140: The Mystery Pack Promo That Sold 700 Opening Day Tickets in November

Sports Marketing Machine Podcast

Sports Marketing Machine Podcast
140: The Mystery Pack Promo That Sold 700 Opening Day Tickets in November
Nov 25, 2025 Season 1 Episode 140
Jeremy Neisser

Send us a text

In this episode, Jeremy breaks down one of the strangest ticket offers he’s ever seen—a “mystery pack” that moved nearly 700 opening day tickets months before first pitch. He unpacks why fans lined up to buy something they couldn’t fully see, using four key levers: price, surprise, giftability, and game-specific demand. You’ll walk away with plug-and-play mystery pack ideas you can adapt for your team this season.

Key Topics Covered

  • The “Mystery Pack” Breakdown – How a minor league team sold 100 packs at $50 and 70 more at $40, pre-selling almost 700 opening day tickets in November.
  • The 4 Levers That Make It Work – Price, surprise, giftability, and game-specific demand—and how each one lowers friction and boosts perceived value.
  • The No-Brainer Floor Test – Why your base offer (even without the mystery items) has to pass a simple, “Would I buy this anyway?” sniff test.
  • Designing Smart Surprise – How to keep the experience known and only make the extras mysterious so the offer feels fun, not risky.
  • Turning Packs into Perfect Gifts – Structuring bundles that can go under the tree, into a stocking, or become an easy “one and done” gift for families, dads, or grandparents.
  • Game-Specific Demand & Early Momentum – Using mystery packs to pre-sell your keystone nights (Opening Night, fireworks, theme nights, etc.) and build urgency months in advance.
  • Ready-to-Use Mystery Pack Templates – Kids Holiday Pack, Father’s Day Dad Box, Theme Night Mystery Pack, and National Ice Cream Day bundle you can copy and customize.
  • Guardrails So It Doesn’t Backfire – Avoiding junky merch, setting quantity limits, nailing fulfillment, and tracking new buyers, usage, and per caps to prove ROI.

Episode Chapters & Timestamps

  • 00:00 – Introduction to the Mystery Pack Promotion
  • 01:21 – The Offer That “Shouldn’t Work”… But Does
  • 07:06 – The Four Key Levers: Price, Surprise, Giftability, Game Demand
  • 13:53 – Pre-Selling Opening Night & Keystone Games
  • 19:54 – Plug-and-Play Mystery Pack Ideas You Can Steal
  • 23:37 – Guardrails, Metrics, and Final Checklist

Call to Action

Testing a mystery pack this season—holiday, Father’s Day, theme night, or something wild your GM dreamed up? Jeremy wants to see it. Send your offer, pricing, and results his way, or head to SportsMarketingMachine.com to schedule a call and workshop your own mystery bundle that makes fans say, “I don’t totally know what’s in it, but I’d be dumb not to buy it.”


Episodes Mentioned:

137: Make Your Black Friday Offer So Good Fans Feel Stupid Saying No To

40 - Savannah Bananas President Jared Orton Talks Social Media & Improving the Fan Experience


Sports Marketing Machine on LinkedIn
Sports Marketing Machine on Instagram
Book a call with Jeremy from Sports Marketing Machine

Episode Artwork 140: The Mystery Pack Promo That Sold 700 Opening Day Tickets in November 27:10 Episode Artwork 139: What Is Conversion Rate Optimization (CRO)? 9:32 Episode Artwork 138: Community Survey vs. Fan Survey — The Value of Both 12:56 Episode Artwork 137: Make Your Black Friday Offer So Good Fans Feel Stupid Saying No 21:36 Episode Artwork 136 - Operational Efficiency Playbook: Getting 3% Better with Mike Van Hise 41:26 Episode Artwork 135: The Simplest Way to Build (and Justify) a Marketing Budget 18:48 Episode Artwork 134 - Single Game vs. Season Tickets : How to Move Fans Up the Ladder 24:58 Episode Artwork 133 - Pros/Cons of All-You-Can-Eat Ticket Plans 18:26 Episode Artwork 132 - The 35,000 Visitor Problem: Why More Traffic Can Tank Your Profits 21:25 Episode Artwork 131 – How Meta’s Advantage+ is Wasting Your Budget 15:20 Episode Artwork 130 - How Teams Can Use Nano Banana to Generate More Revenue 18:15 Episode Artwork 129 - How the Florida Everblades Grew Attendance by 27% with Adam Winslow 36:32 Episode Artwork 128 - 3 Changes with Meta That Affect Your Ads (and How to Sell More Tickets Anyway) 24:12 Episode Artwork 127 - 3 Marketing Lessons from Taylor & Travis (That You Can Steal for Your Team) 14:19 Episode Artwork 126: Service-First Selling: How the Texas Rangers Are Redefining Ticketing Success 46:06 Episode Artwork 125 - “I Saw Your Ad—But Didn’t Buy”: Fixing the Fan Follow-Up Funnel 14:45 Episode Artwork 124: Maximizing Your Football Marketing Plan: What to Do When You Can’t Do It All 49:27 Episode Artwork 123 - Top 10 Theme Nights That Sold Tickets & Won Fans 37:26 Episode Artwork 122 – 9 Ways to Use ChatGPT to Sell More Tickets 19:04 Episode Artwork 121 – How Video Content Makes Paid Traffic Easier (and Cheaper) 16:27 Episode Artwork 120 - What We Are Building - Be A Beta Tester 9:07 Episode Artwork 119: Fan Activation, Revenue Growth, and Digital Engagement with Dash's Jonathan Hufnagel 32:02 Episode Artwork 118: Streaming TV Ads for Sports Teams – Simple, Trackable, and Built to Sell Tickets 19:43 Episode Artwork 117 - Good Deal or Bad Strategy? The Right Way to Use Loss Leaders 11:53 Episode Artwork 116 - Data Gold in Youth Programs: What Most Teams Overlook 14:24