Dr. Bryan Foltice Behavioral Finance Podcast
Welcome to the Bryan Foltice Behavioral Finance Podcast, where we dive deep into the fascinating intersection of financial decision-making and human behavior.
Your host, Dr. Bryan Foltice, aims to embark on this journey with you to explore the quirks, biases, and psychological factors that shape our financial choices. From understanding why we buy high and sell low, to uncovering the emotional drivers behind our investment strategies, each episode will uncover valuable insights to help you navigate the complex world of finance with clarity and confidence.
So, please join us as we unravel the mysteries of personal and behavioral finance and unlock the secrets to making smarter, more informed decisions with your money.
Dr. Bryan Foltice Behavioral Finance Podcast
Did the Reciprocity Effect Just Cost Me $100 or $10,000?!?!
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Question, Comment? Send it Here!
The $100 Shirt That Cost Me $10,000 | Reciprocity, Reference Points & Procrastination
How does a free personal styling session at Nordstrom turn into a $10,000 mistake?
In this episode of the Dr. Bryan Foltice Behavioral Finance Podcast, Bryan shares how a complimentary wardrobe consultation led him to purchase a $100 shirt he didn't really want, establish an expensive new household spending precedent, and procrastinate past his intended return deadline.
Using classic behavioral finance research, Bryan explores three powerful psychological forces—reciprocity, reference points, and present bias—and explains how they influence everyday spending, investment decisions, and relationships with financial advisors.
Discover why free isn't always free, how small decisions can have lasting financial consequences, and why knowing better doesn't always mean doing better.
References
Gouldner, A. W. (1960). The Norm of Reciprocity: A Preliminary Statement. American Sociological Review, 25(2), 161–178. | The social norm of reciprocity
Regan, D. T. (1971). Effects of a Favor and Liking on Compliance. Journal of Experimental Social Psychology, 7(6), 627–639. | Experimental evidence of reciprocity
Cialdini, R. B. (1984). Influence: The Psychology of Persuasion.
Subscribe to our Behavioral Finance Newsletter: https://www.moneystrong.net/behavioral-newsletter
Bryan Foltice Personal Website - www.bryanfoltice.com
Money Strong Website - www.moneystrong.net
Instagram - www.instagram.com/dr.bryanfoltice
Linkedin - https://www.linkedin.com/in/bryanfoltice
Disclaimer: www.bryanfoltice.com/cv
Welcome to the Brian Fultis Behavioral Finance Podcast, where we unravel the mysteries of behavioral finance and unlock the secrets to making smarter, more informed decisions with your money. Now, here's your host, Dr. Brian Fultis.
SPEAKER_02Welcome back, everybody. Today is Friday. It is gorgeous outside here in Indianapolis, Indiana, even here almost in the middle of October. And things are in full swing in the semester and things are going really well. And so I have to tell you the story, though, and it'll lead into our topic today. But the shirt that I'm wearing is going to be the centerpiece of this conversation. And it all started a few weeks, a few Fridays back, where I found out from my wife that Nordstrom offers a free consulting one-on-one wardrobe service. And they will have your personalized stylist help you out finding your new wardrobe. And I had been talking about trying to upgrade my clothes and thinking about what I wanted to do with that. Also was coinciding with some strength gains that I'd had. And so I felt like in a way I was transitioning over the summer. At the beginning of the summer, I was lifting more, I think, than I've ever lifted before. I went and traveled to Europe for six weeks, came back, picked up those pieces and got back within a couple of weeks to where I was. And then I started adding in leg day consistently, because I'd always skip the leg day. Who's looking at my legs? I skipped started adding in leg day. I was like, ooh, I really like this. And probably not coincidentally, as soon as I started adding strength to my legs, then all of a sudden the strength started coming onto my upper body, which led to a dilemma because my men's mediums were just gripping me. And then any, because I'm not stopping drinking, so any little fat that I would have around my waist would be very highly visible. So it was really not working in both ways. And the transition into a large would be super baggy, and then I'm wearing it like it. So I needed some help around this. And when I found out that I could get some free advice, I could not only get what my proper shirt size and fit would be, could also do the same thing with my pants and then suits, just get some new numbers around that. So really good intention. I was actually really excited about doing this. So when I had my Friday appointment, I got a text leading up to that that week from Ches. And I was just like, oh my God, Chez and I are gonna be best friends. And I super hope that it's Che and there's no pronounced pronounced the. And so in my mind, I'm thinking, he doesn't even know that we're gonna be new best friends, and we're gonna do all these cool clothes, and I'm hoping that he's gonna be really excited about it, and then that's gonna make me excited. And this in my mind, I developed this really fun experience. And so I showed him to Nordstrom on that Friday afternoon. Ches was there waiting for me, and it was Ches, super nice guy, and so he takes me into the dressing room where he had already laid out the different clothes that he wanted me to start trying out based on some of the sizes I was trying to show him and trying to describe in the text what sizes and what I was looking to do. So he took the best stab