and people know what an iriv is. So as long as you know that this is not the iriv and you find the bird that has two out of four, you are good to go. Because as long as it's not a raven, it has two out of four kosher simonim, and it's a kosher bird. Says the Gemara, really. Ariv is sulli. The only thing you have to know is that it's not a raven. That's the only bird that's tomai that has two out of four simonim. Vila Tani, but I have a bright saw. What's the iriv in the pasik? When the posik says uriv, it does call uriv leminoi, whatever the exact question is. So it says Uriv Leminoi. Leminoi to its breed, you could translate, right? So Uriv Lemino. So what's Uriv in the Pasik telling you? It's coming to tell you the Ariv is Tame. Leminoi, what's the word in the Pasik telling me? Leminoi Ribazi, I'm says the Haviesa Tzarzir. It's including another bird that not only the Ariv is gonna be Tameh by having two Simonim, but also the Tzarzir that's similar to an Ariv. It's Leminoi that what that it also has two out of four Simon tahara. We just found another one, that also is gonna be Tameh. So Armala Rabalazo, the answer abalazer valley, anshe kvartamartha should be udayu eikhana sanishla in zefekh. But the people in Kvarta Marta that's in uh that's in Judea, they used to eat this czarzir. Why? Because it has a zefek. They take it as uh Torah bird, and they used to eat it. So Amalami told them, very nice, they eat it, but they're wrong. There's gonna be din the hajjmin for them as well because they're doing the wrong thing. Another pshat is Limina Liminayu Lehavi Snoonis Levana. It's coming to include this bird called the Snoonis Levana. That not only the iriv that has two out of the four kosher samanim is gonna be tomai, but also the snoonis levana is a non-kosher bird and it has two out of the four. They told him that well, what about the people of Galilee? They used to eat this bird. Why? Because it has one of the kosher saman, that Kirkabanai Niklaf, that its kurkabon can be peeled. Some of them he told them, af Hena seasonless in a sadin. Just because they did it, doesn't mean they're right. And they're also gonna have a diminution one day because they're doing this. Ella. So what's the question? The question is that we said what? If you find a bird with two Simon, two out of the four Simon at our as long as you know it's not an Uriv, you're good to go, you can eat it. Really? Ariv is so live, Ariv and nothing else. What about the Tsarzir? What about the Snoonis Levana? These are other birds that are similar, included. It depends which gear so you have, but they're they're they're we we remembered it from the postlook of Lemineyu that not only has two out of the four, but also these. So what do you mean you find the bird that has two out of the four as long as it's not an Ayriv? What about Snoonis Lavana? What about the Tsarzir? You have to know and be a bucky about those as well. So it says the Gemara, Ella Urival min Uyriv. You're right. What do we mean when we say you have to know and be a bucky about an Ayriv? We mean as long as you know it's not an Ayriv, Bikal min Ayriv, and anything that's like an Ayriv, like the Zarzir, like the Snoonis Lavana, these things also have two out of the four. As long as you know it's not those tomate birds, it's nothing else, and therefore all by process of elimination it's gonna be ta', and it's gonna be a kosher bird. Says the Gimar. Amarameimar. Hilchsa Uifaba Simon Achatar. What's the allaha? If you find the bird that has one simon, one sim in tahara, only one of the four, it's gonna be tahor. What's the point over here? The point is, and you don't have to be a bucky. You don't even have to be a bucky about the uh the uh the what's you don't even have to be a bucky about the paras and the aznia. Why? Because we're gonna see in a second, because the paras and the aznia were not shhiach. Rashi says it right here. But Filu ein bucky bay no mushroom is saying, Deloy Khashina Delma Paris Azniain. We don't have to be worried that maybe this what this bird that you found that's one out of the four is the paras of aznya. Why don't you have to be worried? You only find them in the midbar, it's not shiach and the ish. If it's not shkiach, if you come