Send us Fan Mail

Most sports teams know exactly who their fans are — the fireworks families, the premium buyers, the last-minute deal seekers — and still send every one of them the same email blast. In Episode 173, Jeremy Neisser uses a simple ice cream shop analogy to show why that quietly drives fans away, and why the fix isn't better copy or a new platform. It's a system that responds to fan behavior after the send. If you felt the pull of Episode 171 on lifecycle marketing but haven't built anything yet, this is the episode that explains what's actually stopping you.

Register for the upcoming July 23 webinar: REGISTER

KEY TOPICS COVERED
- Why "we know we should be doing this" is the most common response from teams — and the real reason they never start
- How to tell the difference between an email problem and a systems problem (and why it matters for your results)
- The weekly email workflow that feels productive but keeps you stuck in the same loop all season
- Why sending everyone the same blast wastes the fan data you already have on purchases, promo nights, and spend
- The Bluey Night example: how generic messaging makes loyal fans feel unseen and stop paying attention
- Why personalization stalls — it's not that teams don't believe in it, it's that it feels overwhelming
- The critical distinction between campaigns and systems, and why great email marketing is built on systems
- How fans actually experience your team (as a night out, not a campaign) and what that means for your marketing
- What should happen after every open, click, purchase, attendance, and no-show
- The one question to ask this week that reveals whether you have a system or just a send button
- How teams are automating their way into more ticket revenue without adding nights and weekends

TIMESTAMPS
[0:00] — The ice cream shop analogy: why knowing your customer means nothing if you market to everyone the same
[2:05] — Connecting back to Episode 171 on lifecycle marketing and reframing the real issue as a systems problem
[3:00] — The repetitive weekly email workflow that feels like progress but keeps teams stuck
[3:53] — You already have the data: who buys premium, who brings kids, who waits until the last minute
[4:50] — The Bluey Night example — what generic messaging feels like from the fan's side
[5:41] — Why this is a systems issue, not a copywriting or creative one
[7:02] — Campaigns vs. systems: the difference between good and great email marketing
[8:27] — Why systems keep running while campaigns end and require someone to remember
[9:26] — The central takeaway: the email isn't finished when you hit send
[10:24] — Building follow-up experiences after every fan interaction
[11:50] — The question to sit with this week: after someone buys a ticket, what happens next?
[12:16] — The upcoming webinar on automating more ticket revenue with the tools you already have
[13:13] — Closing: leave a rating or review to help other ticket sellers find the show

CALL TO ACTION
If this episode has you asking "where do I even start?" — register for the upcoming webinar. Jeremy walks through the framework for building automated journeys, triggers, and priorities using the tools your team already has, with examples from teams that built these systems without working nights and weekends. Link in the show notes.

Links mentioned: 

Episode 171

Episode Webpage

QUOTE PULLS
"It's not an email problem. It's a systems problem." — Jeremy Neisser

"Most sports teams know exactly who their fans are and what they like. They just don't market like it." — Jeremy Neisser

"Campaigns end. Systems keep running. Campaigns require someone to remember — systems remember for you." — Jeremy Neisser

"The email isn't finished when you hit send. It's finished when it changes what your fan does next." — Jeremy Neisser

"The best marketing organizations don't think about sending emails. They think about building experiences." — Jeremy Neisser

Register for the upcoming July 23 webinar: REGISTER

Revelocity Sports
Sports Marketing Machine on LinkedIn
Sports Marketing Machine on Instagram
Book a call with Jeremy from Sports Marketing Machine