at it, had the whole dressing room lined up with different categories and different clothes to try on. So I was super excited, tried on a couple of things, and first thing I noticed were, ooh, I really like this, these fits and how some of these look. On the other hand, I started looking at the price tag, and I knew that Nordstrom is a high-end store. I knew that it was going to be expensive clothes. What I didn't know is how expensive these clothes were going to be. And of course, Ches has his energy on how he's going to show me the nice clothes, the fall clothes of the season, even though it was just hot as hell in the dressing room, and he's giving me all these warm clothes to try on for the fall season. And I they're just extremely expensive. And so I immediately caught myself in this dilemma and of I got this free service, but now all of a sudden I'm starting to feel like these are really expensive. How expensive is today going to be? And I tried on a couple of shirts, and tell you what, that $250 shirt looked really good on me and felt very comfortable. And then we tried the pants, so we kind of had those pants locked in. And so we're moving this forward, but the pants, again, were $200, $250 each. And so I like basic t-shirts, v-necks, and so I thought I get a V-neck shirt for under $100. I can get out the door, and Ches is running back and forth, just get getting me different clothes, different colors, really thinking and giving some real thought about what I might look good look good in. He had convinced me, yes, that's okay. You are a large, you're not a medium anymore. So it's like that Happy Gilmore II with Adam Sandler, where he realizes that you're no longer a medium, that you're a large, and you just need to accept this. And so he's running back and forth, and I'm trying on these clothes, and even the V-neck t-shirt, basic V-neck t-shirt, was $100. And so now I'm starting to really feel some feelings around this. Going, I signed up for this free service. We had a great time. He's working really hard back and forth. I gotta buy something. And so what I looked around the room, all the different things we've tried on. We actually tried on a suit coat based on my old size. And as soon as he's tried, as soon as I put it on, he said, I'm a flight fat guy in a little coat. And if he was dim for me to rip it, so I said, Dad, I'm not even in the market for a suit coat. We'll deal with that size later. And we moved on. But anyway, I've I looked around and I found the shirt that I'm wearing right now for $100 plus tax. And I like this shirt because it was ironically the only medium that fit me. So hanging onto a thread in my last medium shirt, and I liked how it looked. $100 is not something that I am accustomed to paying for clothes. I would much rather spend my money traveling for six weeks in Europe over the summer. This is just how I prioritize my spending with a net worth of seven figures. So anyway, I check out, make sure I get that receipt, because I knew that as soon as I got home, that was a 25-minute car ride from the mall to my house. By the time I had walked in, I had buyer's remorse. And I I thought, okay, yeah, that was I can't keep this shirt. And so all of a sudden I started thinking, you're a behavioral finance guy, right? And what are some of the factors that went into this decision? And I go, there was definitely something I had to reciprocate. And so you look it up and you go, hey, welcome. Final, we're getting to that punchline here. This is the reciprocity effect. And so I found myself in the reciprocity effect, where you feel obligated to reciprocate a favor or a free service that somebody actually does to you. And it's actually a psychology, a psychological effect phenomenon that's been already been studied. The second thing is I have also potentially set a new precedent. And so what this kind of looks like is this reference point dependence that we talk about in prospect theory, where losses and gains are predicated off of this reference point, and we can actually change our reference point. What I was doing essentially, and I realized this as soon as I brought it into the house, that if I'm buying $100 shirts, what about Mandy? Did I just open the floodgates to her buying $100 shirts? And Mandy generally is very cost conscious about clothes. I call her more of a volume person when it comes to clothes, where it's a lot but lower amounts and with weather those storms whenever she gets the itch. And but what I thought to myself is if I raise that bar to $100 minimum, well, does those do those halls become $100 each when she's bringing in those big ass bags of clothes when she goes out? So I realized I might have set a new precedent. And so immediately I set that right out inside the house, right where we leave through the garage, in the bag, didn't leave the bag, and it sat with the receipt in the Nordstrom bag. Full intentions, send it back, wipe it clean, have a good laugh, move on with life. Life gets in the way, 30 days goes by, procrastination takes over, and this is another effect is this present versus future, where the inconvenience of going out of my way for that 25 minutes to the mall, returning it, maybe having an awkward interaction with Ches, if he happens to be there and be the one who returns this, even though I fully intended to go to the woman's lingerie department to avoid that situation. But all that inconvenience to get my $100 back and to wipe away that precedent took effect. So lo and behold, earlier this week, when that 30 days lapsed, guess what I saw on my countertop? It was the receipt with highlighted by Mandy to remind me that 30 days has lapsed. And that we now own this hundred dollar shirt that I am now currently. So just to get this straight, I