across a bird that has one out of the four, you don't have to be high shishish that it's the Paris of the Aznya, which are the only two tummy birds that have one out of the four. Process of elimination means what it is to lay darus. But that's only true if it's not Daris, if it's not uh, if it doesn't uh trample, and we're gonna see that in a second. But where but there's uh Rashi brings it on this page, there's Tysus, Tys over here, speaks out also that that Vihudlai Daris, the Mishnah was a little bit mashma, that Daris on its own can be an issue. Meaning, even though, meaning you're gonna tell me what, Vihudiloi Daris. If it's daris, then it has another, maybe either is Machlikus over here. Does it mean that that's uh Simon Tahara on top of the other one you found? So it's two out of the four. Or Tysus says that this is really the Simon Tahara that you found. That's what Tysis says it over here. Vuhudeloidaris. We nearly Tyson says a few lines down, Deloidaris climber, but oise simen echor. That that simmon you found is not that not that it's daris, because being Diris can be an issue onto its own, even if it's not one of the birds that the Tara lists specifically. The mission was a little bit mashma that way. Vahudaloidaris, that's also one of the you know very uh special Simonituma, that that could be an issue onto its own, even if it's not one of the ones mentioned. But either way, Vuudalaidis, as long as it's not Diris, you found the knife with one simantara, then you're gonna be good to go. What are you gonna do with Ramnachman? Because Rimnachman said what? Remnnachman said that you have to be a bucky. Why an wish my sayin? And you're telling me that as long as you found a bird with one cement tahara, you're good to go, even though even though you're not a buki, what do you mean? What if it's a paras? What if it's an asnia? Those have one simon and they're tame. So what about Rimnachman? So Amalay told him Laishmi. I didn't hear about Rivnachman. Kalaimar. This is a famous line, Lisvirali. What did I mean when I said Lishmieli? Yeah, I meant Lisvirili. I don't hold a Rivnachman. What's the reason I don't hold Rivnachman? We shouldn't Paris Aznia. What's the Kshash? Because you it might be a Paris, which is Tame. It might be an Asniya. Let's nubi Yushuv. They're not around the Yishav. If they're not around the Yishuv, they're only in the midbars. Is Rashi said that the Natshkiya? The Natshkiaf, you don't have to be worried about it. You found a knife with one cement, it's probably not the Paris, it's probably not Aznya. You're good to go, you're gonna be able to eat it. This bird. Kosh of the Taras Matsar. It's gonna be kosher for taharas matar, even. So not only to eat, but it's gonna, there are only certain birds, tahirin, right, Benayana, that you could use for the process of the taharas matzaira. This oifa misaret, it's gonna be so good even for the tahas matzara. You could use it. Vizuis and snoonas levanna. That's the snoonas levanna shinehlukubaram. That Ribazar Kahim had a machlikus about a minute ago. That's the snoonas levanna, it's oifa misaret, it's uh it's uh heine dvaram, it's the same bird, and therefore it's gonna be kosher le Taharas Hamatsaira Umr Amemar. Ameemar said, Bihivra Kresa Kliamala Pligidishariya. When its stomach is white, everyone agrees. There's no machlikus between Rabelez and the Hachamim, everyone's gonna read that it's gonna be motor. He pleasy where's the machikas bidiaruka kresa, where its stomach is green or yellow, that Rabaleza Asrhetan chari, Rabalazar says it's gonna be usur, abanan are gonna be gonna say it's gonna be motor. Marzutra Masniochir. Marzutra had a different version of this, and he said the following Bidi Aruka Kresa, where it's a green stomach, the Usr. Everyone's gonna agree in that case that it's Usr. Keep you where is the Mahleikas? B the chibra kresa. The machlekis is gufa where it has a white stomach. So it's gonna go okay. I understand according to the second sheet over here. This was Marzutra, that said that Bihibra Kresa Pligi, that the machlikis is where the machlikus are belezh and the khahamim is where it has a white stomach. Hainu tiktani, Bach takes out the next two words. Hainu tiktani, snoonis levana. That's