Dr. Bryan Foltice Behavioral Finance Podcast
Welcome to the Bryan Foltice Behavioral Finance Podcast, where we dive deep into the fascinating intersection of financial decision-making and human behavior.
Your host, Dr. Bryan Foltice, aims to embark on this journey with you to explore the quirks, biases, and psychological factors that shape our financial choices. From understanding why we buy high and sell low, to uncovering the emotional drivers behind our investment strategies, each episode will uncover valuable insights to help you navigate the complex world of finance with clarity and confidence.
So, please join us as we unravel the mysteries of personal and behavioral finance and unlock the secrets to making smarter, more informed decisions with your money.
Dr. Bryan Foltice Behavioral Finance Podcast
Real Life Simple Two-Bucket Retirement Withdrawal Strategy Discussion
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Question, Comment? Send it Here!
Retirement Withdrawal Rates in Real Life: Bryan Foltice’s Two-Bucket Approach Beyond the 4% Rule
In this episode of the Bryan Foltice Behavioral Finance Podcast, we discuss how common retirement withdrawal rules hold up in real life and why anything above 4% can be dangerous due to sequence-of-returns risk and compounding inflation.
We explore the “decumulation paradox,” where lifelong savers struggle to spend after retirement, and we frame retirement as a flexible transition rather than a hard stop at 65. We then break down a practical two-bucket strategy: a conservative 3% “ground floor” built around bare-bones expenses (often helped by paying off the house and supplementing with Social Security or part-time work), plus a “bonus bucket” that unlocks additional spending once the portfolio grows beyond a threshold (e.g., 1.5x). We also discuss trade-offs between thresholds, leaving an inheritance, and spending earlier while healthy.
The full working paper can be downloaded here:
Is Less More? Improving on the "Fixed 4%" Rule for Retirement Income
https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=7461338
Chapters
00:00 Podcast Intro
00:26 Why Revisit Withdrawal Rules
01:19 Rethinking Retirement Purpose
02:50 The 4 Percent Rule Problem
04:48 Why Higher Rates Fail
05:40 Sequence Risk and Inflation
07:19 Goal of the Study
08:07 Two Bucket Strategy Basics
10:11 Bonus Bucket Spending Freedom
11:44 Thresholds and All Out Approach
13:37 Inheritance and Living More
14:28 Q and A and Wrap Up
15:57 Outro and Subscribe
Subscribe to our Behavioral Finance Newsletter: https://www.moneystrong.net/behavioral-newsletter
Bryan Foltice Personal Website - www.bryanfoltice.com
Money Strong Website - www.moneystrong.net
Instagram - www.instagram.com/dr.bryanfoltice
Linkedin - https://www.linkedin.com/in/bryanfoltice
Disclaimer: www.bryanfoltice.com/cv
Welcome to the Brian Fultis Behavioral Finance Podcast, where we unravel the mysteries of behavioral finance and unlock the secrets to making smarter, more informed decisions with your money. Now, here's your host, Dr. Brian Fultis.