walked into Nordstrom, wanted free service. I fully intended to get the information that I wanted to, was open to the idea of buying something, but I accidentally established a new household spending threshold. I also spent $100 out of obligation, and I procrastinated long enough that I didn't return the shirt. And this, my friends, is your behavioral finance expert. Ta-da! And doing your financial advising behavioral finance. So anyway, let's talk about reciprocity. Cool word to say. A little bit of academic research actually goes back to 1960. Alvin Goldner, the norm of reciprocity. Hey, so he actually laid this out first in a paper called The Norm of Reciprocity, a preliminary statement from the American Sociological Review, and basically found this as a social norm. So unexpoken rules that we live by are these social norms. And he found this across many cultures and very widespread. This is a transactional way to go. I noticed this. Germany, living in Germany for about six years, Germans are very transactional. And of course, I was hanging out with people who were really good at math. And so we would always, even late in the night, we were always very good at accounting for who was buying what drinks, and I owe you this and this. Um, like I didn't really care, but it was very precise. So we could just always see this reciprocity happening, even in our social worlds. And and so that laid out the foundation theoretical about reciprocity. And then Dennis Reagan came around in 1971 with a paper called Effects of a Favor and Liking on Compliance. This is the Journal of Experimental Social Psychology. So what he did is he used Coca-Cola in his experiment, where two people were working on a project. One was working for the researcher and he remained constant. The other participant who would come in would be split in half. One participant would be given a coke by the collaborator that they were working on together. The other half of the participants would not receive a coke. And so after they worked on their little project, the partner asked a favor if they would be willing to buy raffle tickets. And so what they found obviously the people who received the Coke bought more raffle tickets. And upon a little bit further in their study, they found out that even if the they didn't like that person they were buying from the raffle tickets from, they there was something else. It wasn't like a personal, well, I happen to like them because of the Coca-Cola, whether they liked them or not, they were buying more raffle tickets. And so we found this in the experimental lab that there's something going on here, even if it's just a small Coca-Cola. A book, if you really want to get into this, this looks like Robert Cidaldi oh Chialdini? Robert C-I-A-L-Dini, D-I-N-A, D-I-N-A, called The Reciprocity as an principle of influence. And his book is called Influence, the Psychology of Persuasion. And so he takes us a step further. If Coca-Cola works, what about in the financial world or in our other circumstances where we see these really play out, where there could have more consequences potentially? So in our finance world, we're going to see this from both sides, trying to get new clients and ways you can actually influence people. And then also from a consumer perspective, if you're on the other end and you're receiving this free service, how do you work your way around that? So, first of all, we have the free consultation. So financial advisor gives you an hour of their time, they prepare, they have a meeting, suddenly this free meeting, even if I'm not so sure about them, there's this influence of reciprocity where you have to feel like, I probably will take them on and see how it goes, even if it's not the right fit. Same thing with one of the free seminars. You see a free seminar and you go to that and you feel obligated to sign up for the services or go for that next step. So I think even on a larger scale, there's a multi-step process using the reciprocity effect and this life change. Tim Tebow and Craig Rochelle from Life Church, and they're starting to pull out of this because they're starting to realize this whole marketing funnel of free webinar into the less than $100 day or workshop. And then that moves into the three or four thousand dollar in-person meeting, and then that leads potential people into the $40,000 or $50,000 university, whatever they call it. So they move them sequentially into these huge numbers for access to them. So, anyway, also, so we know about those. We know about the one-on-one consultations, we know about the free webinars in the financial services world, but we also have some gifts, hospitality. You think about some of the boxes or courtside seats that that people use to bring in potential clients. It's all reciprocity effect here. And I'm sure we're all aware of it, but we're just showing it in the different ways here. Reciprocity effect, reference point in anchoring. There's another point here. This was one of my biggest concerns because I realized that the $100 shirt was not just a $100 shirt, that this could potentially be a $10,000 shirt if this precedent is allowed and we let this slide. So we're always thinking about reference points and how we predicate our gains versus losses. This also is like our precedent point. And hopefully we've established after this that $100 is still not acceptable. This will be my one and done. But these are all predicated from the old Tibetsky Kaneman, Judgment under uncertainty, and prospect theory, an analysis of decision under risk. And that's the 1970s classic, prospect theory. So we'll talk more about prospect theory, one of my favorite subjects here in a little bit in more depth. But we always remind students and people that all prospect