why it says before snoonis levana, and it says the stomach was white, because that's goof of where the machlikis is by a snoonas levana, where its stomach is white. And alamandamar with the ruka pligh, but according to my number that said that the whole machlekis is where the stomach is green, then my zuhi snoonas levana. What's the lush we said before? Of this is the snoonas levana, the white one. If they're Dafka arguing where the stomach was green, then why do we call it the snoonas lavana? A white one. Says the Gemara La Fuke debate de uhmasi. It's just coming, it's coming to tell you something else. It's coming to be um, it's coming la a fuke, a black one. There's also actually another black one. You should know that one definitely is not the one we're talking about. It says Amar Rahva. Omar Ribuda. Rahva says in the name of Rebuda, Rahva was the name of uh Amarra. So you say in the name of Ribuda. Excuse me. Tasil, Pasumishum Tyrin, the Kasher Mishum Binayana. This bird called a tasil is posumishum tirin. And it's kasher mishumbin. What does this mean? So tarin are both kashir. So what do you mean pasl mishum tirin? Kash Mishumanayaina? So rash explains. We're talking about the Inyan karban. As it relates to a carbon, so we know you can't bring there are certain types of tarin that are gonna be good, and certain types of yinus that are gonna be good. Whenever the tar says tairim, it says tyran. It doesn't say bina toirim. So it says tarnim, which sounds like matured birds. Doves that are or tyran or pigeons, right? That are matured. So they're already uh they're not baby ones. Whenever it says yinas, which are doves, right? So whenever it says yinas, which is it says b'nayina, which is mashma baby doves. And therefore, and therefore what? Wherever it says wherever you have tyran, rashi says gidoilim kserim, kitanimpsulim, wherever you have tayrim, it's only the gidalim that are gonna be kosher for the carbon. But if you have katanim, it doesn't say bine tairim, and therefore katanim are gonna be posil for the carbon. Wherever you have yinim, you're gonna have it says specifically bineyonim, which teaches me the koshramishom bneyyina, bhiktana. That teaches me b''yonim have to be khtana. So what are we saying when we mean that this bird called a tussil is posumishum tarin vikashum binayana? We mean that it has the din of bneyoina, has the din of a double of a binayoina, that what? That it's that gidoilim are going to be, that the gidoilim of this bird is gonna be kosher to be brought as a tar, and the khtanim are gonna be brought, or rather sorry, kser mishum tarim, psulumishombinayana. Gidoilim sherim, miktanimpsulum, the kosh my shumbinayana miktana. Right. So where you have a tarnim, it's gonna be kosher if it's big, pasal if it's small, as tartrim F to be, by Bineyoyna, kosh mishum binayana and miktana if it's small, it's gonna be koshramish. Says the Gemara, and that and again, that's specifically as relates to Korbanis, because as it relates to kashras, these are both kashra across the board. Masar the Neo Barkatina, the Neo Barakatina asks on this, and he's specifically asking on the fact that we're calling the uh we're calling this uh tussil, that we're calling it, we called it a type of yoina because it has to be it's kashra mishumbanayana biktana. So the fact that this tussle can be a type of yino, that's what he's asking on. Kalha'ifus poislin mechatas. So he's asking a kasha from Hilchus Paraduma. So we know that the mechatas, but for that was used for the paraduma, there was alocha, it cannot have been used for any malacha. As soon as you use it for any malacha, even the paraduma itself, it can't be navat, it can't be used at all. And if it if you do avaida with it, as soon as you ash allah oil, right? As soon as you even put oil on it, it's gonna passle up the para. That has to do with the para and all related avaidasas relate to the paraaduma. So the mechatas cannot, is nifsa ba avaida. As soon as you do any avaida with this mechatas, it's possible, you're not allowed to use it for the available of the paraduma. So if you have a oif that comes into the mechatas and drinks a little bit from it, call eifas paysa mechatas chutmana chutmana yoina. They're gonna