SPEAKER_00Welcome back, everybody. We spent the last two episodes talking about the fixed income flexible three rule, talking about retirement withdrawal rates. And we talked about the research, talked about the paper, and I wanted to come back one last time and talk about how this would apply in real life. And the whole basis of this study was my own reflection of is the 4% rule something that I want to teach? Is it effective? And then I started envisioning myself in retirement, thinking about all right, which one, what would I actually use for my own retirement if I had to come up with a single plan? And first of all, to be honest, I don't actually believe in retirement. I think that there isn't a magical day when you turn 65 that you should just say, well, I'm just gonna turn it all off, and and just every day is gonna be Saturday. I feel like that is for many people a very bad decision that if they lose their purpose, you see health deteriorate significantly within that first year, and then really significantly worse in the next two to three years after they get done and they don't really have much of a purpose. And I understand though, and even in my own world, hey, there might be a situation where I have a health itch, health issue that would forbid me to continue to work or something else that I just didn't want to pursue this as a purpose in my own job or my own business, then how would I survive? How would I live off of that? And so that's where I that's where I fit into this whole equation on retirement. And that doesn't mean that I shouldn't have my own strategy and I shouldn't have my own metrics of what I would do if I were in that case. And and especially if you start thinking about ham 45 and what would early retirement look like if I need an off-ramp, and what are some of the parameters that I can use. Well, as you know from the last two episodes, the the 4% rule is really nice and simple, good on paper, really nice and quick to help me calculate how much do I need to save or have in my portfolio in order to reach my yearly income level that I'm that I'm looking for. And we found out though that it was not very reliable potentially, and that it also has way too much money left over. And this is attributing to this retirement puzzle or the decumulation paradox, where investors and and retirees, those who have diligently saved for the last 40 years of their working lives, they've done all the right things. They can't flip the switch, they don't know how to spend it. So they become really good savers, but they just can't spend it. So they they're winning the game, but they're not acting like they've won after they after they have won. And this is where I sit in the middle, go, okay, no, I'm we're gonna teach awareness. We're trying to say, hey, it's gonna be okay to spend this amount once we get to this level. And we are going to we're not gonna follow I like you know, the Bill Perkins book, Die With Zero. I don't want to die with zero, but I also don't want to leave extra money on the table. It's my retirement. And if I've saved it, then I'm going to feel good about spending that money while I still have a breath in my body. And and that's where we we wind up with these alternative rules. And one last piece of the puzzle anything over four percent is not a viable situation. So once again, old man or the you know, the Dave Ramsey 6'8 rule that they're offering, once you factor in inflation, are almost virtual guarantees, virtual locks, especially if you have a time horizon over 30 years of failure. And if that's what you want to do, then you can go ahead and follow, and maybe you can talk to Rachel Cruz or somebody about that to help you out once you run out of money. Sure, she'll have some good answers for you. Um but the 4% rule was still wishy-washy, but anything higher, let's just get rid of that conversation. And that's the whole reason of sequence of returns. Okay, so you have a little bit of inflation that we're needing to increase the withdrawal rate, you lose 25% in your portfolio. Now you're drawing down from that lower portfolio the higher amount. And if you have a number of low performances up front in your retirement, this is the real sequence of return risk that you will receive. And that's where if you're locked into this higher rate, you can really get into trouble. Um inflation compounds as well. We also often overlook that. We think about it as a one-time event or it happens year over year, but we don't realize that you know this inflation, just like compound interest over time, has this exponential curvature, which means 3% each year is not just 3, 6, 9, 12, 15. And it will actually over, especially in those long periods of time, have this exponential adverse effect in your amounts. So if we had a million-dollar portfolio, I just remember seeing this in the data analysis. The million-dollar portfolio, if you have $40,000, there's 4%. That after 50 years, some of these withdrawal rates are now like 300,000, 250,000 up in that range. And that's just to give you an idea of what that purchasing power will do over periods of time, long periods of time. So the goal of what we were trying to do was try to find a way, is there to not never about like trying to beat the market. It was never about trying to predict the right stocks or find that sweet asset allocation mix, which sometimes we can get carried away with looking at this backwards returns in order to give us this ideal asset allocation mix. That's why we kept it super simple in our particular paper. Um, we just wanted to ask can we can we spend safely if markets start cooperating? So if it starts working in our favor, can we safe, can we spend more of that prosperity and still get away with it, not run out of money? And that's where we came up with that two-bucket approach. So in my mind, I know that 3% is super boring and is really, really discouraging if you're trying to plan and you're saying, I need $100,000 uh in annual income for my retirement. How much do I need based on this 3% rule? Well, it's gonna be like $3.3 million that you'll need in your portfolio for $100,000. And that can be very discouraging for a