theory gains and losses, how we interpret them, are based off of reference point. And reference point can stay the same sometimes, or it can move. And I always use the example of if you go to the Bellagio and you go downstairs, you put in $10, and you just push the button, suddenly you win $50,000. And now all of a sudden you have $50,000 and you're feeling good, so you s decide to double down and you put $50,000 on black in the roulette table, and it turns up red. So now you're back down to zero. You walk back up to your hotel room and you tell your spouse, partner, friend, how much did you lose? And so we say, some people will say, most people will say, Oh, I lost $10. And we're not going to tell them about the changing reference point because it moved all the way back. Some pe if you had the guts, would you actually say you lost $50,000? I know I wouldn't. I think I always say in my world, I would probably say I lost $80 because I would immediately run to the bar, have a good cry, and drink three of the strongest Long Island iced teas that they could possibly serve me. And then I would come back to the room and say, Yeah, I'm down $80 today. Anyway, also procrastination and present bias. This was another one. I could have totally avoided this entire thing by just finding that time, putting it. And so you find the time, you make it a priority, you move it away. Somehow I procrastinated. I have plenty of excuses. Do you think I'm gonna change my behavior? Because we'll talk about, hey, here's how you change your behavior. You should set up an automatic calendar reminder that you should take this back and you should set this up automatically and have this set in place and put it on your calendar, devote enough time. I'm not gonna do that. So I'm not even gonna tell you those things that you should do because I'm just gonna keep my shirt for a hundred bucks, okay? But this comes for the this present bias where the solution was quite straightforward, but the immediate con inconvenience and possible social awkwardness, which I typically don't care about, was keeping me back. And this all comes from when we're putting the framework together, which I will actually go back and do next week. Put together the entire behavioral finance, money strong framework that I've been developing and been thinking through. This is tackling three of the factors that are trying to bridge this knowing and doing gap. So most of us know what to do, yet we still don't do it. There's a gap between these two. What are some of the factors that are getting in our way? And so that's where we'll dive into those three. We've experienced three of those, and reciprocity, reference point, a procrastination. We'll develop that a little bit more into broader categories next week when we come back. And so, how we protect ourselves. You just basically have to be grateful and walk away. Is I even know that's what we're supposed to do. In fact, I'm trying to get my wife on the process. Podcast, so we can talk about a topic called loud budgeting, which is basically trying to stand up for ourselves in social situations when we know what to do. But the bridge to get us there is basically trying to stand up and say, no, I I don't want to do that. And the alternative is to just follow through and go with that. So understanding that if I were to walk into Nordstrom, I probably would not have bought this shirt without that implication of that free service. And so separate that from feeling obligated to do that and be able to stand up for it. That's basically it. And having your financial decisions set in advance because I had got myself really hyped up, I could have gone really crazy on spending because I didn't have a plan. I just wanted to really know what I wanted, but also realized that if I got really pumped up and we were hitting it off, then I could really I didn't have a plan in place. And then remove procrastination from the equation.
SPEAKER_01No, I'm not I'm not gonna do that. Anyway.
SPEAKER_02So there's the $10,000 shirt story. What do you think? Walk in as Nordstrom expecting to take advantage of the free service, walked out buying a hundred dollar shirt that I didn't really want. That's the reciprocity effect. I set a precedent potentially in our household that could cost me thousands of dollars, and I procrastinated long enough not to actually bring it back. So here we're stuck. Three concepts in behavioral finance, one shirt, and a very expensive lesson. I'm gonna leave it at that. I hope you learned a little bit, enjoyed it. We're gonna come back and continue to build out the framework and see how these topics link into that framework next week. I'm excited because that's my fall break, and I actually have some time to record some podcasts, get all caught up on everything, behavioral finance, and continue to pump out some materials that actually get into truly behavioral finance concepts. And you might see this shirt again. So if you would be so kind and made it this far, go ahead and comment. I like your shirt. Would be really appreciative. And with that, I will let you go. Thank you so much for watching. Please see the links below on how you can find me. And also I'll try to get the academic references in there as well. Do my due diligence as a good researcher. And with that, I hope you have an awesome rest of your day, a great weekend, and we'll see you next week Friday. Thanks everyone. Have a great day.
SPEAKER_00Thank you for tuning in to another episode of the Brian Fultis Behavioral Finance Podcast. We hope you found our exploration into the fascinating world of human behavior and finance, both enlightening and thought provoking. Be sure to subscribe for future episodes. And until next time, stay curious and financially savvy.