passle the mechatas by drinking out of it, except for the yina. Why? Why, first of all. First of all, why are all eifas that drink out of the mechatas gonna passle it? So Rashi explains, Im Shasamain, if they drink from it, ma'ach, ma'am pian va rehein kemisha nasas ma'an milach. Because the way the birds drink, they drink out a little bit, and then you have water that drips out of the bird's mouth back into the mechatas. That is considered, Rashi says, it gives it the din as if it was never as if there was some sort of milacha done with this water, since the water drips back into the mechatas, and that's why it's gonna be a problem. I colo eify, pais and mehatas, they're gonna be pause, they're gonna passen the mechatas if they drink from it. Except for the yina, why mibnishas? Because the yaina doesn't do this Indian, the yina is might like sucks up the water. The point is it doesn't drip back out. If it doesn't drip back into the water, then it's going to be not a problem. There's no avid done with it. It says the gamara vimisa. But if you're gonna tell me Zakrashi, the tasl minyainahu, if you're gonna tell me that the tasl is really a type of yina, as we just said on Ahmed Alif, then listen he chutsmyyana vitaslow, then why did we say only chutzmyyana? We should have said chutsmiyana vitasl, because tossel is also type of yina. Answers the gamara, amar of Zayra, of Zera answers that ze mightumeki. Viza migi. The fact that we said that a tossel is a type of yina, Ligabe the Indian, as it relates to uh the cashras for a karman, that has nothing to do with what it physically what physically happens when this word drinks. Happens to me there's a little bit of a difference, a little bit of a difference how uh Yoina drinks and a tossil drinks. Zhu, ze might sumaki. The tossil still has this issue where it's mitsumeki and it spits up a little bit and it goes back in, which would possibly make hates. It's mitesin and it doesn't uh drip back in, and that's why it's not gonna be a problem. The fact that it's considered a breed of a Yina for legabe hilchas carbon, yeah, that's true. But it's still a different breed, it's still slightly different, and therefore, even though it's a type of yina, this bird, the tussle, would still passle up the water if it did drink from it, and therefore, literally the only example we have of a bird that's gonna not passle up the mehatas, even though it drinks from it, is going to be the yina. And we did not say tussle, even though it's really considered a breed of it. I'm gonna repeat it, read us it. Hani Kufshani Tsutsaini. Ksherimagabizbeh. These birds, or uh Kufshani Tsaini Rash it says Kufshani is Tyrin Belish R Arami. So it's Tyron. These Tyrun Tsutzaini that came from Tsuthaino, whatever it was. So these tiren tsutzini, these uh kufshani because they're in ksherim the gabin mizbeh. They're able to be brought as a carbon. And these are the turen shahrachvah that we what that we reference. That says the Gamar, is that true? May smell ask your cash, Aziv. Pask says Aziv. Where does it say that? So this is as it relates to any aloha that you need an Aziv for. We have many in the tower where you need an Aziv, right? So anywhere you need an Aziv, Veloy Aziv Yavan. It means you need an actual Aziv, the plant that was called an Aziv, and not the Aziv, the Greek Aziv, the Aziv Yavan, Veloy Az of Kuhley, not the blue one, Vela Azab Rami, not the Roman Azeb, Veloy Madri, not the one that came from the desert, Veloy call azev shaleshemlevaya. Not any other type of azev that has a different nickname. Any other type of this azeb, that azeb, Roman Aziv, it's all gonna be a problem. What type of azev do you need? You need the bona fide azev and azev only. Okay, so what's the question? The question is then we see right here that when it says azev, we mean azeb and nothing else. So so too, when we say taim can be used as a carbon, we should mean tafka taurim and not anything else, not something that's called kufshani tsutini. So if you have taurium that are the tsutina ones, that should be a problem. The same way when it says azem in the tail, it means azeb and not the Roman Aze. So when we say Taurin in the tire for a carbon, we should mean taurim and not the tsutani