Send us Fan Mail

Most group sales reps are losing deals before they ever hit send. 

In Part 1 of a new three-part group sales series, Jeremy Neisser breaks down why one email template going to every organization on your list is quietly capping your response rate — and how reframing every pitch around the buyer's goal (fellowship, recognition, memories) instead of your ticket inventory tripled one rep's response rate in a matter of weeks. Tactical, specific, and built for marketing and ticket sales leaders who want a smarter outbound program this season.

KEY TOPICS COVERED
• Why product-first thinking is killing your group sales outreach
• The one question every rep should answer before sending a pitch
• Why churches don't buy tickets — they buy fellowship
• Why HR directors need the easy button, not a 68-page PDF
• Why youth team coordinators are buying memories, not pricing
• How to build five core pitches that map to your five biggest group buckets
• Using ChatGPT or Claude to categorize last year's group sales list
• The real reason your 40–50 emails a week aren't converting
• How decision-makers differ across group types — and what each one actually responds to
• The mindset shift that separates order takers from revenue builders
• What's coming in Part 2: the language shift most group sales reps miss

TIMESTAMPS
00:00 – Welcome to Episode 168 and what's different about this three-part series
00:29 – The most common group sales outreach mistake — one template for every group
01:17 – Why product-first thinking shrinks your response rate
01:45 – Case study: 40–50 emails a week to tripled response rate in weeks
03:35 – The one question to answer before every pitch
04:05 – Church outreach: why fellowship beats ticket pricing every time
05:50 – Corporate outreach: why HR directors are buying the easy button
07:44 – Youth sports outreach: memories, not seat maps
09:10 – The tactical shift: build five core pitches, one per group type
09:39 – Ninja move: use ChatGPT or Claude to categorize your existing group sales list
10:38 – Why a specific message beats a high-volume e-blast every time
11:30 – The three big takeaways from Part 1
12:00 – What's coming in Part 2: communication and the language shift most reps miss
12:57 – Share the episode and what to do this week

CALL TO ACTION
If this episode helped, share it with your group sales manager or a teammate selling group tickets — and rate the show on Apple or Spotify so more sports business pros can find it.

QUOTE PULLS
• "Every group that walks through your gate has a reason for being there. And it is almost never because they wanted to buy a hundred tickets." — Jeremy Neisser
• "The reps who ask, why would this group want to come before they send anyone anything are the ones that close more business." — Jeremy Neisser
• "She was sending 40 to 50 emails a week and getting almost no responses. Once she built five different versions, her response rate tripled in a matter of weeks." — Jeremy Neisser
• "The rep who loses leads with ticket pricing. The rep who wins leads with why this is a great fit for what they're already trying to accomplish." — Jeremy Neisser
• "Build your messaging around their goal, not your product." — Jeremy Neisser

Sports Marketing Machine on LinkedIn
Sports Marketing Machine on Instagram
Book a call with Jeremy from Sports Marketing Machine