lot of people. Well, my thought process around this is you get the two-bucket approach. I've got my monthly expenses that are going to be bare bones expenses. And my goal is when that retirement age comes, whether it's in five years or in 15 years, that the house is paid for. So I don't have that huge overhang or that huge mortgage on my monthly expenses, which will cut my expenses drastically. So if I get that out of my life, then all of a sudden 3% is not too bad. I can get that in my portfolio, save it up, and use that as my first bucket ground floor basis. Now, one thing you can think about as well is can you supplement that 3% with uh additional maybe Social Security income? Or even in my world, do you want to kind of phase in to this retirement? So I can work part-time or I can do something on the side that would give me that additional income that would still buffer my 3% and give me a little extra spending if I needed it while not touching my portfolio during that critical time where we want it to try to grow just a little bit more, give it a little bit more time where you're ready to quit and not work full time, that would be a nice transition that you can use to give yourself a comfortable 3%. And then you've got the bonus bucket. And when you use that bonus bucket, that's your portfolio. And I'm telling you what, if you give that five years to grow and get it over that 1.5 threshold, then all that money after that is yours that you can spend freely. And you don't have to spend it right away, you don't have to use it right away, but you can just earmark that for additional spending. And this is where the real fun begins, because that's where you but that's where you can unapologetically spend and still not feel like you're gonna run out of money. And so this is where I feel like a lot of retirees would be hung up on. And we're giving them the green light through this two-bucket approach, and you get that big bonus one year, spend it all or n or some or spread it, spread it out, but you've got that pool of money, that bucket of money is yours to spend. And it also has in this strategy, because we've ripped it down to three percent, there's no cutbacks on that spending at any time. And this is also really important through loss aversion. That's why we put it in here because we didn't want people to cut back on spending. We know how hard that is, and so we just didn't even put it in as a criteria in any of our strategies. And when we go through our retirement through the two-bucket approach, if you were to do the all-out approach, and that's kind of my the one that I would want, the the dynamic approach takes out all the money towards the end because you're dividing that leftover money by numbers of years left. And so not only is it one extra step more complicated, it is basically gonna give the oldest version of myself the most spending power. And I I my thought is if I have any extra prosperity or money, I mean I'm gonna take that as when I'm young and when I can go travel, when I'm mobile, all those things, not when I'm about to croak. So the leftover money, though, is not a die with zero money. The all-out approach will leave you with basically the inflated adjustment amount of your portfolio plus or times your threshold that you use. So I like to think about the 1.5 threshold, but just know the trade-off of threshold the longer you wait, the 2.0 threshold, you let your account double plus in inflation, you will give yourself more income over long periods of time, especially in those good periods on average, and you would leave yourself with more on average as well. So you get to then you outlive your retirement horizon, you still have your inflated amount of portfolio that you originally started with. So if you need to start again, you can by all means go on and do that. And I hope that is a problem that both you and I have to work through and and and your clients. So that's where we and then also you can give away an inheritance. And I know some people say, well, maybe some people want to leave an inheritance. I know we all do, um, but we also should give the retirees who have done all the right things that green light to go travel or to buy that RV or to give that to their kids while you're still alive. We're giving them that opportunity, and that's where I feel that can really enhance many, many people's retirement experience. So that's where I'm gonna leave. Where we had that two-bucket approach in order to really amplify that while decreasing your probability of failure. What do you think? How did we do? Is that something that could be practical in your world? Can you teach your clients this if you were to manage people's money? Is that something that they could get behind? What are some of the sticking points? And this is where I'm in the the dark a little bit because I don't meet with clients, I meet with students, but that's not the same thing. So is there are there any rubs? Are there any points of contention that I might have missed in these findings? So would love to hear from you. Uh please let me know. And uh hopefully this is interesting. Hopefully you're you're helped by this. Uh, I found it interesting. I'll leave it alone, I think, for a little while now that we've done three episodes on it. And hopefully knock on wood will have that published or well received by referees, as it'll be under review at a what I can't, I don't even know what journal we're gonna send it to right away. But um anyway, I'll leave you at that. If you need to contact me, use the show notes, would love to hear from you. Uh you can comment, subscribe, all those things. Find me uh the contact information also in the show notes. Would love to hear from you. And uh I'll leave you with that. Thanks everyone. Have an awesome rest of your day. See you on the next episode. Bye.
SPEAKER_01Thank you for tuning in to another episode of the Brian Fultis Behavioral Finance Podcast. We hope you found our exploration into the fascinating world of human behavior and finance, both enlightening and thought provoking. Be sure to subscribe for future episodes. And until next time, stay curious and financially savvy.