taurim. So why are they gonna be okay? Kshain Lagabi Mesbeh, as we said. Answers the Gemara Amara. Bye, call Shane ishtanish may conne matant, Vikpita Tara love, Yesh Plashem Love. I'll tell you the claw. The claw is anything that had a different name before Matantara, Vikpita Tara love, and even though it had a different name, the Tara still said specifically an Aziv. So you had an Azaiv Rhini, let's say. I don't know if Rome was a thing before Matantyra. But you had uh you had you had these different types of azev. You had this a zoiv and you had that a zoif, uh, and the tara went out of its way to specifically say what? Which a zoif? Azoiv, the main azev. So any anything that existed, then when the tara came along and said which one, it told you specifically the a zoiv, and the tara was machpedvay kipid the tara love. Yeshla Shemai Pasel, then if it has a shamelai, if it has a nickname, it's gonna be Pasel. Why? Because the Tara told you an Azaiv and not the Aiza Midbari, not the one from the Midbar, only a regular Azar. Loinish Tanushman Kohen Matantara, but if the Hani, sorry, the Hani, Loin Nistanushman Kohana Matantara, but these ones, they didn't have a different name before Matantara. They only had a name after Matantara, meaning the the the what's it called? The the taurim that came from Tsutzaina or whatever the place was, that was something that came after Matantara. That was something that they named later on. So in a khanami, the Torah was never makbin on that, and that's why it's gonna be shared in the Gabi Misbeh. Rabba Maraba gives a little bit of a different answer. Hani Kushani Tsani ba strayu stomakaru. You want to know why the Kushani Tsutini are okay? Even though when a tar says azev, it means azev only. So why when the tariff says tyrim, it doesn't mean tyra only. Why turin from tsutaina are gonna be also okay? So it says Rabbah, I'll tell you why, because Tyrin in Tsutaina are Stam Tyran. If you go to Tsuttaina and you ask for a tar, they're gonna give you a tar from tsutaina. It's just called that because you're not in tuttaina or whatever the place is. But if you were there, that's stam, that's regular tairim. So the tyrant said, Tyrim, these are tyran, these are tirem. You're calling it a tyrant tsaiim because you're not from Tsuttaina, but if you were from Tutaina, Stam Tarim are still gonna be tarim, and that's why it's gonna be okay, says the Gamar. Um says, Hani karzi the behilfi. These khagovim, Rashi says, these grasshoppers, these grasshoppers that are uh that are among the the rushes, I don't even know what that means. They're gonna be okay. However, Udabay Karbi, if they're grown, if these grasshoppers you find them among the caribs, uh Rash says Kruv, if you find them by Bukter, then that's here, then they're gonna be awser. Um Ravina Ravina says, Um alkina the layoff, these we're talking about Hilchus grasshoppers now, right? So are they gonna be kosher to eat or not? Ravina says these ones that you find among the bukzer, not only are they asir mishum suffic, but umalkina na layo. You're gonna get malchus for eating it, mishum sharet's aif. It's so bad, meaning it's such a vada. It's not a suffic whether they're okay or not. It's considerable. If it's not kosher grasshopper, it means it's a sharet, and you're gonna get malkus for eating a sharet because we're sure it's a vada that they're actually a problem. Am Rabina Ravida says, Tzarda, sorry, a tzarda, this bird called a tzara is mutter. Bardah Osir. The bird called a barda might sound the same, but it's actually Osir. Vesimnich, how do you remember what's a tzarda? What's a barda? Vesimnich barmine, except for that one, meaning not that one. Not that one, meaning that one is Osir. Barmineh sounds like Barda. Barda is the one that's barmineh, that's gonna be a problem. Marda's fake. So tzarda's okay, barda's a problem. Marda Sveiko, that's actually gonna be a suffic. Amramasi Rasi says, Shmain and Svek is saying there are eight Sveikas as it relates to different types of Ifhos. There are eight of these birds that we're not sure if they're okay or not. What are these eight? Huva, Huga, Suga, Vaharnoiga, Tushlami, Umarda, Kuchilna, and Barnavcho. These are the eight birds that we have a suffic about. My Svika, what exactly is a suffic? Oifois, Tehoirim, Korkabon and Nikolaf. I'll tell you why. The suffic is that regular iftar, their Korkabon is Nikolaf. You could peel it off. Vitmayan aim korkabon and nikolav. And Ipois Timaeon, what's a simatoma, that their korkabon is not Nikolav. You can't peel it off. The honey, but these eight birds, Korkabon Niklaf is akina. You could peel it, but it's not easy. You could only peel it with a knife. And since you can't peel with a hand, so I don't know, it's somewhere in between. You can't peel it off naturally, but you could peel it off with a hand, so it's somewhere in between. So that's why these are spakes. Says Gamaro, okay. What about the following story though? The Ahibarazo, there was a goose. The Havabe Marshmallow, it was in the house of marshmallow, the lay koave miklifkubani that the Krukoban was not being peeled off. They weren't able to. So what they do, the oyster, they put it in the sun. They came with the rough eclipse, and as soon as it got softened by the sun, they were able to peel it off. So what do we see over here? We see that there was no suffig, even though it was a little hard to peel it off. There was still no suffig. They did some uh procedure or whatever it was, they put it in the sun. You needed some external thing to make it softer to help you peel it off, and still there was no suffoc, it was okay. So, so to over here, even if you need a knife, as long as it peels in the end of the day, it should be fine. Says Nikamara, I'll tell you why. Very easy answer. And the obvious answer Hussam. Hutzum Kidrafi Iklif Biyado. Over there, as soon as long as it got soft, it peeled with your hand. Even if you get it soft, lay miklef alabasakina, you're only gonna be able to get it off with a knife, and that's why it's actually worse over here, and that's why it's gonna be a suffix by these eight of that we said before. So, Amara Baya Baya says, Tarnigoila daagma, khad mishwana's fake. The tarnagoila that is in the swamps in the agam, that's one of the eight. Which one? The hainu mardu. That's the mardu that we said is one of the sphakas. Amrapava Rapapa says tarnegoyla daagma sira. This tarnagoila daagma, which we said is the margu, and specifically tarnagoila, which is the male version that's found in the agam, that's the ulcer one. Turnigo todayagma. However, the female version that is Sharia, that is gonna be mutter. Vasimna, how do you remember which one is okay, which one's not? Amaini vilaya minus. Amaini is a problem, layovi aminiam vimayavi vikala shen. And then we know the famous drasha, the vulamalach, right? Amaini vilaya minus. Only the males are the problem. The aminus are not the problem, the females are not the problem. So if you want to remember the as it relates to the tarnigoilum from the agam, which one is a problem, it's gonna be a money vilaya minus, it's the male one, but the tarnigol tah de agma, that's actually Sharia as we saw a minute ago. Darsh meremar, meremar darsh in the following a bit later on. That tarnigolta de agma asero. That although we just made this whole nice drusha, aminea minus, and we said that the tarnigolto, the female one, is okay. Mireymar saw actually that the tarnagolta d'agma, even the female one, is a problem. Why chaziwa did dars of akla? Because they saw that originally they thought that it wasn't darus, but then they saw this tarnagolta dagma, even the female one was darsa of the akla, it was uh being daris other other birds, and then eating it, which is a simitoma, and we referenced before that drisa can be a cementoma even on its own, right? It can be a problem even on its own sometimes. The hainu giruso, and that is the this tarnagolta d'agma. This is the girusa, it's another name for it. But Lemaisa, that's why Mireima comment came around and said, Although we had although we said originally that the female one is gonna be okay, actually, Mreimar Darshan, that the female one is a problem as well. Says Goma Amarav says, Shvor Arnarpitah Shori. The Shvar and Darpitah, this type of bird is gonna be mutter. Peruz andarpitah usur. The perus andarpitah is usr. Vasimni, how do you remember which andarpita is gonna be mutter or which one is usar? Perus or shia. The perus is the one that's usur. How do you remember that? Because there was a guy called Perus, and he was a big rosha. So the big rosha, and that's gonna be the one that's gonna be usar, and that's how you remember. That's Yusiman. Amr Avuna Ravuna says, Punya sharia. Punya, this type of bird is okay. Parva usir. The parva bird is usr. Vasimni, how do you remember which one? Parva Amgusha. Parva Amgusha Ash says it's the name of Am Hashiv. And that's obviously Osir. So the Parva, that's the one that's gonna be Osir. Amr Papa Rappa says Mardu Zagid the Ochil. Sorry. Mardu Zagidma Ochhil Shari. If you have a Mardu that we said before, that mardu bird, that's Zagid the Ochil, it stands up while it eats, then sharya. It's gonna be mutter. Sagid the okil, if it's the type of mardu that bows while it eats, then usr, it's gonna be usr. Vasimna, how do you remember that? You're not allowed to bow to Ava de Zara. So if it bows, that's the one that's gonna be Asser. Umr Shmo Shmo says, Shasya Hamra, the bird that's known as Shasya Hamra, the drinker of wine. Apparently, a bird like that. So Shasya Hamra Asirah. Vasimna, how do you remember that? Shituyayain, psulun navoida, koin that's drunk is not let it do avaida. So we see there's an Indian of Isir over here by Shtuyayain, and therefore that bird is gonna be Assar, and that's your similar to remember. If Amr Shmo Shmo says Mazgahamra, the bird that mixes your wine, he's called the Mazgahamra, that's Asira, that's gonna be Asir. Bas mazgahamra, however, the one that's known as the daughter of the mazgahamra, that's gonna be Shari, that's gonna be Mutr. Vesimnich, how do you remember that one? Yof e koya chaben, mikoya ka'av, you can know that because Yofekahaman, Mikahma Ha'av. So even though the the the mazgah hamra itself is going to be asir, the bas mazgahamra is actually mutter. I'm going to read the reader says Shakitna. The Shakintna bird is a rich shaki visumke. The shakitna bird that has long legs, a rich shaki visumke, and it's also red, its goof is red, charya. That one is gonna be mutter. Vesimnich, how do you remember that? Mirumza. Mirumza, Rashi says, was a known kosher bird, it had long legs and it looked red. So that one is what is a known kosher bird. So so too, if something that looks like that, it has long legs and a red body, that is going to be mutter. However, gutze visumki, even if it has a red body, sumki, but it's butse. It's gutze is a is a is a midget. So uh gutse, it has short legs, so that is gonna be that's gonna be awesome. That nana is puzzle, and nanas is a midget. So this is as it relates to Rashad says to Psule kahuna. Mume kahana be bucharis. And then it's a gemar and buharis that uh uh Kayan is too short. He's uh he's a midget, he's gonna be pasal by that, it's considered a mum. That's your sim into remember if this bird, even though it has a red stomach, but it's uh nanas, he's paselabida, this bird is gonna be puzzle to be eaten, it's gonna be considered puzzle, it's gonna be considered not kosher. Arichi shaki vioruki. However, what if it has long legs? But it doesn't have the red stomach, it has the green stomach, the ruki asir, it's also gonna be a usir. It needs both, it needs the long legs, it needs to be red. If it's any of the other interchangeable things, it's gonna be a problem. So a rich vieruki asir is gonna be usir. Basimne, how do you remember that? Yerukin psulim. That's like Amara, we also learned together not too long ago that if something happened, nehmeru bene aim, if the intestines got singed, they got burned. So how do you know if it's gonna be usr or not? So if it starts turning different colors, uh stuff bene aim that was supposed to be red turned green, it was green, it turned red. So if it starts turning colors, Yerukin Asiri, it's gonna be usually Yerukin Psulim, it's possible. That's as it relates to that trefa. That's how you know if it's a trefa. If it turned to you uh uh that color of green, by that uh specific avenue that we're talking about. Either way, that's your cemetery. Remember that your yaruk is a problem. Where is it gonna be okay by this specific animal? It's if it has long legs and red, but not only one of them, and we'll hold it over here for today. Getcha.